Close
Date TimeNovember 12, 2018
VoiceOumuamua, the first interstellar object ever spotted in our solar system, has been in the spotlight recently after a study from the Harvard Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics suggested it could be "a lightsail of artificial origin" sent from another civilization.
But that idea, while exciting to many, is preposterous and just "wild speculation," according to the physicist and astronomer who discovered it.
Mysterious interstellar object is not an alien probe, says astronomer who discovered it
Speaking with CBC, Canadian physicist and astronomer Robert Weryk said the theory put forth by postdoctoral researcher Shmuel Bialy and professor Abraham Loeb, the director at the CfA's Institute for Theory and Computation, is wild speculation.
"There's a maximum speed that you can be traveling to be bound gravitationally by the sun," Weryk told the Canadian outlet. "When we first saw this object, it was traveling faster than that, so we know for a fact that it's from outside our solar system. We decided that it was a comet that had a bit of outgassing that wasn't visible from the ground, which is why it didn't appear to be a comet."
He continued: "(The Harvard researchers) decided to focus on another aspect of that, that it's an alien spacecraft and that it has a solar sail type material that's causing the non-gravitational trajectory. But we actually believe that's not true based on the data we obtained."
In an email to Fox News, Loeb said his and Bialy's paper "attempts to explain the excess force" that acted on Oumuamua when observed and Weryk's reaction "shows prejudice."
"Our paper follows the standard scientific methodology: an anomaly is observed in data, the standard explanation fails to explain it and so an alternative interpretation is proposed," Loeb wrote in the email. "I encourage anyone with a better explanation to write a paper about it and publish it. Any wrong interpretation can be ruled out when more data will be released on `Oumuamua or other members of its population in the future. A reaction of the type you quoted shows prejudice."
Weryk made the discovery of Oumuamua, which is the Hawaiian name for "pathfinder" or "scout," in October 2017 with the PanSTARRS1 telescope.
In their paper, Bialy and Loeb theorized it could be a "lightsail, floating in interstellar space as a debris from an advanced technological equipment."
The paper continued: "Lightsails with similar dimensions have been designed and constructed by our own civilization, including the IKAROS project and the Starshot Initiative. The lightsail technology might be abundantly used for transportation of cargos between planets or between stars."
The researchers even theorized that Oumuamua "may be a fully operational probe sent intentionally to Earth vicinity by an alien civilization," though that scenario was called "exotic."
Since its discovery, researchers have debated whether it is a comet or an asteroid, though it was eventually determined to be a comet. NASA ruled that it is a "metallic or rocky object" approximately 400 meters (1,312 feet) in length and 40 meters (131 feet) wide.
Oumuamua is traveling away from the Sun at a rate of approximately 70,000 mph, towards the outer part of the solar system. In approximately four years, it will whiz past Neptune's orbit, on its way to interstellar space.
So what does Weryk believe it is?
"I think it's a remnant from another solar system. It's just something that happened to run into us, and we were very lucky to have been operating the telescope that night and looking in that direction," Weryk told CBC.
He added: "It's been theoretically predicted for decades but we've never seen one. Until we see another one, there are a lot of questions that we just can't answer."

Related Stories
NASA’s initiative to put a woman on the Moon is named Artemis, after Apollo’s twin sisterNASA’s initiative to put a woman on the Moon is named Artemis, after Apollo’s twin sister
SpaceX will launch its first 60 satellites to deliver internet from spaceSpaceX will launch its first 60 satellites to deliver internet from space
NASA Needs $1.6 Billion More to Send a Human to the MoonNASA Needs $1.6 Billion More to Send a Human to the Moon
Jeff Bezos Builds a Moon ShipJeff Bezos Builds a Moon Ship
NASAs Mars Helicopter Testing Enters Final PhaseNASA's Mars Helicopter Testing Enters Final Phase
NASA captures stunning photo of the entire sky in X-rayNASA captures stunning photo of the entire sky in X-ray
Trump Tweets About Moon, Mars, the Internet Scratches Its HeadTrump Tweets About Moon, Mars, the Internet Scratches Its Head
Elon Musks SpaceX raises over $1 billion this year as internet satellite production ramps upElon Musk's SpaceX raises over $1 billion this year as internet satellite production ramps up
News Trends
Taylor Swift Just Revealed All The Celebrities Who Will Appear In Her Upcoming VideoTaylor Swift Just Revealed All The Celebrities Who Will Appear In Her Upcoming Video
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle Share Touching New Image of Baby ArchiePrince Harry and Meghan Markle Share Touching New Image of Baby Archie
Bella Thornes Ex Mod Sun Breaks Down the Passport SituationBella Thorne's Ex Mod Sun Breaks Down the Passport Situation
Usain Bolt Grinds On Hot IG Model Zahra EliseUsain Bolt Grinds On Hot IG Model Zahra Elise
Carli Lloyd scores double as USA sweep Chile aside to advance to last 16Carli Lloyd scores double as USA sweep Chile aside to advance to last 16
Anti-LGBT protests have reawakened painful memoriesAnti-LGBT protests have reawakened painful memories
Fathers Day Fast FactsFather's Day Fast Facts
Taylor Swift gives surprise Pride Month performance at Stonewall Inn, a historic LGBT site in New YorkTaylor Swift gives surprise Pride Month performance at Stonewall Inn, a historic LGBT site in New York
Trump says he was briefed on Navy sightings of UFOsTrump says he was briefed on Navy sightings of UFOs
Jennifer Aniston on silver fox co-starJennifer Aniston on 'silver fox' co-star
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
NASA’s initiative to put a woman on the Moon is named Artemis, after Apollo’s twin sisterNASA’s initiative to put a woman on the Moon is named Artemis, after Apollo’s twin sister
SpaceX will launch its first 60 satellites to deliver internet from spaceSpaceX will launch its first 60 satellites to deliver internet from space
NASA Needs $1.6 Billion More to Send a Human to the MoonNASA Needs $1.6 Billion More to Send a Human to the Moon
Jeff Bezos Builds a Moon ShipJeff Bezos Builds a Moon Ship
NASAs Mars Helicopter Testing Enters Final PhaseNASA's Mars Helicopter Testing Enters Final Phase
NASA captures stunning photo of the entire sky in X-rayNASA captures stunning photo of the entire sky in X-ray
Trump Tweets About Moon, Mars, the Internet Scratches Its HeadTrump Tweets About Moon, Mars, the Internet Scratches Its Head
Elon Musks SpaceX raises over $1 billion this year as internet satellite production ramps upElon Musk's SpaceX raises over $1 billion this year as internet satellite production ramps up
News Trends
Taylor Swift Just Revealed All The Celebrities Who Will Appear In Her Upcoming VideoTaylor Swift Just Revealed All The Celebrities Who Will Appear In Her Upcoming Video
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle Share Touching New Image of Baby ArchiePrince Harry and Meghan Markle Share Touching New Image of Baby Archie
Bella Thornes Ex Mod Sun Breaks Down the Passport SituationBella Thorne's Ex Mod Sun Breaks Down the Passport Situation
Usain Bolt Grinds On Hot IG Model Zahra EliseUsain Bolt Grinds On Hot IG Model Zahra Elise
Carli Lloyd scores double as USA sweep Chile aside to advance to last 16Carli Lloyd scores double as USA sweep Chile aside to advance to last 16
Anti-LGBT protests have reawakened painful memoriesAnti-LGBT protests have reawakened painful memories
Fathers Day Fast FactsFather's Day Fast Facts
Taylor Swift gives surprise Pride Month performance at Stonewall Inn, a historic LGBT site in New YorkTaylor Swift gives surprise Pride Month performance at Stonewall Inn, a historic LGBT site in New York
Trump says he was briefed on Navy sightings of UFOsTrump says he was briefed on Navy sightings of UFOs
Jennifer Aniston on silver fox co-starJennifer Aniston on 'silver fox' co-star
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Stan Lee's Greatness Will Never Be Forgotten
Amazon’s HQ2 will bring 25,000 jobs each to New York City and Northern Virginia
Sir Alex Ferguson tried three things to sign Joe Cole for Manchester United
Kim Kardashian Says 'Our Hearts Are Broken' as She Accepts People's Choice Award with Family
Trump Renews Attacks on NATO and Trade Imbalances
Michael Buble UK tour: How to get tickets for singer's Don't Believe the Rumours shows
'I felt like I failed': Michelle Obama opens up on miscarriage, IVF
National Action Trial: Two Found Guilty Of Being In Banned Neo-Nazi Group
Jeremy Corbyn Must Uphold Labour Brexit Policy On Second Referendum, Says Gordon Brown
The 22-Inch TRUMPY BEAR You've Never Wanted Is On Sale With 'Added Bonus'
Kate Upton, Justin Verlander share first picture of new baby
Watch Pete Davidson apologize to Dan Crenshaw face to face on 'SNL'
Brazilian Grand Prix: Sebastian Vettel smashes Interlagos lap record
Meghan Markle conceals baby bump as she attends her first Remembrance Day ceremony
Emmanuel Macron warns of dangers of nationalism in Armistice Day speech
World leaders gather in Paris for Armistice Day – video
Spice Girls tickets cause MAYHEM as Ticketmaster goes into meltdown: 'My heart's breaking'
April Ryan Got Protection After Receiving Ominous Threats Following Trump Attacks
Outlaw King review – bold, watchable portrait of Robert the Bruce
Lady Gaga Opens Up About Her 'Mental Health Crisis'
Colbert Slams Huckabee Sanders for Circulating Doctored Video
Adriana Lima walks Victoria’s Secret runway for last time
'Camp Fire' inferno: North California town of Paradise 'wiped out' as thousands flee
Germany: Merkel warns of modern racism on Kristallnacht 80th
The Latest: Wildfire triggers evacuation order for Malibu
Michelle Obama reveals miscarriage and IVF treatment in new book
Iceland's Christmas TV advert banned for being too political
Sarah Hyland Knew About the Modern Family Pregnancy Reveal for Months
Did Ariana Grande Just Share The Tracklist For Her Next Album?
Tesla names Robyn Denholm new chairman, overseeing Elon Musk
Ruth Bader Ginsburg breaks ribs in fall
Sheriff's Sgt. Ron Helus was set to retire soon. He was killed in the Thousand Oaks attack
Thousand Oaks shooting: gunman kills 12 at California western bar
Lasers could help us attract aliens, MIT study suggests
Oh, no! Ariana Grande trips while performing new song about famous exes on 'Ellen'
Dan Crenshaw addresses Pete Davidson's panned 'SNL' joke during victory speech
'I'm as hopeful as I've ever been': Beto O'Rourke fails to beat Ted Cruz
Trump delivers for McConnell in Senate races
Pro-Trump pimp Dennis Hof wins Nevada election weeks after he died
See Kendall Jenner's Victoria's Secret Fashion Show Evolution
Taylor Swift Makes Impassioned Personal Video Message Urging Fans to Vote
Emmanuel Macron: Six held in 'attack' plot against French president
Idris Elba is named People's Sexiest Man Alive for 2018
8 big questions for Election Day
SpaceX's 'Starman' and Its Tesla Roadster Are Now Beyond Mars
Rihanna doesn't want Trump playing her music at his 'tragic rallies,' but she may not have a choice
Floyd Mayweather to fight Japanese kickboxing sensation on New Year's Eve
'The Walking Dead' Season 9, Episode 5 recap: What happened to Rick Grimes?
Election Day 2018: A nation on edge heads to the polls
FA launch James McClean investigation after he brands fans 'uneducated cavemen'
Trump Jr. calls Alec Baldwin ‘garbage’ in swipe over arrest
Ariana Grande Sings About Pete Davidson and Mac Miller in New Song 'Thank u, next'
Pete Davidson wishes Ariana Grande the best on SNL while she releases song thanking him
Melania Trump Spent Almost $100000 at a Hotel She Never Slept In
Former civil service chief Sir Jeremy Heywood dies aged 56
The X Factor forced to cancel live public vote over sound problems
Elon Musk and SpaceX are building a monster rocket for Mars. Here's how big it is compared to 20 familiar objects
Pete Davidson 'Unfazed' by Ariana Grande Diss: 'He'll Joke About His Life' Anyway, Says Source
2 dead after Amazon building partially collapses in Baltimore
How to Get Destiny 2 for Free on PC
Alec Baldwin denies punching man in face over parking dispute
Two victims and gunman identified in Tallahassee yoga studio shooting
Rashford’s late winner seals Manchester United comeback at Bournemouth
Meghan Markle and Prince Harry Withdrawal? Here's When You Can Expect to See the Couple Again
Tesla's Elon Musk and Twitter: Is Anyone Actually Monitoring His Tweets?
Ariana Grande Uses BBC Music Special To Share Important Mental Health Message
'Bohemian Rhapsody' is about to introduce Queen's music to the Spotify generation
Two men arrested after stabbing at Sony Music's London HQ
'House of Cards': Six Things to Remember Before the Start of Season 6
Ariana Grande wears Mac Miller’s sweatshirt during tribute concert
Soyuz Already Back in the Saddle, with Crewed Launch Set for Early December
Neil Young confirms marriage to Daryl Hannah
Google walkout: global protests after sexual misconduct allegations
Oprah Winfrey to hit campaign trail in Georgia for Stacey Abrams
Arron Banks faces criminal inquiry over Brexit campaign
Jimmy Fallon's Count Trumpula Declares Victory in the War on Halloween: 'Ivanka Suck Your Blood'
Duchess Meghan turns heads in see-through skirt during royal tour
Survey: NBC's canceling of 'Megyn Kelly Today' is 'too harsh' after blackface comments
Meet the mob hitman suspected of killing Whitey Bulger
First look at Henry Cavill in The Witcher as he becomes Geralt of Rivia
A 5-year-old boy tested positive for meth after trick-or-treating. And it wasn't from the candy
Planning To Dress Up Your Pet For Halloween? Here's Why You Should Think Twice
Selena Gomez Isn't Instagram's Most Followed User Anymore, But She's Still Up There
Little Mix Say Nicki Minaj Was Approached For 'Woman Like Me' Collaboration Before Cardi B
Venice under water as deadly storms hit Italy
Suzy Lamplugh murder: police dig up garden at suspect's former home
George Clooney wins Hollywood's Halloween
Accusations versus accountability: Hollywood's complicated relationship with Johnny Depp
Apple launches new MacBook Air with retina display
Ben Affleck and Matt Damon Cheer On the Boston Red Sox to a World Series Win
Lion Air plane crash: Debris found in sea off Jakarta, Indonesia
Student shot dead by classmate in NC high school after fight, police say
Angela Merkel To Step Down From Christian Democrat Party In December
Kellyanne Conway snaps after CNN’s John Berman reads her Trump’s divisive statements: ‘You’re cherry picking!’
Luis Suarez scores hat trick as Barcelona thrash Real Madrid in Clasico
Meghan and Harry attend NZ ceremony to mark first votes for women
'I just want to kill Jews:' Documents detail the Pittsburgh synagogue massacre and name the dead
A R7.3 billion replica of the original Titanic could set sail across the Atlantic in 2022
Ross Barkley makes his mark as Chelsea cut down ineffectual Burnley
Meghan Markle Just Shared Her First Official Photo to Twitter — and It's a Proud Wife Moment
Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Almost Featured a Big Tribute to Sabrina the Teenage Witch
Cesar Sayoc: The mail bomb suspect who drove a van plastered with Trump stickers
Sadio Mané scores twice as Liverpool ease past Cardiff on way to top
Glenn Hoddle ‘seriously ill’ after collapsing at BT Sport studios
Suspect in custody after ‘multiple casualties’ in Pittsburgh synagogue shooting
1 Month to Mars! NASA's InSight Lander Nearing Red Planet Touchdown
Jennifer Lopez and Alex Rodriguez are basically Fenway regulars now
Ariana Grande reveals 'the absolute love of my life'
Johnny Depp leaves Pirates of the Caribbean franchise, say reports
NBC reports Megyn Kelly is negotiating her exit from network; would Fox take her back?
Tiffany Haddish slays James Brown impression in Jimmy Fallon's Lip Sync Battle
Suspicious packages addressed to Cory Booker and James Clapper discovered
Man arrested for trying to steal Magna Carta
Ruth Davidson gives birth to baby boy
SpaceX's Falcon Heavy rocket seems to be a hit with satellite companies
'Modern Family' reveals death of a recurring character
Meghan Markle Had a Very Relatable Fashion Moment
Jennifer Garner Is Dating John Miller: 5 Things to Know About Her New Boyfriend
Red Dead Redemption 2 review – gripping western is a near miracle
Sir Philip Green named as man at heart of 'UK #MeToo scandal'
US mail bombs: Suspect packages sent to Robert De Niro and former Vice President Joe Biden
Cardi B trolls Nicki Minaj fans after new song ‘Money’ leaks
NASA May Have Fixed Hubble By Shaking It and Turning It Off and On
Kate Middleton slammed on for 'truly awful' '80s style banquet dress
Megyn Kelly Apologizes On-Air After a Today Colleague Calls Her Blackface Comments 'Indefensible'
Explosive device found near home of billionaire investor George Soros
Suspected bombs sent to Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama and CNN building: White House condemns 'terrorising acts' as 'despicable'
Vogue Responds to Backlash Over Kendall Jenner's 'Afro' in Recent Photo Shoot
Cardi B – 'Money'
Canadian Rapper Jon James McMurray Dies Filming Airplane Stunt
Amy Schumer Is Pregnant – And We Totally Love How She Announced It
Utah track athlete Lauren McCluskey shot and killed
Megyn Kelly doesn’t understand why blackface is racist
Manchester United v Juventus: Champions League
Dyson to build electric cars in Singapore, with launch planned for 2021
Tommy Robinson: judge refers case to attorney general
Erdogan says Khashoggi was victim of 'ferocious' pre-planned murder
Ariana Grande Posts Tribute to Mac Miller Days After Pete Davidson Breakup
Mars likely to have enough oxygen to support life: study
Simon Mayo Calls Out ‘Appalling’ Abuse Of Jo Whiley After Their Radio 2 Show Is Axed
WWE star Roman Reigns reveals he's battling leukemia again
New York Giants produce another offensive debacle vs. Atlanta Falcons
Meghan Markle wears same dress as Prince Harry’s ex-girlfriend
Meghan Markle Just Broke Another Royal Style Rule with Her Most Daring Look Yet
Ouch! Paula Abdul Falls Offstage During Mississippi Concert
Cristiano Ronaldo: Juventus star sends message to Sir Alex Ferguson before Man Utd return
Watch NASA release 450000 gallons of water in 1 minute
The Surprising Ways Prince Harry and Meghan Markle's Marriage Follows Prince Charles and Princess Diana
Why Kim Kardashian Is 'Grateful' for Frightening Robbery in Paris
From Rosa Parks to Van Gogh: when TV takes on real-life figures
Man Utd boss Jose Mourinho delivers bad Alexis Sanchez news ahead of Juventus clash
Hurricane Willa on verge of becoming Category 5 storm off Mexico's Pacific coast
Former Carolina Panther Rae Carruth released from prison
Ariana Grande Enjoys Some Retail Therapy After Pete Davidson Speaks Out About Breakup
'The Walking Dead' Review: 'Warning Signs' Is Bleak, But In A Good Way
Elon Musk says first tunnel for proposed underground transportation network will open in December
Turkish President Erdogan promises to reveal the 'naked truth' about Jamal Khashoggi's death
Florida Governor Candidates Andrew Gillum and Ron DeSantis Face Off in Contentious Debate
Chiefs QB Patrick Mahomes torches Bengals for 4 TDs in win
EU approves $7.5 bn acquisition of GitHub by Microsoft
Wayne Rooney scores as DC United beat New York City to reach play-offs
Kanye West surprises Kim Kardashian with early birthday gifts
Meghan Markle’s schedule in Australia cut back
Lewis Hamilton: Mercedes chief reveals Kimi Raikkonen and Sebastian Vettel US GP concern
Dominic Calvert-Lewin sparks Everton’s late demolition of Crystal Palace
Eric Reid separated from Malcolm Jenkins in pre-game confrontation
Emilia Clarke in pictures: Game of Thrones actress reunites with co-star at Film Festival
Shocking Video of Floor Collapsing During Clemson Univ. Dance Party
Welcome to Space! BepiColombo Spacecraft Headed to Mercury Snap 1st Photo
US To End Cold War-Era Nuclear Arms Treaty With Russia, Trump Says
Lewis Hamilton has been a ruthless phenomenon to treasure
Ryanair refers racist incident to police amid criticism over inaction
Nicole Kidman talks new film at NYC luncheon
Ariana Grande Follows in Taylor Swift's Footsteps and Encourages People to Vote
After 'Resting at Home,' Meghan Markle Steps Out at Reception with Prince Harry — See the Photos!
Selma Blair Reveals She Has MS in Emotional Instagram Post: 'I'm in the Thick of It'
Elon Musk is too ambitious for Tesla's own good
Japanese MotoGP: Marc Marquez clinches world championship with stunning victory
Dodgers set up World Series with Red Sox after Game 7 win over Brewers
Purdue blasts Ohio State, shaking up Big Ten picture
Lakers FIGHT: LeBron James responds to Rajon Rondo and Chris Paul throwing punches
Pete Davidson still has hope for relationship with Ariana Grande
Kim Kardashian Said Marrying Kanye West Made Her A More Private Person, Which Is No Small Feat
Chelsea’s late leveller against Manchester United sparks touchline chaos around Mourinho
BepiColombo Spacecraft Launch on 7-Year Trek to Mercury for Europe and Japan
Hailey Baldwin Trademarks Her Married Name 1 Month After Wedding Ceremony
Lady Gaga Releases 'I'll Never Love Again' Music Video from A Star Is Born with Bradley Cooper
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle Have a Blast Playing With Kids at Invictus Games
Katy Perry Commends Taylor Swift for Speaking Out on Politics: 'She's Setting a Great Example'
At charity dinner, Nikki Haley takes jabs at Trump and other political elites
'Making a Murderer Part 2' proves you can't re-create a phenomenon
iPhone XR release TODAY as Apple prices and new deals revealed
‘Luke Cage’ Canceled by Netflix
All’s good with Kawhi as Raptors’ season kicks off
Trump says it appears Khashoggi is dead and consequences could be ‘severe’
Britney Spears Announces ''Domination'' Residency With Parade Through Las Vegas Strip
Ariana Grande 'Focusing on Work' Amid Pete Davidson Split: 'Her Family Is Worried About Her'
Prince Harry climbs Sydney Harbor Bridge to kick off Invictus Games
EU WILL NOT BUDGE: Macron demands 'POLITICAL COMPROMISE' from May - 'It is NOT up to us'
David Beckham Says His and Victoria Beckham's Marriage Is 'Always Hard Work'
Close