January 30, 2020
January 28, 2020, is a date that will be remembered in Middle Eastern history – but it will take some time before anyone knows for sure how it will be remembered.The day didn’t start well for Benjamin Netanyahu. Israel’s longest-serving prime minister also became the country’s first prime minister to be indicted while still in office. He faces multiple charges of corruption.But Netanyahu didn’t have much time to sulk. Just a few hours later, he was standing alongside Donald Trump as the pair unveiled the U.S. administration’s long-anticipated plan for Israeli-Palestinian peace, written in no small part in coordination with – and deeply in tune with – Netanyahu’s policies.The fact that the plan’s unveiling came as both men face intense domestic scrutiny – the press conference interrupted coverage of Trump’s impeachment – should not be overlooked.I have been following developments in the Middle East for a long time as a U.S. State Department official, a lifelong student and now a professor of Israeli history, and as a dual citizen of the U.S. and Israel. I know how complex the issues are and how past attempts at peace have fallen well short.
Has Trump proposed a Middle East peace plan – or terms of surrender for the Palestinians?
In black and white …Trump’s plan comprises two different goals.The first – fostering Israeli-Palestinian peace, or at least coexistence – is there in black and white for all to read.The second – tying Trump and Netanyahu’s respective domestic critics into knots – is everywhere between the lines.While the Trump administration worked on the plan in coordination with Israel and “friendly” Arab states like Egypt and Saudi Arabia, it crucially did not involve the Palestinians. Palestinian resistance to the very development of this plan – out of suspicion, weakness and resentment – was met not with a carrot but a stick, with the U.S. cutting all aid to Gaza and the West Bank in February 2019.As a result, positions in the plan that might have been viewed as difficult compromises, had they been negotiated, are instead rightly seen as terms of surrender. Yes, the plan gives Palestinians a path to limited statehood, but only after ceding on the core issues of Israeli settlements, refugees and control of much of Jerusalem.The plan was successfully kept behind the curtains while being drafted, but it now steps out onto a complicated stage. Relations between Israel and the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank have for some years been in utter political stalemate, even as the two have maintained working-level security cooperation. In Hamas-run Gaza, Israel has been in a long war of attrition, mixing ongoing less-than-total violence with tacit mutual understandings aimed at managing the conflict.Meanwhile, Israel’s ties with several Sunni Arab states, especially in the Gulf, have been deepening, united by a desire to ward off Iran and its Shia proxies in Lebanon and what remains of Syria. Jordan, structurally weak but strategically important due to its location and links to Arab and Islamic actors, balances contending forces with skill and jitters.Internal Palestinian politics are riven by the bitter rivalry between the nationalist Palestinian Authority and the Islamist group Hamas and by discontent with the Palestinian Authority’s President Mahmoud Abbas’ hold on power amid claims of corruption and mismanagement in the Palestinian semi-government.Israeli politics is stalemated, too, and headed for its third round of parliamentary elections in less than a year, spurred by fallout from Netanyahu’s corruption scandals and a fragmented opposition.Many Israelis are alienated by Netanyahu’s endless legal troubles and divisive politics, but others are kindled by his attacks on political opponents. Meanwhile the Israeli left has failed to recover the credibility it lost on security issues following the collapse of 2000’s Camp David talks and the ensuing Second Intifada. As for Trump, he remains popular in Israel – including among centrists, who don’t necessarily follow day-to-day U.S. politics and look unfavorably on former President Barack Obama’s handling of the Middle East.At home, Trump’s policies on Israel do not reflect that of the majority of American Jews, who tend to be politically liberal and supportive of a mutually negotiated two-state solution. Rather, Trump’s views chime with that of the smaller but more fervent American Jewish right, and above all with the millions of evangelicals who are a key plank of the president’s base.Into all this drops the 180-page peace plan – whose heart is creating a legally recognized but geographically tiny and fragmented Palestinian state without full military powers – something that falls way short of Palestinian aspirations. Some parts of the plan are not unreasonable, and the many failed attempts at peacemaking to date call for fresh thinking. But the problems in this plan are very real.It stakes out strong positions on the three hard issues that have bedeviled negotiations time and again: Israeli settlements, the status of Jerusalem and the right of return for Palestinian refugees.The Trump plan leaves all Israeli settlements in place and proposes a networks of roads and tunnels to help Palestinian move around the cantons that would make up their state. It also freezes Jerusalem’s status quo and makes permanent Israel’s security barrier between the city’s east and west. As for the Palestinians who fled or were forced out of their homes in the 1948 war and their descendants, the plan says they are to be financially compensated. A few will be absorbed into Israel, but most will be integrated into either the envisioned Palestinian state or their current country of residence – which includes the Arab states that have refused to absorb them to date.These stances will be politically helpful to Netanyahu and congenial to many Israelis, who want to end the country’s occupation of the Palestinians, if their own personal security can be assured.To the Palestinians, they represent bitter pills, each of which would be hard enough to swallow on its own.Reaction to the plan has led to talk of a possible reconciliation between the Palestinian Authority and Hamas, something Israel has been trying to avoid – and put security forces on alert for further violence.Another problem is in the thinking that is evident in the plan’s title, “Peace to Prosperity.” Blueprints for economic development are woven throughout. The ideas are laudable. But the notion that the most fervently committed Jews and Arabs will trade away their deepest convictions for financial gain is as unlikely to take hold now as it did in the Oslo Accords of the 1990s. … and red lines all overSo what happens now?Netanyahu has announced he will begin to annex territory, in a move his main political challenger, former Army Chief of Staff Benny Gantz, described as “reckless and irresponsible,” even as he says he accepts the plan’s broad outlines for an eventual settlement. The Palestinians for their part have rejected the proposals and taken to the streets in protest.The plan raises some serious, immediate questions: How much unilateral action will Netanyahu take without paying a domestic price – especially with Israelis returning to the polls in March? And what responses are open to the Palestinians, other than the tried-and-failed turns to violence and appeals to the U.N. – neither of which will move Israeli public opinion in their direction? Above all, the questions we should be asking are: What does this or any plan do concretely to improve the lives of people in the region? What practical steps could be taken to make viable coexistence – peace is too strong a word – further down the line possible or at least avert new violence triggered by thwarted expectations? There is no easy solution to the bitter Israel-Palestinian conflict. Unilateral annexation by Israel will only further Palestinian resentment and rejectionism. Too many people, in Washington as well as the Middle East, view the conflict in terms of ideological dreams and agendas, paying little heed to the real needs of people on the ground, Israeli and Palestinian alike. Should this plan become, like so many of its predecessors, a political football on both sides of the ocean, the people who make their homes and live their lives on politicians’ playing fields will lose. [ Insight, in your inbox each day. You can get it with The Conversation’s email newsletter. ]This article is republished from The Conversation, a nonprofit news site dedicated to sharing ideas from academic experts.Read more: * Limiting Senate inquiry ignores Founders’ intent for impeachment * The impact of Brexit on relations between the UK and Gulf countriesYehudah Mirsky does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organization that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.
Related Stories
Latest News
Top news around the world
Coronavirus Disease

Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) is an infectious disease caused by a newly discovered coronavirus.

Most people infected with the COVID-19 virus will experience mild to moderate respiratory illness and recover without requiring special treatment. Older people, and those with underlying medical problems like cardiovascular disease, diabetes, chronic respiratory disease, and cancer are more likely to develop serious illness.

Around the World

Celebrity News

> Latest News in Media

Watch It
"Cheer" Star Jerry Harris Arrested for Child Pornography
September 17, 2020
bVnmbrwqmTE
Vanessa Hudgens Celebrates Ashley Tisdale's Pregnancy | E! News
September 17, 2020
WPQFWYio1Ao
Rihanna's 2020 Savage x Fenty Show: 5 Things to Know | E! News
September 17, 2020
j_tcq1vpIHk
‘Cheer’ star Jerry Harris arrested, charged with producing child pornography | Page Six News
September 17, 2020
_iyfMFiyFqs
Before Chris Evans’ penis pic leaked, there was Usher’s steam room nude | Page Six Celebrity News
September 17, 2020
6QeTxPkPl0I
'Botched' doctor reveals which procedure is popular after coronavirus | Page Six Celebrity News
September 17, 2020
1xX0wGo3n5I
Television Humanitarian Awards Virtual Gala - The Creative Coalition
September 17, 2020
wSGcqa7Jvus
How the 'Antebellum' Team Used Horror to Present Racial Injustice
September 17, 2020
c0zWheU3sIU
'Ratched' Star Cynthia Nixon on Queer Couple Representation, Her Thoughts on J.K. Rowling
September 17, 2020
8yjq_Ohi94c
What's In Jimmy Fallon's Briefcase? | TMZ TV
September 17, 2020
_qQfHmucGpk
Tarek El Moussa Down to Do New Show with Fiancee Heather Ray Young | TMZ
September 17, 2020
ONCWYDeQKZs
Kamala Harris' SWAG Is On Point | TMZ TV
September 17, 2020
RpetEGovyxM
TV Schedule
Late Night Show
Watch the latest shows of U.S. top comedians

Sports

Latest sport results, news, videos, interviews and comments
Latest Events
17
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Second qualifying round
Shamrock - AC Milan
17
Sep
MEXICO: Liga de Ascenso, Apertura
Tampico Madero - Morelia
17
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Second qualifying round
Honved - Malmo FF
17
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Second qualifying round
Servette - Reims
17
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Second qualifying round
DAC - Jablonec
17
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Second qualifying round
Mura - AGF Aarhus
17
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Second qualifying round
Sileks - Drita FC
17
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Second qualifying round
Piast Gliwice - Hartberg
17
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Second qualifying round
Sfintul Gheorghe - Partizan
17
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Second qualifying round
Djurgarden - Europa FC
17
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Second qualifying round
CSKA Sofia - BATE
17
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Second qualifying round
Goteborg - FC Kobenhavn
17
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Second qualifying round
Bodo-Glimt - Zalgiris
17
Sep
BRASIL: National Cup
Botafogo - Vasco
17
Sep
ENGLAND: League Cup
Brighton - Portsmouth
17
Sep
COPA LIBERTADORES: Group D
Sao Paulo - River Plate
17
Sep
SWEDEN: Allsvenskan
Falkenberg - Varberg
17
Sep
SWEDEN: Allsvenskan
Elfsborg - Mjallby
17
Sep
ENGLAND: League Cup
Wolves - Stoke City
17
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Second qualifying round
Backa Topola - Steaua
17
Sep
PERU: Primera Division, Apertura
Univ. Cesar Vallejo - Sport Boys
17
Sep
FRANCE: Ligue 1
Marseille - Saint-Etienne
17
Sep
BRASIL: National Cup
Juventude - CRB Maceio
17
Sep
ENGLAND: League Cup
Burnley - Sheffield United
17
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Second qualifying round
OFI - Apollon Limassol
17
Sep
ASIAN CHAMPIONS LEAGUE: Group Stage
Pakhtakor - Al Hilal Riyadh
17
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Second qualifying round
KuPS - Slovan
17
Sep
ASIAN CHAMPIONS LEAGUE: Group Stage
Padideh Khorasan - Al Shabab Al Ahli
17
Sep
ASIAN CHAMPIONS LEAGUE: Group Stage
Al-Shorta - Al Ahli Jeddah
17
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Second qualifying round
FC Botosani - Shkendija
17
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Second qualifying round
Teuta - Granada CF
16
Sep
FRANCE: Ligue 1
PSG - Metz
16
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Barcelona - Girona
15
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Inter Milan - Lugano
14
Sep
ENGLAND: Premier League
Brighton - Chelsea
14
Sep
GERMANY: National cup
Duisburg - Borussia Dortmund
13
Sep
ENGLAND: Premier League
Tottenham Hotspur - Everton
13
Sep
FRANCE: Ligue 1
PSG - Marseille
13
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Juventus - Novara
12
Sep
ENGLAND: Premier League
Liverpool - Leeds
12
Sep
ENGLAND: Premier League
Fulham - Arsenal
10
Sep
FRANCE: Ligue 1
Lens - PSG
09
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Frosinone - Roma
09
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
AC Milan - Vicenza
07
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Borussia Dortmund - Sparta Rotterdam
06
Sep
UEFA NATIONS LEAGUE A: Group Stage
Switzerland - Germany
05
Sep
UEFA NATIONS LEAGUE A: Group Stage
Sweden - France
05
Sep
UEFA NATIONS LEAGUE A: Group Stage
Iceland - England
05
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
AC Milan - Monza
05
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Roma - Sambenedettese
05
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Watford - Tottenham Hotspur
03
Sep
UEFA NATIONS LEAGUE A: Group Stage
Germany - Spain
02
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
AC Milan - Novara
29
Aug
ENGLAND: FA Community Shield
Arsenal - Liverpool
29
Aug
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Brighton - Chelsea
29
Aug
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Tottenham Hotspur - Birmingham
28
Aug
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Tottenham Hotspur - Reading
28
Aug
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Borussia Dortmund - Bochum
28
Aug
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Borussia Dortmund - Paderborn
25
Aug
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Milton Keynes Dons - Arsenal
Find us on Instagram
at @feedimo to stay up to date with the latest.
Featured Video You Might Like
i1XRgbyUtOo -g9Qziqbif8 0vmRhiLHE2U JFCZUoa6MYE UfN5PCF5EUo 2PV55f3-UAg W3y9zuI_F64 -7qCxIccihU pQ9gcOoH9R8 g5MRDEXRk4k tudKp5Vhs3k iwWHibhssSo
Copyright © 2020 Feedimo. All Rights Reserved.