Close
Date TimeAugust 17, 2019
VoiceIn the closing weeks of Brazil’s presidential election last year, a vicious rumour about leftist candidate Fernando Haddad spread from the fever swamps of social media into the national conversation. Suddenly, people across Brazil came to believe, falsely, that Haddad, the former mayor of São Paulo and the last bulwark against the rise of far-right authoritarian Jair Bolsonaro, had endorsed gay pedophilia.
How WhatsApp Is Radicalising The Right In Bolsonaros Brazil
It was a piece of misinformation so blatant but so pervasive that eventually, legitimate media sources and even Haddad’s campaign had to forcefully reject it.
Facebook famously helped bolster Donald Trump’s presidential campaign in 2016 by serving as a force multiplier for wild rumours about Hillary Clinton’s health and phoney ties to uranium purchases in Russia. But in Brazil, the world’s fourth-largest democracy, there was a different culprit (with the same corporate parent): WhatsApp. 
The messaging service is a relative afterthought in the United States’ crowded social media landscape, used by only about one-fifth of the country nationwide ― and even then, primarily only for text messaging. It is a different phenomenon in Brazil, where an estimated 120 million people ― more than half of the nation’s population ― use WhatsApp for nearly everything: massive group chats and disseminating and receiving community, national and even global news.
WhatsApp allows users to join massive groups, sometimes hundreds of members strong, which gives it a special power in Brazil. And in a country with highly concentrated mainstream media, it became an organising tool and an easy way to manoeuvre around traditional news structures. 
During the election, it became a potent tool for the spread of misinformation and fake news, especially for supporters of Bolsonaro. 
Now, eight months into Bolsonaro’s presidency, WhatsApp is still serving as a largely hidden platform for the radicalisation of right-wing Brazilians, even as Bolsonaro’s once-united base has splintered into separate, and often competing, factions. And Brazil is feeling its effects.How WhatsApp Bolstered BolsonaroI began monitoring pro-Bolsonaro WhatsApp groups in March 2018, at the outset of the election the social media app eventually helped Bolsonaro win. I found that fake news spread in typical fashion, through a structure of groups that resembled a pyramid, as I detailed for The Guardian last year. 
Small groups of “influencers” sat at the top of the pro-Bolsonaro WhatsApp ecosystem. They actively manipulated news stories and created misinformation meant to go viral.The influencers then pushed that misinformation down into larger groups made up of Bolsonaro’s most ardent supporters, who served as his troll army. Unified in their support of the right-winger, they pushed the influencers’ fake news to virality. 
From there, the fake news spread into even larger groups of ordinary Brazilians, who used WhatsApp to go around traditional media outlets and receive news that reinforced their inclination to vote for Bolsonaro in discussions that acted as echo chambers for the cause. 
WhatsApp’s assistance to Bolsonaro’s campaign became an international story after the election as the messaging service was revealed to be yet another disruptive social media force in a world where Facebook, YouTube, Twitter and Gab served as incubators for conspiracy theories and misinformation that helped push the far-right to power across the globe.
But after Bolsonaro won the election, attention on WhatsApp faded, and many members left the groups they had participated in during the campaign. Their main goal had been accomplished; they had made Bolsonaro president. 
Those who have remained perpetually logged on have done so for one of the main reasons they joined in the first place: They want to stay informed about Bolsonaro’s government through WhatsApp because they no longer trust the mainstream media to deliver the truth. WhatsApp, for them, is now their primary source of news. Eight months into Bolsonaro’s presidency, WhatsApp is still serving as a largely hidden platform for the radicalization of right-wing Brazilians.But where they were united behind Bolsonaro during his campaign, serving and thriving off of each other, many of the main WhatsApp groups now disagree on the president’s decisions and approach to governance. Bolsonaro’s attempts to appease certain planks of the soft coalition of military men, so-called “anti-globalists,” social conservatives and economic elites that pushed him to power, along with his haphazard and unfocused governing style, have left the groups fighting among themselves about their expectations of ― and disappointments in ― Bolsonaro’s eight-month-old presidency. 
The four groups I originally monitored splintered into loose coalitions and have now split into a total of 10 groups, each of which has continued to radicalise largely out of the sight of Brazilian regulators, politicians, the media, and even WhatsApp itself, which has limited access to the actual content that is spread within the groups it hosts.
The current groups can be split into three broad coalitions. 
Two of them largely support Bolsonaro: one by pushing government propaganda and cries of fake news to convince Brazil that what is happening under Bolsonaro isn’t actually happening; the other by amplifying his socially conservative, far-right views ― including his rampant homophobia, racism and sexism. Members of the third coalition have become something of an insurgency on the far right ― a group of Brazilians who feel Bolsonaro has betrayed their cause and have become his fiercest and most radical opponents.The PropagandistsThe propagandist coalition is most similar to the WhatsApp groups that formed before Bolsonaro’s election and is still made up of an assortment of the influencers, ardent supporters and ordinary Brazilians who propelled him to victory.
These groups of supporters have become even more extreme. Where they once tolerated some debate, they now shut down any opposition to ― or even mild questioning of ― the president’s acts. But instead of consuming, sharing and producing fake news about opposing candidates, as they did before the election, their misinformation now mainly focuses on government propaganda that works to delegitimise traditional news venues that have been reporting the wrongdoings of the government.Nowhere is this more evident, perhaps, than in their efforts to discredit domestic and international reporting about the rapid escalation in deforestation of the Amazon rainforest that has occurred under Bolsonaro ― a development that has drawn international outrage. 
These groups have mobilised against journalists and media outlets who have reported on Amazonian destruction. They have even pushed back against government officials ― like Ricardo Galvão, the former head of Brazil’s National Institute for Space Research, who was fired in August after Bolsonaro openly disagreed with his assertion that rainforest destruction was accelerating. 
One message, for instance, attempts to discredit André Trigueiro, a journalist from Brazil’s Globo news outlet: “André Trigueiro keeps saying that Bolsonaro will kill the Amazon... we can’t expect anything different from someone who works for Globo Garbage! Communist Press!”
“Ricardo Galvão,” another message said, “lied about deforestation data, another fake news! We have to stick together for the nation!”
Such messages are typical, and they quickly spread to forums like Twitter and Facebook, where the propagandists can directly target journalists and other users with cries of “fake news” and challenges to prove that their reporting is true. The Social SupremacistsThe second coalition ― the social supremacists ― is primarily focused on aligning themselves with the far-right views of the president and his son Eduardo, a congressman from São Paulo, to amplify those causes. Members of these groups are not interested in the daily political acts of the government. As long as Bolsonaro continues to pursue a socially conservative agenda, they’re assuaged and supportive. 
They share content that is pro-gun, racist, anti-LGBTQ, anti-Semitic and opposed to Brazil’s Northeast, a region that is among the poorest and blackest parts of Brazil (and has become a target of the president). Nazi propaganda, paedophilic content and favourite symbols of the American white nationalist movement, including Pepe the Frog, are commonly spread through memes and videos, while they often manipulate photos of Brazilian leftists to suggest they are Communists or anti-Christian. But they are not siloed. They often push new members to other, more radical channels of discussion, including Dogolachan and 55Chan. Other forums, meanwhile, share similarities with the U.S. incel ― or involuntary celibate ― movement, and paedophilic, racist, and anti-Semitic content is heavily shared and celebrated. 
Brazil has already suffered from the growth of these groups: In March, two men who had been active on some of these more fringe forums opened fire at a school in Suzano, Brazil, killing 10 people and injuring 17 more. And in the aftermath, these groups provided a forum for a response to gun violence that mimicked the way conservative movements and the gun lobby answer school shootings in the United States.The InsurgentsThere has also been a proliferation of radical WhatsApp groups made up of members who once supported Bolsonaro but have now become some of his fiercest critics ― not because they have become less radical, but because they believe the president isn’t radical enough.
These groups have strong nationalistic sentiment and believe that Bolsonaro betrayed the nation, primarily because his economic minister has sought to privatise or sell Brazil’s state-owned companies to foreign investors. They also claim that Bolsonaro has not kept his promises to “cleanse” the government of its corrupt political establishment, and although he has appointed more generals to his Cabinet than any president elected since Brazil’s military dictatorship ended three decades ago, they are angry that he hasn’t fully stocked the government with members of the armed forces.In their view, the only way to save Brazil is to do what Bolsonaro hasn’t: Organise an armed insurgency to completely cleanse the legislative and judicial branches of government of its past ills.
These insurgents, almost all of whom once belonged to pro-Bolsonaro groups before the election, have ironically exposed some of the dirtiest practices that occurred via WhatsApp during the campaign. Many of them have alleged that they were compensated ― in amounts between $100 to $250 per week ― to disseminate content to benefit Bolsonaro. And in doing so, they have pointed the finger at influential groups of businessmen who they said financed the network, and suggested that virtual militias ― known as the Virtual Activist Movement ― were paid to infiltrate WhatsApp groups and spread misinformation.
They haven’t directly implicated Bolsonaro’s campaign team, though they have said that at least one person who is currently an adviser in Bolsonaro’s government was among those paid to feed fake news to his supporters.
These groups, too, have made their voices heard outside of WhatsApp. They have been instrumental forces behind protests that have called on Bolsonaro to shutter Brazilian Congress, shut down the country’s judiciary and even return to military rule ― an indication of how radical Brazilian discourse has become under a president who himself has long celebrated the country’s deadly and oppressive military dictatorship.What Now?Only a tiny fraction of Brazilians belong to these groups, and they are not representative of all Bolsonaro’s constituents. But they all reveal ways that people are becoming radicalised on messaging apps like WhatsApp. 
As Google, Facebook and Twitter have cracked down more firmly on violent and potentially dangerous speech, consumers of that content have flocked to apps like WhatsApp and Telegram, another messaging service popular in Brazil, in search of safe spaces to find “inspiration” and become radicalised. 
In Brazil, that means strident turns against many of the traits and qualities that the country is internationally known for, including the celebration of ethnic diversity, higher rates of LGBTQ tolerance than other parts of socially conservative Latin America, the practice of African religions, and anti-gun politics. And though Bolsonaro has posed his own threats to Brazil’s environment, its most marginalised communities and even its democracy, these groups have not just bolstered him but, at times, acted on their own in dangerous and anti-democratic fashion. 
The solution to this issue requires a multifaceted response. Law enforcement and courts have to impose the law ― in many countries, including Brazil, violent hate speech is criminalised. Radicalisation can also start at an early age; thus, parents need to pay attention to what their children are doing on the internet and be ready to intervene. 
Tech companies also have to continue to de-platform these radicalising spaces and figures. De-platforming has worked at times: Facebook and Twitter have banned figures like Milo Yiannopoulos and Alex Jones, limiting their influence. But they still have thousands of followers on Telegram.
A spokesperson for WhatsApp told HuffPost in a statement: “In the run up to last year’s Brazil elections, we placed a label on forwarded messages and piloted a limit on how they can be sent. We also banned hundreds of thousands of accounts for spam and are constantly working to improve our ability to detect and ban automated accounts. Additionally, WhatsApp worked to raise awareness about misinformation through a broad education campaign on the radio, in print and online. We helped bring Project Comprova onto WhatsApp as one of several organisations conducting fact checking via WhatsApp. We will continue to expand on these efforts and work with others across society to help address the challenges posed by misinformation.”
Though WhatsApp has made changes in response to the election, it still serves as a unique platform for the spread of dangerous misinformation in Brazil and elsewhere. Radicalisation happens at high speed ― combating it requires an even faster response.
David Nemer is an assistant professor of media studies at the University of Virginia who has studied the influence of social media in Brazil’s elections. He is the author of “Favela Digital: The Other Side of Technology,” a book about the use of technology in Brazil’s informal neighbourhoods. Find him on Twitter @davidnemer.

Related Stories
Meet The Man Walking 400 Miles From Glasgow To London To Protest NHS PrivatisationMeet The Man Walking 400 Miles From Glasgow To London To Protest NHS Privatisation
The Satanic Sex Cult Leader Who Loved Animal Sacrifices, Orgies, and MurderThe Satanic Sex Cult Leader Who Loved Animal Sacrifices, Orgies, and Murder
I Found Love On Naked AttractionI Found Love On Naked Attraction
Gemma Collins, No One Needs To Sniff Your Fingers – These Are The Symptoms Of A Yeast InfectionGemma Collins, No One Needs To Sniff Your Fingers – These Are The Symptoms Of A Yeast Infection
Game Of Thrones Star Sophie Turner Meets Queer Eyes Jonathan Van Ness, Much Screaming EnsuesGame Of Thrones Star Sophie Turner Meets Queer Eye's Jonathan Van Ness, Much Screaming Ensues
Husband of woman killed in mass shooting invites public to her funeral because he has no other familyHusband of woman killed in mass shooting invites public to her funeral because 'he has no other family'
Phoebe Waller-Bridge lands gig hosting Saturday Night LivePhoebe Waller-Bridge lands gig hosting Saturday Night Live
Where in the World Is Ghislaine Maxwell?Where in the World Is Ghislaine Maxwell?
I am transgender: Guardian football writer Nicky Bandini comes out in Twitter video'I am transgender': Guardian football writer Nicky Bandini comes out in Twitter video
U.S. Intel Officials Eye Disinformation Campaign Targeting John Bolton’s FamilyU.S. Intel Officials Eye Disinformation Campaign Targeting John Bolton’s Family
Latest News
Demi Moore reveals she was raped aged 15Demi Moore reveals she was raped aged 15
Ride Like a Girl review – cinematic schmaltz swamps Michelle Paynes ride to the Melbourne CupRide Like a Girl review – cinematic schmaltz swamps Michelle Payne's ride to the Melbourne Cup
Richard Madeley Joins The Circle And We Already Cant Wait To See How He Gets OnRichard Madeley Joins The Circle And We Already Can't Wait To See How He Gets On
I Was A Stay-At-Home Mom For 22 Years. I Dont Need A Second Act To Feel FulfilledI Was A Stay-At-Home Mom For 22 Years. I Don't Need A 'Second Act' To Feel Fulfilled
Demi Moore Reveals She Was Raped At The Age Of 15 By Man Who Paid Her Mother $500Demi Moore Reveals She Was Raped At The Age Of 15 By Man Who Paid Her Mother $500
Donald Trump Posts Sarcastic Message Over Greta Thunbergs Impassioned Speech At UNDonald Trump Posts Sarcastic Message Over Greta Thunberg's Impassioned Speech At UN
Boris Johnson Declines To Rule Out Suspending Parliament AgainBoris Johnson Declines To Rule Out Suspending Parliament Again
Vaginismus Left Me Feeling Like A Failure – Because We Dont Teach Women About BodiesVaginismus Left Me Feeling Like A Failure – Because We Don't Teach Women About Bodies
Met chief outraged at Line of Duty over corruption portrayalMet chief 'outraged' at Line of Duty over corruption portrayal
Thousands rally against Indonesian bill to ban extra-marital sexThousands rally against Indonesian bill to ban extra-marital sex
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Boris-JohnsonBoris Johnson
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Theresa-MayTheresa May
Member of Parliament of the United Kingdom
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
Meet The Man Walking 400 Miles From Glasgow To London To Protest NHS PrivatisationMeet The Man Walking 400 Miles From Glasgow To London To Protest NHS Privatisation
The Satanic Sex Cult Leader Who Loved Animal Sacrifices, Orgies, and MurderThe Satanic Sex Cult Leader Who Loved Animal Sacrifices, Orgies, and Murder
I Found Love On Naked AttractionI Found Love On Naked Attraction
Gemma Collins, No One Needs To Sniff Your Fingers – These Are The Symptoms Of A Yeast InfectionGemma Collins, No One Needs To Sniff Your Fingers – These Are The Symptoms Of A Yeast Infection
Game Of Thrones Star Sophie Turner Meets Queer Eyes Jonathan Van Ness, Much Screaming EnsuesGame Of Thrones Star Sophie Turner Meets Queer Eye's Jonathan Van Ness, Much Screaming Ensues
Husband of woman killed in mass shooting invites public to her funeral because he has no other familyHusband of woman killed in mass shooting invites public to her funeral because 'he has no other family'
Phoebe Waller-Bridge lands gig hosting Saturday Night LivePhoebe Waller-Bridge lands gig hosting Saturday Night Live
Where in the World Is Ghislaine Maxwell?Where in the World Is Ghislaine Maxwell?
I am transgender: Guardian football writer Nicky Bandini comes out in Twitter video'I am transgender': Guardian football writer Nicky Bandini comes out in Twitter video
U.S. Intel Officials Eye Disinformation Campaign Targeting John Bolton’s FamilyU.S. Intel Officials Eye Disinformation Campaign Targeting John Bolton’s Family
Latest News
Demi Moore reveals she was raped aged 15Demi Moore reveals she was raped aged 15
Ride Like a Girl review – cinematic schmaltz swamps Michelle Paynes ride to the Melbourne CupRide Like a Girl review – cinematic schmaltz swamps Michelle Payne's ride to the Melbourne Cup
Richard Madeley Joins The Circle And We Already Cant Wait To See How He Gets OnRichard Madeley Joins The Circle And We Already Can't Wait To See How He Gets On
I Was A Stay-At-Home Mom For 22 Years. I Dont Need A Second Act To Feel FulfilledI Was A Stay-At-Home Mom For 22 Years. I Don't Need A 'Second Act' To Feel Fulfilled
Demi Moore Reveals She Was Raped At The Age Of 15 By Man Who Paid Her Mother $500Demi Moore Reveals She Was Raped At The Age Of 15 By Man Who Paid Her Mother $500
Donald Trump Posts Sarcastic Message Over Greta Thunbergs Impassioned Speech At UNDonald Trump Posts Sarcastic Message Over Greta Thunberg's Impassioned Speech At UN
Boris Johnson Declines To Rule Out Suspending Parliament AgainBoris Johnson Declines To Rule Out Suspending Parliament Again
Vaginismus Left Me Feeling Like A Failure – Because We Dont Teach Women About BodiesVaginismus Left Me Feeling Like A Failure – Because We Don't Teach Women About Bodies
Met chief outraged at Line of Duty over corruption portrayalMet chief 'outraged' at Line of Duty over corruption portrayal
Thousands rally against Indonesian bill to ban extra-marital sexThousands rally against Indonesian bill to ban extra-marital sex
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Boris-JohnsonBoris Johnson
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Theresa-MayTheresa May
Member of Parliament of the United Kingdom
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
The NHS Is Slowly Cancelling Free IVF – And This Is The Impact It's Having
9 Classic Books To Read Before The End Of The Holidays
Why Do We Call It 'French Kissing'?
Zimbabwe police beat protesters defying regime 'worse than Mugabe'
The Latest: Crews clear lane of road, buses begin to return
Beto O'Rourke: 'I will not in any scenario run for the United States Senate'
Dozens of US teens hospitalized with lung disease after vaping
Jimmy Kimmel and Trevor Noah offer thoughts, not jokes, about the weekend's mass shootings
Kentucky political feud bursts into public ahead of election
Moscow set for fresh protests after month of rallies
Epstein girlfriend Ghislaine Maxwell pictured at burger bar in first public sighting since financier’s death
Bill Maher Mocks Fox News’ Sean Hannity For Claiming He’s Causing a Recession
US murderer executed after choosing electric chair
Tom Homan shares exclusive video of attack on Washington ICE detention center
China flexes muscle near Hong Kong amid more weekend rallies
The powerful pro-Israel lobby and leading Democrats tear into Trump for pressuring Israel to bar Ilhan Omar and Rashida Tlaib from visiting
Kazakhstan court frees anti-Beijing activist
London teen lost at Malaysian resort died from ulcer bleed
India vows to ease Kashmir clampdown as clashes with Pakistan continue
Correction: Steve King-Abortion story
Israel intercepts Gaza rocket after weeks of calm
Captain called hero after bird strike disables Russian plane
China police exercises across from Hong Kong seen as threat
States team up against W.House immigrant benefits rule
Cathay Pacific CEO resigns after Beijing pressure
Ford Celebrates 25th Annual Woodward Dream Cruise With Mustang Alley
'Trump is exporting his bigotry': AOC blasts Israel for banning Omar and Tlaib
Claims: Migrant children molested in US-funded foster care
'Explosive' situation on migrant rescue boat in limbo off Italy
North Korea 'fires missiles off coast' and says talks with 'impudent' South are over
Jeffrey Epstein’s Body Claimed by His Brother
Arrests precede major demonstrations in Portland, Oregon
Bayern Munich agree season-long loan deal for Barcelona’s Philippe Coutinho
Huddersfield sack coach Jan Siewert after one win in seven months
Mauricio Pochettino puts faith in Spurs bravery to halt Manchester City | Dominic Fifield
Talking Horses: Soft-ground specialists to come to the fore | Tony Paley
Wales’s James Davies: ‘I take opportunities and change opinions’ | Paul Rees
Pep Guardiola says Mauricio Pochettino does not believe his praise is genuine
Steve Bruce understands volatile nature of life for manager at Newcastle
Pep v Poch: Spurs manager jokingly suggests one-on-one competition with Guardiola – video
Hot Package: Kerry Washington & Sterling K. Brown To Star In ‘Shadow Force’
Peter Fonda, celebrated actor known for Easy Rider, dies aged 79
O’Rourke Announces Support for Federal Confiscation of Assault-Style Weapons
Tennessee inmate executed in electric chair for killings
Portland’s Feared Far-Right Rally Hit by Multiple Setbacks
DNA leads to arrest in another Florida rape case from 1980s
UK judge to allow firm to try to seize $9 billion in Nigerian assets in gas dispute
Jones highlights need for England warm-ups after McConnochie injury
Kyle Sinckler: ‘You think Eddie is tough? My mum put me in my place’
Aritz Aduriz’s late acrobatics for Athletic Bilbao stun Barcelona
Warrington’s horrendous build-up to Wembley final continues at Wigan
Barcelona’s Philippe Coutinho set for season-long loan to Bayern Munich
Frank Lampard ready to play Tammy Abraham for Chelsea after racial abuse
Fresh blow to England as Olly Stone is ruled out for rest of series
Everton signed Moise Kean to play centre-forward, says Marco Silva
‘Krypton’ Canceled After Two Seasons, Spinoff ‘Lobo’ Not Moving Forward On Syfy
America Ferrera & Eva Longoria Among A-Listers To Pen Letter In Support Of Latino Community
Medical Examiner Rules Jeffrey Epstein's Death As Suicide
The Only Thing Jeffrey Epstein’s Broken Bone Proves
Japan's new emperor speaks of 'deep remorse' in 1st speech marking WWII
Hundreds defy restrictions, join protests in Kashmir
Natalie Crichlow: Barbados Police Say There Is 'Nothing To Indicate' An Intruder Killed Mum-Of-Three
Mexico does not want El Paso shooter executed
Woman survives plunging a mile after parachute fails to open
Parents claim body of Franco-Irish teen found dead in Malaysia
US lawmaker barred by Israel calls move 'chilling' insult
The Latest: US to revoke visas held by crew of Iranian ship
Trump says people have 'no choice' but to vote for him to save stock market
Ed Smart, father of kidnapping survivor Elizabeth Smart, comes out as gay
Jofra Archer off mark for England but threat of second Test draw looms
Athletic Bilbao v Barcelona: La Liga opener – live!
Jofra Archer quickly becomes England’s go-to bowler for all occasions | Andy Bull
Steve Bruce: ‘It would settle everybody if we got a result at Norwich’
Journeyman Andy Lonergan could get big chance in Liverpool’s goal
Frank Lampard 'disgusted' by racist abuse directed at Tammy Abraham – video
Zinedine Zidane ready to rely on ‘important’ Gareth Bale for Real Madrid
Greenland is NOT for sale! Danes ridicule Donald Trump
James Bond Aston Martin DB5 sold at auction for £5.2m
Joe Jonas Gets Cake And Concert Kiss From Sophie Turner For 30th Birthday
Trump accuses media of crashing the economy to ruin his presidency amid recession concerns
ICE Confines Some Detainees With Mental Illness in Solitary for Months
Ashes 2019: England v Australia second Test, day three abandoned after rain – as it happened
Jay-Z's deal with NFL branded 'disgusting' by Colin Kaepernick's girlfriend
The Fiver | Losing the absolute run of oneself
Netflix Orders Elvis Animated Action Comedy Series ‘Agent King’ (EXCLUSIVE)
James Bond's 1965 Aston Martin DB5 auctioned for $6.4 million
Art Spiegelman's Marvel essay 'refused publication for Orange Skull Trump dig'
Mother Who Drowned IVF Twins In 'Anger' At Estranged Husband Is Jailed
Exclusive: Leaked Doc Reveals Civil Servants Told To Report 'Unhelpful Narratives' On Brexit To No.10
Butcher Pawel Relowicz Jailed For Sex Acts Including Burglary And Voyeurism
Since Having Children I Go 'Out Out' More Than Ever
Family seeks more answers to London teen's death in Malaysia
17 missing in SW China landslide
Germany expects No Deal and will not renegotiate, says leaked briefing
The Latest: Trump defends Israel move to bar 2 congresswomen
Philadelphia mayor calls for gun control action after officers injured in standoff
For inmates like Epstein, suicide watch is meant to be short
Shiite cleric returns to Nigeria after India medical row
S.Africa announces visa waivers to boost tourism
Trump Mocks ‘Serious Weight Problem’ of Supporter at His Rally
Day off cancelled and individual meetings – how Hasenhüttl has prepared for Liverpool
Chelsea win high court injunctions against 11 ticket touts
Sheffield United’s Carla Ward: ‘Not acting the clown was tough early on’
The Obamas' first film: will American Factory be the biggest documentary of 2019?
Vacuums, Plants And All The Other Things We Never Thought We'd Care About In Our Late 20s
There's A High Chance You've Unwittingly Been Part Of A Facial Recognition Trial
1981 Chevrolet Camaro Z28 Pro Touring Boasts Show Quality
John Oliver examines U.S. prison labor, finds real-life Shawshank Redemption villains
Ashes 2019: England v Australia second Test, day three rain delay – live
Premier League countdown: Guardiola wary of 'second best team in Europe' Spurs - live!
Ruaridh McConnochie a doubt to make England debut against Wales
Arsenal land Fiorentina in Women's Champions League draw
Russell Crowe, Kalvin Phillips’ gran and hope – Leeds documentary has it all (apart from Bielsa)
Return of the Jedi: Ewan McGregor to reprise role as Obi-Wan Kenobi
Fugitive On Child Sex Charges Evades Police For 3 Years In Solar-Powered Bunker
Normani's Motivation Music Video: Did You Spot All The 2000s References?
Nora Quoirin's Family Insist There Are 'Dark Areas' And More Questions About Her Mysterious Death
Endometriosis Sufferers Are Crying Out For More Research – And While We Wait, Lives Are Being Put On Hold
Prince George And Princess Charlotte 'Lean On Each Other' – I Totally Get That Sibling Bond
Social media must not rob us of the right to change our minds | Peter Ormerod
Hong Kong protesters face crucial weekend test after airport setback
El Paso mayor says Trump used derisive term in meeting
Planet 10 times Earth's mass may have smacked Jupiter long ago
Cathay CEO resigns amid Hong Kong protest blowback as more rallies planned
Israel Will Allow U.S. Lawmaker Tlaib to Make Humanitarian Visit
Cuban government imposes price controls as it seeks to keep lid on inflation
Tears and shouting as Australia dilutes Pacific climate warning
Is AJ Tracey ushering in a UK garage revival?
Women's Champions League draw – live!
Premier League countdown: Man City v Spurs buildup, Liverpool goalkeeper concern and more - live!
‘It’s crazy’: Adrián a doubt for Liverpool after being injured by celebrating fan
Chess: Magnus Carlsen admits to confidence crisis after shock losing run
La Liga's big clubs have different outlooks after summer of spending
Ole Gunnar Solskjaer expects Alexis Sánchez to play ‘a lot of games’ once fit
'I am transgender': Guardian football writer Nicky Bandini comes out in Twitter video
Nick Kyrgios calls umpire 'a tool' and smashes two rackets during Khachanov defeat – video
Israel will allow Democrat Rashida Tlaib to visit West Bank for 'humanitarian' trip after barring official visit
Is Sapiosexuality A Real Thing: Doesn't Intelligence Matter To Everyone When Dating?
Criticism Is The Toxic Habit That Can Slowly Ruin Your Relationship
Epilepsy Patients Are Turning To Private Clinics For Medical Cannabis
Berkshire 'Murder': Police Officer Andrew Harper Killed While Attending Burglary
Jessie J Appearing At James 'Arg' Argent's Marbella Gig Is The Story That Has (Almost) Everything
Man Guilty Of Murdering Ashley Ellerin The Night She Was Due To Meet Ashton Kutcher For A Date
Stormzy Says Brampton Manor Is Where He's Sending His Kids (When He Has Some)
Holly Willoughby Reunites With Dec Donnelley As They Holiday With Phillip Schofield
The Latest: Philly police: Gunman had AR-15, handgun
Israel bans Omar and Tlaib after Trump says 'it would show great weakness' to let them in
'A heavy lift': Religious black voters weigh Buttigieg's bid
Nigerian cleric leaves India after medical care row: supporters
Mother arrested in death of 2-year-old Wichita boy
Tracks of the week reviewed: Normani, Katy Perry, Lana Del Rey
The Hold Steady: Thrashing Thru the Passion review – chancers and chasers in fist-punching glory
Tales of the Turntable review – a musical magical history tour
Blanck Mass: Animated Violence Mild review – grief, rage and transcendent electronica
Ashes 2019: England v Australia second Test, day three – live
I'm Nicky Bandini – and I'm still a sports writer
Premier League countdown: Man City v Spurs buildup, team news and more - live!
Grasski World Championships – in pictures
'I felt like a spy infiltrating the IRA' – the hurling player who exposed his sport
Raccoon Caught Inside High School Vending Machine, Lurking Among Snacks
The Anniversary Of Peterloo Is A Timely Reminder That Attempts To Suppress Voters Must Be Resisted
Miley Cyrus Alludes To Liam Hemsworth Split In New Break-Up Song Slide Away
Lib Dem Accused Of 'Sexist Sour Grapes' After Calling Police Commissioner 'Barbie Doll'
I Didn't Buy Any Clothes For A Year. Here's How It Changed Me
Strictly Come Dancing's Jamie Laing Revealed As Having Previous Dance Experience
This Economic Signal Has Predicted Every US Recession For 50 Years – This Is What It's Saying Now
Ghislaine Maxwell: The missing woman who may hold the key to resolving Epstein's crimes
North Korea fires missiles, derides South Korea's Moon as 'impudent'
China says pig herd shrinks by 32% in July amid swine fever outbreak
Israel Bars Two U.S. Muslim Lawmakers After Trump Calls for Move
Širom: A Universe That Roasts Blossoms for a Horse review | John Lewis's contemporary album of the month
Friendly Fires: Inflorescent review – deliciously cheesy 80s disco vibes
The Boss on film: a brief history of Bruce Springsteen on screen
‘It’s a love story really’: Mick Fleetwood and Stevie Nicks on wooing Neil Finn
Singer in the 1975 Matt Healy defies UAE's anti-gay law by kissing man at concert
David Bowie's festival bandstand gets Grade II listing
Sasha DiGiulian: 'There's an assumption the male takes the lead in climbing'
Is Emilia Clarke about to fall in love with a ghost in Last Christmas?
Dora and the Lost City of Gold review – live-action romp for the teen explorer
Donald Trump Floated The Idea Of Buying Greenland. Yes, The Entire Country
The O.C. Reunion Isn't Happening Any Time Soon, Says Boss Josh
Peter Duncan: New Details Emerge Of 'Devoted Father' Stabbed To Death In Newcastle
UK Weather Forecast: An Entire Month's Worth Of Rain Is Going To Soak You Today
This Is What It's Really Like To Work In An STI Clinic
How Do You Go Out When You’re A Parent? (The Answer Is Massively)
Instagram to let US users report false content
Tim Worner resigns as Seven West Media CEO
John Jarratt drops defamation action against Daily Telegraph
Empire strikes back: News Corp turns blowtorch on former Australian reporter | The Weekly Beast
Mexico pushes U.S. to designate El Paso shooting an act of terrorism
Lawsuit challenges California's assault weapons ban
The Latest: HK police: not aware of any China military plans
Harry and Meghan go on first holiday as family of three to celebrate Duchess's birthday
Dave Grohl: 'I never imagined myself to be Freddie Mercury'
Stephen Colbert endorses placing Trump Tower on Obama Avenue, explains how liberals troll
'I'm an expressionist nihilist at heart': the dark allure of Tom Burke
5 Cute Animals To End The Week: Clive The Cocker And Jeffree The Cat Are The Nation's Pet Heroes
The 'Inverted Yield Curve' Explained In A Way That Won't Make Your Head Hurt
5 Truths About Children's Shoes You Only Know If You're A Parent
China says it won't 'sit by' on Hong Kong, Trump expresses concern
Close