Close
Date TimeDecember 04, 2018
VoiceA senior adviser to the EU court of justice has said the UK can revoke article 50. The path to remain is hard – but now clearer
Britain can legally cancel Brexit. That’s EU advice – but will parliament agree?
We can cancel Brexit. That’s what the advocate general to the court of justice of the EU, Europe’s highest court, advised this morning.
The advocate general, Manuel Campos Sánchez-Bordona, said that the UK can cancel its article 50 notice unilaterally. This means that if our own parliament decides that our interests are best served by remaining, the EU cannot stand in our way.
His decision is not certain to be followed by the full court – which has yet to announce when it will give its judgment – but courts follow their advocate general in the overwhelming majority of cases. And if it does here, we are much more likely to stay in the EU.
Article 50 is silent about whether a member state that had decided to leave can change its mind. And the issue had been shrouded in doubt since Gina Miller’s barrister told the supreme court it could not be done. But this morning the advocate general disagreed.
We also learned that we should be able to continue to benefit from the perks we presently enjoy – such as the £100m a week rebate and the control over our borders that comes from us opting out of the Schengen agreement on free movement. Politicians know that giving these up would make it much harder to justify staying in the EU – and that’s why only last week Michael Gove stated categorically that “we would be forced to accept far tougher terms than we have now. Keeping the rebate? Forget about it.” But we know now – as he should have known then – that this is highly unlikely to be true.
The opinion also clears the legislative path to remaining. One option is for MPs to just cancel the article 50 notice without a further referendum. That is a course the advocate general has recognised is open to parliament. And the 2016 referendum parliament enacted was only advisory, after all.
Faced with that choice today MPs would undoubtedly reject it. But the European Research Group’s failure to gather the 48 letters to start a Conservative leadership context proves just how little support there is in parliament for a no-deal Brexit. If MPs find themselves approaching the 29 March 2019 deadline without a deal, the appeal of a simple backstop to avoid the no-deal precipice may become overwhelming. And they may reflect on this paradox: if the vote in June 2016 was legitimate, how can we contemplate another referendum? And if it was illegitimate, why do we need another one?
The difficulty with the alternative route – a second referendum – is one of timing. Even after this morning’s opinion we still need the permission of the other EU member states to extend time to hold a second referendum. But, if the political will exists, a referendum could be held in short order. The referendum in Greece on whether to accept the bailout conditions took place only a week after its parliament voted for one. And the opinion gives the EU every reason to extend the time. A choice to remain made by the people may well be considered a stronger mandate than a decision to remain made by MPs alone.
It would be an act of great hubris to pretend any of this was simple, or settled, or done. There are formidable obstacles in the way of MPs seeking to force through a decision against the wishes of the government. We learn that, if nothing else, from the attempts to force the government to disclose its legal advice on the Irish backstop. But there is no denying the path to remain just got easier.
• Jolyon Maugham QC is a barrister and director of the Good Law Project

Related Stories
Brexiteer MPs say delay would be political calamityBrexiteer MPs say delay would be political calamity
Storm Gareth: warnings issued about power cuts and travel difficultiesStorm Gareth: warnings issued about power cuts and travel difficulties
Worried about Brexit? What, with these geniuses in charge? | Marina HydeWorried about Brexit? What, with these geniuses in charge? | Marina Hyde
UK parliament speaker does not select any amendments for Brexit voteUK parliament speaker does not select any amendments for Brexit vote
Government could ignore indicative Brexit votes, says Liam FoxGovernment could ignore indicative Brexit votes, says Liam Fox
Brexit stitch up: Revoke Article 50 petition hits 4 million – could pass 5 million TONIGHTBrexit stitch up: Revoke Article 50 petition hits 4 million – could pass 5 million TONIGHT
Brexit: Legal risk of backstop remains unchanged says Geoffrey CoxBrexit: Legal risk of backstop remains 'unchanged' says Geoffrey Cox
May Day: UK Parliament rejects prime minister’s Brexit dealMay Day: UK Parliament rejects prime minister’s Brexit deal
Trick or treat? EU, UK agree to delay Brexit until HalloweenTrick or treat? EU, UK agree to delay Brexit until Halloween
Brexit: Corbyn asks for PMs withdrawal agreement updateBrexit: Corbyn asks for PM's withdrawal agreement update
News Trends
Parents of murdered AJ Freund, 5, ‘made him stand under freezing shower to punish him’Parents of murdered AJ Freund, 5, ‘made him stand under freezing shower to punish him’
Stefanie Sherk, Actress and Wife to Demian Bichir, Dies at 43Stefanie Sherk, Actress and Wife to Demian Bichir, Dies at 43
NFL Draft 2019: Giants pick Daniel Jones, Dwayne Haskins LAUGHS and fans are shockedNFL Draft 2019: Giants pick Daniel Jones, Dwayne Haskins LAUGHS and fans are shocked
Plan for Banksy art gallery in Port Talbot may be under threatPlan for Banksy art gallery in Port Talbot may be under threat
Lord of the Rings star in fiery CLASH with Caroline Lucas on BBC QT Our last GREAT hopeLord of the Rings star in fiery CLASH with Caroline Lucas on BBC QT 'Our last GREAT hope'
Taylor Swift releases her new song ME!Taylor Swift releases her new song 'ME!'
Lyra McKee funeral: politicians urged to seize the momentLyra McKee funeral: politicians urged to seize the moment
The Greta Thunberg effect: her activism in London in two minutes - videoThe Greta Thunberg effect: her activism in London in two minutes - video
Jennifer Garner thinks her face on cover of Peoples Beautiful Issue is so ridiculousJennifer Garner thinks her face on cover of People's Beautiful Issue is 'so ridiculous'
Rapper Bun B Shoots Armed Robber in His Houston HomeRapper Bun B Shoots Armed Robber in His Houston Home
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
Brexiteer MPs say delay would be political calamityBrexiteer MPs say delay would be political calamity
Storm Gareth: warnings issued about power cuts and travel difficultiesStorm Gareth: warnings issued about power cuts and travel difficulties
Worried about Brexit? What, with these geniuses in charge? | Marina HydeWorried about Brexit? What, with these geniuses in charge? | Marina Hyde
UK parliament speaker does not select any amendments for Brexit voteUK parliament speaker does not select any amendments for Brexit vote
Government could ignore indicative Brexit votes, says Liam FoxGovernment could ignore indicative Brexit votes, says Liam Fox
Brexit stitch up: Revoke Article 50 petition hits 4 million – could pass 5 million TONIGHTBrexit stitch up: Revoke Article 50 petition hits 4 million – could pass 5 million TONIGHT
Brexit: Legal risk of backstop remains unchanged says Geoffrey CoxBrexit: Legal risk of backstop remains 'unchanged' says Geoffrey Cox
May Day: UK Parliament rejects prime minister’s Brexit dealMay Day: UK Parliament rejects prime minister’s Brexit deal
Trick or treat? EU, UK agree to delay Brexit until HalloweenTrick or treat? EU, UK agree to delay Brexit until Halloween
Brexit: Corbyn asks for PMs withdrawal agreement updateBrexit: Corbyn asks for PM's withdrawal agreement update
News Trends
Parents of murdered AJ Freund, 5, ‘made him stand under freezing shower to punish him’Parents of murdered AJ Freund, 5, ‘made him stand under freezing shower to punish him’
Stefanie Sherk, Actress and Wife to Demian Bichir, Dies at 43Stefanie Sherk, Actress and Wife to Demian Bichir, Dies at 43
NFL Draft 2019: Giants pick Daniel Jones, Dwayne Haskins LAUGHS and fans are shockedNFL Draft 2019: Giants pick Daniel Jones, Dwayne Haskins LAUGHS and fans are shocked
Plan for Banksy art gallery in Port Talbot may be under threatPlan for Banksy art gallery in Port Talbot may be under threat
Lord of the Rings star in fiery CLASH with Caroline Lucas on BBC QT Our last GREAT hopeLord of the Rings star in fiery CLASH with Caroline Lucas on BBC QT 'Our last GREAT hope'
Taylor Swift releases her new song ME!Taylor Swift releases her new song 'ME!'
Lyra McKee funeral: politicians urged to seize the momentLyra McKee funeral: politicians urged to seize the moment
The Greta Thunberg effect: her activism in London in two minutes - videoThe Greta Thunberg effect: her activism in London in two minutes - video
Jennifer Garner thinks her face on cover of Peoples Beautiful Issue is so ridiculousJennifer Garner thinks her face on cover of People's Beautiful Issue is 'so ridiculous'
Rapper Bun B Shoots Armed Robber in His Houston HomeRapper Bun B Shoots Armed Robber in His Houston Home
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Mafia 'godfather' among 45 alleged mobsters held in Sicily
Italy's M5S sacks entire board of health experts, sparking political interference concerns
Football star Ada Hegerberg asked to twerk after inaugural women's Ballon d'Or win
Victoria Beckham pictures: Designer joins husband David Beckham at Haig Club House Party
MACRON BUCKLES: Weak French President CAVES IN as riots and rebels force red-faced u-turn
UK can stop article 50 without EU approval, top ECJ adviser says
NASA probe reaches Bennu – asteroid that could one day hit Earth
Israel begins operation to expose Hezbollah 'attack tunnels' on Lebanon border
Kate Middleton And Meghan Markle 'Feud' Questioned By Everyday Sisters-In-Law
Strictly Come Dancing's Stacey Dooley Trades Kevin Clifton For Aljaž Škorjanec As She Joins Live Tour
Samsung Nigeria tweets update using Apple iPhone
Protest-hit France 'to halt fuel tax rise'
Pete Davidson describes online 'bullying' after Ariana Grande split
YouTube top earners: The seven-year-old making $22m
George HW Bush funeral: Trump pays respects at US Capitol
Michelle Obama on ‘leaning in’: ‘Sometimes that shit doesn’t work’
Missing Emirati princess 'planned escape for seven years'
Manchester City may face Champions League ban after Uefa FFP investigation
Drake, Post Malone and XXXTentacion are most-streamed artists of 2018 on Spotify
Trump's praise for Roger Stone could amount to witness tampering – experts
Senior minister could be suspended over Brexit legal advice
CIA chief Haspel to brief US Senate leaders on Khashoggi's death
First women’s Ballon d’Or marred as winner Ada Hegerberg is asked to twerk
Ariana Grande Covered Up Her Pete Davidson Tattoo with a Mac Miller Tribute
NASA, Roscosmos Successfully Launch Soyuz After Aborted Mission
John Barrowman Returns To ‘I’m A Celebrity’ After Spending Night In Hospital Following Nasty Fall
A cult figure, Paul Sherwen brought cycling to the world
Halsey's message for Victoria's Secret Fashion Show
Pittsburgh synagogue holds its first Hanukkah ceremony since the Tree of Life massacre
Chicago Bulls fire coach Fred Hoiberg; Boylen takes over
Samantha Eastwood murder: man jailed for minimum of 16 years
Does The International Day of Disabled Persons Really Change Anything?
Ariana Grande Reveals What It Was Like Working With Kris Jenner on "Thank U, Next"
Live coverage: SpaceX delays commercial rideshare launch to Monday
Paris riots: Yellow vests 'infiltrated by violent elements'
Donald Trump, Xi Jinping Agree To Trade Truce At G-20 Summit
Ken Berry, TV Actor in ‘F-Troop,’ ‘Mayberry R.F.D,’ Dies at 85
Lucas Torreira caps Arsenal’s comeback in 4-2 derby win over 10-man Spurs
G20: Step Up to Boost Inclusive Growth
Royal family DENIES Kate Middleton slapped down Meghan Markle for berating her staff
Ariana Grande apologised to Pete Davidson for "dipping" in her 'thank u, next' video
George HW Bush, 41st US president, dies aged 94
Kate Osamor Resigns From Shadow Cabinet After 'Throwing Bucket Of Water At Reporter'
Ariana Grande shares letter she wrote to fans after Manchester bombing
Canada, U.S., Mexico sign revised NAFTA deal Trump says ‘changes the trade landscape forever’
Marriott reveals data breach of 500 million Starwood guests
Jay-Z seemingly disses Kanye West and his MAGA hat on new Meek Mill song
Celebrities jump to David Beckham’s defence after criticism for on-the-lips kiss
Deutsche Bank offices raided in connection with Panama Papers
Michael Cohen pleads guilty to making false statements to Congress
The greatest showman? Hugh Jackman announces world tour
Theresa May accepts BBC Brexit debate but Jeremy Corbyn prefers ITV
Jimmy Fallon Transforms Into Trump As An Elvis Impersonator
Ivanka Trump defends use of private email, brushes aside Mueller probe
Quentin Letts to leave Daily Mail for Murdoch-owned papers
Harry Leslie Smith, WWII veteran and activist, dies at 95
Google Fi for iPhones: Fewer Features, Lower Prices
Margaret Atwood announces The Handmaid's Tale sequel, The Testaments
Why Meghan Markle and Prince Harry Are Spending Their Engagement Anniversary Apart
Ariana Grande's 'Thank U, Next' Trailer Is All 'Mean Girls' And Pete Davidson Jokes
Macron talks about a unified Europe but presides over a divided France
Mel B snaps during live TV interview
Amanda Bynes speaks candidly about her drug-fuelled spiral
Baroness Trumpington, Bletchley Park codebreaker and longtime politician, dies at 96
Red Dead Redemption 2 multiplayer release time: When does RDR2 online beta start?
NASA InSight Lander Arrives on Martian Surface to Learn What Lies Beneath
US forces: 3 American service members killed in Afghanistan
Manafort held secret talks with Assange in Ecuadorian embassy, sources say
Sol Campbell is the new Macclesfield Town manager
NASA's InSight Mars Lander Reaches Mars Today! Here's What to Expect
Melania Trump Has Unveiled the 2018 White House Christmas Decorations
Russia accuses Ukraine of naval 'provocation' in Kerch strait
Margaret Thatcher eligible to be 'scientist' on new £50 note
Oscar-winner, director of ‘Last Tango in Paris,’ Bernardo Bertolucci dies at 77
Lena Dunham breaks up with Brooklyn for the West Village
Mack Brown in discussions with North Carolina about returning as football coach
BREXIT BLACKMAIL: Macron will FORCE UK into backstop unless May grants EU fishing access
Diddy Delivers Emotional Eulogy at Kim Porter's Funeral
Ricky Jay, Magician and 'Boogie Nights' Actor, Dies at 72
NFL linebacker Reuben Foster arrested on domestic violence charge
Russia space agency chief: We'll verify US moon landings
Jennifer Garner is too cute as she copies Snoop Dogg's dance on Hollywood Walk of Fame
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle Will Move Out of Kensington Palace to a New Home in Windsor
French police fire tear gas at protesters on Champs Elysees
Madrid's perfect run with Solari ends with 3-0 loss to Eibar
Nicolas Roeg, director of Don't Look Now and Walkabout, dies aged 90
Madonna posts rare photo of her kids in Malawi on Thanksgiving
Justin Bieber Sings 'Happy Birthday' to Wife Hailey Baldwin — and Shoves Her Face into Sheet Cake
'The Lion King' Trailer Is Frame-By-Frame Identical To The Animated Version
Amazon workers strike in Germany, Spain on Black Friday
NASA's InSight Lander Will Look Inside Mars Like Never Before. Here's Why
Jimmy Fallon Singing a Christina Aguilera Song With a Robot is Exactly as Creepy as It Sounds
American killed by isolated tribe on North Sentinel Island in Andamans
Rita Ora announces UK arena tour and she's coming to Birmingham - how to get tickets
Chelsea great Drogba retires from football
Donald Trump attempts political satire in Thanksgiving turkey pardon – video
Hillary Clinton: Europe must curb immigration to stop rightwing populists
Katy Perry edges out Taylor Swift, Beyonce to become highest-paid woman in music
Ariana Grande ditches engagement ring from Pete Davidson for friendship ring
Trump Thanks Saudi Arabia For Low Gas Prices After Jamal Khashoggi's Killing
Harry Redknapp sets out tactics in crab-stroking I’m A Celebrity debut
Wreck-It Ralph finally gives the internet what it deserves in Ralph Breaks the Internet
Martin O’Neill and Roy Keane leave Republic of Ireland roles
Matthew Hedges: British academic accused of spying jailed for life in UAE
Devin Lima Dead: LFO Singer Dies Aged 41, After Adrenal Cancer Battle
1 killed in fiery Brooklyn Bridge crash
Cardi B Fulfills "Childhood Dreams" After Purchasing Her Mom a New House
Harry and Meghan May Not Become William and Kate's Neighbors After All
Ivanka Trump Reportedly Used Personal Email Account For Official White House Business
Chris Watts Gets Life in Prison for Killing Daughters and Pregnant Wife
'Dancing With the Stars' crowns shocking winner
Police officer, 2 staffers killed in shooting at Mercy Hospital in Chicago
Kabul wedding hall blast kills 40, Afghan officials say
Facebook, Instagram go down, and some just can't deal
Taylor Swift Signs New Deal With Universal Music Group
Joe Theismann feels Alex Smith’s pain
Paul Gascoigne denies sexual assaulting woman on train
Nissan Renault chief Carlos Ghosn faces arrest in Japan
Stephen Colbert reveals why he returned to Catholicism
Hailey Baldwin Changes Last Name on Instagram as Justin Bieber Praises His "Wife"
Elon Musk says a 'radical change' is coming to SpaceX's monster Mars rocket design
Browns’ stunning option for next head coach: Condoleezza Rice
Meghan Markle & Prince Harry Enjoy Double Date with Prince William & Kate Middleton at Royal Dinner
Hailey Baldwin and Justin Bieber appear to confirm marriage
Ariana Grande debuts a new look and people have a lot of opinions about it
WATCH: HBO’s Bill Maher destroys Trump for bungling his response to every national disaster that happens
Roger Federer OUT of ATP Finals as Alexander Zverev delivers shock upset
Jimmy Kimmel gets Michelle Obama to say things she couldn't say as First Lady
Ariana Grande’s “thank u, next” Is the Breakup Song for the Social-Media Age
Is Julian Assange facing criminal charges in the US?
Butch Cassidy and Princess Bride scriptwriter William Goldman dies aged 87
Watch SpaceX launch and land a used Falcon 9 rocket
Kim Kardashian West: Kanye drawn more to Donald Trump's personality than his politics
Elton John's John Lewis Christmas ad: it could have been so different
After arrest, Michael Avenatti denies LA domestic violence
Carrie Underwood reveals the gender of her baby at CMAs
Jacob Rees-Mogg Demands Theresa May Resign - As Tory MPs Savage Brexit Deal
Bradley Cooper's Original 'A Star Is Born' Script Had an Ending Even More Faithful to the 1937 Original
‘Bill Clinton should want to apologize’: Monica Lewinsky opens up about scandal in new documentary
Who is Mira Ricardel? First Lady Melania Trump wants the national security official fired
Novak Djokovic sweeps aside Alexander Zverev at ATP Finals
Game of Thrones Season 8 Finally Has a Premiere Date
I’m A Celeb’s Emily Atack ‘keen to set record straight’ about fling with disgraced Strictly star Seann Walsh
Detective Pikachu: 'Gross' furry Pokemon divides fans
Mysterious interstellar object is not an alien probe, says astronomer who discovered it
Stan Lee's Greatness Will Never Be Forgotten
Amazon’s HQ2 will bring 25,000 jobs each to New York City and Northern Virginia
Sir Alex Ferguson tried three things to sign Joe Cole for Manchester United
Kim Kardashian Says 'Our Hearts Are Broken' as She Accepts People's Choice Award with Family
Trump Renews Attacks on NATO and Trade Imbalances
Michael Buble UK tour: How to get tickets for singer's Don't Believe the Rumours shows
'I felt like I failed': Michelle Obama opens up on miscarriage, IVF
National Action Trial: Two Found Guilty Of Being In Banned Neo-Nazi Group
Jeremy Corbyn Must Uphold Labour Brexit Policy On Second Referendum, Says Gordon Brown
The 22-Inch TRUMPY BEAR You've Never Wanted Is On Sale With 'Added Bonus'
Kate Upton, Justin Verlander share first picture of new baby
Watch Pete Davidson apologize to Dan Crenshaw face to face on 'SNL'
Brazilian Grand Prix: Sebastian Vettel smashes Interlagos lap record
Meghan Markle conceals baby bump as she attends her first Remembrance Day ceremony
Emmanuel Macron warns of dangers of nationalism in Armistice Day speech 
World leaders gather in Paris for Armistice Day – video
Spice Girls tickets cause MAYHEM as Ticketmaster goes into meltdown: 'My heart's breaking'
April Ryan Got Protection After Receiving Ominous Threats Following Trump Attacks
Outlaw King review – bold, watchable portrait of Robert the Bruce
Lady Gaga Opens Up About Her 'Mental Health Crisis'
Colbert Slams Huckabee Sanders for Circulating Doctored Video
Adriana Lima walks Victoria’s Secret runway for last time
'Camp Fire' inferno: North California town of Paradise 'wiped out' as thousands flee
Germany: Merkel warns of modern racism on Kristallnacht 80th
The Latest: Wildfire triggers evacuation order for Malibu
Michelle Obama reveals miscarriage and IVF treatment in new book
Iceland's Christmas TV advert banned for being too political
Sarah Hyland Knew About the Modern Family Pregnancy Reveal for Months
Did Ariana Grande Just Share The Tracklist For Her Next Album?
Tesla names Robyn Denholm new chairman, overseeing Elon Musk
Ruth Bader Ginsburg breaks ribs in fall
Sheriff's Sgt. Ron Helus was set to retire soon. He was killed in the Thousand Oaks attack
Thousand Oaks shooting: gunman kills 12 at California western bar
Lasers could help us attract aliens, MIT study suggests
Oh, no! Ariana Grande trips while performing new song about famous exes on 'Ellen'
Dan Crenshaw addresses Pete Davidson's panned 'SNL' joke during victory speech
'I'm as hopeful as I've ever been': Beto O'Rourke fails to beat Ted Cruz
Trump delivers for McConnell in Senate races
Pro-Trump pimp Dennis Hof wins Nevada election weeks after he died
See Kendall Jenner's Victoria's Secret Fashion Show Evolution
Taylor Swift Makes Impassioned Personal Video Message Urging Fans to Vote
Emmanuel Macron: Six held in 'attack' plot against French president
Idris Elba is named People's Sexiest Man Alive for 2018
8 big questions for Election Day
SpaceX's 'Starman' and Its Tesla Roadster Are Now Beyond Mars
Rihanna doesn't want Trump playing her music at his 'tragic rallies,' but she may not have a choice
Floyd Mayweather to fight Japanese kickboxing sensation on New Year's Eve
'The Walking Dead' Season 9, Episode 5 recap: What happened to Rick Grimes?
Election Day 2018: A nation on edge heads to the polls
FA launch James McClean investigation after he brands fans 'uneducated cavemen'
Trump Jr. calls Alec Baldwin ‘garbage’ in swipe over arrest
Ariana Grande Sings About Pete Davidson and Mac Miller in New Song "Thank u, next"
Pete Davidson wishes Ariana Grande the best on SNL while she releases song thanking him
Melania Trump Spent Almost $100000 at a Hotel She Never Slept In
Former civil service chief Sir Jeremy Heywood dies aged 56
Close