Close
Date TimeJune 14, 2018
VoiceLaura Cicco claims the moonwalker gave her the memento when she was a child.
Woman says Neil Armstrong gave her moon dust. She's suing NASA to keep it
In a case that mixes nostalgia with serious questions about who is allowed to own materials brought back from space, a Tennessee woman is suing NASA to maintain possession of what she says is a vial of moon dust that astronaut Neil Armstrong gave her when she was 10 years old.
In her lawsuit filed in federal court last week, Laura Cicco says Armstrong, the first human to walk on the moon, gave her the vial in the 1970s along with a handwritten note: “To Laura Ann Murray — Best of Luck — Neil Armstrong Apollo 11.”
Woman says Neil Armstrong gave her moon dust. She's suing NASA to keep it
Cicco, then named Laura Murray, claims she received the memento while living with her family in Cincinnati. She maintains that Armstrong, who taught aerospace engineering at the University of Cincinnati at the time, had been a friend of her late father. Armstrong died in 2012.
A handwriting expert authenticated the signature on the note, said Cicco’s lawyer, Christopher McHugh of Kansas City, Missouri. Tests of the vial's contents found that "there is no evidence to rule out a lunar origin," according to the court documents, but terrestrial materials from Earth's crust were also identified in the sample.
Cicco told the Washington Post that she had lost track of the vial until five years ago, when she rediscovered it in her father’s belongings after his death, and that she had filed the suit in an effort to block NASA from trying to seize the moon dust.
The space agency declined a request by MACH to comment on the case, but it has a reputation for aggressiveness in its efforts to take possession of lunar samples held by private citizens. In one highly publicized case from 2011, NASA conducted a sting operation in Lake Elsinore, California, to seize paperweights containing slivers of moon rock that a 74-year-old woman was trying to sell.
“Lunar samples that have been collected by U.S. government missions are considered unique and limited natural resources,” said Michelle Hanlon, co-founder of For All Moonkind, a nonprofit dedicated to preserving the Apollo lunar landing sites. “NASA retains all lunar samples collected through U.S. government missions as NASA property.” Hanlon is not involved in the case.
McHugh said there is no law against private ownership of moon dust. “The law is silent on this — it’s still an open question,” he said. “NASA bases its position on the assumption that no lunar material ever left NASA unless it was stolen, but there is no law that says you can’t own lunar material.”
The outcome of Cicco's case will hinge on whether Armstrong or the government owned the dust at the time it was given, according to Christopher Johnson, a professor of law at Georgetown University in Washington, D.C. and a space law expert. “If it’s the property of the U.S. government, he could not have passed it along to somebody else — he didn’t have the correct chain of custody or title for that,” said Johnson, who is not involved in the case.
Woman says Neil Armstrong gave her moon dust. She's suing NASA to keep it
McHugh said the handwritten note from Armstrong gives Cicco a strong claim of ownership. “We get past that hurdle because we have proof that Laura was given it directly by Neil Armstrong,” he said. “Unless you call Neil Armstrong a thief,” he added, “he had the authority to own it and give it to people. I don’t think Neil Armstrong was a thief.”
If there are no federal statutes against private ownership of materials from space, other experts say international law may provide some guidance. The Treaty on Principles Governing the Activities of States in the Exploration and Use of Outer Space, signed in 1967 and commonly called the Outer Space Treaty, prohibits governments from claiming territory on the moon and other celestial bodies. It is recognized by 107 countries, including the U.S. and Russia.
“In international law, nobody can appropriate anything in space. That is very clear,” said Ram Jakhu, an associate professor of space law at McGill University in Montreal, Canada. But, he added, “There are some exceptions and tolerance of violations. Countries like the U.S. and Russia have been collecting these moon samples and have been keeping it, so there’s some kind of tolerance of violation of international law.”
NASA now has 60 days to respond to the lawsuit.

Related Stories
India Loses Contact With Spacecraft During Attempted Moon LandingIndia Loses Contact With Spacecraft During Attempted Moon Landing
Moon Picks Ally Accused of Graft as South Korea Justice MinisterMoon Picks Ally Accused of Graft as South Korea Justice Minister
A full moon will rise Friday the 13th. Heres why its so rare and why itll look smallA full moon will rise Friday the 13th. Here's why it's so rare and why it'll look small
80-Year-Old Widows To Marry After Falling In Love Over A Jigsaw Puzzle80-Year-Old Widows To Marry After Falling In Love Over A Jigsaw Puzzle
Northern Lights And Party Nights: 72 Hours In ReykjavikNorthern Lights And Party Nights: 72 Hours In Reykjavik
Watch as India attempts a historic moon landing this afternoonWatch as India attempts a historic moon landing this afternoon
Making Sense of Israel’s Post-Election Political ChaosMaking Sense of Israel’s Post-Election Political Chaos
Chandrayaan-2: Indias second moon mission thought to have failed as scientists lose contact with landerChandrayaan-2: India's second moon mission thought to have failed as scientists lose contact with lander
Mum Who Has 10 Boys Finally Gives Birth To A Baby GirlMum Who Has 10 Boys Finally Gives Birth To A Baby Girl
Boltons White House exit signals new hope for US-North Korea talks despite summer of missile testsBolton's White House exit signals new hope for US-North Korea talks despite summer of missile tests
Latest News
Ajax v Chelsea: Champions League Group H – live!Ajax v Chelsea: Champions League Group H – live!
Faf de Klerk: ‘I guess moving to England was a blessing in disguise’ | Paul ReesFaf de Klerk: ‘I guess moving to England was a blessing in disguise’ | Paul Rees
England should look to past to ensure they have a Rugby World Cup future | Matt McIlraithEngland should look to past to ensure they have a Rugby World Cup future | Matt McIlraith
Trump to lift sanctions on Turkey as government says Syria ceasefire will be made permanentTrump to lift sanctions on Turkey as government says Syria ceasefire will be made 'permanent'
Alyssa Milano Says She’s Talking With Holly Marie Combs About Making ‘Charmed’ Movies for Netflix (Video)Alyssa Milano Says She’s Talking With Holly Marie Combs About Making ‘Charmed’ Movies for Netflix (Video)
Former GOP Reps Charlie Dent and Sean Duffy in CNN Face-Off: ‘My Nose Is Not a Heat-Seeking Missile for the President’s Backside’Former GOP Reps Charlie Dent and Sean Duffy in CNN Face-Off: ‘My Nose Is Not a Heat-Seeking Missile for the President’s Backside’
President Supervillain: behind the alarmingly accurate Trump-Marvel mashupPresident Supervillain: behind the alarmingly accurate Trump-Marvel mashup
Paul Hollywood Apologises For Thoughtless Diabetes Remark During This Weeks Great British Bake OffPaul Hollywood Apologises For 'Thoughtless' Diabetes Remark During This Week's Great British Bake Off
Who Are We Kidding, Racism Is An Open Secret At UniversitiesWho Are We Kidding, Racism Is An Open Secret At Universities
Erdogan hails historic agreement with Putin over SyriaErdogan hails 'historic agreement' with Putin over Syria
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Boris-JohnsonBoris Johnson
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Theresa-MayTheresa May
Member of Parliament of the United Kingdom
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
India Loses Contact With Spacecraft During Attempted Moon LandingIndia Loses Contact With Spacecraft During Attempted Moon Landing
Moon Picks Ally Accused of Graft as South Korea Justice MinisterMoon Picks Ally Accused of Graft as South Korea Justice Minister
A full moon will rise Friday the 13th. Heres why its so rare and why itll look smallA full moon will rise Friday the 13th. Here's why it's so rare and why it'll look small
80-Year-Old Widows To Marry After Falling In Love Over A Jigsaw Puzzle80-Year-Old Widows To Marry After Falling In Love Over A Jigsaw Puzzle
Northern Lights And Party Nights: 72 Hours In ReykjavikNorthern Lights And Party Nights: 72 Hours In Reykjavik
Watch as India attempts a historic moon landing this afternoonWatch as India attempts a historic moon landing this afternoon
Making Sense of Israel’s Post-Election Political ChaosMaking Sense of Israel’s Post-Election Political Chaos
Chandrayaan-2: Indias second moon mission thought to have failed as scientists lose contact with landerChandrayaan-2: India's second moon mission thought to have failed as scientists lose contact with lander
Mum Who Has 10 Boys Finally Gives Birth To A Baby GirlMum Who Has 10 Boys Finally Gives Birth To A Baby Girl
Boltons White House exit signals new hope for US-North Korea talks despite summer of missile testsBolton's White House exit signals new hope for US-North Korea talks despite summer of missile tests
Latest News
Ajax v Chelsea: Champions League Group H – live!Ajax v Chelsea: Champions League Group H – live!
Faf de Klerk: ‘I guess moving to England was a blessing in disguise’ | Paul ReesFaf de Klerk: ‘I guess moving to England was a blessing in disguise’ | Paul Rees
England should look to past to ensure they have a Rugby World Cup future | Matt McIlraithEngland should look to past to ensure they have a Rugby World Cup future | Matt McIlraith
Trump to lift sanctions on Turkey as government says Syria ceasefire will be made permanentTrump to lift sanctions on Turkey as government says Syria ceasefire will be made 'permanent'
Alyssa Milano Says She’s Talking With Holly Marie Combs About Making ‘Charmed’ Movies for Netflix (Video)Alyssa Milano Says She’s Talking With Holly Marie Combs About Making ‘Charmed’ Movies for Netflix (Video)
Former GOP Reps Charlie Dent and Sean Duffy in CNN Face-Off: ‘My Nose Is Not a Heat-Seeking Missile for the President’s Backside’Former GOP Reps Charlie Dent and Sean Duffy in CNN Face-Off: ‘My Nose Is Not a Heat-Seeking Missile for the President’s Backside’
President Supervillain: behind the alarmingly accurate Trump-Marvel mashupPresident Supervillain: behind the alarmingly accurate Trump-Marvel mashup
Paul Hollywood Apologises For Thoughtless Diabetes Remark During This Weeks Great British Bake OffPaul Hollywood Apologises For 'Thoughtless' Diabetes Remark During This Week's Great British Bake Off
Who Are We Kidding, Racism Is An Open Secret At UniversitiesWho Are We Kidding, Racism Is An Open Secret At Universities
Erdogan hails historic agreement with Putin over SyriaErdogan hails 'historic agreement' with Putin over Syria
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Boris-JohnsonBoris Johnson
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Theresa-MayTheresa May
Member of Parliament of the United Kingdom
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Fire ravages Glasgow School of Art's Mackintosh building -- again
Chris Hardwick Under Fire as Ex-Girlfriend Alleges Abuse, Blacklisting
Time Warner unveils its new name: WarnerMedia
Brilliant Ronaldo rescues Portugal in thriller
Aziz Bouhaddouz own goal in added time hands Iran win against Morocco
Trump praises Kim on Fox & Friends: 'I want my people to do the same'
Oprah Winfrey to create new TV shows for Apple
Cristiano Ronaldo pays $21.7 million to avoid jail time in tax fraud case
Natalie Portman slights former Harvard classmate Jared Kushner: He's a 'super villain'
Australian comedian raped and murdered
Judge sends Manafort to jail, pending trial
Fox Apologizes for Robbie Williams' Obscene Gesture at World Cup
Christina Aguilera: Liberation review – #MeToo makeover hits high and low notes
Incredibles 2 is dream job for Sophia Bush
Sanders uses Bible to defend Trump's separation of children from families at border
How Mohamed Salah managed the impossible: to unite Egypt
Trump up for Nobel Peace Prize after Kim summit
French President Emmanuel Macron takes heat over new dishes
Chrissy Teigen celebrates Trump’s birthday with $288,000 donation to ACLU
'But my emails': Hillary Clinton claps back after report reveals Comey used Gmail
Two adults, two children shot in Westminster; suspect in custody
Late-Night Hosts Imagine How Trump Celebrated His Birthday
Stephen Colbert Offers Scathing Takedown Of Trump’s Immigration Policy
Trump approves tariffs on $50 billion worth of Chinese goods
Grenfell Tower fire: thousands attend silent march one year on
New York attorney general sues Trump foundation over self-dealing
Ellen DeGeneres Sets First Stand-Up Tour in 15 Years
Nicole Kidman Inks First-Look Film, TV Deal at Amazon
Trump returns salute of North Korean general at summit, state media footage reveals
Russia open World Cup with thumping win over Saudi Arabia
Meghan Markle, Queen Elizabeth step out for first royal engagement together
Russia World Cup to generate a staggering $6 billion for FIFA
Fashion’s first 11: which is the most stylish World Cup kit?
Sarah Sanders and Raj Shah ‘planning to LEAVE’ White House in HUGE BLOW to Trump
Where do we stand a year after the Grenfell Tower fire?
NYPD develops cards for deaf and hard of hearing motorists to ease communication
Chicago mayor wants Elon Musk to build high-speed transit linking O'Hare and downtown
Anne Donovan, Olympic gold medalist, basketball Hall of Famer, dies at 56
British political operatives met with Russian ambassador days after Trump visit
‘Wonder Woman 1984’ First Image Reveals Chris Pine’s Return
Michael Cohen is expected to split with legal team. Will he cooperate with prosecutors?
Stephen Hawking's voice to be beamed into black hole while his ashes are interred at Westminster Abbey
Antarctic ice melting faster than ever, studies show
Nicki Minaj Says Being Single Made Her Music Better
Germany fines VW $1.2 billion over diesel scandal
World Cup: More than 1,200 UK football hooligans blocked from flying to Russia
Italy summons French ambassador in row over migrant rescue boat
U.S., Mexico and Canada to Host 2026 Soccer World Cup
Late-Night TV's Comedy King Is Not Who You Think
Kim Jong-un hailed victor in 'meeting of century' by North Korean media
Two women get kicked out of Uber after kiss
Elon Musk, in Search of Profit, Cuts Tesla's Work Force
Late-Night Sounds Off on Trump's Historic Meeting With Kim Jong-un
Angelina Jolie required to give Brad Pitt more access to their kids
ZTE stock plummets 40% after US ban
AT&T bid for CNN's parent company approved
The Switch is getting some cool local multiplayer indie games
Armed man takes hostages in Paris
Iran says it can't remain in nuclear deal without benefits
Hilary Duff Looks Back at Past Fashion Choices on 'The Late Late Show'
The two really important people at the summit (beside Trump and Kim)
US to suspend military exercises with South Korea, Trump says
Obama's shock presidential intervention: Barack has eyes on 2020 race
11 dead as boats collide in Russian city hosting World Cup
Trump Played Kim Jong Un This Crazily Intense Video at Meeting
Ariana Grande & Pete Davidson's Relationship 'Moving a Million Miles a Minute'
New Look slashes prices amid sharp fall in annual sales
Ivanka Trump and Jared Kushner made over $82m outside White House roles
WATCH: Peculiar moment Trump shows off his $1.6million BEAST to Kim Jong-un at summit
Trump pledges security guarantees to NKorea after summit
The Latest: Pompeo updates Japan, South Korea after summit
Jimmy Kimmel Teases 'Blobfish Basketball Classic' Charity Game Against Ted Cruz
Trevor Noah Reveals The Real Reason Jon Stewart Left ‘The Daily Show’
READ: Full text of Trump-Kim signed statement
PICTURE SPECIAL: How Trump met Kim
Dennis Rodman gets emotional discussing Trump and Kim
Millicent Fawcett: Who was the tireless suffragist and how did she change women's voting rights forever?
Square Enix's E3 showcase was a bust
Former NBA star Dennis Rodman arrives in Singapore ahead of Trump-Kim summit
A sexy walk is as important to a woman's attractiveness as her body shape, British study claims
Theresa May says G7 summit with Donald Trump was 'difficult'
Peace talks between Russia, Ukraine get underway in Berlin
Kim Jong Un's sister arrives in Singapore in separate plane from North Korean leader
Could humans live on Mars? 'Absolutely,' a NASA expert says
Jane Fonda to Receive Career Honor at Lyon's Lumiere Festival
Spain offers to take migrant ship after Italy's populists turn it away
IHOP becomes IHOb, with 'b' for burgers
Chloe Ayling kidnapper sentenced to 16 years in prison
Kendall Jenner makes Trump joke during 'Celebrity Family Feud'
Airman with top-secret clearance, who disappeared in 1983, is discovered living in California
Top attractions in Moscow: The best things to do in Russia's capital
Trump told Macron EU worse than China on trade
Jackson Odell (of 'The Goldbergs') dies at 20; coroner investigating
Opera Omaha is making a name for itself with festivals, productions
North Korea hails 'new era' of relations with US ahead of Trump-Kim summit
Microsoft's E3 2018 conference shows that Xbox is (sort of) back
Here Are The 2018 Tony Award Winners
Nadal wins 11th French Open title by beating Thiem in 3 sets
Vince Vaughn arrested in California on DUI, resisting arrest charges
The end of net neutrality has arrived
Women march across UK to celebrate 100 years of female suffrage
Trump arrives in Singapore ahead of historic North Korea summit
Trump's top economic aide on Trudeau: 'It was a betrayal'
Arron Banks ‘met with Russian officials multiple times before Brexit vote’
Donald Trump REFUSES to sign G7 agreement before BLASTING Theresa May and Justin Trudeau
Stephen Colbert Hits Back at 'Hateful Dweebs' Who Harassed 'Star Wars' Actress
Kim Jong Un arrives in Singapore for historic summit
Canadian GP: Vettel beats Bottas, Verstappen to pole
Sea of Solitude's haunting trailer is about humans who turn into monsters
'We are ready' Putin warns Russia is prepared for meeting with Trump in AUSTRIA
Tommy Robinson march: Five police officers injured as London rally spirals out of control
Holocaust survivor Gena Turgel, consoler of Anne Frank, dies
German Chancellor Merkel's stare down photo sums up Trump's time at G-7
Trump calls for elimination of tariffs, end to US being world's 'piggy bank'
Donald Trump and Kim Jong-un’s rocky road to Singapore – video explainer
Merkel proposes trade dispute body as G7 summit begins
Meghan Markle attends annual Trooping the Colour parade, makes Buckingham Palace balcony debut
Kate Spade and Anthony Bourdain: How the press can cover suicide without creating a 'contagion'
200,000 trillion calculations per second: U.S. launches the world’s most powerful supercomputer
Kevin Durant wins Finals MVP for second consecutive year
Jimmy Kimmel, Ryan Gosling Travel to Space to Celebrate 'First Man' Trailer Release
MSNBC Host Asks If Silent Ivanka And Melania Trump ‘Dead Inside’
Trump could handle Brexit better than May, Boris hints
Actress Emma Thompson made a dame in Queen's birthday honors list
Plane's emergency highway landing
Conservative commentator Charles Krauthammer announces he has cancer, weeks left to live
China stole sensitive U.S. navy data on submarine warfare, officials say
Ex-Trump campaign chair Paul Manafort, Russian associate hit with obstruction charges
Michelle Wolf Defends Monica Lewinsky, Slams Media for 'High Horse' Coverage of Recent Clinton Comment
Hilary Duff shares pregnancy news
David Beckham endorses North America World Cup bid
The Washington Capitals, After Years of Frustration, Win the Stanley Cup
Soyuz capsule with 3 astronauts docks with space station
Trump says Russia should be reinstated in group of leading industrialized nations
CNN's Anthony Bourdain dead at 61
Stormy Daniels releases new perfume called Truth
Pippa Middleton confirms pregnancy and reveals she escaped morning sickness unlike her sister Kate
Trump to leave G-7 summit early amid feud with world leaders, calls Trudeau 'so indignant'
Stephen Colbert’s Latest Trump Joke May Have Been Censored By CBS
Kim Kardashian shares the joy of how she called Alice Johnson in prison to tell her she would be freed
Jack Ma's online payments giant just raised $14 billion
Liverpool set to complete £53m signing of Nabil Fekir from Lyon
Trump says outcome of summit with Kim Jong Un depends on ‘attitude,’ less on preparation
MIT scientists created an AI-powered 'psychopath' named Norman
Lady Gaga steps into the spotlight in the 'A Star is Born' trailer
NASA's Curiosity rover finds organic matter on Mars
Car RAMS into US Embassy in Seoul 'driven by North Korean defector screaming 'help me!''
Britain now the enemy? Brussels boots out UK military – 'UK no place in defence of Europe'
No, Mr. Trump, Canada did not burn down the White House in the War of 1812
‘You Did It’: Alice Johnson Thanks Kim Kardashian For Never Giving Up On Her
Time Magazine’s Latest Cover Features Trump As ‘King Me’
Kate Spade's husband says she battled demons but death was complete shock
Giuliani defends comments about Stormy Daniels' credibility
Virginia Apgar: Who is the Dr who saved millions of babies and who Google is celebrating?
UK Supreme Court criticizes Northern Ireland abortion laws
David Davis urged not to resign over Brexit backstop
Peter Stringfellow's life in pictures: Nightclub tycoon who was a magnet for celebrities
Jimmy Kimmel Finds First Lady To Be A Little Stiff
Colbert Has A Hilariously Awful List Of People Trump Could Pardon Next
Trevor Noah: What If Facebook Was A Physical Place?
Samantha Bee Apologizes On-Air For Calling Ivanka Trump An Epithet
Australian news crew mugged while filming on London street
EU to hit US with $3.3B in retaliatory tariffs in July
Amid rumors, Melania Trump makes first public appearance in nearly a month
GOP Senate report says Obama officials gave Iran access to US financial system
About 100 firefighters tackle blaze at London hotel
Trump commutes woman's life sentence after Kim Kardashian West's plea
Voters oust California judge in Brock Turner sexual assault case
Kellyanne Conway comes unglued on CNN host, and says calling out Trump’s lies hurts his ratings
Cambridge Analytica director 'met Assange to discuss US election'
Anger in Israel after Argentina cancels soccer match
All eyes on Canada as first G7 nation prepares to make marijuana legal
Australia remains preferred destination for millionaire migrants
Social media in MELTDOWN as video emerges of police chasing 'STOLEN TANK' in Virginia, US
Facebook confirms data sharing with Chinese companies
Elon Musk appears emotional as he overcomes vote to remove him as Tesla chairman
Shawn Mendes Indulges Harry Potter Obsession, Sings Hits on 'Carpool Karaoke'
Bill Clinton Responds to Monica Lewinsky Comment Controversy: 'I Was Mad at Me'
Ariana Grande: I had PTSD following Manchester attack
US government to use facial recognition technology at Mexico border crossing
Macron uses laws and sausages to deflect Trump call question
Putin says he speaks regularly to Trump, isn't trying to divide Europe
Trump to NFL: 'No escaping to locker rooms'
Novak Djokovic OUT of French Open after quarter-final defeat to Marco Cecchinato
Designer Kate Spade, 55, found dead in New York
First ‘Bumblebee’ Trailer Is Heavy on Feels, Light on ‘Transformers’ Action
Serena Williams Withdraws From French Open With A Fierce Message
Guatemala volcano: at least 62 killed and 300 injured after Fuego erupts
Miss America is scrapping the swimsuit portion from its pageant
Sex robots won’t solve loneliness nor curb violence against women, doctors say
NASA to make MAJOR announcement on Thursday about LIFE on Mars
Braless Kim Kardashian West gets cheeky in CFDA Awards speech: 'I'm naked most of the time'
Late-Night Hosts Take Jabs at Trump's Self-Pardon Tweet
French man to cross Great Pacific Garbage Patch on 6-month swim
Apple's new 'digital wellbeing' tools aim to help reduce screen time
Edward Snowden: 'The people are still powerless, but now they're aware'
Trump's phone call with Macron described as 'terrible'
Google honors legendary marathoner Tom Longboat
Vladimir Putin invites North Korean leader Kim Jong-un to Russia – how will Trump react?
Steph Curry's historic NBA Finals Game 2 a window to Warriors before Kevin Durant
Close