Close
Date TimeJune 19, 2019
VoiceThe House waded into the decades-old debate over reparations for African-Americans on Wednesday, convening its first hearing on legislation introduced 30 years ago that would create a commission to develop proposals to address the lingering effects of slavery and consider a “national apology” for the harm it has caused.

Hundreds of spectators, mostly black, were on hand for the historic hearing by a House Judiciary subcommittee, whose witnesses included Senator Cory Booker, the New Jersey Democrat and presidential candidate, the actor Danny Glover and the writer Ta-Nehisi Coates, who took direct aim at Mitch McConnell, the Senate majority leader, for remarks he made Tuesday opposing the idea.
The room grew raucous at times, with spectators hissing at Republican witnesses and Representative Mike Johnson of Louisiana, the subcommittee’s senior Republican, when he spoke against the measure. In a comment that rippled throughout the hearing, Mr. Johnson suggested that great black leaders like Frederick Douglass and Booker T. Washington thought African-Americans should pull themselves up by their bootstraps.
“Those great leaders encouraged people to take responsibility for their own lives, because that gives every human being a greater sense of meaning and satisfaction,” he said, adding that the bill “risks communicating the opposite message.”
That the hearing was held at all was a reflection of how the debate over reparations has been rejoined. Nearly 60 House Democrats, including Speaker Nancy Pelosi, support the bill. And at least 11 Democratic presidential candidates — with former Vice President Joseph R. Biden Jr. a notable exception — have embraced either the concept of reparations or the bill to study it.
They include Mr. Booker, who is sponsoring a companion bill in the Senate and made an impassioned plea for it on Wednesday, calling the legacy of slavery, especially the mass incarceration of African-Americans, “a cancer on the soul of this country.”
But the real star was Mr. Coates, whose 2014 article “The Case for Reparations” in The Atlantic rekindled the debate, arguing that African-Americans had been exploited by nearly every American institution. Mr. Coates called out Mr. McConnell several times by name, citing the senator’s comment that he does not favor reparations “for something that happened 150 years ago, for whom none of us currently living are responsible.”
Mr. Coates responded by ticking off a list of government-sponsored discriminatory policies, including those in Mr. McConnell’s native Alabama, including redlining and poll taxes, that are the legacy of slavery.
“He was alive for the redlining of Chicago and the looting of black homeowners of some $4 billion,” Mr. Coates said. “Victims of their plunder are very much alive today. I am sure they would love a word with the majority leader.”
“While emancipation deadbolted the door against the bandits of America, Jim Crow wedged the windows wide open,” he added. “That’s the thing about Senator McConnell’s ‘something.’ It was 150 years ago. It was right now.”
The hearing itself was laden with symbolism. This year marks the 400th anniversary of the first documented arrival of Africans to the port of Jamestown in what was then the colony of Virginia. Wednesday, June 19, is Juneteenth, the holiday that celebrates the end of slavery in the United States. And the bill carries the designation H.R. 40, a reference to the first proposal for reparations: the unfulfilled “40 acres and a mule” promise to freed slaves after the Civil War.
The House bill, titled the “Commission to Study and Develop Reparation Proposals for African-Americans Act,” would authorize $12 million for a 13-member commission — three members appointed by the president, three by the House, one by the Senate and six from organizations that have championed racial justice. The panel would study the effects of slavery and racial discrimination, hold hearings across the country and recommend “appropriate remedies” to Congress.
Wednesday’s session does not guarantee that the bill will be taken up by the full committee or get a vote on the House floor. A Democratic aide characterized it as an educational opportunity and chance to enhance the national dialogue around reparations. And even if the bill passed the House, it has virtually no chance of securing Senate passage or President Trump’s signature.
But both witnesses and advocates of the bill, including Representative Jerrold Nadler of New York, the chairman of the Judiciary Committee, said it was important to at least have a conversation about reparations.
“The discussion of reparations is a journey in which the road traveled may be almost as important as the destination,” Mr. Nadler said.

Memphis Grizzlies star Mike Conley traded to Utah Jazz
Mars has a brand new crater, and it sure is pretty
Khloe, Kourtney, Kim and Kylie React to Jordyn-Tristan Scandal: 'I Need the F--king Whole Truth!'
Tommy Lee praises wife Brittany Furlan's '100% natural body' on Instagram: See the bikini pic
Mats Hummels to rejoin Borussia Dortmund from Bayern for £34m
'Little Women: Atlanta' Star Ashley 'Minnie' Ross Busted for DUI
Hope Hicks arrives for closed-door interview with House panel
Joy Harjo Becomes The First Native American U.S. Poet Laureate
Bella Thorne Slams Whoopi Goldberg Over 'Sick' Response To Nude Photos Hack
NASA reveals details of plans to put astronauts on the Moon by 2024
Trump launches re-election bid before jam-packed arena, vows to 'Keep America Great'
Ashley Benson & Cara Delevingne Are Dating!
Lauren Bushnell Is Engaged! All the Details on Her $80,000 Diamond Ring From Chris Lane
Max Landis Accused of Sexual and Psychological Abuse by 8 Women
U.S. defeat Guyana 4-0 in Gold Cup opener
Oxford University accepts £150m from US private equity boss
Calls for 195-year-old Vagrancy Act to be scrapped
NASA boss says 'no doubt' SpaceX explosion delays flight program
Tesla Model 3 goal not met, leaked documents suggest
Here's the tech behind Facebook's Libra cryptocurrency
Bella Hadid apologises for 'offensive' photo
‘YOU’RE DISGUSTING’: Kelly Ripa’s daughter walks in on her, husband having sex
Japan earthquake: Tsunamis expected 'imminently' in three coastal regions
Trump says Shanahan out of confirmation process to be defense secretary
Mohamed Morsy, ousted Egyptian president, dies in court
Gary Woodland has more than the US Open to celebrate
All The Celebrity Cameos In Taylor Swift's You Need To Calm Down Music Video
Gloria Vanderbilt: farewell fashion's innovative heiress
Harvard rescinds offer to Kyle Kashuv, pro-Second Amendment Parkland survivor, due to past remarks, he says
Lee Bowyer set to leave Charlton after failing to reach contract agreement
Taylor Swift Just Revealed All The Celebrities Who Will Appear In Her Upcoming Video
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle Share Touching New Image of Baby Archie
Bella Thorne's Ex Mod Sun Breaks Down the Passport Situation
Carli Lloyd scores double as USA sweep Chile aside to advance to last 16
Anti-LGBT protests have reawakened painful memories
Father's Day Fast Facts
Taylor Swift gives surprise Pride Month performance at Stonewall Inn, a historic LGBT site in New York
Trump says he was briefed on Navy sightings of UFOs
Jennifer Aniston on 'silver fox' co-star
OJ Simpson Has Joined Twitter
Romeo And Juliet Director Franco Zeffirelli Dies Aged 96
Man Utd eyeing shock swap deal for West Ham star Issa Diop: £45m plus player offer ready
Netflix’s Murder Mystery: Adam Sandler and Jennifer Aniston are a lot of fun
Kourtney Kardashian Says Kylie Jenner Has 'Entitlement' Issues
You're hired! Lord Sugar backs Boris Johnson despite Brexit jail demand
Washington Capitals trade Matt Niskanen to Philadelphia Flyers for Radko Gudas
Design leaks for Harriet Tubman $20 bill after Mnuchin announces delay
Happy Birthday Mr. President? Trump Turns 73, Gets Trolled on Twitter as #JohnMcCainDay Goes Viral
Trump Compares First Lady 'Melania T' to 'Jackie O'
Gulf of Oman tanker attacks: Everything you need to know
Jessica Biel not against vaccinations, just against bill
Amanda Knox's fiancé jokes latest Italy trip will be 'different'
Elizabeth Lederer, Prosecutor of Central Park Five, Resigns From Columbia Law
If you're trying to silence me through the Hatch Act, it's not going to work
First trailer for The Shining sequel Doctor Sleep nods to the original's most iconic moments
Donald Trump Boasts About Meeting The 'Prince Of Whales'
Jennifer Aniston says Ross and Rachel would still be together
Selena Gomez reveals what Bill Murray whispered to her during viral moment on Cannes Film Festival red carpet
Trump says he is sure Hong Kong, China will be able to work things out
Boris Johnson pledges new determination to leave EU by 31 October
Chris Froome out of Tour de France after suffering suspected broken leg
BBC defends Jo Brand after she says: 'Why bother with milkshake when you could get some battery acid?'
Khloe Kardashian apologizes to Tristan’s baby mama Jordan after cheating accusations
Jennifer Aniston Slays at Murder Mystery Premiere: All the Times She's Killed the Fashion Game
Lorraine Kelly And Esther McVey's Beef Steps Up Another Notch
The Frozen 2 Trailer Is Here And Things Don't Look Any Easier For Elsa
Jon Stewart lashes out at Congress over 9-11 victims fund
Animal Crossing Switch Delayed To March 2020
Bradley Cooper and Irina Shayk's Relationship 'Changed' After A Star Is Born, Says Source
Rihanna Gets Candid About Marriage, Kids and Boyfriend Hassan Jameel
Kim Kardashian Shares First Photo of Baby Psalm
Earthquake in Cleveland, Ohio: United States Geological Survey confirmed a 4.0 magnitude quake
Billy Porter wore a gender-fluid uterus suit to the Tony Awards
Pilot Dies in Helicopter Crash Atop Manhattan Office Tower
People's Vote Supporter Sam Gyimah Pulls Out Of Tory Leadership Race
‘Planet Zoo’ Brings The Most Realistic Animals in Games to PC on Nov. 5
Trump attacks John Dean ahead of his congressional testimony on the Mueller report
Justin Bieber challenges Tom Cruise to fight
Tony Parker says he's retiring from NBA after 18 seasons
E3 2019 liveblog: all the news from Ubisoft, Square Enix and the PC Gaming Show
Meghan Markle Trooping the Colour Photos ,Hidden Outfit Details
Maduro Reopens Venezuelan Border With Colombia
The Latest: Nadal beats Thiem for 12th French Open title
Jordan Pickford saves the day as England beat Switzerland on penalties
Trump Tweets About Moon, Mars, the Internet Scratches Its Head
Bradley Cooper and Irina Shayk tried to make it work for their daughter
Kim Kardashian Goes Braless While Getting Lunch With Khloe
Ferrari's Vettel: Still reasonable gap to Mercedes in Canadian GP
Justin Edinburgh, Leyton Orient manager, dies aged 49
Fourteen lions escape from Kruger park in South Africa
GSW owner's wife, Jay-Z chat led to threats
Bradley Cooper, Irina Shayk considering split?: 'It has nothing to do with Lady Gaga
Johanna Konta questions French Open organisers after semi-finals court switch
Granger Smith’s son died in drowning accident at home
Vans unveils Harry Potter sneaker collection
Rafael Nadal ousts Roger Federer in straight sets to reach French Open final
Yeezys: Thousands queue through night for Kanye West trainers
Sally Challen walks free as court rules out retrial for killing abusive husband
Jeff Bezos explains why he's trying to colonise the moon: 'We need to go to the moon to save the Earth'
NASA's Mars Helicopter Testing Enters Final Phase
Shakira appears before Spanish judge in tax fraud case
Sophie Turner slapped Conan O'Brien across the face while playing a drinking game on 'Conan': Watch
Amanda Anisimova shocks Halep to reach French Open semi-final
West Point Accident Kills Cadet and Injures 22 Others
Matthijs de Ligt transfer race down to TWO clubs after Man Utd make decision on defender
Google Stadia will reportedly get ‘Destiny 2’ and cross-platform saves
Ancient Siberia was home to previously unknown humans, say scientists
HBO’s ‘Chernobyl’ Is Now the Top-Ranked TV Show of All Time
Stephen Colbert Laughs at London Trolling Trump With Baby Blimp, Giant Lawn Penis
President Donald Trump attempts to explain his Meghan Markle 'nasty' comments
A first look at Amazon’s new delivery drone
CNN Poll: Rising share expect Trump to win in 2020
Pokemon Sword & Shield Nintendo Direct: Rewatch Stream, News Recap
Sheridan Smith: 'Dad would have been so proud'
Bette Midler likens tiff with Trump to WWII’s ‘Battle of the Bulge’
Abortion rights advocates criticize Biden over support for Hyde Amendment
Man Utd fans DEMAND Bruno Fernandes and Joao Felix signings - 'Would love them at United'
Black Mirror season five review: sweet, sadistic and hugely impressive
Cristiano Ronaldo rape allegation: lawsuit moved to federal court, says lawyer
Ex-Trump aide Hope Hicks agrees to give campaign documents to Congress
Kate Middleton attends Donald Trump state banquet in white lace dress
Roger Federer produces SUBLIME skill against Stan Wawrinka to send French Open crowd wild
Change UK loses six of its 11 MPs after dire EU elections result
Sturridge, Moreno to leave Liverpool this offseason
NASA captures stunning photo of the entire sky in X-ray
Miley Cyrus narrowly avoids man trying to force a kiss, grope her while she was with husband Liam Hemsworth
Kylie Jenner’s daughter Stormi hospitalized for allergic reaction
Apple accidentally reveals iPadOS ahead of WWDC keynote
Apple expected to close iTunes after 18 years
Paul Darrow, cult favourite in Blake's 7, dies aged 78
Donald Trump meets the Queen at start of UK state visit
Cricket World Cup: Buttler and Root tons in vain as Pakistan stun England
Corbyn accuses Trump of interfering in UK politics with Johnson comments
Marilyn Monroe Birth Anniversary: Interesting Facts About the Hollywood Icon
Jose Antonio Reyes dead at 35: Arsenal and Spain star killed in car accident
Serena Williams and top seed Osaka crash out of French Open
Liverpool win Champions League after Salah and Origi sink Tottenham
Eddie Hearn believes Deontay Wilder has already agreed to fight next
Andy Ruiz Jr springs historic upset of Anthony Joshua for unified heavyweight title
Miley Cyrus Drops Raunchy, Edgy Six-Track 'She Is Coming', First of Three Planned EPs This Year
Kim Kardashian Spends Day At San Quentin's Death Row to Visit Kevin Cooper
Arnav Gupta, Maryland man who set himself on fire near White House, has died
A historic win. The National Spelling Bee has not one, but 8 champions
Cardi B ditches clothes in ‘Press’ album art
Senior Labour Figure Pete Willsman Suspended For Alleging Anti-Semitism ‘Whipped Up’ By Israeli Embassy
The Real Reason Meghan and Harry Are Bringing Their Son to America
The New 'Death Stranding' Trailer Is Absolutely Wild, And Almost 9 Minutes Long
Moeen Ali: ICC Ranking, Career Info, Stats and Form Guide as on May 30
Young boy 'falls from rollercoaster' at Lightwater Valley theme park
'Out of sight': White House reportedly steers USS John McCain away from Trump
Jennifer Hudson Honors Aretha Franklin's Legacy at Pulitzer Prize Ceremony With 'Amazing Grace'
MacKenzie Bezos pledges at least half her wealth to charity
See exclusive first photos of Ansel Elgort and Nicole Kidman in Donna Tartt's 'The Goldfinch'
Britain's Got Talent hopefuls delight fans by bringing back Stavros Flatley
Game of Thrones star Kit Harington enters treatment for personal issues
Pokemon Go Snorlax is Now Sleeping
‘Game of Thrones': 5 things we learned from 'The Last Watch’ behind-the-scenes documentary
Housing minister Kit Malthouse enters race to be next UK PM
Inside the Warwick University rape chat scandal
Chernobyl: US President's FURIOUS reaction to nuclear disaster 'forced Soviets to change'
'The Bachelorette' recap: Hannah goes to the emergency room; Luke P. and Cam unravel
'Large and dangerous tornado' strikes near Dayton, Ohio
Miley Cyrus Says Her Black Mirror Episode Is ‘Outrageously Out There’
Aladdin casts box office spell
New Death Stranding Trailer Will Arrive Later This Week, Kojima Productions Confirms
Memorial Day: sweltering heat and storms follow tornadoes and flooding
Corbynism is now in crisis: the only way forward is to oppose Brexit | Paul Mason
European Elections 2019: Six Big Things To Look Out For
Kendall Jenner Soaks Up the Sun on Jet Skis With Luka Sabbat in Monaco
Natalie Portman calls Moby an 'older man being creepy,' denies relationship rumors
How yoga teacher Amanda Eller survived 17 days lost in a Hawaiian jungle
Sasha Obama stuns in fitted black gown for high school prom
Shami Chakrabarti warns police over Extinction Rebellion prosecutions
Auburn radio voice Rod Bramblett, wife Paula, die following car accident
Warriors open as massive NBA Finals favorites over Raptors in Las Vegas
Inside Kim Kardashian and Kanye West's Low-Key Anniversary Dinner
Federal judge blocks Trump from using Defense funds for parts of border wall
Naomi Wolf admits blunder over Victorians and sodomy executions
‘Aladdin’: Naomi Scott on Why Her Princess Jasmine Needed Nasim Pedrad’s New Character
Former Baylor coach Art Briles named head coach of Texas' Mount Vernon High School
'Delete Facebook now': WhatsApp co-founder gives a talk at Stanford
Feel no pity for Theresa May. She has been the worst prime minister in modern times | Owen Jones
Kylie Jenner Breaks Silence on Jordyn Woods Betrayal in Heartbreaking ‘KUWTK’ Clip
Kim Kardashian and Kanye West Celebrate 5-Year Wedding Anniversary
Elon Musk's SpaceX raises over $1 billion this year as internet satellite production ramps up
Boris Johnson Says UK Must Be Prepared To Leave EU With No-Deal In October
Adam Levine is leaving 'The Voice'
Call Of Duty 2019 is just called Modern Warfare claim rumours
Theresa May Announces Resignation, New Prime Minister Will Takeover In July
Trump erupts, blows up meeting, as Pelosi pursues impeachment lite
New Aladdin movie is (almost) everything you could wish for
Jessica Alba 'stopped eating a lot' when she became an actress to ward off unwanted attention
Judith Kerr, beloved author of The Tiger Who Came to Tea, dies aged 95
Turner 'Tfue' Tenney files lawsuit against FaZe Clan
Tornado in Jefferson City: Residents take to social media after powerful storm
House Judiciary subpoenas Hope Hicks and former McGahn aide
Joe Panik’s walk-off single lifts Giants to comeback before smallest home crowd of 2019
Indonesia election violence leaves six protesters dead and 200 injured as riots hit Jakarta
British Steel to enter insolvency after rescue talks with government fail
Manchester Arena attack: thousands to mark anniversary
Close