Close
Date TimeSeptember 18, 2019
VoiceIn recent years we have seen the government deficit – the difference between public spending and revenue – coming down. But what these figures always fail to show is the economic damage it has caused to get here.
David Cameron Says Austerity Should Have Been Deeper And Faster. The Facts Say Different
The government has consistently argued that austerity was a necessity not a political choice. And we heard David Cameron parroting this line again this week. But this is simply not true. While getting to grips with the public finances may have been necessary, there were different options to get there. The government could have opted to raise taxes rather than cut taxes for those that were better off. Cutting corporation tax from 21% to 19% alone cost the Exchequer in excess of £5billion a year. They could have chosen to provide a fiscal stimulus to boost the economy and increase tax receipts. But instead they opted for deep cuts that disproportionately hit the poorest in our society and communities that were already under pressure. 
And while it is extremely hard to estimate what the true extent of the economic impacts of austerity have been, the human impacts have always been clear. Whether rising homelessness, frozen benefit payments, overcrowded school classes or excessively long waits in hospital A&E services, the starved ambition and resources of our public realm have touched the lives of almost everyone.
So what have been the impacts, if any, on the country’s overall level of income?
At the New Economics Foundation we have estimated the effects of austerity on GDP over the decade so far. The calculations make for grim reading. The isolated impact of government policy has reduced GDP growth every single year since 2010 – in the 2018/​19 alone, it suppressed the level of GDP by almost £100billion.
To break this number down another way, it means that deliberate policy from government over the past nine years has had the standalone effect of suppressing incomes and expenditure in the economy by more than £3,600 per household. We also know the effects have not been evenly felt, with the heaviest burden borne by the poorest households in society.
To put this in a Brexit context, the Bank of England estimated earlier this year that uncertainty since the 2016 referendum will cost the economy 2% of GDP in 2018/​19, works out about £1,500 per household in 2018/​19. Austerity by comparison has been far more corrosive.
The sad truth is that austerity needn’t have happened at all.
There was in fact ample time and space to reduce borrowing more slowly as a proportion of GDP across the period. By not doing this, government in fact offloaded part of the country’s debt burden onto those that could least afford it – with households increasingly having to borrow to make up for it.
By bemoaning his failure to cut deeper quicker, David Cameron has shown he has learnt very little from the last decade. Managing the public finances off the backs of families that were struggling was the wrong choice. The prospects of communities across the country have been bleaker as a direct consequence of the actions from their own government.
It didn’t have to be this way. Next time must be different.
Miatta Fahnbulleh is an economist and chief executive of the New Economics FoundationRelated... Exclusive: Brexit Party Candidate Quits Over 'Islamophobic' Social Media Posts Jeremy Corbyn Hints He Will Stay Neutral In Second Referendum David Cameron Says Cuts Should Have Been Deeper And Made Earlier

Related Stories
England’s Owen Farrell ‘missing part of his nose’ after bruising win over USAEngland’s Owen Farrell ‘missing part of his nose’ after bruising win over USA
Investigation Launched Into Awarding Of Grant To Boris Johnsons Close FriendInvestigation Launched Into Awarding Of Grant To Boris Johnson's 'Close Friend'
Wales v Ireland: Rugby World Cup warm-up – live!Wales v Ireland: Rugby World Cup warm-up – live!
Labour NEC In Shock Move To Abolish Tom Watsons Deputy Leader PostLabour NEC In Shock Move To Abolish Tom Watson's Deputy Leader Post
George Ford makes England’s World Cup attack hum and cannot be dropped   | Nick EvansGeorge Ford makes England’s World Cup attack hum and cannot be dropped | Nick Evans
Bill Clinton and Jeb Bush seek refuge from Trump impeachment stormBill Clinton and Jeb Bush seek refuge from Trump impeachment storm
Philip Hammond Says He Will Not Back Election As Brexit Crisis LoomsPhilip Hammond Says He Will Not Back Election As Brexit Crisis Looms
Man with no shame: the papers on Boris Johnsons performance in the Commons'Man with no shame': the papers on Boris Johnson's performance in the Commons
Rugby World Cup: England v France off and Japan v Scotland under threat from Typhoon HagibisRugby World Cup: England v France off and Japan v Scotland under threat from Typhoon Hagibis
Mike Pence accused of humiliating hosts in IrelandMike Pence accused of humiliating hosts in Ireland
Latest News
James Mattis pokes fun at Trumps insult: I guess Im the Meryl Streep of generalsJames Mattis pokes fun at Trump's insult: 'I guess I'm the Meryl Streep of generals'
Ginger Baker, towering drummer and Cream cofounder, has died at 80Ginger Baker, towering drummer and Cream cofounder, has died at 80
Christmas Food 2019: Where To Find The Best Mince Pies, Turkey And MoreChristmas Food 2019: Where To Find The Best Mince Pies, Turkey And More
Premier League: 10 things to look out for this weekendPremier League: 10 things to look out for this weekend
Manchester United’s recruitment has been dysfunctional, admits Ed WoodwardManchester United’s recruitment has been dysfunctional, admits Ed Woodward
Talking Horses: Future of Tote under new owners brighter than for yearsTalking Horses: Future of Tote under new owners brighter than for years
Sean and Matty Longstaff: ‘Knowing your brother has got your back is special’Sean and Matty Longstaff: ‘Knowing your brother has got your back is special’
Pochettino says Spurs players still want him and rules out January signingsPochettino says Spurs players still want him and rules out January signings
‘El Camino: A Breaking Bad Movie’ Scores 6.5 Million Viewers Across First Weekend‘El Camino: A Breaking Bad Movie’ Scores 6.5 Million Viewers Across First Weekend
Tory MP Mark Field To Step Down Over Brexit ‘Divisions’Tory MP Mark Field To Step Down Over Brexit ‘Divisions’
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Boris-JohnsonBoris Johnson
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Theresa-MayTheresa May
Member of Parliament of the United Kingdom
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
England’s Owen Farrell ‘missing part of his nose’ after bruising win over USAEngland’s Owen Farrell ‘missing part of his nose’ after bruising win over USA
Investigation Launched Into Awarding Of Grant To Boris Johnsons Close FriendInvestigation Launched Into Awarding Of Grant To Boris Johnson's 'Close Friend'
Wales v Ireland: Rugby World Cup warm-up – live!Wales v Ireland: Rugby World Cup warm-up – live!
Labour NEC In Shock Move To Abolish Tom Watsons Deputy Leader PostLabour NEC In Shock Move To Abolish Tom Watson's Deputy Leader Post
George Ford makes England’s World Cup attack hum and cannot be dropped   | Nick EvansGeorge Ford makes England’s World Cup attack hum and cannot be dropped | Nick Evans
Bill Clinton and Jeb Bush seek refuge from Trump impeachment stormBill Clinton and Jeb Bush seek refuge from Trump impeachment storm
Philip Hammond Says He Will Not Back Election As Brexit Crisis LoomsPhilip Hammond Says He Will Not Back Election As Brexit Crisis Looms
Man with no shame: the papers on Boris Johnsons performance in the Commons'Man with no shame': the papers on Boris Johnson's performance in the Commons
Rugby World Cup: England v France off and Japan v Scotland under threat from Typhoon HagibisRugby World Cup: England v France off and Japan v Scotland under threat from Typhoon Hagibis
Mike Pence accused of humiliating hosts in IrelandMike Pence accused of humiliating hosts in Ireland
Latest News
James Mattis pokes fun at Trumps insult: I guess Im the Meryl Streep of generalsJames Mattis pokes fun at Trump's insult: 'I guess I'm the Meryl Streep of generals'
Ginger Baker, towering drummer and Cream cofounder, has died at 80Ginger Baker, towering drummer and Cream cofounder, has died at 80
Christmas Food 2019: Where To Find The Best Mince Pies, Turkey And MoreChristmas Food 2019: Where To Find The Best Mince Pies, Turkey And More
Premier League: 10 things to look out for this weekendPremier League: 10 things to look out for this weekend
Manchester United’s recruitment has been dysfunctional, admits Ed WoodwardManchester United’s recruitment has been dysfunctional, admits Ed Woodward
Talking Horses: Future of Tote under new owners brighter than for yearsTalking Horses: Future of Tote under new owners brighter than for years
Sean and Matty Longstaff: ‘Knowing your brother has got your back is special’Sean and Matty Longstaff: ‘Knowing your brother has got your back is special’
Pochettino says Spurs players still want him and rules out January signingsPochettino says Spurs players still want him and rules out January signings
‘El Camino: A Breaking Bad Movie’ Scores 6.5 Million Viewers Across First Weekend‘El Camino: A Breaking Bad Movie’ Scores 6.5 Million Viewers Across First Weekend
Tory MP Mark Field To Step Down Over Brexit ‘Divisions’Tory MP Mark Field To Step Down Over Brexit ‘Divisions’
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Boris-JohnsonBoris Johnson
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Theresa-MayTheresa May
Member of Parliament of the United Kingdom
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
RuPaul's Drag Race UK Launch: All The Tea We Can Spill From The Event
Gareth Thomas Lambasts Journalist Who Told His Parents He Was HIV+ Before He Got The Chance
This Is What It's Like Be Plagued By Severe Night Terrors As An Adult
Man With Stage 4 Cancer Battles The Elements To Complete One Of Britain's Hardest Walks
Polish Ambassador Urges Poles Living In The UK To 'Seriously Consider' Returning To Their Homeland Post-Brexit
Waterloo Station Death: Engineer Killed Working On Moving Walkway
I Took Out A $20,000 Loan To Get Married... To Myself
Birth Diaries: 'My Husband Was On A Work Do When I Went Into Labour – And Fell Asleep In Hospital)
Wary of conflict with Iran, Trump takes go-slow approach to attack on Saudi oil
Into the Unknown for Israel as Netanyahu’s Election Gamble Fails
Trump lists familiar White House faces as possible Bolton successors
Climate activist Greta Thunberg meets with Obama in Washington
Investors Urge South Africa to Leave Their $163 Billion Savings
Houston area preparing for heavy rain, flooding from Imelda
Stephen Colbert and Jimmy Kimmel aren't sure how Corey Lewandowski is allowed to stonewall Congress
Wales attempt to steady ship after Rob Howley bombshell at Rugby World Cup
England mobile phone ban imposed for Rugby World Cup matchdays
South Africa stick to winning formula for World Cup opener against All Blacks
Frank Lampard says Chelsea defeat was harsh Champions League lesson
Rugby World Cup: All Blacks cover up tattoos in Japan to tackle yakuza link
'Truth is funnier than anything': the life of Preston Sturges told by his son
Inconceivable! Rumour of The Princess Bride remake sends fans into pit of despair
Jeremy Corbyn Hints He Will Stay Neutral In Second Referendum
Backstreet Boys Star Nick Carter Granted Restraining Order Against Brother Aaron
Birth Diaries: 'My Husband Was On A Work Do When I Went Into Labour (And He Fell Asleep)
US Fed signals rate cut as market odds fluctuate
Afghan president sees his chance after collapse of U.S.-Taliban talks
South Korea drops Japan from 'white list' in trade row
Stephen Colbert Desperately Tries to Get Elizabeth Warren to Bad-Mouth Joe Biden
France gives more people iodine pills in case of nuclear accident
Mercury hopefuls Black Midi: 'All great art comes from self-indulgence'
Stephen Colbert, Trevor Noah compare Trump's awkward Hispanic outreach in New Mexico, Warren's NYC rally
Rugby World Cup 2019: Fiji team guide
Colorado woman becomes 1st person to swim across the English Channel 4 times in a row
Summer box office 2019: what are the major lessons of the season?
Don't 'Tell Off' Your Kids, Say Experts – Here's What You Should Do Instead
This £13 Face Cream Beat Expensive Brands To Capture My Heart (And Face)
Yemen Houthi drones, missiles defy years of Saudi air strikes
'Nobody can stop it': Saudi oil attack signals an escalating crisis
The Latest: Pelosi swears in 2 North Carolina congressmen
Taliban kill at least 48 in bloody day ahead of Afghan polls
Pentagon Refuses Funding for 20-Miles of Border Barrier Due to Cost
‘The Bachelor’: ABC Announces Leading Man For Season 24
Bill Gates says he regrets meeting Epstein after his conviction and agreeing to donate $2m to MIT
California GOP congressman won't seek re-election
Lewandowski: I have nothing to hide because we never committed any crimes with the campaign
Benjamin Netanyahu's fate uncertain after exit polls show no clear winner in Israel vote
Macron worried attack on Saudi oil may hurt moves to ease U.S.-Iran crisis: diplomats
Winter of discontent leaves Brisbane Broncos at NRL club's lowest ebb | Nick Tedeschi
‘SEAL Team’ Showrunner John Glenn Exits CBS Military Drama Following Investigation
Las Vegas man faces weapons charge in synagogue, other plots
Israel's Netanyahu appears to suffer setback in exit polls
Teen activist to lawmakers: Try harder on climate change
N. Korea demands security guarantees for nuclear talks
Two Thirds Believe We Should Stop Air Travel To Tackle Climate Change
Free-To-Use ATMs Are Vanishing More Quickly In Poorer Areas
Labour MPs To Face Reselection Battles Despite Impending Snap Election
Slow digital services are marginalising rural areas, MPs warn
Israel exit polls show possibility of another deadlock
KFC is testing a fried chicken sandwich with donuts as the buns
Trump gives California grief - but also likes its money
Hong Kong Protesters Battle Police, Set Fire to Key Subway Station
US sanctions Italy, Panama and Colombia firms over Venezuela ties
Biden's 1960s gang fight yarn: Son of 'bad dude' Corn Pop confirms his father knew Dem frontrunner
GM stops paying for health insurance for striking union workers; talks continue
Book Review: Justice Neil Gorsuch’s A Republic, If You Can Keep It
DEA agent accuses Chavez of easing drug trafficking to US: Spain court
Liverpool might be the best but the rest have done their homework | Barney Ronay
Jürgen Klopp blames dive and VAR for Liverpool’s defeat to Napoli
Afton Williamson ‘Rookie’ Investigation: Studio Finds No ‘Inappropriate’ Workplace Behavior
Labour's 'Moderate' Student Wing Abolished By Party's Ruling NEC
New spats shake Iraq's teetering stability -- and its PM
Teen activist to lawmakers: Forget praise, work on climate
California woman rescued by cops who stopped her abductor over vehicle violations
Liverpool make bad start as Napoli’s Fernando Llorente rounds off win
Ross Barkley’s penalty miss costs Chelsea as Valencia win opener
Only Masters win could come close to Open triumph, says Shane Lowry
England should consider Pacific Islands tour, says coach Scott Wisemantel
AOC Calls for Kavanaugh’s Impeachment following Botched NYT Article
Edward Snowden Is Exposing His Own Secrets This Time
20 arrested, 18 charged in Minneapolis beatings
In leaderless Hong Kong movement, Joshua Wong just 1 voice
New photo leak reveals final design of 2019 iPad Pro with triple-lens camera
House of Ukraine's former top central banker set on fire
Triple threat: Tropical Storm Imelda swamps Texas, Humberto nears Bermuda and TD 10 forms in Atlantic
Biden's abortion shift tests the politics of his faith
US-Russia nuclear war would kill 34 million people within hours and is increasingly likely, Princeton study concludes
Napoli v Liverpool: Champions League – live!
Rob Howley: a successful player and coach who struggled to win hearts
Chelsea v Valencia: Champions League – live!
Sexual abuse and misconduct claims in US Olympic sports rise by 55% in 2019
Pirates' All-Star closer Felipe Vázquez jailed for solicitation of a child
County cricket: Somerset face hard chase after James Vince century
Pochettino preaches positivity and realism as Spurs start the healing | David Hytner
The inconvenient truth that threatens All Blacks World Cup supremacy | Matt McIlraith
Corey Lewandowski trolls Democrats while heaping praise on Trump in chaotic congressional hearing
Kiefer Sutherland Joins Quibi's 'Fugitive' Reboot as 'Legendary' Detective
Mandy Moore Drops New Single and Video, First Album in a Decade Due Early 2020
Labour MPs To Still Face Reselection Battles Despite Impending Snap Election
Here's What Happened On Day One Of The Supreme Court Prorogation Hearing
Facebook teams up with police to stop streaming of terror attacks
AOC endorses first liberal candidate against incumbent Democrat
20 dead as truck falls off cliff in southern Philippines
Couple reveal they are raising child 'gender neutral' and haven't even told close family their baby's sex
Andrew Yang wants to give families money and 450,000 signed up to take part in the rollout
US soldier killed in Afghanistan after failed peace talks
French boy, 10, dies 8 years after supermarket burger poisoning
Mediterranean migrant rescues, deaths; French camp emptied
Afghan president narrowly avoids Taliban bomb in worst violence since collapse of US negotiations
Vaping-related illness kills man in seventh death linked to e-cigarettes
Ex-Ukraine central bank chief's home burnt down in attack
Manhattan District Attorney Issues Subpoena for Trump’s Tax Returns
Earth warming more quickly than thought, new climate models show
It’s Great to See Democrats Falling in Love With Elizabeth Warren—and Terrible to See Them Hating on Joe Biden
New York Post columnist Miranda Devine says attacks against Kavanaugh are all about abortion
Wales's Rob Howley sent home from World Cup amid betting investigation
Manchester City’s refusal to pay above the odds is hurting Pep Guardiola | Jamie Jackson
Ten exciting Champions League debutants to watch this week
Pirates' All-Star closer Felipe Vázquez arrested for solicitation of a child
Cagliari fined for fans throwing bottles but not racist abuse of Lukaku
Journalists, lawmakers remember Cokie Roberts as a broadcast 'pioneer'
Exclusive: Brexit Party Candidate Quits Over 'Islamophobic' Social Media Posts
Cokie Roberts, famed journalist and political commentator, dies at 75
U.S. to Return Ambassador to Belarus as Minsk Seeks New Friends
Police clear major migrant camp in northern France
Dem presidential candidates call for Kavanaugh's impeachment
Divided Fed set to cut interest rates this week, but then what?
Judge Refuses to Scrap Plea Deal That Protected Jeffrey Epstein’s Co-Conspirators
Protest likely to greet Trump fundraising trip in California
The Latest: Egypt calls for world to back Saudi Arabia
Should silent discos be banned?
Wales's Rob Howley sent home from World Cup amid betting allegations
Adil Rashid: ‘If I don’t get a Test deal, I need to decide what to do next’
John Stones out for at least a month to deepen Manchester City injury crisis
Antonio Brown farted in my face and didn't pay his bill, NFL star's doctor says
The Fiver | The consequences of defeat will be … almost entirely inconsequential
Woman becomes first person to swim Channel four times non-stop – video
Trump suggests U.S. could back Saudi Arabia in a war with Iran because the kingdom 'pays cash'
Alex Trebek is facing another round of chemotherapy
Hannah Brown and Alan Bersten blow off ‘showmance’ rumors after steamy ‘DWTS’ premiere
Taylor Swift Announces U.S. Tour for 2020 — And It’s Only Hitting Two Cities
Inside Tinder’s Secret Streaming Series (EXCLUSIVE)
‘Downton Abbey’ Mansion Now Listed on Airbnb, Open to Select Lords and Ladies
Ilhan Omar doesn't trust Trump administration, warns against another 'endless war'
How a thrilling eight-minute short might save the Jurassic franchise
Jo Swinson Says Lib Dems Must Embrace Defections To Be More Than 'Narrow And Pure'
Manhunt After Assault On Police Officer At Tommy Robinson Demo
Māori Tribe Brands Captain Cook 'A Barbarian' And Bans Visit From Explorer's Replica Ship
Beer And Bohemia: 72 Hours In Prague
Boris Johnson’s Secret Brexit Ideas Shown To EU, But Not Handed Over Amid Leak Fears
Good Morning Britain Mix-Up Leaves Bonnie Tyler Howling After They Confuse Her With Tribute Act
UN experts urge probe of Rohingya killings in Bangladesh
NYC to Allow 1.1 Million Students to Skip Class for Climate Protests
AP Explains: Why auto workers went on strike against GM
Putin’s Trolling of Trump Isn’t Just About Missiles
Lost in translation? World Cup has arrived in Japan but don’t tell everybody | Andy Bull
How the Ben Roethlisberger and Drew Brees injuries will shake up the NFL
Joe Biden's Corn Pop tale is at least not completely made up
NBCUniversal Unveils Originals Slate, Name For Streaming Service
Good Morning Britain Leaves Bonnie Tyler Howling After They Mix Her Up With A Lookalike
Ben Stokes Slams The Sun For 'Immoral And Utterly Disgusting' Front Page Story About His Family
Revealed: catastrophic effects of working as a Facebook moderator
Trump boasts about wealth and makes series of false claims in hate-filled rally speech disrupted by flies and protesters
20 killed as truck plunges down ravine in Philippines
Merkel urges return to Iran nuclear deal to defuse Middle East tensions
Iran charges three detained Australians with spying
Trump lashes out at Kavanaugh accusers as pressure builds for justice's impeachment
Violence flares after Hong Kong protesters defy police ban
Detroit mayor wants to wipe out residential blight with bonds
Stephen Colbert and Jimmy Fallon recap CNN's 7-hour climate change event, fixate on Biden's bleeding eye
World Rugby admits concerns over proposed CVC and Six Nations deal
What next for London Broncos after their 'heartbreaking' relegation?
Rugby World Cup 2019: Georgia team guide
Ashes 2019: stellar images from an unforgettable summer
Banning fans' free speech is not consistent with our vision of sport. Or democracy
Trump asks Latino supporter if he likes 'the country' or 'the Hispanics' more
'I thought it was basically amazing': readers' pick of the best movies since 2000
More Met Police Officers Will Carry Tasers, But 20% Don't Want Them, Chief Says
The 50 Coolest Neighbourhoods In The World – How Many Have You Visited?
It's Official: 'Hunger Fog' Really Does Cloud Your Decision Making
Strictly's Anton Du Beke Says Emma Barton Is A 'Dream' Partner Because She's 'Got Her Own Teeth'
The Prodigy’s 50th Birthday Tribute To Keith Flint Is Typically Rock & Roll
Ben Stokes attacks 'despicable' Sun story about family tragedy
Saudi Arabia knows its defences are not up to war with Iran
Half of the 147 tigers rescued from Thai temple have died
The Attack on Saudi Arabia Is the Crisis Iran Was Waiting For
China signals veto in standoff with U.S. over Afghan U.N. mission: diplomats
The Latest: Taliban claim attacks on Ghani rally, in Kabul
Taiwan says China meddling with elections after Solomon Islands cuts ties
Jihad, history link Taliban to al-Qaida in Afghanistan
Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show
Saudi Aramco attacks: What we know so far
Tyler, the Creator review – hero's welcome for rap's heartbroken dandy
Keane: how we made Somewhere Only We Know
Tracks of the week reviewed: AG Cook, Post Malone, Bombay Bicycle Club
BBC's Graham Norton struggles to explain the whole Brexit mess to Stephen Colbert and America
The Spin | Ashes 2019: Guardian writers pick out their highs and lows
South Africa reveal scope of random drug testing at Rugby World Cup
David Squires on … a famous day for the Rebel Alliance, Norwich branch
Neglect of player welfare is something women’s football must address fast | Suzanne Wrack
Close