Close
Date TimeMarch 06, 2018
VoiceWhen Spotify launched in 2008, Ken Parks heard one question again and again from journalists and investors: Why wouldn't Apple just kill this thing while it's still in the cradle?
Parks, the chief content officer at Spotify from its founding until 2015, had a simple answer: Because Apple (AAPL) probably didn't think it needed to.
At the time, Apple's iTunes store had a dominant position in the music industry -- but for downloads, not streaming. Spotify was competing less against giants like Apple than streaming services like Pandora (P), MOG, Grooveshark and Rdio, all of which except Pandora have since shut down. And Apple didn't appear too worried about streaming or this latest upstart doing it.

"Companies that have a very successful business model typically hew to that model unless forced to pivot," Parks, now the executive chairman at Pluto TV, told CNN in an interview last week.
It would be years before Apple, Google (GOOGL) and Amazon (AMZN) launched streaming products of their own. Each were framed in the press as "Spotify killers." None lived up to that title.
Ten years after it launched, Spotify filed paperwork last week to go public on the New York Stock Exchange. The move marks a major milestone for the company and could further boost its profile as it continues to take on the biggest names in tech, Apple chief among them.
Apple was mentioned more than a dozen times in Spotify's IPO paperwork, starting with a victory lap of sorts on page one. The company notes that its user base is "nearly double the scale of our closest competitor, Apple Music."
Spotify survived thanks to its early mover advantage, a war chest of funding and the luxury of being able to focus on one core product rather than the vast range of pursuits at a company like Apple, company insiders and industry watchers told CNN after the IPO news.
"A couple thousand people totally dedicated to the task of maximizing the value of music and delivering the most compelling product to its users is going to beat a company for whom it's not part of the core business," Parks said.
And though Apple may not have paid it much attention early on, Spotify executives did pay close attention as Apple pushed into the streaming market. Pär-Jörgen Parson, an early Spotify investor and longtime board member, told CNN that leadership "saw a potentially difficult situation unfolding."
Parson said any initial concerns were eased somewhat by app data suggesting that users were more engaged on Spotify than Apple Music. "But obviously [Apple] could throw a lot of weight in terms of distribution power," he added.
In particular, Spotify took issue with Apple taking a 30% cut of subscription revenue from apps operating in Apple's App Store. The cut required Spotify to charge more to make the same amount of money, effectively cutting into its ability to compete with Apple Music directly on price.
Parson called it a "monopolistic situation." Spotify eventually complained to antitrust authorities. (Apple did not respond to a request for comment on this story.)
The actual Apple Music service was viewed as less of an existential threat, according to Parson and Parks. Spotify believed its focus on algorithms to personalize the music experience was a better bet than Apple's push for human curators.
Parks says Spotify also believed its free, ad-supported listening option offered "a key differentiator between Spotify and other services [that would] continue to drive mass scale in Spotify's paid user base." Apple only offers a paid subscription option.
"Spotify ... had a head start and built a great product," said David Pakman, a venture capitalist at Venrock and former CEO of eMusic. "They also have been able to raise a huge amount of money to cover the losses and unprofitable model."
Inside the war between Spotify and Apple
The company had a net loss of $1.5 billion in 2017, more than double the amount from the prior year, stemming from the cost of licensing content. Those losses would once have been unfathomable for a startup, but Spotify was able to raise billions in debt and venture capital despite them.
Still, just because Spotify made it this far doesn't mean it's guaranteed to thrive as a public company.
Snapchat, for example, survived numerous clones from its much larger rival Facebook (FB) before going public. But in its first year as a public company it has struggled to show it can grow its user base in the face of a direct challenge from Facebook's Instagram.
Apple, like Amazon and Google, "can afford to run their services at a loss for many years longer than Spotify likely can, now that they are public," says Pakman. "The real question is how long will the public markets allow them to lose money."
In an unusual move, Spotify is not actually raising money in its IPO. Instead, it's listing existing shares on the public market. But Parson says Spotify could still turn to Wall Street to raise money at a later date for acquisitions and other investments to ensure it can keep competing with Apple as a public company.
Spotify won't be alone in that fight. Dropbox, another startup that Apple once vowed to destroy, filed for an IPO in February too. Both serve as reminders that David can still outmaneuver Goliath in the tech industry.

Justin Trudeau Called Donald Trump To Talk About Steel, Aluminum Tariffs And NAFTA
Paris launches 'shock' poster campaign against sexual harassment on public transport
Kremlin 'ready to cooperate' over former spy's illness in UK
Facebook says it mistakenly asked users for views on grooming
Oscars: 15 Memorable Audience Reactions
Dreamers Aren’t Safe Just Because The Courts Ruled Against Trump On DACA
Trump says Canada won’t be exempt from steel and aluminum tariffs until ‘fair’ NAFTA is signed
Terry Bryant Arrested For Stealing Frances McDormand's Oscars Trophy
Italian election results cast a pall over the European Union
'House of Cards' Debuts Teaser for Final, Kevin Spacey-Less Season
Russia will ‘never’ extradite citizens accused by U.S., Putin says
ISIS suspects arrested after US Embassy in Turkey closed due to 'security threat'
What Is an Inclusion Rider? Frances McDormand's Oscars Speech Explained
Victory for Eurosceptic, populist parties shocks the establishment in Italy election
Fans react to Allison Janney's first Oscar win
Oscars 2018: The Winner’s List
Oscars Embrace 'The Shape of Water' In a Consciously Inclusive Ceremony
Oscars: Watch All of the Musical Performances From the Show
Fiorentina captain Davide Astori dies of 'sudden illness' at 31, team says
Leicester explosion: sixth man arrested
Women march in London to call for gender equality
Theresa May tells Trump of 'deep concern' over US trade tariff plans
Watch out for this clever credit card scam
Amazon To Stop Selling Google's Nest Products
Northeast Storm Leaves At Least 9 Dead, More Than 1.5 Million Without Power
Senator Says Kushner Must Go If He Shaped Foreign Policy To Aid Family Business
Trump tells Gridiron: North Korea 'called up' and 'would like to talk'
Theresa May Rejects 'Passporting' For City Of London After Brexit
BREAKING: Sir Roger Bannister dead - First to run a mile in under four minutes dies at 88
WATCH: Moment topless activist confronts Silvio Berlusconi as he casts vote
'President for life' not a bad idea, Trump says of China proposal
South Korea to send high-level officials to North for talks
Spirit Awards: Greta Gerwig Wins Best Screenplay for 'Lady Bird'
Donald Trump jokes about White House chaos at Gridiron Dinner: 'Who will be next to leave? Steve Miller, or Melania?'
Italy goes to the polls after divisive election campaign
MH370 disappearance 4 years on, Malaysia to end search in June
'SNL': Alec Baldwin's Donald Trump Rambles on Gun Control, Wakanda in Cold Open
White House on lockdown and staff told to take shelter after gunman SHOOTS HIMSELF
Beyoncé returns to a vegan diet
Need a North Korean Missile? Call the Cairo Embassy
Where Hollywood Stars and Insiders Are Watching the Oscars
Putin tells U.S. to send evidence of vote meddling
Why 'Get Out' is the future of the Oscars
Lebanon PM posts selfie with Saudi crown prince after strain
Razzie Awards name 'The Emoji Movie' worst film of 2017
Ex-GOP Senate candidate Roy Moore pleads for money to cover legal fees
Police arrest Michigan college student suspected of killing parents
Jennifer Lawrence, Jodie Foster to present Best Actress at Oscars, report says
Jessica Alba to Star Alongside Gabrielle Union in NBC's 'Bad Boys' Spinoff
Report: Muslims Were Attacked At Least 950 Times In Germany In 2017
Central Michigan University shooting TWO DEAD - ALL schools in city on lockdown
Theresa May says Brexit will reduce UK access to single market
What to Wear at the Oscars When You Know You're Probably Not Going to Win
Trump tweeted that “trade wars are good, and easy to win.”
President Trump Has a Message for ‘Alex’ Baldwin About His SNL Impression
GitHub Survived the Biggest DDoS Attack Ever Recorded
French embassy 'under attack' in Burkina Faso's capital
Why Silvio Berlusconi looks like stability to many Italians
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle's 'people's wedding': Hundreds of school children invited to Windsor Castle
Holi Festival 2018: Google marks Festival of Colour with dramatic doodle
Israeli police question Netanyahu in telecoms corruption case
Melania Trump Got A Green Card For Immigrants With ‘Extraordinary Abilities’
Chinese state media loves Elon Musk's latest tweets
Here's why Trump's tariffs spooked markets around the world
World Book Day 2018: teachers, send us pictures of your costumes
How to celebrate Women's History Month in Philadelphia
‘Mass casualty incident’ Ambulances rush to Houston school amid fears of major gas leak
Ex-USA Volleyball coach accused of raping six girls 'hundreds of times,' lawsuit alleges
Jennifer Lawrence Unsure If She Will Speak With Ryan Seacrest at Oscars
Prince William to make first official royal visit to Israel and Palestine
Equifax identifies additional 2.4 million customers hit by data breach
Russia developing nuclear weapons immune to interception, Putin claims
Uber Health will get patients to and from the doctor
UK snow latest: Make sure your car is fully protected from STORM EMMA with these 10 tips
Meghan Markle SPEAKS OUT for women in first Royal engagement with the Duchess of Cambridge
Chadwick Boseman Surprises Passionate 'Black Panther' Fans on 'Tonight Show'
White House Comms Director And Longtime Trump Aide Is Resigning
The unseen power of Hope Hicks
'Tutu' painting by Ben Enwonwu sells for $1.6 million
Oscars Host Jimmy Kimmel Explains Why He Won't Reference #MeToo And Time's Up
Georgia teacher arrested after firing gunshot alone in school classroom
#MeToo and #TimesUp have pushed 48% of companies to review pay policies
10 best foods for your heart
Thousands of jobs at risk as Maplin and Toys R Us fall into administration - business live
Florida school shooting survivors return to school for first time since massacre
Bill Gates Says Cryptocurrencies Have Caused Deaths
Afghanistan offers to recognize Taliban as legitimate 'political party'
Hope Hicks refuses to answer U.S. House investigators’ questions about Trump administration
Japan unveils Tokyo 2020 Olympics superhero mascots
Jared Kushner, President Trump's son-in-law, has security clearance downgraded
Facebook Named Live Stream Partner for 'The Oscars: All Access'
iQiyi, the Netflix of China, is going public in the US
Close Trump aide Hope Hicks testifies in House Intelligence Committee regarding Russia probe
Donald Trump WILL run for US President in 2020 as Republican names his campaign chief
Jennifer Lawrence Drinks Rum With Stephen Colbert, Calls Harvey Weinstein a "Horrible Ass Boil"
Apple is leading the race to $1 trillion
Four billboards say Serena Williams is the 'greatest momma of all time'
Global Markets: Asian shares rise to three-week high ahead of Powell's testimony
Kim Kardashian West's Vogue India Cover Sparks Debate About Representation
Russia's 'humanitarian pause' comes into effect in eastern Ghouta
Gov Jay Inslee To Trump: ‘Less Tweeting ... More Listening’
Saudi Arabia sacks military commanders in late-night reshuffle
North Carolina man killed on Facebook Live minutes after leaving police station
Supreme Court won't hear Trump bid to end DACA program
Apple confirms that it's a Google Cloud customer — and it's a big victory for Google cloud boss Diane Greene
Ivanka Trump: It’s ‘Inappropriate’ To Ask Me About My Father’s Accusers
“I really believe I’d run in there even if I didn’t have a weapon,” said Trump
Kevin Smith suffers massive heart attack, tweets 'For now, I’m still above ground!'
Jennifer Lawrence dropped out of middle school, says she's 'self educated'
Qualcomm Leaves Price as Final Hurdle to Broadcom Takeover
Lewinsky sees 'problematic' issue of consent in Clinton affair
Jacinda Ardern's 'sexist, creepy' 60 Minutes interview angers New Zealand
Ivanka Trump Doesn’t Know If Teachers Should Be Armed
'Black Panther' roars past $700M worldwide
Storms kill four people in Kentucky, Arkansas
Kompany on target as Manchester City cruise past Arsenal in Carabao Cup final
Papua New Guinea hit by 7.5 earthquake
From News to Shoes: How big is big tech?
Olympian Gus Kenworthy Burns Ivanka Trump: ‘TF Is She Doing Here?’
Sridevi Kapoor, Bollywood superstar, dies aged 54
US, Britain in cybersecurity divide over Chinese tech firm Huawei
NRA defends itself after corporations pull away
Toyota, Hyundai recall roughly 110000 vehicles
Record-breaker Marit Bjoergen sends Norway top of final medal tally
China to drop presidential term limits, clearing way for Xi Jinping to stay on
North Korea willing to talk to US, South Korea says
Deandre Ayton dominant but Arizona falls in OT
Democrats' new Russia memo is an anti-Trump political attack
Mexican president cancels trip to Washington after heated call with Trump
Ivanka Trump tours Olympic venues, meets athletes after vow to increase pressure on North Korea
Warren Buffett letter: 3 tips for stock investors
Emma Chambers Dies at 53
UN Security Council approves 30-day Syria ceasefire
Italian election: Chaos on the streets of Italy as riot police CLASH with antifascists
Watch: Moment when police officers catch falling 5-year-old
Jennifer Lawrence, Catt Sadler Prepping #MeToo, Time's Up Movement TV Docuseries
Apple, Amazon, YouTube Urged To Pull NRA TV Channel
Report: School shooter describes emotional struggle in 911 call
Ivanka Trump practices diplomacy on South Korea Olympics trip
How Kylie Jenner should really use her power
The secret behind Norway's Winter Olympic success
I try like hell to hide that bald spot, says Donald Trump – video
U.S. expects to open Jerusalem embassy in May, officials say
Switzerland: 2 killed in shooting in Zurich
Trump announces new North Korea sanctions
Tesla buyers to lose $7,500 tax credit later this year
Harvery Weinstein apologizes to Jennifer Lawrence, Meryl Streep for lawyers' words
Tiffany Haddish named host of 2018 MTV Movie & TV Awards
There Could Be 7 Amazon Go Stores This Year
Alina Zagitova edges countrywoman Evgenia Medvedeva to win figure skating gold
Rights group: Turkey not avoiding civilians in Syria strikes
'The Bachelor Winter Games' Finale Delivers Surprise Engagement
Ivanka Trump to attend closing ceremony
Justin Trudeau's India visit sparks outrage
How does KFC run out of chicken?
'France is no longer free': Marine Le Pen's niece brings French far right to CPAC
NRA's Wayne LaPierre says gun control advocates 'hate individual freedom'
WATCH: Bundestag speech SCOLDING Merkel for THREATS to Britain prompts HUGE APPLAUSE
Jimmy Kimmel, Stephen Colbert, Trevor Noah on kids who 'got woke' in Best of Late Night
Oprah Reacts To Trump’s Tweet Calling Her ‘Very Insecure’
Snapchat stock drops on news Kylie Jenner no longer uses the app
U.S women's hockey gold medal came in great Olympic game, made even greater statement
White powder letter sent to Prince Harry and Meghan Markle
Trump says only 'highly trained' teachers should have guns to prevent school shootings
Man dies after throwing device at US embassy in Montenegro
Perfect pastels: Why India's 'Pink City' is a photographer's paradise
Jennifer Lawrence responds to 'sexist' dress criticism: 'It was my choice'
Trump Tower ‘BOMB THREAT’ after police receive ‘disturbance call’
Watch Chloe Kim and Jimmy Fallon Photo-Bomb Olympics Fans on Shortened 'Tonight Show'
Vice President Mike Pence visits the Texas-Mexico border
Who is NRA spokeswoman Dana Loesch?
Melania Trump’s parents are legal permanent residents. Experts say that means they likely relied on ‘chain migration,’ which Donald Trump has condemned
Jimmy Kimmel Explains His Reaction to Fergie's "Unusually Sultry" National Anthem at NBA All-Star Game
Bill Gates flunks Ellen's grocery shopping challenge
Actress Karla Souza alleges she was raped by director
Spokesman: Evangelist Billy Graham has died at age 99
Sky U.K. Orders Weekly ‘Late Late Show With James Corden’ Highlights Program
Uber Express is like a minibus with cheaper rides
Growth of AI could expand security threats if no action taken, report warns
Queen makes surprise appearance at London fashion week
Late-Night Hosts Applaud Florida Students Demanding Action on Gun Control
Jared Kushner reportedly doesn’t want to give up his security clearance
US Vice President Mike Pence was set to meet with North Korean officials, but they canceled
There are no longer any words to describe Syria's horror
Olympic ice skating: Medvedeva sets world record, then Zagitova breaks it
Congress wonders if this time will be different for gun control
George and Amal Clooney to attend March For Our Lives
Donald Trump Jr. promotes Trump brand, new luxury developments in India
How the #MeToo women’s movement is changing politics
Turkey 'opens fire on Syrian regime forces' coming to the aid of Kurds in Afrin
Alleged $150K payoff to Trump accuser, ex-Playboy model Karen McDougal: Was it illegal?
Kim Jong Un's sister, Kim Yo Jong, is pregnant, report says
China and Europe love SpaceX's new Falcon Heavy rocket. Does NASA?
Say goodbye to Android Pay and hello to Google Pay
‘Black Panther’ Marks A New Kind Of Black Superhero Movie
Chelsea prepare for Barcelona clash but what is David Luiz doing to Tiemoue Bakayoko?
Man City star Sergio Aguero 'PUNCHES' Wigan fan after shocking FA Cup defeat - WATCH
American ice dance duo Madison Chock and Evan Bates suffer shocking fall in long program
Meghan Markle receives royal secretary ahead of wedding to Prince Harry
President Trump endorses Mitt Romney in Utah Senate race
Close