Close
Date TimeApril 25, 2018
VoicePeers rip up ‘blank chequebook ministers that sought to give themselves’, inflicting heavy defeat
May loses Lords vote on post-Brexit powers for ministers
Peers and MPs claimed a significant victory on Wednesday when an attempt to give sweeping powers to ministers was thrown out of the Brexit bill as complaints about the power of the Lords to reverse the decisions of the Commons grew louder.
In the first of a series of votes on how the powers brought back from Brussels would be limited by the balance between ministers and parliament, peers from all parties defeated the government by 349 to 221 – a majority of 128.
On Tuesday, the Tory backbencher and vociferous Brexiter Jacob Rees-Mogg accused peers of “playing with fire” over Brexit. A petition calling for a referendum on the abolition of the Lords has attracted more than 100,000 signatures and is eligible for a debate at Westminster.
Amnesty International said the Lords had “ripped up the blank chequebook that ministers sought to give themselves.
“The Lords have sent a clear message to the Commons: leaving the EU shouldn’t mean leaving rights behind.”
The vote on Wednesday, which was one of the biggest majorities against the government so far, overturned an attempt to give ministers the power to decide to make changes to EU laws on the basis of what they “considered appropriate” rather than what was necessary.
Critics, led by the crossbencher Lord Lisvane, argued that it was too low a bar to set for what may be very significant decisions. He dismissed a compromise offered by the government to include the phrase “good reason”.
“The test for political decision-making is not simply whether there are good reasons. There may be good reasons for doing something and better reasons for not doing it,” Lisvane said.
He said the EU withdrawal bill would be a precedent for other legislation resulting from Brexit.
“Whichever side of the Brexit debate they stand, people might reasonably believe that taking back control would be under the sovereignty of parliament rather than ceding swaths of power to the executive.”
Among other powers sought by the government but expected to be rejected by the Lords was the power to set up new agencies without an act of parliament, and the power to create new criminal offences.
The government faces three more days of challenges to the bill, in particular over the row with Scotland over devolved powers, which the Scottish National party has refused to accept. As a result Holyrood could refuse to grant legislative consent, creating another standoff with Westminster.
The Brexit minister Lord Callanan argued that the changes risked making the bill unworkable. On Monday, peers overturned a move to exclude the EU charter of fundamental rights from the bill.

Related Stories
Sure, Boris Johnson is funny. But has he ever done a job well?Sure, Boris Johnson is funny. But has he ever done a job well?
Meet The Man Walking 400 Miles From Glasgow To London To Protest NHS PrivatisationMeet The Man Walking 400 Miles From Glasgow To London To Protest NHS Privatisation
Philip Hammond Suggests He Could Vote To Bring Down Boris Johnsons Government Over No-Deal BrexitPhilip Hammond Suggests He Could Vote To Bring Down Boris Johnson's Government Over No-Deal Brexit
Kim Darroch quits as UK ambassador to US after Johnson remarksKim Darroch quits as UK ambassador to US 'after Johnson remarks'
If Tom Watson had guts, he would quit Labour. Instead he is weakening the party | Dawn FosterIf Tom Watson had guts, he would quit Labour. Instead he is weakening the party | Dawn Foster
Tom Harwood on Question Time: Brexit Party anthem protest dignifiedTom Harwood on Question Time: Brexit Party anthem protest 'dignified'
Grant Shapps: What can we expect from Boris Johnsons new transport secretary, from HS2 to Heathrow?Grant Shapps: What can we expect from Boris Johnson's new transport secretary, from HS2 to Heathrow?
Sunday Shows Round-Up: Hammond Out, Brexit Impasse, Iran Failure And Labour Anti-SemitismSunday Shows Round-Up: Hammond Out, Brexit Impasse, Iran 'Failure' And Labour Anti-Semitism
UK PM Johnson tells EU: ditch the backstop or there will be no-deal BrexitUK PM Johnson tells EU: ditch the backstop or there will be no-deal Brexit
Boris Johnson and Donald Trump Are Peak White Male PrivilegeBoris Johnson and Donald Trump Are Peak White Male Privilege
Latest News
US issues warrant for seizure of Iranian tanker in GibraltarUS issues warrant for seizure of Iranian tanker in Gibraltar
Gutsy Newbury win puts Technician back in frame for success in St LegerGutsy Newbury win puts Technician back in frame for success in St Leger
Svetlana Kuznetsova beats Ashleigh Barty to meet Madison Keys in finalSvetlana Kuznetsova beats Ashleigh Barty to meet Madison Keys in final
Shortcomings of Lampard the manager echo those of Lampard the player | Jonathan WilsonShortcomings of Lampard the manager echo those of Lampard the player | Jonathan Wilson
Aaron Wan-Bissaka is quick to make an impression at Manchester UnitedAaron Wan-Bissaka is quick to make an impression at Manchester United
Sheffield United’s Ollie Norwood: ‘Fergie told me I’d get here … I don’t know if he meant it’Sheffield United’s Ollie Norwood: ‘Fergie told me I’d get here … I don’t know if he meant it’
The Businesses Stockpiling For A Disastrous No-Deal BrexitThe Businesses Stockpiling For A 'Disastrous' No-Deal Brexit
Owen Jones attacked outside London pubOwen Jones attacked outside London pub
Trump suspends CNN analysts credentials in another shot at the pressTrump suspends CNN analyst's credentials in another shot at the press
Alan Jones told he will be sacked if he makes more offensive comments on radioAlan Jones told he will be sacked if he makes more offensive comments on radio
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
Sure, Boris Johnson is funny. But has he ever done a job well?Sure, Boris Johnson is funny. But has he ever done a job well?
Meet The Man Walking 400 Miles From Glasgow To London To Protest NHS PrivatisationMeet The Man Walking 400 Miles From Glasgow To London To Protest NHS Privatisation
Philip Hammond Suggests He Could Vote To Bring Down Boris Johnsons Government Over No-Deal BrexitPhilip Hammond Suggests He Could Vote To Bring Down Boris Johnson's Government Over No-Deal Brexit
Kim Darroch quits as UK ambassador to US after Johnson remarksKim Darroch quits as UK ambassador to US 'after Johnson remarks'
If Tom Watson had guts, he would quit Labour. Instead he is weakening the party | Dawn FosterIf Tom Watson had guts, he would quit Labour. Instead he is weakening the party | Dawn Foster
Tom Harwood on Question Time: Brexit Party anthem protest dignifiedTom Harwood on Question Time: Brexit Party anthem protest 'dignified'
Grant Shapps: What can we expect from Boris Johnsons new transport secretary, from HS2 to Heathrow?Grant Shapps: What can we expect from Boris Johnson's new transport secretary, from HS2 to Heathrow?
Sunday Shows Round-Up: Hammond Out, Brexit Impasse, Iran Failure And Labour Anti-SemitismSunday Shows Round-Up: Hammond Out, Brexit Impasse, Iran 'Failure' And Labour Anti-Semitism
UK PM Johnson tells EU: ditch the backstop or there will be no-deal BrexitUK PM Johnson tells EU: ditch the backstop or there will be no-deal Brexit
Boris Johnson and Donald Trump Are Peak White Male PrivilegeBoris Johnson and Donald Trump Are Peak White Male Privilege
Latest News
US issues warrant for seizure of Iranian tanker in GibraltarUS issues warrant for seizure of Iranian tanker in Gibraltar
Gutsy Newbury win puts Technician back in frame for success in St LegerGutsy Newbury win puts Technician back in frame for success in St Leger
Svetlana Kuznetsova beats Ashleigh Barty to meet Madison Keys in finalSvetlana Kuznetsova beats Ashleigh Barty to meet Madison Keys in final
Shortcomings of Lampard the manager echo those of Lampard the player | Jonathan WilsonShortcomings of Lampard the manager echo those of Lampard the player | Jonathan Wilson
Aaron Wan-Bissaka is quick to make an impression at Manchester UnitedAaron Wan-Bissaka is quick to make an impression at Manchester United
Sheffield United’s Ollie Norwood: ‘Fergie told me I’d get here … I don’t know if he meant it’Sheffield United’s Ollie Norwood: ‘Fergie told me I’d get here … I don’t know if he meant it’
The Businesses Stockpiling For A Disastrous No-Deal BrexitThe Businesses Stockpiling For A 'Disastrous' No-Deal Brexit
Owen Jones attacked outside London pubOwen Jones attacked outside London pub
Trump suspends CNN analysts credentials in another shot at the pressTrump suspends CNN analyst's credentials in another shot at the press
Alan Jones told he will be sacked if he makes more offensive comments on radioAlan Jones told he will be sacked if he makes more offensive comments on radio
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Bayern Munich 1-2 Real Madrid REACTION: Cristiano Ronaldo blanks in Champions League win
President Trump thanks Kanye West for complimenting him on Twitter
Bradley Cooper to Get American Cinematheque Award Honor
After the hugs and kisses, Macron rips Trumpism
U.S. Supreme Court weighs legality of Trump's travel ban
Russia’s Supreme Court upholds criminal conviction against opposition leader Alexei Navalny
Khloe Kardashian, Tristan Thompson's relationship 'not in a good place,' report says
Amazon unveils colorful Echo Dot for kids
Danish inventor given life sentence for gruesome Kim Wall murder
North Korea to discuss DENUCLEARISATION during explosive talks this Friday
EU urge Russia, Iran, Turkey to deliver on Syria promises
BMW's Concept iX3 dials back the futuristic styling
Colbert Solves The Mystery Of Why Melania Won’t Hold Trump’s Hand
Liverpool 5-2 Roma: Jurgen Klopp delivers verdict on Champions League semi-final win
Anzac Day 2018: When do Australia and New Zealand celebrate their fallen soldiers?
Mummified remains found on construction site in Iran could be father of last shah
Donald Trump warns Iran it ‘will have bigger problems’ if it restarts nuclear program
Melania Trump is finally getting her moment
Ronny Jackson, Trump's pick for veterans affairs job, faces hearing delay
What we know about Toronto van attack suspect Alek Minassian
Earthquake in southeast Turkey injures dozens
Trump welcomes Macron to White House
New 'Venom' Trailer Unveils Tom Hardy's Anti-Hero Transformation
U.S. appeals court rejects monkey business over selfies
The Latest: Taliban attack checkpoint, kill 5 Afghan troops
Face recognition for galaxies: Artificial intelligence brings new tools to astronomy
'American Idol': Top 10 Revealed
Michelle Obama Sends Sweet Message To The New Royal Baby
Colbert Proves Trump Wrong With A Single Photo
Macron hopes Trump relationship can help make France great again
Waffle House shooting suspect Travis Reinking captured in woods with loaded silver handgun
Amazon is reportedly working on its first home robot
Police Respond After Van Rams Into Crowd Of Pedestrians On Toronto Street
Armenian Prime Minister resigns after protests
It's a boy! Photos of the new royal baby
Trump under pressure to stand by Iran nuclear deal
NASA Aircraft Spots Mysterious Circles In Remote Arctic Sea Ice
Professor Who Sold Facebook Data To Cambridge Analytica ‘Sincerely Sorry’
Paris suspect Abdeslam jailed in Belgium
MasterChef contestant Matt Campbell dies after collapsing during London Marathon
Kate Middleton Has Been Admitted to Hospital to Deliver Royal Baby No. 3
LeBron James: Cavs star fuels Lance Stephenson rivalry after Game 4 win over Pacers
South Korea silences cross-border propaganda broadcasts before summit
WATCH: Macron STRUGGLES to explain support collapse as riots PLUNGE France into chaos
'American Idol': Top 14 Sing for America's Vote
4 Presidents, 4 First Ladies Pose For Photo At Barbara Bush Funeral
What we know about the Tennessee Waffle House shooting
Macron to put 'bromance' with Trump to the test during US visit
Trump says North Korea nuclear crisis 'long way from conclusion'
Kellyanne Conway says asking about her husband's anti-Trump tweets is a 'double standard'
DJ Avicii's death: Authorities rule out 'criminal suspicion'
London Marathon Beats Record For Hottest Ever
Olivier Giroud: Chelsea star scored one of the greatest FA Cup goals - Jermaine Jenas
London Marathon 2018: Katie Price and Joel Dommett among celebs gearing up to face heat
Mitt Romney will face primary after setback in run for US Senate
Waffle House shooting: Naked gunman opens fire in Nashville restaurant - 3 dead, 4 injured
Dozens dead in bombing at Kabul voter registration centre
Jane Goodall Celebrates Earth Day in Sunday's Google Doodle
Prince Harry arrives at London Marathon after Queen starts it off
'It will not be very pleasant,' Iran warns, if Trump sabotages nuclear deal
Your Gmail account is about to change forever - Five new features every user needs to know
Saudi forces shoot down drone in the capital as Middle East tensions escalate
Nabi Tajima, world's oldest person, dies in Japan at 117
Man bitten by shark, bear, snake in less than 4 years
Verne Troyer, 'Mini-Me' in Austin Powers films, dies at 49
Manchester United’s Ander Herrera sinks Tottenham in semi-final
How to make your own custom Alexa commands
'The first lady of the greatest generation': Barbara Bush honored for her humor and warmth at funeral in Houston
Inspectors visit site of suspected chemical attack in Syria after delays
Melania Trump looks to history for inspired state dinner with the Macrons
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle meet Sydney Invictus heroes
Queen Elizabeth II celebrates 92nd birthday
'Smallville' actress Mack charged in sex trafficking case
Israeli forces kill two at Gaza frontier during fourth week of protests
Trump fires back on Twitter over Democrats' lawsuit
Stormy Daniels' Lawyer Says He Thinks There Are 'Embarrassing' Documents About Sean Hannity
Kim Jong Un: North Korea no longer needs nuclear tests, state-run media reports
Theresa May says Windrush victims will be paid compensation
Democratic Party sues Russia, Trump campaign and WikiLeaks, claiming conspiracy to help Trump win election
Prince Charles reportedly to lead Commonwealth
Swedish house DJ Avicii dead at 28
David Copperfield forced to reveal magic trick secret in lawsuit
Armstrong agrees to pay $5 million to settle cheating lawsuit
Parkland survivors rally in Colo. on eve of Columbine massacre
Arsene Wenger to step down as Arsenal manager at end of season
Pyongyang calling: North and South Korean leaders get hotline as stage set for summit
Bomb found in Berlin - city centre evacuated
Natalie Portman snubs 'Jewish Nobel' in apparent protest against Israel
Comey Memos Provide Intimate Look Into Trump Presidency
China challenged Australian warships in South China Sea
Video of Iran 'morality police' wrestling with woman sparks outrage
PARIS UNDER SIEGE: Protestors CLASH with police amid fury over Macron's labour reforms
Russia, NATO military chiefs meet in Azerbaijan
NASA’s Tess spacecraft embarks on ‘Goldilocks’ planet search
'Late Show With Stephen Colbert' writer slammed for insensitive Barbara Bush tweet
Jennifer Lopez to Premiere Song at Billboard Latin Music Awards
Oklahoma Wildfires Leave At Least 2 Dead, 20 Injured
Trump: ‘Human Trafficking Is Worse Than It’s Ever Been In The History Of World’
North Korea wants total denuclearisation, says Seoul
Facebook moves 1.5bn users out of reach of new European privacy law
Amazon Prime Hits 100M Subscribers
Haley's retort shows why she's unique in Trump's White House
Government in chaos over Windrush after double setback for May
Vladimir Putin’s salary REVEALED: Does Russia’s STRONGMAN earn as much as you think?
Devastating Indonesia EARTHQUAKE kills 3 and damages HUNDREDS of homes
Royal wedding: Meghan Markle set for 'FASHION WAR' with Kate after Prince Harry marriage
Trump Says He'll Abandon Kim Talks If They're Not 'Fruitful'
Qualcomm Cuts Jobs to Boost Profit
Karen McDougal Released From Contract Restricting Her From Talking Trump Affair
Colbert Thinks He Has Proof That Trump Watches His Show
Beaten, tortured, sexually abused: An American ISIS widow looks for a way home
Tesla is being investigated for workplace safety
British girl wins gold medal in international maths competition
Barbara Bush's funeral will be attended by Melania Trump, Clintons, others
Beyoncé reminds us we are all divas, soldiers and survivors
Former British PM David Cameron says he doesn't regret the Brexit referendum
Nikki Haley hits back at White House claims she is 'confused' over Russia sanctions
Turkey to hold snap elections on 24 June, says Erdoğan
UN chemical weapons investigators 'SHOT AT in Syria' – probe delayed AGAIN
COUNTDOWN BEGINS! Meghan and Harry shine at Commonwealth event four weeks ahead of wedding
Musk's Leaked Email Raises More Questions About Tesla Than It Answers
Saudi Arabia ending a 35-year ban on movie theaters with 'Black Panther' screening
Trump calls Stormy Daniels suspect sketch 'a total con job'
Saudi Arabia willing to send ARMY to Iranian-backed Syria as tensions ESCALATE
US and Russian nuclear arsenals set to be unchecked for first time since 1972
Police 'too slow to change' after Stephen Lawrence murder
Taylor Swift stalker suspect wore mask, had knife and rope, police say
Google Launches Chrome 66 For Windows, Mac, Linux, Android And iOS
Stephen Colbert, James Comey Talk About What It's Like 'Working for a Mob Boss'
Hannity's rising role in Trump's world: 'He basically has a desk in the place'
Chinese President Xi Jinping will visit Pyongyang 'soon,' official says
CIA Director Mike Pompeo secretly met with North Korea's Kim Jong Un
Barbara Bush, former US first lady, dies at 92
Russia blocks millions of IP addresses in battle against Telegram app
Could North Korea and South Korea finally end their war? Reports say yes
Israeli army reveals images allegedly showing Iran's involvement in Syria
Microsoft, Facebook and 32 other tech firms join CyberSecurity Tech Accord
President Trump meets with Japan's prime minister
Stormy Daniels releases sketch of man who allegedly threatened her over Trump affair
Southwest flight makes emergency landing after losing an engine
Macron: political divisions in Europe are like a civil war
Theresa May apologises for treatment of Windrush citizens
Nerve agent used to attack Sergei Skripal was liquid, says Defra
Canada withdraws diplomats' families from Cuba over mystery illness
Scientists accidentally create mutant enzyme that eats plastic bottles
Emmanuel Macron SLAPPED DOWN by Donald Trump over claims he changed US policy in Syria
Syrian state media report new missile attack in Homs region
Facebook is probably tracking you whether you use it or not — and it doesn't really give you a choice
US Cuts Off China's ZTE From American Tech for Seven Years
Late-Night Hosts Slam Sean Hannity for Sharing Trump Lawyer
First US winner of Boston Marathon since '85
United States said Russia may have tampered with evidence at the Douma site
Khloe Kardashian reveals baby name: True Thompson
Amber Rudd pledges action to resolve status of Windrush citizens
Boston Marathon drenched as heavy storm causes flash floods in New York
Michael Cohen's mystery third client is Sean Hannity
Ant McPartlin fined £86,000 for drink-driving
Kellyanne Conway: Comey ‘Loved Being Alone In The Oval Office’
Syria bombing protest erupts into RIOT as activists try to topple US President statue
Syria chemical attack: Russia and Syria BLOCK inspectors from Douma
South Carolina prison fight leaves seven inmates dead, at least 17 injured
Justin Bieber reportedly punched man who assaulted woman at Coachella party
Facebook ad feature claims to predict user's future behaviour
Special BAFTA Craft Award for 'Game of Thrones'
John Cena and Nikki Bella end engagement
Bank of America hauls in biggest profit ever
Catalan protesters call for return of jailed or exiled leaders
Comey says in ABC interview that Trump is ‘morally unfit to be president’
Pakistan watchdog says country failing on human rights
Future of Iran deal may depend on European intervention
In Syria, Trump needs a strategy to keep Russia, Assad and Iran off-balance - and US involvement to a minimum
ACM Awards: Carrie Underwood Returns to Stage in First Performance Since Accident
Xi Jinping sends warning to Taiwan, United States with live fire drills
Phenomenal growth of Netflix
Former first lady Barbara Bush in failing health
BREAKING: Two planes COLLIDE in midair in Germany - fatalities confirmed
Man City wins Premier League after United loses to West Brom
Nikki Haley says more sanctions against Russia coming Monday
Zakaria: On Syria, Trump looks a lot like Obama
Syria attack: British submarine 'hunted by Russian subs' in deadly cat and mouse game
Kim Jong Un meets high-ranking Chinese diplomat in Pyongyang
SpaceX Big Falcon Rocket, Humanity's First Spaceship
Golden Arch Awards: Oscar-Nominated 'Loveless' Wins Best Movie
Trump defends 'mission accomplished' tweet
Trump attacks Comey for handling of Clinton email probe
Scandal in Sweden: Nobel prize for literature faces #MeToo moment
UN Security Council rejects Russia’s call to condemn U.S.-led airstrikes in Syria
Starbucks apologizes after two Black men in Philadelphia were arrested after waiting at a table
How Facebook ads target you
Beyoncé makes history with a live performance at Coachella
Satellite images show craters at alleged Syrian chemical weapons facilities
March for Science 2018: Passionate advocates push the cause for research across the globe
‘We are not scared of America’s missiles’ — Syrians gather in defiance after U.S.-led strikes
Cardi B Trolls Trump During 'Tonight Show' Co-Host Stint
Facebook has spent $20 million on Mark Zuckerberg's security since 2015
Haley says US 'locked and loaded,' prepared to maintain pressure on Syria
Russia claims Syria SHOT DOWN more than two thirds of US and British missiles last night
Russia condemns US-led strikes on Syria as 'act of aggression against a sovereign state'
British jets in 'successful' strike on chemical weapons base in Syria as Theresa May denies aim is 'regime change'
Russian officials warn of 'consequences' after US-led airstrikes on Syria
Close