Close
Date TimeApril 02, 2018
VoiceDespite the eagerness to declare it ebbing, Syria's war is unlikely to get closer to its end simply because Vladimir Putin, Recip Tayyip Erdogan and Hassan Rouhani are meeting in Ankara this week.
Russia-Turkey-Iran solution for Syria leaves key issues unresolved
Yes, these leaders represent the three largest foreign military forces operating now inside Syria, excluding the US, whose commander-in-chief said late last week that America would soon be letting "others" take care of Syria. But Russia, Turkey and Iran meet without the contribution of a reasonably important factor in this ghastly experiment in human cruelty: Syrians.
You can argue that the regime in Damascus will do what Tehran or Moscow tells it to. But the prospect of Russia, Turkey and Iran agreeing what a new status quo inside Syria should look like is a short-term stopgap at best, and one that overlooks the underlying and unresolved causes of the war.
The accepted premise of this trilateral solution is that Iran and Russia are content that the regime has full access to the coast and a clear channel all the way to the Iraqi capital Baghdad -- through which Tehran can slowly harass Israel and dominate the region, and Moscow can retain an airbase on the Mediterranean.
Turkey is meant to be happy as its proxies control the area west of the Euphrates Rivers along to Idlib, and provide a space for Sunni militants to create their own communities into which millions of Syrian refugees currently in Turkey might return.
The unspoken annex to this is that the Americans retain adequate firepower and influence in the northeast for the area to remain a de facto Syria-Kurdish enclave for the years to come.

Long- and short-term flaws
Yet already the short-term flaws to this solution are emerging. Ankara has its sights on harassing Manbij, just across to the west of the Euphrates, which is currently held by Syrian Kurds with American backing. And the regime is also eyeing the most populated area in the northwest, where Turkey has large influence: Idlib. It is to Idlib that the Syrian Sunni rebels of Ghouta, Aleppo and elsewhere have fled, along with tens of thousands of civilians.
These are just the short-term problems. The longer-term ones are even harder to solve.
Essentially, this supposed trilateral arrangement fails to deal with the underlying demographic and sectarian issues that began the war in the first place.
Syria's Sunnis rose up against a predominantly Shia regime in 2012. These Sunnis still lack proper representation or a functional homeland. They are squeezed into a tiny pocket of the northwest, and outside Syria's borders into Turkey and Jordan, with many in Lebanon too.
Keeping this disenfranchised, beleaguered and under-resourced population in the rubble, tents and rural flatlands of Idlib won't reduce the influence of extremists in their midst -- it will amplify it.
There are two things you can count on in the months ahead: that Russia and the regime will bombard Idlib and its thousands of civilians, and that the Sunni rebel militants who take shelter in it will respond as extremely as they can. Both sides will continue to do what they have done before.
Secondly, Syria's Kurds, thanks to the near-defeat of ISIS in Syria, control an outsized chunk of the northeast now. Everything east of the Euphrates River was not exclusively Kurdish before ISIS and is not entirely so now, but the Syrian Democratic Forces are the unwavering authority there.
If the US leaves, as President Donald Trump has said is likely, then the Syrian Kurds will have to either forge a deal of coexistence with the Syrian regime or go it alone, potentially against both Turkish and regime forces.

Three forces, three agendas
Yes, the Iran- and Russia-backed Shia regime has solidified its control over the territory it wants, but the majority of the country -- the Sunnis of Syria -- has not settled the question of where they will live and who will rule them. That started this, and must be resolved if it is to end.
Finally, Syria's three dominant forces -- Turkish-backed rebels, US-backed Syrian Kurds and the regime supported by Iran and Russia -- have backers with totally opposed agendas. Turkey wants to defeat the Kurds. The regime wants to defeat the rebels Turkey is backing, and keep the US out. And the US wants to defeat Iranian and regime ambitions in the region, while also keeping Russia in check.
Russia, Iran and Turkey can smile for the cameras in Ankara, but they still walk on Syria's broken glass.

Related Stories
Gulf of Oman tanker attacks: Everything you need to knowGulf of Oman tanker attacks: Everything you need to know
Trump says Obama fumbling pushed Turks to buy Russian missile systemTrump says Obama fumbling pushed Turks to buy Russian missile system
Ancient Siberia was home to previously unknown humans, say scientistsAncient Siberia was home to previously unknown humans, say scientists
Trump announces hard-hitting new sanctions against IranTrump announces 'hard-hitting' new sanctions against Iran
Mats Hummels to rejoin Borussia Dortmund from Bayern for £34mMats Hummels to rejoin Borussia Dortmund from Bayern for £34m
Oil Surges as Trump Says Iran Made Big Mistake Shooting Down US DroneOil Surges as Trump Says Iran Made 'Big Mistake' Shooting Down US Drone
Trump says Iran made a very big mistake after drone downingTrump says 'Iran made a very big mistake' after drone downing
NASA boss says no doubt SpaceX explosion delays flight programNASA boss says 'no doubt' SpaceX explosion delays flight program
Iran claims to have shot down US spy droneIran claims to have shot down US spy drone
Trump jokes to Putin they should get rid of journalistsTrump jokes to Putin they should 'get rid' of journalists
News Trends
Modern Family star Sarah Hyland and Bachelorette contestant Wells Adams are engaged'Modern Family' star Sarah Hyland and 'Bachelorette' contestant Wells Adams are engaged
Elon Musks Neuralink hopes to put sensors in human brains next yearElon Musk's Neuralink hopes to put sensors in human brains next year
EU opens Amazon antitrust investigationEU opens Amazon antitrust investigation
Love Island: Michaels Behaviour Towards Amber Sparks Ofcom ComplaintsLove Island: Michael's Behaviour Towards Amber Sparks Ofcom Complaints
Kris Kobach: I Might Still Support Trump if He Came Out and Said ‘I’m a Racist’Kris Kobach: I Might Still Support Trump if He Came Out and Said ‘I’m a Racist’
Shailene Woodley May Have Revealed The ‘Big Little Lies’ Season 2 EndingShailene Woodley May Have Revealed The ‘Big Little Lies’ Season 2 Ending
Review: The Lion King gives us more of a miaow than a roarReview: 'The Lion King' gives us more of a miaow than a roar
The Squad revives feud with Pelosi: Be aware when you single us out that were women of color'The Squad' revives feud with Pelosi: Be aware when you 'single us out' that we're 'women of color'
Feds confirm ‘Ice Bae’ is a CBP officer, is free to use social mediaFeds confirm ‘Ice Bae’ is a CBP officer, is free to use social media
Is The Big One next? California was shaking again Tuesday, with six earthquakes of 3.5 or greaterIs 'The Big One' next? California was shaking again Tuesday, with six earthquakes of 3.5 or greater
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
Gulf of Oman tanker attacks: Everything you need to knowGulf of Oman tanker attacks: Everything you need to know
Trump says Obama fumbling pushed Turks to buy Russian missile systemTrump says Obama fumbling pushed Turks to buy Russian missile system
Ancient Siberia was home to previously unknown humans, say scientistsAncient Siberia was home to previously unknown humans, say scientists
Trump announces hard-hitting new sanctions against IranTrump announces 'hard-hitting' new sanctions against Iran
Mats Hummels to rejoin Borussia Dortmund from Bayern for £34mMats Hummels to rejoin Borussia Dortmund from Bayern for £34m
Oil Surges as Trump Says Iran Made Big Mistake Shooting Down US DroneOil Surges as Trump Says Iran Made 'Big Mistake' Shooting Down US Drone
Trump says Iran made a very big mistake after drone downingTrump says 'Iran made a very big mistake' after drone downing
NASA boss says no doubt SpaceX explosion delays flight programNASA boss says 'no doubt' SpaceX explosion delays flight program
Iran claims to have shot down US spy droneIran claims to have shot down US spy drone
Trump jokes to Putin they should get rid of journalistsTrump jokes to Putin they should 'get rid' of journalists
News Trends
Modern Family star Sarah Hyland and Bachelorette contestant Wells Adams are engaged'Modern Family' star Sarah Hyland and 'Bachelorette' contestant Wells Adams are engaged
Elon Musks Neuralink hopes to put sensors in human brains next yearElon Musk's Neuralink hopes to put sensors in human brains next year
EU opens Amazon antitrust investigationEU opens Amazon antitrust investigation
Love Island: Michaels Behaviour Towards Amber Sparks Ofcom ComplaintsLove Island: Michael's Behaviour Towards Amber Sparks Ofcom Complaints
Kris Kobach: I Might Still Support Trump if He Came Out and Said ‘I’m a Racist’Kris Kobach: I Might Still Support Trump if He Came Out and Said ‘I’m a Racist’
Shailene Woodley May Have Revealed The ‘Big Little Lies’ Season 2 EndingShailene Woodley May Have Revealed The ‘Big Little Lies’ Season 2 Ending
Review: The Lion King gives us more of a miaow than a roarReview: 'The Lion King' gives us more of a miaow than a roar
The Squad revives feud with Pelosi: Be aware when you single us out that were women of color'The Squad' revives feud with Pelosi: Be aware when you 'single us out' that we're 'women of color'
Feds confirm ‘Ice Bae’ is a CBP officer, is free to use social mediaFeds confirm ‘Ice Bae’ is a CBP officer, is free to use social media
Is The Big One next? California was shaking again Tuesday, with six earthquakes of 3.5 or greaterIs 'The Big One' next? California was shaking again Tuesday, with six earthquakes of 3.5 or greater
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
White House confirms Trump, Putin discussed summit
Winnie Mandela, anti-apartheid activist, dies aged 81
ESPN makes a bid for morning TV ratings glory with 'Get Up!'
SpaceX Cargo Mission Launches to the Space Station Today
Snapchat is mocking Facebook and its Russian political ads controversy with a new April Fools' Day filter
North Korea’s Kim Jong Un attends South Korean pop stars’ show in Pyongyang
China retaliates against Trump tariffs by targeting US food imports
Turkey President calls Israel's Netanyahu 'leader of a TERRORIST state' in VICIOUS attack
Same-sex marriage supporter easily wins Costa Rica elections
Chinese space lab falls to Earth over Pacific Ocean
As the White House releases a photo of its interns, the internet asks: Why so few people of colour?
Melania Trump runs White House from 'behind the scenes,' new book claims
Trump: 'NO MORE DACA DEAL'
Queen Elizabeth II, royal family attend Easter service
Pope celebrates Easter Mass in St. Peter's Square before tens of thousands
Stephen Colbert Takes On Mark Zuckerberg, Proposes a Revamped Facebook
Former England captain Ray Wilkins in critical condition
Stephen Hawking's Funeral Brings Out Hundreds To English Streets
OnePlus 6 definitely will include THIS crucial feature, company confirms
Two dead after home-built plane crashes in California
College student who had distressing behavior, rifles will be deported for visa violation
Foreign Office considers Russian consular access to Yulia Skripal
AI could threaten democracy: Macron issues warning
Meghan Markle and Prince Harry's wedding reported to cost a grand $45 million
UN calls for inquiry after Gaza's most violent day in 4 years
Trump continues attacks on Amazon and Washington Post
Baton Rouge officer fired, another suspended in 2016 fatal shooting of Alton Sterling
Putin hits back at Britain in SHOCK move: Russia orders 50 MORE UK diplomats to 'GO HOME'
Stephen Hawking funeral LIVE: Eddie Redmayne leads the great and the good to pay tribute
Turkish president recites Muslim prayer at the Hagia Sophia
5 awesome new iPhone features in iOS 11.3 that no one is talking about
Notre Dame beats UConn, will face Mississippi State in NCAA Women's Championship
Whose idea was it? Who took the sandpaper? The questions David Warner didn't answer
14.7 million visitors to U.S. could face social media screening
Russia complains about alleged search of airplane in London
Google Ending URL Shortener Support In Favor Of Dynamic Links
James Corden's "News Team" Is Determined to Figure Out #WhoBitBeyonce
Jimmy Carter Rips Trump: Apparently, America Wants A Jerk For President
Noor Salman, wife of Orlando Pulse shooter, found not guilty
HUGE fire in Manchester city centre as black smoke fills the sky
Confused Stephen Colbert on Trump's Ohio Rally: ''Roseanne' Is About the Trumps?'
Russia releases 'Satan 2' missile test footage
India sends notice to Facebook and Cambridge Analytica over the alleged data breach
At least 6 dead, 500 hurt after clashes along Israel-Gaza border
Russia Ramps up Diplomatic Clash, Expels More UK Diplomats
Cameron Diaz says she's 'actually retired'
Howard University students demand answers in financial aid scandal
Cardi B Drops New Track 'Be Careful'
Fox News: ads pulled from Laura Ingraham show for mocking Parkland survivor
Tokyo hit by 5.3 magnitude EARTHQUAKE as ‘BUILDINGS SHAKE’ in Japan capital
TRAGEDY as 21 people DIE in blazing bus INFERNO in Thailand
SpaceX gets FCC approval to offer broadband internet service with satellites
India limits visits to Taj Mahal to 3 hours per person
Daughter of Russian ex-spy who was poisoned no longer in critical condition
5.8 magnitude earthquake ROCKS Solomon Islands - Pacific Ring of Fire on alert
Netflix 'Acquires' Seth Rogen in Comedy Special Stunt
Russia expels US diplomats and shuts consulate in tit-for-tat move
Opening Day: Everything you need to know to start baseball season
Cheating-spouse website Ashley Madison has its affairs in order after notorious data breach
Abdel Fattah el-Sisi heading for landslide 90% victory in Egypt election
Facebook to stop allowing data brokers such as Experian to target users
Elon Musk says Mars colony a hedge against World War III
Trump slams Amazon for 'putting many thousands of retailers out of business'
'Enough is enough', say marchers at Paris rally for murdered Holocaust survivor
Vital Boeing computer network INFECTED with WannaCry VIRUS - is it safe to fly?
EU parents warned children need papers to stay in UK after Brexit
Malala Yousafzai in Pakistan for 1st time since she was shot
China warns U.S. not to open Pandora's Box, unleash trade ills on world
Scores killed in Venezuela prison fire
North and South Korean leaders to meet April 27 for first time in decade
France honors hero cop who died saving hostage in terror attack
Al Qaeda leader killed by drone strike in Libya identified by Pentagon
Julian Assange's Internet cut off over controversial social media activity
Trevor Noah Calls Out Heineken With Mock Campaign
Surprise meetings and potential pitfalls. Trump preps for North Korea
Ireland announces date for abortion referendum
R. Kelly Trained 14-Year-Old Girl As Sex ‘Pet,’ Ex-Girlfriend Says
Tommy Robinson banned from Twitter
Trump says Second Amendment ‘will never be repealed’
NASA Delays James Webb Space Telescope Again to May 2020
CNN's Anderson Cooper to interview James Comey in town hall
Trump claims Chinese President told him Kim meeting went 'very well'
IPL 2018: Steve Smith and David Warner OUT of competition for ball-tampering in HUGE blow
John Worboys to stay in prison: Parole Board boss Nick Hardwick 'forced to resign' as taxi rapist's release blocked
Putin to stand down? Russian citizens take to Moscow streets 'BEGGING' for Putin to RESIGN
Saudi crown prince and UN leader meet to talk about Yemen
Islamic State haunts northern Iraq months after its defeat
Stephon Clark killing gets independent investigation as protests mount
Playboy: We're quitting Facebook over data scandal
Kim met with Xi in Beijing
Trump is privately pressing for the military — not Mexico — to pay for his border wall
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu ill in hospital
Boris Johnson apologises for 'sexist' reference to Emily Thornberry
Mitt Romney says he is more conservative on immigration than Trump
Heineken pulls ad after racism claims
Nikki Haley berates colleagues over Syria: 'This should be a day of shame'
Alton Sterling shooting: two police officers will not be charged with any crime
Op-Ed Contributor: John Paul Stevens: Repeal the Second Amendment
Manchester Arena bombing: fire service arrived two hours late, says report
Elon Musk's father has baby with step-daughter he has known since she was four
California to sue Trump admin over citizenship question in 2020 census
A NASA Astronaut Stays In Orbit With SpaceX And Boeing
Cambridge Analytica whistleblower says his predecessor was allegedly poisoned and police bribed
Nickelodeon Parts Ways With Producer Dan Schneider
Putin lays red roses at venue of deadly mall blaze in Kemerovo that killed 64
California man who believes Earth is flat propels himself 600 metres in self-built rocket
The Latest: Convoy seen in Beijing arriving at train station
Stephen Colbert Says Stormy Daniels '60 Minutes' Interview 'Felt Truer' Than Trump's Election
Russia warns of retaliation after 100 diplomats expelled
Jewish leaders tell Jeremy Corbyn ‘enough is enough’ in anti-semitism row
Facebook's privacy practices are under investigation, FTC confirms
Netanyahu, wife, son questioned by police in corruption case
Trump expelling 60 Russian diplomats in wake of UK nerve agent attack
Mystery train carries rumors about a Kim Jong Un visit to China
Far Cry 5 review – cults, chaos and all-American silliness
Air Canada Flight 7618 Makes Emergency Landing After Smoke Found In Cockpit
Protests break out after Catalonia ex-leader is detained
Children among 64 dead in Russia shopping center fire
Jewish leaders accuse Jeremy Corbyn of 'siding with antisemites'
World War 3: Turkey's Erdogan calls for 'ARMY of Islam' to ATTACK Israel on all sides
The Latest: Polls open in Egypt's presidential election
Facebook denies it collects call and SMS data from phones without permission
Stormy Daniels interview adds to '60 Minutes' legacy of big hits
Saharan sandstorm turns Russia snow orange
Saudi Arabia intercepts 7 missiles fired from Yemen, military officials say
What you need to know ahead of Stormy Daniels' '60 Minutes' interview
Facebook logs texts and calls, users find as they delete accounts
Rome terror fears: Bomb alert hours after military launch terrorist manhunt in capital
SHOCK VIDEO: Horror moment police officer 'slashed with SWORD' in Manchester attack
Apple CEO Tim Cook Calls for 'Well-Crafted' Regulations on Data Privacy After Facebook Controversy
‘Black Panther’ Makes Box Office History!
Santorum: Instead of calling for gun laws, kids should take CPR classes
Day after March for Our Lives, Pope Francis uses Palm Sunday sermon to urge youths to lead
'Owen Smith jumped the gun!' Peston BLASTS Labour over 'inevitable' second referendum move
Kim Kardashian suffers photoshop faux pas as she attends March for Our Lives protest
BREAKING: Four children dead and 10 injured as huge blaze rips through shopping centre
'Bordering on BANDITRY' Putin attacks UK as tensions SOAR over Russian spy poisoning
Chinese Space Station's Crash to Earth: Everything You Need to Know
Catalonia's ex-leader Carles Puigdemont detained in Germany, lawyer says
I downloaded 14 years of my data on Facebook. Here's what I found
For Stoneman Douglas Alums, Witnessing Tragedy From Afar Sprung Them Into Action
BREAKING: Five men arrested on Thomas Cook flight from Manchester to Las Vegas
BREAKING: South Korea ferry crash - 192 stranded after ship CRASHES into rocks
Obama's message to marchers: 'You're leading us forward'
What Melania now has in common with Hillary
Australian GP: Sebastian Vettel repeats 2017 victory in season-opener
March for Our Lives: Martin Luther King Jr.'s granddaughter has dream 'enough is enough'
Lights go dark for Earth Hour to focus on climate change
White House 'applauds' historic gun control march but no word from Trump
Boat Race 2018 LIVE: Oxford v Cambridge - live updates
Kim Kardashian West fan had $500,000 surgery to resemble her
In pictures: The March for Our Lives protests
March for Our Lives: hundreds of thousands demand end to gun violence
Cameron Bancroft ball-tampering claims mar South Africa v Australia
Paris Jackson reportedly dating super-model Cara Delevingne
New Tavis Smiley witnesses detail sexual misconduct
What Do You Do With $184 Billion? Here's What Elon Musk Is Likely to Do With It
Investigators search Cambridge Analytica's London offices
Car bomb EXPLODES - one dead and three wounded as Alexandria rocked by blast
Game Day: Patrick Corbin, Diamondbacks take on Indians in Goodyear
March for our Lives protests planned for 800 places across the world
Vettel quickest in final Australian GP practice
First non-stop flight between Australia and UK set for take-off
Violent protests break out in Barcelona - riot police on scene
2 Americans, 1 Russian dock with International Space Station
140 whales die on Australian beach
Trump bars most transgender people from military
French officer who offered himself for hostage in supermarket attack dies
A timeline of DACA offers Trump has rejected
NFL star Michael Bennett indicted over injury to paraplegic woman at Super Bowl 51
Trump signs budget deal after raising government shutdown threat
Watch Will Smith and Jimmy Fallon Perform the History of Sitcom Themes
Serena Williams Posts Inspiring Message After Defeat At Miami Open
Jimmy Carter briefed by White House on North Korea
Hostage-taker killed at supermarket, two victims
Elon Musk DELETES SpaceX and Tesla Facebook pages after Twitter challenge
Ibrahimovic leaves Manchester United to sign with LA Galaxy
Putin thanks voters for 'greatest support in modern Russia’s history'
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle in Northern Ireland: Couple's rapturous welcome on unannounced visit
Russian foreign minister: ‘UK stance on Skripal is pushing us to brink of WAR’
5 facts about John Bolton, Trump's new national security adviser
One killed in French supermarket hostage-taking
At least 13 dead and 27 injured as MASSIVE FIRE rips through Vietnam city
Karen McDougal to Melania: I'm sorry for sleeping with Donald Trump
Pakistan celebrates National Day with military parade
Ex-Playboy model says she kept journal of days she met with Trump
Trump replaces H.R. McMaster as national security adviser with John Bolton
Protesters block NBA arena over fatal Sacramento police shooting
Mysterious tiny skeleton found in Chile was human girl with rare genetic mutations, scientists say
PARIS ERUPTS: Furious scenes on streets of France as THOUSANDS rally against Macron
UK passport humiliation: French DEMAND passports are printed in France – UK capitulates
Russia blasts Boris Johnson's Putin-Hitler comparison as insulting, 'totally irresponsible'
James Corden Stole a Candle From Mariah Carey's House Before Filming 'Carpool Karaoke'
Trump Administration Appointee Worked At Cambridge Analytica
Dalai Lama cuts foreign travel due to age, exhaustion
Toys 'R' Us founder Charles Lazarus dies
Donald Trump's top Russia lawyer John Dowd resigns
Giants trading Jason Pierre-Paul to Buccaneers
World Water Day: Deadly plight of Brazil's river defenders goes unheard
Trump attacks Joe Biden amid reports of 2020 presidential run
Close