Close
Date TimeAugust 17, 2019
Voice
White supremacy-fuelled killings to be classed as domestic terrorism under new law proposed in New York
Amid a national debate about racism, extremism and mass shootings, governor Andrew Cuomo proposed to make New York the first state to classify “hate-fuelled” killings as domestic terrorism on Thursday.Democrat Mr Cuomo unveiled the proposal almost two weeks after the back-to-back massacres in El Paso, Texas, and Dayton, Ohio, prompted all-too-familiar cries for action from both political parties.Describing the need to address the “new violent epidemic” of “hate-fuelled, American-on-American terrorism,” Mr Cuomo called for raising the penalties for violence motivated by race, gender, sexual orientation or other protected classes by making them punishable by up to life in prison without parole.“Today, our people are three times more likely to suffer a terrorist attack launched by an American than one launched by a foreigner,” he said. “Now this is not just repulsive. This is not just immoral. This is not just anti-American. It is illegal."And we must confront it by enacting a new law to fit the crime.”While the governor’s office has not shared any bill language, it said mass casualties would be defined as any death of at least one person and the attempted murder of at least two more.Lawmakers have wrestled with how to define and prosecute domestic terrorism for years.There is no federal crime of domestic terrorism. While congress passed a law after the 9/11 attacks defining domestic terrorism as violent acts intended to intimidate civilians or the government, that law did not create an accompanying federal offence, such as exists for international terrorism.Acts of domestic terrorism have instead been prosecuted under different charges, such as attempting to “destroy a building in interstate commerce”.Dozens of states, including New York, have enacted state-level laws defining terrorism. Some, including Georgia and Vermont, explicitly mention domestic terrorism.But those laws, like the federal one, largely measure terrorism as an attempt to coerce or destabilise the public or the government.New York’s new law, by contrast, would specify that domestic terrorism included acts of mass violence against people for their identities.“White supremacists, anti-Semites, anti-LGBTQ, white nationalists: these are Americans committing mass hate crimes against other Americans,” Mr Cuomo said. “And it should be recognised for what it is: domestic terrorism.”The governor also called on congress to enact a new federal domestic terrorism law. Senator Martha McSally introduced a bill on Wednesday to do that.Brooklyn congressman Hakeem Jeffries, a Democrat who also spoke at the event at the New York City Bar Association, joined the call for federal action. “Rome is burning right now, and yet Donald Trump and his co-conspirators in the Republican Party are fiddling around,” he said.Mr Cuomo’s proposal appears well positioned to win support in the state legislature, which this year fell under Democratic control for the first time in nearly a decade.While leaders of both the state Senate and Assembly did not explicitly say that they would back the bill, in statements they said they shared Mr Cuomo’s goal of ensuring safety and condemning hate.Mary McCord, a former top national security official in the justice department, said states’ existing domestic terrorism laws have not proved very effective, in part because they do little to address crime prevention.“They kind of just sit there unused, because they don’t necessarily have the same experience in investigating and prosecuting terrorism cases” as federal authorities, she said. “I think all states should have domestic terrorism statutes, it’s a good thing for them to have, but it hasn’t really moved the ball significantly.”Brian Michael Jenkins, a senior researcher at the RAND Corporation think tank, said that murder typically already carries the maximum penalties, whatever the motivation.“A mass murderer with a manifesto is still a mass murderer,” Jenkins said.Supporters of Mr Cuomo’s proposal said that singling out political motivation was, in part, the point.Malcolm Hoenlein, the executive vice chair of the Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organisations, appeared at Thursday’s speech alongside Mr Cuomo. He urged the audience to remember that “words are important”.“If you don’t name it, you can’t fight it," he said. The New York Times

Related Stories
Meet The Man Walking 400 Miles From Glasgow To London To Protest NHS PrivatisationMeet The Man Walking 400 Miles From Glasgow To London To Protest NHS Privatisation
The Satanic Sex Cult Leader Who Loved Animal Sacrifices, Orgies, and MurderThe Satanic Sex Cult Leader Who Loved Animal Sacrifices, Orgies, and Murder
Trump gives thumbs up in photo with El Paso orphanTrump gives thumbs up in photo with El Paso orphan
Husband of woman killed in mass shooting invites public to her funeral because he has no other familyHusband of woman killed in mass shooting invites public to her funeral because 'he has no other family'
Cyntoia Brown Released From Prison After Serving 15 Years Of Life SentenceCyntoia Brown Released From Prison After Serving 15 Years Of Life Sentence
Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell boasted of collecting compromising material on the rich and famousJeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell 'boasted of collecting compromising material on the rich and famous'
Fox News Host Pete Hegseth Getting Married to Colleague at Trump’s New Jersey ClubFox News Host Pete Hegseth Getting Married to Colleague at Trump’s New Jersey Club
Phoebe Waller-Bridge lands gig hosting Saturday Night LivePhoebe Waller-Bridge lands gig hosting Saturday Night Live
Jeffrey Epstein kept painting of Bill Clinton in drag at his houseJeffrey Epstein kept painting of Bill Clinton in drag at his house
Where in the World Is Ghislaine Maxwell?Where in the World Is Ghislaine Maxwell?
Latest News
Kim Kardashian and Kendall Jenner Present at 2019 Emmy AwardsKim Kardashian and Kendall Jenner Present at 2019 Emmy Awards
Emmys 2019: See the complete list of winnersEmmys 2019: See the complete list of winners
Iran asks West to leave Persian Gulf as tensions heightenedIran asks West to leave Persian Gulf as tensions heightened
Emmys 2019: Kim Kardashian, Kendall Jenner laughed at for calling themselves real people onstage: SavageEmmys 2019: Kim Kardashian, Kendall Jenner laughed at for calling themselves 'real people' onstage: 'Savage'
Greek police make arrest in 1985 hijacking of TWA Flight 847Greek police make arrest in 1985 hijacking of TWA Flight 847
GM workers mark Solidarity Sunday on week two of strikeGM workers mark 'Solidarity Sunday' on week two of strike
US police assess rise in threat tips after 3 mass killingsUS police assess rise in threat tips after 3 mass killings
Michelle Williams thanks studio for paying her equally in powerful Emmys speechMichelle Williams thanks studio for paying her equally in powerful Emmys speech
John Kerry, James Mattis weigh in on IranJohn Kerry, James Mattis weigh in on Iran
Patricia Arquette pays tribute to sister Alexis, calls for trans equality during moving Emmys acceptance speechPatricia Arquette pays tribute to sister Alexis, calls for trans equality during moving Emmys acceptance speech
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Boris-JohnsonBoris Johnson
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Theresa-MayTheresa May
Member of Parliament of the United Kingdom
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
Meet The Man Walking 400 Miles From Glasgow To London To Protest NHS PrivatisationMeet The Man Walking 400 Miles From Glasgow To London To Protest NHS Privatisation
The Satanic Sex Cult Leader Who Loved Animal Sacrifices, Orgies, and MurderThe Satanic Sex Cult Leader Who Loved Animal Sacrifices, Orgies, and Murder
Trump gives thumbs up in photo with El Paso orphanTrump gives thumbs up in photo with El Paso orphan
Husband of woman killed in mass shooting invites public to her funeral because he has no other familyHusband of woman killed in mass shooting invites public to her funeral because 'he has no other family'
Cyntoia Brown Released From Prison After Serving 15 Years Of Life SentenceCyntoia Brown Released From Prison After Serving 15 Years Of Life Sentence
Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell boasted of collecting compromising material on the rich and famousJeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell 'boasted of collecting compromising material on the rich and famous'
Fox News Host Pete Hegseth Getting Married to Colleague at Trump’s New Jersey ClubFox News Host Pete Hegseth Getting Married to Colleague at Trump’s New Jersey Club
Phoebe Waller-Bridge lands gig hosting Saturday Night LivePhoebe Waller-Bridge lands gig hosting Saturday Night Live
Jeffrey Epstein kept painting of Bill Clinton in drag at his houseJeffrey Epstein kept painting of Bill Clinton in drag at his house
Where in the World Is Ghislaine Maxwell?Where in the World Is Ghislaine Maxwell?
Latest News
Kim Kardashian and Kendall Jenner Present at 2019 Emmy AwardsKim Kardashian and Kendall Jenner Present at 2019 Emmy Awards
Emmys 2019: See the complete list of winnersEmmys 2019: See the complete list of winners
Iran asks West to leave Persian Gulf as tensions heightenedIran asks West to leave Persian Gulf as tensions heightened
Emmys 2019: Kim Kardashian, Kendall Jenner laughed at for calling themselves real people onstage: SavageEmmys 2019: Kim Kardashian, Kendall Jenner laughed at for calling themselves 'real people' onstage: 'Savage'
Greek police make arrest in 1985 hijacking of TWA Flight 847Greek police make arrest in 1985 hijacking of TWA Flight 847
GM workers mark Solidarity Sunday on week two of strikeGM workers mark 'Solidarity Sunday' on week two of strike
US police assess rise in threat tips after 3 mass killingsUS police assess rise in threat tips after 3 mass killings
Michelle Williams thanks studio for paying her equally in powerful Emmys speechMichelle Williams thanks studio for paying her equally in powerful Emmys speech
John Kerry, James Mattis weigh in on IranJohn Kerry, James Mattis weigh in on Iran
Patricia Arquette pays tribute to sister Alexis, calls for trans equality during moving Emmys acceptance speechPatricia Arquette pays tribute to sister Alexis, calls for trans equality during moving Emmys acceptance speech
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Boris-JohnsonBoris Johnson
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Theresa-MayTheresa May
Member of Parliament of the United Kingdom
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Putin gives pilot who landed in cornfield Russia's top medal
PG&E plans to cut thousands of trees to prevent fires. Here’s why hundreds didn’t get chopped
Afghan palace emerges from ruins as centenary nears
Venezuelan exodus may soon double, triggering a bigger regional crisis | Opinion
Yemen rebel attack sparks fire in Saudi gas plant: Aramco
Warren, Sanders get personal with young, black Christians
Appeals court sides with Trump administration on asylum rules
Smith and Archer hypnotise to leave second Test tantalisingly poised
Lucas Moura earns Spurs draw at Manchester City as VAR history repeats
'The mentality giants are in town': Klopp reflects on beating Southampton – video
'Portland is being watched very closely': Trump stokes tension over far right rally
Yemen rebel drone attack targets remote Saudi oil field
The New York Times reports Barack Obama tried to talk Joe Biden out of a White House run
Indian ambassador to UN slams international interference over Kashmir
Claims: Migrant children molested in U.S.-funded foster care
'I am transgender': Guardian football writer Nicky Bandini comes out in Twitter video
Box Office: ‘Good Boys’ Eyes Best Original Comedy Opening of 2019
Cheryl's waxwork removed from London's Madame Tussauds
New Orleans news anchor dies in plane crash
Toni Kroos scores stunning goal as Real Madrid get off to a flyer at Celta Vigo
Peter Fonda, star of 'Easy Rider,' has died
Proud Boys Portland rally: Police brace for violence at far-right protests today
Hundreds of strangers showed up to an El Paso shooting victim's funeral
Easy Rider to Ulee's Gold: Peter Fonda's most memorable roles – video obituary
Owen Jones 'Beaten Up In Blatant Premeditated Assault'
Trump to drop out of 2020 race within months, former aide Scaramucci claims
Lawyer: Iranian supertanker captain no longer wants the job
‘We’ve been bullied out of the water by the sharks’: Rise in great white numbers triggers panic on US beaches
Iran tanker in limbo off Gibraltar as US issues warrant
McConnell undergoes surgery to repair shoulder fracture
Bat for Lashes: ‘I didn’t know if I was going to make an album again’
George North try helps Wales bounce back with home win against England
Manchester City v Tottenham Hotspur: Premier League – live!
Sadio Mané returns to haunt Saints and help Liverpool to nervy win
Norwich brush aside Newcastle thanks to Teemu Pukki hat-trick
Dina Asher-Smith full of confidence before toughest test of the year
Bernard’s early goal is difference as Everton keep Watford at bay
Harry Wilson goal edges Bournemouth past Aston Villa after early blitz
Brighton’s Leandro Trossard denied by VAR then pegs back West Ham
Peter Fonda: the elegant rebel who set the counterculture in motion
Peter Duncan Stabbing: 17-Year-Old Charged With Murder Of 'Devoted Father'
Marium The Insanely Cute Baby Dugong Dies After Eating Plastic Waste
The Latest: All tourists return to Denali entrance safely
Rashida Tlaib, fiery US lawmaker at center of Israel uproar
'A new Hawaiian Renaissance': how a telescope protest became a movement
Airstrikes in Syrian rebel stronghold kills family of 7
India eases some curbs in Kashmir, including fixed line phone use
Crews reopen Denali park road; stranded tourists leave
Lacazette and Aubameyang give Arsenal the edge over sturdy Burnley
‘Things are quite special here’: Union Berlin prepare for the Bundesliga
Aduriz gets standing ovation after stunning volley against Barcelona – video
Acclaimed animator who created Roger Rabbit dies aged 86
PC Andrew Harper: Everything We Know So Far About The Death Of The Newlywed Police Officer
Nora Quoirin's Family Demands End To 'Distressing' Speculation About Daughter's Death
Thailand's lost baby dugong dies from shock, eating plastic
Aid group: Italy must let all migrants off rescue ship
Priest who appeared in The Exorcist accused of 'grooming and sexually abusing' student at Jesuit school
Barbados police say no signs of an intruder in house where British woman found dead
Unprecedented heatwave 'kills thousands of fish' in Alaska
Trump and His Allies’ Batshit New Rallying Cry: Media Creating Recession to Swing 2020 to Democrats
Lewis Capaldi review – an ecstatic sense of homecoming
Shaun Ryder: ‘I’m a really good dad, this time around anyway’
One to watch: Snoh Aalegra
Wales v England: Rugby World Cup warmup – live!
Southampton v Liverpool, Everton v Watford and more – live clockwatch!
Peter Fonda: a life in pictures
Easy Rider to Ulee's Gold: Peter Fonda's most memorable roles - video obituary
Crews reopen Denali park road, tourist buses begin to return
The Latest: Omar disputes Netanyahu's claims about itinerary
Russian opposition to defy authorities with fresh protests
Shooting near Alabama campus kills 2, injures 3
'You're blaming video games?' Jimmy Fallon, Seth Meyers, Trevor Noah, and Stephen Colbert shoot down the GOP's latest mass shooting scapegoat
Arsenal v Burnley: Premier League – live!
All Blacks deliver Bledisloe pain with 36-point whitewash of Wallabies
Disney's Mulan Live-Action Remake Faces Boycott Calls After Liu Yifei Controversy
Peter Fonda, Star Of Easy Rider, Dies Aged 79
'My ancestor founded the Guardian. Its work has never been so vital'
ITV to bring Who Wants to Be a Millionaire scandal to screen
Jamie Demetriou on the return of Stath Lets Flats
Ilhan Omar and Rashida Tlaib Partnered with Vicious Anti-Semites to Plan Their Trip to Israel
China media says Hong Kong response 'won't repeat' Tiananmen
Rap's X Factor: can a TV talent show find the next Stormzy?
Instead of wedding gifts, Florida couple asks guests for school supplies
Ashes 2019: England v Australia second Test, day four – live
Bledisloe Cup 2019: All Blacks v Wallabies Eden Park decider – live!
Time nearly up for Bradford’s crumbling, much-loved Odsal home
Injured McConnochie replaced by Watson for England's warm-up against Wales
Megan Rapinoe: 'We're everything Trump loves – except that we're powerful women'
Art Spiegelman: golden age superheroes were shaped by the rise of fascism
Game Of Thrones' Alfie Allen Dismisses Fan Backlash After Divisive Finale
Peter Fonda, Star Of Easy Rider, Dies Aged 74
Andrew Harper Death: Ten In Custody Over Police Officer's Killing
Streaming: Netflix and the Obamas raise the stakes
‘Do black people read?’ What my years in publishing have taught me about diversity in books | Natalie Jerome
Darkly funny, desperate and full of rage: what makes a millennial novel?
Gingrich on Tlaib visiting Israel, Trump's New Hampshire rally, 2020 Democrat polls
Portland, Oregon, awaits right-wing rally, counter protests
The Latest: Reporter ID'd in New Orleans small plane crash
Stephen Colbert appreciates Beto O'Rourke's 'shouts and swears' on Trump and gun violence
Once Upon A Time In Hollywood Cast: All The Key Cameos To Look Out For
How WhatsApp Is Radicalising The Right In Bolsonaro's Brazil
The NHS Is Slowly Cancelling Free IVF – And This Is The Impact It's Having
9 Classic Books To Read Before The End Of The Holidays
Why Do We Call It 'French Kissing'?
Zimbabwe police beat protesters defying regime 'worse than Mugabe'
The Latest: Crews clear lane of road, buses begin to return
Beto O'Rourke: 'I will not in any scenario run for the United States Senate'
Dozens of US teens hospitalized with lung disease after vaping
Jimmy Kimmel and Trevor Noah offer thoughts, not jokes, about the weekend's mass shootings
Kentucky political feud bursts into public ahead of election
Moscow set for fresh protests after month of rallies
Epstein girlfriend Ghislaine Maxwell pictured at burger bar in first public sighting since financier’s death
Bill Maher Mocks Fox News’ Sean Hannity For Claiming He’s Causing a Recession
US murderer executed after choosing electric chair
Tom Homan shares exclusive video of attack on Washington ICE detention center
China flexes muscle near Hong Kong amid more weekend rallies
The powerful pro-Israel lobby and leading Democrats tear into Trump for pressuring Israel to bar Ilhan Omar and Rashida Tlaib from visiting
Kazakhstan court frees anti-Beijing activist
London teen lost at Malaysian resort died from ulcer bleed
India vows to ease Kashmir clampdown as clashes with Pakistan continue
Correction: Steve King-Abortion story
Israel intercepts Gaza rocket after weeks of calm
Captain called hero after bird strike disables Russian plane
China police exercises across from Hong Kong seen as threat
States team up against W.House immigrant benefits rule
Cathay Pacific CEO resigns after Beijing pressure
Ford Celebrates 25th Annual Woodward Dream Cruise With Mustang Alley
'Trump is exporting his bigotry': AOC blasts Israel for banning Omar and Tlaib
Claims: Migrant children molested in US-funded foster care
'Explosive' situation on migrant rescue boat in limbo off Italy
North Korea 'fires missiles off coast' and says talks with 'impudent' South are over
Jeffrey Epstein’s Body Claimed by His Brother
Arrests precede major demonstrations in Portland, Oregon
Bayern Munich agree season-long loan deal for Barcelona’s Philippe Coutinho
Huddersfield sack coach Jan Siewert after one win in seven months
Mauricio Pochettino puts faith in Spurs bravery to halt Manchester City | Dominic Fifield
Talking Horses: Soft-ground specialists to come to the fore | Tony Paley
Wales’s James Davies: ‘I take opportunities and change opinions’ | Paul Rees
Pep Guardiola says Mauricio Pochettino does not believe his praise is genuine
Steve Bruce understands volatile nature of life for manager at Newcastle
Pep v Poch: Spurs manager jokingly suggests one-on-one competition with Guardiola – video
Hot Package: Kerry Washington & Sterling K. Brown To Star In ‘Shadow Force’
Peter Fonda, celebrated actor known for Easy Rider, dies aged 79
O’Rourke Announces Support for Federal Confiscation of Assault-Style Weapons
Tennessee inmate executed in electric chair for killings
Portland’s Feared Far-Right Rally Hit by Multiple Setbacks
DNA leads to arrest in another Florida rape case from 1980s
UK judge to allow firm to try to seize $9 billion in Nigerian assets in gas dispute
Jones highlights need for England warm-ups after McConnochie injury
Kyle Sinckler: ‘You think Eddie is tough? My mum put me in my place’
Aritz Aduriz’s late acrobatics for Athletic Bilbao stun Barcelona
Warrington’s horrendous build-up to Wembley final continues at Wigan
Barcelona’s Philippe Coutinho set for season-long loan to Bayern Munich
Frank Lampard ready to play Tammy Abraham for Chelsea after racial abuse
Fresh blow to England as Olly Stone is ruled out for rest of series
Everton signed Moise Kean to play centre-forward, says Marco Silva
‘Krypton’ Canceled After Two Seasons, Spinoff ‘Lobo’ Not Moving Forward On Syfy
America Ferrera & Eva Longoria Among A-Listers To Pen Letter In Support Of Latino Community
Medical Examiner Rules Jeffrey Epstein's Death As Suicide
The Only Thing Jeffrey Epstein’s Broken Bone Proves
Japan's new emperor speaks of 'deep remorse' in 1st speech marking WWII
Hundreds defy restrictions, join protests in Kashmir
Natalie Crichlow: Barbados Police Say There Is 'Nothing To Indicate' An Intruder Killed Mum-Of-Three
Mexico does not want El Paso shooter executed
Woman survives plunging a mile after parachute fails to open
Parents claim body of Franco-Irish teen found dead in Malaysia
US lawmaker barred by Israel calls move 'chilling' insult
The Latest: US to revoke visas held by crew of Iranian ship
Trump says people have 'no choice' but to vote for him to save stock market
Ed Smart, father of kidnapping survivor Elizabeth Smart, comes out as gay
Jofra Archer off mark for England but threat of second Test draw looms
Athletic Bilbao v Barcelona: La Liga opener – live!
Jofra Archer quickly becomes England’s go-to bowler for all occasions | Andy Bull
Steve Bruce: ‘It would settle everybody if we got a result at Norwich’
Journeyman Andy Lonergan could get big chance in Liverpool’s goal
Frank Lampard 'disgusted' by racist abuse directed at Tammy Abraham – video
Zinedine Zidane ready to rely on ‘important’ Gareth Bale for Real Madrid
Greenland is NOT for sale! Danes ridicule Donald Trump
James Bond Aston Martin DB5 sold at auction for £5.2m
Joe Jonas Gets Cake And Concert Kiss From Sophie Turner For 30th Birthday
Trump accuses media of crashing the economy to ruin his presidency amid recession concerns
ICE Confines Some Detainees With Mental Illness in Solitary for Months
Ashes 2019: England v Australia second Test, day three abandoned after rain – as it happened
Jay-Z's deal with NFL branded 'disgusting' by Colin Kaepernick's girlfriend
The Fiver | Losing the absolute run of oneself
Netflix Orders Elvis Animated Action Comedy Series ‘Agent King’ (EXCLUSIVE)
James Bond's 1965 Aston Martin DB5 auctioned for $6.4 million
Art Spiegelman's Marvel essay 'refused publication for Orange Skull Trump dig'
Mother Who Drowned IVF Twins In 'Anger' At Estranged Husband Is Jailed
Exclusive: Leaked Doc Reveals Civil Servants Told To Report 'Unhelpful Narratives' On Brexit To No.10
Butcher Pawel Relowicz Jailed For Sex Acts Including Burglary And Voyeurism
Since Having Children I Go 'Out Out' More Than Ever
Family seeks more answers to London teen's death in Malaysia
17 missing in SW China landslide
Germany expects No Deal and will not renegotiate, says leaked briefing
The Latest: Trump defends Israel move to bar 2 congresswomen
Philadelphia mayor calls for gun control action after officers injured in standoff
For inmates like Epstein, suicide watch is meant to be short
Shiite cleric returns to Nigeria after India medical row
S.Africa announces visa waivers to boost tourism
Close