Close
Date TimeSeptember 22, 2019
Voice
Have Archaeologists Found Where Jesus Fed the 5,000?
University of HaifaArchaeologists excavating near the Sea of Galilee may have discovered the site where Jesus is said to have miraculously fed a crowd of five thousand people using only five loaves and two fish. The miracle, which is mentioned in all four of the canonical Gospels, is regarded by some historians as one of the more ancient traditions associated with Jesus.The new claim is based on discoveries made by scientists from the University of Haifa. During excavations at the Byzantine era “Burnt Church” in the Hippos National Park (the church is named because it was one of seven churches destroyed as part of the Sasanian conquest in 614 CE).  Archaeologists uncovered a 1,400 year old mosaic on the floor of the church that depicts the feeding miracle.According to the Gospel of Mark, Jesus and his disciples withdrew to a “deserted place” in the Galilee region after the death of John the Baptist in order to rest (Mark 6:31). The location must have been relatively close to the shore of the Sea of Galilee because they used a boat to get there. Once the group came ashore they were swamped by a crowd of people who had followed them there. The ever-practical disciples advised Jesus to send the crowd away as it was growing late and there was nothing for people to eat.The miracle that follows is by biblical standards a rather low-key affair. Jesus had the disciples gather up the nutritional resources of the group. Then, Jesus looked up to heaven, blessed and broke the bread, and had the loaves and fishes evenly distributed among the people. “And all ate and were filled; and they took up twelve baskets full of broken pieces and of the fish. Those who had eaten the loaves numbered five thousand men.” (Mark 6:42-44). The story is repeated in Matthew, Mark, and John. There’s even a similar incident in Mark and Matthew known as the Feeding of the Four Thousand and even more food is left over.Traditionally, people have believed that the feeding of the five thousand miracle took place in Tabgha, Capernaum, on the northwest shore of the Sea of Galilee. There’s even a church there, called the Church of the Multiplication, that celebrates the event. The earliest evidence of Christian worship in Tabgha dates to the mid-fourth century but the mosaics that refer to the feeding of the five thousand come from around 480 A.D.Hippos, the site of the newest discovery, is on the southeastern shore of the Sea of Galilee. The history of the city there dates back to the turn of the era and there’s some evidence of occupation there as early as the third century B.C. There are several mosaics from the Burnt Church that appear to refer to the miracle story. The first depicts Jesus performing the miracle; the second shows twelve baskets filled with bread and fruit. Dr. Michael Eisenberg, who oversaw the excavation on behalf of the University of Haifa, noted that these may be a reference to the baskets of bread that were left over after the multitude had eaten.Eisenberg cautiously hypothesized that perhaps Hippos was the place that the miracle supposedly took place. He told The Jerusalem Post:“Nowadays, we tend to regard the Church of the Multiplication in Tabgha on the northwest of the Sea of Galilee as the location of the miracle, but with careful reading of the New Testament, it is evident that it might have taken place north of Hippos within the city’s region.” If Eisenberg’s theory is correct this would mean that Christians had been, to borrow a phrase from Indiana Jones, celebrating the miracle ‘in the wrong place.’Before jumping to conclusions, however, it is important to evaluate precisely what kinds of evidence we have for both the site in Hippos and that in Tabgha. Both sites contain mosaics of the miracle of the multiplication and these mosaics (and the churches that contained them) date to the fifth century.The earliest evidence for Christians visiting any site associated with the miracle comes from the Pilgrimage diary of Christianity’s first female travel writer, Egeria, who visited the Holy Land ca. 381 A.D. According to her diary, the site she visited, “where the Lord fed the people with the five loaves and the two fishes” was near Capernaum. Even if the Church of the Multiplication is the same place visited by Egeria (and it is likely to be in the general vicinity), she was still traveling some 350 years after Jesus is reported to have performed this miracle. None of the archaeological or literary evidence can confirm either that the miracle took place, or where it took place.What we do have evidence for is a trend in the artistic and theological program of late fifth century Christians living in the Holy Land. Whether or not those who commissioned the mosaics intended to claim that this was where the feeding miracle was performed, they are both very interested in this story about the divine provision of food. (Interestingly the artist who produced the mosaic in Tabgha was not a local fisherman: the mosaics there show the fish with two dorsal fins while fish from the Sea of Galilee only have one dorsal fin).Both these churches were constructed during a period in which Christians made pilgrimages to religious sites looking for the alleviation of physical suffering. This suffering was usually related to sickness but people also asked for help with the hardships that resulted from crop failure, famine, taxation, and conflict. Perhaps what we have here are different religious centers that competed for and catered to the needs of pilgrims and tourists. These churches might have been equally appealing to members of the local fishing industry, who relied upon good hauls of fish in order to sustain themselves and their families. Bread and fish are evocative symbols for early Christians, but, for those who lived around the Sea of Galilee or were agrarian workers they also had a great deal of practical economic significance.Equally, the discovery of multiple churches claiming a connection to the feeding of the five thousand story might just be directing us to the importance of food in ancient religion and religion in general. We tend to define religion as about religious books and prayers, but food has often played an important role in our relationship with the cosmic and supernatural order. As Meredith Warren, a lecturer at the University of Sheffield and author of Food and Transformation in Ancient Mediterranean Literature, told the Daily Beast “Eating is one of the most fundamental ways that humans interact with the world, so it is no surprise that food and meals feature so prominently in the creation of meaning by early Christians.”Have we discovered where the feeding of the 5000 actually took place (assuming that you believe that it happened)? Probably not. But archaeologists may well have unearthed another location where Christians genuinely believed Jesus had performed this miracle and remembered and commemorated that event. The discovery of these new mosaics can tell us a great deal about was important to Christians living in the region, the Bible stories that appealed to them, and the ways that various religious centers competed with each other.
Egypt's hardline president el-Sissi faces calls to quit in rare protests
Tuilagi double helps England kick off with bonus-point win against Tonga
West Ham v Manchester United: Premier League – live!
Steve Hansen says World Rugby will alter HIA process after Cane debacle
Pochettino praises 'fantastic' Spurs performance despite defeat at Leicester – video
Can Spider-Man survive outside of the Marvel universe?
Holidaymakers 'Held Hostage' In Hotel As Thomas Cook Faces Collapse
McCluskey Tells Pro-EU Shadow Ministers To Back Corbyn Or 'Step Aside'
Rohingya 'bandit' couple killed in Bangladesh gunfight
Israel set for crucial talks on who should be next PM
Iran may release British-flagged tanker within hours, Swedish owner says
EU's Juncker says he is convinced Brexit will happen: Sky
More Fracking, or More War?
F1: Singapore Grand Prix – live!
Labour Party Vows To Abolish 'Unfit For Purpose' Ofsted
Madonna Blasts Fans For Recording Madame X Tour Despite No-Phone Rule
Man Drowns Proposing To Girlfriend During 'Once-In-A-Lifetime' Holiday
Family of murdered Maltese journalist raise concerns over public inquiry
Facebook suspends thousands of apps over privacy issues
May I have a word about… Facebook claiming the word ‘book’ | Jonathan Bouquet
Weather radar picks up mysterious shadow across three states ‘caused by huge dragonfly swarm’
The Latest: Man suspected of shooting Chicago cop captured
Despite Saudi turmoil, new oil shock unlikely
Lorena spares Los Cabos, heads up coast of Mexico's Baja
England v Tonga: Rugby World Cup 2019 – live!
Ireland earn bonus point after powering past Scotland with physical display
Keira Knightley: ‘Iraq was the first time I’d been politically engaged’
X Factor: Celebrity Line-Up Teased In New Trailer
Jeremy Corbyn Says He Would Serve Full Term As Prime Minister
Key Labour Policy Chief Quits In Fresh Blow For Corbyn
Kelvin Fletcher Has Already Joined The Strictly Hall Of Fame With His Must-See Samba Routine
Abortions in Clinics Decline, but Abortions With Black-Market Pills Are Rising
Sussex Tour: Duke and Duchess urged to put Archie front and centre so public can 'refall in love with them'
Syria says it captured drone near Israeli-occupied Golan
68 people injured as a pair of strong earthquakes rattle Albania
Ireland v Scotland: Rugby World Cup 2019 – live!
Somerset and Essex create thrilling climax but what is the future of county cricket? | Tanya Aldred
Italy overcome early scare to beat spirited Namibia in Rugby World Cup
Owen Wright nabs third at Freshwater Pro to cement spot in WSL top 10
I was abused by Larry Nassar. I had to admit the damage and face it | Rachael Denhollander
Iraq war whistleblower Katharine Gun: ‘Truth always matters’
Phoenix review – horror comes home in chilly Scandi drama
John McDonnell Warns Labour Will Not 'Take S***' From Media During Election Campaign
John Humphrys attacks BBC's 'liberal bias' days after retiring
How Trump could lose the popular vote again – and hold the White House
Stealth bomber for Area 51 crowd? U.S. military unit apologizes for tweet
Metronomy: Metronomy Forever review – an eclectic glide through the genres
Italy v Namibia: Rugby World Cup 2019 – live!
Can The Sound-Reducing Sleeep Pro Ear Plugs Help Me Sleep Through The Night?
US envoy meets Israel's embattled PM to discuss peace plan
Swiss to hold high-altitude wake for lost glacier
Hiss Golden Messenger: Terms of Surrender review – country-rock with a conscience
Liam Gallagher: Why Me? Why Not? review – occasionally sizzling, often sentimental
Meghan Markle, Ivanka Trump, Katy Perry and more stars attend Misha Nonoo's wedding
Hezbollah calls on Syrian refugees from Qusayr to return
The Latest: US may send some asylum-seekers to El Salvador
Youth leaders at UN demand bold climate change action
Reactor at worst US nuclear accident site finally closed
How reports of Trump pushing Ukraine's president to investigate Hunter Biden could hurt Joe Biden's campaign
Could Bermuda feel effects from Jerry next week?
Hurricane Lorena makes landfall at Mexico's Los Cabos resort
Everyone Is Running Up Debt Except America’s States and Cities
Is America ready for gay president? Iowa casts first votes
Animal rights groups take credit after Taylor Swift cancels Melbourne Cup performance
Where does Reece Hodge’s escape leave crackdown on high tackles? | Andy Bull
Sport sponsors must join the war on doping, says anti-drug boss
Players nearly walked off pitch over racist abuse, says Dover manager
Will Smith Squirms When Wife Jada Pinkett Smith Confronts Him About His Drinking (Video)
Justin Trudeau's brownface scandal is bad. But voting him out isn't the solution
Trump slams 'partisan' whistleblower, Biden pushes back
Kevin Hart Likely To File Lawsuit Against Company Who Built His Barracuda
Justin Trudeau says he'll ban assault rifles amid backlash to blackface controversy
Italy rise in 'phantom' boats as new route sees migrants go undetected
Iran's Guard says ready for 'any scenario' amid US standoff
Katarina Johnson-Thompson goes to Doha on back of ‘best run-in ever’
Klopp hungry for high-rolling Liverpool to make away days pay
Positional switch the key in Australia's Rugby World Cup win over Fiji
Tammy Abraham faces Liverpool test after his jaw-dropper at Wolves
Granada stun Barcelona to go top despite Lionel Messi’s rescue effort
European roundup: Lukaku seals Milan derby win as Ramsey scores for Juve
Pogba is at Manchester United for the long haul, says Ole Gunnar Solskjær
Blame me for Arsenal’s collapse against Watford, says Unai Emery
Fabian Schär rescues Newcastle in drab stalemate with Brighton
McCluskey Warns Watson To 'Listen' To 'Shot Across His Bows' Over Brexit Defiance
Diane Abbott Says BBC’s Fiona Bruce Still To Apologise Over Question Time Row
U.S. Plan to Add Mideast Troops After Attack Draws Pelosi Rebuke
‘The View’ Blows Up Over Meghan McCain’s Confusing Whistleblower Claim: ‘Don’t Scream at Me!’
Trump announces sanctions but says won't strike Iran
At School, 'Everyone Vapes,' and Adults Are in Crisis Mode
Stacks of cash shown at trial of Sudan's toppled leader Bashir
Bill Maher Makes the Case for Joe Biden: He Is ‘Mildly Embarrassing’ But Not ‘Insane’ Like Trump
Damascus says second drone downed in 48 hours over south Syria
The Ridiculous Anti-Vaping Crusade
Owen Farrell: ‘I try to take the emotion out of it – you want to be in control’
Simon Harmer guides Essex to last-ball T20 Blast title win over Worcestershire
England and Billy Vunipola expect hot reception from Tonga under the dome
Warren Gatland’s Wales look for calmer waters after Howley storm
Is Arsenal’s strategy of playing out from the back too great a risk? | Jonathan Wilson
European roundup: Aaron Ramsey scores on first start for Juventus
Guardiola and Sánchez Flores react to Manchester City's 8-0 demolition of Watford – video
Plumber Receives £80,000 In Donations After Help For The Vulnerable Goes Viral
Breaking Down the Whistleblower Frenzy
US and El Salvador sign agreement on asylum to curb migration
Saudi Arabia to wait for investigation before responding to attacks: minister
Cory Booker will exit presidential race if $1.7m not raised by end of month
Heavy rain, locally severe storms to soak the central US this weekend
Milan v Inter: Serie A – live!
Jon Rahm and Danny Willett pull three shots clear in BMW PGA Championship
Fabian Schär rescues poor Newcastle in drab stalemate with Brighton
Football League: Preston and QPR close gap on Championship's top two
Iran issues 'battlefield' warning and U.S. deploys troops
US sending more troops to Gulf, Trump announces Iran sanctions
Saudi Aramco has emerged from attacks 'stronger than ever': CEO
U.S. Orders Defensive Boost to Mideast After Saudi Attacks
Dozens detained in Kazakhstan at anti-China protests
Women leave Montana town over border agency lawsuit backlash
Refugees from rising seas: no place to call home
Paper tigers: India's big cat surveys 'over reporting numbers'
Manchester City hit eight past Watford as Bernardo Silva scores hat-trick
T20 Blast Finals Day: Essex to face Worcestershire in final – live!
Sheffield United win at Everton to put pressure on Marco Silva
Burnley’s Chris Wood hits double to bring Norwich crashing to earth
Nicky Henderson commits Altior to taking on fellow-titan Cyrname
Chris Martin’s late strike sees Derby snatch draw from wasteful Leeds
Jake Bidwell sent off as promotion rivals Bristol City and Swansea fail to fire
Batman Day Takes Flight Worldwide, ‘Joker’ Takes Cue From ‘Catwoman’
A YouTuber and a U-Haul full of strangers: Inside the final attempt to storm Area 51
Queer Eye’s Jonathan Van Ness Opens Up About ‘Devastating’ HIV Diagnosis
Labour Chief Jennie Formby Thanks NHS For Saving Her Life From Cancer
Government Urged To Help As Thomas Cook Seeks £200m To Prevent Collapse
Epstein Victim: Ghislaine Maxwell Made Me Recruit ‘Youngest-Looking’ Girls for Epstein
Justices' DC sniper case examines teen murderers' sentences
Trump attacks Biden after ‘repeatedly urging Ukrainian president’ to investigate 2020 opponent’s son
Candace Owens to House panel: 'White supremacy and white nationalism is not a problem'
China's Pacific influence grows as it signs up new friend in Solomon Islands
New Zealand defy doubters and South Africa in clash of World Cup titans | Liam Napier
Charles Leclerc storms to Singapore F1 GP pole ahead of Lewis Hamilton
Newcastle v Brighton: Premier League – live!
T20 Blast Finals Day: Derbyshire chasing 161 to beat Essex – live!
Rugby World Cup: Key moments as New Zealand, France and Australia win – video highlights
Read and Barrett react after All Blacks' thrilling win over Springboks – video
Rape Complainants Face 'Routine' Requests To Hand Over Phone Data
Imelda’s toll in Texas: Flooding and fears about a bridge
GOP Strategy to Shield Trump by Canceling Primaries Carries Risk
Parachutists jump over Dutch heath to mark WWII operation
Manchester City v Watford, Premier League and more: clockwatch – live!
Leicester’s fast start continues as James Maddison sinks Spurs with late stunner
T20 Blast Finals Day: Worcs pip Notts to reach final, Derbyshire v Essex – live!
How the greatest Red Sox team in history turned into an embarrassment
Chloë Sevigny: ‘Make lists after break-ups or have a passionate fling
Epstein Accuser Claims Prince Andrew 'Thanked' Her For Sex
Extinction Rebellion Activists 'Superglue' Themselves To A20 In Bid To 'Blockade' Port Of Dover
Area 51 events mostly peaceful; thousands in Nevada desert
White supremacist who praised ‘psychedelic Nazis’ caught with stockpile of guns and LSD
United States announces military response and Iran sanctions after attacks on Saudi oil facilities
History buff finds ships that sank in 1878 in Lake Michigan
Khalid review – teen spirit squandered?
New Zealand stand firm against South Africa in heavyweight thriller
T20 Blast Finals Day: Notts chasing 148 to beat Worcs in first semi-final – live!
Lizzie Deignan heads GB’s World Championships charge in Harrogate
New Zealanders vent anger at being unable to watch Rugby World Cup
Extinction Rebellion Activists To 'Blockade' Port Of Dover
Labour’s ‘Politburo’ To Decide Who's PM If Jeremy Corbyn Suddenly Quits No.10
Corbyn Halts Motion To Scrap Tom Watson's Labour Deputy Leader Position
AOC's first congressional endorsements reflect subtle shift away from outsider status
Mosques in Liberia dedicate Friday prayers to pupils killed in fire
Trump news: US nuclear arsenal now 'in tippy-top shape' says president when asked about responding to Iran: 'We should all pray we don't have to use them'
Three Mile Island nuclear power plant's shutdown is imminent
US to send troops to Saudi Arabia, hold off on striking Iran
Argentina heartbreak after Camille Lopez’s drop goal rescues France
Leicester v Tottenham: Premier League – live!
T20 Blast Finals Day: Worcestershire v Nottinghamshire in first semi – live!
Scotland’s Duncan Taylor aims to upset Ireland after injury nightmare
Where does Reece Hodge’s baffling escape leave high tackle crackdown? | Andy Bull
GWS holds out Collingwood to reach first ever grand final
Sir Bradley Wiggins: ‘My most embarrassing moment? Post 2012, I had a few hissy fits’
The Goldfinch: would it have worked better as a TV show?
Labour's Tom Watson Condemns Move To Abolish His Position
Jennifer Lopez Took Everyone Back To 2000 In A Jaw-Dropping New Version Of *That* Versace Dress At Milan Fashion Week
Thousands of Paris police deployed over 'yellow vest' clash fears
'It’s happening, [Trump] is getting impeached', says former White House ethics chief
Anti-Sisi protests break out in Egypt, several arrested
Navy Orders Trial for Two in Hazing Death of Green Beret Logan Melgar
Trump Says 'It's Crazy' to Spend $13 Million Per Inmate at Guantánamo
Taylor Swift cancels Melbourne Cup performance after criticism from animal rights groups
France v Argentina: Rugby World Cup 2019 – live!
New Zealand v South Africa: Rugby World Cup 2019 – live!
Australia rally to Rugby World Cup win as Fiji count cost of high Hodge tackle
Rugby World Cup: Wales aim to put Howley saga to bed against Georgia
Always in Season: behind the painful film about lynching in America
Streaming: gently does it with Dominga Sotomayor
Is James Bond about to die? What the new 007 title might mean
Graham Norton Reveals His Favourite Ever Guest - And Who He Still Wants To Get On His Couch
Why Are So Many People Publicly Confronting Boris Johnson? We Asked The Experts
Who Will Be Labour's Next Leader? Why Laura Pidcock Is The One To Watch
Sheriff: 1 officer dead, 1 injured in Louisiana shooting
Area 51 raid lures festive UFO hunters to Nevada desert; five arrested
Republican Rep Spars with Al Sharpton over Past Anti-Semitic, Racist Remarks during Congressional Hearing
Making Sense of Israel’s Post-Election Political Chaos
Romesh Ranganathan: My kids loved Lil Dicky’s Earth – but not for the reasons I hoped
Close