February 25, 2020
The British government could dodge sanctions for breaking a range of environmental laws because of a lack of clarity over what happens post-Brexit, it has been revealed.There are currently 11 environmental protection cases that could end up in a “dead end” if they are not taken up by a new UK independent regulator after departure from the EU, analysis by Unearthed, Greenpeace’s investigations unit has found.Campaigners say the findings will raise fresh concerns about the government’s future dedication to green concerns – an issue which will return to the fore on Wednesday, as the government’s environment bill has its second Commons reading.Among the outstanding cases is the UK’s failure to bring nitrogen dioxide pollution, much of which comes from diesel vehicles, within legal levels. The court is yet to rule on the case, referred in 2018. “It’s a real concern for us, what may happen after Brexit and whether air quality will even be a real priority,” Jemima Hartshorn, founder of air quality activism group Mums For Lungs, told HuffPost UK.“The government is simply going to be focused on making Brexit seem like a success, and it’s going to be very difficult to hold them to account when we are not a member of the EU.”Under the withdrawal agreement, the European Court of Justice (CJEU) will have jurisdiction over all referrals for breaches of EU law before the end of the Brexit transition period on December 31 – and cases can continue to be launched up until the end of 2024.But legal experts say that there is a risk of them meeting a “dead end”, if for political and financial reasons the EU does little to proactively transfer them to the new Office of Environmental Protection, the UK’s post-Brexit environmental regulator.  Boris Johnson has also refuted the idea of EU jurisdiction after Brexit.Environmental lawyers at ClientEarth, who brought similar cases against the government in the past and won, fear it will not progress to a stage where sanctions, such as a hefty fine, could be implemented. UK spokesperson Tom West said there is “nothing currently that guarantees” active cases will reach a conclusion.“It’s also unclear whether or not the EU courts and EU commission will have the ability to impose fines on these cases,” he added.“The other question is what is going to be the political dynamic of these cases - in what circumstances is it going to be seen as worthwhile or expedient for the Commission to bring such a challenge?”Hartshorn, a mum-of-two, said: “We are really worried the government won’t feel compelled to act without the threat of court action that has acted as a driver in the past.”Other cases referred to the CJEU include: A case originally from 2003 about sewage spills from facilities in London and Whitburn. The CJEU had already ruled that the UK had broken the law and the UK is now awaiting another court date, where heavy fines could be imposed.A case from 2013 that accuses the UK of sewage spills or inadequate treatment of sewage in 17 locationsA 2013 case about a failure to protect sites for harbour porpoises, a threatened species in Europe. The UK has been ordered to create more conservation zonesA 2010 case regarding public access to justice and decision-making on environmental issuesAnother case, at an earlier stage of infringement proceedings, concerns the burning of peat bogs on protected areas in Northern England.Campaigners say the practice, carried out to improve habitat for grouse, exacerbates local flooding as the ground can no longer hold enough water.  The bogs are globally rare and can store huge amounts of carbon, but moorland owners burn them to support grouse shooting. Luke Steele, of Leeds-based campaign group Stop The Shoot, said:  “In recent weeks we have seen firsthand the effects of peat burning, with serious flooding in Yorkshire. “This not only has a human consequence, but also huge economic implications, costing communities millions of pounds. “We know climate change is only going to make incidents like this more common, so it’s vital that we, quite literally, hold back the water on the moors.”Since the EU commission launched its case in 2016, the government has been in discussion with estates to encourage them to cut the practice and had pledged to introduce legislation to ban it, but efforts seem to have stalled. The RSPB’s head of casework told Unearthed: “This was promised two to three years ago, and the UK government hasn’t yet taken this vital last step, so it remains a risk that if the European Commission doesn’t continue to act because of Brexit, the government may not honour its commitment to conserve the UK’s peatlands.”The case is one of six where the EU has begun infringement proceedings, but they have not yet been referred to the CJEU. The others are:A case launched in 2012 that concerns one of Europe’s largest gas plants in Pembroke, Wales. The EU says that the cooling system is causing damage to a protected marine area and its fish, and that environmental assessments were inadequate. A 2007 case that states that the UK has not fully enacted the Water Framework Directive and that authorities lack the power to properly tackle water pollution. A case from 2015 about the UK’s failure to adopt conservation measures under the Habitats DirectiveA case launched last year that states that the UK has not met a deadline to report on the environmental state of its seasA case launched in 2017 about a failure to report to the EU on the transposition of new legislation on air pollution monitoring Experts say the future of these is more uncertain. Francesca Carlsson, legal officer at the European Environmental Bureau, said while the EU Commission claims it is committed to more enforcement, there is the issue of budgets, and whether it is wise for the commission to invest in cases regarding a member state that is not contributing.She added: “Really, it should be up to the UK authorities to ensure compliance with what is now UK law anyway. In some ways, these cases are the first test of whether environmental standards are to be maintained in the UK or whether the government is already seeking to escape enforcement action.”A spokesperson from the EU Commission said: “As set out in the withdrawal agreement, EU law continues to apply in full to the UK for the duration of the transition period. In particular, the UK remains subject to the EU’s enforcement mechanisms, such as infringement procedures.”The UK’s new Office for Environmental Protection, which is being introduced as part of the government’s environment bill in parliament, will be able to start dealing with complaints from 1 January 2021.Green MP Caroline Lucas said any outstanding cases would be “a litmus test” for the government’s pledge to remain “a world-leader in environmental protection” after Brexit.“Environmental laws – whether over dirty air, polluted waters or anything else – must be enforced,” she added.
Exclusive: How Brexit Could Help The Government Dodge Punishment For Breaking Environmental Laws
“The government has an opportunity to fix this in the environment bill.  It must transfer existing cases to the Office for Environmental Protection and, most crucially, grant the watchdog proper independence and real teeth, with enforcement powers similar or better than those of the EU courts and commission.”Any cases currently before the CJEU, or new cases relating to allegations that took place before the end of the transition period and brought within four years of the end of the transition period, will remain under its jurisdiction.Once the new office takes over, failures by public authorities to implement environmental law will no longer be considered through European enforcement processes.  Instead the new body will “engage with public authorities to reach a solution”.Jemima Hartshorn, of Mums For Lungs Hartshorn, added: “It seems to me that this new ‘independent body’ will be far too closely linked to the secretary of state and department to properly hold it to account in any way.”
Doug Parr, Greenpeace UK chief scientist, said failing to deliver on such issues would “speak volumes” about the Johnson government’s reliability “when it comes to safeguarding people and planet”. 
“One thing he can be sure of is that any attempt to sweep the issues under the carpet will not go unnoticed or ignored by those who brought them to public attention. The only right and sensible thing for Johnson to do would be to insist his government properly manages each and every one,” he added.A Defra spokesperson said: “The environment bill demonstrates our global leadership at a crucial time for the planet – creating a world-leading system for environmental governance, with the Office for Environmental Protection as our independent watchdog with the teeth to hold government and other public bodies to account.“We have been clear we will not weaken any of our world-leading environmental standards. Now we have left the EU we will look to enhance these even further where possible.”Related... Has The Australian Bushfire Crisis Changed The Way We Donate To Climate Causes? Boris Johnson To End Sale Of New Petrol And Diesel Cars By 2035 Discarded Plastic And Uneaten Food: The Shameful Story Of Waste On Planes
Related Stories
Latest News
Top news around the world
Russo-Ukrainian War

The Russo-Ukrainian War has been ongoing between Russia and Ukraine since February 2014.

Russia's war in Ukraine has proven almost every assumption wrong, with Europe now wondering what left is safe to assume.

Around the World

Celebrity News

> Latest News in Media

Watch It
Madonna’s most bizarre TikTok and Instagram videos of 2022 | Page Six Celebrity News
December 30, 2022
Ggk_RlohXuI
Teresa Giudice and Luis Ruelas stand by sex multiple times a day: It’s ‘normal’ | Page Six
December 30, 2022
AljKbtgRGnc
Lisa Hochstein shared video confronting Lenny Hochstein & girlfriend at Miami club #shorts | PageSix
December 30, 2022
j_JVk60r6EI
'Channel 5' Creator Andrew Callaghan Talks BTS of 'This Place Rules' Documentary Feature
December 30, 2022
dJit_YG5fjg
#brendanfraser on getting jacked to play 'George of the Jungle' after 'Airheads" with #adamsandler
December 30, 2022
bkwreE4eMRQ
Selena Gomez, Ryan Gosling and Julia Fox Top the List Of Variety's Best Red Carpet Moments Of 2022
December 29, 2022
pv2A-331cLg
Wiz Khalifa Joins Neek Bucks For Upcoming 'Shot Caller' Video | TMZ
December 26, 2022
TxkRr1jj-gk
Andrew Zimmern Says TikTok Recipes Need to Stop This Holiday Season | TMZ
December 26, 2022
DdlO88KfJoY
Top 7 WTF Moments of 2022 | TMZ
December 26, 2022
3JA-5abr6A4
Most HIGHLY ANTICIPATED Movies of 2023 | E! News
January 01, 2023
3-1K1VSRjys
22 Pop Culture Moments That Defined 2022: Link in Comments! #shorts | E! News
December 31, 2022
MNnChuudoSA
Suspect Charged With Murder in Idaho College Killings | E! News
December 31, 2022
aeonRlI5xL0
TV Schedule
Late Night Show
Watch the latest shows of U.S. top comedians

Sports

Latest sport results, news, videos, interviews and comments
Latest Events
01
Jan
ENGLAND: Premier League
Tottenham Hotspur - Aston Villa
01
Jan
ENGLAND: Premier League
Nottingham Forest - Chelsea
01
Jan
ENGLAND: Championship
Coventry - Bristol City
01
Jan
ENGLAND: Championship
Blackburn - Cardiff City
01
Jan
ENGLAND: Championship
Huddersfield - Luton
01
Jan
ENGLAND: Championship
Millwall - Rotherham
01
Jan
ENGLAND: Championship
Blackpool - Sunderland
31
Dec
ENGLAND: Premier League
Manchester City - Everton
31
Dec
ENGLAND: Premier League
Wolves - Manchester United
31
Dec
ENGLAND: Premier League
Brighton - Arsenal
31
Dec
SPAIN: La Liga
Barcelona - Espanyol
31
Dec
SPAIN: La Liga
Real Sociedad - Osasuna
31
Dec
ENGLAND: Premier League
Bournemouth - Crystal Palace
31
Dec
ENGLAND: Premier League
Newcastle United - Leeds
31
Dec
ENGLAND: Premier League
Fulham - Southampton
31
Dec
SPAIN: La Liga
Villarreal - Valencia
30
Dec
SPAIN: La Liga
Real Valladolid - Real Madrid
30
Dec
ENGLAND: Premier League
Liverpool - Leicester City
30
Dec
ENGLAND: Championship
Birmingham - Hull City
30
Dec
ENGLAND: Championship
Stoke City - Burnley
30
Dec
ENGLAND: Championship
Norwich City - Reading
30
Dec
ENGLAND: Premier League
West Ham United - Brentford
30
Dec
ENGLAND: Championship
Swansea City - Watford
30
Dec
SPAIN: La Liga
Celta Vigo - Sevilla
30
Dec
SPAIN: La Liga
Cadiz - Almeria
30
Dec
SPAIN: La Liga
Getafe - Mallorca
29
Dec
SPAIN: La Liga
Atletico Madrid - Elche
29
Dec
ENGLAND: Championship
West Bromwich Albion - Preston NE
29
Dec
ENGLAND: Championship
Blackpool - Sheffield United
28
Dec
ENGLAND: Premier League
Leeds - Manchester City
27
Dec
ENGLAND: Premier League
Manchester United - Nottingham Forest
27
Dec
ENGLAND: Premier League
Chelsea - Bournemouth
26
Dec
ENGLAND: Premier League
Arsenal - West Ham United
26
Dec
ENGLAND: Premier League
Brentford - Tottenham Hotspur
26
Dec
ENGLAND: Premier League
Aston Villa - Liverpool
Find us on Instagram
at @feedimo to stay up to date with the latest.
Featured Video You Might Like
zWJ3MxW_HWA L1eLanNeZKg i1XRgbyUtOo -g9Qziqbif8 0vmRhiLHE2U JFCZUoa6MYE UfN5PCF5EUo 2PV55f3-UAg W3y9zuI_F64 -7qCxIccihU pQ9gcOoH9R8 g5MRDEXRk4k
Copyright © 2020 Feedimo. All Rights Reserved.