Close
Date TimeSeptember 21, 2019
Voice
Breaking Down the Whistleblower Frenzy
The Democrats’ media narrative of impeachment portrays President Trump and his administration as serial law-breakers who, true to form, obstruct all congressional investigations of wrongdoing. This then becomes the analytical framework for every new controversy. There are at least two fundamental problems with this.First, our constitutional system is based on friction between competing branches vested with separate but closely related powers. The Framers understood that the two political branches would periodically try to usurp each other’s authorities. Congress often does this by enactments that seek to subject executive power to congressional (or judicial) supervision. Presidential pushback on such laws is not criminal obstruction; it is the Constitution in action.Second, we’ve become so law-obsessed that we miss the forest for the trees. Often, the least important aspect of a controversy -- viz., whether a law has been violated -- becomes the dominant consideration. Short shrift is given to the more consequential aspects, such as whether we are being competently governed or whether power is being abused.These problems are now playing out in the Trump controversy du jour (or should I say de l'heure?): the intelligence community whistleblower.As this column is written on Friday afternoon, the story is still evolving, with the president tweeting as ever, and the New York Times producing a report by no fewer than eight of its top journalists, joining the seven (and counting) who are working it for the Washington Post, which broke the story.It stems from -- what else? -- anonymous leaks attributed to former intelligence officials. Whether they are among the stable of such retirees now on the payroll at anti-Trump cable outlets is not known. While the media purport to be deeply concerned about Trump-administration law-breaking in classified matters, there is negligible interest in whether the intelligence officials leaking to them are flouting the law.A Promise to Ukraine? In any event, we learn that an unidentified “whistleblower” has filed a complaint with the intelligence community’s inspector general (IGIC), relating that President Trump had recent interaction with an unidentified foreign leader during which the president made a “promise” which is not further described to us, other than that the whistleblower found it very “troubling.” The inference that President Trump is the subject of the complaint (or at least a subject) derives from the fact that intelligence officials say it involves someone who is “outside the intelligence community,” and that there are issues of “privilege” that justify non-disclosure to Congress. (The president is “outside” the intelligence community in the sense of being over it as chief executive; and, as I discussed in a column earlier this week, presidents have executive privilege, which shields communications with advisers.)The latest news to break suggests that the communications (there is more than one) relate, at least in part, to Ukraine. The whistleblower complaint is believed to have been filed on August 12. President Trump is known to have spoken by phone with Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelensky on July 25. Rudy Giuliani, who is Trump’s private lawyer (and who hired me as a prosecutor many years ago), has been open about urging Ukraine to pursue an investigation implicating Democratic presidential hopeful Joe Biden. Specifically, when he was Obama-administration vice president, Biden is rumored to have pressured Ukraine to fire a prosecutor who was conducting a corruption investigation of a natural-gas company. Biden’s son, Hunter, sat on the company’s board, and his law firm was lavishly compensated.Thus, the theorizing in anti-Trump circles is that an intelligence official privy to details of the July 25 call must have learned that the president made a quid pro quo arrangement with Ukraine, promising some kind of assistance in exchange for movement on an investigation that could politically wound Trump’s potential 2020 opponent. (A CNN interview that became a spirited argument between Giuliani and Chris Cuomo got lots of play on Friday. Meanwhile, to my knowledge, there has not been much congressional interest in examining Obama-administration and Clinton-campaign dealings with Ukraine in 2016, when our government encouraged Kiev to investigate Paul Manafort, and a leak about a claim of lavish cash payments to Manafort resulted in his removal as Trump’s campaign chairman.)President Trump is pooh-poohing the whistleblower complaint as a fabrication by “Radical Left Democrats and their Fake News Partners, headed up again by Little Adam Schiff.” That last derogatory reference is to the California Democrat and Trump antagonist who chairs the House Intelligence Committee. Conveniently omitted by the president are the facts that (a) the whistleblower has tried to comply with federal law and go through government channels rather than leaking information to the Trump-hostile media; (b) the IGIC to whom the whistleblower made his report is a Trump appointee, namely Michael Atkinson, a career Justice Department prosecutor who got the IGIC gig in 2018; and (c) Atkinson concluded that the whistleblower’s complaint was credible and sufficiently serious to be deemed a matter of “urgent concern.”‘Urgent Concern’ -- Another Confusing Dual-Use Term This brings us to a common situation that we rarely notice but that often skews public debate. I’ll call it the dual-use term: A word or phrase that has both a common meaning because it is invoked in everyday parlance and a specialized meaning in statutory law -- either because Congress has taken the trouble to define it or the courts have authoritatively construed it.“Urgent concern” is a dual-use term. Such terms confuse things because politicians seamlessly shift from the common to the specialized meaning. Frequently, legal consequences limited to the narrower legal sense of the term are triggered by anything that fits the term’s broad general understanding. To take a notorious example, “collusion” -- the subject, ahem, of a certain new book -- has both a broad general connotation (concerted activity that can be benign or sinister, or anything in between) and a narrow specialized meaning when invoked in law-enforcement investigations (criminal conspiracy). For years, Chairman Schiff and other Trump critics have intimated that episodes of unremarkable collusion in the broad sense (e.g., negotiating policy or real-estate deals with Russians) are evidence of illegal collusion in the narrow, specialized sense (conspiracy to commit cyberespionage with Russians).The common meaning of urgent concern is obvious: It could describe anything that raises the specter of imminent harm. But urgent concern is also a specialized term in federal law. Under Section 3033(k)(5)(G) (of Title 50, U.S. Code), an “urgent concern” relates to specified problems involving intelligence activities and classified information that are within the responsibility of the Director of National Intelligence. The DNI is the cabinet official who oversees the so-called community of intelligence agencies. The urgent concerns Section 3033 outlines include, for example, violations or abuses of laws or executive orders, or deficiencies in the funding, administration or operation of an intelligence activity. Section 3033 urgent concerns also include misleading of Congress regarding intelligence activities, and reprisals against whistleblowers who report an urgent concern.Notice the difference between the common and statutory meaning.Any executive action that imperils national security, particularly in connection with classified information falling into the hands of a foreign power, could accurately be described as a matter of urgent concern, as that term is commonly understood. Even if there were no Section 3033, and there were no specialized statutory definition of “urgent concern,” it would be entirely appropriate for Congress to inquire into such matters.On the other hand, if a situation qualifies as one of the narrower sets of “urgent concerns” defined by Section 3033, it triggers the mandatory reporting procedures prescribed in the statute. To wit, if an intelligence official believes a Section 3033 urgent concern has arisen, that official (a whistleblower) may report the matter to the IGIC with an eye toward its transmission to Congress. The IGIC then has two weeks to decide whether a complaint is credible. If the IGIC so finds, the matter must be referred to the DNI, who must notify the congressional intelligence committees within one week.Section 3033 Does Not Apply to the President Here, the whistleblower (who is reportedly represented by a lawyer well versed in Section 3033) believed President Trump’s undescribed promise to the unidentified foreign leader qualified as an “urgent concern” under the statute. On August 12, the whistleblower reported the matter to IGIC Atkinson. In what I believe was an error, Atkinson concluded that the complaint did indeed spell out a Section 3033 urgent concern because it was credible and raised a serious issue. (As we’ll see, my quarrel is with the application of the statute to the president; I assume the Trump-appointed IGIC is correct that the complaint is credible and serious.)Atkinson thus notified Joseph Maguire, the acting DNI. Maguire, however, did not believe the matter met the Section 3033 definition of an urgent concern, because it related to an activity by someone not under the authority of the DNI (inferentially, the president). Consequently, Maguire declined to pass the complaint along to the House and Senate Intelligence Committees.As noted above, current and former intelligence officials continue to leak like sieves in their years-long campaign against the sitting president. Thus, the existence of the complaint, the report of it to the IGIC, and the acting DNI’s refusal to alert Congress became known to the media and to Chairman Schiff. The chairman is claiming that the Trump administration is violating the law by failing to notify Congress of an urgent concern, as mandated by Section 3033.In my view, Chairman Schiff’s claim, based on IGIC Atkinson’s interpretation of the statute, is wrong. Section 3033 does not apply to a president’s negotiations with or commitments to foreign powers, or to a president’s sharing of classified information with foreign powers. To repeat, the statute applies to intelligence activities by government officials acting under the authority of the DNI. If I am right, the Trump administration should not be accused of law-breaking for declining to follow Section 3033, even if the whistleblower had an “urgent concern” in the ordinary understanding of that term.In our system, the conduct of foreign policy is a nigh plenary authority of the chief executive. The only exceptions are explicitly stated in the Constitution (Congress regulates foreign commerce, the Senate must approve treaties, etc.). Congress may not enact statutes that limit the president’s constitutional power to conduct foreign policy; the Constitution may not be amended by statute.Consistent with this principle, the Justice Department has long adhered to the so-called “clear statement” rule: If the express terms of a statute do not apply its provisions to the president, then the statute is deemed not to apply to the president if its application would conflict with the president’s constitutional powers. Section 3033 does not refer to the president. By its terms, it applies to intelligence-community officials. And, in any event, it may not properly be applied to the president if doing so would hinder the president’s capacious authority to conduct foreign policy.At least when a Republican is in the White House, progressives are enthralled by laws that, in effect, empower bureaucrats -- here, “intelligence professionals”- to second-guess and otherwise check the president’s power to direct the executive branch. That is not our system.Congress’s Selective Interest in Presidential Abuses of Power In conducting foreign affairs, the president may make commitments to other foreign leaders (subject to the Constitution’s treaty clause). The president, unlike his subordinates, also has the power to disclose any classified information he chooses to disclose. Like all presidential powers, these may be abused or exercised rashly. When there is a credible allegation that they have been, that should cause all of us urgent concern.To take one example, President Obama misled Congress and the nation regarding the concessions he made to Iran in connection with the nuclear deal (the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action). The Obama administration, moreover, structured the arrangement so that commitments to Iran were withheld from Congress -- as if what were at stake were understandings strictly between Tehran and the U.N.’s monitor (the International Atomic Energy Agency), somehow of no concern to the United States. Representative Schiff’s skepticism about Iran became muted when a Democratic president cut the deal. Yet these cloak-and-dagger arrangements with a jihadist regime that proclaims itself America’s mortal enemy, in which a U.S. president willfully end-ran the Constitution’s treaty provisions and congressional oversight, were and remain urgent concerns for millions of Americans and most members of Congress.So how should we evaluate the current controversy?For starters, we should recognize what is important and what is not. Section 3033 should be the least of our considerations. As argued above, it very likely does not apply, despite the IGIC’s conclusion to the contrary. Its lack of application would not stop the whistleblower from getting the information to Congress (though it may affect whether the whistleblower is protected from reprisals). More to the point, it is irrelevant whether Congress should have been notified within one week of X date as prescribed by statute. Regardless of whether I am right about the statute’s inapplicability, the intelligence committees are now on notice and positioned to examine the matter.The issue is not Section 3033 and whether the DNI should have alerted Schiff. The issue is whether President Trump has abused his foreign-affairs powers.On that score, we should withhold judgment until more facts are in. Democrats would have us leap to the conclusion that impeachable offenses have been committed; the president would have us dismiss the matter out of hand as a political contrivance. There are reasons to doubt both of them.For one thing, there has been a three-year campaign by current and former government officials to undermine the Trump presidency by lawless leaks of politicized intelligence. On the other side of the coin, though, IGIC Michael Atkinson is a Trump appointee. It is he who found the whistleblower’s complaint serious and credible. And the acting DNI, Joseph Maguire, does not appear to be refuting that conclusion; his quibble (which I share) appears to be that Section 3033 urgent concerns are inapposite where presidential foreign-affairs powers are involved. Many of President Trump’s foreign policy moves have been impulsive; it is hardly inconceivable that he could have offered a commitment that was poorly thought through. Giuliani, a key outside adviser to the president, has been pressing the Ukrainians to look into Biden, and, when asked on Friday about whether he discussed Biden in the July call with Ukraine’s president, Trump declined to answer directly, replying, “Someone ought to look into Joe Biden.”And maybe someone should. The fact that Biden may end up being Trump’s rival in the 2020 election does not immunize him from investigation. If he used his political influence to squeeze a foreign power for his son’s benefit, that should be explored. Of course, Trump should not use the powers of his office solely for the purpose of obtaining campaign ammunition to deploy against a potential foe. But all presidents who seek reelection wield their power in ways designed to improve their chances. If Trump went too far in that regard, we could look with disfavor on that while realizing that he would not be the first president to have done so. And if, alternatively, the president had a good reason for making a reciprocal commitment to Ukraine, that commitment would not become improper just because, collaterally, it happened to help Trump or harm Biden politically.The president has the power to conduct foreign policy as he sees fit. The Congress has the power to subject that exercise to thorough examination. The clash of these powers is a constant in our form of government. It is politics. For once, let’s find out what happened before we leap to DEFCON 1.

Related Stories
The ATF Has Been Enforcing a Rule That Does Not ExistThe ATF Has Been Enforcing a Rule That Does Not Exist
Investigation Launched Into Awarding Of Grant To Boris Johnsons Close FriendInvestigation Launched Into Awarding Of Grant To Boris Johnson's 'Close Friend'
Labour NEC In Shock Move To Abolish Tom Watsons Deputy Leader PostLabour NEC In Shock Move To Abolish Tom Watson's Deputy Leader Post
Donald Trump vows to hit Taliban harder than ever on 9/11 anniversaryDonald Trump vows to 'hit Taliban harder than ever' on 9/11 anniversary
Dem presidential candidates call for Kavanaughs impeachmentDem presidential candidates call for Kavanaugh's impeachment
John Oliver Explains Why Trump Might Finally Be Impeached Over Ukraine Whistleblower ScandalJohn Oliver Explains Why Trump Might Finally Be Impeached Over Ukraine Whistleblower Scandal
The blockbuster that wasnt: inside an alleged $14m scam to make the next Netflix hitThe blockbuster that wasn't: inside an alleged $14m scam to make the next Netflix hit
Bill Clinton and Jeb Bush seek refuge from Trump impeachment stormBill Clinton and Jeb Bush seek refuge from Trump impeachment storm
Anthony Joshua defends desert fight and points to Saudi Arabia ‘reforms’Anthony Joshua defends desert fight and points to Saudi Arabia ‘reforms’
Everything You Wanted To Know About Life As A Flight AttendantEverything You Wanted To Know About Life As A Flight Attendant
Latest News
Parliament Votes on Boris Johnson’s Brexit Deal: Your GuideParliament Votes on Boris Johnson’s Brexit Deal: Your Guide
Gabbard Responds to Hillary’s Russia Attacks, Challenges Her to Join Dem PrimaryGabbard Responds to Hillary’s Russia Attacks, Challenges Her to Join Dem Primary
Protesters Lose Appeal on Police’s March Ban: Hong Kong UpdateProtesters Lose Appeal on Police’s March Ban: Hong Kong Update
GOP member Rooney thinking about impeachmentGOP member Rooney 'thinking' about impeachment
Brexit reversed: How could Britain end up with a second referendum?Brexit reversed: How could Britain end up with a second referendum?
All the hood rats would jam with us: Grandmaster Flash, AJ Tracey and other artists on the generation gap'All the hood rats would jam with us': Grandmaster Flash, AJ Tracey and other artists on the generation gap
Patrick Day didnt need to be savedPatrick Day didn't need to be saved
Streaming: Meryl Streep kicks off a season of starry Netflix offeringsStreaming: Meryl Streep kicks off a season of starry Netflix offerings
The Circle Final Brings The Drama As The Players Find Out The Truth About SammieThe Circle Final Brings The Drama As The Players Find Out The Truth About 'Sammie'
The Batman Casts Paul Dano As The Riddler, To Appear Opposite Robert PattinsonThe Batman Casts Paul Dano As The Riddler, To Appear Opposite Robert Pattinson
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Boris-JohnsonBoris Johnson
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Theresa-MayTheresa May
Member of Parliament of the United Kingdom
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
The ATF Has Been Enforcing a Rule That Does Not ExistThe ATF Has Been Enforcing a Rule That Does Not Exist
Investigation Launched Into Awarding Of Grant To Boris Johnsons Close FriendInvestigation Launched Into Awarding Of Grant To Boris Johnson's 'Close Friend'
Labour NEC In Shock Move To Abolish Tom Watsons Deputy Leader PostLabour NEC In Shock Move To Abolish Tom Watson's Deputy Leader Post
Donald Trump vows to hit Taliban harder than ever on 9/11 anniversaryDonald Trump vows to 'hit Taliban harder than ever' on 9/11 anniversary
Dem presidential candidates call for Kavanaughs impeachmentDem presidential candidates call for Kavanaugh's impeachment
John Oliver Explains Why Trump Might Finally Be Impeached Over Ukraine Whistleblower ScandalJohn Oliver Explains Why Trump Might Finally Be Impeached Over Ukraine Whistleblower Scandal
The blockbuster that wasnt: inside an alleged $14m scam to make the next Netflix hitThe blockbuster that wasn't: inside an alleged $14m scam to make the next Netflix hit
Bill Clinton and Jeb Bush seek refuge from Trump impeachment stormBill Clinton and Jeb Bush seek refuge from Trump impeachment storm
Anthony Joshua defends desert fight and points to Saudi Arabia ‘reforms’Anthony Joshua defends desert fight and points to Saudi Arabia ‘reforms’
Everything You Wanted To Know About Life As A Flight AttendantEverything You Wanted To Know About Life As A Flight Attendant
Latest News
Parliament Votes on Boris Johnson’s Brexit Deal: Your GuideParliament Votes on Boris Johnson’s Brexit Deal: Your Guide
Gabbard Responds to Hillary’s Russia Attacks, Challenges Her to Join Dem PrimaryGabbard Responds to Hillary’s Russia Attacks, Challenges Her to Join Dem Primary
Protesters Lose Appeal on Police’s March Ban: Hong Kong UpdateProtesters Lose Appeal on Police’s March Ban: Hong Kong Update
GOP member Rooney thinking about impeachmentGOP member Rooney 'thinking' about impeachment
Brexit reversed: How could Britain end up with a second referendum?Brexit reversed: How could Britain end up with a second referendum?
All the hood rats would jam with us: Grandmaster Flash, AJ Tracey and other artists on the generation gap'All the hood rats would jam with us': Grandmaster Flash, AJ Tracey and other artists on the generation gap
Patrick Day didnt need to be savedPatrick Day didn't need to be saved
Streaming: Meryl Streep kicks off a season of starry Netflix offeringsStreaming: Meryl Streep kicks off a season of starry Netflix offerings
The Circle Final Brings The Drama As The Players Find Out The Truth About SammieThe Circle Final Brings The Drama As The Players Find Out The Truth About 'Sammie'
The Batman Casts Paul Dano As The Riddler, To Appear Opposite Robert PattinsonThe Batman Casts Paul Dano As The Riddler, To Appear Opposite Robert Pattinson
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Boris-JohnsonBoris Johnson
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Theresa-MayTheresa May
Member of Parliament of the United Kingdom
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
US and El Salvador sign agreement on asylum to curb migration
Saudi Arabia to wait for investigation before responding to attacks: minister
Cory Booker will exit presidential race if $1.7m not raised by end of month
Heavy rain, locally severe storms to soak the central US this weekend
Milan v Inter: Serie A – live!
Jon Rahm and Danny Willett pull three shots clear in BMW PGA Championship
Fabian Schär rescues poor Newcastle in drab stalemate with Brighton
Football League: Preston and QPR close gap on Championship's top two
Iran issues 'battlefield' warning and U.S. deploys troops
US sending more troops to Gulf, Trump announces Iran sanctions
Saudi Aramco has emerged from attacks 'stronger than ever': CEO
U.S. Orders Defensive Boost to Mideast After Saudi Attacks
Dozens detained in Kazakhstan at anti-China protests
Women leave Montana town over border agency lawsuit backlash
Refugees from rising seas: no place to call home
Paper tigers: India's big cat surveys 'over reporting numbers'
Manchester City hit eight past Watford as Bernardo Silva scores hat-trick
T20 Blast Finals Day: Essex to face Worcestershire in final – live!
Sheffield United win at Everton to put pressure on Marco Silva
Burnley’s Chris Wood hits double to bring Norwich crashing to earth
Nicky Henderson commits Altior to taking on fellow-titan Cyrname
Chris Martin’s late strike sees Derby snatch draw from wasteful Leeds
Jake Bidwell sent off as promotion rivals Bristol City and Swansea fail to fire
Batman Day Takes Flight Worldwide, ‘Joker’ Takes Cue From ‘Catwoman’
A YouTuber and a U-Haul full of strangers: Inside the final attempt to storm Area 51
Queer Eye’s Jonathan Van Ness Opens Up About ‘Devastating’ HIV Diagnosis
Labour Chief Jennie Formby Thanks NHS For Saving Her Life From Cancer
Government Urged To Help As Thomas Cook Seeks £200m To Prevent Collapse
Epstein Victim: Ghislaine Maxwell Made Me Recruit ‘Youngest-Looking’ Girls for Epstein
Justices' DC sniper case examines teen murderers' sentences
Trump attacks Biden after ‘repeatedly urging Ukrainian president’ to investigate 2020 opponent’s son
Candace Owens to House panel: 'White supremacy and white nationalism is not a problem'
China's Pacific influence grows as it signs up new friend in Solomon Islands
New Zealand defy doubters and South Africa in clash of World Cup titans | Liam Napier
Charles Leclerc storms to Singapore F1 GP pole ahead of Lewis Hamilton
Newcastle v Brighton: Premier League – live!
T20 Blast Finals Day: Derbyshire chasing 161 to beat Essex – live!
Rugby World Cup: Key moments as New Zealand, France and Australia win – video highlights
Read and Barrett react after All Blacks' thrilling win over Springboks – video
Rape Complainants Face 'Routine' Requests To Hand Over Phone Data
Imelda’s toll in Texas: Flooding and fears about a bridge
GOP Strategy to Shield Trump by Canceling Primaries Carries Risk
Parachutists jump over Dutch heath to mark WWII operation
Manchester City v Watford, Premier League and more: clockwatch – live!
Leicester’s fast start continues as James Maddison sinks Spurs with late stunner
T20 Blast Finals Day: Worcs pip Notts to reach final, Derbyshire v Essex – live!
How the greatest Red Sox team in history turned into an embarrassment
Chloë Sevigny: ‘Make lists after break-ups or have a passionate fling
Epstein Accuser Claims Prince Andrew 'Thanked' Her For Sex
Extinction Rebellion Activists 'Superglue' Themselves To A20 In Bid To 'Blockade' Port Of Dover
Area 51 events mostly peaceful; thousands in Nevada desert
White supremacist who praised ‘psychedelic Nazis’ caught with stockpile of guns and LSD
United States announces military response and Iran sanctions after attacks on Saudi oil facilities
History buff finds ships that sank in 1878 in Lake Michigan
Khalid review – teen spirit squandered?
New Zealand stand firm against South Africa in heavyweight thriller
T20 Blast Finals Day: Notts chasing 148 to beat Worcs in first semi-final – live!
Lizzie Deignan heads GB’s World Championships charge in Harrogate
New Zealanders vent anger at being unable to watch Rugby World Cup
Extinction Rebellion Activists To 'Blockade' Port Of Dover
Labour’s ‘Politburo’ To Decide Who's PM If Jeremy Corbyn Suddenly Quits No.10
Corbyn Halts Motion To Scrap Tom Watson's Labour Deputy Leader Position
AOC's first congressional endorsements reflect subtle shift away from outsider status
Mosques in Liberia dedicate Friday prayers to pupils killed in fire
Trump news: US nuclear arsenal now 'in tippy-top shape' says president when asked about responding to Iran: 'We should all pray we don't have to use them'
Three Mile Island nuclear power plant's shutdown is imminent
US to send troops to Saudi Arabia, hold off on striking Iran
Argentina heartbreak after Camille Lopez’s drop goal rescues France
Leicester v Tottenham: Premier League – live!
T20 Blast Finals Day: Worcestershire v Nottinghamshire in first semi – live!
Scotland’s Duncan Taylor aims to upset Ireland after injury nightmare
Where does Reece Hodge’s baffling escape leave high tackle crackdown? | Andy Bull
GWS holds out Collingwood to reach first ever grand final
Sir Bradley Wiggins: ‘My most embarrassing moment? Post 2012, I had a few hissy fits’
The Goldfinch: would it have worked better as a TV show?
Labour's Tom Watson Condemns Move To Abolish His Position
Jennifer Lopez Took Everyone Back To 2000 In A Jaw-Dropping New Version Of *That* Versace Dress At Milan Fashion Week
Thousands of Paris police deployed over 'yellow vest' clash fears
'It’s happening, [Trump] is getting impeached', says former White House ethics chief
Anti-Sisi protests break out in Egypt, several arrested
Navy Orders Trial for Two in Hazing Death of Green Beret Logan Melgar
Trump Says 'It's Crazy' to Spend $13 Million Per Inmate at Guantánamo
Taylor Swift cancels Melbourne Cup performance after criticism from animal rights groups
France v Argentina: Rugby World Cup 2019 – live!
New Zealand v South Africa: Rugby World Cup 2019 – live!
Australia rally to Rugby World Cup win as Fiji count cost of high Hodge tackle
Rugby World Cup: Wales aim to put Howley saga to bed against Georgia
Always in Season: behind the painful film about lynching in America
Streaming: gently does it with Dominga Sotomayor
Is James Bond about to die? What the new 007 title might mean
Graham Norton Reveals His Favourite Ever Guest - And Who He Still Wants To Get On His Couch
Why Are So Many People Publicly Confronting Boris Johnson? We Asked The Experts
Who Will Be Labour's Next Leader? Why Laura Pidcock Is The One To Watch
Sheriff: 1 officer dead, 1 injured in Louisiana shooting
Area 51 raid lures festive UFO hunters to Nevada desert; five arrested
Republican Rep Spars with Al Sharpton over Past Anti-Semitic, Racist Remarks during Congressional Hearing
Making Sense of Israel’s Post-Election Political Chaos
Romesh Ranganathan: My kids loved Lil Dicky’s Earth – but not for the reasons I hoped
Justin Trudeau’s Blackface Photos Force Reckoning On Canada’s Global Image
Here's Why You Should Walk Your Child To School On Monday
Climate Strike 2019: How Our Kids Woke Us Up To Care Again
Colt to stop making AR-15 rifles, weapon of choice in US mass shootings
Trump Announces ‘Highest Level’ of New Sanctions on Iranian National Bank
Israel's Netanyahu clings to power as coalition talks loom
Russian priests break silence on opposition crackdown
Australia v Fiji: Rugby World Cup 2019 – live!
Experienced Wales looking forward to Rugby World Cup match up with Georgia
Host Japan rallies to open Rugby World Cup with win over Russia
'90s kids were asked to do 'simple things' to save the Earth. Gen Z is thinking bigger
A historic first? Israel's Arabs could lead parliamentary opposition
Trump Sues Own Accounting Firm, NYC District Attorney to Prevent Release of Tax Returns
House votes to end forced arbitration in business disputes
Taiwan loses another ally as Kiribati switches allegiance to China
Trump asked Ukraine president 8 times to investigate Joe Biden's son, say reports
Trump says he was 'surprised' by Canadian Prime Minster Justin Trudeau's blackface scandal
Atlantic likely to churn out tropical systems into 2nd half of September
Texas man wanted for allegedly divorcing his wife without her knowledge
Scenes of destruction at Saudi oil plant hit by attacks
Hong Kong police warn officers 'might have to kill someone' as violence escalates
The Latest: Greek refugee camp unable to house new arrivals
Officials: Political donor caused deadly overdose during sex
Hong Kong diners offered protest-inspired 'eyeball' mocktails and 'tear gas' eggs
'They're forming like roaches.' The 6 tropical storms whirling at once have tied a record
Pro-China groups to tear down pro-democracy graffiti in Hong Kong
Iranian Foreign Minister Says U.S. Military Strike Means ‘All-Out War’
Houston area sees relief, rescues after Imelda leaves 4 dead
This nomad couple travels the country and lives out of their custom built van!
Mason Mount already a go-to man for Lampard in his new-look Chelsea | Jacob Steinberg
Taking Horses: Bank on Arecibo to strike in the Ayr Gold Cup
Inside Saudi Arabia's response to a raid on the heart of the oil kingdom
Young Black Voters to Their Biden-Supporting Parents: 'Is This Your King?'
U.S. Senate hearing to confirm Trump pick Issa for trade post delayed by concern over FBI check
Trump slams 'partisan' whistleblower as scandal swirls
Gerald Bostock Was Fired. He Wants His Supreme Court Case to Help Change LGBTQ Rights in America
Yang predicts Trump's nickname for him
Hezbollah tells Saudi Arabia to stop Yemen war
England’s World Cup preparations disrupted by team doctor’s exit
George Ford takes inspiration from the Beckham experience in Sapporo
Wigan dig deep to hold off a spirited Salford in qualifying final
Buoyant Bournemouth sink Southampton to stay on upward curve
New England Patriots release Antonio Brown amid sexual assault allegations
Fleeting nature of tennis greatness makes legacy building tough | Tumaini Carayol
Death of Blue Girl shines light on women's rights in Iran
Liam Williams says senior Wales players have 'stepped up' after Howley exit
'Friends' at 25: The show creators tell all, from 'horrible' test screenings to the main character that never was
Charlie Rose Sued for Sexual Harassment by Longtime Makeup Artist
Labour NEC In Shock Move To Abolish Tom Watson's Deputy Leader Post
An attorney forced out of the CIA's watchdog office is representing the Trump whistleblower
2 dead as Imelda strands drivers, floods homes in Texas
Campaigning Trudeau vows Canada assault rifle ban
Son who threw his terminally ill 79-year-old mother to her death spared jail
AP Source: GM's offer to UAW would add lower-paying jobs
Rory McIlroy breathes sigh of relief after making PGA Championship cut
'I'm done': Bill Belichick shuts down presser over Antonio Brown questions
House Hunters host Suzanne Whang dies at 56
Candace Owens to Congress: ‘White Supremacy and White Nationalism Is Not a Problem’
Gun Owner Tells Beto ‘Hell No You’re Not’ Taking My Gun’ During Rally
Taiwan Loses Second Ally This Week to China
George Conway says Trump should be impeached if he pressured Ukraine to investigate Joe Biden
The Latest: Officials say third death tied to Imelda floods
Saudis threaten UN-brokered truce in strike near Yemeni port city
We got Obama elected! West Wing stars relive the parties, pranks and power games
Chris Drake obituary
Climate change could turn oceans from friend to foe, UN report warns
Opener provides result Rugby World Cup needed but real fireworks are to come | Paul Rees
Southampton v Bournemouth: Premier League – live!
Eden Hazard can shine at Real Madrid without being the new Cristiano Ronaldo | Barney Ronay
Sebastian Vettel adjusting to lower expectations at Singapore GP
Upbeat Moeen Ali to take break after losing his England Test contract
Fuji hogs the horizon as ITV fails to park stereotypes but passes World Cup test | Simon Burnton
‘Hustlers’ Banned in Malaysia for ‘Excessive Obscene Content’
Labour’s Ruling NEC Backs Move To Get More Black MPs In 'White' Areas Across UK
Which Friends Episode Is Really The Best, As The Show Turns 25?
8 WTF Moments The Cast Of Friends Have Experienced Since The Beloved Show Finished
Friends Characters We Wish We'd Seen More Of, As The Hit Show Turns 25
21 Climate Strike Pictures That Show How Massive Protests Really Are
PHOTOS: Tropical Storm Imelda floods Texas
With viral moments and hard facts, Democrats seek to seize the moment on gun control
The Latest: High winds topple scaffolding in San Antonio
Buttigieg’s Health Plan Gets One Big Thing Right
Why do e-cigarette makers suddenly want to be regulated?
Imelda leaves 2 dead in Texas, others stranded and trapped
Lebanon exhibits drones used in alleged Israeli attack
Thanks for the Dance: posthumous Leonard Cohen album announced
These discos are anything but silent | Letters
Japan open Rugby World Cup by overcoming dogged Russia
England can practise moving through World Cup gears against Tonga | Ugo Monye
Olympic cycling champion faces army warning for bare-cheeked Trump taunt
Chess: Jeffery Xiong aims to emulate Bobby Fischer after beating No2 seed
Talking Horses: Lyons will complete cunning plan if Buffer lifts the Cup
Rugby World Cup 2019: top try and points scorers
The Fiver | The feat of being Manchester United's youngest ever scorer in Europe
Trump says it 'doesn't matter what I discussed' with Ukraine's president amid whistleblower scandal
Fox & Friends mocks climate strike before pivoting to catastrophic hurricane coverage in Texas
With Mosul, the Russo brothers fall prey to white saviour syndrome
The Crown Season 3 Trailer: Long Live Queen Olivia Colman
Lenny Henry Jokes 'Hello, I’m Justin Trudeau' During Diversity Speech
19 Climate Strike Pictures That Show How Massive Protests Really Are
Labour Can, And Should, Leave Conference As A Pro-Remain Party
Teenager Arrested On Suspicion Of Murdering Woman Whose Body Was Found In A Stream
Close