Close
Date TimeMay 04, 2018
VoiceFrom trainer fetishism to Facebook fever, it’s all there in The Communist Manifesto and Das Kapital
Two centuries on, Karl Marx feels more revolutionary than ever | Stuart Jeffries
The other day I stood at the grave of Karl Marx in Highgate cemetery in north London, wondering if he has anything say to us today, 200 years after his birth, on 5 May 1818. “Workers of all lands unite,” reads the tombstone. But they haven’t – the solidarity of the exploited, which Marx took to be necessary to end capitalism, scarcely exists.
“What the bourgeoisie produces, above all, are its own gravediggers,” he and Friedrich Engels wrote 170 years ago in The Communist Manifesto. “Its fall and the victory of the proletariat are equally inevitable.” Not really: capitalism today is rampant. In the kind of historical irony that the philosopher Hegel called the cunning of reason, capitalism has even co-opted its gravediggers to keep it alive: China, the world’s biggest socialist society (if only ostensibly) supplies capitalist enterprises with cheap labour that undercuts other workers around the world.
So is Marx finished? Not at all. For me, what makes Marx worth reading now is not his Panglossian prognoses, but his still resonant diagnoses. For instance, he and Engels foresaw how globalisation would work. “In place of the old wants,” they wrote, “satisfied by the production of the country, we find new wants, requiring for their satisfaction the products of distant lands and climes.” That’s why Chinese workers make products we never conceived would exist, let alone that we would covet, and that would convert us into politically quiescent, borderline sociopathic, sleepwalking narcissists. That’s right – I’m talking about iPhones.
I find it hard to read the first few pages of The Communist Manifesto without thinking that I live in the world he and Engels described. “Constant revolutionising of production, uninterrupted disturbance of all social conditions, everlasting uncertainty and agitation distinguish the bourgeois epoch from all earlier ones.” We inhabit a world just like that, only more intensely than Marx and Engels dared imagine. For me, these words don’t just capture how Uber, Deliveroo and the other virtuosos of the gig economy chip away at values and standards to make a fast buck, but also how the planet is relentlessly despoiled in order to satisfy tax-avoiding shareholders.
Consider, as the Marxist professor David Harvey did recently, São Paulo: a city whose economic base is a car industry that produces vehicles that spend hours in traffic jams, polluting streets and isolating individuals from each other – a potent emblem of how free-market economies are inimical to the real needs of real people.
Marx didn’t foresee Facebook, but he grasped the essentials of Mark Zuckerberg’s business model, certainly better than American senators did at last month’s congressional hearings. “The bourgeoisie,” Marx and Engels wrote, beautifully, “has left remaining no other nexus between man and man than naked self- interest, than callous ‘cash payment’. It has drowned the most heavenly ecstasies of religious fervour, of chivalrous enthusiasm, of philistine sentimentalism, in the icy water of egotistical calculation.”
Facebook, not to mention Amazon and Google, have made humans into exploitable assets. Which is some kind of genius.

But it’s what Marx wrote in Das Kapital in 1867 on commodity fetishism that, I think, is most painfully relevant to us today. By that term he meant how the ordinary things that workers produce – iPads, cars, even the spate of new books commemorating Marx’s 200th birthday – become, under capitalism, bewitchingly strange. Just as in some religions an object invested with supernatural powers becomes a fetish for those who worship it, so commodities under capitalism are accorded magical powers.
When an iPhone is sold, it is exchanged for another commodity (generally money). The exchange takes no account of the labour that went into the iPhone’s making, still less the fact that some of Apple’s underpaid workers have contemplated suicide in order to escape their lives manufacturing purportedly must-have gizmos for you and me. “A commodity, therefore, is a mysterious thing simply because in it the social character of men’s labour appears to them as an objective character stamped upon the product of that labour,” wrote Marx.
György Lukács, who profoundly influenced the Frankfurt School of thinkers, argued that a new kind of human arises in a world where commodity fetishism is rampant. Those new humans are so degraded that buying and selling is their essence: I shop therefore I am. Instead of uniting to end capitalism, we buy more shoes. When JD Sports announced a 24% rise in profits last month, for me it felt less like good news for the ailing British high street than footwear fetishism propping up the degrading system that Lukács described. We’ve been took, as Malcolm X put it, in another context. We’ve been had.
In such a world it’s easy to collapse, as many of the Frankfurt School did, into the philosophical quietism that drove Marx nuts. “The philosophers,” he wrote in words also emblazoned on his tombstone, “have only interpreted the world in various ways; the point, however, is to change it.”
That remains the challenge. We need Marx to help us understand the state we’re in, though that is only a prelude to the bigger struggle, for which his writings are less helpful: namely, how to get out of it.

'Pyongyang Time' scrapped as North Korea synchronises clocks with the South
6.9-magnitude earthquake hits Hawaii’s Big Island, USGS says, following a recent volcanic eruption
NASA InSight set to launch Saturday to help scientists study inner depths of Mars
Trump shames Mueller team in NRA speech, on heels of judge's rebuke
This is the music video the Parkland students made
Star Wars Day: What to do on May 4 (and why)
'They threw everything they had and FAILED' Theresa May taunts Labour after election FLOP
Meghan Markle’s parents to meet Queen Elizabeth II, other royals ahead of wedding
Kris Jenner defends Kanye West, calls Khloe Kardashian 'a good mom'
Palestinian leader apologizes for speech condemned as anti-Semitic
Unemployment below 4% in US for first time since 2000
Trump walks back Giuliani: 'He'll get his facts straight'
Kevin Hart thanks ‘angels’ after private jet blows tire
Labour and Tories enjoy mixed night of results in local elections in England
Twitter security fail: Users urged to change passwords after glitch
Stephen Colbert Mocks Giuliani’s Fox News Interview: ‘Rudy, You’re Not Helping!’
Sarah Huckabee Sanders On Michelle Wolf: I Hope She Can Find Happiness
White House warns China on growing militarization in South China Sea
Iran will not ‘renegotiate or add onto’ the nuclear deal, foreign minister says
Motion Picture Academy Expels Bill Cosby And Roman Polanski
Trump shifts story over Michael Cohen payment to Stormy Daniels
In a blistering statement, Camille Cosby says her husband is a victim of mob justice
A look at the 3 Americans detained in North Korea
At least 81 killed by high-intensity dust storms in India
'Empire' Renewed for Season 5 at Fox
Ariana Grande to Open the Billboard Music Awards
Giuliani says Trump repaid lawyer for $130,000 payment to Stormy Daniels
White House's top Russia lawyer Ty Cobb departs in latest Trump shake-up
Cambridge Analytica announces closure
US v IRAN: Tehran ordered to pay $6BN to 9/11 families for helping terror attack
Basque group ETA announces it has 'completely dissolved'
Taming the multiverse. Stephen Hawking's final theory about the big bang
Macron Calls Australian PM’s Wife ‘Delicious’
Prince Harry gives British press the cold shoulder ahead of the royal wedding to Meghan Markle
Ariana Grande Takes Over 'The Tonight Show', Announces New Album
Hundreds detained after Paris May Day protests turn violent
Kanye West just said 400 years of slavery was a choice
Trump's ex-doctor claims Trump dictated glowing health letter
Facebook is taking on Tinder with new dating feature
At least 14 members of immigrant caravan allowed to apply for asylum, organizers say
Tony Awards: 'Mean Girls,' 'SpongeBob SquarePants' Top List of Nominations
Ashley Judd discusses her lawsuit against Harvey Weinstein on 'Good Morning America'
Trump slams 'disgraceful' leak of Mueller questions
WhatsApp CEO Jan Koum quits over privacy disagreements with Facebook
Trump: Killing Iran nuclear deal will send 'right message' to North Korea ahead of talks
Late-Night Hosts Defend Michelle Wolf's WHCD Speech
Cardinal George Pell, Vatican Treasurer, Will Stand Trial For Sexual Abuse
Kim Jong Un agrees to meet Donald Trump at DMZ, source says
In meeting with Nigerian president, Trump now says there's 'no place more beautiful'
Ten journalists among 36 killed in Afghanistan attacks
Porn star Stormy Daniels sues Trump for defamation
Netanyahu says he has proof of secret Iranian nuclear program
Trump suggests meeting Kim Jong-un at Peace House on South Korea border
Gloria Allred booed for yelling 'Bill Cosby Guilty!' at Daytime Emmy Awards
Sajid Javid named new UK home secretary after Windrush scandal
Sainsbury's to buy Asda from Walmart for $10.1 billion
World's oldest known spider dies at 43 after a quiet life underground
Kabul: more than 20 dead as explosions hit city centre
White House mystery: Where is Macron’s gifted oak tree?
Missile attack kills 26, mostly Iranians in Syria, report says
NAFTA-linked visas for Canada and Mexico need a closer look before Congress passes NAFTA 2.0
Daytime Emmys: The Winners List
UK home secretary resigns over immigration scandal
Pompeo says US stands with Israelis, Saudis against Iran
Michelle Wolf Debuts First Promo for Netflix Late-Night Show
Celtic seal Scottish Premiership title with 5-0 rampage over Rangers
London elections set to leave British PM May down, but not out
Iran confirms arrest of British-Iranian professor
'Like father like daughter': comedian Michelle Wolf stuns media with attack on White House team
You may soon be able to control your home with a smart wall
North Korea will close nuclear test site in May, South says
Why Bill Cosby may not spend any time in prison
Trump and Merkel tried – and failed – to hide their differences in Washington
Melania Trump 'CANNOT do anything' Brigitte Macron condemns White House security
Pompeo starts Mideast tour with call for new Iran sanctions
Katy Perry and Orlando Bloom meet the Pope, step out together in Rome
Trump 'absolutely' deserves credit on Korean peace talks, Australia's prime minister says
Azerbaijan Grand Prix 2018 FP3 results: Lewis Hamilton pipped by Sebastian Vettel
Alfie Evans dies at Alder Hey hospital after life support withdrawn
Happy Ed Balls Day!
7 students killed in knife attack at Chinese school
Kim Kardashian Breaks Silence On Khloe Cheating Scandal
Russians followed up on Trump Tower meeting after election, Democrats say
Israeli forces kill three Palestinians amid protests along Gaza border
Jason Witten plans to retire from Cowboys, take 'Monday Night Football' job, per report
James Corden Hosts 'Avengers: Infinity War' Cast on Tour Around Los Angeles
Pompeo says Trump likely to leave Iran nuclear agreement
President Trump and Germany's Merkel hold press conference
ABBA return after 35 years with two new songs
Prince Louis: Royals name third child
The summit In pictures: Cheers, applause and tears
Avengers Infinity War spoiler-free REVIEW: Does the Marvel epic live up to the hype?
Colbert Left Speechless By Trump’s Terrible ‘Birthday Present’ For Melania
Trump tweets on 2026 World Cup bid
Kim Jong Un and Moon Jae-in declare new chapter in Korean relations at high-stakes summit
Trump sounds off on Comey, Cohen, Kanye and more in freewheeling 'Fox & Friends' interview
Donald Trump to meet Queen on UK visit in July
Wisconsin explosion: DOZENS hurt after 'SONIC BOOM' in US city - EVACUATION underway
NASA and ESA Are Getting Serious About Bringing Martian Soil to Earth
Mike Pompeo sworn in as Trump's second secretary of state
Bill Cosby makes outburst in court after guilty verdict
Protests in Spain as five men cleared of teenager's gang rape
Putin’s WARNING to the West: Russia unleashes fearsome Su-30 strikes in chilling threat
Ronny Jackson withdraws as VA secretary nominee
Harry picks Prince William as best man for wedding to Meghan Markle
Shawn Mendes awkwardly consoles rejected man as girlfriend shuts down proposal live on air
Facebook posts record revenues for first quarter despite privacy scandal
Venice to SEGREGATE locals from visitors in a bid of control mass tourism
Trump officials warn of arrests as migrant caravan reaches US border
Late-Night Hosts Pick Apart Kanye West's Pro-Trump Tweets
Kim Jong Un to cross line at DMZ: Here's what will happen
May loses Lords vote on post-Brexit powers for ministers
Bayern Munich 1-2 Real Madrid REACTION: Cristiano Ronaldo blanks in Champions League win
President Trump thanks Kanye West for complimenting him on Twitter
Bradley Cooper to Get American Cinematheque Award Honor
After the hugs and kisses, Macron rips Trumpism
U.S. Supreme Court weighs legality of Trump's travel ban
Russia’s Supreme Court upholds criminal conviction against opposition leader Alexei Navalny
Khloe Kardashian, Tristan Thompson's relationship 'not in a good place,' report says
Amazon unveils colorful Echo Dot for kids
Danish inventor given life sentence for gruesome Kim Wall murder
North Korea to discuss DENUCLEARISATION during explosive talks this Friday
EU urge Russia, Iran, Turkey to deliver on Syria promises
BMW's Concept iX3 dials back the futuristic styling
Colbert Solves The Mystery Of Why Melania Won’t Hold Trump’s Hand
Liverpool 5-2 Roma: Jurgen Klopp delivers verdict on Champions League semi-final win
Anzac Day 2018: When do Australia and New Zealand celebrate their fallen soldiers?
Mummified remains found on construction site in Iran could be father of last shah
Donald Trump warns Iran it ‘will have bigger problems’ if it restarts nuclear program
Melania Trump is finally getting her moment
Ronny Jackson, Trump's pick for veterans affairs job, faces hearing delay
What we know about Toronto van attack suspect Alek Minassian
Earthquake in southeast Turkey injures dozens
Trump welcomes Macron to White House
New 'Venom' Trailer Unveils Tom Hardy's Anti-Hero Transformation
U.S. appeals court rejects monkey business over selfies
The Latest: Taliban attack checkpoint, kill 5 Afghan troops
Face recognition for galaxies: Artificial intelligence brings new tools to astronomy
'American Idol': Top 10 Revealed
Michelle Obama Sends Sweet Message To The New Royal Baby
Colbert Proves Trump Wrong With A Single Photo
Macron hopes Trump relationship can help make France great again
Waffle House shooting suspect Travis Reinking captured in woods with loaded silver handgun
Amazon is reportedly working on its first home robot
Police Respond After Van Rams Into Crowd Of Pedestrians On Toronto Street
Armenian Prime Minister resigns after protests
It's a boy! Photos of the new royal baby
Trump under pressure to stand by Iran nuclear deal
NASA Aircraft Spots Mysterious Circles In Remote Arctic Sea Ice
Professor Who Sold Facebook Data To Cambridge Analytica ‘Sincerely Sorry’
Paris suspect Abdeslam jailed in Belgium
MasterChef contestant Matt Campbell dies after collapsing during London Marathon
Kate Middleton Has Been Admitted to Hospital to Deliver Royal Baby No. 3
LeBron James: Cavs star fuels Lance Stephenson rivalry after Game 4 win over Pacers
South Korea silences cross-border propaganda broadcasts before summit
WATCH: Macron STRUGGLES to explain support collapse as riots PLUNGE France into chaos
'American Idol': Top 14 Sing for America's Vote
4 Presidents, 4 First Ladies Pose For Photo At Barbara Bush Funeral
What we know about the Tennessee Waffle House shooting
Macron to put 'bromance' with Trump to the test during US visit
Trump says North Korea nuclear crisis 'long way from conclusion'
Kellyanne Conway says asking about her husband's anti-Trump tweets is a 'double standard'
DJ Avicii's death: Authorities rule out 'criminal suspicion'
London Marathon Beats Record For Hottest Ever
Olivier Giroud: Chelsea star scored one of the greatest FA Cup goals - Jermaine Jenas
London Marathon 2018: Katie Price and Joel Dommett among celebs gearing up to face heat
Mitt Romney will face primary after setback in run for US Senate
Waffle House shooting: Naked gunman opens fire in Nashville restaurant - 3 dead, 4 injured
Dozens dead in bombing at Kabul voter registration centre
Jane Goodall Celebrates Earth Day in Sunday's Google Doodle
Prince Harry arrives at London Marathon after Queen starts it off
'It will not be very pleasant,' Iran warns, if Trump sabotages nuclear deal
Your Gmail account is about to change forever - Five new features every user needs to know
Saudi forces shoot down drone in the capital as Middle East tensions escalate
Nabi Tajima, world's oldest person, dies in Japan at 117
Man bitten by shark, bear, snake in less than 4 years
Verne Troyer, 'Mini-Me' in Austin Powers films, dies at 49
Manchester United’s Ander Herrera sinks Tottenham in semi-final
How to make your own custom Alexa commands
'The first lady of the greatest generation': Barbara Bush honored for her humor and warmth at funeral in Houston
Inspectors visit site of suspected chemical attack in Syria after delays
Melania Trump looks to history for inspired state dinner with the Macrons
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle meet Sydney Invictus heroes
Queen Elizabeth II celebrates 92nd birthday
'Smallville' actress Mack charged in sex trafficking case
Israeli forces kill two at Gaza frontier during fourth week of protests
Trump fires back on Twitter over Democrats' lawsuit
Stormy Daniels' Lawyer Says He Thinks There Are "Embarrassing" Documents About Sean Hannity
Kim Jong Un: North Korea no longer needs nuclear tests, state-run media reports
Theresa May says Windrush victims will be paid compensation
Democratic Party sues Russia, Trump campaign and WikiLeaks, claiming conspiracy to help Trump win election
Prince Charles reportedly to lead Commonwealth
Swedish house DJ Avicii dead at 28
David Copperfield forced to reveal magic trick secret in lawsuit
Armstrong agrees to pay $5 million to settle cheating lawsuit
Parkland survivors rally in Colo. on eve of Columbine massacre
Arsene Wenger to step down as Arsenal manager at end of season
Pyongyang calling: North and South Korean leaders get hotline as stage set for summit
Bomb found in Berlin - city centre evacuated
Natalie Portman snubs 'Jewish Nobel' in apparent protest against Israel
Close