Close
Date TimeAugust 05, 2018
VoiceU.S. President Donald Trump wants a Space Force, a new military service he says is needed to ensure American dominance in space. But the idea is gaining little traction at the Pentagon, where the president’s defence chief, Jim Mattis, says it would add burdensome bureaucracy and unwanted costs.
The Pentagon acknowledges a need to revamp its much-criticized approach to defending U.S. economic and security interests in space, and it is moving in that direction. But it’s unclear whether this will satisfy Trump, who wants to go even further by creating a separate military space service.
Trump may want a ‘Space Force’ but the Pentagon has a different idea
The administration intends to announce next week the results of a Pentagon study that is expected to call for creating a new military command — U.S. Space Command — to consolidate space war-fighting forces and making other organizational changes short of establishing a separate service, which only Congress can do. Any legislative proposal to create a separate service would likely not be put on the table until next year.
Mattis, who said prior to Trump’s “Space Force” announcement in June that he opposes creating a new branch of the military for space, said afterward that this would require “a lot of detailed planning.”
Mattis is allied on this with key Republicans on Capitol Hill including Sen. James Inhofe, a member of the Senate Armed Services Committee who opposes a separate Space Force but is open to creating a Space Command. The command would co-ordinate the use of space forces of existing services, such as those that operate military satellites, but would not be a separate service.
Mattis’s chief spokesperson, Dana W. White, said Friday he believes that consolidating space functions will “ensure we move at the speed of relevancy. Space is a joint war-fighting domain that the U.S. must dominate.”
Trump mentioned as recently as Tuesday that he had ordered the Pentagon to begin the process of creating a Space Force as a new branch of the military, but he did not repeat the phrase he used in June — a “separate but equal” service. That may open the possibility of the Pentagon proposing to establish a cadre of space experts that would be part of a space “corps” attached to the Air Force rather than as a separate service.
On Friday, Trump hailed the news that NASA has named the astronauts who will ride the first commercial capsules into orbit next year. “We have the greatest facilities in the world and we are now letting the private sector pay to use them,” he tweeted. “Exciting things happening. Space Force!”
Trump’s focus has generated an unusual level of talk about space, but with little clarity.
“At the moment, there is no concrete proposal on the table for what a Space Force will look like or what it will do,” said Brian Weeden, an Air Force veteran who is director of program planning at the Secure World Foundation, which promotes peaceful uses of outer space. “It’s just sort of a notional concept.”
Weeden points out that creating a new service would not address what is generally seen as a need for a more coherent force to defend U.S. interests in space, since by law a service recruits, trains and equips troops but does not do combat. That is why a Space Command is being considered, since it would be the combat arm for space much as Central Command is the organization responsible for combat operations in the Middle East.
Aside from the organizational issues, the Pentagon’s role in space is under scrutiny because of a recognition that the United States is increasingly reliant on satellites that are difficult to protect in space. Satellites provide communications, navigation, intelligence and other services vital to the military and the economy. Whereas space has long been America’s technological edge, it is increasingly seen as its Achilles’ heel.
War in space is not just Hollywood fiction. The U.S. intelligence agencies reported earlier this year that Russia and China are pursuing “non-destructive and destructive” anti-satellite weapons for use during a future war.
A related problem that the Pentagon has struggled to address is the sluggish pace of developing and acquiring satellites through the Air Force Space and Missile Systems Center, which could be replaced by a new space development agency.
In an interim report to Congress in March on ways to reorganize its space organizations, the Pentagon said it is making changes to “ensure that we are prepared for” potential conflicts in space. This includes making satellites more resilient to potential attack by Russia or China.
Deborah James, who was the civilian leader of the Air Force for the final three years of the Obama administration, said at a think-tank forum Monday that creating a separate Space Force does not address the legitimate concerns about U.S. space defences. One of the criticisms of the Air Force, which is the primary service responsible for military satellites, is that it devotes too little money and attention to space.
“If money is your issue, Space Force is not your answer,” she said. If the logic of creating a separate space service were applied broadly, she said, it would imply other radical changes such as creating a single nuclear service by combining management of the strategic nuclear weapons of the Air Force and Navy, which no one is considering.

Related Stories
Pete Buttigieg calls Vice President Pence a cheerleader for the porn star presidencyPete Buttigieg calls Vice President Pence a 'cheerleader for the porn star presidency'
Tim Apple: Donald Trump gets name of tech giants CEO wrong'Tim Apple': Donald Trump gets name of tech giant's CEO wrong
Historys first all-female spacewalk will take place March 29History's first all-female spacewalk will take place March 29
Roscosmos Chief, Elon Musk Exchange Courtesies After SpaceX Capsule LandingRoscosmos Chief, Elon Musk Exchange Courtesies After SpaceX Capsule Landing
SpaceX Dragon crew capsule makes successful splashdown after test flightSpaceX Dragon crew capsule makes successful splashdown after test flight
New York attorney general is investigating Trump projectsNew York attorney general is investigating Trump projects
North Korea rocket site is being monitored in real time, U.S. official saysNorth Korea rocket site is being monitored 'in real time,' U.S. official says
SpaceX Crew Dragon, built to carry humans, heads home from ISSSpaceX Crew Dragon, built to carry humans, heads home from ISS
Robert Mueller report will be a gold mine of improprieties. Trump shouldnt celebrate yetRobert Mueller report will be a gold mine of improprieties. Trump shouldn't celebrate yet
Trump to make $8.6 billion wall demand, triggering new standoff with CongressTrump to make $8.6 billion wall demand, triggering new standoff with Congress
News Trends
Lyra McKee funeral: politicians urged to seize the momentLyra McKee funeral: politicians urged to seize the moment
The Greta Thunberg effect: her activism in London in two minutes - videoThe Greta Thunberg effect: her activism in London in two minutes - video
Jennifer Garner thinks her face on cover of Peoples Beautiful Issue is so ridiculousJennifer Garner thinks her face on cover of People's Beautiful Issue is 'so ridiculous'
Rapper Bun B Shoots Armed Robber in His Houston HomeRapper Bun B Shoots Armed Robber in His Houston Home
SpaceX Crew Dragon Accident Another Bump in the Road for Commercial CrewSpaceX Crew Dragon Accident Another Bump in the Road for Commercial Crew
Meghan Markle and Prince Harry wrote a sweet birthday message for Prince Louis, but some people think it broke royal protocolMeghan Markle and Prince Harry wrote a sweet birthday message for Prince Louis, but some people think it broke royal protocol
Elon Musk told this Reddit user they should interview at Tesla, heres whyElon Musk told this Reddit user they 'should interview at Tesla', here's why
‘His career was incredible’. Billy McNeill was a winner as player and manager‘His career was incredible’. Billy McNeill was a winner as player and manager
Natalie Portman makes a surprise appearance at the Avengers: Endgame premiereNatalie Portman makes a surprise appearance at the Avengers: Endgame premiere
Seahawks, Chiefs blow up NFL draft with Frank Clark tradeSeahawks, Chiefs blow up NFL draft with Frank Clark trade
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
Pete Buttigieg calls Vice President Pence a cheerleader for the porn star presidencyPete Buttigieg calls Vice President Pence a 'cheerleader for the porn star presidency'
Tim Apple: Donald Trump gets name of tech giants CEO wrong'Tim Apple': Donald Trump gets name of tech giant's CEO wrong
Historys first all-female spacewalk will take place March 29History's first all-female spacewalk will take place March 29
Roscosmos Chief, Elon Musk Exchange Courtesies After SpaceX Capsule LandingRoscosmos Chief, Elon Musk Exchange Courtesies After SpaceX Capsule Landing
SpaceX Dragon crew capsule makes successful splashdown after test flightSpaceX Dragon crew capsule makes successful splashdown after test flight
New York attorney general is investigating Trump projectsNew York attorney general is investigating Trump projects
North Korea rocket site is being monitored in real time, U.S. official saysNorth Korea rocket site is being monitored 'in real time,' U.S. official says
SpaceX Crew Dragon, built to carry humans, heads home from ISSSpaceX Crew Dragon, built to carry humans, heads home from ISS
Robert Mueller report will be a gold mine of improprieties. Trump shouldnt celebrate yetRobert Mueller report will be a gold mine of improprieties. Trump shouldn't celebrate yet
Trump to make $8.6 billion wall demand, triggering new standoff with CongressTrump to make $8.6 billion wall demand, triggering new standoff with Congress
News Trends
Lyra McKee funeral: politicians urged to seize the momentLyra McKee funeral: politicians urged to seize the moment
The Greta Thunberg effect: her activism in London in two minutes - videoThe Greta Thunberg effect: her activism in London in two minutes - video
Jennifer Garner thinks her face on cover of Peoples Beautiful Issue is so ridiculousJennifer Garner thinks her face on cover of People's Beautiful Issue is 'so ridiculous'
Rapper Bun B Shoots Armed Robber in His Houston HomeRapper Bun B Shoots Armed Robber in His Houston Home
SpaceX Crew Dragon Accident Another Bump in the Road for Commercial CrewSpaceX Crew Dragon Accident Another Bump in the Road for Commercial Crew
Meghan Markle and Prince Harry wrote a sweet birthday message for Prince Louis, but some people think it broke royal protocolMeghan Markle and Prince Harry wrote a sweet birthday message for Prince Louis, but some people think it broke royal protocol
Elon Musk told this Reddit user they should interview at Tesla, heres whyElon Musk told this Reddit user they 'should interview at Tesla', here's why
‘His career was incredible’. Billy McNeill was a winner as player and manager‘His career was incredible’. Billy McNeill was a winner as player and manager
Natalie Portman makes a surprise appearance at the Avengers: Endgame premiereNatalie Portman makes a surprise appearance at the Avengers: Endgame premiere
Seahawks, Chiefs blow up NFL draft with Frank Clark tradeSeahawks, Chiefs blow up NFL draft with Frank Clark trade
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Venezuela's Maduro: Drone attack was attempt to kill him
Convicted child rapist escapes from Kansas prison three days after arrival
Melania Trump contradicts her husband on LeBron James
Meghan Markle dazzles in navy as she arrives for wedding of Prince Harry's close friend
18 killed after Russian helicopter crashes in Siberia, airline says
Urban Meyer says he knew about and reported 2015 incident of alleged abuse by assistant
Astronomers discover a free-range planet with incredible magnetism
Facebook Dating will be a feature, not an app; here's a peek
Barack Obama Day: Former president's political home state of Illinois kicks off holiday
Mission Possible: How To Hike Pulpit Rock Like Tom Cruise Onscreen
Cristiano Ronaldo: Juventus star thought Real Madrid exit was humiliating for one reason
Weekend Box Office: 'Mission: Impossible 6' Making More Honey Than 'Christopher Robin'
Europe's record temperature of 48C could be beaten this weekend
First woman fined in Denmark for wearing full-face veil
President Trump bashes LeBron James over CNN interview: Don Lemon made him 'look smart'
Melania Trump shows of incredible figure in tight white jeans with husband Donald
'Zombie Boy' Rick Genest, tattooed muse to Lady Gaga, dies aged 32
More than 100 goats invade Boise neighbourhood, chew on everything they could find
May and Macron hold 'informal' Brexit talks in France
These 9 Astronauts Will Fly the 1st Flights on SpaceX and Boeing Spaceships
Judge Denies Larry Nassar’s Appeal For New Sentence
Ella Mai: ‘If it were up to England, Boo’d Up definitely wouldn’t be where it is now’
Travis Scott will drop new album this week
Barcelona complete signing of Arturo Vidal for £27m from Bayern Munich
My son, Osama: the al-Qaida leader’s mother speaks for the first time
Donald Trump hits back at criticism: 'DISGUSTING! I was EARLY and waiting for the QUEEN!'
Boeing and SpaceX delay first crucial test flights of new passenger spacecraft again
Colbert Mocks Paul Manafort’s Wardrobe: Looks Like ‘A Blind Pimp Got 100 Wishes’
Black pastors see Trump bringing 'new hope' -- but still need to convince their flocks
395 people sickened in McDonald's salad outbreak
Suspected Russian spy caught working inside US embassy in Moscow
Urban Meyer placed on leave as Ohio State investigates what he knew about alleged abuse
Virat Kohli’s brilliant century frustrates England in India fightback
Trump received letter from North Korea's Kim on August 1: White House
Ivanka Trump: Migrant separations a ‘low point’ and journalists are not ‘enemy of the people’
May prepares for talks with Macron that could make or break Brexit plan
Stonehenge mystery SOLVED: Who built Stonehenge? Latest study on stone formation REVEALED
Naomi Campbell, 48, stuns in two bikini photos, shuts down pregnancy rumors
Iran deploys 50 small boats to Strait of Hormuz for large-scale 'swarming' exercise
Thousands march in Jerusalem Gay Pride amid surrogacy uproar
Elon Musk Shares Image of Reusable Falcon 9 Blazing a Trail in the Night
Kim Kardashian Disses Kourtney As 'Least Exciting To Look At' In Brutal Fight
Papa John's founder says he has 'no confidence' in current management team, including CEO Steve Ritchie
Apple is now worth $1,000,000,000,000
There's a very simple reason Trump wants to sit down with Mueller
NASA says we can't terraform Mars. Elon Musk disagrees
Giant hands lift new Vietnam bridge toward heavens
Bank of England poised to raise interest rates
Mount Olympus: Google doodle celebrates Greece's Mount Olympus and its heroic climbers
BREXIT LIVE: Remainers turn AGAINST EU and warn 'don't offer May Brexit FUDGE'
Life Needs Sunlight — and That Could Change Where We Look for Aliens
Reddit hacked, despite SMS two-factor authentication
Tesla Doubles Loss, but Burns Less Cash Than Expected
Colbert Finds A Way He Could Actually Vote For Trump
Madonna Reveals She Fled To Portugal To Escape Trump
US threatens raising tariffs to 25% on $200 billion of Chinese goods
Ex-wife of Ohio State assistant fired for abuse says Urban Meyer knew of case
Protests in Denmark as 'burqa ban' comes into effect
Manafort put himself 'above the law' to fund his expensive tastes, court hears
LONDON BLOODBATH: One man dead and two injured after triple stabbing in Camberwell
3 Russian journalists killed while filming documentary on private Russian security group in Africa
Bermuda Triangle mystery 'solved,' scientists claim
If We Ever Want to Walk on Mars, We'd Better Get Serious About Planetary Protection
Mother of missing Iowa college student recounts last text she sent to daughter
Former President Obama Endorses 81 Candidates For Midterms
Tiffany Haddish Says She Was Raped By A Police Cadet When She Was 17
‘Friends’ Cast Had An Adorable Backstage Ritual When Lisa Kudrow Was Pregnant
US sanctions 2 Turkish officials over detention of US pastor
What to Know About Gerda Taro, the War Photographer Celebrated By Today’s Google Doodle
Tommy Robinson freed on bail as court orders retrial
Trump pushes Jeff Sessions to end Mueller's Russia investigation 'right now'
Meghan Markle so ‘DEEPLY HURT’ by father Thomas Markle the Queen might get involved
NBA trade news: Lakers told Kawhi Leonard move failed because of LeBron James
Mexico plane crash: 103 people onboard but all survived, say officials
‘Not good, not nice’: At Florida rally, Trump says China has ‘targeted our farmers’
John Kelly says he will remain Donald Trump's chief of staff until 2020
Facebook removes accounts amid fears of Russian meddling in US midterms
Kevin Hart bans phones during Florida comedy performance
Mars Is At Its Closest to Earth Since 2003 Today! It Won't Be Closer Until 2287
Watch Obama and Biden surprise bakery staff
Kim Kardashian: 'I have nothing bad to say about the president'
France bans smartphones from schools
Guardians of the Galaxy cast signs open letter in support of James Gunn
Trump says he would meet with Iran without preconditions
Lady Amelia Windsor: Royal's 'most beautiful member' takes a dip on Ibiza beach
Glasgow fire: Huge blaze erupts at school - firefighters race to scene in Crookston Road
MH370 report says someone deliberately 'manipulated’ plane’s controls
Can We Terraform Mars to Make It Earth-Like? Not Anytime Soon, Study Suggests
IBM's blockchain app store wants to help banks cut costs
Video shows moment harasser slaps woman on streets of Paris
Dillian Whyte and Joseph Parker should have been a DRAW
'A fire tornado': death toll in massive California blaze rises to five
There May be Water on Mars but Don't Pack Your Bags Just Yet
Trump Again Threatens to Shut Down Government
Tour de France 2018: Geraint Thomas wins to make sporting history
Russia's navy parade: Big show without substance?
CEO of broadcast giant CBS Les Moonves investigated for sexual misconduct 
Carrie Fisher will be in Star Wars: Episode IX
Vogue's Rihanna cover photographer accused of cultural appropriation
Pope Francis accepts resignation of Cardinal Theodore McCarrick over sex abuse allegations
Professor Hanington's Speaking of Science: Water on Mars
Is time running out for Julian Assange?
Reports: Priyanka Chopra and Nick Jonas are engaged after two months of dating
Macron RAMPS up pressure on Juncker to reveal MORE about Trump trade deal
Avenatti: Hush money paid before election to 3 more women who claim affairs with Trump
Trevor Noah Fawns Over ‘Great Leader’ Trump In Brutal Takedown
Putin is 'ready' to go to Washington, invites Trump to Moscow
North Korea hands over the possible remains of American war dead
Facebook's wipeout is the biggest in stock market history
CNN reporter banned: Fox joins outcry after exclusion from White House event
WATCH: Colorado residents SHOCKED as destructive flooding crashes through home
Free from Facebook: Study reveals what types of people are fleeing the social network
Khan warmed up to be Pakistan PM by being cricket captain
Mike Pence Says U.S. Will Sanction Turkey Unless American Pastor Freed
Amy Poehler and Seth Meyers reunite to take on James Comey
Explosive detonated outside US embassy in Beijing
Fortnite Birthday Challenges not showing: Epic Games confirm release time for PS4 and Xbox
Demi Lovato 'awake' in hospital after reported drug overdose
Serena Williams hits out at frequency of her anti-doping tests
Trump's 'pay with cash' offer on Cohen tape could spell fresh peril for president
Emmanuel Macron says he takes the blame over Benalla scandal
Maria Butina's lawyer rejects claim she tried to trade sex for a job
Pompeo says US won't recognize Russia's Crimea annexation
Evidence detected of lake beneath the surface of Mars
Israel shoots down Syrian fighter jet that it says entered airspace
Ivanka Trump's fashion company is shutting down
'A Terrible Day': Greek Wildfires Kill At Least 74 People, Devastate Resort Village
Tour de France riders accidentally tear-gassed
Vikings offensive line coach Tony Sparano dies at 56
Macron under pressure to say why aide's brutality went unreported
Taylor Swift Sends Sweet Birthday Cake Wish To Selena Gomez
DONALD TRUMP'S ALL-CAPS IRAN TWEET IS A BIG DEAL
Elon Musk tweets and Tesla's stock tumbles
Mesut Ozil quits German national soccer team, citing 'racism and disrespect'
SpaceX delivers for Telesat with successful early morning launch
Katharine McPhee Shows Off Massive Engagement Ring In Emotional Post
Trump tweets explosive threat to Iran
At least 14 people shot in Toronto and shooter is dead, police say
Mega Millions winning numbers announced for $433M jackpot
Russia tells US to release alleged spy Maria Butina after 'fabricated charges'
The Latest: Woods shoots 66, in contention at British Open
Starting this weekend, SpaceX is about to land a whole lot more rockets
Stephen Colbert Suggests Menu Choices For Putin White House Visit
'Guardians of the Galaxy Director James Gunn Apologize for Old Jokes
Fifty firefighters tackle Edmonton Tower block blaze in North London 
Macron security officer in custody and will be fired over violent video
White House invites Putin to Washington for fall meeting
Man with knife attacks bus passengers in Germany, 10 hurt
Launch of NASA's Parker Solar Probe rescheduled for Aug. 6
Russia Says Putin And Trump Discussed Referendum In Ukraine
Missouri duck boat accident among deadliest in nearly 20 years
Trump's ex lawyer taped them discussing payment to ex-Playboy model
Israel launches 'wide-scale attack' against Hamas targets in Gaza
The Latest: Putin says US-Russia summit was successful
Trevor Noah mocks French critic who slammed his joke that Africa won World Cup, not France
Denis Ten, Olympic Skating Medalist, Stabbed to Death in Kazakhstan
Brad Pitt And Leonardo DiCaprio Could Have Been In ‘Brokeback Mountain’
Trump and Putin morph into same person on Time magazine cover
Angela Merkel 'cancels summer walking holiday' for first time in a decade
Trump says Russia no longer targeting US, contradicting intelligence chief
Boris Johnson attacks May's 'miserable' Brexit plan in resignation speech
Katy Perry suffered from 'situational depression' after negative response to 'Witness' album
NASA Takes Over Fenway Park for Space-Mission Show
Mark Zuckerberg says Facebook won't ban Holocaust deniers because it wants to give people 'a voice'
David Spade Gets Emotional Remembering Sister-In-Law Kate Spade
Europe hits Google with record fine
Vladimir Putin refuses to touch list of new election meddling indictments as he dismisses 'utterly ridiculous' Russia investigation
Obama to deliver Mandela address in likely rebuke to Trump
Innovating for Mars, and maybe Earth, too
Google Doodle honors physicist Georges Lemaitre's 124th birthday
Amazon Prime Day's Best Xbox One Gaming Deals (US)
Police: Drowning of NHL goalie Ray Emery not suspicious
How Croatia's president won hearts across the globe in World Cup final defeat to France
Putin says he wanted Trump to win in 2016, didn't interfere
Trump throws Putin's soccer ball gift to Melania
Elon Musk calls British diver in Thai cave rescue a 'pedo' in baseless attack
Trump arrives to meet Putin, leaving the UK reeling in his wake
French President Macron has plenty of fun at World Cup final
France beat Croatia to win its second World Cup title
Donald Trump going into Helsinki Putin meeting 'with low expectations'
Archeologists in Egypt find mummification workshop
Protesters in southern Iraq demand better services, jobs
Best streaming service: Netflix vs. Vudu vs. Amazon Prime vs. Hulu
Obama is in Kenya for his sister's project. Then he's off to South Africa
Serena sends message to moms after Wimbledon loss
May: Trump advised me to sue the EU
Mature Serena Williams sees positives in Wimbledon loss
Trump supporters turn out in London a day after protests
No, NASA did not find 'proof of life' on Mars then accidentally destroy it
Emmys: HBO’s ‘Game of Thrones’ Aims to Claim Creative Arts Crown
Belgium records best finish with victory over England
Donald Trump: I didn't criticise PM over Brexit. That is fake news
Stockport shooting: One in hospital, gunman on the run
Tens of thousands of protesters greet Trump in U.K. — along with giant baby balloon
Microsoft says it doesn’t work on ICE facial recognition and calls for regulation
Queen Elizabeth Meets With Trump And Melania
Justin Bieber and Katy Perry among Twitter users hit hardest by follower purge
12 Russians indicted in Mueller investigation
Investigation reopened in brutal slaying of Emmett Till
Antonio Conte sacked by Chelsea with Maurizio Sarri set to replace him
Close