Close
Date TimeSeptember 02, 2019
VoiceAlarmist reactions to the ‘rightwing’ film – starring Joaquin Phoenix as a needy, dangerous wannabe star comic – overlook its subtler points
Incel violence is horrific, but Joker is complex, and doesnt take sides
Todd Phillips’s Joker had its world premiere at the Venice film festival only on Saturday, so it’s impressive that nearly everyone on the internet has an opinion on it. Reviews from critics here have been largely positive, though have also already sparked discontented rumblings from that nebulous collection of industry folks and movie fans known as “film twitter”. One of the central points of contention around Phillips’s comic-book villain origin story is that it in some way panders to incel culture, or “involuntary celibates” – men who see themselves as losers and “beta males” who women don’t want to sleep with. Angry, misogynistic and feeling entitled to sex and attention, incels have been prone to real-world violence, as with the Isla Vista murders in 2014, when a killer targeted a sorority – shooting 11 people and killing six before killing himself.
Related: Joker review – Joaquin Phoenix’s villain has last laugh in twisted tale

Related Stories
Ex-casino employee to seek parole chance in Vegas killingEx-casino employee to seek parole chance in Vegas killing
Incel violence is horrific, but Joker is complex, and doesnt take sides'Incel' violence is horrific, but Joker is complex, and doesn't take sides
Trump news – live: President claims never to have heard of Category 5 storm as London mayor brands him global poster boy for white nationalismTrump news – live: President claims never to have heard of Category 5 storm as London mayor brands him 'global poster boy for white nationalism'
Beto O’Rourke: Meghan McCain Is Almost Giving People ‘Permission to Be Violent’Beto O’Rourke: Meghan McCain Is Almost Giving People ‘Permission to Be Violent’
San Francisco Labels NRA a ‘Domestic Terrorism Organization’San Francisco Labels NRA a ‘Domestic Terrorism Organization’
2020 Democrats Warm to Mandatory ‘Buybacks’ of Assault Weapons2020 Democrats Warm to Mandatory ‘Buybacks’ of Assault Weapons
Odessa Victims Include Cops, a Baby, a High Schooler and a Postal CarrierOdessa Victims Include Cops, a Baby, a High Schooler and a Postal Carrier
Sydenham Shooting: Man Shot Dead In Broad Daylight In LondonSydenham Shooting: Man Shot Dead In Broad Daylight In London
Two Women Charged With Drive-By Shooting Of Man Just Yards From His HomeTwo Women Charged With Drive-By Shooting Of Man Just Yards From His Home
West Texas Shooting: At Least 7 Killed And More Than 20 InjuredWest Texas Shooting: At Least 7 Killed And More Than 20 Injured
Latest News
The Peanut Butter Falcon review – Shia LaBeouf brings soul to odd-couple adventureThe Peanut Butter Falcon review – Shia LaBeouf brings soul to odd-couple adventure
Don’t Diss My Doodle Poll, Wed Never Meet Up OtherwiseDon’t Diss My Doodle Poll, We'd Never Meet Up Otherwise
My Intrusive Thoughts Mean I Imagine Horrible Things Happening To My KidsMy Intrusive Thoughts Mean I Imagine Horrible Things Happening To My Kids
Watch A Bunch Of Scientists Freak Out Over A ‘Whale Fall’ On The Bottom Of The OceanWatch A Bunch Of Scientists Freak Out Over A ‘Whale Fall’ On The Bottom Of The Ocean
Young Workers Are Scared Of Snowflake Label For Taking Mental Health Sick DaysYoung Workers Are Scared Of 'Snowflake' Label For Taking Mental Health Sick Days
Lankum: The Livelong Day review | Jude Rogerss folk album of the monthLankum: The Livelong Day review | Jude Rogers's folk album of the month
Vagabon: Vagabon reviewVagabon: Vagabon review
Ben Youngs urges England to attack from the start against AustraliaBen Youngs urges England to attack from the start against Australia
Manchester United v Liverpool buildup, team news and more – live!Manchester United v Liverpool buildup, team news and more – live!
$1m per touchdown: did Brock Osweiler have the easiest ever NFL career?$1m per touchdown: did Brock Osweiler have the easiest ever NFL career?
Celebrities
Miley-CyrusMiley Cyrus
American singer-songwriter
Jennifer-LopezJennifer Lopez
American singer
Stephen-ColbertStephen Colbert
American comedian
Selena-GomezSelena Gomez
American singer
Lady-GagaLady Gaga
American singer-songwriter
Khloe-KardashianKhloé Kardashian
American media personality
Jay_ZJay-Z
American rapper
Oprah-WinfreyOprah Winfrey
American executive
Ellen-DeGeneresEllen DeGeneres
American comedian
MadonnaMadonna
American singer-songwriter
Jimmy-KimmelJimmy Kimmel
American television host
Kim-KardashianKim Kardashian
American media personality
Ariana-GrandeAriana Grande
American singer
BeyoncéBeyoncé
American singer-songwriter
Taylor-SwiftTaylor Swift
American singer
Justin-BieberJustin Bieber
Canadian singer-songwriter
Kylie-JennerKylie Jenner
American television personality
Related Stories
Ex-casino employee to seek parole chance in Vegas killingEx-casino employee to seek parole chance in Vegas killing
Incel violence is horrific, but Joker is complex, and doesnt take sides'Incel' violence is horrific, but Joker is complex, and doesn't take sides
Trump news – live: President claims never to have heard of Category 5 storm as London mayor brands him global poster boy for white nationalismTrump news – live: President claims never to have heard of Category 5 storm as London mayor brands him 'global poster boy for white nationalism'
Beto O’Rourke: Meghan McCain Is Almost Giving People ‘Permission to Be Violent’Beto O’Rourke: Meghan McCain Is Almost Giving People ‘Permission to Be Violent’
San Francisco Labels NRA a ‘Domestic Terrorism Organization’San Francisco Labels NRA a ‘Domestic Terrorism Organization’
2020 Democrats Warm to Mandatory ‘Buybacks’ of Assault Weapons2020 Democrats Warm to Mandatory ‘Buybacks’ of Assault Weapons
Odessa Victims Include Cops, a Baby, a High Schooler and a Postal CarrierOdessa Victims Include Cops, a Baby, a High Schooler and a Postal Carrier
Sydenham Shooting: Man Shot Dead In Broad Daylight In LondonSydenham Shooting: Man Shot Dead In Broad Daylight In London
Two Women Charged With Drive-By Shooting Of Man Just Yards From His HomeTwo Women Charged With Drive-By Shooting Of Man Just Yards From His Home
West Texas Shooting: At Least 7 Killed And More Than 20 InjuredWest Texas Shooting: At Least 7 Killed And More Than 20 Injured
Latest News
The Peanut Butter Falcon review – Shia LaBeouf brings soul to odd-couple adventureThe Peanut Butter Falcon review – Shia LaBeouf brings soul to odd-couple adventure
Don’t Diss My Doodle Poll, Wed Never Meet Up OtherwiseDon’t Diss My Doodle Poll, We'd Never Meet Up Otherwise
My Intrusive Thoughts Mean I Imagine Horrible Things Happening To My KidsMy Intrusive Thoughts Mean I Imagine Horrible Things Happening To My Kids
Watch A Bunch Of Scientists Freak Out Over A ‘Whale Fall’ On The Bottom Of The OceanWatch A Bunch Of Scientists Freak Out Over A ‘Whale Fall’ On The Bottom Of The Ocean
Young Workers Are Scared Of Snowflake Label For Taking Mental Health Sick DaysYoung Workers Are Scared Of 'Snowflake' Label For Taking Mental Health Sick Days
Lankum: The Livelong Day review | Jude Rogerss folk album of the monthLankum: The Livelong Day review | Jude Rogers's folk album of the month
Vagabon: Vagabon reviewVagabon: Vagabon review
Ben Youngs urges England to attack from the start against AustraliaBen Youngs urges England to attack from the start against Australia
Manchester United v Liverpool buildup, team news and more – live!Manchester United v Liverpool buildup, team news and more – live!
$1m per touchdown: did Brock Osweiler have the easiest ever NFL career?$1m per touchdown: did Brock Osweiler have the easiest ever NFL career?
Celebrities
Miley-CyrusMiley Cyrus
American singer-songwriter
Jennifer-LopezJennifer Lopez
American singer
Stephen-ColbertStephen Colbert
American comedian
Selena-GomezSelena Gomez
American singer
Lady-GagaLady Gaga
American singer-songwriter
Khloe-KardashianKhloé Kardashian
American media personality
Jay_ZJay-Z
American rapper
Oprah-WinfreyOprah Winfrey
American executive
Ellen-DeGeneresEllen DeGeneres
American comedian
MadonnaMadonna
American singer-songwriter
Jimmy-KimmelJimmy Kimmel
American television host
Kim-KardashianKim Kardashian
American media personality
Ariana-GrandeAriana Grande
American singer
BeyoncéBeyoncé
American singer-songwriter
Taylor-SwiftTaylor Swift
American singer
Justin-BieberJustin Bieber
Canadian singer-songwriter
Kylie-JennerKylie Jenner
American television personality
Two Women Charged With Drive-By Shooting Of Man Just Yards From His Home
Teenager Who Died After Eating Byron Burger On His 18th Birthday Was ‘Misled Over Allergens’
GCSE Suicide Letter Task Branded 'Irresponsible' And 'Dangerous' By Charity
Trump says national security advisor restrained him on Venezuela
Snoozing crew raises specter of criminal charge in boat fire
Black man Trump called 'my African American' quits Republicans and says president believes white people are superior
Ukraine leader says Russia sanctions must remain in place
British Airways has begun cancelling hundreds of flights ahead of next strike by pilots
State IG Set to Recommend Discipline for Trump’s Top Iran Hand
Gruff Rhys: Pang! review – acoustic, pastoral, global … and as unpredictable as ever
Tracks of the week reviewed: Metronomy, Grimes, Foals
Win a VIP package to the 2019 Hyundai Mercury Prize
Bleeping it real: the tricks, kicks and tech behind the year’s best records
Quiz: Can you tell these Hyundai Mercury Prize shortlisted albums by their covers?
‘The love is very appreciated’: what the Hyundai Mercury Prize means to today’s musicians
Paddleboarding and luxury: Miyazaki is Jones’s special place for final preparation | Gerard Meagher
The Joy of Six: champions | Daniel Harris
Australia heartbroken by Spain in Fiba Basketball World Cup double overtime thriller
Chess: Michael Adams knocked out in first round of World Cup in Siberia
Beer dispensaries and ball pimples: 10 bits of Rugby World Cup miscellany
Roosters burst out of blocks to blow away Rabbitohs in NRL finals opener
Rugby World Cup 2019: South Africa team guide
Sheffield United v Southampton: match preview
Tyson Fury: Wilder rematch talk can wait until I've finished partying in Vegas – video
MSNBC's Joe Scarborough bashes Julián Castro for 'cheap shot' at Biden's memory
Jamelle Bouie and Sean Penn fundamentally disagree about why Thursday's Democratic debate worked
Father Charged With Murder Of Baby In River Appears In Court
Secondary School Serves Vegetarian-Only Lunches – Here's What Parents Think Of That
95,000 Brits May Be 'Unaware They Have Life-Threatening Hepatitis C Infection'
Strictly Come Dancing Won’t Be Signing Up Stephen Fry Anytime Soon: 'I Can't Bear It'
As Multiple Teens Are Hospitalised In America, Should The UK Ban Flavoured Vaping Products?
Tory Rebel Could Launch 'Kamikaze' Move To Unseat Boris Johnson At Next Election, Says Rory Stewart
Game Of Thrones' Jacob Anderson Addresses Fans' Upset At Finale: 'I Don’t Know What They Expect Me To Do'
Domestic Violence Killings Hit Five-Year High
Heavy Periods? This Keyhole Surgery Could Help
Love Island's Maura Higgins Details Wine Incident That Landed Her In 'Really Big Trouble' With Producers
Love Posh Candles? This Hack Helps Burn Them To The Very Bottom
The Whistles Sale Is On – Here Are Our Top Picks (Including Dresses, Blazers And More)
I Found Love With An Old Friend I Hadn't Seen In 60 Years
Crew was asleep when fatal boat fire ignited, officials say
Philippines arrests 270 Chinese citizens in fraud raid
Netanyahu meets Putin as he makes desperate bid for Russian speaking voters ahead of knife-edge election
'I'll never go back': Nigerians flee S.Africa xenophobic violence
Adele files for divorce following separation from husband
End of the Road festival review – potent bacchanalia and mysticism
Sampa the Great: The Return review
Ashes 2019: England v Australia, fifth Test day two – live!
Premier League team news, Liverpool v Newcastle buildup and more – live!
Fiba Basketball World Cup 2019 semi-final: Spain v Australia in overtime – live!
Sports quiz of the week: big goals, beer, bans, beaten finalists and a bum
Shane Warne urges cricket to be proactive about climate crisis dangers
County cricket: Warwickshire v Essex, Gloucestershire v Sussex and more – live!
Talking Horses: Crystal Ocean was the best runner-up a star could want
Football transfer rumours: N'Golo Kanté to fix Real Madrid's midfield?
CNN's Jake Tapper and Jon Lovett pick Democratic debate winner and losers on Stephen Colbert's Late Show
Late night hosts joke about Andrew Yang’s freedom dividend contest: 'Asian Oprah'
The directors’ cut: film-makers choose the best movies of the century so far
True History of the Kelly Gang review – brutal portrait of the outback outlaw
British Man Killed In US Skydive Was Given Jump As 30th Wedding Anniversary Gift From Wife
Paedophile Nursery Worker To Be Banned From Two Counties When She Is Released From Prison
Google Earth Solves Mystery Of Man Who Vanished 22 Years Ago By Locating His Skeletal Remains
Why Is Friday 13th Unlucky?
Here's What I Wish My Friends (And Everyone Else) Knew About My Alopecia
Genuinely Tasty Cooking Apps So The Kids Can Nail It In The Kitchen
Life-Changing Moments That Connected Families Will No Longer Miss
This Is Why I Took My Seat In Parliament Despite Johnson's Unlawful, Manipulative Suspension
Simon Cowell Gets Real About Botox Use... And Admits He 'Maybe Had Too Much' In The Past
British Airways Cancels Flights Due To More Strike Action
Heathrow Drone Protest Fails To Get Off The Ground Following Public Nuisance Arrests
What’s Really Going On With Brexit Medicine Shortages?
Trump administration puts tough new asylum rule into effect
Julián Castro Questions Biden’s Memory at Democratic Debate
Pope's visit to Thailand will also be a family reunion
Biden Responds to Attacks on Obama Immigration Policies: ‘We Didn’t Lock People Up in Cages’
In small Alaska city, Native women say police ignored rapes
The 100 best albums of the 21st century
Why the best album of the 21st century is Amy Winehouse's Back to Black
Charli XCX: Charli review – a raw, rousing step towards superstardom
Jóhann Jóhannsson: 12 Conversations with Thilo Heinzmann | John Lewis's contemporary album of the month
The best classical music works of the 21st century
Fiba Basketball World Cup 2019 semi-final: Spain v Australia – live!
Belichick ensures everything with the Patriots is always different. Except winning
All Blacks lose Luke Jacobson for Rugby World Cup after concussion diagnosis
West Coast take on Geelong in AFL finals reeling from Willie Rioli's Asada finding
Stephen Colbert and Jimmy Kimmel joke through the highlights of Thursday's Democratic debate
Trevor Noah recaps Thursday's one-night-only, Obama-hugging Democratic debate
Camden Stabbing: Man Dies And Another In Hospital After Attack On High Street
How Turkish TV is taking over the world
Danish project aims to plant 1m trees across nation in TV fundraiser
YouTuber PewDiePie scraps $50,000 pledge to anti-hate group after fan backlash
MPs condemn 'misleading' no-deal Brexit publicity campaign
Alan Jones' radio show under 'full review' as advertiser exodus continues
Andrew Bolt at the ABC? That's not happening, Ita Buttrose says | Weekly Beast
Paris court finds Saudi princess guilty in beating case
As unrest deepens, Hong Kongers eye exits from Vancouver to Melbourne
New Zealand plans further restrictions to gun ownership
Trump Says He Plans to Unveil Middle-Class Tax Cut in Next Year
Report: Recalled California judge fired from coaching job
Julian Castro Questions Biden’s Memory at Democratic Debate
50 great tracks for September from Normani, Tinariwen, Miley Cyrus and more
All Blacks suffer blow on eve of World Cup with Luke Jacobson out with concussion
Julián Castro promises he wasn't trying to insult Joe Biden's age
ABC's Jon Karl says Julián Castro was 'just flatly wrong' in his attack on Joe Biden's memory
The 100 best films of the 21st century
'An account of how insane we once were' – Paul Thomas Anderson on There Will Be Blood
Trump officials to move to impose near-total block on asylum seekers at border
Charred wreckage of California dive boat raised from ocean floor
Venezuela's Maduro says he will skip U.N., but envoys will slam U.S. sanctions
MIT President: Oh Yeah, We DID Cover Up Epstein’s Donations
Biden Hits Warren, Sanders on Medicare for All at Dem Debate
Under US pressure Mexico shifts immigration policy
ABC's Jon Karl says Júlian Castro was 'just flatly wrong' in his attack on Joe Biden's memory
Joe Biden suggests putting on 'record players' at night to solve institutionalized racism
Trump favours 'whole deal' with China, two sides prepare for trade talks
US to disclose name of Saudi sought by 9/11 victims
The Words Missing from a New York Times Essay about Religious Liberty
Peru ex-president denied bail in U.S., wife dragged from court after outburst
San Marino seizes $19m from Congo dictator who spent $100,000 on crocodile shoes
A man sees the unimaginable while watching Hurricane Dorian coverage on AccuWeather
Condoleezza Rice shuts down NBC question on whether Russia helped Trump win in 2016
Congress orders US Taliban negotiator to testify
Woman charged; led police to apparent remains of child, 5
U.S. House panel wants Boeing CEO to allow employee interviews on 737 MAX crashes
Beto O'Rourke: 'Hell yes, we're going to take your AR-15, your AK-47'
Biden shrugs off health-care costs when Sanders brings up Canada: 'This is America'
Joe Biden tried to pit Elizabeth Warren against Obama. She wasn't having it
Kamala Harris brings up a Trump indictment during debate opening
Tracee Ellis Ross to Reunite With ‘Girlfriends’ Cast on ‘Black-ish’ This Season
Echoing Trump, speaker at 9/11 ceremony questions Muslim congresswoman's patriotism
Ohio cheerleader bursts into tears as murder verdict is read
Judge: Hastert victim broke terms of $3.5M hush-money deal
Trump's immigration crackdown starts to gain traction
Elizabeth Warren Proposes Boosting Social Security by Hiking Taxes on the Rich
Rugby World Cup 2019: New Zealand team guide
Premier League: 10 things to look out for this weekend
Andy Murray hoping again to play and beat tennis’s big three
Manchester City hit Lugano for second-half six in Champions League thrashing
New ‘SNL’ Cast Member Shane Gillis Uses Racial Slur in Resurfaced Video
Tarantino's gruesome revenge fantasies are growing more puerile and misogynistic | Caspar Salmon
Whirlpool Recall: Urgent Tumble Dryer Appeal Issued Over Fire Risk
Congress committee subpoenas Trump envoy to Taliban talks
Google Earth leads to remains of missing Florida man in lake
Justice Department nears prosecution of ex-FBI official McCabe: sources
Young Ohio mother acquitted of killing newborn
Donna Brazile sees 'good news' for Democrats in North Carolina special election defeat
US says tanker spotted in Syria shows Iran deceitful
Shep Smith Skewers Vaping Lobbyist: ‘Weren’t the Flavors Marketed to Kids?’
Kyle Sinckler ready to play two World Cup games in five days for England
'Nine surgeries, 20 concussions': Rob Gronkowski reflects on toll of NFL career
Mauricio Pochettino has no regrets over Kieran Trippier’s Tottenham departure
Watch the third Democratic debate here
Amber Heard Seeks Info on Johnny Depp’s Arrests and Substance Abuse
John Lithgow to Star Opposite Jeff Bridges on FX CIA Drama Pilot ‘The Old Man’
Motherless Brooklyn review – Edward Norton's weighty labour of love
The Two Popes: Anthony Hopkins and Jonathan Pryce divine in papal faceoff
Crisis at the boar-der: panic as Canadian feral hogs approach the US
Afghan Taliban Stronger Than Ever After U.S. Spends $900 Billion
Virginia Lt. Gov. Fairfax sues CBS over accuser interviews
Democrats slam decision to end immigrant medical relief
This Is Life for Muslim-Americans 18 Years After 9/11
Jos Buttler admits fatigue confusion after waking from lull to revive England
Suzann Pettersen forced out of first Solheim Cup morning by illness
Vivianne Miedema inspires Arsenal to winning return to Champions League
Mitchell Marsh swings into Ashes groove to hush Australian naysayers | Geoff Lemon
Nick Jonas Takes Down an Enemy Plane in Intense New ‘Midway’ Trailer (Video)
Cheryl Hines To Star In Freeform’s ‘Turkey Drop’ Thanksgiving Movie; Two More Cast; Premiere Date Set
Queen Sugar Renewed for Season 5
Lucy in the Sky review – Natalie Portman orbits a nervous breakdown
Dear Boris Johnson, watch these six films before you rip up the Irish backstop and trigger violence | Mark Cousins
Zakari Bennett: Man Charged With Murder After Death Of Baby Rescued From River
John Bercow Compares Prospect Of Boris Johnson Ignoring Law Blocking No-Deal Brexit To 'Robbing A Bank'
Twitter blocks accounts of Raúl Castro and Cuban state-run media outlets
The Latest: N Carolina polls close for 2 congressional seats
White House disputes accounts of Russian CIA informant
Stowaway passengers killed in DR Congo train disaster
Parents of Georgia Tech student shot by police file lawsuit
Lebanon detains former militia member accused of torture
Jos Buttler keeps England afloat after familiar collapse against Australia
Legal action by players should be the next step for online abuse | Eni Aluko
Anthony Joshua’s trainer McCracken backed over concussion comments
Heavy sits the crown of captaincy on Joe Root after ugly half-century | Barney Ronay
Football League clubs who defy Rooney rule should lose points, says report
HBO’s 1980s Lakers Pilot Finds Its Magic Johnson and Kareem Abdul-Jabbar
SNL Adds 3 New Featured Players, Including First Asian Cast Member
Teenager With Food Allergies Died Celebrating His 18th Birthday With A Burger
Marie Claire wasn’t all fluff. It filled a crucial gap in women’s lives | Gaby Hinsliff
Iran urges US to 'put warmongers aside' after Bolton firing
New US ambassador takes up post at United Nations
The Latest: Texas executes inmate for 2010 killing of woman
Former Dem Gov Labels Warren ‘Hypocrite’ for Shunning Big Donors after Taking Their Money
The Latest: NC House Republicans defend veto override action
The Netanyahu Show Is Finally Fizzling Out
2,500 unaccounted for in hurricane-hit Bahamas: official
Kamala Harris’s ‘Apology’ to the Disabled Won’t Cut It
Vuelta a España: Primoz Roglic closes in on glory after stage 18
County cricket: Somerset beat Yorkshire, Lancashire promoted – as it happened
Mathieu van der Poel regains Tour of Britain lead to set up duel with Trentin
Justify drug test cover-up deals immense blow to US horse racing
Bristol University Students Offered Accommodation In Wales Due To Room Shortage
Boris Johnson And Michael Gove 'Breached Ministerial Code' With No-Deal Brexit Ads, Says Jo Swinson
Close