Close
Date TimeSeptember 29, 2017
VoiceLets Talk About Hugh Hefners Political Legacy - New York Times

Since the news that Hugh Hefner died on Wednesday night, at 91, the obituaries and tributes have been pouring in. While many have focused on the pajama-clad avatar of sybaritic male pleasure, others have paid tribute to a less familiar figure: Hef the progressive.

No less a liberal lion than Norman Lear praised him on Twitter as “a true explorer.” Jesse Jackson hailed him as a strong supporter of the civil rights movement, while Larry King called him “a GIANT” of free speech. Others noted that while Hefner loved to excoriate feminists in the pages of Playboy, he was a supporter of some of their causes, including abortion rights and the Equal Rights Amendment.
It was an image Mr. Hefner himself was keen to promote, especially in recent years. But how well does the idea of Hef the liberator of women really hold up? The New York Times Culture writers Amanda Hess, Wesley Morris and Taffy Brodesser-Akner joined me in a discussion of Hefner’s social and cultural legacy.

JENNIFER SCHUESSLER First, a disclosure. I grew up outside Chicago — the original seat of the Hefner empire — but my primary exposure to Playboy was furtive glances at houses where I was babysitting. (I’m pretty sure I wasn’t looking at it for the articles.)
But the magazine, at least in the beginning, wasn’t meant for us ladies, of whatever age. The editorial in the first issue, in 1953, put it bluntly: “If you’re somebody’s sister, wife or mother-in-law and picked us up by mistake, please pass us along to the man in your life and get back to your Ladies’ Home Companion.”

O.K., that was then. Today, Playboy’s tagline is “Entertainment for All.” What has Playboy done for women?
TAFFY BRODESSER-AKNER I have a disclosure, too: I wrote for Playboy (proudly) at the beginning of my career. They gave me my first celebrity assignment, in fact, which has become my bread and butter (not to imply that celebrities eat either bread or butter). Playboy was a magazine for men. Whatever its political stance, it didn’t pretend it was going for inclusivity. Why would it? Does Redbook have a column for men (wait, does it?)? Does Vogue give back-hair grooming advice?

AMANDA HESS I suppose I should disclose that I once wrote an article for Playboy.com about straight guys who are into butt stuff. Moving on ——
BRODESSER-AKNER Wait, why would we move on from that?
HESS Welcome to The Times, Taffy. I’m interested in Mr. Hefner’s legacy as an architect of the sexual revolution, a claim that’s been repeated so often, for so long, that at this point it goes unexamined. What he did was more like a sexual pivot. He rebranded the objectification of women as both intellectual and cute. He kicked off the magazine by buying a nude photograph that Marilyn Monroe had posed for when she was unknown, desperate and broke, and reframing it as an object of public celebration.
When his fans list all the progressive causes that Mr. Hefner championed — civil rights, gay rights, “sexual freedom”— gender equality is not among them, because he was never invested in a revolution of sexual relationships. His project ultimately had very little to do with sex. His brand, to me, was about power — he was a guy who kept a collection of living dolls in his playhouse, an environment that he could fully control, so he never left.

WESLEY MORRIS Amanda, that’s deeply true. Have you all ever seen the syndicated shows “Playboy’s Penthouse” or “Playboy After Dark?” They ran from 1959 through the 1960s and were part talk show, part haunted house. Guests are drifting around the set while the camera follows Mr. Hefner around the apartment, where occasionally Lenny Bruce or Nat King Cole or Buddy Rich might show up and have a conversation about what they’re up to. Once, Mr. Hefner gathered Cole, Bruce and the composer Cy Coleman in the living room area. Cole and Bruce did a lot of the talking, and behind them is a woman, lounging on the floor, gripping a railing and smiling.
Meanwhile, on the sofa, is Rona Jaffe. Her book “The Best of Everything” had just become a movie with Hope Lange and Joan Crawford, and she’s there to promote it. It’s not until most of the famous men have left that Hefner addresses her. It’s just a strange crystallization of the Playboy ethos. Women are people who make and do things. They’re also décor.
SCHUESSLER Can we talk about how much of a time capsule that all is? It seems like a lot of the celebration of Mr. Hefner now is nostalgic. Creepy as some may have found him, he was pretty benign compared to a lot of what else is out there now. Today’s men’s rights/bro-culture crowd doesn’t pretend to be interested in taking their porn with a side of Picasso.
BRODESSER-AKNER What’s remarkable is that much of that nostalgia was fomented by Playboy itself. I don’t know if there was a more self-referential magazine around.
HESS It makes sense, then, that Mr. Hefner would become an early reality star with “The Girls Next Door” — though I’m not sure that the bright lights of TV did much to preserve the allure of the grotto, or his silk pajamas.

BRODESSER-AKNER
I love that the Playboy website tries to reset that image with just one photo: Young Hefner, staring straight into the camera, phallic object out of side of mouth. And with this quote: “Life is too short to be living someone else’s dream.”
This would be inspiring, I suppose, if not for the fact that it is now the page for every Playboy link, meaning on some level it’s the middle finger to everyone who’s ever read Playboy. Get your own fantasy. This was mine. It’s over now. Go make something yourself. This is probably not what the post meant, but Playboy has been so clumsy these last few years, when the magazine became something that tried to be modern. How do you make this modern? You know what’s modern? Porn.

SCHUESSLER It’s really too bad about that placeholder, and not just because I want to read both of your articles. Vice ran an interesting story just last month about Playboy’s recent “woke” rebranding under Cooper Hefner, one of Hugh’s sons. The tagline “Entertainment for Men” became “Entertainment for All.” (Well, maybe not all: They brought back nude photos, which had been banished in 2015). Cooper said the battle to allow topless women on the cover of Playboy, just like topless men are allowed on the cover of Men’s Health, was a “feminist fight.”

BRODESSER-AKNER I don’t know. Did we really need Hef to let us be naked? The nudity came with so many conditions: It wasn’t just a woman who conformed to our ideals of beauty. It was a woman who conformed to his ideals of beauty, made even more Hef-perfect in photoshop, giving her digital labiaplasty and making her belly button — her belly button! — more adorable.

MORRIS This is where I should say two things. First, I’m pretty gay. Playboy was a depiction of women that baffled me. As a kid, I couldn’t even make the joke about reading the articles, because I didn’t know there were any. Playboy was kryptonite, and the boys I was around preferred Hefner’s mutant offspring. (As a grown man, I did discover the Playboy Interview, which had the intoxicating, sometimes flabbergasting candor of the show.)

Second, I grew up in a Johnson Publishing household, which published Jet magazine at the time. It still features Beauty of the Week. As much as I thought it’d be fun to type “John H. Johnson was the Hugh Hefner of black America,” that would be untrue, since Johnson’s progressiveness was more evident in that he wanted to elevate a race and showcase all it could be. Hugh Hefner might have had Nat King Cole come by the penthouse, but it took a while for him to invite a nonwhite woman onto his pages. There’s progressive, then there’s progressive.

BRODESSER-AKNER This idea that Playboy was feminist is also really strange. Yes, Hef told Esquire in 2007 that he was “a feminist before there was such a thing as feminism.” He gave money to abortion rights causes and to the A.C.L.U. In 1965, the magazine came out in favor of a woman’s right to choose. That’s great, but there are reasons to support abortion rights outside of feminism, right? If, let’s say, you were running a magazine in the pre-Pill era that advocated as much sex with as many female partners as possible.

HESS It seems appropriate that our final cultural image of Hugh Hefner is a sexless one: The geriatric puttering around the house in his pajamas, surrounding himself with young women who made him seem even older, only achieving actual coitus with medical intervention. Now he’ll be laid to rest in the crypt next to Marilyn Monroe’s — he paid $75,000 for the plot back in 1992. He used her body to launch his brand and now he’s used it to retire it, too. Let’s not forget that Mr. Hefner’s whole branding “relationship” with Ms. Monroe — from the magazine centerfold to the crypt — were undertaken without Monroe’s consent. It’s a morbid symbolic coupling. This time, though, both partners are objects.

BRODESSER-AKNER Ugh, is that true, Amanda? I didn’t know that. When I wrote for Playboy, I went to the Playmate of the Year party. It was decorated like a bat mitzvah: pink tent, chocolate-covered strawberries, squealing young women. Hef was always at the center, surrounded by blondes and then another layer of security. People stood near the grotto, talking about the good old days. Playboy fell like Rome — slowly, then all at once.

UK only has HOURS to prepare for WW3: North Korea vs US is REAL possibility - shock report
Theresa meets Ange: May to steal 30 minutes away from EU prying eyes to speak to Merkel
This Blind Astrophysicist 'Sees' the Universe in the Most Amazing Way | Short Film Showcase
UK's top supplier of supermarket chicken fiddles food safety dates
Attorney: Kushner used private email account to talk to WH officials
Uber ruling puts jobs at risk, says Theresa May
Inside the Playboy Mansion With Hugh Hefner - RollingStone.com
Julia Louis-Dreyfus Reveals Breast Cancer Diagnosis
Rising up against May: 50,000 anti-Brexit protesters to descend on Tory conference
What is the Jones Act?
Rep. Steve Scalise returns to House after shooting
Netflix commits half a billion dollars to new Canadian productions: sources
U.S. Plans To Monitor Immigrants’ Social Media Accounts, Search Histories
Theresa May threatens US TRADE WAR over Bombardier row
Emmanuel Macron launches SAVAGE attack on David Cameron for failing during Brexit campaign
Hefner started Playboy with $600 and built it into a multimillion-dollar entertainment empire. He died at 91
'Survivor' Season 35: The First One Out Reveals What Went Wrong
Trudeau ‘disappointed’ in U.S. decision to slap 220 per cent duty on Canada’s Bombardier jets
World War 3 latest: Russia on war footing as Putin's troops amass on North Korea border
Robots could destabilise world through war and unemployment, says UN
Passengers in Puerto Rican airport have little water or food, no working ATMs and no idea when they'll leave
'Big Brother' Fan-Favorites to Compete on 'The Amazing Race' (Exclusive)
Russia and US will cooperate to build moon's first space station
Iraqi Kurds back independence in referendum
'Schengen dies, EU dies' Brussels faces tussle with Merkel and Macron over border controls
Prince Harry hits the CN Tower and the crowd goes wild
Britain will be BETTER OFF after Brexit and EU could FAIL, Austrian politician says
Roy Moore beats Trump’s choice to claim Alabama’s GOP Senate nomination
Jurgen Klopp frustrated as Liverpool fail to unlock Spartak on crazy European night
Twitter trials 280-character tweet limit
Prince George is already fed up of school and does NOT want to go, Prince William reveals
Clinton: White House private emails 'height of hypocrisy'
What doctors want from health care reform
BREAKING: Russia fires ballistic missile with HUGE warhead as Putin ratchets up WW3 threat
BREAKING: Trump says US will take 'devastating military option' to end North Korea tension
Madonna Tries Her Kim Kardashian Impression on 'The Tonight Show'
Microsoft's new coding language is made for quantum computers - Engadget
As millions struggle for food, water and fuel after Hurricane Maria, Trump tweeted how Puerto Rico is billions in debt
ADIOS MAJORCA: End of an era as Britons HATED by ‘arrogant locals’ start leaving isle
U.S. Vice-President Mike Pence blasts ‘failings’ of Canadian health system
Palestinian gunman kills three Israelis in West Bank
Thousands in mass evacuation as Monaro volcano ERUPTS
Tony Blair claims UK opinion changing on Iraq War outrage despite 'faulty evidence'
The war of words could be pushing the region to the point where a wrong move could be calamitous
'Big Bang Theory' Boss Explains That Season 11 Premiere Double Shocker
North Korea accuses Trump of declaring war
For Prince Harry and Meghan Markle, it's love during wheelchair tennis match at Invictus Games
'Pretty Little Liars' Spinoff Starring Sasha Pieterse, Janel Parrish a Go at Freeform
Chelsea Manning says she's been denied entry into Canada
Review: Megyn Kelly tries to ditch politics for 'fun' on 'Today'
The country's foreign minister says President Trump declared war through a tweet over the weekend
What's the deal with the new travel ban? - CBS News
Uber boss Dara Khosrowshahi apologises after London ban
'German vote shows federalism has FAILED' Vanis Varoufakis says four years of EU collapse
Jeremy Corbyn BANS Labour conference vote on Brexit - uses 'ultra-lefts' to stop MPs vote
America watched as NFL players united in protest after Trump's criticism. These are the most powerful photos
'I, Tonya' Gets 2017 Awards-Qualifying Release Date (Exclusive)
Gunman opens fire in Nashville church; 1 dead, 8 hurt
BREXIT SABOTAGE: Macron and Merkel to unleash plot to tie UK to Brussels FOREVER
Trump responds to protests: Locking arms is good, kneeling is not
'Now you can feel Russia's power:' Russian military in Syria eager to show its victories
German election polls latest LIVE: Angela Merkel and AfD push for victory in final hour
NFL Players Kneel to Protest Anthem and Trump Comments in Opening Game
Women should pop a squat for equality: Teitel
BBC's Laura Kuenssberg to get 'bodyguards to protect her from Labour hate mob'
LeBron James Explains Why Trump’s Attack On The NFL Is Personal
‘You’re not just here to inspire, you’re here to win’: Trudeau to athletes at Invictus Games opening ceremony
Brexit: Jeremy Corbyn urges caution on single market
Meghan Markle makes first PUBLIC appearance with Prince Harry at Invictus Games
Mystery SOLVED: Archaeologists uncover who made the Great Pyramid of Giza
Bruce Maxwell is the first MLB player to kneel during the national anthem
The President, NFL commissioner and top basketball players are embroiled in a public fight over patriotism
North Korea says rockets to U.S. 'inevitable' as U.S. bombers fly off North Korean coast
Uber protest petition tops 600,000
Westfield shopping centre acid attack: Six injured in east London, police at the scene
MACRON BACKLASH: Angry scenes as thousands march in Paris against president's reforms
With 'son of a b**** comments, Trump tried to divide NFL and its players
Canada could win the Amazon sweepstakes due to Trump scaring 'the bejesus out of everyone'
North Korea hit by EARTHQUAKE sparking fears of fresh Kim Jong-un missile test
Trump said he wanted NFL owners to 'get that son of a b*tch off the field.'
Diego Costa opens up on Chelsea exit and delight at returning home to Atletico Madrid
Brexit: UK needs to clarify issues - Macron
Meghan Markle 'given VIP pass' to Prince Harry’s Invictus Games – will he propose?
UK storm season ARRIVES: Floods to SMASH Britain THIS WEEKEND as misery fortnight begins
Ivanka Trump: It's 'not my job' to be voice of moderation in White House
Ellen DeGeneres Parodies Taylor Swift's 'Look What You Made Me Do' Video
Theresa May fires back at BBC's Kuenssberg during HEATED exchange after Brexit speech
Facebook Is Now The Federal Election Commission, But With More Secrets
Cillizza: President's tweets about a 'Russia hoax' contradict every intel agency and his own adviser
Theresa May Florence speech: Europe reacts LIVE with Brexit chiefs set for warm response
What happens if N. Korea explodes a H-bomb above the Pacific?
Netflix Children's Show Producer Says Penis Drawing Was 'Very Bad Joke' From One Artist
German election becomes battle for third place in coalition
How to make your CV stand out from the crowd
Brink of war: Kim Jong-un vows USA will pay as North Korea considers 'STRONGEST response'
Trump orders new sanctions to tighten screws on North Korea nuclear program
Spain in CRISIS: Troops sent in as 40,000 protest over 'WAR' on Catalan independence vote
Canada struggles to improve conditions for Indigenous People, Trudeau says at the UN
Google's $1.1 billion HTC deal: Can Google learn from its Motorola miscues? - ZDNet
Up yours Barnier! Theresa May to IGNORE ‘French bully’ and do Brexit deal with Merkel
Hurricane Maria heads for Dominican Republic after destruction in Puerto Rico
Theresa May threatens to hold back MILLONS from 'bloated' United Nations
North Korea: Trump's UN speech amounted to 'the sound of a dog barking' - CNN
Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.) can stop this health care bill – but will he?
World War 3: Japan warns North Korea the time for talking is OVER as tensions soar with US
In pictures: Hurricane Maria pummels Puerto Rico
TV Ratings: 'Talent' Scores a 3-Year High
Spanish police arrest Catalan officials in attempt to halt illegal independence referendum - ABC Online
Hillary Clinton mocks ‘manspreading’ Putin on Colbert’s ‘Late Show’
Apple Watch review: Ditch the iPhone
City of London on lockdown in terror alert - police close Moorgate and Liverpool Street
At Least 20 Children Killed After Earthquake Destroys Mexico City Primary School
Hurricane Maria packs 155 mph winds as it roars into Puerto Rico, the strongest storm to hit the island since 1932
No US President has spoken to the world like this
Hillary Clinton Says Goal of New Book Is to Prevent Another 2016 Election
Jimmy Kimmel Criticizes New Health Care Proposal, Says Sen. Bill Cassidy 'Lied Right to My Face'
President Trump addresses the United Nations (entire speech)
TERROR ALERT: Holborn EVACUATED as armed police race to scene amid bomb scare
Diversity took center stage at the Emmys
'Game of Thrones' Podcast: How an Ancient Prophecy Teases the End
Craig David 'most dangerous' celebrity to search online
Workers ‘forced to watch’ child porn
The Category 4 storm now churns toward Puerto Rico, where the governor warns of a 'catastrophe'
Selena Gomez's Mom Opens Up About Her Daughter's Kidney Transplant
'We're running out of time' North Korea is grave nuclear threat, Trump adviser warns
Trudeau threatens to kill purchase of Boeing fighter jets to protest firm’s trade complaint
If You Are Worried About 'Hacked' Democracy, Quit Facebook
Putin keeps a close eye on Russian war games
'South Park' Takes Aim at North Korea in New Episode
‘A mistake we WON’T make again’ German election could KILL Macron-Juncker eurozone dream
Why Are Drug Prices So High? We’re Curious, Too
Maria is expected to get stronger in a hurry as it takes aim at the Caribbean islands devastated by Irma
Exclusive: New Report Offers Proof Of U.S. Hate Crime Rise In The Trump Era
The complete list of Emmy winners
'Netflix Is a Joke' Billboards Unveiled as Comedy Campaign
‘Body parts everywhere’ Hero Marine who saved kids from M5 crash reveals horrific details
World War 3: China FURIOUS with ‘major liability’ North Korea over Kim’s missile tests
Corbyn 'took advantage of Manchester terror attack vigil to GAIN VOTES during election'
Trump retweets edited video of him hitting Hillary Clinton with golf ball
Man dies in hospital after Toronto restaurant shooting
Parsons Green: Second arrest over Tube bombing
Prince Charles may ‘convert Buckingham ­Palace into business-like monarchy HQ’ when King
Don’t look now, but full Obamacare repeal is back on the table
Hurricane Jose looms off the US East Coast
Manitoba's NDP chooses Wab Kinew as new leader - CBC.ca
Casey Affleck's divorce from Summer Phoenix finalized
BREAKING: London Bridge EVACUATED - armed police rush to scene amid terror fears
Toronto to Montreal in 39 minutes? Futuristic people mover zips to next stage
Late-Night Lately: Colbert Prepares for the Emmys, Corden Becomes 'It,' Jennifer Lawrence and Fallon Compete
Barcelona News: Real Madrid star Isco snubbed transfer because of Lionel Messi
‘Dress-wearing’ students must submit photos before dances, Wisconsin high school says
FEMA’s Hurricane Response Is Making Trump Look Good. Thanks, Obama
Parsons Green terror: Teenager arrested in Dover in connection with bomb attack
Beyoncé And Jay-Z Enjoy A Kid-Free Evening At Rihanna's Diamond Ball
Sanders Rips Trump: ‘Let Me Tell You What A Curse On The American People Is’
Theresa May ‘has already set aside £27bn to pay EU for a three-year transition deal’
Facebook hands over Russia-linked ads
Emmys 2017: How to Stream the Show Online
Toronto police find two missing brothers
Parsons Green terror: Theresa May warns attack is IMMINENT - threat level now CRITICAL
Cassini: Probe incinerates on entry to Saturn
LONDON TERROR ATTACK: Police identify key suspect behind Parsons Green Tube explosion
Universal Kids to Release Russian Series 'Masha and the Bear' In U.S
Mother of 6-year-old boy connected to Amber Alert found dead, Quebec police say
What we know so far about the London Underground explosion
Trump again seizes on terror incident to call for travel ban
BREAKING: London terror attack - second bomb at Parsons Green, reports
Witnesses say they heard announcements from officials that 'some kind of explosion' had occurred on a train
Candice Bergen Wore A Message For Melania On Her Sweater
North Korea fires missile
Couples Sex Tapes Reality Series in the Works at eOne, Armoza Formats
Chelsea Manning, Sean Spicer named fellows at Harvard
Trump: There will be a wall, no amnesty
Selena Gomez has kidney transplant after best friend donates organ 'The ultimate gift'
The U.S. wants to negotiate a NAFTA deal that automatically expires after 5 years, commerce secretary says
Martin Shkreli Is Jailed for Seeking a Hair From Hillary Clinton
TV Ratings: 'Talent' Approaches Finale With Wednesday Win
Real Madrid opens Champions League defence on high note
Paris officially named host city for the 2024 Olympic Games
In a series of tweets, Trump denied he made a deal with Dems on immigration
Halle Berry, 51, exposes NIPPLES as she flaunts extreme cleavage in boob-baring top
Japan is building the fastest supercomputer in the world
ESPN's Jemele Hill Responds After White House Criticism of 'Trump is A White Supremacist' Comments
‘Strange things happen every day:’ Merkel sings at election event (VIDEO)
Theresa May to deliver Brexit speech in Florence
Schumer and Pelosi say Trump agreed to fix DACA and tackle border security, minus his border wall. The WH disagrees
Royal wedding on the way? Prince Harry 'introduces Meghan Markle to the Queen at Balmoral'
Clinton Torches Ivanka For ‘Lip Service,’ Says She Should Be ‘Held Accountable’
Hear the White House response to Jemele Hill's tweets
End of the World on September 23, 2017: Shock Bible prophecy warns The Rapture is COMING
Bye-bye, bikini: Kate Upton made her modestly-dressed NYFW debut at Michael Kors
Russia says it proposed full normalization with US under Trump
Feds call July 2018 timeline for marijuana legalization ‘reasonable’
FOOD SHORTAGE: Caribbean running out of supplies
Emmys: Colbert Calls Trump 'Biggest' TV Star, Jokes About Host 'Manual Labor'
Trudeau's Bahamas vacation cost over $215K — far more than initially disclosed
Millions in Florida could be without electricity for weeks with temperatures in the 90s
How 'Black Mirror' Predicted New Apple Technology
The Disaster Artist review – James Franco's ode to bad film-making is a riot
ESPN’s Jemele Hill: Trump Is A ‘White Supremacist’ And Unfit For Office
Close