Close
Date TimeMay 19, 2019
VoiceSally Wainwright has turned Anne Lister’s diary into a thrilling coal-town romp that flirts with parody
Gentleman Jack review: Suranne Jones rocks Halifax as the first modern lesbian
It’s Regency Fleabag! Because the heroine occasionally breaks the fourth wall and exteriorises her inner monologue. But it’s set in Halifax in 1832, so it could be Northern Jane Austen. Then again, it’s about Anne Lister, who – since her 4 million-word diary came to light and particularly the encoded sections were deciphered – has been dubbed the first modern lesbian, so maybe it’s Queer Brontë ...
You can afford to have a little fun with Gentleman Jack (BBC One); Sally Wainwright clearly has. The writer, best known for the harrowing Happy Valley series and whose most recent outing was a fierce account of the Brontës’ lives as the sisters of an unsalvageable alcoholic brother, has turned those 4 million words into eight pacy episodes that amount, by Wainwright standards, to almost a romp.
The title is the local nickname given to Lister, the manorial lord of all she surveys (thanks to an uncle who took one look at her hapless father and left the lot to his unconventional niece) in early 19th-century Shibden.
We first meet her surveying it all a bit bleakly, however. She has been forced home, it emerges in a series of flashbacks that punctuate the romp with sudden eruptions of terrible hope and sadness, by a love affair gone wrong. Miss Hobart, the “companion” Lister abandoned her international travels to attend, decided that discretion was the better part of valour and accepted a man’s offer of marriage. At the news, Lister (Suranne Jones, always spectacularly good at lunges of feeling towards either tragedy or comedy) simply howls into her beloved’s skirts in despair.
Most of the time, however, we are in Shibden itself. Lister reacclimatises herself to her “shabby little village and shabby little family” – or rather, Lister being wholly and indefatigably Lister, we are in Shibden as she forces it to reacclimatise to her.
She rides in with an injured coachman, no one else having had the gumption to pick up the reins. She takes over the rent-collecting from the estate’s usual man, turfing out underserving tenants as she goes. She makes plans to sink her own pits and start mining the plentiful coal sitting beneath the rest of them. She ignores any familial objections (“Nasty business, coal” says her father, who is played by Timothy West, thereby providing all of us who remember his magnificent Bradley Hardacre in Brass with a shining moment of glee) and generally sets the place to rights.
She is a woman who does not deal in half-measures in any area of life. In bed with her occasional visitor Mrs Lawton, she responds angrily to her suggestion that she too should marry a rich, titled man and quiet the gossips. “I thoroughly intend to live with someone I love.” The problem, Mrs Lawton gently points out, is that very few women with her tastes feel brave or strongly enough to do the same.
As a romp, Gentleman Jack works fine. Jones is a sufficiently swaggering presence to make her family’s and villagers’ blend of fascination, delight and awe as they behold her believable (ditto her dutiful sister’s swelling resentment of a sibling to whom people’s attention is drawn as iron filings are to a magnet). The subplots, including the pregnancy of Lister’s new lady’s maid Eugenie, aren’t very well integrated but this may improve in later episodes.
But while it is fun, and has moments of heart, it also has moments that seem to flirt with period drama parody. This is especially the case with the arrival of Rosie Cavaliero, indelibly associated with Hunderby, as one of the servants and with lines like: “It’s all very well being different in York or Paris, but this is Halifax!”
By the end of the first episode, at least, Gentleman Jack feels just slightly like a missed opportunity. There is so much meat to a story about a woman determined to live unbound by convention (in every aspect of her life, though her sexuality was central to it) and constantly defy expectations (and confront more opprobrium, surely, than the few silly gossips on show here); especially for Wainwright, whose specialist subject is female strength – what it costs to gather it, wield it and sustain it in their frequently unequal battles in life.
She has assembled a cast with the chops to handle anything thrown at them (it includes Gemma Jones as Lister’s quietly accommodating mother figure, Gemma Whelan as sister Marian and Stephanie Cole as the aunt of an forthcoming love interest, as well as West and Suranne Jones herself) and it would be immensely satisfying to see them gorge themselves on the rich feast she could offer. Maybe the main course is yet to come.

Brooks Koepka basks in 'phenomenal run' after retaining US PGA title
American Idol Names a 2019 Winner
If Tehran wants to fight, that'll be the official end of Iran, Trump warns
Westworld season 3 trailer: HBO show takes whole different direction
Brexit party's funding must be investigated, says Gordon Brown
SpaceX will launch its first 60 satellites to deliver internet from space
Harry and Meghan share behind-the-scenes pictures of wedding
Kylie Jenner Finally Got Jordyn Woods to Come Pick Up Her Stuff
Omar Khayyam, Mathematics and Astronomy Ingenuous, Honoured by Google Doodle on His 971st Birth Anniversary
Country star Travis Tritt's tour bus sideswiped in crash that killed 2
Michigan's Justin Amash becomes first Republican to back Trump impeachment
Deontay Wilder targets Anthony Joshua after knockout win over Dominic Breazeale
Vincent Kompany to leave Man City and become Anderlecht player-manager
‘SNL’ newbie Ego Nwodim gushes over friendship with Leslie Jones
Justin Bieber & Ed Sheeran Drop 'I Don't Care' Video
Game Of Thrones Finale: Clue Could Mean Dany Dies In Episode 6, Season 8
US lifts steel and aluminum tariffs on Canada and Mexico
‘Treason!’ Trump calls for ‘long jail sentences’ for investigators after Mike Flynn bombshell
Houses passes Equality Act to increase protections for sexual orientation and gender identity
Grumpy Cat Has Died At The Age Of 7
Why 'Black Mirror' needs Miley Cyrus
Britney Spears may never perform again, manager says
Boris Johnson confirms bid for Tory leadership
Bob Hawke, former Australian prime minister, dead at 89
Lady Gaga And Reese Witherspoon Join Celebrities Condemning Alabama Abortion Law
Bill de Blasio announces 2020 presidential bid
NASA Needs $1.6 Billion More to Send a Human to the Moon
‘Game of Thrones’ set photographers seemingly forgot Jaime Lannister only has one hand
Virgin Mobile says it will compensate customers for service disruption
Inside Jennifer Lawrence and Cooke Maroney's Low-Key Engagement Party
Tim Conway, star of the 'Carol Burnett Show,' dies at 85
Pelicans primed for Zion Williamson after winning No 1 pick in NBA draft
Alabama passes bill banning abortion
NASA’s initiative to put a woman on the Moon is named Artemis, after Apollo’s twin sister
Doris Day dead at 97
Bitcoin tops US$8,000 as resurgence of cryptocurrencies goes on
Vodafone slashes share payout after posting 6.6bn loss
Robert De Niro swaps mean streets of New York for the back streets of Bolton for new Warburtons TV ad
WhatsApp flaw let hackers install spyware on cellphones
HBO’s Chernobyl miniseries comes with a message about ignoring facts
Rapper Kodak Black is arrested on firearm charges at Rolling Loud Festival
Facebook says it needs more regulation, not a breakup
Trump tells China to 'act now' on trade or face a 'far worse' deal in his second term
Tina Fey and Amy Poehler Join Emma Thompson in ‘SNL’ Mother’s Day Monologue (Watch)
Jonas Brothers Happily Return to 'SNL' With 'Sucker,' 'Cool' and Surprise Throwback 'Burnin' Up'
Jessica Andrade stuns Rose Namajunas, Anderson Silva falls
Peggy Lipton: Twin Peaks and The Mod Squad star dies aged 72
Tony Blair Chips In With Advice On European Elections and It Won't Please Jeremy Corbyn
Elon Musk faces trial over 'pedo' tweet
‘Power Rangers’ actor Pua Magasiva found dead at 38
MLB trade rumors: Giants to deal Madison Bumgarner? Yankees in the mix?
Alyssa Milano calls for 'sex strike' to protest wave of anti-abortion bills
‘HE’S PERFECT!’: Kim Kardashian welcomes baby number four
Paul Lo Duca: '57 Chevy helped Billy Wagner get umpire Joe West to expand strike zone
Ben Shapiro ends BBC interview, scolds host: 'I'm popular and no one has ever heard of you'
James Charles: Tips and trips from beauty vlogger
Tyra Banks is back and on the cover of 'Sports Illustrated'
Harry and Meghan reveal royal baby's name is Archie
Tottenham superheroes achieved near miracle at Ajax, says Pochettino
Paul Pierce Farted On Michelle Beadle On TV
Kevin Durant exits Game 5 between Warriors and Rockets with calf strain
Ayesha Curry shows off new tattoo
Amy Schumer strikes Met Gala pose before heading to the hospital to give birth
Sandra Bland: Her phone video of arrest emerges
Kim Kardashian West helps free 17 inmates in 90 days
A’s potential Opening Day starter Mike Fiers already mentor to Jesus Luzardo
Falklands veteran 'forced out over sexuality' plans to sue MoD
Giant robotic arm catches SpaceX's Dragon cargo spacecraft
Microsoft is going to ship a full Linux kernel in Windows 10
Dow Jones Industrial Average Falls as Trump Tariff Threat Overtakes Earnings
Kendall and Kylie Jenner Wore Twinning Feathered Gowns to the Met Gala
Zendaya Transformed Into Cinderella On The Met Gala Red Carpet And I'm At A Loss For Words
Celebs try to out-camp each other at wild Met Gala
Max Homa's journey from $18,008 to $1.42 million
Met Gala 2019: Who is attending and how do you get an invite?
Sixers' Elton Brand nixed Ben Simmons-Magic Johnson meeting 'over a month ago'
‘Game of Thrones’ episode 4 recap: Cersei battles Dany for Iron Throne
Kylie Jenner and Travis Scott Make Their Love Even More Permanent
Tesla boosts capital raise to $2.7 billion, Musk buys more stock
Rachel Held Evans, Voice of the Wandering Evangelical, Dies at 37
'SNL': Adam Sandler sings about being fired with Chris Rock, pays tribute to Chris Farley
Canelo Álvarez outpoints Daniel Jacobs to unify middleweight title belts
Nigel Farage Pranked By Teen As He Films Message For His Mother
It's Star Wars Day and SpaceX Just Launched Its Own 'Falcon' Into Space
Is Meghan Markle the New 'People's Princess?'
Tesla Model 3 police car makes an appearance at law enforcement tech conference
Explosion at Illinois silicone plant leaves 4 injured and 3 unaccounted
'Sonic the Hedgehog' director promises redesign after backlash, but changes could be costly
Dead to Me review – come back Desperate Housewives, all is forgiven!
Trump stresses importance of Russia’s steps to denuclearize North Korea - White House
North Carolina lawyer Cheslie Kryst named Miss USA 2019
Texas Officer Charged With Homicide For Shooting Black Man During Traffic Stop
Vampire Weekend: Father of the Bride review, a scrapbook of brilliant ideas
Shawn Mendes Drops New Single ‘If I Can’t Have You’ With Video (Watch)
Local Elections 2019: Tories And Labour Punished Over Brexit As Lib Dems Win Big
Chewbacca actor Peter Mayhew dies aged 74
SpaceX's mission to the International Space Station delayed by electrical problems
Biden says Barr 'should' resign: 'He's lost the confidence of the American people'
Channing Tatum Posts Naked Shower Pic After Losing Jenga Game To Girlfriend Jessie J
Alex Trebek on his cancer: ‘My oncologist says I’m doing well even though I don’t always feel it’
Former Child Star Ricky Schroder Arrested on Suspicion of Domestic Abuse
Jenelle Evans’ Husband Just Broke His Silence on Shooting and Killing Their French Bulldog, Nugget
Maluma: Madonna is 'a huge master'
Attorney General William Barr Acts as Donald Trump’s Human Shield on Capitol Hill
Shaun Edwards will leave post as Wales’ defence coach after World Cup
Bombardier to sell Belfast operations
Game Of Thrones' Sophie Turner Marries Joe Jonas In Las Vegas After Billboard Music Awards
Watch Jennifer Lopez' twins Emme and Max put her in the hot seat during cute video
Maisie Williams responds to THAT huge 'Game of Thrones' moment with the perfect Instagram video
Larry King is recovering in the hospital after undergoing a heart procedure
Trump sues Deutsche Bank and Capital One to block release of financial records
Glasgow airport: Flights resume after security alert on inbound plane
Football rumours: Rio Ferdinand to be Manchester United sporting director?
Let’s seize the moment and create a Green New Deal for the UK
This Elon Musk Comment Should Terrify Tesla Investors
Police: 8 shot, 1 fatally, in latest Baltimore shooting
Model Tales Soares Dies After Collapsing On Catwalk At Sao Paulo Fashion Week
Glastonbury resale: What time are tickets on sale and how do I get them?
Elliott wins NASCAR race at Talladega
Tony Slattery: ‘I had a very happy time until I went slightly barmy’
'Game of Thrones' Gaze Turns South in Episode 4 Trailer
The universe is younger and expanding faster than we thought, a new study found and we may need new physics as a result
SpaceX and NASA close ranks after the mystery crew capsule incident as details remain scant
San Diego police identify synagogue shooting suspect – video
Bruins victory over Leafs ensures an American team will hoist the Stanley Cup
Mo Farah Finishes Fifth In London Marathon After Controversial Week
NASA's InSight Mission Detects Its First Marsquake
Putin: Maria Butina's sentence is 'lawlessness'
Donald Trump to withdraw US from Arms Trade Treaty
'Avengers: Endgame' Star Chris Evans for Men's Journal Magazine
Fake heiress Anna Sorokin found guilty after fooling banks and New York's elite
World Championship 2019: Mark Selby loses to Gary Wilson
Sam Donaldson Explains How Sarah Huckabee Sanders' Lying Is Unprecedented
Idris Elba marries Sabrina Dhowre in Morocco
‘Santa Clarita Diet’ Canceled After Three Seasons at Netflix
Facebook investigated by New York AG over email harvesting
Joe Biden Announces 2020 US Presidential Bid
Daniel Craig's final outing as James Bond will include Rami Malek as the bad guy
Parents of murdered AJ Freund, 5, ‘made him stand under freezing shower to punish him’
Stefanie Sherk, Actress and Wife to Demian Bichir, Dies at 43
NFL Draft 2019: Giants pick Daniel Jones, Dwayne Haskins LAUGHS and fans are shocked
Plan for Banksy art gallery in Port Talbot may be under threat
Lord of the Rings star in fiery CLASH with Caroline Lucas on BBC QT 'Our last GREAT hope'
Taylor Swift releases her new song 'ME!'
Lyra McKee funeral: politicians urged to seize the moment
The Greta Thunberg effect: her activism in London in two minutes - video
Jennifer Garner thinks her face on cover of People's Beautiful Issue is 'so ridiculous'
Rapper Bun B Shoots Armed Robber in His Houston Home
SpaceX Crew Dragon Accident Another Bump in the Road for Commercial Crew
Meghan Markle and Prince Harry wrote a sweet birthday message for Prince Louis, but some people think it broke royal protocol
Elon Musk told this Reddit user they 'should interview at Tesla', here's why
‘His career was incredible’. Billy McNeill was a winner as player and manager
Natalie Portman makes a surprise appearance at the Avengers: Endgame premiere
Seahawks, Chiefs blow up NFL draft with Frank Clark trade
Jared Kushner dubs Trump-Russia investigation 'a big distraction'
Vanessa Hudgens reveals why she is ‘grateful’ for her romance with Zac Efron
Tesla to Investigate Car That Appeared to Burst Into Flames in Shanghai
Stephen Graham says This Is England role nearly ended his acting career
Maisie Williams could show 'as much or as little' as she wanted in shocking 'Game of Thrones' sex scene
Sri Lanka Attacks: Asos Billionaire Loses Three Children In Easter Sunday Blasts
These 10 Democrats Want Trump Impeached
Rep. Seth Moulton Launches 2020 Presidential Bid
Why observe Earth Day on April 22?
Beyoncé lands $60M deal with Netflix
Tesla’s Elon Musk could earn up to $2.2 billion from stock options
Paris police use tear gas against 'yellow vest' protesters
Adele announces separation from husband Simon Konecki
Elizabeth Warren says House should start impeachment proceedings for Trump
Michelle Williams and her husband, musician Phil Elverum, have split
These Wisps Around Black Holes Could Reveal How the Cosmic Beasts Eat
'Boyz n the Hood' director John Singleton suffers stroke: report
Newcastle boss Rafa Benitez wants ONE thing to STAY - Michael Owen reveals what he's heard
Johnny Depp Allegedly Tried to Get Amber Heard Fired From Aquaman
Kourtney Kardashian's ex Younes Bendjima attends her 40th birthday party
Emma Thompson Joins Extinction Rebellion In Climate Change Protest
Lil Dicky drops the music video of his environmental anthem, 'Earth'
Dissecting Taylor Swift’s April 26 clues
The cause of the Notre Dame Cathedral fire remains unknown. Everything else is a rumor
Kathie Lee Gifford Reacts to Hoda Kotb’s Surprise Baby News
Westbrook vows to play better after loss
Mark Carney tells global banks they cannot ignore climate change dangers
Beyoncé's 'Homecoming' is as black as it can be
SpaceX loses Falcon Heavy's center booster to the sea
Why Netflix Has A 'Game Of Thrones' Problem
Trump Campaign Makes Minnesota An Early 2020 Target
Actor Lori Loughlin, other parents plead not guilty in U.S. college admissions case
Georgia Engel, who played Georgette on The Mary Tyler Moore Show, has died
Would you visit a 'fake' Notre Dame? You're already doing it at other sites
Russell Wilson and the Seahawks win with record extension
Coachella day three review: Ariana Grande on fire and Pusha T on an iceberg
Man, Woman, and Robot in Ian McEwan’s New Novel
Thousands join Extinction Rebellion protests across London
Hillsborough: Jury fails to reach verdict in David Duckenfield trial
Sarah Hyland Shows Off Her Toned Abs In Green Sports Bra While Hitting The Gym
Facebook investors launch desperate bid to oust Mark Zuckerberg
Uber IPO: Former CEO Travis Kalanick to earn billions
Chinese GP: Bottas Takes Pole For His 1000th F1 Race, Hamilton Finishes 2nd in Qualifying
BTS performed on SNL and fans went crazy
Interview with American Top Team’s Dustin Poirier who headlines UFC 236 for a title
The Perfect Date review: Netflix’s latest Noah Centineo movie is fine
Close