Close
Date TimeOctober 21, 2017
Voice
The five living former US presidents made a rare appearance together on stage on Saturday night at a fundraiser for those affected by recent hurricanes that struck Texas, Florida, Puerto Rico and the US Virgin Islands.
It was a show of unity and compassion after a week in which Barack Obama and George W Bush broke an unwritten rule to deliver implicit criticism of the present occupant of the White House.
While neither mentioned Donald Trump by name, Bush gave a speech in New York expressing concern that “bigotry seems emboldened” in a climate of cruel rhetoric and nativism, while Obama referred to the “politics of division” and “folks who are deliberately trying to make folks angry” at Democratic campaign stops in New Jersey and Virginia.
Politics was set aside for the sold-out concert at Texas A&M University’s Reed Arena, however, as Bush, Obama, Jimmy Carter, Bill Clinton and George HW Bush were given a rapturous welcome by the audience. Both Bushes live in Texas and the 41st president’s library and museum is on the A&M campus.
The event, Deep From The Heart: The One America Appeal, featured a host of country and gospel music stars. It was launched last month after Hurricane Harvey battered Texas and expanded when Hurricane Irma hit Florida and Hurricane Maria devastated parts of the Caribbean, together causing several hundred deaths and billions of dollars in damage.
Trump, whose response to relief efforts in Puerto Rico has come under fire, has frequently denigrated Obama and earlier this year baselessly claimed his predecessor in the Oval Office ordered Trump Tower to be wiretapped before the 2016 election. Last Monday he intimated Obama and other former presidents treated the families of dead military members with a lack of respect.
However, he recorded a two-minute video message for the appeal which was rather more collegial in tone. “Now, as we begin to rebuild, some of America’s finest public servants are spearheading the One America Appeal. Through this effort, all five living former presidents are playing a tremendous role in helping our fellow citizens recover,” he said.
“[First Lady] Melania and I want to express our deep gratitude for your tremendous assistance. This wonderful effort reminds us that we truly are one nation, under God, all unified by our values and our devotion to one another.”


Related Stories
Watch: Trump gives Rose Garden speech after vowing to declare national emergencyWatch: Trump gives Rose Garden speech after vowing to declare national emergency
Grammys 2019: Joy Villa dresses up in barbed wire and Donald Trump border wall dressGrammys 2019: Joy Villa dresses up in barbed wire and Donald Trump border wall dress
Cornered: Trump escalates shutdown crisisCornered: Trump escalates shutdown crisis
Ann Coulter Admits To Bill Maher: ‘OK, I’m Very Stupid Girl About Donald TrumpAnn Coulter Admits To Bill Maher: ‘OK, I’m Very Stupid Girl' About Donald Trump
SNL: Alec Baldwin returns to mock Trumps national emergency press conference'SNL': Alec Baldwin returns to mock Trump's national emergency press conference
Pelosi: No money for wall in U.S. border deal talksPelosi: No money for wall in U.S. border deal talks
Trumps State of the Union showed he represents the people, not the swampTrump's State of the Union showed he represents the people, not the swamp
Jeff Flake rules out 2020 primary challenge to TrumpJeff Flake rules out 2020 primary challenge to Trump
Whitaker squares off with Democrats at fiery hearingWhitaker squares off with Democrats at fiery hearing
Ellen Page Calls Out Trump And Pence Over Hate: This Needs To F**king Stop!Ellen Page Calls Out Trump And Pence Over Hate: This Needs To F**king Stop!
News Trends
Miley Cyrus Poses Topless and Parodies Shawn Mendes Calvin Klein CampaignMiley Cyrus Poses Topless and Parodies Shawn Mendes' Calvin Klein Campaign
Instagram wants you to look like a good person, but Facebook just wants your credit cardInstagram wants you to look like a good person, but Facebook just wants your credit card
Kylie Jenner: Get Rich or Die FollowingKylie Jenner: Get Rich or Die Following
Karl Lagerfeld, Chanel fashion designer, dies aged 85Karl Lagerfeld, Chanel fashion designer, dies aged 85
Bernie Sanders 2020: where the presidential candidate stands on key issues – video profileBernie Sanders 2020: where the presidential candidate stands on key issues – video profile
The Real Reason Prince William and Kate Middletons Breakup Made Them StrongerThe Real Reason Prince William and Kate Middleton's Breakup Made Them Stronger
Lara Logan Trending on Twitter After Recommending Reading Breitbart to Get The Other Side'Lara Logan' Trending on Twitter After Recommending Reading Breitbart to Get 'The Other Side'
Nigel Farage slams APPALLING Angela Smith race apology - Looks like a HOSTAGE VIDEO!Nigel Farage slams 'APPALLING' Angela Smith race apology - 'Looks like a HOSTAGE VIDEO!'
Malia Obama, 20, spotted sipping on a $20 bottle of Whispering Angel Rose with friends in MiamiMalia Obama, 20, spotted sipping on a $20 bottle of Whispering Angel Rose with friends in Miami
Maajid Nawaz, LBC presenter, hurt in racially motivated attackMaajid Nawaz, LBC presenter, hurt in 'racially motivated' attack
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
Watch: Trump gives Rose Garden speech after vowing to declare national emergencyWatch: Trump gives Rose Garden speech after vowing to declare national emergency
Grammys 2019: Joy Villa dresses up in barbed wire and Donald Trump border wall dressGrammys 2019: Joy Villa dresses up in barbed wire and Donald Trump border wall dress
Cornered: Trump escalates shutdown crisisCornered: Trump escalates shutdown crisis
Ann Coulter Admits To Bill Maher: ‘OK, I’m Very Stupid Girl About Donald TrumpAnn Coulter Admits To Bill Maher: ‘OK, I’m Very Stupid Girl' About Donald Trump
SNL: Alec Baldwin returns to mock Trumps national emergency press conference'SNL': Alec Baldwin returns to mock Trump's national emergency press conference
Pelosi: No money for wall in U.S. border deal talksPelosi: No money for wall in U.S. border deal talks
Trumps State of the Union showed he represents the people, not the swampTrump's State of the Union showed he represents the people, not the swamp
Jeff Flake rules out 2020 primary challenge to TrumpJeff Flake rules out 2020 primary challenge to Trump
Whitaker squares off with Democrats at fiery hearingWhitaker squares off with Democrats at fiery hearing
Ellen Page Calls Out Trump And Pence Over Hate: This Needs To F**king Stop!Ellen Page Calls Out Trump And Pence Over Hate: This Needs To F**king Stop!
News Trends
Miley Cyrus Poses Topless and Parodies Shawn Mendes Calvin Klein CampaignMiley Cyrus Poses Topless and Parodies Shawn Mendes' Calvin Klein Campaign
Instagram wants you to look like a good person, but Facebook just wants your credit cardInstagram wants you to look like a good person, but Facebook just wants your credit card
Kylie Jenner: Get Rich or Die FollowingKylie Jenner: Get Rich or Die Following
Karl Lagerfeld, Chanel fashion designer, dies aged 85Karl Lagerfeld, Chanel fashion designer, dies aged 85
Bernie Sanders 2020: where the presidential candidate stands on key issues – video profileBernie Sanders 2020: where the presidential candidate stands on key issues – video profile
The Real Reason Prince William and Kate Middletons Breakup Made Them StrongerThe Real Reason Prince William and Kate Middleton's Breakup Made Them Stronger
Lara Logan Trending on Twitter After Recommending Reading Breitbart to Get The Other Side'Lara Logan' Trending on Twitter After Recommending Reading Breitbart to Get 'The Other Side'
Nigel Farage slams APPALLING Angela Smith race apology - Looks like a HOSTAGE VIDEO!Nigel Farage slams 'APPALLING' Angela Smith race apology - 'Looks like a HOSTAGE VIDEO!'
Malia Obama, 20, spotted sipping on a $20 bottle of Whispering Angel Rose with friends in MiamiMalia Obama, 20, spotted sipping on a $20 bottle of Whispering Angel Rose with friends in Miami
Maajid Nawaz, LBC presenter, hurt in racially motivated attackMaajid Nawaz, LBC presenter, hurt in 'racially motivated' attack
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Trump says he will allow scheduled release of JFK files
Who wants Amazon’s HQ2 the most? Take a look at bids from other cities
Trump: 'End of the ISIS caliphate is in sight' - CNN
‘This is a coup!’ Catalonia chaos erupts with calls for independence NOW as Spain steps in
Bitcoin smashes through $6,100 to hit a new record high
Loved ones say good-bye to Sgt. La David Johnson, US soldier slain in Niger
EU to IMITATE Spain's brutal Catalan tactics in Brexit no-deal, warns former No 10 insider
IBM lags in cloud computing and AI. Can tech’s great survivor recover?
Razer made a webcam with a selfie light for streamers - The Verge
7 hilariously brutal cartoons about the GOP's last-chance health-care bill
Laptops could be banned from checked bags on planes due to fire risk
Windows 10 Fall Creators Update has THIS great hidden feature
French envoy attempt to 'seduce British businesses and exploit UK industry Brexit fears'
Senate investigators spoke with Russians present at Trump Tower meeting with Trump Jr.
The women fighters who helped defeat ISIS in Raqqa
Trump incorrectly suggests link between terrorism and rising UK crime rate - CNN
Bittersweet return for Leigh Halfpenny as Scarlets lose at Toulon
Lara Trump becomes face of Donald Trump's 2020 re-election campaign
Dusty Baker out as Nationals manager
Lulu the dog did not want to join the CIA, but she’s still a very good girl
Catalonia economic chaos: Independence to push Spanish debt to 120 per cent of GDP
Google Play 'try it now' button lets users test-drive an Android app without installing it - TechRepublic
Angela Merkel eases Theresa May's Brexit nightmare
OnePlus promises to stop collecting YOUR data with future update
UK faces MONTHS of SNOW: Sinking polar vortex to trigger COLDEST winter since GREAT FREEZE
The Return of Obama - U.S. News & World Report
UK mobile phone firms overcharging customers after contracts expire - The Guardian
REVEALED: Prince Harry and Meghan Markle ‘wedding date already set’
Hollywood Film Awards to Honor 'Blade Runner 2049,' 'The Disaster Artist'
South Korea does a sudden U-turn on nuclear power
Amanda Holden teases Simon Cowell ROMANCE as she makes shock confession
Google Maps: How to explore space with Google's interactive map of the solar system
George W. Bush Condemned The Trend Of ‘Nationalism Distorted Into Nativism’
World War 3: EU security boss issues STERN threat to North Korea - 'gravest punishment'
Ellen DeGeneres Talks Sexual Assault in Hollywood, Praises #MeToo Movement
Google's parent company leads $1 billion investment in Lyft
North Korea threatens 'unimaginable' strike on United States
'Survivor' Season 35: Jeff Probst Breaks Down the Tribe Swap
Google Doodle: Who is astrophysicist S. Chandrasekhar? - Metro
Trump tried to look compassionate. Instead, he looked like a jerk.
Is Merkel BLUFFING? Leaked paper shows Germany is preparing for EU trade deal with Britain
Samsung's new camera has 17 lenses and costs $10500 - CNET
Relationship between sugar and cancer is now clearer, scientists say
Howard Stern on Harvey Weinstein: "When Did This Guy Have Time to Make Movies?"
'It's able to create knowledge itself': Google unveils AI that learns on its own
Roma fans in London RIOT: Supporters clash with police ahead of Chelsea match
BREAKING: Explosion rips through Belgian restaurant - at least three injured
3 killed, 2 wounded in shooting at Maryland office park, authorities say
Hillary Clinton calls Trump's North Korea threats 'dangerous' and 'short-sighted' - Business Insider
Trump Freaks Out After FBI Confirms Comey Wrote Clinton Exoneration Letter
IBM gets a boost from low taxes and cloud computing
Rihanna’s cosmetics line is a game-changer for women of colour
Storm Brian WORSE than Ophelia: Met Office confirm 'dangerous' WEATHER BOMB to SMASH UK
The Xi Jinping economy: What's next for China?
Liverpool and Man City run riot in Europe as Tottenham salvage point against Real Madrid
Battle against Bitcoin: Russia launches own cryptocurrency dubbed the Cryptoruble
Trump warns McCain: 'Be careful ... I fight back'
Britain facing most 'intense' terror threat ever, MI5 boss warns
Google firm wins competition to build high-tech Quayside neighbourhood in Toronto
Netflix Sort of Releases Some Ratings Data
BREAKING: Royal baby due date REVEALED - Kate and William make big announcement
Jennifer Lawrence shares story of abuse in Hollywood: I had to lose 15 pounds, pose nude
MIPCOM: Nominations for International Emmy Kids Span 16 Countries
MIPCOM: Harvey Weinstein Scandal Hangs Over Cannes
North Korea defector says life is MUCH WORSE than what the West says
ISIS routed in Raqqa as 'major military operations' declared over
Families warned: Mortgage interest rates set to RISE as inflation hits five-year high
BREAKING: Air force jet pilot dies as F-18 crashes while wife and son wait for his return
Emotional Sen. John McCain blasts 'half-baked, spurious nationalism'
Will the next iPhone charge wirelessly?
'I dread it': Jimmy Kimmel opens up about those emotional monologues
North Korea Says Nuclear War ‘May Break Out Any Moment’
UK universities 'generate almost £100 billion a YEAR for the economy'
Brexit dinner SHOWDOWN: Theresa May arrives in Brussels for crunch talks
North Korea rejects diplomacy with US for now, source says
WI-FI WARNING - Almost ALL phones, PCs and tablets vulnerable to devastating attack
End is NIGH: Social media panic as blood red sun rises above UK in terrifying phenomenon
Hillary Clinton Compares Trump With Harvey Weinstein
Mysterious Planet Nine Exists: NASA Close To Finding It, Reassures Us It Won't Hit The Earth - Tech Times
DANCING QUEEN! Kate with baby bump on full show jives with Paddington Bear
Kirkuk: A crisis waiting to happen, with consequences for region
Barcelona News: Lionel Messi had secret Antoine Griezmann transfer chat after La Liga draw
Hurricane Ophelia track: Storm develops huge ‘STING JET’ that is terrifying forecasters
Catalonia leader fails to clarify independence declaration
'Wonder Wheel': Film Review | NYFF 2017
Windows 10 Fall Creators Update - Why users may face a delay in downloading this upgrade
Clinton on Putin: 'Keep an eye on him, because he's not done'
Victoria Beckham posts Instagram pic of her sons
Tillerson on North Korea: Diplomacy will continue 'until the first bomb drops'
Brexit talks MUST progress: May and Merkel agree end to deadlock over EU payment demands
Here’s why Kate Winslet didn’t thank Harvey Weinstein when she won an Oscar
Tillerson won't say if he called Trump a 'moron'
Patients in England to be quizzed over their sexuality
Samsung Galaxy S8 vs Google Pixel 2: Which one is best for you?
'Saturday Night Live' Explains Why It's Hard to Make Jokes About Harvey Weinstein
US will be reduced to ASHES: North Korea sparks WW3 fears with threat to 'loser’ Trump
Tesla fires hundreds of workers - Ars Technica
Here's why Obama stays quiet as Trump attacks his legacy
Why are more women than men illiterate? - BBC News
Russia to the rescue! Moscow offers to mediate between South & North Korea to prevent WAR
Joshua Boyle demands justice from Afghan government after returning to Canada
Kate Middleton’s jewellery collection inspired by Princess Diana? Jeweller reveals ALL
Hurricane Ophelia track: Where is Hurricane Ophelia now? When will it hit the UK & Ireland
James Bond: Luke Evans says replacing Daniel Craig as 007 looks ‘attractive but NOT easy’
Russian cargo ship blasts off, heads for space station - CBS News
Woman dies in California wildfires trying to rescue her dog
Xperia XZ1 review - Has Sony really done enough to beat the Galaxy S8?
Trump's goals for decertifying Iran deal remain a mystery
Freed hostage says Taliban-linked captors killed infant daughter, raped American wife
Future home? Prince Harry and Meghan Markle ‘interested in Cotswold hills properties’
Pretend you have a Pixel 2 by downloading the new Pixel 2 launcher
Pound V euro: GBP exchange rate against EUR surges amid Brexit deal reports
Megyn Kelly Highlights "Inconsistency" With Rose McGowan, Trump Lawyer Tweets
What Trump's move on Iran means for the US and the world
Trump administration introduces 5-year ‘sunset clause’ into NAFTA talks
Germany’s Brexit mind games: Merkel warns UK ‘time is running out’ to strike deal with EU
Iran nuclear deal: Trump 'will not sign off agreement'
WhatsApp set to make the biggest change since it was bought by Facebook
Trump has halted billions in key Obamacare payments to insurers.
Trump to announce combative new approach to Iran
Seth Meyers Takes on Trump, Weinstein and "Toxic Culture of Male Entitlement" in 'Late Night' Rant
WATCH OUT KIM: World’s biggest nuclear submarine from US arrives on North Korea doorstep
Israel says Trump UNESCO pullout means 'new era' at United Nations
Prince Harry calls for regular HIV and Aids testing
Game of Thrones’ Jason Momoa SLAMMED for joking about ‘raping beautiful women’ on show
Amazon Studios chief Roy Price suspended following harassment allegation - StreetInsider.com
Trump signs order to eliminate ACA insurance rules, undermine marketplaces - Washington Post
Jimmy Kimmel, Stephen Colbert, Seth Meyers Challenge Trump's Threat to NBC
Google to donate $1 billion to help people land technical jobs
Equifax takes web page offline after reports of new cyber attack - Reuters
Teen, 15, and alleged getaway driver, 30, arrested in 10 bank robberies
London's Brexit BOOM: Capital's growth to beat Paris and Frankfurt, study finds
Google forced to break the Home Mini to stop it spying on people - The Independent
China under attack: North Korea 'preparing to fire 30 Scud missiles at own ALLY next week'
California fires: Searchers seek hundreds of missing
Hurricane Ophelia TERRIFYING path to UK: Huge tropical superstorm to smash Britain IN DAYS
Seth Meyers Responds to Eminem's Anti-Trump Cypher With Rap of His Own
Officials Say They’re ‘Horrified’ By What They’ve Seen In Deadly Wildfires
Stock Market Shock: Google reported to be purchasing Apple in ‘ERRONEOUS’ Dow Jones hiccup
Ivanka Trump reveals hint of chest as she cosies up to Justin Trudeau and wife at event
Meddling Merkel: German Chancellor's team 'BLOCKING Barnier from opening talks with UK'
Cara Delevingne: Harvey Weinstein tried to lure me into a threesome
Remember that Canada is America’s biggest customer, Trudeau tells Congress in Washington
Jennifer Lopez, Marc Anthony and Alex Rodriguez Team for NBC Disaster Relief Benefit Concert
Barcelona News: Lionel Messi heroics for Argentina anger Real Madrid ace Cristiano Ronaldo
Matt Damon Interrupts Chris Hemsworth's Interview with Jimmy Kimmel
Facebook's VR headset Oculus Go doesn't require a phone or PC
Has US military helicopter been SHOT DOWN? Aircraft crashes in Japan near North Korea
Kimmel Shakes Up Late Night Ratings Race as Fallon Sinks
Facebook and Twitter face a 'bully tax' in Britain
Miley Cyrus shows of long tongue in Carpool Karaoke trailer
NFL owners to consider rule forcing players to stand for national anthem
Equifax says 15.2 million UK records exposed in cyber breach
Zuckerberg's social VR is a future nobody really wants or needs - Wired.co.uk
Newsnight: Theresa May right-hand man declares the 'UK WILL be worse off after Brexit'
US fails to reach 2018 World Cup; Argentina breathes sigh of relief
Previewing health order, Trump vows 'great, great' insurance
Harvey Weinstein denies rape accusations
How do I make money? What mortgage suits me? Top 10 most Googled financial questions
Lionel Messi, Cristiano Ronaldo, Luka Modric and more: How the stars might not actually align at the 2018 World Cup - The Independent
Google Chrome WARNING as THOUSANDS of users tricked into downloading THIS fake app
Macron can do NOTHING! Catalan MEP blasts French threat to punish an independent Catalonia
World War 3: North Korea hackers steal ultra-classified USA WAR PLANS
SpaceX launch stream: Falcon 9 rocket launches 10 Iridium NEXT satellites – WATCH it here
Netflix Italy Announces Soccer Docu-Series: 'Juventus FC'
While Netflix hikes, Hulu drops price for its entry-level plan
Late-Night Hosts Respond to Harvey Weinstein's Ouster
London Tube bomber's accomplice became council 'poster girl' after bosses failed to uncover criminal record - Telegraph.co.uk
Is Taylor Swift failing on the charts? Here's why her first two singles haven't soared
World War 3: Russia orders US to ABANDON North Korea fight as major conflict looms
Melania Trump responds to Ivana Trump calling herself 'first lady'
Trump demands border wall funds, immigration changes
Amazon's new Echo speaker with a touchscreen is on sale for the first time ever - Business Insider
Meryl Streep Speaks Out Against Harvey Weinstein
Google uncovers Russian-bought ads on YouTube, Gmail and other platforms - Washington Post
NIBIRU COVER UP? Mysterious death of scientists who ‘found Planet X’
Hillary Clinton attacks Brexit voters’ 'SMALL VILLAGE’ ideas that reject 'modern future'
Trump administration releases hard-line immigration principles, threatening deal on 'dreamers' - Washington Post
Apple Stores offer FREE coding sessions - Here's how you can learn these vital skills
Barcelona News: Lionel Messi gave blessing for Antoine Griezmann to replace Neymar
Miley Cyrus' Lip Sync Battle With Jimmy Fallon Is Exhausting Just To Watch
REVEALED: Why Prince Harry and Meghan Markle are 'permitted' to show affection in public
The world's most mysterious family tree
Dove apologises for ad showing black woman turning into white one
MAPPED: Which countries have nuclear weapons? Does North Korea have nukes?
SpaceX Rocket to Launch 10 Satellites Early Monday: How to Watch Live - Space.com
Elon Musk warns 'end of simulation we live is COMING SOON & AI will overtake human race'
End of Surface? Shock claims Microsoft could SCRAP tablet and laptop line
Rafael Nadal gives Nick Kyrgios advice after winning stormy China Open final
Lewis Hamilton wins Japanese GP to take big step towards F1 title - The Guardian
If you really like Samsung, you should probably buy an iPhone X
The Catalans who oppose a split from Spain
Hurricane Nate weakens to a tropical storm after making US landfall twice
Chelsea News: Antonio Conte thinking about quitting at the end of the season - EXCLUSIVE
Theresa May planning to 'silence Boris Johnson with imminent Cabinet reshuffle'
Trump says 'only one thing will work' with nuclear-armed North Korea
3 best and worst features of the Google Pixel 2 and Pixel 2 XL - The Verge
Meghan Markle secures Middleton wedding dress designer as Prince Harry proposal 'imminent'
PS5 release date killer feature gets update, will Xbox One X and Nintendo Switch follow? - Express.co.uk
North Korea issued World War 3 warning by Donald Trump - ‘Only one thing will work!’
Close