August 04, 2020
The Scottish government has become embroiled in a row over the moderation of exam results disadvantaging students from poorer backgrounds as critics warned the same problem could happen in the rest of the UK.
Poorest Pupils Hit Hardest As Exam Results Downgraded In UKs First Covid Moderation
In Scotland’s first school year without exams due to Coronavirus, the Scottish Qualifications Authority’s (SQA) moderation process reduced the pass rate of the poorest Higher pupils by more than twice that of the richest.
The pass rate of pupils in the most deprived data zones was reduced by 15.2% from teacher estimates after the exam board’s intervention.
In contrast, the pass rate for pupils from the most affluent backgrounds dropped by 6.9%.
Education commentators said “systemic biasing in favour of the least deprived” was the result of basing results on a school’s previous performance, rather than an individual’s track record.
Labour’s shadow Scottish secretary Ian Murray said using previous results from schools to decide grades “embeds disadvantage and the ridiculous league tables that has artificially hampered schools in more deprived areas”.
SNP MP Mhairi Black said she was “deeply concerned” with students from deprived areas seeing their results reduced at a higher rate and urged her colleagues running the Scottish Government to address the issue.
But Scotland’s first minister Nicola Sturgeon said that without the moderation the results would have been “unprecedented and therefore not credible”.
 The reduction based on deprivation levels is linear7% for least deprived9% for next least deprived11% for next least deprived13% for next least deprived15% for most deprivedNo random variation between groups ... a systematic biasing in favour of the least deprived https://t.co/7SwkuHOJFw— Dr Nick Troop 🌹 🎵 (@NicholasTroop) August 4, 2020 
Barry Black, a postgraduate researcher at the University of Glasgow, told HuffPost UK that the SQA was warned about the impact on the most disadvantaged pupils by the Scottish parliament’s education committee, and that the poorest were “actually being failed by a statistical model”.
He made the point that the poorest have been downgraded from a pass to a fail over twice the rate of their most affluent peers.
He said: “It’s not being moved from an A to B, or a B to a C, it’s actually from a pass to a fail. The potential consequences of that are really quite significant for those young people. It could be the difference between a university and college entry.
“If you went to a school in a rich area, and your teacher estimated you should have an A, it’s twice as likely that A would have been kept than if you were a deprived school because the affluent school wouldn’t have been questioned as much.
“The problem is is that you’re applying system-wide statistics to individual exam results.”
He said the SQA had argued a range of evidence would be used to make the calculations but “what we see in the methodology today is actually it’s purely been based on historical school data”.
“I’ve been in politics and education for a good few years and I’ve never seen palpable anger on such a scale,” he continued.
“I think this is probably forbearing exactly what’s going to happen in England and Wales because they’re pretty similar systems. And I imagine it is going to be similar in terms of results.”Syeda Mashaim Bukhari, 17, from St Andrew’s Academy in Glasgow, hit out at the “shocking” decision after she received her results, calling the “classist” approach “deeply flawed”.
She told HuffPost UK: “There is no justification for this, pupils have been disadvantaged simply because of the fact they live in a deprived area and pupils before them haven’t performed well.
“I think the SQA should have moderated the results based on individual performances of pupils in the past.
“This would have ensured pupils aren’t just given a huge advantage or disadvantage based on something that is completely out of their control.”
  
Drew Skinner, 17, who attends St Mungo’s Academy in Glasgow, said she was “disheartened after seeing people from privileged areas achieving straight As purely because they live in affluent areas”.
She told HuffPost UK of her “shock and upset” after receiving her results and “let down” by the SQA. She has another year to gain more Highers but thinks she will now have to work harder to get into university.
“I have some Friends in the year above that now need to take alternative routes such as college before university because of this,” she said.
 Can’t help but feel disheartened after seeing people from privelleged areas achieving straight A’s purely because they live in affluent areas. Here’s a letter I wrote to @JohnSwinney regarding this. Would really appreciate if you took some time to read and rt. pic.twitter.com/l0fdJHic8z— Drew Skinner (@drwskinner) August 4, 2020 
Asked about the SQA’s figures showing deprived children being affected more by the downgrading of results, Sturgeon said that without the moderation there would have been a 19.8% increase of the pass rate among the poorest fifth of pupils.
Sturgeon said: “What we want to make sure is that this year’s results have the degree of credibility that means that they are not so out of sync with previous years that people are going to look at them and say ‘they don’t make any sense’.
“As much as I would love to be in the position of standing here credibly saying that 85% of the 20% in the most deprived areas had passed Higher, given that it was 65% last year, that would raise a real credibility issue.”
She added: “Anybody who has a result, has passed a Higher or a National 5 today, can hold their head up for having a credible exam result, albeit without the actual exam.
“That’s why the methodology in the moderation system is important in order to do that so that people don’t look at incredible inflation and pass rates and say the whole system wasn’t in some way credible.”
At National 5 level, the pass rate for the poorest pupils was 74% when teachers’ estimates would have led to an 84.5% pass rate without moderation.
For the least deprived, the 92.3% estimated pass rate fell to 87.1% after the SQA’s moderation.
More than a quarter (26.2%) of grades were changed during moderation by the SQA - a total of 133,762 - while 377,308 entries were accepted unchanged.
The exam board’s criteria for moderation included the historic performance of of schools and grades were adjusted “where a centre’s estimates were outside the constraint range for that course”, according to the SQA chief examining officer Fiona Robertson
New schools without previous exam results were unchanged.
Despite the downgrading 124,564 pupils’ results - 93.1% of all the moderated grades - exam pass rates rose at every level and would have been the highest on record without the SQA downgrading some submitted results, education secretary John Swinney said.
Swinney stressed that approximately 90% of moderation “involved a change of just one grade”.
An SQA spokesman said: “The most disadvantaged young people have achieved better results in 2020 compared to both 2019 and the average results for the last four years.
“At Grades A to C, the attainment gap between the most and least disadvantaged young people is also narrower this year for National 5, Higher and Advanced Higher than for last year or the average gap for the last four years.”Related... A-Level Sociology Textbook Says Working Class Black Students 'Lack Reasoning Skills' MPs Warn Of 'Unfair Bias' In Predicted Exam Grade System Teachers Reveal Why Government’s £1bn Tutoring Plan Won’t Work
Related Stories
Latest News
Top news around the world
Coronavirus Disease

Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) is an infectious disease caused by a newly discovered coronavirus.

Most people infected with the COVID-19 virus will experience mild to moderate respiratory illness and recover without requiring special treatment. Older people, and those with underlying medical problems like cardiovascular disease, diabetes, chronic respiratory disease, and cancer are more likely to develop serious illness.

Around the World

Celebrity News

> Latest News in Media

Watch It
'Julie and the Phantoms' Star Madison Reyes on How She Was Inspired by Zendaya
September 23, 2020
O39BtXvSHls
Dulé Hill and James Roday Rodriguez Discuss 'Psych 2: Lassie Come Home'
September 23, 2020
vIe_y6kK9So
Execs Break Down How Consumer Habits are Changing
September 23, 2020
tpdR96TMT_g
Emmy-nominated 'Pose' makeup artist breaks down her favorite looks | Page Six Celebrity News
September 23, 2020
mwnf88fnaxE
‘Clueless’ costume designer shares the stories behind the film’s fashion | Page Six Celebrity News
September 23, 2020
vwFBH9ijjj8
Kyle Richards posts message to Teddi Mellencamp after ‘RHOBH’ exit | Page Six Celebrity News
September 23, 2020
j8bMHBoB2Xc
Kim Kardashian's Kid's Are Wild & Cute! | TMZ TV
September 24, 2020
7UfBhWAVuqc
Austin Mahone Wants to Help Kanye and Other Artists Get Their Masters | TMZ
September 23, 2020
dhxZbYnOmZ8
Al Sharpton Urges Voting Over Violence in Wake of Breonna Taylor Case | TMZ
September 23, 2020
Tx8bcGhFv7Q
Mandy Moore Pregnant With First Child | E! News
September 24, 2020
39ueVkwLPWw
Cardi B Already Getting Tons of Flirty DMs After Offset Split | E! News
September 24, 2020
P1D_xGQD8qE
"Cake Boss" Star Buddy Valastro Impales Hand In Accident | E! News
September 24, 2020
TW5uWqXPTSE
TV Schedule
Late Night Show
Watch the latest shows of U.S. top comedians

Sports

Latest sport results, news, videos, interviews and comments
Latest Events
24
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Third qualifying round
Charleroi - Partizan
24
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Third qualifying round
Rosenborg - Alanyaspor
24
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Third qualifying round
St. Gallen - AEK
24
Sep
ASIAN CHAMPIONS LEAGUE: Group Stage
Persepolis - Al Sharjah
24
Sep
ASIAN CHAMPIONS LEAGUE: Group Stage
Al Duhail - Al Taawon
24
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Third qualifying round
Willem II - Rangers
24
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Third qualifying round
Basel - Anorthosis
24
Sep
ARMENIA: Premier League
Van - Alashkert
24
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Third qualifying round
APOEL - Zrinjski
24
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Third qualifying round
FC Kobenhavn - Piast Gliwice
24
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Third qualifying round
KI Klaksvik - Dinamo Tb.
24
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Third qualifying round
Riga - Celtic
24
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Third qualifying round
Wolfsburg - Desna
24
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Third qualifying round
Legia - Drita FC
24
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Third qualifying round
Sporting - Aberdeen
24
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Third qualifying round
Besiktas - Rio Ave
24
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Third qualifying round
CSKA Sofia - B36 Torshavn
24
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Third qualifying round
Djurgarden - Cluj
24
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Third qualifying round
Rostov - Maccabi Haifa
24
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Third qualifying round
Ararat-Armenia - Celje
24
Sep
PORTUGAL: League U-23
Benfica U-23 - Sporting U-23
24
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Third qualifying round
Mura - PSV
24
Sep
ASIAN CHAMPIONS LEAGUE: Group Stage
Al Nasr Riyadh - Al Ain
24
Sep
ASIAN CHAMPIONS LEAGUE: Group Stage
Sepahan - Al Sadd SC Doha
24
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Third qualifying round
KuPS - Suduva
24
Sep
KAZAKHSTAN: Premier League
Kaisar - Astana
24
Sep
CHINA: Super League
Jiangsu Suning - Guangzhou Evergrande
24
Sep
KAZAKHSTAN: Premier League
Ordabasy - Kyzyl-Zhar
24
Sep
RUSSIA: PFL, Group 4
Novosibirsk - KAMAZ
24
Sep
RUSSIA: PFL, Group 4
Dinamo Barnaul - Zenit Izhevsk
24
Sep
RUSSIA: PFL, Group 2
Zenit Irkutsk - Leningradets
24
Sep
RUSSIA: PFL, Group 2
Chita - Dinamo M-2
23
Sep
ENGLAND: League Cup
Leicester City - Arsenal
23
Sep
ENGLAND: League Cup
Chelsea - Barnsley
24
Sep
CHINA: Super League
Henan Jianye - Shandong Luneng
24
Sep
KAZAKHSTAN: Premier League
Zhetysu - Shakhter Karaganda
22
Sep
ENGLAND: League Cup
Luton - Manchester United
21
Sep
ENGLAND: Premier League
Wolves - Manchester City
21
Sep
ITALY: Serie A
AC Milan - Bologna
20
Sep
ENGLAND: Premier League
Chelsea - Liverpool
20
Sep
ENGLAND: Premier League
Southampton - Tottenham Hotspur
20
Sep
FRANCE: Ligue 1
Nice - PSG
20
Sep
SPAIN: La Liga
Real Sociedad - Real Madrid
20
Sep
ITALY: Serie A
Juventus - Sampdoria
20
Sep
ITALY: Serie A
Parma - Napoli
19
Sep
ENGLAND: Premier League
Arsenal - West Ham United
19
Sep
ITALY: Serie A
Verona - Roma
19
Sep
ENGLAND: Premier League
Manchester United - Crystal Palace
17
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Second qualifying round
Lokomotiv Plovdiv - Tottenham Hotspur
17
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Second qualifying round
Shamrock - AC Milan
16
Sep
FRANCE: Ligue 1
PSG - Metz
16
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Barcelona - Girona
15
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Inter Milan - Lugano
14
Sep
ENGLAND: Premier League
Brighton - Chelsea
14
Sep
GERMANY: National cup
Duisburg - Borussia Dortmund
13
Sep
ENGLAND: Premier League
Tottenham Hotspur - Everton
13
Sep
FRANCE: Ligue 1
PSG - Marseille
13
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Juventus - Novara
12
Sep
ENGLAND: Premier League
Liverpool - Leeds
12
Sep
ENGLAND: Premier League
Fulham - Arsenal
10
Sep
FRANCE: Ligue 1
Lens - PSG
09
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Frosinone - Roma
09
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
AC Milan - Vicenza
Find us on Instagram
at @feedimo to stay up to date with the latest.
Featured Video You Might Like
L1eLanNeZKg i1XRgbyUtOo -g9Qziqbif8 0vmRhiLHE2U JFCZUoa6MYE UfN5PCF5EUo 2PV55f3-UAg W3y9zuI_F64 -7qCxIccihU pQ9gcOoH9R8 g5MRDEXRk4k tudKp5Vhs3k
Copyright © 2020 Feedimo. All Rights Reserved.