Close
Date TimeNovember 09, 2017
VoiceThe FBI says it has not been able to access Devin P. Kelley’s phone. Kelley is the Air Force veteran responsible for killing more than two dozen people at a Texas church on Sunday.

Texas gunman’s phone could reignite FBI-Apple fight over encryption

The FBI and Apple are bracing for another potential fight over encryption, this time because of the iPhone of the dead gunman in the Texas church shooting, according to people familiar with the matter.
The federal government and the company have shied away from open confrontation since a 2016 standoff when the locked and encrypted iPhone of a gunman in San Bernardino, Calif., led to a major court battle. In that fight, the Justice Department tried to force Apple to unlock the dead terrorist’s phone. The company refused, saying to do so would create a security weakness in the phones of all customers.
That legal fight sparked a national debate about the competing interests of national security, law enforcement, personal privacy and giant tech firms. But the larger legal question of whether the government could force companies to provide access to phones and other electronic devices was never answered by the courts, because in the middle of the fight over the San Bernardino phone, the FBI found a private firm that could access it. Another similar case also fizzled when the suspect suddenly remembered his passcode and provided it to investigators.
On Tuesday, the FBI said it had not been able to access the phone belonging to Devin P. Kelley, the Air Force veteran responsible for killing more than two dozen people Sunday at a Texas church. Officials did not say what type of phone Kelley had, but people familiar with the case said it is an iPhone.
After the FBI said it was dealing with a phone it couldn’t open, Apple reached out to the bureau to learn if the phone was an iPhone and if the FBI was seeking assistance. Late Tuesday an FBI official responded, saying it was an iPhone but the agency was not asking anything of the company at this point. That’s because experts at the FBI’s lab in Quantico, Virginia, are trying to determine if there are other methods, such as cloud storage or a linked laptop, that would give access to the phone’s data, these people said. That process could take weeks, these people said.
If the FBI and Apple had talked to each other in the first two days after the attack, it’s possible the device might already be open.
That time frame may have been critical because Apple’s iPhone “Touch ID” — which uses a fingerprint to unlock the device — stops working after 48 hours. It wasn’t immediately clear if the gunman had activated the Touch ID feature on his phone, but more than 80 per cent of iPhone owners do use that feature. If the bureau had consulted the company, Apple engineers would likely have told the bureau to take steps such as putting the dead gunman’s finger to the phone to see if doing so would unlock it. It’s unclear if the FBI tried to use the dead man’s finger to open the device in the first two days.
The two sides have sparred in the past over the first investigative steps involving an iPhone. In the case of the San Bernardino County shootings in December 2016, Apple has said the FBI squandered an early chance to get the data. The gunman in that incident worked for the county government, and the phone in question was his work phone. FBI investigators did not reach out to Apple and instead asked a county technician to reset the shooter’s Apple iCloud password. That foreclosed the possibility of an automatic backup to Apple iCloud servers, which could have been accessed by investigators.
If the FBI is ultimately unable to see the data on the phone, Justice Department officials will be faced with a choice: Is this phone worth another high-stakes legal battle with Apple?
Given the extent of carnage inflicted by the Texas gunman and the growing problem encryption poses for law enforcement, officials could decide that it is a good test case for their argument that companies should make devices that are accessible with a signed order from a judge.
But that impulse may be tempered by another consideration: So far, the Texas gunman appears to have acted alone in what some officials have called a domestic violence problem that escalated into a mass murder.
If there is little reason to think the gunman had any accomplices, the Justice Department may have a less compelling argument to try to take Apple to court to force them to open the phone.
After the previous cases faded, the Justice Department has shied away from direct public confrontations with Apple and other firms over encryption.
While FBI Director Christopher Wray has warned there are nearly 7,000 phones that cannot be opened, and those technologies are making it harder to fight terrorism and crime, Congress has shown little interest so far in tackling the issue.
Law enforcement officials argue that encryption that prevents a police officer from opening a suspect’s phone even with a court order makes it increasingly difficult to solve murders and a host of other crimes; privacy advocates say that encrypted communications protect everyone from hackers and thieves and that the government should be able to find evidence through other means.

TSLA: Wall Street goes after Tesla at a critical time - Electrek
Serena Williams’s Australian Open Comes to an Abrupt, Bizarre End - The Ringer
Phillip Schofield Insists He And Holly Willoughby Aren't In Trouble Over Gemma Collins 'Dancing On Ice' Comments
Jonas Mekas, titan of underground filmmaking, dies aged 96
Speaker Nancy Pelosi stands firm: No State of the Union address in the House next week
Venezuela: Trump recognises opposition leader as president
Johnny Depp Claims He Has Evidence to Disprove Amber Heard's Domestic Violence Allegations
Miley Cyrus's Bold New Tattoo Is Totally Miley
Comedian and co-creator of 'Rel' Kevin Barnett dies at 32
Four men accuse Bohemian Rhapsody director Bryan Singer of sexual misconduct
Pete Buttigieg forms exploratory committee to run for president
Santander to close 140 branches across UK, putting 1,270 jobs at risk
PMQs verdict: Corbyn leaves May sounding defensive on Brexit
No Brexit deal means hard Irish border, EU says
‘Still here’: Tom Brady isn’t going anywhere. And he’s going to let you know it.
Cardiff City’s Emiliano Sala was on missing plane, French authorities say
Drake UK tour 2019: How to get tickets as dates to nationwide Assassination Vacation shows announced
Why the conversations between black men in ‘If Beale Street Could Talk’ feel so rare
Oscars 2019: Biggest snubs including Bradley Cooper, Emily Blunt and 'Crazy Rich Asians'
American singer Chris Brown detained in Paris after rape complaint
Oscar Nominations 2019: Olivia Colman, 'Black Panther' And 'A Star Is Born' Lead Academy Award Nominees
Lady Gaga Says Mike Pence Is 'Worst Representation' of Christianity During Las Vegas Show
Emma Stone Debuts Drastically Darker Hair at the Producers Guild Awards
Cardi B Gets Into Twitter Beef with Tomi Lahren Over Politics
Gemma Collins Furiously Accuses 'Dancing On Ice' Judge Jason Gardiner Of 'Selling Stories' On Her
Chris Evans on Virgin Radio – same show, different station
Arsenal confirm Sven Mislintat will leave club on 8 February
Pence links Trump’s push for border wall to Martin Luther King Jr.’s legacy
Kamala Harris officially enters US presidential race
Ariana Grande Sends Message to Mac Miller on His Birthday
'SNL': Pete Davidson appears to joke about Instagram post that prompted wellness check
Stefanos Tsitsipas stuns Roger Federer in four-set Australian Open thriller
Sterling and Sané ensure Manchester City cruise to victory at Huddersfield
Victoria Beckham admits rocky marriage rumors are ‘frustrating’
Kim Kardashian Effectively Makes Peace With Taylor Swift by Listening to Her Music
US, China to Share, Publicly Release Data From Dark Side of the Moon - NASA
Ariana Grande accused of copying latest song '7 Rings' from rapper Princess Nokia
Charity renews call for elderly driver eye tests after Prince Philip crash
'Glass' Review: It's not Perfect, But It Says a Lot About Heroism
Maggie Rogers: Heard It in a Past Life review – Alaska hitmaker's debut lacks edge
Trump reportedly told Michael Cohen to lie. His own attorney general pick testified that’s a crime
TV tonight: ‘Frankie and Grace,’ ‘The Punisher’ return on Netflix
Ariana Grande drops '7 rings'
Hailey Baldwin and Justin Bieber Are Marrying in L.A. and Their Guest List Includes Kylie Jenner and Travis Scott
Pelosi only gives Trump a bigger audience by canceling State of the Union
Miley Cyrus shuts down pregnancy rumors in 'egg-celent' way: 'Can everyone leave me alone'
Hitachi scraps £16bn nuclear power station in Wales
Rudy Giuliani: 'I never said there was no collusion' by Trump campaign
Louisville to rename airport for Muhammad Ali
American service members killed in Isil blast near US patrol in Syria's Manbij
Pelosi asks Trump to move State of the Union address
Who ya gonna call? Ivan Reitman sends son Jason to direct Ghostbusters 3
Hitman guilty of murdering Salford 'Mr Big' Paul Massey
Ariana Grande to Headline Lollapalooza 2019 (EXCLUSIVE)
Alicia Keys to Host Grammys 2019
Kim Kardashian defends Kanye West from reports
Gillette’s ad is not PC guff, Piers Morgan – look beyond the macho stereotype | Gaby Hinsliff
Carol Channing, star of Hello, Dolly! on Broadway, dies aged 97
'Spider-Man: Far From Home' trailer: Watch the first look here
Watch The 'Game Of Thrones' Season 8 Teaser Here
Meghan Markle reveals her due date: report
Lady Gaga Rushes Home After Critics' Choice Awards to Be With Dying Horse: 'I Am So Very Sad'
Trump says 'I never worked for Russia,' calls claim 'a whole big fat hoax' after explosive report of FBI probe
Toyota brings back the Supra sports car after more than 20 years
'So happy you said yes': Chris Pratt engaged to Katherine Schwarzenegger
Mayor of Gdansk dies after being stabbed on stage at charity event
Gareth Johnson: Tory Tasked With Getting Other MPs To Vote For May’s Deal Quits – To Vote Against It
Andy Murray out of Australian Open after losing what could be his last match
Katy Perry Is Glad She "Made the Right Choice" With Orlando Bloom
Neil Warnock on Brexit: ‘I can’t wait to leave. To hell with the rest of the world’
'The most insulting thing I've ever been asked': Fox News' Jeanine Pirro asks Trump if he's ever worked for Russia
Americans blame Trump and GOP much more than Democrats for shutdown, Post-ABC poll finds
Megyn Kelly, NBC News reach separation agreement
SpaceX will lay off 10 percent of its staff to fund projects
The partial government shutdown is now the longest ever as Trump border wall fight rages on
Paris bakery 'gas explosion' kills two firefighters
Tulsi Gabbard: Democrat says she will run for president in 2020
Tim Tebow Is Engaged to Miss Universe 2017 Demi-Leigh Nel-Peters
Sen. Kamala Harris teases a presidential run to Stephen Colbert, predicts how the shutdown ends
Dianne Oxberry, BBC weather presenter, dies aged 51
Andy Murray: Sporting great and champion feminist retires
Jayme Closs, 13, found alive three months after parents' murder
Meghan Markle's Royal Patronages Have Finally Been Announced and There Are FOUR
Lady Gaga apologizes for 'poor judgment' over R. Kelly song, vows to pull 'Do What U Want'
Jeff Bezos' Relationship with TV Host Lauren Sanchez Led to Divorce
Jaguar Land Rover is slashing 4,500 jobs
Corbyn says Labour may delay Brexit if it wins snap election
This Awesome Shot of Earth Was Taken From 70M Miles Away
[VIDEO] Donald Trump Primetime Address: Jimmy Kimmel Speech Reaction
BAFTA Awards Nominations 2019: Complete List
MPs force Theresa May to table plan B if she loses Brexit deal vote
John Bercow's decision endangers the office of Speaker, and our democracy | Anne Perkins
Rod Rosenstein, who appointed the special counsel investigating Trump, expected to leave Justice Dept
Amazon Becomes World's Most Valuable Company
New trailer offers more footage from ‘Captain Marvel’ (VIDEO)
Susan Boyle makes emotional appearance on America’s Got Talent
Celebs celebrate Cyntoia Brown clemency decision
Prime-time Trump faces credibility crisis
Stoke City sack manager Gary Rowett after eight months in charge
Scottish government acted unlawfully over Alex Salmond claims, court rules
Padraig Harrington feels trepidation at being Europe’s 2020 Ryder Cup captain
David Bowie Is ... app review – the freakiest show on your smartphone
Golden Globes 2019 Winners List
Cornered: Trump escalates shutdown crisis
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Says There's 'No Question' About Trump's Racism
What was the deal with Christian Bale's accent at the Golden Globes?
Carol Burnett reflects on her iconic career as she receives new Golden Globe award
Tory MP Anna Soubry Called 'Nazi' By Chanting Protesters Live On BBC News
Crystal Palace goalkeeper Wayne Hennessey denies Nazi salute
Pete Davidson and Machine Gun Kelly Take Their Friendship to a Basketball Game
Video of Drake With Girl, 17, Resurfaces, to Internet's Horror
'The Greatest Dancer' Is The Fresh Talent Show 'X Factor' Wishes It Could Be
US withdrawal from Syria depends on conditions, John Bolton says
Murder charge filed in death of 7-year-old Jazmine Barnes in Houston
Theresa May Refuses To Rule Out Holding Multiple Votes On Her Brexit Deal
Trump gives Kanye West a shout-out after rapper tweets his praise
Emma Watson talks of 'optimism' on Time's Up anniversary
California shooting: three people killed at Torrance bowling alley
Chelsea vs Nottingham Forest line-ups: Fabregas captain on final match, Hudson-Odoi starts
Kate Middleton Reportedly Felt Meghan Markle "Used Her to Climb the Royal Ladder" and Told Her So at Christmas
Ellen still wants Kevin Hart to host the Oscars
US economy added 312,000 jobs in December, blowing past expectations
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez dancing in college – video
Lifetime Defiant After R. Kelly Threatens to Sue Over Documentary
1st PHOTO of moon’s ‘mysterious’ far side taken by Chinese probe
Golden Globes 2019: Who will win – and who should?
Kim Kardashian & Kanye West Hire New Surrogate to Deliver Baby No. 4
Bob Einstein, comedy writer and Curb Your Enthusiasm actor, dies aged 76
Coachella 2019 lineup: Ariana Grande, Childish Gambino and Tame Impala to headline
Michael Schumacher turns 50, FA Cup third-round shocks and sneaky drinks
Bristol-Myers Squibb to buy Celgene in $74 billion deal
US enters new phase as women change the face of Congress
Kylie Jenner channels Meghan Markle on New Year's Eve
Kim Kardashian West roasted over 'Bird Box'
Miley Cyrus Spends New Year's With Liam Hemsworth's Family After Surprise Wedding
Pete Davidson Reveals ‘Sad’ First Reaction To Ariana Grande’s ‘Thank U, Next’
Tesla shares fall on price cut, soft Model 3 deliveries
Madonna Delivers Rousing Speech As She Spends New Year's Eve At The Historic Stonewall Inn
Kobe Bryant announces he and wife Vanessa expecting fourth baby girl
Harry Reid: Trump Is 'The Worst President We've Ever Had'
Mitt Romney: Trump's biggest failure is a lack of character in leading 'divided' nation
Greggs launches vegan sausage roll
Christian Pulisic joins Chelsea from Borussia Dortmund for £58m
Kate Middleton Reportedly Waited Until Meghan Markle Left Before Joining Royal Family Hunt
Volunteers Prepare Flower-Decked Floats for Rose Parade
Dry January might be bad for your health
Why Trump Reigns as King Cyrus
Jamie Vardy punishes dismal Everton as Leicester start new year in winning style
Tokyo car attack: Driver hits New Year's revelers in city's Harajuku district
Hubble telescope 'mother' Nancy Grace Roman dies
Comedian Louis C.K. mocks Parkland shooting survivors in leaked audio
U.S. Citizen Arrested In Moscow On Suspicion Of Spying
NFL coaching picture: Dirk Koetter, Todd Bowles fired; Dolphins’ Adam Gase awaits his fate
Elizabeth Warren announces 2020 run for president against Trump
Peter Thompson, former Liverpool and England winger, dies aged 76
Is Selena Gomez Sending Cryptic Messages With Her Graphic T-Shirts?
Bre Payton, 26-year-old conservative writer, dies following sudden illness
Gavin and Stacey actor Mathew Horne 'hit by train after night out'
John Kelly blames Jeff Sessions for 'zero tolerance,' family separations along border
Rashford learns from master at Solskjaer's finishing school
'Bird Box,' starring Sandra Bullock sets new Netflix viewing record in its first week
A Vegas star is born: Lady Gaga stuns, soars in Sin City debut
Sears Holdings announced another round of store closures
Mega Millions jackpot grows -- with next drawing on New Year's Day
Ryan Jack gives Rangers deserved Old Firm victory over Celtic
Alastair Cook knighted, Gareth Southgate, Harry Kane awarded in New Year’s honours
Kim and Kanye buying $14M luxury condo in Miami
Kevin Spacey ‘Let Me Be Frank’ YouTube Video Tops 8 Million Views In 3 Days
Tesla names Larry Ellison and Kathleen Wilson-Thompson to board after SEC settlement
Angelina Jolie open to move into politics
HMV Administration: Thousands Of Jobs At Risk As Retailer Collapses For Second Time In Six Years
KTLA anchor Chris Burrous dies at 43
Instagram update 2018: What is the new Instagram update, is it coming back?
Nationwide internet outage hits CenturyLink customers
Israeli novelist Amos Oz dies aged 79
'Black Mirror: Bandersnatch': Here's What Critics And Fans Are Saying About The New Game-Changing Episode
NASA wants you to celebrate New Years with its New Horizons space probe
Kim Kardashian slammed over North West's lipstick
Putin Says 'Invulnerable' New Hypersonic Nuclear Missile Is Ready For Deployment
Miley Cyrus confirms secret wedding to Liam Hemsworth
Secret new ‘Black Mirror’ movie now has a trailer, release date
Ariana Grande FaceTimes With Her Estranged Father on Christmas
Box Office: 'Aquaman' Hits $106M; 'Holmes & Watson' Gets D+ CinemaScore
How your holiday travel plans will be impacted by the partial federal government shutdown
Liverpool goes six points clear in EPL as Man City loses at Leicester
Russia: Hole drilled from inside Int'l Space Station capsule
Meghan Markle, Prince Harry join Kate Middleton, Prince William for Christmas Day service amid feud rumors
Kendall Jenner Has A Hilarious Response To Being Left Out Of Kardashian Christmas Card
Trump asks 7-year-old, 'Are you still a believer in Santa?'
Us trailer: How to watch the trailer for Jordan Peele's new horror movie
SpaceX closes out year with successful GPS satellite launch
Pete Davidson gets VIP treatment at Machine Gun Kelly concert a week after disturbing post
Miley Cyrus Sent Ariana Grande the Sweetest Text After Her Split from Pete Davidson
Kourtney Kardashian And Sofia Richie Look Like They're Best Friends On Christmas Vacation Together (PHOTOS)
Stocks plummet after Steven Mnuchin's odd statement fails to calm markets
Box Office: 'Aquaman' Opens to $67M; 'Mary Poppins' Edges Past 'Bumblebee'
Rihanna Gives Fans An Album Update
President Trump not going to change mind on Syria, even after resignations: Mulvaney
Carl Frampton not ready to make a hasty decision on his boxing future
Drone footage shows damage caused by Indonesian tsunami – video
Close