Close
Date TimeDecember 28, 2017
VoiceFacebook and Twitter threatened with sanctions in UK fake news inquiry
Facebook and Twitter could face sanctions if they continue to stonewall parliament over Russian interference in the EU referendum, the chair of a Commons inquiry has said.
Damian Collins, chair of the Department of Culture, Media and Sport select committee, which is looking into so-called “fake news”, has given the companies until 18 January to correct their failure to hand over information he requested about Russian misinformation campaigns on their platforms.
“There has to be a way of scrutinising the procedures that companies like Facebook put in place to help them identify known sources of disinformation, particularly when it’s politically motivated and coming from another country,” Collins said.
“They need to be able to tell us what they can do about it. And what we need to be able to do is say to the companies: we recognise that you are best placed to monitor what is going on your own site and to get the balance right in taking action against it but also safeguarding the privacy of users.
“But what there has to be then is some mechanism of saying: if you fail to do that, if you ignore requests to act, if you fail to police the site effectively and deal with highly problematic content, then there has to be some sort of sanction against you.”
Collins’s intervention, the first concrete warning that sanctions could follow any failure to provide the information required, is likely to cause concern for the social media firms. Previously he had signalled his dissatisfaction in letters to the two companies without specifying the consequences of noncompliance.
In a letter to Twitter this month, he wrote: “The information you have now shared with us is completely inadequate … It seems odd that so far we have received more information about activities that have taken place on your platform from journalists and academics than from you.”
Collins said his inquiry was looking at the question of what form sanctions could take. “In other countries they’ve taken different positions. Germany has obviously gone furthest down this road.”
In mid-December, the German competition authority issued the country’s latest rebuke of Facebook, accusing the company of violating European data protection principles by merging information gathered through WhatsApp and Instagram with Facebook user accounts.
Collins suggested that one outcome of the inquiry could be social networks being hit where it hurts most: their revenue. “On the advertising side, what’s important is, well, the extent of fake accounts. If you’re selling advertising against those numbers, that cannot be ethical, and clearly that is something the advertising industry should be interested in.”
Collins would not have direct powers to punish Twitter and Facebook if they fail to cooperate more fully, but could ensure bad publicity for both if he continues to summon their representatives to face his committee. Meanwhile, ministers are understood to be concerned by the companies’ attitude and could be sympathetic to any request for action.
Collins’s committee has asked Facebook and Twitter for a broad swath of information about Russian interference in the EU referendum, including details of the accounts and pages operated by Russian misinformation actors. Instead, in early December the two companies handed over a carbon copy of the information they had provided the Electoral Commission in response to a much narrower query about advertising spend from Russia during the six weeks leading up to the vote.
“What I didn’t expect was they would essentially completely ignore our request,” Collins said, describing the companies’ response as “extraordinary”.
“They don’t believe that they have any obligation at all to initiate their own investigation into what may or may not have been happening on the site – to look at the accounts that have been identified by the American authorities and say: OK, are there other accounts that share similar characteristics that could have come from the same source? They’ve not done any of that work at all.”
Advertisement
In the information the companies handed over to the Electoral Commission, they identified small ad spends from previously known Russian actors. Facebook said just $0.97 had been spent on Brexit-related adverts by Russians that were seen by Brits, while Twitter claimed that the only Russian spending it was aware of during the period in question was $1,000 from the broadcaster RT.
The Russian embassy in Britain seized on the initial figures released by Facebook to criticise media focus on misinformation operations. “It’s [the Times columnist Hugo Rifkind] who holds British democracy in contempt by suggesting 52% voters can be bought for £0.73,” the embassy tweeted shortly after the exchange of letters between Facebook, Twitter and Collins.
A few days later, the embassy shared a statement from the Russian foreign affairs ministry: “US & UK financial elites controlling mainstream media are unleashing a campaign to put Facebook, Google, Twitter under strict control alleging they are used by extremists. Russia was targeted by social media fakes many times but it never curbed freedom of speech in internet.” (In fact, Russian authorities have banned thousands of sites since Vladimir Putin’s re-election in 2012, some for promoting “social ills”, others for political dissent.)
In the US, Facebook and Twitter carried out wide-ranging investigations that identified significant interference beyond simple ad spending. Facebook identified 470 accounts and pages run by the Russian Internet Research Agency, a St Petersburg-based “troll army”, while Twitter provided Congress with a list of 2,752 accounts that it believed were linked to the organisation.
“I hope they realise that people’s concerns about this issue aren’t going away,” Collins said. “They have an opportunity to be seen to be proactive. This is taking place in the context of the broader debate of their responsibilities.”

Related Stories
Kendall Jenner Soaks Up the Sun on Jet Skis With Luka Sabbat in MonacoKendall Jenner Soaks Up the Sun on Jet Skis With Luka Sabbat in Monaco
Virgin Mobile says it will compensate customers for service disruptionVirgin Mobile says it will compensate customers for service disruption
WhatsApp flaw let hackers install spyware on cellphonesWhatsApp flaw let hackers install spyware on cellphones
Kate Middleton attends Donald Trump state banquet in white lace dressKate Middleton attends Donald Trump state banquet in white lace dress
Facebook says it needs more regulation, not a breakupFacebook says it needs more regulation, not a breakup
British Steel to enter insolvency after rescue talks with government failBritish Steel to enter insolvency after rescue talks with government fail
Donald Trump meets the Queen at start of UK state visitDonald Trump meets the Queen at start of UK state visit
Change UK loses six of its 11 MPs after dire EU elections resultChange UK loses six of its 11 MPs after dire EU elections result
Housing minister Kit Malthouse enters race to be next UK PMHousing minister Kit Malthouse enters race to be next UK PM
Delete Facebook now: WhatsApp co-founder gives a talk at Stanford'Delete Facebook now': WhatsApp co-founder gives a talk at Stanford
News Trends
Mohamed Morsy, ousted Egyptian president, dies in courtMohamed Morsy, ousted Egyptian president, dies in court
Gary Woodland has more than the US Open to celebrateGary Woodland has more than the US Open to celebrate
All The Celebrity Cameos In Taylor Swifts You Need To Calm Down Music VideoAll The Celebrity Cameos In Taylor Swift's You Need To Calm Down Music Video
Gloria Vanderbilt: farewell fashions innovative heiressGloria Vanderbilt: farewell fashion's innovative heiress
Harvard rescinds offer to Kyle Kashuv, pro-Second Amendment Parkland survivor, due to past remarks, he saysHarvard rescinds offer to Kyle Kashuv, pro-Second Amendment Parkland survivor, due to past remarks, he says
Lee Bowyer set to leave Charlton after failing to reach contract agreementLee Bowyer set to leave Charlton after failing to reach contract agreement
Taylor Swift Just Revealed All The Celebrities Who Will Appear In Her Upcoming VideoTaylor Swift Just Revealed All The Celebrities Who Will Appear In Her Upcoming Video
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle Share Touching New Image of Baby ArchiePrince Harry and Meghan Markle Share Touching New Image of Baby Archie
Bella Thornes Ex Mod Sun Breaks Down the Passport SituationBella Thorne's Ex Mod Sun Breaks Down the Passport Situation
Usain Bolt Grinds On Hot IG Model Zahra EliseUsain Bolt Grinds On Hot IG Model Zahra Elise
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
Kendall Jenner Soaks Up the Sun on Jet Skis With Luka Sabbat in MonacoKendall Jenner Soaks Up the Sun on Jet Skis With Luka Sabbat in Monaco
Virgin Mobile says it will compensate customers for service disruptionVirgin Mobile says it will compensate customers for service disruption
WhatsApp flaw let hackers install spyware on cellphonesWhatsApp flaw let hackers install spyware on cellphones
Kate Middleton attends Donald Trump state banquet in white lace dressKate Middleton attends Donald Trump state banquet in white lace dress
Facebook says it needs more regulation, not a breakupFacebook says it needs more regulation, not a breakup
British Steel to enter insolvency after rescue talks with government failBritish Steel to enter insolvency after rescue talks with government fail
Donald Trump meets the Queen at start of UK state visitDonald Trump meets the Queen at start of UK state visit
Change UK loses six of its 11 MPs after dire EU elections resultChange UK loses six of its 11 MPs after dire EU elections result
Housing minister Kit Malthouse enters race to be next UK PMHousing minister Kit Malthouse enters race to be next UK PM
Delete Facebook now: WhatsApp co-founder gives a talk at Stanford'Delete Facebook now': WhatsApp co-founder gives a talk at Stanford
News Trends
Mohamed Morsy, ousted Egyptian president, dies in courtMohamed Morsy, ousted Egyptian president, dies in court
Gary Woodland has more than the US Open to celebrateGary Woodland has more than the US Open to celebrate
All The Celebrity Cameos In Taylor Swifts You Need To Calm Down Music VideoAll The Celebrity Cameos In Taylor Swift's You Need To Calm Down Music Video
Gloria Vanderbilt: farewell fashions innovative heiressGloria Vanderbilt: farewell fashion's innovative heiress
Harvard rescinds offer to Kyle Kashuv, pro-Second Amendment Parkland survivor, due to past remarks, he saysHarvard rescinds offer to Kyle Kashuv, pro-Second Amendment Parkland survivor, due to past remarks, he says
Lee Bowyer set to leave Charlton after failing to reach contract agreementLee Bowyer set to leave Charlton after failing to reach contract agreement
Taylor Swift Just Revealed All The Celebrities Who Will Appear In Her Upcoming VideoTaylor Swift Just Revealed All The Celebrities Who Will Appear In Her Upcoming Video
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle Share Touching New Image of Baby ArchiePrince Harry and Meghan Markle Share Touching New Image of Baby Archie
Bella Thornes Ex Mod Sun Breaks Down the Passport SituationBella Thorne's Ex Mod Sun Breaks Down the Passport Situation
Usain Bolt Grinds On Hot IG Model Zahra EliseUsain Bolt Grinds On Hot IG Model Zahra Elise
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Report: Israel, US Form Joint Plan to Contain Iran
Golden Globes: Hugh Grant, Ricky Martin, Isabelle Huppert Among First Group of Presenters
Alabama judge denies Roy Moore's complaint
Russia Warns U.S.: Don’t ‘Meddle’ In Upcoming Presidential Election
Russia slams US plan to sell anti-missile system to Japan
China 'selling oil to North Korea' in shocking satellite images DESPITE sanctions
Apple and Amazon in talks to set up in Saudi Arabia
40 killed and dozens wounded in suicide bomb blast
Putin says St. Petersburg explosion was terror attack
Roy Moore tries to block Alabama election result
Anthrax found in North Korean defector raises new concerns about country’s biological weapons
Bitcoin price WARNING: Expert MOCKS cryptocurrency – You can't buy McDonald's with bitcoin
China build nuclear power plant on artificial island to 'conquer disputed South China Sea'
Obama Is ‘Most Admired Man’ For 10th Year In A Row, Gallup Poll Says
Volcano ERUPTION: Terrifying video shows Mount Sinabung spew HUGE ash cloud
St Petersburg EXPLOSION video: Aftermath after 'potential mass homicide' in Russia
Putin Critic Navalny Steps Up The Pressure After Kremlin Crackdown
Behind the Scenes of Editing 'Baby Driver'
Trump tests eight 30ft high border walls
End of Merkel: Voters want German Chancellor to QUIT before term ends, shock poll claims
'Black Mirror' returns solid, with some cracks
Obama tells Prince Harry social media leads to ‘different realities’ in dig at Trump
Israel minister plans Trump train station at Western Wall
'Mad About You' Revival in the Works
Why China jails activists at Christmas
Healthy lifestyle and exercise key to staving off alzheimer's, study finds
FSTE 100: Top 10 most popular stocks of 2017
Russia test-fires new ballistic missile designed to 'overcome defence systems'
Kim Jong-un gives sister BIG promotion as she makes rare public appearance in North Korea
Two nighttime quakes shake Santa Clara County
Even for a place that gets a ton of snow, this was a record-breaking two days for Erie
Apple suppliers drop on report of weak iPhone X demand; analysts' views mixed
Kremlin: Russia ready to act as mediator for US and North Korea
Even bitcoin must follow basic economic rules
Tesla Model 3 and 15 other new cars, SUVs that will shake up 2018
Christmas at the Space Station: Astronauts Celebrate with New Tree, Gifts from Earth
Laura Plummer jailed for three years for smuggling drugs into Egypt
North Korea war: Tens of thousands of US citizens to DIE if conflict starts, says Russia
Jodie Whittaker Set for Historical Introduction in 'Doctor Who' Christmas Special
Exclusive: Iconic White House tree to be cut down
Chinese firm clones gene-edited dog in bid to treat cardiovascular disease
Cardinals' Fitzgerald writes Christmas tribute to John McCain
U.S. gets $285M cut in UN’s 2018-19 budget
Donald Trump could snub UK visit if Obama attends Prince Harry and Meghan Markle wedding
JetBlue plane slides off taxiway at Boston airport
South Korean forces to create North Korea nuclear monitoring team
The Sound of Music star Heather Menzies-Urich dies aged 68
First lady Melania Trump tweets Christmas greeting in Santa-hat filter
Kremlin critic Alexey Navalny barred from entering presidential race
BREAKING: Bus ploughs into crowd at busy underground station - five dead and many injured
Prince Harry’s most shocking present for Queen REVEALED as Meghan Markle joins festivities
Text of Pope Francis' traditional Christmas day message
Queen's speech 2017: Queen's picture collection missing some notable Royal Family members
North Korea SHOCK warning: Nuclear weapons now built bigger & quicker than EVER before
Julian Assange's official Twitter account not appearing
Pope speaks out for immigrants in Christmas Eve message
Spain's king attempts to calm Catalonia crisis in Christmas speech
Missing submarine mystery as NEW signal detected, Russian and US ships scramble to scene
Angela Merkel facing New Year NIGHTMARE with ONE WEEK to form government
The Memo: The Top 10 Trump controversies of 2017
Trump Reportedly Told His Friends They Got Richer From Tax Bill
How Trump's first year changed the Middle East
200 skiers stuck on gondola at French Alps resort
Several people killed in Christmas Eve plane crash in Florida
UFOs DO EXIST: Alien existence proved 'BEYOND reasonable doubt' after multiple sightings
Here's the Tesla that Elon Musk will launch into orbit around Mars
Drinking alcohol every day for a month: The FOUR damaging effects on YOUR body
Pennsylvania police shootings were 'terror attack,' DHS says
BREAKING: At least NINE injured in LA after 'machete-wielding rampage by man in gas mask'
Edward Snowden made an app to protect your laptop
North Korea says new UN sanctions an act of war
Few Americans Are Cheering The Repeal Of Net Neutrality
India bus crash kills 33 Hindu pilgrims
Federal judge lifts parts of Trump travel ban
Steelers release veteran LB James Harrison
Miss America leadership resigns after emails shaming past pageant winners come to light
Gogglebox’s Leon Bernicoff Dies, Aged 83
More than 120 killed in Philippines mudslides and floods as storm hits
Christmas shopping horror: Explosion in Spain tourist town leaves several injured
UK royal apologizes for wearing 'racist' brooch to palace lunch with Markle
Fire rips through London Zoo with petting area engulfed in flames, 70 fighters on scene
Terror attack at San Francisco's Pier 39 thwarted, federal authorities say
Climate change could trigger more volcanic eruptions, study finds
Elon Musk and Amber Heard spotted together — again
SpaceX Puts On Breathtaking Show With Falcon 9 Launch
US will provide anti-tank weapons to Ukraine, State Dept. official says
'A ridiculous statement!' Tory MP slaps down Gina Miller's criticism of blue passports
Arsenal 3 - Liverpool 3: Sanchez and Salah on target in thrilling Emirates encounter
Space Tourism: Russia Plans Luxury Hotel on the ISS
UN Security Council imposes new sanctions on North Korea over missile test
Seth Meyers, Jimmy Fallon Tell Trump Christmas Tales
Elizabeth Vargas Leaving ABC News After Two Decades
Madrid train crash: Up to 45 people injured and four seriously hurt near Spain capital
Mexico bus crash victims killed include 8 Americans
Bitcoin lost a third of its value in 24 hours
Boris Johnson in Russia: UK-Russo relations at 'a low level' Lavrov warns Britain
How Tesla and Elon Musk Are Designing a New Paradigm for Drivers
Catalan separatists win majority in election, in rebuke to Spain and EU
BREAKING: Stabbing near Kings Cross in London - road sealed off as man fights for life
Pence pays surprise visit to Kabul
Boris Johnson tells Russia: we will retaliate against cyber-attacks
Theresa May’s name 'noted' by the US as UK votes against Trump’s Jerusalem decision
Bitcoin slips below $14,000, down 30 percent from record peak
Ivanka Trump fumbles on 'Fox & Friends' tax interview
South Korea fire: 29 killed as flames rip through Jecheon building
Nikki Haley Threatens to Yank Funding from U.N. over Jerusalem Resolution: ‘This Vote Will Be Remembered’
US says Russia intentionally violating Syria military agreement
Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe 'eligible for early release' in Iran
World War 3? US and Russia tensions SOAR as Putin vows ‘reciprocal measures’ on America
Tesla, Porsche top Consumer Reports car satisfaction survey
Apple: Yes, we slow down older iPhones
Catalan Election: Catalans go to the polls amid independence crisis
Prince Harry, Meghan Markle release engagement photos
Melbourne EXPLOSION: Frankston Shopping Centre on fire just hours after car crash terror
Bradley Cooper, Lady Gaga's 'A Star Is Born' to Hit Theaters During 2018 Awards Season After All
REVEALED: Elon Musk releases photos of new space rocket set to launch in WEEKS
Shots fired along demilitarized zone as North Korean soldier defects
Khloe Kardashian shares a photo of her pregnant belly: 'We are having a baby!'
Car hits pedestrians in Flinders Street, Melbourne
Rebel Wilson, Jimmy Fallon Sing Holiday Tunes With Google Translate
Reggie ‘Combat Jack’ Ossé dead at 48
Larry King's Employer Denies 'False' Sexual Misconduct Allegation
Trump's first year in video review
Brexit Britain: UK named best country in world for BUSINESS
Meryl Streep posters claiming 'she knew' about Harvey Weinstein pop up in Los Angeles
Can Apple make us play Pokemon Go again?
South Korea opens fire on ships from China after they CHARGE at patrol boat
Oscars: 341 Feature Films Eligible to Compete
Cardinal Bernard Law, symbol of church sex abuse scandal, dead at 86
Senate approves most drastic changes to US tax code in 30 years
Microsoft removes Google's Chrome installer from the Windows Store
‘The Voice’ Crowns Season 13 Winner
Ridley Scott: Kevin Spacey Went ‘Underground’ After Misconduct Allegations
May and Trump hold first call since tweet row
Anna Kendrick, Darlene Love Play 'Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)' With Classroom Instruments
McDonald's to start selling the McVegan burger
Is BOEING to unveil the world’s first military SPACE PLANE in NEXT HOUR?
Millions of Brits cancelling ‘out of date’ TV licence in favour of Netflix and Amazon
Golden Globe, SAG Award Noms Reveal Disruption of Trump Era in Oscar Race
Disney adds Trump robot to its Hall of Presidents
Sarah Palin's oldest son charged with beating up his father
UN Security Council slams U.S. recognition of Jerusalem
K-Pop Singer Jonghyun Died After Attempting Suicide, Police Confirm
Google Chrome update will bring one of the most requested features to your browser
Yemen rebels fire ballistic missile on Saudi capital, state TV reports
Japan buys US missile defence system to counter North Korean threat
The U.S. Blames North Korea for the ‘WannaCry’ Ransomware Attack
Trump and Putin, closer than ever
Trump doctrine: Economic security is national security
Donald Trump Begs for an Emmy in Showtime's 'Cartoon President' Teaser
Matthew Petersen's letter to Trump withdrawing his judicial nomination
Washington train crash: At least 3 dead as Amtrak train derails and plummets off bridge
'Lady Bird' Named Best Film of 2017 by Vancouver Critics Circle
Twitter suspends Britain First account that Trump retweeted
Ivanka Trump and Jared Kushner sued over failures on financial disclosure forms
Uber driver with criminal past arrested after British woman diplomat, 30, murdered, left by side of road
The year feminism fought back. The ranks of women CEOs got even smaller this year
Doug Jones: Trump shouldn't resign over sexual misconduct allegations
Sarah Mullally appointed bishop of London
World War 3 threat: China fighter jets enter NO entry zone between North Korea and South
This Chinese startup's electric SUV is a lot cheaper than Tesla's
World War 3: US to shell out MILLIONS building air bases to counter 'Russian AGGRESSION'
Miss Iraq's family forced to flee after selfie with Miss Israel
Thomas Fire on course to become California's largest-ever wildfire
Power outage suspends flights at Atlanta airport
Putin phoned Trump to thank him for CIA tip on planned terror attack, Kremlin says
British diplomat Rebecca Dykes found dead in Lebanon
Prince Harry interviews Barack Obama for radio show
11 police killed in Taliban attack on Afghanistan checkpoints
Special Counsel Robert Mueller gets access to thousands of Trump transition emails - AP
The California wildfires by the numbers
WATCH: US nuclear tests show what END OF THE WORLD could look like if WW3 broke out
Birmingham crash: Six dead after horrific multi-vehicle accident – road remains closed
President Donald Trump calls Cindy McCain with 'best wishes' for Sen. John McCain's health
THERESA MAY: We WILL leave the European Union
Australia arrests 'agent of North Korea'
NY Times: Pentagon study of UFOs revealed
Washington Post attack on Trump about Russia briefings is deeply flawed fake news
'SNL' in the White House: 10 Most Memorable Trump Sketches of 2017
First bitcoin homes sell in the UK
Brexit: UK will retain EU rules during transition, says Hammond
Heinz Wolff Dead: Great Egg Race Presenter And Prominent Scientist Dies Aged 89
3 awkward pictures that tell you everything about how Donald Trump and Jeff Sessions feel about each other
Canadian pharmaceutical billionaire and wife found dead in Toronto in 'suspicious' circumstances
China installs high-frequency radars in secret plot to militarise islands over WW3 fears
Mattis: North Korea isn't capable of striking the US
Strong earthquake strikes Indonesia; 3 dead
SpaceX launches recycled rocket on delivery mission to International Space Station
Trump-Russia: Republicans trying to kill off investigation, says Adam Schiff
Uber accused of espionage, bribery and hacking by former employee
Watergate Series from George Clooney in the Works at Netflix
Women At Fox News Are Furious Over Rupert Murdoch Comments On Sexual Misconduct
The funniest wildlife photos of 2017 are just as wild and hilarious as you'd expect
Hillary Clinton Says GOP Tax Plan Will 'Hurt So Many People'
Tillerson: 'North Korea must earn its way back to the table'
Dustin Hoffman accused of sexual assault
Buying Bitcoin Means 'Buying Risk,' Bank Of Canada Governor Says
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle to marry on 19 May
Merkel reveals 'MASTER PLAN’ for EU true union and integration
Mario Batali Fired From ABC's 'The Chew' Amid Sexual Misconduct Claims
Close