Close
Date TimeAugust 10, 2019
VoiceLady Gaga has vowed to fight a potential lawsuit after being accused of copying her hit Shallow. 
Lady Gaga Vows To Fight Potential Lawsuit After Being Accused Of Copying A Star Is Born Hit Shallow
Unknown singer Steve Ronsen has threatened the hitmaker with legal action after claiming she stole the hook for her track from the three-note melody in his 2012 song, Almost. 
According to US site Page Six, Ronsen is requesting “millions and millions” from Gaga, with his lawyer telling the website that a musicologist and professor had “determined that there are significant tempo, melodic, rhythmic and harmonic similarities between the two hooks of the songs at issue”.They claim the three notes — G, A, B — correspond to the hook of Shallow, which was the stand-out song on the soundtrack to last year’s box office smash A Star Is Born, in which Gaga appeared alongside Bradley Cooper. 
Gaga’s team has branded the lawsuit as a “brazen shakedown”, arguing that the three-note melody is extremely common and has featured in multiple recordings dating back decades, including Kansas’ 1978 track Dust In The Wind.
Gaga’s attorney Orin Snyder said: “Mr. Ronsen and his lawyer are trying to make easy money off the back of a successful artist. It is shameful and wrong.
“I applaud Lady Gaga for having the courage and integrity to stand up on behalf of successful artists who find themselves on the receiving end of such [claims].
“Should Mr. Shirian proceed with this case, Lady Gaga will fight it vigorously and will prevail.”Ronsen’s track, Almost, had less than 300 streams on Soundcloud when the lawsuit threat was first reported. 
After being featured on the soundtrack for A Star Is Born, Shallow went on to reach number one across the globe, including the UK where is has been certified with Platinum status. 
The song also won an Oscar, a Golden Globe and two Grammys.
Listen to Shallow below...READ MORE... Lady Gaga Reminds Fans Of The Importance Of Pronouns During Pride-Themed Speech Katy Perry's Dark Horse Improperly Copied Christian Rap Song, Jury Rules Katy Perry And Her Collaborators Ordered To Pay £2.3m In Dark Horse Copyright Trial Damages

Related Stories
Meet The Man Walking 400 Miles From Glasgow To London To Protest NHS PrivatisationMeet The Man Walking 400 Miles From Glasgow To London To Protest NHS Privatisation
Gemma Collins, No One Needs To Sniff Your Fingers – These Are The Symptoms Of A Yeast InfectionGemma Collins, No One Needs To Sniff Your Fingers – These Are The Symptoms Of A Yeast Infection
I Found Love On Naked AttractionI Found Love On Naked Attraction
Naked Attraction: 10 X-Rated Things You Didn’t Know About Channel 4’s Nude Dating ShowNaked Attraction: 10 X-Rated Things You Didn’t Know About Channel 4’s Nude Dating Show
Disney, king of the box office, now primed to do battle with NetflixDisney, king of the box office, now primed to do battle with Netflix
El Paso Shooting: Multiple Deaths Reported In Texas Walmart IncidentEl Paso Shooting: Multiple Deaths Reported In Texas Walmart Incident
ABCs Sabra Lane breaks down on air over child abandoned by surrogate parentsABC's Sabra Lane breaks down on air over child abandoned by surrogate parents
Macron tells Johnson Brexit backstop is indispensableMacron tells Johnson Brexit backstop is indispensable
Normanis Motivation Music Video: Did You Spot All The 2000s References?Normani's Motivation Music Video: Did You Spot All The 2000s References?
Kevin Hart In Car Accident As Vehicle Falls Down Embankment Leaving Him With Major InjuriesKevin Hart In Car Accident As Vehicle Falls Down Embankment Leaving Him With 'Major Injuries'
Latest News
Prince Harry Sends Support To ‘Legend’ Gareth Thomas After He Is Forced To Go Public With His HIV StatusPrince Harry Sends Support To ‘Legend’ Gareth Thomas After He Is Forced To Go Public With His HIV Status
Chuka Umunna Denies Joining Lib Dems Out Of Crude Self InterestChuka Umunna Denies Joining Lib Dems Out Of 'Crude Self Interest'
Banksy Work Depicting MPs As Chimpanzees To Go Under The HammerBanksy Work Depicting MPs As Chimpanzees To Go Under The Hammer
I plan on winning: At 87, Joe Arpaio is running for sheriff again'I plan on winning': At 87, Joe Arpaio is running for sheriff again
Americas Next Iran Nightmare: Could Tehran Build a Super Submarine Fleet?America's Next Iran Nightmare: Could Tehran Build a Super Submarine Fleet?
Hong Kong police deny street brawl double standardsHong Kong police deny street brawl 'double standards'
Trevor Noah and Stephen Colbert explain Boris Johnsons Brexit fiasco, find some silver liningsTrevor Noah and Stephen Colbert explain Boris Johnson's Brexit fiasco, find some silver linings
Rugby World Cup 2019: Wales team guideRugby World Cup 2019: Wales team guide
The Guardian women’s cricketer of the year 2019: Katie Levick | Raf NicholsonThe Guardian women’s cricketer of the year 2019: Katie Levick | Raf Nicholson
Scotland strive to avoid World Cup slip-ups with shampoo-soaked ballsScotland strive to avoid World Cup slip-ups with shampoo-soaked balls
Celebrities
Khloe-KardashianKhloé Kardashian
American media personality
Kylie-JennerKylie Jenner
American television personality
Ellen-DeGeneresEllen DeGeneres
American comedian
Selena-GomezSelena Gomez
American singer
Jay_ZJay-Z
American rapper
Taylor-SwiftTaylor Swift
American singer
Stephen-ColbertStephen Colbert
American comedian
Miley-CyrusMiley Cyrus
American singer-songwriter
Kim-KardashianKim Kardashian
American media personality
Ariana-GrandeAriana Grande
American singer
BeyoncéBeyoncé
American singer-songwriter
Oprah-WinfreyOprah Winfrey
American executive
Lady-GagaLady Gaga
American singer-songwriter
Justin-BieberJustin Bieber
Canadian singer-songwriter
Jennifer-LopezJennifer Lopez
American singer
Jimmy-KimmelJimmy Kimmel
American television host
MadonnaMadonna
American singer-songwriter
Related Stories
Meet The Man Walking 400 Miles From Glasgow To London To Protest NHS PrivatisationMeet The Man Walking 400 Miles From Glasgow To London To Protest NHS Privatisation
Gemma Collins, No One Needs To Sniff Your Fingers – These Are The Symptoms Of A Yeast InfectionGemma Collins, No One Needs To Sniff Your Fingers – These Are The Symptoms Of A Yeast Infection
I Found Love On Naked AttractionI Found Love On Naked Attraction
Naked Attraction: 10 X-Rated Things You Didn’t Know About Channel 4’s Nude Dating ShowNaked Attraction: 10 X-Rated Things You Didn’t Know About Channel 4’s Nude Dating Show
Disney, king of the box office, now primed to do battle with NetflixDisney, king of the box office, now primed to do battle with Netflix
El Paso Shooting: Multiple Deaths Reported In Texas Walmart IncidentEl Paso Shooting: Multiple Deaths Reported In Texas Walmart Incident
ABCs Sabra Lane breaks down on air over child abandoned by surrogate parentsABC's Sabra Lane breaks down on air over child abandoned by surrogate parents
Macron tells Johnson Brexit backstop is indispensableMacron tells Johnson Brexit backstop is indispensable
Normanis Motivation Music Video: Did You Spot All The 2000s References?Normani's Motivation Music Video: Did You Spot All The 2000s References?
Kevin Hart In Car Accident As Vehicle Falls Down Embankment Leaving Him With Major InjuriesKevin Hart In Car Accident As Vehicle Falls Down Embankment Leaving Him With 'Major Injuries'
Latest News
Prince Harry Sends Support To ‘Legend’ Gareth Thomas After He Is Forced To Go Public With His HIV StatusPrince Harry Sends Support To ‘Legend’ Gareth Thomas After He Is Forced To Go Public With His HIV Status
Chuka Umunna Denies Joining Lib Dems Out Of Crude Self InterestChuka Umunna Denies Joining Lib Dems Out Of 'Crude Self Interest'
Banksy Work Depicting MPs As Chimpanzees To Go Under The HammerBanksy Work Depicting MPs As Chimpanzees To Go Under The Hammer
I plan on winning: At 87, Joe Arpaio is running for sheriff again'I plan on winning': At 87, Joe Arpaio is running for sheriff again
Americas Next Iran Nightmare: Could Tehran Build a Super Submarine Fleet?America's Next Iran Nightmare: Could Tehran Build a Super Submarine Fleet?
Hong Kong police deny street brawl double standardsHong Kong police deny street brawl 'double standards'
Trevor Noah and Stephen Colbert explain Boris Johnsons Brexit fiasco, find some silver liningsTrevor Noah and Stephen Colbert explain Boris Johnson's Brexit fiasco, find some silver linings
Rugby World Cup 2019: Wales team guideRugby World Cup 2019: Wales team guide
The Guardian women’s cricketer of the year 2019: Katie Levick | Raf NicholsonThe Guardian women’s cricketer of the year 2019: Katie Levick | Raf Nicholson
Scotland strive to avoid World Cup slip-ups with shampoo-soaked ballsScotland strive to avoid World Cup slip-ups with shampoo-soaked balls
Celebrities
Khloe-KardashianKhloé Kardashian
American media personality
Kylie-JennerKylie Jenner
American television personality
Ellen-DeGeneresEllen DeGeneres
American comedian
Selena-GomezSelena Gomez
American singer
Jay_ZJay-Z
American rapper
Taylor-SwiftTaylor Swift
American singer
Stephen-ColbertStephen Colbert
American comedian
Miley-CyrusMiley Cyrus
American singer-songwriter
Kim-KardashianKim Kardashian
American media personality
Ariana-GrandeAriana Grande
American singer
BeyoncéBeyoncé
American singer-songwriter
Oprah-WinfreyOprah Winfrey
American executive
Lady-GagaLady Gaga
American singer-songwriter
Justin-BieberJustin Bieber
Canadian singer-songwriter
Jennifer-LopezJennifer Lopez
American singer
Jimmy-KimmelJimmy Kimmel
American television host
MadonnaMadonna
American singer-songwriter
Father of black man killed by US police in 2014 demands answers
Immigrants lock doors, rally around children of detained
Police identify armed man arrested at Missouri Walmart
Manhunt for escaped Tennessee inmate intensifies as state issues rare Blue Alert
Iran says any external military presence in Gulf 'source of insecurity'
West Ham United v Manchester City: Premier League – live!
Wallabies v All Blacks: Bledisloe Cup - Rugby Championship 2019 – live!
Leeds United v Nottingham Forest: Championship – live!
The joy (and the jokes) of the Premier League weekend
The Fiver | There's no sign of the Premier League succumbing to its excesses. No siree!
'Truly Outrageous' Gun And Machete Attack Marks Second Night Of Violence In Birmingham
Kid Rock Blasted For Lewd And 'Sexist' Taylor Swift Twitter Rant
Alan Dershowitz: Unsealed Email and Manuscript Show Epstein Accuser Lied About Sex With Me
Kashmir curfew partially eased for prayers amid lockdown
Puerto Rico's new governor says she intends to remain in office
Straight Pride parade ‘dog whistling to white supremacy’ says gay son of organiser
Create beef and never apologise: my Premier League social media guidelines | Marina Hyde
Liverpool sweat on Alisson calf injury with goalkeeper set to miss Super Cup
Serena Williams bests Naomi Osaka in Rogers Cup rematch of US Open final
Australia’s cupboard is full of fast bowlers, says Mitchell Starc
Streaming: in praise of Pantaflix…
The Weather Is Rubbish And Lots Of Things Are Cancelled – Here's The Latest
This Is What Activism Does To Your Body
We're Due A 'Bumper Wasp Season' – Here's Why That Might Be A Good Thing
The Protests That Have Rocked Moscow For Weeks – Explained For Brits
Prince Andrew Groped Young Woman At Epstein Apartment, Court Documents Allege
The Latest: Police detail call about Crusius owning gun
‘Cruelty knows no bounds’: Trump condemned after 680 detained in largest ICE raids of his presidency
The Queens Of Drag SOS Discuss The Important Message We Can All Learn From The Show
We Need To Talk About The Pain Of Losing A Pet – And How To Process The Loss
Your $2,000 beater car can have a head-up display like a $75,000 luxury car for only $40
Manhunt after Israeli off-duty soldier killed in West Bank
Rare baby panda twins born at Belgian zoo
Jeffrey Epstein Sent Girl to Governor and Senator for Sex, She Testified
Biden criticized after saying: 'Poor kids are as bright as white kids'
Hundreds rally in Kentucky for gun control legislation
Explosion at interracial couple's home treated as hate crime after swastika painted on garage
Key airport closed as Indian state faces repeat flood crisis
Allegations of labor abuses dogged Mississippi plant years before immigration raids
Here's the data on white supremacist terrorism the Trump administration has been 'unable or unwilling' to give to Congress
Canada praises 'grit' of Canadians detained in China
Fox News Guest: Cory Booker’s ‘Pretending He’s Like Some Homie From the Hood’
Danny Trejo rescues boy trapped in overturned car after crash
3D printer gun plans seller pleads guilty to sex with minor
Hong Kong protesters produce 'laser show' over arrest of demonstrator shining pointer at police
China issues 'red alert' as super typhoon approaches mainland
Massive Collection of Classic Cars Up For Auction In MN
Virginia transgender bathroom case: Judge favors ex-student
Britain will spend 'whatever it takes' on no deal: Gove
EPA won't approve warning labels for Roundup chemical
Damascus rejects Turkey-US plan, Kurds give guarded welcome
Talking Horses: Hayley Turner has big chance of landing Shergar prize | Chris Cook
Border Patrol Agents Shot at from Mexican Side of Rio Grande
NRA boss asked for luxury mansion to protect his safety after Parkland shooting
Roadmap for India's troubled Kashmir under its new status
Biden in Iowa Says ‘Poor Kids’ Are Just as Smart as ‘White Kids’
Scandal-ridden NRA head LaPierre digs in against gun control
Downturn to hit Hong Kong like a 'tsunami', as China slaps warning on Cathay
Fox News and Its Advertisers Silent After Tucker Carlson Calls White Supremacy a ‘Hoax’
British astrophysicist died 'instantly from fall' on Greek island
3 killed when small plane crashes in PA backyard
Montana judge orders neo-Nazi website publisher to pay $14M
Arizona prosecutor who questioned Kavanaugh accuser promoted
Police: 2 men arrested after road rage shooting at school
Liverpool brush aside Norwich to make an early statement of intent
England’s experimental lineup looks to hit ground running against Wales
Wales ‘in a good place’ says Warren Gatland with No 1 spot in sight
Amnesty International criticises sanctioning of Joshua v Ruiz Jr in Saudi Arabia
Ash Handley on hand as rampant Leeds run rings round Catalans
Donald Trump: 'I'd love to see Colin Kaepernick come in, if he's good enough'
Manchester City expect Leroy Sané to be out for six months with knee injury
Spurs ‘vulnerable’ to bids for players from Europe, says Mauricio Pochettino
Frank Lampard denies David Luiz forced Arsenal move with strike threat
Marco Silva says Everton’s failure to land central defender is a risk
Donald Trump Attacks The Entertainment Industry, Calls 'Liberal' Hollywood 'Racist'
Twitter Unlocks McConnell Campaign Account after GOP Groups Pull Ads
Michael Brown's father seeks new investigation into killing
Tucker Carlson Responds to Critics After Calling White Supremacy a Hoax: ‘Calm Down’
Documents: Epstein ducked sex abuse questions in deposition
Fukushima nuclear plant out of space for radioactive water
Verdict set for Cambodians who worked for US-funded radio
Liverpool v Norwich: Premier League – live!
Amnesty International criticises sanctioning of Joshua v Ruiz Jr II in Saudi Arabia
Andy Murray confirms singles comeback next week in Cincinnati
Former England rugby union player Christian Wade scores on first NFL touch
Repeat after me: you don't need to get fit to get married
Power Cut Causes Transport Chaos Across The UK
Princess Charlotte Sticks Her Tongue Out at Crowd
Anne Hathaway’s baby bump makes red carpet debut in bold cutout dress
Trump gives thumbs up in photo with El Paso orphan
Biden lashes out at reporter who suggested he misquoted Trump on Charlottesville
Timeline of events in shooting of Michael Brown in Ferguson
Indians plant 220 million trees in single day
U.S. calls China 'thuggish regime' for singling out U.S. diplomat in Hong Kong
Zimbabwe's Mnangagwa fires minister for 'inappropriate behavior' after corruption charge
Armed Trump supporter detained with gun and knife outside immigrant centre in El Paso
What Does 'I Purple You' Mean? BTS Fans Celebrate 1,000 Days of Kim Taehyung's Phrase of Love
BTS member V releases 'Winter Bear' music video
Flight attendant from Waukesha arrested after passenger alerts United: She 'appears to be quite drunk'; Air Wisconsin was operating flight
VAR VAR voom! The Premier League gets set for video referees
David Berman obituary
Smith and Stokes emerge into light of redemption as comeback trails entwine | Isa Guha
Arsenal withdraw Özil and Kolasinac due to ‘further security incidents’
VAR VAR voom! The Premier League gets set for video referees | Paul MacInnes
Chess: Try your skill on the Levitt test. Michael Adams took five minutes
Mark Prince: ‘Kiyan represents all those kids who are buried too early’
Wilfried Zaha could play against Everton despite transfer snub, says Hodgson
Tottenham v Aston Villa: match preview
Trump is now mad at movies: 'Hollywood is racist'
Donald Trump launches attack on 'racist' Hollywood
Notorious review – Hitchcock's deliciously entertaining story of espionage
Below review – Fight Club meets Australian immigration detention in jumbled black comedy
Fast and Furious: Hobbs & Shaw review – silly spin-off
Eight People Arrested In Search For 15-Year-Old Vietnamese Tourist Missing In York
Game Of Thrones' Natalia Tena 'Ranted For An Hour' After Disappointing Finale
Home Births No More Risky Than Hospital Births, Says Major New Study
This Is The Most Expensive Place To Be Cremated In The UK (And The Cheapest)
Amazon's new Lord of the Rings 'cannot use much of Tolkien's plot'
Kylie Jenner celebrates birthday on £1m-a-week superyacht
Jade Goody: a scorned celebrity who held a mirror up to bitter Britain
Bull, meet China shop: Trump's foreign policy in Asia is disastrous
Tucker Carlson: Advertisers abandon Fox News host after he says 'white supremacy is a hoax'
Illinois Cop Shot Unarmed Black 12-Year-old in Bed During Botched Raid: Lawsuit
McConnell says won't recall US Senate to pass new gun laws after shootings
Migrant workers in Qatar hold rare strikes over conditions as 2022 World Cup looms
Hong Kongers harness traffic cones, kitchenware to battle tear gas
Fake anti-Brexit banknotes added to British Museum collection
Roger Kelly obituary
Hirst's bronze giants run riot while Saatchi goes raving – the week in art
Smith and Stokes emerge into light of redemption after dark side of obsession | Isa Guha
Eddie Jones’s England picture remains unclear as World Cup looms | Robert Kitson
English football gets David Luiz wrong. He is a fine Arsenal signing | Barney Ronay
England replace Moeen Ali with Jack Leach for second Ashes Test
‘That’s not normal in a boy his age’ – the journey that made Rodri the perfect Guardiola player | Sid Lowe
Ole Gunnar Solskjær ‘relieved’ window closed as Manchester United look ahead
The players who have hit hat-tricks on Premier League opening weekends
West Ham v Manchester City: match preview
Burnley v Southampton: match preview
Bournemouth v Sheffield United: match preview
Julián Castro unveils gun control plan to 'disarm hate' and address domestic terrorism
Sexpionage! Why film-makers can't resist a honeytrap
My selfish mother-in-law treats our home like a hotel
Good luck finding true love with no drama - fulfilment takes work | Oliver Burkeman
My friend has male pornographic photos all over his flat
You are never too old to disappoint your parents | Coco Khan
Cocktail of the week: Manette Bar’s Dedalus | The Good Mixer
The best jumpsuits for all ages – in pictures
Donald Trump Slammed For Grinning In Photo With Baby Orphaned In El Paso Shooting
Jailed Lostprophets Frontman Ian Watkins Guilty Of Phone Possession
WPP shares bounce back as company beats City forecasts
I’m a journalist. Monsanto built a step-by-step strategy to destroy my reputation | Carey Gillam
How Friends taught the world to speak English – from Jürgen Klopp to Korean pop megastars
Curfew eased partially in Kashmir for Friday prayers
Trump administration re-authorizes 'cyanide bombs' to kill wildlife
Dayton shooting: Man shields girlfriend from attack as Ohio gunman opens fire in unseen footage
Husband, wife, teen killed after plane crashes behind home
Economic downturn to hit Hong Kong like a 'tsunami', city's leader warns
200 hit by New Zealand massacre take part in hajj pilgrimage
Trump picks new acting national intelligence director
Israel navy seeks to raise profile with multi-national drill
Man fights off grizzly bear by stabbing it in neck with pocket knife as it savaged him
Black women deserve better from Kamala Harris. Don't take our vote for granted
Yorkshire's steely antidote to London-centric art – Platform 2019 review
‘Astounding’ 19th-century print portfolio goes under the hammer
Ai Weiwei has ‘no trust’ UK can intervene in Hong Kong crisis
Marika Hackman: Any Human Friend review – selfishness, sex and passion
Tracks of the week reviewed: Haim, Ariana Grande, Iggy Pop
‘I’ve been through some painful experiences’ – Sheryl Crow on #MeToo and Michael Jackson
Ludovico Einaudi review – as cliched and shameless as a Simon Cowell No 1
Mabel: High Expectations review – confident pop lacks personality | Alexis Petridis's album of the week
Willi Heinz handed vice-captain role on England debut against Wales
W Series’ first champion marks key step for women in motor racing | Giles Richards
New world order? Welcome to Premier League's new era of excellence | Barney Ronay
Premier League 2019‑20 preview No 20: Wolves
Shane Warne named as coach of Lord’s Hundred team
Sports quiz of the week: Premier League, Eden Hazard and sore feet
Talking Horses: Mahmood al-Zarooni seeks a pardon over steroids ban
Chess: Teenagers impress as Michael Adams clinches seventh British title
Manchester United needed a rebuild this summer but failed to act once again | Daniel Harris
Pair face jail over leaked Emiliano Sala mortuary images
Jimmy Kimmel, Seth Meyers, James Corden count the ways Trump made his El Paso, Dayton visits about Trump
Biden says 'poor kids' are just as bright as 'white kids'
How to wear lace | Kenya Hunt
From tinted tresses to name necklaces: this week’s fashion trends
Good to go: Anna Jones' recipes to take on a trip | The Modern Cook
Signs of the times: horoscopes rise again online
How Two Teenage Fugitives Wanted For Murder Led Canadian Police On A 2,000 Mile Manhunt
Farewell, telepathic octopus! Netflix has killed off The OA, and it’s a travesty
Kashmir's streets silent as people's despair and rage grow
Scores from Mexico, Guatemala detained in Mississippi raids
Joe Biden’s Latest Slip-Up: Telling Iowa Voters ‘Poor Kids Are Just as Bright’ as ‘White Kids’
Records: Festival gunman had passport, survival guide in car
Buy a classic Guardian photograph: Margate beach, 1972
Trippie Redd: ! review – compelling but contradictory emo-rap
Premier League kick-off: team news, previews and more – live!
Willi Heinz handed vice captain role on England debut against Wales
Simone Biles 2.0: Somehow, someway, there's nowhere to go but up
Premier League 2019‑20 preview No 19: West Ham
Serena Williams faces Naomi Osaka for first time since the US Open
Manchester United needed a rebuild this summer but failed to act once again
Close