Close
Date TimeNovember 07, 2019
Voice
Right to Confrontation: The Latest Bogus Legal Argument over the ‘Whistleblower’
As a constitutional lawyer, Rand Paul makes a good medical doctor.I used to have occasion to say that in the Patriot Act debates, when the senator was wowing us with his Fourth Amendment theories. With impeachment upon us, he’s now onto the Sixth Amendment -- specifically, the confrontation clause. It guarantees the right of cross-examination: In all criminal trials, the accused must be given the right to confront the accusers. Senator Paul has deduced that this must mean that the identity of the so-called whistleblower has to be revealed, lest President Trump be denied his constitutional rights.Sigh.Mind you, Senator Paul has been making this argument while he himself shrinks from outing the man at issue -- whom we are reliably told is a 33-year-old CIA official, formerly tasked to the White House National Security Council as a Ukraine expert. There is but a small circle of people who fit that description, so Paul, like many in Washington, has known the name, to near certainty, for some time.The senator makes the fair point that there is no legal barrier to the media’s naming the man. We can be confident that if a Democratic president had been accused of impeachable offenses, that would already have happened weeks ago (and, indeed, some right-leaning media sites have published the name).Paul conveniently omits, though, that, as a senator, he has speech or debate-clause immunity. Even if there were legal confidentiality concerns here (there aren’t -- I’ll get to that), he could broadcast the name without any liability. Naturally, he wants someone else to take the heat while he carps from the well-appointed cheap seats.The inanity of the legal disputes surrounding the so-called whistleblower does not begin with Paul. It begins with misunderstandings about the concept of whistleblower itself.As I’ve previously explained, the man in question may be a “whistleblower” in some common-usage sense of the word. Yet, he is not a whistleblower in the statutory sense. That’s the only sense that matters because the relevant statute is what triggers whistleblower protections. Under that statute, protected status is given to an official who reports on intelligence activities within the jurisdiction of the director of national intelligence. The statute does not apply to the president’s conducting of foreign policy, including his communications with foreign heads of state.In this instance, the inspector general of the intelligence community (IGIC) chose to handle the man’s complaint as if it raised an intelligence-related “urgent concern,” as defined by the statute. The IGIC thus treated the man as if he had protected status. That was an error. The acting director of national intelligence correctly found that the complaint did not meet the statutory criteria, and he therefore declined to pass it along to Congress (as the statute mandates for complaints that do meet the criteria). But as he is new and understandably did not want to be perceived as throwing the IGIC under the proverbial bus, the acting DNI publicly conformed to the fiction that the man has protected status under the law. He does not.As if that were not enough confusion, we next come to the brouhaha over anonymity. Contrary to what has become received wisdom (Democratic talking points peddled to the media tend to achieve that status), the law does not guarantee anonymity even to a statutorily qualified whistleblower. Instead, it calls for only the ICIG to keep the identity confidential. Even that, though, is an overstatement. The law says that even the ICIG may disclose the person’s identity if the IGIC (a) believes doing so is unavoidable under the circumstances, or (b) makes disclosure to the Justice Department in anticipation of a prosecution.To be fair to Senator Paul, just-mentioned point (b) shows he was in the right ballpark, although way off the mark. If there is a prosecution in court, the Justice Department has various disclosure obligations that take precedence over a witness’s interest in remaining anonymous. Whistleblowers who are essential witnesses in criminal prosecutions do not get to remain anonymous. Paul’s problem, as we’ll see, is that impeachment is not a prosecution in court.The law imposes this highly qualified confidentiality requirement only on the ICIG. It does not bind other government officials, much less members of Congress, the media, and the public. The point of the law is to shield whistleblowers from reprisals (being fired, demoted, denied promotion, transferred to Anchorage, etc.), not from public identification.The posturing on this point has been patently political. If we were dealing with actual classified information that could compromise a significant national-security program, the media would breathlessly reveal it and lecture us about the public’s “right to know” newsworthy information. And when the whistleblower complaint first emerged, it was impeachment impresario Adam Schiff himself who insisted that the whistleblower had to be brought forward to testify. Natch, he did a 180 when it was revealed that the so-called whistleblower had huddled with Schiff’s staff before filing the complaint with the IGIC. (The point of the statute is to create an intra-agency review of complaints before Congress is notified.)Of course, it has since come out that -- I’ll be darned! -- the “whistleblower” has ties to prominent Democratic Trump detractors. So now, the same Democrats who previously saw the man as a potential star witness have decided that his usefulness has run its course. Now that he is a potential liability, it suddenly has become unpatriotic to utter his name.Meanwhile, Republican Trump defenders first took the position that the “whistleblower” was irrelevant because all his material revelations are hearsay. Since we have a transcript of the Trump-Zelensky call, and witnesses with first-hand knowledge about other pertinent events have testified, they reasoned that he was an unnecessary witness. But, as night follows day, once it became clear that Democrats want to hide him away, the GOP decided that the Republic’s survival hinges on his being exposed and interrogated.Hence, Senator Paul’s Sixth Amendment meanderings.The confrontation clause protects only the accused at a criminal trial. The point is that before one’s liberty is taken away, one must have the opportunity to question one’s accusers. Impeachment, however, is not even a legal proceeding, much less a criminal trial. It is a political proceeding. No one’s liberty is at stake; it is strictly about whether an official should be stripped of political authority -- in the president’s case, of the executive power.Moreover, because the Constitution wholly vests the process of impeachment in the House, and the conduct of impeachment trials in the Senate, those chambers have plenary authority over the respective proceedings. No court has the power to tell the House or Senate what quantum of due process must be afforded to an official in an impeachment case. No one can make Congress apply the Sixth Amendment.Finally, even when the Sixth Amendment does apply (at a criminal trial), the confrontation it guarantees is the ability to cross-examine the witnesses the prosecution calls to establish its case. It does not extend to other people (e.g., tipsters, others who’ve provided hearsay information to investigators). It is very common in the investigative stage for police to receive damning information about a suspect from second- and third-hand sources. That information is investigated, which is how the police and prosecutors locate the first-hand witnesses who are called at the eventual trial. There is no right to confront witnesses the prosecutor does not call, even if they have provided accusatory information.The president is not without arguments for why the so-called whistleblower’s identity should be disclosed, and why this person should be called to testify. I’ll address them in a separate column. But for present purposes: The so-called whistleblower is not a statutory whistleblower, and his anonymity is not protected by law; but the Sixth Amendment has nothing to do with impeachment, and it does not advance a claim that the “whistleblower” should be outed and questioned.

Related Stories
The ATF Has Been Enforcing a Rule That Does Not ExistThe ATF Has Been Enforcing a Rule That Does Not Exist
John Oliver Explains Why Trump Might Finally Be Impeached Over Ukraine Whistleblower ScandalJohn Oliver Explains Why Trump Might Finally Be Impeached Over Ukraine Whistleblower Scandal
Bill Clinton and Jeb Bush seek refuge from Trump impeachment stormBill Clinton and Jeb Bush seek refuge from Trump impeachment storm
Len Goodman’s Rude Response To Contestant’s High-Five On US Strictly Shocks ViewersLen Goodman’s 'Rude' Response To Contestant’s High-Five On US Strictly Shocks Viewers
Philip Hammond Says He Will Not Back Election As Brexit Crisis LoomsPhilip Hammond Says He Will Not Back Election As Brexit Crisis Looms
Hong Kong lashed by fresh violence as thousands defy mask banHong Kong lashed by fresh violence as thousands defy mask ban
Mueller Was Seeking FBI Director Job When He Met with Trump in 2017: ReportMueller Was Seeking FBI Director Job When He Met with Trump in 2017: Report
Former SC congressman Mark Sanford announces GOP presidential bid against TrumpFormer SC congressman Mark Sanford announces GOP presidential bid against Trump
The Latest: Dems agree Giuliani should testify about UkraineThe Latest: Dems agree Giuliani should testify about Ukraine
Trumps stonewalling could speed up impeachmentTrump's stonewalling could speed up impeachment
Latest News
Taylor Swift Says Scooter Braun, Scott Borchetta Are Blocking Her From Playing Old Hits at AMAsTaylor Swift Says Scooter Braun, Scott Borchetta Are Blocking Her From Playing Old Hits at AMAs
Labour Promises Free Broadband For All If It Wins The General ElectionLabour Promises Free Broadband For All If It Wins The General Election
Ruth Bader Ginsburg misses Supreme Court hearings due to illnessRuth Bader Ginsburg misses Supreme Court hearings due to illness
Bolivia interim leader recognises Guaido as legitimate Venezuelan leader as balance shiftsBolivia interim leader recognises Guaido as legitimate Venezuelan leader as balance shifts
Jewish Groups Blast Fox News for Joe diGenova’s Anti-Semitic Soros Conspiracy TheoryJewish Groups Blast Fox News for Joe diGenova’s Anti-Semitic Soros Conspiracy Theory
Worlds oldest captive white rhino dies in French zooWorld's oldest captive white rhino dies in French zoo
England celebrate 1,000th game with seven-goal charge into Euro 2020 finalsEngland celebrate 1,000th game with seven-goal charge into Euro 2020 finals
Roger Federer defeats Novak Djokovic: ATP Finals – as it happenedRoger Federer defeats Novak Djokovic: ATP Finals – as it happened
Sonny Bill Williams steps into unknown but Toronto mission is no ‘holiday’Sonny Bill Williams steps into unknown but Toronto mission is no ‘holiday’
Harry Kane hears echoes of the past and rockets past Finney and Shearer | Barney RonayHarry Kane hears echoes of the past and rockets past Finney and Shearer | Barney Ronay
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Boris-JohnsonBoris Johnson
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Theresa-MayTheresa May
Member of Parliament of the United Kingdom
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
The ATF Has Been Enforcing a Rule That Does Not ExistThe ATF Has Been Enforcing a Rule That Does Not Exist
John Oliver Explains Why Trump Might Finally Be Impeached Over Ukraine Whistleblower ScandalJohn Oliver Explains Why Trump Might Finally Be Impeached Over Ukraine Whistleblower Scandal
Bill Clinton and Jeb Bush seek refuge from Trump impeachment stormBill Clinton and Jeb Bush seek refuge from Trump impeachment storm
Len Goodman’s Rude Response To Contestant’s High-Five On US Strictly Shocks ViewersLen Goodman’s 'Rude' Response To Contestant’s High-Five On US Strictly Shocks Viewers
Philip Hammond Says He Will Not Back Election As Brexit Crisis LoomsPhilip Hammond Says He Will Not Back Election As Brexit Crisis Looms
Hong Kong lashed by fresh violence as thousands defy mask banHong Kong lashed by fresh violence as thousands defy mask ban
Mueller Was Seeking FBI Director Job When He Met with Trump in 2017: ReportMueller Was Seeking FBI Director Job When He Met with Trump in 2017: Report
Former SC congressman Mark Sanford announces GOP presidential bid against TrumpFormer SC congressman Mark Sanford announces GOP presidential bid against Trump
The Latest: Dems agree Giuliani should testify about UkraineThe Latest: Dems agree Giuliani should testify about Ukraine
Trumps stonewalling could speed up impeachmentTrump's stonewalling could speed up impeachment
Latest News
Taylor Swift Says Scooter Braun, Scott Borchetta Are Blocking Her From Playing Old Hits at AMAsTaylor Swift Says Scooter Braun, Scott Borchetta Are Blocking Her From Playing Old Hits at AMAs
Labour Promises Free Broadband For All If It Wins The General ElectionLabour Promises Free Broadband For All If It Wins The General Election
Ruth Bader Ginsburg misses Supreme Court hearings due to illnessRuth Bader Ginsburg misses Supreme Court hearings due to illness
Bolivia interim leader recognises Guaido as legitimate Venezuelan leader as balance shiftsBolivia interim leader recognises Guaido as legitimate Venezuelan leader as balance shifts
Jewish Groups Blast Fox News for Joe diGenova’s Anti-Semitic Soros Conspiracy TheoryJewish Groups Blast Fox News for Joe diGenova’s Anti-Semitic Soros Conspiracy Theory
Worlds oldest captive white rhino dies in French zooWorld's oldest captive white rhino dies in French zoo
England celebrate 1,000th game with seven-goal charge into Euro 2020 finalsEngland celebrate 1,000th game with seven-goal charge into Euro 2020 finals
Roger Federer defeats Novak Djokovic: ATP Finals – as it happenedRoger Federer defeats Novak Djokovic: ATP Finals – as it happened
Sonny Bill Williams steps into unknown but Toronto mission is no ‘holiday’Sonny Bill Williams steps into unknown but Toronto mission is no ‘holiday’
Harry Kane hears echoes of the past and rockets past Finney and Shearer | Barney RonayHarry Kane hears echoes of the past and rockets past Finney and Shearer | Barney Ronay
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Boris-JohnsonBoris Johnson
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Theresa-MayTheresa May
Member of Parliament of the United Kingdom
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Roger Stone trial: Witness denies 'back-channel' to WikiLeaks in bizarre testimony
Two BOE Members Unexpectedly Vote for Rate Cut as Outlook Sours
EU's Moscovici expects orderly Brexit
Kesha: 'The world's going to burn up – I might as well have a good time'
Domestic disco! How messages from a marriage became a unique double LP
Kele: 2042 review – Okereke's most political work yet
Land of Kush: Sand Enigma review – the disorientating sound of Egypt
'It's possible to live together in peace': the Turkish rap epic taking on the government
Dawid Malan's stunning century sets up England rout in fourth T20 international
Australia v Pakistan: third Twenty20 international – live!
Stephen Colbert and Jimmy Kimmel think it's a bad sign William Barr declined to defend Trump on Ukraine
Driven review – stranger-than-fiction tale of drugs and DeLoreans
Man Made: behind a powerful documentary about trans bodybuilders
The Yacht-Racing Gay Rights Campaigner Who Wants To Be A Brexit Party MP
How Not To End Up With A Sh*t Haircut – We Asked The Experts
Why Every Mother Deserves A ‘Mum Cave’
Rightwing columnist smacks journalist Glenn Greenwald on Brazil radio show
'Attack on the media': Vanuatu newspaper boss has work visa refused
ABC pulls Q&A’s 'confronting' feminist debate from iview amid investigation | Weekly Beast
Sea levels could rise even faster, higher than feared: study
Dirty Indian Politics Has No Answer for the World’s Most Toxic Air
In Trump adviser trial, comedian contradicts Stone's account, regales jury with jokes
U.S. Warns Asean That Cambodia Exiles Face Torture if Sent Back
Hong Kong protesters blame police after student dies in fall
Year's most destructive California wildfire declared extinguished after two weeks
House Republicans appear to be throwing Giuliani, Sondland, and Mulvaney under the bus to save Trump
'Bala' Movie Review: Ayushmann Khurrana's Film Is A Delightful Parody On Bollywood
The Best Gift Subscription Boxes To Give This Christmas
I Was Unexpectedly Widowed at 29. Then I Found Out About My Husband's Affairs
Man serving life sentence says it ended once he died, was revived in medical emergency
Families come from across U.S. to grieve relatives slain in Mexico
Brazil for first time votes against U.N. call for end to U.S. embargo on Cuba
Vietnam to Check Huawei, Xiaomi Phones for Disputed Map: Report
Democrat Sanders vows to halt immigration raids, deportations if elected president
Inside the Private Messages of Neo-Nazi Group Atomwaffen Division
Elizabeth Warren challenges Bill Gates on 'wealth tax'
New Zealand v England: fourth T20 international – live!
Anger over Las Vegas ban on sleeping in streets
The Latest: Chicago mayor: Police chief staying through year
Mainland Chinese student jailed in Hong Kong protests
Mexico killing highlights confusion over Mormon groups
Looking for a hero: shirtless Chilean protester, police-hating dog rise to fame
After Democratic legislative gains, Virginia governor vows new gun-control push
Fox’s ‘BH90210’ Will Not Return for Season 2
'Weeds' Revival In the Works at Starz; Mary-Louise Parker Set to Return
SPAC Nation Scandal: Church Fighting Knife Crime Fails To Act On Rogue Pastors Flourishing In Its Ranks
Trump fumes about reports that he wanted Barr to host news conference clearing him on Ukraine call
The Latest: Las Vegas makes sleeping on the streets illegal
Charges: Chinese surveillance goods illegally sold to US
Child seats in Italy to be fitted with alarms after spate of deaths of children trapped in hot cars
Some in GOP warn against election challenge in Kentucky
Dirty Indian Politics Have No Answer for the World’s Most Toxic Air
Chicago police chief steps down after tumultuous three years
Manchester City fear repeat of bus attack after message to Liverpool fans
Jamie Chadwick inspired by Lewis Hamilton in ambition to compete in F1
Manchester United reach last 32 after Anthony Martial strikes against Partizan
Uefa must increase sanctions to help eradicate racism, says Gareth Southgate
'Rugby’s LeBron James': Toronto confirm Sonny Bill Williams signing
Neil Lennon hails Celtic’s ‘amazing’ night after win away to Lazio
Eric Dier: ‘People said I was injured but I just kept on falling ill’
Jonny Bairstow asked by England to stay in New Zealand for Test warm-ups
Alfredo Morelos breaks deadlock for Rangers to overcome Porto
Raúl Jiménez heads Wolves to verge of Europa League knockout stage
Fans’ representative resigns from Hibernian board over ‘relentless abuse’
James Maddison recalled by England and made aware of responsibilities
Kanye West awkwardly asks crowd 'what y'all laughing at' while describing plans to run for president
Apple TV Plus Renews Four Series as Glimpses Emerge of First-Week Activity
Tory Candidate Nick Conrad, Who Said Women Should 'Keep Their Knickers On' To Avoid Rape, Stands Down
The Latest: Netanyahu says UN watchdog 'confirms Iran lied'
Farmers blamed for Delhi's pollution say they are helpless
Secret Service study: School attackers showed warning signs
Johnson, Grassley ask State Department for Hunter Biden docs
Witch hunt or necessity? Maine's rugged independent voters torn over impeaching Trump
Al-Baghdadi's wife revealed ISIS group secrets after capture
White House expects two new hires to bolster Trump impeachment defense: official
Canadian man who lost eye after police beating says he had 'no chance to fight back'
His Victim Forgave Him Years Ago. Now the State Has, Too
Texas executes inmate for strangling El Paso woman in 2002
Manchester United v Partizan, Wolves and Rangers in action: Europa League – live!
Olivier Ntcham’s late show at Lazio fires Celtic into Europa League last 32
On Bean’s Final Broadcast, ‘Poorman’ Comes on KROQ for First Time Since 1993 Firing — and It Gets Real
Kristen Bell to Return as Narrator for HBO Max ‘Gossip Girl’ Reboot
Succession season two finale – battle of the backstabbers: discuss with spoilers
Uxbridge Murder Inquiry: Teenager Dies After Being Stabbed In The Chest In West London
U.N. nuclear watchdog, Western powers criticize Iran for holding inspector
The Latest: Texas man executed in 2002 strangulation
Baghdadi's wife revealed IS group secrets after capture
'Prepare to die' Trump adviser Stone texted witness, trial jury hears
The Latest: Mexico official says suspect not tied to attack
Robots 'not evil' says Boston Dynamics as humanoids go viral
Baby Faith found in bullet-ridden SUV reunited with dad after Mexico family massacre
Pep Guardiola needs Champions League win with City to join all-time greats | Eni Aluko
Labour Candidate Defends Would-Be MP Who Said She’d Cheer Blair’s Demise: ‘People Celebrated Hitler’s Death’
George Osborne Warns Of Tory Tax Bombshell As Javid Unveils £100bn 'Renewal Fund'
I’m A Rape Survivor With Good Reason To Fear A Boris Johnson Government
Bevin Refuses to Concede Kentucky Gubernatorial Race, Citing Voting ‘Irregularities’
Factbox: Key facts about Ethiopia's giant Nile dam
Democrats won Virginia and are claiming victory in Kentucky. What's next?
Woman who lost job for middle-finger gesture to Trump wins election and now gets power to legislate over his golf course
Top Republican McConnell says Twitter ban on political ads undermines free speech
New Zealand passes law aimed at combating climate change
Muslim preachers must speak German to work in the country under proposed law
McConnell, Trump joined for 2020, despite Kentucky setback
The internet can't get enough of this betrayed cat
Chicago's top cop retiring after turbulent 3-plus years
Beverly Glenn-Copeland review – a trance state of love, nature and spirituality
Lazio v Celtic and more: Europa League – live!
What has gone wrong for Phil Neville’s England – and how can he fix it?
Chelsea's manic draw with Ajax and Kyle Walker in goal – Football Weekly Extra
Betting patterns could be scrutinised in modified whip case
Antonio Brown says he has quit NFL and accuses league of racial discrimination
Former Team Sky doctor’s QC to question credibility of head coach
Stand-in keepers: outfield players between the posts – in pictures
Marco Silva says it is ‘possible’ for André Gomes to play again this season
Stoke confident of landing Northern Ireland’s Michael O’Neill as manager
The Fiver | Winning the coin toss in a triumph suggesting he is to the captaincy born
Meghan McCain confronts Trump Jr. on The View: 'You and your family have hurt a lot of people'
Study finds LGBTQ characters hit record high on network TV
GLAAD: LGBTQ Series Regulars on Broadcast TV Hit All-Time High
2040 review – an optimist's guide to saving the world
Royal Mint Released This Poppy Coin To Mark 100 Years Of Remembrance Day
‘It’s Only Because I Love You’ – This Is What It’s Like To Survive An Emotionally Abusive Relationship
Justin Theroux Is Making a Request To Ex Jennifer Aniston On Instagram
BritBox: 'inappropriate' classic UK TV shows to be kept off service
Jodie Chesney murder: Two teens found guilty
US rapper TI faces backlash over daughter’s virginity test
Then and now: One year after devastating Paradise California wildfire
Rep. Tulsi Gabbard clashes with 'View' co-host
Teacher suspended for 'segregating students based on religion and mocking them for their beliefs'
The Wrong Defense
Bangladesh bans fringe Islamist group
Sen. Tom Cotton says the only answer to heavily armed Mexican cartels is more bullets and bigger bullets
'I'm not convinced we will have fair elections in America': Stacey Abrams' fight against voter suppression
The Latest: UN nuclear agency slams Iran explosives' claim
Mary Cain ‘emotionally and physically abused’ by Alberto Salazar’s system
Trump ‘very keen’ on doing ‘The Apprentice: White House’, and keeps pitching it to NBC creator Mark Burnett
Dr Dre's 20 best productions – ranked!
Blood, terror and bass: the heavy return of dub poetry
Mary Cain ‘emotionally and physically abused’ by Alberto Salazar’s system
GB’s Alex Walmsley: ‘There’s a point you know you’re done, but I wasn’t’
Macclesfield battling to end players' strike over wages before FA Cup tie
Sheffield Lib Dems HQ Burgled, Phones And Laptops Reported Missing
This Is What A Hymen Actually Does And Doesn't Do
Dawn Butler Announces She Will Run For Labour Deputy Leader
Essex Lorry Deaths: Police Identify All 39 People Found Dead
UK police ID all 39 Vietnamese victims found in truck
Iran holding IAEA inspector was 'outrageous provocation': U.S
South Korea deports North Koreans who fled after killing 16
Ten Nigerian troops killed in jihadist ambush: military sources
Boris Johnson’s Tories Stumble as Senior Minister Forced to Apologize
China jails nine for selling fentanyl into US
Manchin, Tester Vow They’ll Never Nuke the Legislative Filibuster
Gordon Ramsey Drives Dozens Of His Insane Cars On Track
FKA twigs: Magdalene review – stifled perfection from pop's poledancing swordfighter
England call up Oxlade-Chamberlain, Hudson-Odoi and Stones for qualifiers
Scottish Rugby fined £70,000 over Mark Dodson’s World Cup comments
Watford have not won a league game this season, but all is not lost
How 'Crazy Rich Asians' paved the way for the diverse couples in 'Last Christmas'
Stabbed tongues and swallowed eyeballs: was the Amazing Johnathan's terminal diagnosis his greatest trick?
Reanimating James Dean is a monstrous, legacy-destroying idea
Polar Squad review – John Cleese dials it up for lukewarm anti-fracking fable
Whitney Houston's Best Friend Breaks Silence On Their 'Physical' Relationship
Being A Boss Has Nothing To Do With Having A Vagina
BritBox: All Your Questons About The Streaming Service Answered, Including What Shows To Look Out For
BBC Breakfast's Dan Walker Hits Back After Susanna Reid's Column About 'Catty' Male Presenters
Dalian Atkinson Death: Police Officer Charged With Murdering Former Aston Villa Footballer
It's mission impossible! Why BritBox will never rival Netflix
Three charged in US with spying on Twitter users for Saudi Arabia
Alex Jones Goes on Tirade Against Roger Stone Jurors
Israel aiding Syria's Kurds, advocating for them with U.S.: official
Hong Kong court convicts teen for carrying laser pointer
Germany commits to NATO spending goal by 2031 for first time
The Latest: 5 kids are stable after surviving Mexico attack
Rajan Declines to Comment If He's Been Approached About BOE Job
Johnny Marr scotches Smiths reunion rumours: 'Nigel Farage on guitar'
FKA twigs: Magdalene review – an emotional study in chaos and order
Dylan Hartley, former England captain, retires from rugby because of injury
Police officer charged with murder of Dalian Atkinson
Hypocrisy is in the air as Premiership rivals turn their backs on Saracens | The Breakdown
England’s Ellie Roebuck says watching Lionesses at Wembley was life-changing
Son Heung-min in text message contact with André Gomes after serious injury
England’s Joe Denly back in the nets as Test players arrive in New Zealand
Stoke hope to land Northern Ireland’s Michael O’Neill as manager with big offer
The Good Liar review – Helen Mirren and Ian McKellen are irresistible
Rise of the Footsoldier 4: Marbella review – another round of cheery nastiness
Jeremy Edwards Hits Back At Anton Du Beke After X Factor Celebrity Jibes
Police Officer Charged With Murdering Former Aston Villa Footballer Dalian Atkinson
Labour Candidate Who Wanted To ‘Celebrate’ Death Of Tony Blair Faces Deselection
UK Weather: Met Office Warns Of 'Danger To Life' As Severe Rainfall Sets In
Harry Dunn Death: Ambulance Delay Saw Teenager Lying Untreated On The Road For 43 Mins
5 Secrets Of Pasta Perfection From Italian Grannies In The Know
Bill Gates says Elizabeth Warren’s wealth tax would leave him ‘counting what he had left over’
Trump news – live: Attorney general ‘refused’ president’s request to deny he had broken law over Ukraine, as impeachment inquiry names first public witnesses
Consulting Firm Hired by Burisma Leveraged Biden’s Name to Secure Meeting with State Dept
Russia re-enacts legendary World War II parade in Moscow
Lizzo review – love-bombing, hair-flipping hen party energy
Whitney Houston's close friend Robyn Crawford says they had sexual relationship
Can Liverpool v Manchester City be accepted as England’s biggest game? | Paul Wilson
VAR celebrations, ice-hockey genius and a cat's NFL touchdown | Classic YouTube
Lewis Hamilton ‘reminds me very much of Ayrton Senna’, says Gerhard Berger
Close