Close
Date TimeOctober 26, 2017
VoiceFirms should make more information about salaries public

SWEDES discuss their incomes with a frankness that would horrify Britons or Americans. They have little reason to be coy; in Sweden you can learn a stranger’s salary simply by ringing the tax authorities and asking. Pay transparency can be a potent weapon against persistent inequities. When hackers published e-mails from executives at Sony Pictures, a film studio, the world learned that some of Hollywood’s most bankable female stars earned less than their male co-stars. The revelation has since helped women in the industry drive harder bargains. Yet outside Nordic countries transparency faces fierce resistance. Donald Trump recently cancelled a rule set by Barack Obama requiring large firms to provide more pay data to anti-discrimination regulators. Even those less temperamentally averse to sunlight than Mr Trump balk at what can seem an intrusion into a private matter. That is a shame. Despite the discomfort that transparency can cause, it would be better to publish more information.
There is a straightforward economic argument for making pay public. A salary is a price—that of an individual worker’s labour—and markets work best when prices are known. Public pay data should help people make better decisions about which skills to acquire and where to work. Yet experiments with transparency are motivated only rarely by a love of market efficiency, and more often by worry about inequality. In the early 1990s, it was outrage at soaring executive salaries which led American regulators to demand more disclosure of CEOs’ pay. Such transparency does not always work as intended. Compensation exploded in the 1990s, as firms worried that markets would interpret skimpy pay-packets as an indicator of the quality of executive hires.
Despite this, bosses tend to oppose transparency, for understandable reasons. Firms have an easier time in pay negotiations when they know more about salaries than workers do. What is more, shining a light on pay gaps can poison morale, as some workers learn that they earn substantially less than their peers. A study of employees at the University of California, for instance, found that when workers were given access to a database listing the salary of every public employee, job satisfaction among those on relatively low wages fell. In industries in which competition for talented workers is intense, the pernicious effects on morale of unequal pay create an incentive to split the high-wage parts of the business from the rest. Research published in 2016 concluded that diverging pay between firms (as opposed to within them) could account for most of the increase in American inequality in recent decades. That divergence in turn resulted from increased segregation of workers into high- and low-wage firms.
Yet transparency increases dissatisfaction not because it introduces information where there was none before, but because it corrects misperceptions. Surveys routinely find that workers overestimate their performance and pay relative to their peers’. This is true across economies as well as within firms. In 2001, tax records in Norway were put online, allowing anyone to see easily what other Norwegians had earned and paid in tax. Reported happiness among the rich rose significantly, while the well-being of poorer people fell as they learned their true position on the economic ladder. Better information changes behaviour. Low-paid workers at the University of California became more likely to seek new jobs after salary data became public. In Norway the poor became more likely to support redistribution.
Transparency might threaten the function of capitalist economies if people were implacably opposed to pay gaps, but they are not. A study published in 2015 of factory workers in India, for instance, found that unequal pay worsened morale and led to reduced effort when workers could not see others’ contributions, but not when productivity differences were easily observable.
Yet in the modern economy, individual contributions are often devilishly hard to assess. Simple theory suggests that workers are paid according to their productivity. Were they to earn more, their employers would lose money; were they to earn less, other firms could profit by hiring away underpaid employees. But although it is easy enough to see how many shirts a textile worker stitches in an hour, it is much harder to evaluate the contribution of one member of a team that has spent years developing new software. When it is difficult to observe important parts of a job, economists believe that trying to link pay closely to narrow measures of performance can be misguided. Workers inevitably neglect murky but critical tasks in favour of those the boss can easily quantify. In the knowledge economy, therefore, the relationship between pay and productivity is often loose.
Pay gaps are often nonetheless justified. Workers with scarce and valuable skills can easily threaten to leave, and can therefore bargain for higher pay. Those fat pay-packets serve the economy by encouraging young workers to develop skills that are in short supply—provided, of course, that they know how much they can expect to earn. But the difficulty in observing productivity allows factors to influence pay, such as office politics, discrimination or a simple tendency to silence the squeakiest wheels with grease.

Open-plan offices
Not every country will opt for radical transparency. Even Nordic governments continue to tweak their policies: in 2014 Norway banned anonymous searching of its tax database, so citizens could see who had nosed around their finances. But increased openness about pay could improve both the fairness and the functioning of the economy. When pay is public, it is not the justifiable inequities that create the most discomfort, but those firms cannot defend.

Russia-linked posts 'reached 126m Facebook users in US' - BBC News
ABC Orders More Episodes of 'Grey’s Anatomy,' 'American Housewife' and 'Black-ish'
How to buy bitcoin in the UK: Cash, wallets, price and everything you need to know
Jennifer Lawrence, Channing Tatum Among 'Jimmy Kimmel Live' Guest Hosts
Lewis Hamilton survives collision to win fourth Formula One world title
Spain V Belgium: Catalonia leader travels to BRUSSELS after asylum offer from Belgium city
Elon Musk Shares Photo Of 500-Foot Tunnel He's Digging Under Los Angeles - Newsweek
Hollywood Film Awards to Honor Adam Sandler, Director Joe Wright (Exclusive)
Kevin Spacey apologizes after actor accuses him of harassment when he was a teenager
AI Can Detect Bowel Cancer In Less Than A Second
Iran blocks 'illegal' rally at ancient king's tomb
Apple fires iPhone X engineer after daughter posts hands-on video before official release - India Today
'Walk away' Theresa May under pressure to quit Brexit talks and leave EU with NO DEAL
How 'Stranger Things' Season 2 Expands its Upside Down Universe
MSNBC Host Skewers Claims Clinton Helped Sell Uranium To The Russians
‘DO SOMETHING!’: Panicky Trump Tweets about ‘phony Trump/Russia collusion’ as Monday arrests loom
Trump denounces Russia investigation 'witch hunt' as possible charges loom
This mystery object may be our first visitor from another solar system
Oakland A's catcher Bruce Maxwell arrested on gun charge
Celebrate National Cat Day With These Record-Setting Felines
Spain: thousands join Barcelona rally against Catalan independence
Bank of England set to raise interest rates for first time in a decade this week
United states of Europe: Juncker's plot for Chancellor for ALL of EU
Steps for crafting the perfect password
Theresa May: 'I will use all my power to transform mental health services'
Trump says will release nearly all JFK assassination files
Canadian astronomer spots 'visitor' from beyond our solar system
Queen and Prince Philip anniversary: The day Britain celebrated royal wedding 70 years ago
Hollywood Film Awards to Honor Kate Winslet and Jake Gyllenhaal
Victoria's Secret 2017: Who is performing at the show? Harry Styles Taylor Swift REUNION?
Robot who wants to ‘DESTROY humans’ has been given Saudi Arabia citizenship
WALK AWAY! Brexit no deal is 'win win' because EU needs UK MORE than we need them
YouTube prank sparks discussion of online teen safety
Russians fear 'ALIEN INVASION' and 'END OF THE WORLD' as Putin launches nuclear warning
'Stranger Things' Creators Explain the Darkest Turn of Season 2
White House: All The Women Who Say Trump Sexually Harassed Them Are Liars
Report: Russian lawyer who met with Trump Jr. discussed memo with Kremlin
WhatsApp FINALLY lets user delete sent messages, here’s how to do it
Catalonia government dissolved after declaring independence from Spain
How many barrels of oil are needed to mine one bitcoin?
White House: 'Real Russia scandal' is Clinton camp's ties to controversial dossier
Spain imposes direct rule after Catalonia votes to declare independence
NHS 'could have prevented' WannaCry ransomware attack
Stephen Colbert Believes Ivanka Trump "Doesn't Know What Words Mean"
Incomplete JFK file dump doesn't provide the drama Trump promised
WORLD WAR 3 FEARS: Russia unleashes SATAN 2 and fires ballistic missiles near North Korea
JFK files LIVE: KGB claim of Johnson plot to kill Kennedy, FBI bid to kill Castro - LATEST
Cloud computing drives massive growth for big US tech firms - Reuters
The latest AI can work things out without being taught
Twitter Bans Two Kremlin-Backed News Outlets From Advertising - New York Times
Google Pixelbook is an impressive Chromebook. But is it worth $1,000?
Apple Watch Series 3 - Major update makes the best smartwatch even better
Scientists discover VISITOR comet that DID not originate in our solar system
Netflix to Launch 'Stranger Things' After-Show (Exclusive)
Sen. Jeff Flake announces retirement in dramatic anti-Trump speech
Malware WARNING: 'Bad Rabbit' ransomware triggers flight delays, is YOUR PC susceptible?
Julian Assange: WikiLeaks Rejected Request From Trump-Linked Firm
World War 3: Trump blasts Russia for ‘HURTING’ a diplomatic resolution with North Korea
Megyn Kelly Asks Why Fox News Would "Unleash" Bill O'Reilly on Its Workforce
JFK files: Trump teases release as deadline arrives
Kate Middleton pregnancy in pictures: George, Charlotte and Baby No 3
Stephen Colbert, Ellen DeGeneres Take CNN's "Facts First" Campaign One Step Further
Bergen: War against ISIS goes global
North Korea announce plan for HUGE nuclear test - USA on alert
Watch an exclusive trailer for Angelina Jolie's timely animated film 'The Breadwinner'
President George H.W. Bush apologizes to actress who alleged improper touching
David Davis: Brexit deal will not take 'years'
Late-Night Hosts Invite God to Respond to Bill O'Reilly
Grambling State University: 2 shot dead on campus
North Korea owe Sweden £2.4billion after stealing 1,000 classic Volvos to use as TAXIS
Sky TV launches brand-new channel for Halloween
Europeans really want to work at Google
Einstein’s theory of happiness sells for $1.3M at auction
World War 3: US fires ominous warning to North Korea – 'We're ready to fight TONIGHT'
Trevor Noah Calls Out Fox News for Differing Treatment of Weinstein and O'Reilly
Protester throws Russia flags at Trump on Capitol Hill
WARNING: ISIS training jihadis in Caribbean tourist hotspots to target Western holidayers
Saudi Arabia vows to DESTROY extremism - Crown Prince announces return to ‘moderate Islam’
U.S. Is Now The Only Country, Besides Syria, Not To Support Paris Agreement
IVANKA: TAX CUTS NOW!
Macron BLOW as poorer EU nations REFUSE to buckle to French pressure on EU workers rights
Microsoft Declares Victory in Fight to Tell Users About Government Email Searches - Fortune
Federer or Nadal: Who has had the best year?
WATCH: Moment Jean-Claude Juncker is grilled over SHOCK German paper Brexit talk leaks
North Korea: women accused of killing Kim Jong-nam revisit scene of crime
George Clooney's "Twins" Make TV Debut on 'Jimmy Kimmel Live!'
Trump Called Up For Vietnam Service After Last Of Draft Deferments Expires
'Big Bang Theory' Star Simon Helberg Sells CIA Comedy to CBS
Cristiano Ronaldo named Best FIFA Men's Player for second year running
WATCH: Moment Emily Thornberry mouths at Theresa May during heated Brexit speech
George Clooney Talks About Wife Amal Facing Sexual Harassment
Melania Trump addresses bullying in surprise trip to Michigan
Catalan parliament to hold key session, discuss response to Spain’s plan to take control
“If we’re going to ask every American to serve, every American should serve.”
Two Italian regions are holding autonomy referendums
'The Walking Dead': How the 100th Episode Honored its Past
REVEALED: Shock graph that shows Lords could BLOCK Brexit even if we AGREE deal with EU
'Worse than nuclear bombs!' Putin reveals terrifying sci-fi weapon amid World War fears
Why Trump's Korean war talk should be taken seriously
Abe to push reform of Japan's pacifist constitution after election win - Reuters
Meghan Markle’s family’s anger as sister to cash in on relationship with Prince Harry
Tesla reaffirms effort to build cars in China; mum on deal report
WhatsApp might've revealed its next major new feature
Angelina Jolie on the 'vulnerability' of girls at The Breadwinner premiere in L.A
President Trump: With tax reform we can make it morning in America again
Trump on North Korea: 'We're prepared for anything'
Experts worried as mountain hosting North Korea’s nuclear blasts shows signs of exhaustion
Carlo Ancelotti favourite to replace Antonio Conte at Chelsea - Exclusive
Jimmy Carter interview: Five memorable lines
Google Pixel 2 might have the same problem as iPhone 6 Plus, and this video shows why
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle engagement IMMINENT as aides told to start planning wedding
All five living former US presidents make rare appearance together
Trump says he will allow scheduled release of JFK files
Who wants Amazon’s HQ2 the most? Take a look at bids from other cities
Trump: 'End of the ISIS caliphate is in sight' - CNN
‘This is a coup!’ Catalonia chaos erupts with calls for independence NOW as Spain steps in
Bitcoin smashes through $6,100 to hit a new record high
Loved ones say good-bye to Sgt. La David Johnson, US soldier slain in Niger
EU to IMITATE Spain's brutal Catalan tactics in Brexit no-deal, warns former No 10 insider
IBM lags in cloud computing and AI. Can tech’s great survivor recover?
Razer made a webcam with a selfie light for streamers - The Verge
7 hilariously brutal cartoons about the GOP's last-chance health-care bill
Laptops could be banned from checked bags on planes due to fire risk
Windows 10 Fall Creators Update has THIS great hidden feature
French envoy attempt to 'seduce British businesses and exploit UK industry Brexit fears'
Senate investigators spoke with Russians present at Trump Tower meeting with Trump Jr
The women fighters who helped defeat ISIS in Raqqa
Trump incorrectly suggests link between terrorism and rising UK crime rate - CNN
Bittersweet return for Leigh Halfpenny as Scarlets lose at Toulon
Lara Trump becomes face of Donald Trump's 2020 re-election campaign
Dusty Baker out as Nationals manager
Lulu the dog did not want to join the CIA, but she’s still a very good girl
Catalonia economic chaos: Independence to push Spanish debt to 120 per cent of GDP
Google Play 'try it now' button lets users test-drive an Android app without installing it - TechRepublic
Angela Merkel eases Theresa May's Brexit nightmare
OnePlus promises to stop collecting YOUR data with future update
UK faces MONTHS of SNOW: Sinking polar vortex to trigger COLDEST winter since GREAT FREEZE
The Return of Obama - U.S. News & World Report
UK mobile phone firms overcharging customers after contracts expire - The Guardian
REVEALED: Prince Harry and Meghan Markle ‘wedding date already set’
Hollywood Film Awards to Honor 'Blade Runner 2049,' 'The Disaster Artist'
South Korea does a sudden U-turn on nuclear power
Amanda Holden teases Simon Cowell ROMANCE as she makes shock confession
Google Maps: How to explore space with Google's interactive map of the solar system
George W. Bush Condemned The Trend Of ‘Nationalism Distorted Into Nativism’
World War 3: EU security boss issues STERN threat to North Korea - 'gravest punishment'
Ellen DeGeneres Talks Sexual Assault in Hollywood, Praises #MeToo Movement
Google's parent company leads $1 billion investment in Lyft
North Korea threatens 'unimaginable' strike on United States
'Survivor' Season 35: Jeff Probst Breaks Down the Tribe Swap
Google Doodle: Who is astrophysicist S. Chandrasekhar? - Metro
Trump tried to look compassionate. Instead, he looked like a jerk
Is Merkel BLUFFING? Leaked paper shows Germany is preparing for EU trade deal with Britain
Samsung's new camera has 17 lenses and costs $10500 - CNET
Relationship between sugar and cancer is now clearer, scientists say
Howard Stern on Harvey Weinstein: "When Did This Guy Have Time to Make Movies?"
'It's able to create knowledge itself': Google unveils AI that learns on its own
Roma fans in London RIOT: Supporters clash with police ahead of Chelsea match
BREAKING: Explosion rips through Belgian restaurant - at least three injured
3 killed, 2 wounded in shooting at Maryland office park, authorities say
Hillary Clinton calls Trump's North Korea threats 'dangerous' and 'short-sighted' - Business Insider
Trump Freaks Out After FBI Confirms Comey Wrote Clinton Exoneration Letter
IBM gets a boost from low taxes and cloud computing
Rihanna’s cosmetics line is a game-changer for women of colour
Storm Brian WORSE than Ophelia: Met Office confirm 'dangerous' WEATHER BOMB to SMASH UK
The Xi Jinping economy: What's next for China?
Liverpool and Man City run riot in Europe as Tottenham salvage point against Real Madrid
Battle against Bitcoin: Russia launches own cryptocurrency dubbed the Cryptoruble
Trump warns McCain: 'Be careful ... I fight back'
Britain facing most 'intense' terror threat ever, MI5 boss warns
Google firm wins competition to build high-tech Quayside neighbourhood in Toronto
Netflix Sort of Releases Some Ratings Data
BREAKING: Royal baby due date REVEALED - Kate and William make big announcement
Jennifer Lawrence shares story of abuse in Hollywood: I had to lose 15 pounds, pose nude
MIPCOM: Nominations for International Emmy Kids Span 16 Countries
MIPCOM: Harvey Weinstein Scandal Hangs Over Cannes
North Korea defector says life is MUCH WORSE than what the West says
ISIS routed in Raqqa as 'major military operations' declared over
Families warned: Mortgage interest rates set to RISE as inflation hits five-year high
BREAKING: Air force jet pilot dies as F-18 crashes while wife and son wait for his return
Emotional Sen. John McCain blasts 'half-baked, spurious nationalism'
Will the next iPhone charge wirelessly?
'I dread it': Jimmy Kimmel opens up about those emotional monologues
North Korea Says Nuclear War ‘May Break Out Any Moment’
UK universities 'generate almost £100 billion a YEAR for the economy'
Brexit dinner SHOWDOWN: Theresa May arrives in Brussels for crunch talks
North Korea rejects diplomacy with US for now, source says
WI-FI WARNING - Almost ALL phones, PCs and tablets vulnerable to devastating attack
End is NIGH: Social media panic as blood red sun rises above UK in terrifying phenomenon
Hillary Clinton Compares Trump With Harvey Weinstein
Mysterious Planet Nine Exists: NASA Close To Finding It, Reassures Us It Won't Hit The Earth - Tech Times
DANCING QUEEN! Kate with baby bump on full show jives with Paddington Bear
Kirkuk: A crisis waiting to happen, with consequences for region
Barcelona News: Lionel Messi had secret Antoine Griezmann transfer chat after La Liga draw
Hurricane Ophelia track: Storm develops huge ‘STING JET’ that is terrifying forecasters
Catalonia leader fails to clarify independence declaration
'Wonder Wheel': Film Review | NYFF 2017
Windows 10 Fall Creators Update - Why users may face a delay in downloading this upgrade
Clinton on Putin: 'Keep an eye on him, because he's not done'
Victoria Beckham posts Instagram pic of her sons
Close