Close
Date TimeSeptember 28, 2019
Voice
How about a Bipartisan Treaty against the Criminalization of Elections?
Back home in the Bronx is where I first heard the old saw about the Irishman who, coming upon a donnybrook at the local pub, asks a bystander: “Is this a private fight or can anybody join?”I was a much younger fellow then. The prospect becomes less alluring with age, so I have some trepidation stepping in between two old friends, Andrew Napolitano and Joe DiGenova. Through intermediary hosts, the pair -- Napolitano a former New Jersey Superior Court jurist and law professor, DiGenova a former United States Attorney for the District of Columbia and prominent defense lawyer -- brawled this week on Fox News (where I, like they, contribute regularly).I’m going to steer clear of the pugnacious to-ing and fro-ing. Let’s consider the intriguing legal issue that ignited it.Judge Napolitano argues that the July 25 conversation between President Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky contains the makings of a campaign-finance crime. He highlights Trump’s request for Ukraine’s help in investigating then–vice president Joe Biden. In 2016, Biden pressured Kyiv to drop a corruption investigation of Burisma, a natural gas company that paid Biden’s son, Hunter, big bucks to sit on its board.Biden, of course, is one of the favorites for the Democratic presidential nomination. Napolitano reasons that the information Trump sought from Ukraine would be a form of “opposition research” that could be seen as an in-kind donation to Trump’s reelection campaign, which should be deemed illegal because the law prohibits foreign contributions and attempts to acquire them. (Napolitano also raised the “arguable” possibility of a bribery offense, on the theory that Trump was withholding defense aid as a corrupt quid pro quo to get the Biden information. But he emphasized the foreign contribution issue. That is his stronger argument, and I am focusing on it, given that the Trump-Zelensky transcript does not support a quid pro quo demand; plus bribery, in any event, raises the same “thing of value” proof problems addressed below.)DiGenova strongly disagrees. Though there wasn’t much time to elaborate, he is clearly relying on the lack of past campaign-law prosecutions on similar facts. DiGenova is also voicing the prudent conservative hostility to campaign-finance laws: Any expansion of criminal liability would necessarily restrict political speech, the core of First Amendment liberty.I’m with DiGenova on this, but it’s a closer question than he suggests. Napolitano’s construction of the campaign laws, while not wholly implausible, is purely academic. It ignores real-world concerns about free speech and the prosecutor’s burden to prove intent.Most of the commentary on this has been very politicized (surprise!). For dyed-in-the-wool anti-Trumpers, no technicality is too trifling to be a felony. For the Trump base, it’s all a witch hunt. In light of this, the most helpful source we can turn to is the Mueller Report. (File in: Sentences I’d Have Bet My Life I’d Never Write.)Special Counsel Robert Mueller’s team overflowed with partisan Democrats, and their report could have been entitled “Roadmap to Impeachment.” While they faced complications (that I’ve addressed) in making a case against the president, the prosecutors were not inhibited when it came to other subjects of the investigation. They’d have loved to nail Donald Trump Jr. But the only thing they had was the notorious Trump Tower Meeting of June 2016, when Don Jr. orchestrated a meeting with a Kremlin-tied lawyer (Natalya Veselnitskaya) in an effort to obtain Russian dirt to be used against Hillary Clinton. Veselnitskaya supplied information, but it was a dud.The campaign-finance offense that Napolitano urges be charged against President Trump appears to be the same one Mueller considered charging against Don Jr. The Mueller team’s analysis (Vol. 1, pp. 186-187) is thus on point. And it is frustratingly ambiguous -- as befits the constitutionally dubious campaign-finance laws.Two offense elements proved to be stumbling blocks for the prosecutors. The first is the question whether opposition research is a “thing of value” under federal law. Mueller’s team assumed that, in theory, it might be (the Napolitano view), but that to interpret it as such would break new ground and raise troubling First Amendment issues (the DiGenova position).The second problem was the intent element. As I’ve observed before, regulatory crimes are not innately wrong (in contrast to, say, murder or robbery). They are illegal only because we choose to make them illegal (for you Latinists out there, they are malum prohibitum). Because the conduct is not wrong in itself (malum in se), the law requires a higher degree of malevolent intent before it can be criminalized. Prosecutors must prove willfulness, which very nearly reverses the adage that “ignorance of the law is no excuse.” The defendant must be shown to have known that his intentional conduct was illegal -- not merely unsavory but actually prohibited by law. The Mueller team concluded that they could not have hoped to prove willfulness beyond a reasonable doubt.So, while there might be some conceivable scenario in which acquiring information from a foreign source for use in a campaign could be a federal crime, it is highly unlikely -- so unlikely that some Type A prosecutors wisely decided that the huzzahs they’d have gotten for indicting the president’s son were outweighed by the humiliation they’d endure when the case inevitably got thrown out of court.The Mueller report is also worth considering because the campaign-finance charge the prosecutors rejected is stronger than would be any similar charge against President Trump arising out of the Zelensky call. That, no doubt, is why the Justice Department summarily declined prosecution.To hear the media-Democrat complex tell it, DOJ declined because it is beholden to the president and Attorney General Barr is acting as Trump’s lawyer, not the government’s chief prosecutor. No one who actually took five minutes to read the relevant section of the Mueller Report would see it that way. Moreover, the fact that the president is president complicates matters not only politically but legally.Trump detractors hyper-focus on the president’s request that President Zelensky provide Attorney General Barr with any information Ukraine might have about Biden twisting arms to quash an investigation involving his son’s cashing in on dad’s influence. I say “hyper-focus” because there was a lot more to it than that. Long before the conversation came around to the Biden topic, the “favor” that Trump asked for was Zelensky’s assistance in Barr’s ongoing investigation of the genesis of the Trump-Russia investigation.No matter how much Democrats seek to discredit that probe and the AG overseeing it, it is a legitimate investigation conducted by the United States Department of Justice, which has prosecutors assigned and grand jury subpoena power. It is examining questionable Justice Department and FBI conduct. It is considering whether irregularities rise to the level of crimes. It will be essential to Congress’s consideration of whether laws need to be enacted or modified to insulate our election campaigns from politicized use of the government’s counterintelligence and law-enforcement powers.I mention all this because it is a commonplace for the government to seek assistance from foreign counterparts for ongoing federal investigations.Indeed, as Marc Thiessen pointed out this week in an important Washington Post column, Democratic senators pressured Ukraine to cooperate with the Mueller probe -- notwithstanding the obvious potential electoral ramifications and the specter of “foreign interference in our democracy.” These requests for assistance often occur at the head-of-state level. When I was a federal prosecutor in the mid-nineties, for example, the FBI and Justice Department asked President Clinton to intervene with Saudi authorities to assist the investigation of Iranian complicity in the Khobar Towers bombing.There is nothing wrong with our government’s requesting the assistance of foreign governments that have access to witnesses and evidence relevant to an ongoing Justice Department investigation. The president is the democratically elected, constitutionally empowered chief executive: There is nothing his subordinates may properly do that he may not do himself (it is his power that they exercise). And the president is never conflicted out of executive branch business due to his political interests. There is no legal or ethical requirement that the Justice Department be denied potentially probative evidence because obtaining it might affect the president’s political fortunes.There was no impropriety in President Trump’s asking Ukraine’s president to assist the Justice Department’s investigation of Russiagate’s origins. Okay, you say, but what does that have to do with Biden?Well, Biden was the Obama administration’s point man in dealing with Kyiv after Viktor Yanukovych fled in 2014. That course of dealing came to include Obama administration agencies leaning on Ukraine to assist the FBI in the investigation of Paul Manafort, Trump’s campaign chairman. So, Biden’s interaction with Ukraine is germane: The fact that he had sufficient influence to coerce the firing of a prosecutor; the fact that, while Biden was strongly influencing international economic aid for Kyiv, a significant Ukrainian energy company thought it expedient to bring Biden’s son onto its board and compensate him lavishly -- although Hunter Biden had no experience in the industry.That aside, I do not understand why there has not been more public discussion of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act in light of the instances of Hunter Biden conveniently cashing in with foreign firms while his dad was shaping American policy toward those firm’s governments. As we saw with the collusion caper, it does not take much evidence of any crime for the FBI and the Justice Department to open an investigation and scorch the earth in conducting it. And if it would have been legit for the Justice Department to open an FCPA investigation of one or both of the Bidens, then it was appropriate for President Trump to ask President Zelensky to help the Justice Department determine if an FCPA crime took place – even if doing so could have affected the 2020 fortunes of Biden and Trump.Don’t get me wrong: I am not rooting for Joe Biden or his son to be subjected to investigation and prosecution. I agree with Attorney General Barr that there has been too much politicization of law enforcement and intelligence. In the absence of a concrete, patent, and serious violation of the criminal law, I want the Justice Department and the FBI out of politics – which would be better for them and for politics. If you think there is an indecorous heavy-handedness to the way Donald Trump and Joe Biden conduct foreign policy, that’s fine – go vote against them on Election Day. We don’t need creative prosecutors deciding elections by testing the boundaries of abstruse statutes.Neither, however, do I believe in unilateral disarmament. There is at least as much basis for opening an FCPA investigation against the Bidens as for opening campaign-finance investigations against the Trumps. If I had my druthers, all of this nonsense would end. But as I detailed earlier this week, we have one candidate for the presidency -- a once-serious legal scholar and practitioner -- who publicly and straight-faced says Trump’s call with Zelensky could rate the death penalty. As we saw in the late 1990s, when Bill Clinton got to experience the independent-counsel statute up close and personal, maybe it takes Democrats being hoisted on their own petard before we finally say: This has to stop.

Related Stories
The ATF Has Been Enforcing a Rule That Does Not ExistThe ATF Has Been Enforcing a Rule That Does Not Exist
Investigation Launched Into Awarding Of Grant To Boris Johnsons Close FriendInvestigation Launched Into Awarding Of Grant To Boris Johnson's 'Close Friend'
Labour NEC In Shock Move To Abolish Tom Watsons Deputy Leader PostLabour NEC In Shock Move To Abolish Tom Watson's Deputy Leader Post
Donald Trump vows to hit Taliban harder than ever on 9/11 anniversaryDonald Trump vows to 'hit Taliban harder than ever' on 9/11 anniversary
Trump insists incorrect ‘Sharpiegate’ hurricane map is accurateTrump insists incorrect ‘Sharpiegate’ hurricane map is accurate
John Oliver Explains Why Trump Might Finally Be Impeached Over Ukraine Whistleblower ScandalJohn Oliver Explains Why Trump Might Finally Be Impeached Over Ukraine Whistleblower Scandal
Dem presidential candidates call for Kavanaughs impeachmentDem presidential candidates call for Kavanaugh's impeachment
The blockbuster that wasnt: inside an alleged $14m scam to make the next Netflix hitThe blockbuster that wasn't: inside an alleged $14m scam to make the next Netflix hit
Bill Clinton and Jeb Bush seek refuge from Trump impeachment stormBill Clinton and Jeb Bush seek refuge from Trump impeachment storm
Diahann Carroll Remembered by Ava DuVernay, Mitzi Gaynor and More:  ‘One of the All-Time Greats’Diahann Carroll Remembered by Ava DuVernay, Mitzi Gaynor and More: ‘One of the All-Time Greats’
Latest News
Chile protests: At least eight people killed during riots in SantiagoChile protests: At least eight people killed during riots in Santiago
William Barrs speech on religious freedom alarms liberal CatholicsWilliam Barr's speech on religious freedom alarms liberal Catholics
Thousands protest against Haitis presidentThousands protest against Haiti's president
Milan seeks US apology for WWII bomb that killed childrenMilan seeks US apology for WWII bomb that killed children
Lebanon rocked by vast protests demanding resignation of Hariri governmentLebanon rocked by vast protests demanding resignation of Hariri government
Michael Cheika does it his way but Wallabies results spoke loud and clear | Bret HarrisMichael Cheika does it his way but Wallabies results spoke loud and clear | Bret Harris
How A Single Lost Letter Can Cost The Homeless A HouseHow A Single Lost Letter Can Cost The Homeless A House
Burmese fishermen faint after mistaking $20 million of floating crystal meth for natural deodorantBurmese fishermen 'faint' after mistaking $20 million of floating crystal meth for natural deodorant
Syria, Ukraine, Republican rebellion, G7: Trumps very bad weekSyria, Ukraine, Republican rebellion, G7: Trump's very bad week
Priscilla to unleash flooding rainfall across southwest Mexico early this weekPriscilla to unleash flooding rainfall across southwest Mexico early this week
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Boris-JohnsonBoris Johnson
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Theresa-MayTheresa May
Member of Parliament of the United Kingdom
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
The ATF Has Been Enforcing a Rule That Does Not ExistThe ATF Has Been Enforcing a Rule That Does Not Exist
Investigation Launched Into Awarding Of Grant To Boris Johnsons Close FriendInvestigation Launched Into Awarding Of Grant To Boris Johnson's 'Close Friend'
Labour NEC In Shock Move To Abolish Tom Watsons Deputy Leader PostLabour NEC In Shock Move To Abolish Tom Watson's Deputy Leader Post
Donald Trump vows to hit Taliban harder than ever on 9/11 anniversaryDonald Trump vows to 'hit Taliban harder than ever' on 9/11 anniversary
Trump insists incorrect ‘Sharpiegate’ hurricane map is accurateTrump insists incorrect ‘Sharpiegate’ hurricane map is accurate
John Oliver Explains Why Trump Might Finally Be Impeached Over Ukraine Whistleblower ScandalJohn Oliver Explains Why Trump Might Finally Be Impeached Over Ukraine Whistleblower Scandal
Dem presidential candidates call for Kavanaughs impeachmentDem presidential candidates call for Kavanaugh's impeachment
The blockbuster that wasnt: inside an alleged $14m scam to make the next Netflix hitThe blockbuster that wasn't: inside an alleged $14m scam to make the next Netflix hit
Bill Clinton and Jeb Bush seek refuge from Trump impeachment stormBill Clinton and Jeb Bush seek refuge from Trump impeachment storm
Diahann Carroll Remembered by Ava DuVernay, Mitzi Gaynor and More:  ‘One of the All-Time Greats’Diahann Carroll Remembered by Ava DuVernay, Mitzi Gaynor and More: ‘One of the All-Time Greats’
Latest News
Chile protests: At least eight people killed during riots in SantiagoChile protests: At least eight people killed during riots in Santiago
William Barrs speech on religious freedom alarms liberal CatholicsWilliam Barr's speech on religious freedom alarms liberal Catholics
Thousands protest against Haitis presidentThousands protest against Haiti's president
Milan seeks US apology for WWII bomb that killed childrenMilan seeks US apology for WWII bomb that killed children
Lebanon rocked by vast protests demanding resignation of Hariri governmentLebanon rocked by vast protests demanding resignation of Hariri government
Michael Cheika does it his way but Wallabies results spoke loud and clear | Bret HarrisMichael Cheika does it his way but Wallabies results spoke loud and clear | Bret Harris
How A Single Lost Letter Can Cost The Homeless A HouseHow A Single Lost Letter Can Cost The Homeless A House
Burmese fishermen faint after mistaking $20 million of floating crystal meth for natural deodorantBurmese fishermen 'faint' after mistaking $20 million of floating crystal meth for natural deodorant
Syria, Ukraine, Republican rebellion, G7: Trumps very bad weekSyria, Ukraine, Republican rebellion, G7: Trump's very bad week
Priscilla to unleash flooding rainfall across southwest Mexico early this weekPriscilla to unleash flooding rainfall across southwest Mexico early this week
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Boris-JohnsonBoris Johnson
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Theresa-MayTheresa May
Member of Parliament of the United Kingdom
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Boy Blue: Redd review – sequel to Blak Whyte Gray pushes the pain button
Michael Cheika embarrassed at tackle confusion in Australia’s loss to Wales
World Athletics Championships 2019: women's 100m final and more – live!
Leicester City 5-0 Newcastle United: Premier League – live reaction!
Mads Pedersen wins men’s elite road race at sodden world championships
Dean and Quinn on target as Tottenham upset West Ham before bumper crowd
Australia 25-29 Wales: Rugby World Cup player ratings | Michael Aylwin
Box Office: ‘Abominable’ Climbs to No. 1 With $20.8 Million, ‘Judy’ Hits High Note
Robert De Niro on his father's journals: 'It was sad for me to read. He had his demons'
Boris Johnson Is A Feminist But Like 'Frank Spencer In A China Shop', Says Penny Mordaunt
Three Brothers Charged With Murder After Fatal West London Stabbing
Murder Investigation Launched After Woman Stabbed To Death In North London Home
Boom for experience economy as hit TV shows enter real world
Government may seek $4.3 billion interim dividend from RBI: media reports
One year on, Saudi struggles to turn page on Khashoggi murder
Amb. Richard Grenell on whistleblower complaint, Germany's support for Ukraine
Thousands rally in Moscow to demand release of jailed protesters
Bodyguard of Saudi king killed in shooting
Winterlike storm unleashing feet of snow, life-threatening conditions in northwestern US
Could Elizabeth Warren end up the real winner from the Trump impeachment inquiry?
Supercars taken from African leader's son auctioned for $27M
Rudy Giuliani: How a 9/11 hero became Trump's conspiratorial Ukraine fixer
Three more elephants killed in Sri Lanka, bringing toll to seven
Lewis Hamilton wins Russia F1 GP as Vettel ignores orders before retiring
Leicester City v Newcastle United: Premier League – live!
Cycling World Championships 2019: Mads Pedersen wins men's elite road race – as it happened
Motivated Samoa could punish Scotland for wading into tackle row | Andy Bull
In conversation with Vic Marks – The Spin Podcast Special
Cycling: heavy rain and flooding at world championships in Yorkshire – video
Kanye West’s ‘Jesus Is King’ Documentary Film Coming Next Month
Vaccinations Could Be Made Compulsory, Reveals Health Secretary Matt Hancock
Prime Minister Pledges £2.7b To 'Transform' Six Hospitals
Why death of war reporter Christopher Allen must be made visible | Roy Greenslade
'We know they aren't feeding': fears for polar bears over shrinking Arctic ice
Mexico theme park crash: Two people killed after rollercoaster car flips over mid-ride
Texas officer who made headlines for his turban and beard killed in traffic stop
At UN, Malaysia PM seeks to curb use of sanctions
'Alarming' rise in far-Right weapons seizures prompts Germany to beef up police powers
EU Set to Resume Expansion Push With Balkan Accession Talks
Police impose restrictions in Indian Kashmir after Pakistan PM's speech
Man Who Berated Woman Over T-Shirt With Puerto Rican Flag Is Convicted of Hate Crimes
Donald Trump-Ukraine whistleblower battles to keep identity secret amid Republican attacks
Wales’ Biggar and Patchell recall glory days and get drop on Australia | Paul Rees
Lewis Hamilton wins Russian F1 Grand Prix in Mercedes one-two finish
West Ham v Tottenham: Women's Super League – live!
Pete Alonso hits 53rd home run of season to break Aaron Judge's rookie record
SNL's Trump asks Kim Jong Un for advice on how to handle the whistleblower
Banner And Effigies Hung On Salford Bridge As Tory Conference Gets Underway
Legal setback for Trump administration plan to speed some deportations
Benin counts the cost after Nigeria shutters border
A Samsung Galaxy Fold review in three words: Don’t buy it
Clashes Intensify With Petrol Bombs and Fires: Hong Kong Update
Countries that make weapons of war foment migration but refuse refugees, Pope Francis says
Neal: Democrats, Lighthizer have resolved some USMCA issues
England’s Piers Francis cleared to resume World Cup after citing dismissed
Australia's Will Genia and Bernard Foley wilt in Wales defeat | Oliver Trenchard
Rugby World Cup: Wales squeeze past Australia, Georgia beat Uruguay – video highlights
Robert De Niro on his father's journals: 'It was sad for me to read. He had his demons'
Boris Johnson Rejects Suggestion He Would Resign Rather Than Delay Brexit
Naga Munchetty reprimand blurs BBC’s own lines between reportage and opinion | Kenan Malik
Bodyguard of Saudi king killed in shooting: police
Ukraine must investigate Joe Biden's son, says ex-Ukrainian PM
China ‘poised to unveil new nuclear missile’ at military parade in warning to Trump
Trump Impeachment Is a Market Nothingburger—for Now
Native American 2020 candidate aims to raise awareness of indigenous peoples
Wales cling on in face of Australia comeback to edge brilliant Pool D clash
F1: Russian Grand Prix – live!
Cycling World Championships 2019: men's elite road race – live!
'Re-written history': how Japan reacted to shock win over Ireland
Australia down Sri Lanka in T20 run-fest
Football’s diverse landscape remains polluted by racists despite our outrage | Andrew Anthony
Renée Zellweger: ‘A little mystery never hurt a girl’
De Niro: I can’t face reading about demons that haunted my artist father
Dividing And Redefining: How RuPaul’s Drag Race Has Changed The Face Of British Drag
Jennifer Arcuri 'Told Friends Of Affair' With Boris Johnson
Jeremy Clarkson Brands Greta Thunberg A ‘Spoilt Brat’ And Tells Her To ‘Go Back To School’
BBC Staff ‘Told Not To Join Protests Backing Naga Munchetty’
Strictly Come Dancing Viewers Note Tension Between Judges Craig Revel Horwood And Motsi Mabuse During ‘Bananas’ Live Show
Final editions: why no local news is bad news
Nicholas Coleridge: colossus of the glossy mag
Emily Maitlis: BBC 'looks out of touch' over Munchetty decision
End front-page falsehoods and regain the public’s trust | Alan Rusbridger
Is the rise of the unscientific vox pop a fresh take on news or just plain laziness? | Catherine Bennett
Beijing hopes glitzy new airport will take off as aviation hub
Winterlike storm to unleash feet of snow, life-threatening conditions in northwestern US
Ken Starr's warning to Democrats pushing to impeach President Trump
Afghanistan since the Taliban regime fell in 2001
Australia v Wales: Rugby World Cup 2019 – live!
Georgia trounce Uruguay to kickstart Rugby World Cup campaign
Controversial Christian Coleman wins men’s 100m gold in 9.76sec
Errol Spence drops Shawn Porter in 11th to unify titles in split-decision thriller
Ditching Ole Gunnar Solskjær will not stop the rot at Manchester United | Jonathan Wilson
Aardman's 20 best films – ranked!
Cars taken from African leader's son worth $18.5M at auction
Thai model death 'scandal' casts spotlight on murky industry
Girl Band: The Talkies review – a true haunted house horror
Errol Spence Jr defeats Shawn Porter to unify IBF and WBC welterweight titles – as it happened
Ready Or Not review – a wedding night with a gory class-war twist
Everything You Wanted To Know About Life As A Flight Attendant
This Is What It's Like To Be Targeted By Baby Ads After Miscarriage Or IVF Struggles
Mollie King: 'I Felt Lost After The Saturdays, But Strictly Put Me Back On My Feet'
How Downton Abbey Could Become The Next Big Film Franchise
Hong Kong protest leader will run for office
Clashes as Hong Kong marks five years since 'Umbrella' protests
Errol Spence Jr v Shawn Porter: IBF/WBC welterweight unification championship – live!
Shola Amoo: the man behind the British Moonlight
Pakistan warns of Kashmir bloodbath, India silent
Trump impeachment: Barr has 'gone rogue' to cover up allegations of Ukraine interference, says Pelosi
Huge tanker blast sparks fire injuring 18 in South Korea
King Tide to cause flooding in portions of coastal South Florida
'I'm so sorry,' ex-Dallas cop weeps on witness stand at her murder trial
Liam Gallagher: Why Me? Why Not review | Alexis Petridis's album of the week
Stephen Colbert and Seth Meyers take a closer look at Elizabeth Warren's surge in the polls
Iran releases photo of Khamenei with Hezbollah chief
Saudi Arabia implements public decency code as it opens to tourists
18 Transgender Killings This Year Raise Fears of an 'Epidemic'
Controversial Christian Coleman wins men’s 100m gold in Doha
Liverpool report offensive ‘Hillsborough chants’ to Football Association
How Hustlers shows the importance of female solidarity
Democratic candidate Tom Steyer backs rival Joe Biden around impeachment inquiry, says he 'should be left out of this'
Oil shipping rates soar as U.S. supertanker sanctions rattle crude trade
'It's one big earworm': readers' picks of the best albums this century
Manchester City response to Bernardo Silva tweet a joke, says Anichebe
Thomas Partey makes noise but Atlético Madrid fail to break down Real Madrid
England’s tackling will be hard but fair, insists Courtney Lawes
José José, Famed Latin Singer, Dies at 71
Julian Assange ‘subjected to every kind of torment’ in Belmarsh prison as he awaits extradition
AP FACT CHECK: Trump's distortions on Ukraine, whistleblower
Once Again, Progressive Anti-Christian Bigotry Carries a Steep Legal Cost
Greta Thunberg marches in Montreal for global climate protests
Trump can do more damage than Nixon. His impeachment is imperative
Joseph Wilson, U.S. diplomat who spoke out on Iraq War, dies at 69: NYT
Meghan visits memorial to murdered South African woman
Christian Coleman wins men’s 100m gold at World Athletics Championships
Atlético Madrid 0-0 Real Madrid: La Liga – live!
Streaming: film criticism you can watch
‘He is a psychopath’: has the 2019 Joker gone too far?
The Irishman review: Scorsese, De Niro, Pacino and Pesci are foes reunited in de-aged mob epic
Nigel Farage's Comment That 'We'll Take The Knife' To Civil Servants Was Not A Criminal Offence, Say Police
Leaked Memo: Colleagues Unload on John Solomon, the Journo Who Kicked Off Trump’s Ukraine Conspiracy
Fox Host Moves Goalposts on Trump-Ukraine: Quid Pro Quo Isn’t ‘Necessarily Illegal’
Bogota in photos row over Venezuela at UN
Analysis: To combat Islamophobia, Khan bridges East and West
Violent Protests in Indonesia Signal Tough Road Ahead for Jokowi
Cairo on lock-down as Egyptian government tries to head off anti-Sisi protests
Raheem Sterling seals hard-fought win for Manchester City at Everton
Earthlight wins Middle Park but Frankie Dettori steals the show
Atlético Madrid v Real Madrid: La Liga – live!
Football League: Leeds slip at Charlton, Derby end week with win
Scottish Premiership: Celtic held by Hibs and Rangers close gap
Send in the crowns: in trumping Venice competition, Joker begins grand slam | Xan Brooks
Labour Demands Probe Over Claims Financial Backers Of Boris Johnson Stand To Profit From A No-Deal Brexit
Labour's Margaret Hodge Facing Reselection Battle After Members Trigger Challenge
Zimbabwe's Mugabe buried in home village, ending an era
Hillary Clinton: Trump 'has turned American diplomacy into a cheap extortion racket'
Yemen's Houthis say attacked Saudi border frontline, no immediate Saudi confirmation
Hong Kong pro-democracy rally ends early as violence erupts
Fix the Nintendo Switch’s biggest design flaw for $11
The Latest: Hong Kong rally ends early amid violence
Trump Organization Receives Approval to Expand Golf Resort in Scotland
World Athletics Championships 2019: day two – live!
Harry Kane rescues Hugo Lloris as 10-man Tottenham beat Southampton
Willian’s deflected effort seals deserved win for Chelsea over Brighton
Luka Milivojevic and Andros Townsend score as Crystal Palace beat Norwich
South Africa coast home with nine-try thrashing of Namibia in World Cup
European roundup: Suárez helps end Barcelona’s barren away run, Bayern top
Matt Doherty leads Wolves to vital victory against winless Watford
Chris Wood strikes for Burnley to deny a frustrating Aston Villa
Aaron Cresswell’s strike salvages draw for West Ham at Bournemouth
Bilic hails ‘positive’ full-back Ferguson after goal propels West Brom top at QPR
Jürgen Klopp says Liverpool only deserved draw with Sheffield United – video
Stormy Daniels to Get $450,000 Settlement After Arrest at Columbus Strip Club
Kim Kardashian shares Kanye West album release date, after mysterious 'Jesus Is King' event, last-minute Sunday Service
Maitlis: BBC 'looks out of touch' over Munchetty decision
Republicans rally base around Trump impeachment probe in battleground Wisconsin
The Latest: Afghan polls close amid complaints, violence
Trump's envoy for Ukraine resigns as scrutiny of his role in Trump-Zelensky scandal grows
Prince Harry's wife Meghan honors murdered South African student
Russians Used Greed to ‘Capture’ NRA, Senator Alleges in New Report
Malaysia PM says can't provoke Beijing on South China Sea, Uighur issue
Iran slams US for barring Zarif from New York hospital visit
An Ode to Canada Tech Stocks After $6 Billion in Value Erased
EU and Japan ink plan to bypass China's 'new Silk Road'
Dance revolution: Has Boiler Room changed club culture forever?
Annemiek van Vleuten goes solo to seal stunning women’s road race world title
Everton v Manchester City: Premier League – live!
Doha world championships ‘a disaster’, says decathlon record-holder Mayer
Japan’s Shizuoka Sensation against Ireland can attract new audience | Robert Kitson
Wales looking to give the northern hemisphere a shot in the arm
‘I am hugely proud’: Japan’s Jamie Joseph praises team after Ireland upset
Matheus Pereira extends West Brom’s unbeaten start with win at 10-man QPR
Celtic held by Hibs as manager Paul Heckingbottom sent to the stand
Japan fans celebrate wildly after stunning Ireland in Rugby World Cup – video
Metallica Scraps Rest of 2019 Tour as Lead Singer James Hetfield Enters Rehab
Bill Maher on Impeachment Inquiry: ‘Trump’s Got Treason on His Computer Like Most Men Have Porn’ (Video)
Robert De Niro Hopes Trump Is Impeached: ‘He’s Such A Low Life’
Complaint To Police Watchdog Against Boris Johnson Was 'Politically Motivated', Insists Theresa Villiers
Plans To Ban Long Journeys To The Slaughterhouse For Animals Post-Brexit
Boris Johnson Is Backed By 'Radicals' Who Don't Want A Brexit Deal, Says Philip Hammond
Stormy Daniels settles lawsuit over arrest at Ohio strip club
Close