Close
Date TimeAugust 31, 2019
VoiceAllowing third parties access to the online giants is as risky as it is profitableDigital networks have two significant properties: they can expand very rapidly, given the right conditions, and, if they do grow, powerful network effects kick in very quickly. A network effect is the phenomenon whereby the value of a network increases according to the number of people using it. In the 1980s, Bob Metcalfe tried to quantify the multiplier effect of additional users with what became known as Metcalfe’s law, which says that the value of a network is proportional to the square of the number of users. A network with 10 users has a value of 100, but one with a thousand users has a value of a million (1,000 squared).
Been duped on Facebook and Amazon’s platforms? Well, you’re not alone | John Naughton
Ever since the web arrived, the overriding mantra of online entrepreneurs has been “get big fast”: recruit users or customers as quickly as possible to get to the point where the network effect kicks in and discourages potential competitors. For most of the successful firms, the way to achieve this was to offer free services. This was the route chosen by Google and, later, Facebook and YouTube. For Amazon, growth was achieved by low prices, efficient dispatch, good customer service, prompt delivery and a colossal inventory.

Related Stories
Labour NEC In Shock Move To Abolish Tom Watsons Deputy Leader PostLabour NEC In Shock Move To Abolish Tom Watson's Deputy Leader Post
Gel Manicures Look Good, But Whats The Damage To Your Nails?Gel Manicures Look Good, But What's The Damage To Your Nails?
Federal Weather Workers ‘Shocked’ and ‘Irate’ by NOAA Backing Trump, Union Head SaysFederal Weather Workers ‘Shocked’ and ‘Irate’ by NOAA Backing Trump, Union Head Says
Students Repeatedly Posed in Blackface and Threatened Black Classmates. Their School Ignored, Lawsuit AllegesStudents Repeatedly Posed in Blackface and Threatened Black Classmates. Their School Ignored, Lawsuit Alleges
#FlipGirl car crash video goes viral after clip from ABC show mistaken for real thing#FlipGirl car crash video goes viral after clip from ABC show mistaken for real thing
Remains of missing man found on Google Earth after 20 years after submerged car spotted in lakeRemains of missing man found on Google Earth after 20 years after submerged car spotted in lake
Will the CIA’s Former Top Spy Fall Prey to Putin’s Murderous Mole Hunt?Will the CIA’s Former Top Spy Fall Prey to Putin’s Murderous Mole Hunt?
Baby Boy Who Died After Being Rescued From River Irwell Is NamedBaby Boy Who Died After Being Rescued From River Irwell Is Named
Vulnerable Man Stripped Naked And Beaten By Gang Of Birmingham Youths'Vulnerable' Man 'Stripped Naked' And Beaten By Gang Of Birmingham Youths
Buy one of these sleek new iPhone 11 or 11 Pro cases and you’ll get a pair of Bluetooth earbuds for free!Buy one of these sleek new iPhone 11 or 11 Pro cases and you’ll get a pair of Bluetooth earbuds for free!
Latest News
England v Australia: Rugby World Cup 2019, quarter-final – live!England v Australia: Rugby World Cup 2019, quarter-final – live!
The Creepy Way Facebook And Amazon Profit Off Our Private DataThe Creepy Way Facebook And Amazon Profit Off Our Private Data
How To Sleep Better On PlanesHow To Sleep Better On Planes
If Muslims Put Climate Change At The Centre Of Their Faith, We Can Make A DifferenceIf Muslims Put Climate Change At The Centre Of Their Faith, We Can Make A Difference
High-profile cases turn spotlight on domestic violence in RussiaHigh-profile cases turn spotlight on domestic violence in Russia
Trump news: President hails disputed Syria ceasefire as White House appears to confirm quid pro quo with UkraineTrump news: President hails disputed Syria 'ceasefire' as White House appears to confirm quid pro quo with Ukraine
The Amazon hasnt stopped burning. There were 19,925 fire outbreaks last month, and more fires are in the futureThe Amazon hasn't stopped burning. There were 19,925 fire outbreaks last month, and 'more fires' are in the future
Taco Bell sued by NJ couple over $2.18 dispute over Chalupa Cravings BoxesTaco Bell sued by NJ couple over $2.18 dispute over Chalupa Cravings Boxes
The Latest: Woman denies link to Alabama child abductionThe Latest: Woman denies link to Alabama child abduction
U.N. Investigates Possible Chemical Weapons Use by Turkish Forces in SyriaU.N. Investigates Possible Chemical Weapons Use by Turkish Forces in Syria
Celebrities
Jimmy-KimmelJimmy Kimmel
American television host
Justin-BieberJustin Bieber
Canadian singer-songwriter
Selena-GomezSelena Gomez
American singer
Lady-GagaLady Gaga
American singer-songwriter
Miley-CyrusMiley Cyrus
American singer-songwriter
Jennifer-LopezJennifer Lopez
American singer
Stephen-ColbertStephen Colbert
American comedian
Jay_ZJay-Z
American rapper
Ariana-GrandeAriana Grande
American singer
Ellen-DeGeneresEllen DeGeneres
American comedian
MadonnaMadonna
American singer-songwriter
Taylor-SwiftTaylor Swift
American singer
Kylie-JennerKylie Jenner
American television personality
Khloe-KardashianKhloé Kardashian
American media personality
Oprah-WinfreyOprah Winfrey
American executive
BeyoncéBeyoncé
American singer-songwriter
Kim-KardashianKim Kardashian
American media personality
Related Stories
Labour NEC In Shock Move To Abolish Tom Watsons Deputy Leader PostLabour NEC In Shock Move To Abolish Tom Watson's Deputy Leader Post
Gel Manicures Look Good, But Whats The Damage To Your Nails?Gel Manicures Look Good, But What's The Damage To Your Nails?
Federal Weather Workers ‘Shocked’ and ‘Irate’ by NOAA Backing Trump, Union Head SaysFederal Weather Workers ‘Shocked’ and ‘Irate’ by NOAA Backing Trump, Union Head Says
Students Repeatedly Posed in Blackface and Threatened Black Classmates. Their School Ignored, Lawsuit AllegesStudents Repeatedly Posed in Blackface and Threatened Black Classmates. Their School Ignored, Lawsuit Alleges
#FlipGirl car crash video goes viral after clip from ABC show mistaken for real thing#FlipGirl car crash video goes viral after clip from ABC show mistaken for real thing
Remains of missing man found on Google Earth after 20 years after submerged car spotted in lakeRemains of missing man found on Google Earth after 20 years after submerged car spotted in lake
Will the CIA’s Former Top Spy Fall Prey to Putin’s Murderous Mole Hunt?Will the CIA’s Former Top Spy Fall Prey to Putin’s Murderous Mole Hunt?
Baby Boy Who Died After Being Rescued From River Irwell Is NamedBaby Boy Who Died After Being Rescued From River Irwell Is Named
Vulnerable Man Stripped Naked And Beaten By Gang Of Birmingham Youths'Vulnerable' Man 'Stripped Naked' And Beaten By Gang Of Birmingham Youths
Buy one of these sleek new iPhone 11 or 11 Pro cases and you’ll get a pair of Bluetooth earbuds for free!Buy one of these sleek new iPhone 11 or 11 Pro cases and you’ll get a pair of Bluetooth earbuds for free!
Latest News
England v Australia: Rugby World Cup 2019, quarter-final – live!England v Australia: Rugby World Cup 2019, quarter-final – live!
The Creepy Way Facebook And Amazon Profit Off Our Private DataThe Creepy Way Facebook And Amazon Profit Off Our Private Data
How To Sleep Better On PlanesHow To Sleep Better On Planes
If Muslims Put Climate Change At The Centre Of Their Faith, We Can Make A DifferenceIf Muslims Put Climate Change At The Centre Of Their Faith, We Can Make A Difference
High-profile cases turn spotlight on domestic violence in RussiaHigh-profile cases turn spotlight on domestic violence in Russia
Trump news: President hails disputed Syria ceasefire as White House appears to confirm quid pro quo with UkraineTrump news: President hails disputed Syria 'ceasefire' as White House appears to confirm quid pro quo with Ukraine
The Amazon hasnt stopped burning. There were 19,925 fire outbreaks last month, and more fires are in the futureThe Amazon hasn't stopped burning. There were 19,925 fire outbreaks last month, and 'more fires' are in the future
Taco Bell sued by NJ couple over $2.18 dispute over Chalupa Cravings BoxesTaco Bell sued by NJ couple over $2.18 dispute over Chalupa Cravings Boxes
The Latest: Woman denies link to Alabama child abductionThe Latest: Woman denies link to Alabama child abduction
U.N. Investigates Possible Chemical Weapons Use by Turkish Forces in SyriaU.N. Investigates Possible Chemical Weapons Use by Turkish Forces in Syria
Celebrities
Jimmy-KimmelJimmy Kimmel
American television host
Justin-BieberJustin Bieber
Canadian singer-songwriter
Selena-GomezSelena Gomez
American singer
Lady-GagaLady Gaga
American singer-songwriter
Miley-CyrusMiley Cyrus
American singer-songwriter
Jennifer-LopezJennifer Lopez
American singer
Stephen-ColbertStephen Colbert
American comedian
Jay_ZJay-Z
American rapper
Ariana-GrandeAriana Grande
American singer
Ellen-DeGeneresEllen DeGeneres
American comedian
MadonnaMadonna
American singer-songwriter
Taylor-SwiftTaylor Swift
American singer
Kylie-JennerKylie Jenner
American television personality
Khloe-KardashianKhloé Kardashian
American media personality
Oprah-WinfreyOprah Winfrey
American executive
BeyoncéBeyoncé
American singer-songwriter
Kim-KardashianKim Kardashian
American media personality
How ‘fake news’ stories helped to inspire new TV thriller The Capture
Can a new podcast bring classical to the masses? – podcasts of the week
Dior perfume ad featuring Johnny Depp criticized over Native American tropes
Valerie Harper, Emmy award-winning star of TV series Rhoda, dies aged 80
Jo Brand: such a mistake to take comedians too seriously | Rebecca Nicholson
In lieu of Ian McKellen’s own memoirs, a new biography offers revelations
Biden Says He Would Prefer a Woman or Person of Color as Running Mate
California deputies rescue wailing bear trapped in dumpster
How Warren surged past Sanders – and how he fought back
What's really behind Trump's surprising tweet on Iran's 'failed satellite launch'
Researchers detail the most dangerous piece of iOS malware we’ve ever seen
The Latest: Red Cross reacts to Yemen airstrike killing 60
Ben Stokes, hero of Headingley, is England’s buccaneering totem
Bury crisis 'could be something we see more frequently', says Southgate
Hong Kong protesters target airport as city mops up
US strikes jihadists in Syria, monitor says 40 killed
Samsung may offer up to 1TB of internal storage on the Galaxy S11
Hurricane Dorian upgraded to ‘extremely dangerous’ storm as it nears Florida and Bahamas
Stop adding THC to e-cigarettes: US health authorities
Black Belt Eagle Scout: At the Party with My Brown Friends review – atmospheric indie rock
Taxi Wars: Artificial Horizon review – intelligent jazz from dEUS frontman
Kano: Hoodies All Summer review – grime elder statesman back with force
The Futureheads: Powers review – a welcome return
The Observer guide to the best autumn culture
Though comments veiled, Mattis repudiates former boss Trump
The Fiver | A mere 427 matches away from reaching next summer’s final in Gdansk
Arnold Schwarzenegger pays emotional tribute as 'best friend' Franco Columbu dies
President launches rant over 'stolen time' by FBI as Hurricane Dorian approaches U.S
James R Leavelle, detective handcuffed to Lee Harvey Oswald when he was shot, dies aged 99
Bahamas braces as monster Hurricane Dorian heads for US mainland
Why has America taken so long to confront its dark history?
Thousands of Russians rally to demand free elections
Pain and Glory review – life meets art in Almodóvar's wistful extravaganza | Peter Bradshaw's film of the week
Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark review – horror-comic summer special
Arnold Schwarzenegger pays tribute to 'best friend' Franco Columbu, who dies aged 78
Watch a man brazenly light a cigarette at gunpoint during an armed robbery
President says decision on whether to order evacuations in Florida will be made on Sunday
Trump Denies U.S. Involvement in Failure of Iranian Rocket Launch
No state-wide evacuation call for Dorian, unlike Irma
Hong Kong police fire water cannon and tear gas as protesters defy rally ban with petrol bombs
Hezbollah leader: We have no missile factories in Lebanon
Man told Starbucks barista his name was Aziz and she put ‘Isis’ on his cup
Twin Toddlers Sneak In Into Mom's Makeup and Make a Mess
One dead, nine wounded in French knife attack
Former Canadian PM 'rooting for a direct hit' of Hurricane Dorian on Mar-a-Lago
Hong Kong Masses Defy Police, Show China They’re Ready to Fight
Peter Mandelson pictured with Jeffrey Epstein in 2005
Iran official says U.S. showing 'some flexibility' on oil sales
Trump Iran photo tweet raises worries about disclosure of U.S. surveillance secrets
Sheer Mag: A Distant Call review – swagger rockin' on grim reality
Taylor Townsend aiming to go all the way and finally fulfil promise
Vasiliy Lomachenko outpoints Luke Campbell to add WBC lightweight title
'It's conceding as a team ... we switch off': Lampard laments Chelsea defending - video
In defence of gossip: why we should bring back the newspaper diary column
EU's Barnier says Brexit deal cannot be changed
Joe Biden under fire for war hero story 'filled with inaccuracies'
1st Special Forces Green Beret dies during combat operations in Afghanistan
Taliban launch major attack on Afghan city of Kunduz
Netanyahu tells Macron 'wrong time' for talks with Iran
Conan O'Brien gets advice from the Property Brothers on how best to buy Greenland for Trump
England have unity that was absent in 2015 World Cup, says Dan Cole
Charlie Edwards retains title after low blow by Julio César Martínez
Kalidou Koulibaly’s spectacular own goal hands Juventus win over Napoli
Manchester United are on right path despite draw, says Solskjær
Manchester City’s Demi Stokes: ‘We want playing in big stadiums to be the norm’
England must keep style evolving towards Euro 2020, says Southgate
Old Firm derby offers Neil Lennon chance to turn page on Cluj backlash
Mauricio Pochettino says Tottenham are different to big spending rivals
Unai Emery’s Arsenal still searching for its soul amid the tinkering | Nick Ames
Final lineup set for ABC Democratic primary debate; de Blasio, others miss cut
US blacklists Iranian tanker in Mediterranean
One dead, eight injured in French knife rampage
2020 Vision: 'Gaffe machine' in high gear, Biden's campaign says it doesn't matter
WATCH: Video of raid on Jeffrey Epstein's Palm Beach mansion reveals home decorated in part with illicit photos
National Rifle Association Calls NRATV a ‘Failed Endeavor’ in New Lawsuit
Washington's giant pandas could be sent back to China in latest casualty of US-China trade war
US Open 2019: Nadal defeats Chung, Wozniacki beaten by Andreescu – live!
Jürgen Klopp plays down Sadio Mané tantrum after striker is substituted
European roundup: Osasuna hold Barcelona despite teenage Fati’s record
Roberto Firmino adds shine to Liverpool’s victory over Burnley
US Open 2019: Nadal v Chung, Wozniacki beaten by Andreescu – live!
Juventus v Napoli: Serie A – live!
Kurt Zouma’s late own goal gives Sheffield United a point at Chelsea
Pinatubo still fancied for 2,000 Guineas despite Positive showing in Solario
Ireland show no signs of ageing to dampen Gatland’s home farewell | Michael Aylwin
Daniil Medvedev fights the boos to send out a defiant message at the US Open
Football League: Brentford punish Derby as Stoke slump again
Aston Villa rage at disallowed equaliser as Ayew earns Crystal Palace win
Ellie Goulding Tied The Knot In A Lavish Castle Wedding Worthy Of Royalty
Joker review – Joaquin Phoenix’s villain has last laugh in twisted tale
Angel Has Fallen: is Gerard Butler Hollywood's weirdest action hero?
Lisa Nandy Ready To Back Ken Clarke As Caretaker PM To Avoid No-Deal Brexit
German media, lawmakers point finger at Moscow over executed Georgian
Utah man found guilty of running massive opioid ring
The Slower Hurricane Dorian Moves, the More Dangerous It Is
Kamala Harris Attended LA Fundraisers The Same Day She Missed Endorsement Interview
Cocoa Beach city manager says timing of Hurricane Dorian could not be worse
Hurricane Dorian changes course, strengthens to Category 4
Anthoine Hubert killed in F2 crash with Juan Manuel Correa at Spa
Two-try Jacob Stockdale helps Ireland squeeze home against Wales
Kurt Zouma’s late own-goal gives Sheffield United a point at Chelsea
Kevin De Bruyne and Sergio Agüero lead Manchester City’s rout of Brighton
Dazzling Jamie Vardy hits double for Leicester to see off Bournemouth
Vuelta a España: Nicolas Edet takes race lead as Arndt wins stage eight
Daniil Medvedev fights the boos to send out defiant message at the US Open
Sébastien Haller on target again to guide West Ham to easy win over Norwich
Crystal Palace’s Jordan Ayew punishes Aston Villa after Trézéguet red card
Fabian Schär’s scrappy strike salvages draw for Newcastle against Watford
Wayne Routledge secures win for Swansea to displace Leeds at the top
Can Spider-Man survive outside of the Marvel universe?
The Entire Global Economy Is Complicit In The Destruction Of The Amazon
Street Artist SubDude Protests The Age Of Donald Trump With Posters
Democrats shut out of September debate say DNC rules are eliminating candidates before voters tune in
New York investigators reportedly zero in on Epstein recruiter as net tightens around his 'enablers'
Delta Air Lines pilot charged with alcohol violation
Trump accused of tweeting image from secret intelligence briefing as he says US not involved in Iran satellite launch failure
Texas governor says 'mistakes' made in immigrant rhetoric
Colombian troops kill nine FARC dissidents in raid: minister
Little Simz: ‘Every story told in Top Boy, I’ve witnessed a version’
Wales 17-22 Ireland: Rugby World Cup warm-up – live!
US Open 2019: Wozniacki v Andreescu, Nadal in action on day six – live!
Charles Leclerc on Belgian F1 GP pole in Ferrari lockout with Vettel
Burnley v Liverpool: Premier League – live!
Australia’s Mitchell Starc takes seven wickets to blast out Derbyshire
What’s Coming to Amazon Prime in September 2019
In ‘Joker,’ Joaquin Phoenix Wanted to Create a Character ‘That Wasn’t Identifiable’
Jeremy Corbyn Impersonates Boris Johnson As He Mocks Him For Lack Of Brexit Detail
The Best Signs From Today's Stop The Coup Protests Across The UK
Sudan court charges Bashir with illegal use of foreign funds
Tear Gas, Petrol Bombs and Barricade Bonfires: Hong Kong Update
Destination remains obscure for Iran oil tanker sought by US
German nurse under investigation for murdering patients
Iowa Dems Furious With DNC for Killing Virtual Caucus Plan
Mexican president backs official accused of suspect real estate purchases
Craig David: ‘Bo’ Selecta! was a blessing in disguise’
One to watch: O’Flynn
Lana Del Rey: Norman Fucking Rockwell review – stops you in your tracks
Manchester City v Brighton, Chelsea v Sheffield United and more – live!
Manchester United held by 10-man Southampton thanks to Vestergaard
Wales v Ireland: Rugby World Cup warm-up – live!
Stop the Coup Protests: Thousands Descend On Cities Across The UK To Protest Parliament Suspension
Yemen govt hits out at UAE over Aden raids
Alabama governor apologizes for wearing blackface in college
Hurricane Dorian strengthens to category 4 as Florida braces for landfall
India announces series of state-run bank mergers to strengthen lenders
Meet El Paso’s Punk Rock Border Angels
Southampton v Manchester United: Premier League – live!
Ben Stokes’s teammates have chance to pay off their debt at Old Trafford | Vic Marks
London Broncos still swinging in relegation battle nobody saw coming
Christian Eriksen’s Tottenham career reaches its D-Day before derby
Turning our clubs into global brands means there will be more Burys | Jonathan Wilson
Prince Andrew Returns To Royal Duties As Epstein Controversy Continues
1MDB – The Biggest Political Scandal You've Probably Never Heard Of
Paul McCartney Reveals Grandson Was Recently Mugged At Knifepoint In London
Two Men Left Fighting For Their Lives After Separate Knife Incidents Hours Apart In London
Strictly Judge Motsi Mabuse Dismisses Claims Oti Is Now At An Advantage Because They're Sisters
Video of raid on Jeffrey Epstein's Palm Beach mansion reveals home decorated in part with illicit photos
Hong Kong activists freed on bail, protest march banned
Condemned Tennessee inmate will be spared execution
The Latest: Category 4 Dorian inches toward Bahamas, Florida
Trump says U.S. has good negotiations with Taliban but no deal yet
Vasiliy Lomachenko: ‘Max was a very good person. But it’s the life we all live as fighters’
Valerie Harper, Star Of The Mary Tyler Moore Show And Rhoda, Dies Aged 80
Ariana Grande Cancels Fan Meet-And-Greet, Saying Her Anxiety And Depression Are At 'All-Time High'
Millions Of EU Nationals In Britain Haven’t Applied For Settled Status. We Asked Them Why
Jeffrey Epstein: Everything We Learned This Week About The Case
BBC Changes Stance Over Strictly Come Dancing Same-Sex Couples
Correction: Immigration-Citizenship story
Tens of Thousands of Marchers Defy Police Ban: Hong Kong Update
Judge ends case against Epstein, with a nod to the accusers
China's Communist Party elite to meet in October
Government: Let's end agreement for migrant kid detention
Girls schools could admit trans boys under proposals being considered by equalities watchdog
Kerry Washington Misses Live-Tweeting ‘Scandal’ With Fans – So She Gave Out Her Phone Number on Twitter
The Capture: Here's Who's In The Cast And What BBC One's New Drama Is All About
A Cut Post-Credit Scene Wasn't Clowning Around When It Came To It: Chapter Two
Yes, Penis Dysmorphia Is A Real Thing
23 Destination Wedding Photos To Remind You Love Is An Adventure
US blacklists Iran oil tanker in Mediterranean
PHOTOS: Florida prepares for Hurricane Dorian
Swedish teen climate activist leads protest near UN
Police in Oregon make more arrests in mass protest
Angry Roger Federer denies influencing US Open schedule after rout of Dan Evans
The Best Beauty Advent Calendars For 2019
Texas governor says 'mistakes were made' in a fundraising mailer that contained anti-illegal immigration rhetoric
Hurricane Dorian strengthens to category 4 as Florida braces for storm
Bahamas, Florida in path of 'dangerous' Hurricane Dorian
Appeals court reinstates lawsuit in SC church shooting case
Veterans condemn new citizenship policy for kids of overseas U.S. service members
China's factory activity shrinks for fourth month as trade pressure mounts
Turkish guards fire in air, stop protesting Syrians crossing border: AFP
China tells Philippines it won't recognize ruling on sea row
Hollywood Remembers Valerie Harper: “Honest And Hugely Funny”
Melting glaciers, as well as ice sheets, raising Earth's seas
Alabama Governor Apologizes for Blackface Skit, Refuses to Resign
Fox News Host Jeanine Pirro believes Democrats plotting to ‘replace American citizens with illegals’
5,000 bodies found in unmarked graves in Mexico since 2006
The Oddest and Most Awkward Diplomatic Posting in the World
Police admit white powder seized during drugs bust at Gatwick airport is actually cake mix for vegan bakery
Syrian troops to start unilateral cease-fire in Idlib
Close