October 02, 2018
Securities and Exchange Commission officials were understandably taken aback on Thursday morning when Tesla’s board — and its chairman, Elon Musk — abruptly pulled out of a carefully crafted settlement.
Elon Musks Ultimatum to Tesla: Fight the SEC, or I Quit
After the S.E.C. responded by accusing Mr. Musk, but not the company that he had co-founded, of securities fraud, the board further defied regulators, issuing a provocative statement saying that the directors were “fully confident in Elon, his integrity, and his leadership of the company.”
It was a stunning reversal: The board had rejected a settlement that was extraordinarily generous — it would have allowed Mr. Musk to remain as chief executive, and required him to step down as chairman for only two years. Now, the company was at risk of losing Mr. Musk as chairman and chief executive if regulators prevailed in court.
“What it tells us is this board, as a strategic plan, must be using the Jim Jones-Jonestown suicide pact,” Jeffrey Sonnenfeld, a professor at the Yale School of Management, said Friday on CNBC. “They are drinking the Kool-Aid of the founder. It is completely as self-destructive as Musk is.”
But Mr. Musk had given the board little choice: In a phone call with directors before their lawyers went back to federal regulators with a final decision, Mr. Musk threatened to resign on the spot if the board insisted that he and the company enter into the settlement. Not only that, he demanded the board publicly extol his integrity.
Threatened with the abrupt departure of the man who is arguably Tesla’s single most important asset, the board caved to his demands, according to three people familiar with the board’s decision.
The next day, Tesla’s lawyers were back at the S.E.C., all but groveling for a second chance — this time with Mr. Musk’s grudging approval.
One factor in Mr. Musk’s change of heart: Tesla’s stock plunged Friday morning as investors absorbed news of the rejected settlement and the possibility that the S.E.C. would force Mr. Musk to step down. It would finish down almost 14 percent on Friday.
On Saturday, the company and Mr. Musk finally agreed to settle the matter, ending a crisis that began with Mr. Musk’s now-infamous Twitter post saying that he had “funding secured” for a buyout at $420 a share.
Mr. Musk’s 48 hours of obstinance came at a significant price to him and the company. They had passed on Thursday’s generous offer, and the S.E.C. felt compelled to extract greater concessions. The ban on Mr. Musk’s serving as chairman went from two years to three, and his fine doubled to $20 million. Tesla will also pay a $20 million fine, and Mr. Musk agreed to personally buy the same amount in Tesla stock.
The S.E.C. is also requiring the company to add two independent directors and to elect an independent director as chairman.
“Rejecting such a favorable settlement is proof that he needs monitoring,” said John C. Coffee Jr., a professor at Columbia Law School. “He didn’t have a legal leg to stand on, and I’m sure his lawyer told him that. But he got very touchy about not being able to proclaim his innocence.”
From Mr. Musk’s view, that had been a crucial problem with a settlement from the beginning. Mr. Musk neither admitted nor denied guilt as part of the agreement, and he cannot publicly contest the S.E.C.’s allegations. He cannot say, as he did on Thursday, that “I have always taken action in the best interests of truth, transparency and investors” and “the facts will show I never compromised this in any way.”
Tesla’s stock has rebounded this week, reflecting investors’ relief that Mr. Musk will remain as chief executive while the company puts mechanisms in place to curb his increasingly impulsive behavior. The board will closely watch Mr. Musk’s communications with investors, and establish a permanent committee responsible for, among other things, monitoring disclosures.
But it remains to be seen how effective the board can be, given Mr. Musk’s erratic temperament and his dominant role in the company.
People involved in the board’s deliberations this week told me that some directors have proposed their fellow director, James Murdoch — the chief executive of 21st Century Fox, most of which is being sold to the Walt Disney Company — as chairman. But Mr. Murdoch hasn’t volunteered for the post nor has he discussed it with any other director. And another person close to the selection process said the board hadn’t yet engaged in any “serious” discussions of who should be chairman. The people spoke on the condition of anonymity because the board discussions were private.
Under terms of the settlement, the board has 45 days before Mr. Musk must resign. Whether it is Mr. Murdoch or another similarly qualified candidate who takes over as chairman, managing Mr. Musk will be no easy challenge.
Independent directors frequently face difficulty asserting themselves in any company with an outsize figure like Mr. Musk, whether it be a founder, controlling shareholder or powerful chief executive, said Lucian Bebchuk, a professor at Harvard Law School and an expert in corporate governance. Such people can often replace any director who crosses them, he said.
“Adding two independent directors can be expected to help, but its impact is likely to be limited,” Professor Bebchuk said. “As courts and governance researchers have long recognized, the presence of a dominant shareholder is likely to reduce the effectiveness of independent directors as overseers of the C.E.O.’s decisions and behavior.”
In the end, it took legal action by the S.E.C. to accomplish what had been increasingly obvious to most Tesla observers, including many of Tesla’s own directors: For all his brilliance, Mr. Musk’s reckless impulses must be kept in check.
Foremost among those should be threats to quit if he doesn’t get his way.
Related Stories
Latest News
Top news around the world
Coronavirus Disease

Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) is an infectious disease caused by a newly discovered coronavirus.

Most people infected with the COVID-19 virus will experience mild to moderate respiratory illness and recover without requiring special treatment. Older people, and those with underlying medical problems like cardiovascular disease, diabetes, chronic respiratory disease, and cancer are more likely to develop serious illness.

Around the World

Celebrity News

> Latest News in Media

Watch It
Queen Victoria Comes for Katie, Cheesy Roleplay & Bro-Zoned - "Nightly Pop" 01/25/21 | E! News
January 26, 2021
rL0W6V7Qc3U
J.Lo Challenge Backfires, Wendy's Fall & Bridgerton Sex Scenes - "Nightly Pop" 01/25/21 | E! News
January 25, 2021
T0icFdpMMVg
"Bling Empire" Star Kelly Mi Li Reveals Relationship Status | E! News
January 25, 2021
dn-agi3giT4
Ioan Gruffudd’s wife, Alice Evans, tweets actor is ‘leaving his family’ | Page Six Celebrity News
January 26, 2021
b1ZuMpCCW70
Disgraced billionaire Steve Wynn lists Beverly Hills mansion for $110M | Page Six Celebrity News
January 26, 2021
ZA_bTZ4SBdY
Elliot Page files for divorce from Emma Portner | Page Six Celebrity News
January 26, 2021
cAyj0v_iL_M
Carey Mulligan & Zendaya on Feminist Rage, 'Promising Young Woman,' ‘Malcolm & Marie’
January 26, 2021
rjjvIOoP0t0
Pete Davidson Tells Glenn Close He Thought She Was British | Actors on Actors
January 25, 2021
z_nLMQyx-nk
Golden Globes: Limited Series & TV Movie -- Who Will Be Nominated?
January 25, 2021
UJ8Ty2uStzs
Adam Carolla Slams Gov. Newsom, Says COVID Restriction Lift 'Too Little, Too Late' | TMZ
January 26, 2021
uI7ttM5JU6k
Diplo Uses His Tesla To Recreate His New Song | TMZ TV
January 26, 2021
la4tx4paXIc
Luke Bryan Took Wife Caroline Duck Hunting and It Didn’t Go Well | TMZ TV
January 26, 2021
VPHZLNm6geg
TV Schedule
Late Night Show
Watch the latest shows of U.S. top comedians

Sports

Latest sport results, news, videos, interviews and comments
Latest Events
27
Jan
ENGLAND: Premier League
Chelsea - Wolves
27
Jan
ENGLAND: Premier League
Manchester United - Sheffield United
27
Jan
ENGLAND: Premier League
Everton - Leicester City
27
Jan
ENGLAND: Championship
Middlesbrough - Rotherham
27
Jan
ENGLAND: Championship
Coventry - Sheffield Wednesday
27
Jan
ENGLAND: Championship
Barnsley - Cardiff City
27
Jan
ENGLAND: Championship
Swansea City - Brentford
27
Jan
ENGLAND: Premier League
Brighton - Fulham
27
Jan
ENGLAND: Premier League
Burnley - Aston Villa
26
Jan
ENGLAND: Premier League
Southampton - Arsenal
26
Jan
ENGLAND: Premier League
West Bromwich Albion - Manchester City
26
Jan
ENGLAND: Championship
Bristol City - Huddersfield
26
Jan
ENGLAND: Championship
Millwall - Watford
24
Jan
GERMANY: Bundesliga
Schalke - Bayern Munich
24
Jan
SPAIN: La Liga
Atletico Madrid - Valencia
24
Jan
SPAIN: La Liga
Elche - Barcelona
24
Jan
ITALY: Serie A
Verona - Napoli
24
Jan
ITALY: Serie A
Juventus - Bologna
23
Jan
SPAIN: La Liga
Alaves - Real Madrid
23
Jan
ITALY: Serie A
Udinese - Inter Milan
23
Jan
ITALY: Serie A
AC Milan - Atalanta
23
Jan
ITALY: Serie A
Roma - Spezia
22
Jan
GERMANY: Bundesliga
Borussia Monchengladbach - Borussia Dortmund
21
Jan
SPAIN: La Liga
Eibar - Atletico Madrid
21
Jan
ENGLAND: Premier League
Liverpool - Burnley
20
Jan
ENGLAND: Premier League
Manchester City - Aston Villa
20
Jan
GERMANY: Bundesliga
Augsburg - Bayern Munich
20
Jan
ENGLAND: Premier League
Fulham - Manchester United
Find us on Instagram
at @feedimo to stay up to date with the latest.
Featured Video You Might Like
zWJ3MxW_HWA L1eLanNeZKg i1XRgbyUtOo -g9Qziqbif8 0vmRhiLHE2U JFCZUoa6MYE UfN5PCF5EUo 2PV55f3-UAg W3y9zuI_F64 -7qCxIccihU pQ9gcOoH9R8 g5MRDEXRk4k
Copyright © 2020 Feedimo. All Rights Reserved.