Close
Date TimeJuly 29, 2019
VoiceA Los Angeles jury has found that the 2013 hit infringed on a previous work.
Katy Perry’s ‘Dark Horse’ Handed Defeat in Trial
Katy Perry’s 2013 hit “Dark Horse” infringed on the song “Joyful Noise” by Christian rap artist Marcus Gray, aka Flame, a Los Angeles jury found on July 29. The decision concerning the track’s underlying beat followed a week-long trial in Los Angeles civil court which included an appearance by Perry herself, who testified for 35 minutes.
In her testimony, Perry said that co-writers and producers Dr. Luke (Lukas Gottwald) and Cirkut (Henry Walter) brought her the song’s instrumental track, which suggests the two could have included elements of “Joyful Noise” in the song without Perry’s knowledge.
Another cowriter of “Joyful Noise,” Emmanuel Lambert Jr., whose stage name is Da Truth, said the song had been a significant hit in the Christian music genre and is widely available on streaming services, thus it would have been easy for the “Dark Horse” writers to have heard it.
During Perry’s testimony, her attorneys attempted to play audio of “Dark Horse” but were thwarted by technical difficulties. Showing her characteristic sass, Perry offered to perform the song live, to laughter from the people assembled in the courtroom.
Perry’s attorneys also argued that the musical phrase is too common and brief to be protected by copyright, but the nine-person jury disagreed, handing the victory over to the plaintiffs. (Perry, who is on vacation, was not in the courtroom for the verdict.) Penalty will be decided determining the dollar figure owed to “Joyful Noise” stakeholders.

Related Stories
One to watch: ScarypoolpartyOne to watch: Scarypoolparty
Fireworks expected at MCG as Katy Perry factor gives Women’s World T20 a boost | Adam CollinsFireworks expected at MCG as Katy Perry factor gives Women’s World T20 a boost | Adam Collins
Love the game: Drake and Taylor Swifts decade in pop dominanceLove the game: Drake and Taylor Swift's decade in pop dominance
Latest News
After GOP Rep. Matt Gaetz brings up Hunter Bidens substance abuse, hes reminded of his own DUIAfter GOP Rep. Matt Gaetz brings up Hunter Biden's substance abuse, he's reminded of his own DUI
Meghan McCain warns Nikki Haley will be haunted by her defense of Confederate flag — as her father wasMeghan McCain warns Nikki Haley will be 'haunted' by her defense of Confederate flag — as her father was
Black Christmas review – woke slasher remake is an unholy, unscary messBlack Christmas review – woke slasher remake is an unholy, unscary mess
Weinstein Company creditors join settlement including $25m for accusersWeinstein Company creditors join settlement including $25m for accusers
Are Exit Polls Reliable For The General Election?Are Exit Polls Reliable For The General Election?
Mason Greenwood double leads Manchester United past AZ AlkmaarMason Greenwood double leads Manchester United past AZ Alkmaar
Light lies the crown before Michael van Gerwen’s visit to the Palace | Jonathan LiewLight lies the crown before Michael van Gerwen’s visit to the Palace | Jonathan Liew
Alfredo Morelos takes Rangers through despite late Young Boys equaliserAlfredo Morelos takes Rangers through despite late Young Boys equaliser
Diogo Jota comes off bench to grab rapid hat-trick as Wolves rout BesiktasDiogo Jota comes off bench to grab rapid hat-trick as Wolves rout Besiktas
Nigel Pearson plots Watford escape after ‘surprising’ top-flight returnNigel Pearson plots Watford escape after ‘surprising’ top-flight return
Celebrities
Justin-BieberJustin Bieber
Canadian singer-songwriter
Ariana-GrandeAriana Grande
American singer
Jay_ZJay-Z
American rapper
Taylor-SwiftTaylor Swift
American singer
Miley-CyrusMiley Cyrus
American singer-songwriter
Stephen-ColbertStephen Colbert
American comedian
Kylie-JennerKylie Jenner
American television personality
Jennifer-LopezJennifer Lopez
American singer
BeyoncéBeyoncé
American singer-songwriter
MadonnaMadonna
American singer-songwriter
Lady-GagaLady Gaga
American singer-songwriter
Khloe-KardashianKhloé Kardashian
American media personality
Jimmy-KimmelJimmy Kimmel
American television host
Oprah-WinfreyOprah Winfrey
American executive
Kim-KardashianKim Kardashian
American media personality
Ellen-DeGeneresEllen DeGeneres
American comedian
Selena-GomezSelena Gomez
American singer
Related Stories
One to watch: ScarypoolpartyOne to watch: Scarypoolparty
Fireworks expected at MCG as Katy Perry factor gives Women’s World T20 a boost | Adam CollinsFireworks expected at MCG as Katy Perry factor gives Women’s World T20 a boost | Adam Collins
Love the game: Drake and Taylor Swifts decade in pop dominanceLove the game: Drake and Taylor Swift's decade in pop dominance
Latest News
After GOP Rep. Matt Gaetz brings up Hunter Bidens substance abuse, hes reminded of his own DUIAfter GOP Rep. Matt Gaetz brings up Hunter Biden's substance abuse, he's reminded of his own DUI
Meghan McCain warns Nikki Haley will be haunted by her defense of Confederate flag — as her father wasMeghan McCain warns Nikki Haley will be 'haunted' by her defense of Confederate flag — as her father was
Black Christmas review – woke slasher remake is an unholy, unscary messBlack Christmas review – woke slasher remake is an unholy, unscary mess
Weinstein Company creditors join settlement including $25m for accusersWeinstein Company creditors join settlement including $25m for accusers
Are Exit Polls Reliable For The General Election?Are Exit Polls Reliable For The General Election?
Mason Greenwood double leads Manchester United past AZ AlkmaarMason Greenwood double leads Manchester United past AZ Alkmaar
Light lies the crown before Michael van Gerwen’s visit to the Palace | Jonathan LiewLight lies the crown before Michael van Gerwen’s visit to the Palace | Jonathan Liew
Alfredo Morelos takes Rangers through despite late Young Boys equaliserAlfredo Morelos takes Rangers through despite late Young Boys equaliser
Diogo Jota comes off bench to grab rapid hat-trick as Wolves rout BesiktasDiogo Jota comes off bench to grab rapid hat-trick as Wolves rout Besiktas
Nigel Pearson plots Watford escape after ‘surprising’ top-flight returnNigel Pearson plots Watford escape after ‘surprising’ top-flight return
Celebrities
Justin-BieberJustin Bieber
Canadian singer-songwriter
Ariana-GrandeAriana Grande
American singer
Jay_ZJay-Z
American rapper
Taylor-SwiftTaylor Swift
American singer
Miley-CyrusMiley Cyrus
American singer-songwriter
Stephen-ColbertStephen Colbert
American comedian
Kylie-JennerKylie Jenner
American television personality
Jennifer-LopezJennifer Lopez
American singer
BeyoncéBeyoncé
American singer-songwriter
MadonnaMadonna
American singer-songwriter
Lady-GagaLady Gaga
American singer-songwriter
Khloe-KardashianKhloé Kardashian
American media personality
Jimmy-KimmelJimmy Kimmel
American television host
Oprah-WinfreyOprah Winfrey
American executive
Kim-KardashianKim Kardashian
American media personality
Ellen-DeGeneresEllen DeGeneres
American comedian
Selena-GomezSelena Gomez
American singer
Kamala Harris releases healthcare policy plan days before Democratic debate
Stephen Colbert Exposes Trump’s ‘Racist’ Hypocrisy on Baltimore and Rep. Elijah Cummings
Sex Diaries: 'My Wife And I Role Play – And Sometimes It Lasts For Days'
Liz Earle's Must Haves: 'Elnett Has Been My Go-To Hairspray For Decades'
China defends Hong Kong police, blames Western forces
6-Year-Old Boy Among 3 Killed at Gilroy Garlic Festival Mass Shooting
When You're White-Passing, White People Treat You Like The ‘Acceptable Ethnic'
I've Never Been More Unhappy Than When I Was Thin
Best Shops To Buy Petite Women's Clothes In The UK
Trump nominee sparks worries of intelligence politicization
Small plane crashes in Pakistan, killing at least 12
Senate bows to Trump vetoes, allows Saudi arms sales
Maryland’s Republican Governor Condemns Trump’s Baltimore Remarks
The Latest: Relative identifies 3 of 5 killed in Wisconsin
Trump billionaire friend aimed to profit from Mideast nuclear deal: Democrats
'The Bachelorette' finale: Hannah reveals what really happened in windmill with Peter
Iran vs. Royal Navy: British Naval Destroyer Deploys to Persian Gulf
15 killed as Pakistani army plane crashes into residential area
Tip on Canada murder suspects turns up empty: police
WhatsApp is about to get a huge upgrade that’ll let you use the same account across platforms
The 1 Thing the U.S. Marines Could Teach U.S. Navy SEALs
Amazon Studios’ ‘Modern Love,’ Based on New York Times Column, to Premiere Oct. 18
Egypt, Jordan leaders hold talks over Israeli-Palestinian peace
Trump's intelligence pick is attempt to 'neutralise' spy agencies, say ex-officials
The Latest: Police: Shooting survivors ranged from 12 to 69
Narendra Modi is surprise guest on Bear Grylls' Man vs Wild
Water meant for Puerto Rican hurricane victims dumped on farmland
Shark Week has begun and fans are angry: 'Most disgraceful start to Shark Week ever'
Witness Says Najib Note Shows He Knew Source of $10 Million in His Account
Freshmen House Democrats raise more money than GOP opponents
The It List: 2-night 'Bachelorette' finale, tickets for 'Friends' pop-up, 'Kiki's Delivery Service' and 'Glory' turn 30 and the best in pop culture the week of July 29, 2019
Coalition says strike kills 5 IS jihadists in Syria
Mosquitos carrying deadly, brain-swelling virus detected in Florida
Is Biden Really Democrats’ Best Bet?
NSPCC: 200,000 Secondary School Kids 'May Have Been Groomed Online'
Gunman posted online minutes before killing 3 at festival
Limbaugh: It's about time somebody pushed back against the human misery caused by Democrat leadership
Britain rules out seized tanker swap with Iran
Off-duty Los Angeles police officer killed; gunman sought
Leak shows Samsung’s brand new Galaxy Note 10+ isn’t even as powerful as Apple’s year-old iPhones
Mitch McConnell: Top Trump ally angrily hits back at 'modern-day McCarthyism' amid row over election security and Russia
California has strict gun laws. Here's how the Gilroy gunman evaded them
Four people including gunman killed in shooting at California food festival
CNN's Jake Tapper Reminds Bernie Sanders He Accused Pharmaceutical Executives of Murder
Fox News host presses WH chief of staff over 'racial stereotyping' in Trump tweets
Meghan Markle's British Vogue Guest Editor Letter: 'We Are Even Stronger Together'
Labour Claims Fracking Will Make Net-Zero By 2050 Impossible
Love Island: Amber Gill And Greg O'Shea Crowned 2019 Winners In Close-Run Live Final
Amazon Strikes Development Deals With Blake Lively, Connie Britton & Lena Waithe
Shark Week: Your Complete Guide to Discovery's 'Fincredible' Programming
Dolly Parton Joins Brandi Carlile’s All-Star, All-Women Blowout at Newport (Watch)
Shark Week has begun and fans are angry: ‘Most disgraceful start to Shark Week ever’
Robert Downey Jr’s ‘Sherlock Holmes 3’ to Receive $20.8 Million California Tax Credit
Al Franken Helped With New Chris Rock Script (Exclusive)
‘Drop Dead Gorgeous’ Team Remembers Late Co-Star Brittany Murphy at Outfest Screening
Al Sharpton Tweets Old Photo With Then-Friendly Trump After ‘Conman’ Tweet: ‘Different Tune Now’
Celebrities react to death of 6-year-old in Gilroy Garlic Festival shooting: 'My heart is broken'
Gunman kills 2 kids, 1 other at Gilroy, California, festival
Years of ignoring peaceful protests fuels Hong Kong violence: jailed activist
Johnson presses EU to give way amid no-deal Brexit warnings
Saudi Arabia to Ban Foreigners From Slew of Hospitality Jobs
Iran says US rejected offer as 'not seeking dialogue'
Trump’s Racist Tweets Don't Break Any Rules, Twitter Says
‘Dilbert’ Creator Scott Adams Tries to Sell Interviews With Gilroy Garlic Festival Shooting Survivors
The Real Reason the U.S. Navy's F-14 Tomcat Was Born
Trump says Coats is out as national intelligence director
Kamala Harris releases Medicare-for-all plan ahead of second 2020 U.S. Democratic debate
Indian police say they killed a top militant in Kashmir
Santino William Legan: What we know about Gilroy Garlic Festival suspect
Nicola Sturgeon Accuses Boris Johnson Of Secretly Pursuing No-Deal Brexit
Boris Johnson Issues Ultimatum to EU Over Brexit Talks as Pound Slumps
5 dead, 2 injured in residential shootings in Wisconsin
Trump touts Ground Zero experience in 9/11 compensation bill signing
Be Fast And Furious In This 1992 Nissan Skyline GT-R
India's wild tiger population jumps to almost 3,000: census
Trump steps up attack on black lawmaker, calls him 'racist'
Executive Director of House Dems’ Campaign Arm Resigns amid Backlash over Lack of Diversity
Chris Wallace Confronts WH Chief of Staff on Trump’s Racist Baltimore Tweets: There’s a ‘Clear Pattern Here’
Biden's Campaign in Crisis? Former Obama VP 'Scrambling' to Reassure Donors
Sophie Gradon's Mum Pens Heart-Wrenching Open Letter Slamming ITV Boss On Eve Of Love Island Finale
Israelis cleared of rape to sue British accuser in Cyprus
Land Panel Report Highlights Rifts That Divide South Africa
Beijing reiterates support for Hong Kong's Lam, police
Donald Trump Just Granted 5 Full Pardons. Check Out to Who
New York reduces penalties for marijuana possession
Michelle Obama issues veiled rebuke of Trump after Baltimore insults
Tom Steyer Is Crushing the 2020 Field on Facebook
India's tiger population rises to nearly 3,000 animals
Harrowing photos show Guatemalan mother begging Mexican soldiers to let her cross into U.S
It's not cricket – but Las Vegas grasshopper invasion is harmless
Dan Coats, intelligence chief who clashed with Donald Trump, 'to step down'
Wall Street Journal Corrects ‘Bombshell’ Report On North Korea Nukes
Canadian police descend on small town as teen murder suspects spotted
Brazil prison riot: 16 prisoners decapitated as dozens killed in mass jail uprising
Police hunt for second suspect in shooting at California food festival
Trump news - live: President jokes about stage collapsing with 9/11 first responders as congress hints at looming impeachment
Afghan presidential candidates fear for safety after attack
Barack and Michelle Obama offer rare rebukes of Trump over attacks on Baltimore
DHS Chief Praises Supreme Court Decision: ‘Big Victory’ For Border Wall
Kamala Harris Uses Her New Medicare For All Plan To Go After Bernie
Harris Releases ‘Medicare for All’ Plan That Allows for Limited Private Insurance
Did Justin Theroux and Jennifer Aniston reunite for their shared dog's funeral?
Trump signs 9/11 Victim Compensation Fund extension
China to weigh in on deepening Hong Kong crisis
Trump doubles down on Cummings attacks, shares vulgar comment about Baltimore on Twitter
Christina Milian shares adorable baby news with boyfriend Matt Pokora: ‘What a blessing!’
Lori Loughlin's daughter shared birthday message to mom amid college admissions scandal
Former Coronation Street actor Paula Williamson dies aged 38
Slack DOWN and Server Status Latest: Is Slack Down? Outage issues hit messaging app
Greta Thunberg to sail across Atlantic for climate summits because she refuses to fly on planes
U.K. Warship Arrives to Protect Hormuz as Seoul Mulls Deployment
Officer hurt in shootout in popular tourist area in Arkansas
Kamala Harris Unveils ‘Medicare For All’ Plan That Preserves Private Insurance
Boris Johnson's All-Male Brexit War Cabinet Shows 'Dangerous Machismo Approach' To Leaving EU
Paula Williamson, Wife Of Charles Bronson And Coronation Street Actress, Dies Aged 38
Michelle Obama Tells Meghan Markle Motherhood Is 'A Masterclass In Letting Go'
Vietnam seizes 125 kg of rhino horn worth £6m concealed in plaster shipment
Incredible photo shows an elderly woman standing up for the youth in Hong Kong
British PM Johnson tells EU: Ready to talk Brexit when you shift position
Women taking photos of themselves without headscarves face 10-year prison sentence in Iran
Vatican bones found to be too old in quest to solve mystery of missing teenager Emanuela Orlandi
IS threat hovers over Syria camp, rattling authorities
Suspicions over crash that left rape case India teen in hospital
Police officer accuses McDonald's workers of taking bite out of sandwich then admits he ‘forgot he ate it’
Sailing to America: Teen to bring her climate activism to US
Boy, 8, dies in Germany after being pushed onto train tracks
Trump news – live: President triggers new onslaught against another black leader as senior congressman hints at looming impeachment
Protest Is The Only Weapon We Ordinary People Have To Hold The Powerful To Account
Muslim Council Of Britain Slams The Daily Telegraph For 'Inaccurate' Flu Vaccine Story
Australia’s Got Talent Contestant Pricasso Paints Portrait With His Penis And Nicole Scherzinger’s Reaction Is All Of Us
Putin opponent Navalny 'poisoned': lawyer
What Is EMDR Therapy? Jameela Jamil Reveals It 'Saved Her Life'
British Pro-Wrestler Blames Losing On Boris Johnson In Hilarious Video
Boris Johnson Says Michael Gove Is Wrong To Assume We're Heading For No-Deal Brexit
The Latest: Iran official says 24 tons of uranium enriched
Hong Kong plunges into pandemonium for second day in a row as protests continue
Bear Grylls Has Made A Show With Narendra Modi
How To Choose A Good Pram: These Are The 5 Features You Shouldn't Compromise On
Dwayne ‘The Rock’ Johnson Praises Boris Johnson, Deletes It And Backtracks 15 Minutes Later
Baltimore paper blasts Trump after his attacks on city: 'Better to have a few rats than to be one'
Earth Overshoot Day Shows We're Tearing Through Resources Faster Than Ever
Eamonn Holmes Says Ruth Langsford Is 'Difficult' To Live With, Comparing Her To A 'Racehorse'
Vaginal Mesh Is Tested Less Vigorously Than Vacuum Cleaners, Chemist Claims
Man Who Filmed Cardboard Grenfell Model On Bonfire 'Said It Was A Stupid Moment'
Boris Johnson Will Not Hold Brexit Talks With EU Until They Agree To Change Exit Deal, No.10 Signals
YouTubers Tana Mongeau and Jake Paul get married: report
Game of Thrones’ Emilia Clarke, Jason Momoa reunite as she wishes him an early happy birthday
Trump blasts 'con man' Al Sharpton, as feud with Dems over Baltimore heats up
2 US teens jailed in Italy in policeman's killing
Jared Kushner owns Baltimore apartments ‘infested’ with rodents, mould and maggots
Boris Johnson's Girlfriend Carrie Symonds WILL Move Into Downing Street
Stepping up feud, Trump assails Cummings as 'racist'
Ky. teen's $250 million suit against the Washington Post dismissed
Narendra Modi surprise guest on Bear Grylls' Man vs Wild
Why North Korea Fears the F-35 Stealth Fighter
'Stay inside and lock your doors': Tiny Canadian village on lockdown as teenage murder spree suspects spotted scavenging for food
Stacey Dooley Says She Deserved To Win Strictly Because She ‘Worked Harder Than Everyone Else’
Boris Johnson's Partner Carrie Symonds WILL Move Into Downing Street
Boy, 6, among 3 killed in US festival shooting, suspected gunman dead
Is Love Island A Substitute For Sex Education – And Should We Be Worried About That?
Report alleges ethical abuses at UN agency for Palestinians
Montana searchers find body of missing Oregon child
Outrage as Trump brands mostly-black Baltimore 'infested mess'
The Latest: Hospital: At least 5 people shot at festival
Is Love Island A Substitute For Sex Education – And Should We Be Worried?
Dad Charged With Homicide After Infant Twins Found Dead In Hot Car
Meghan Markle's Vogue September Issue – Who Are The 15 Women On The Cover?
Love Island's Belle Hassan Brands Molly-Mae 'Two-Faced' After Being Dumped From Villa
Oliver Letwin Warns MPs No-Deal Brexit May Now Be Inevitable
Love Island’s Dr Alex George Glad To See The Back Of ‘Inaccurate’ Lie Detector Tests
Man Rescued After Getting Trapped In Rocks Off Norfolk Coast Had Just Saved Toddler From Sea
People Are Comparing This Red ASOS Dress To A Sack Of Onions
Alexei Navalny: Everything We Know About The Russian Opposition Leader's 'Allergic Reaction'
Trump news – live: Impeachment looms as senior congressman says ‘we have to do this’ amid backlash over president’s attacks on ‘s***hole’ Baltimore and black congressman
Beijing says China stepping up U.S. soy imports, yet to show up in U.S. data
Iran says reporter once detained in US could interview Pompeo
California Shooting: Gunman Kills At Least Three People And Wounds 15 Others At Gilroy Garlic Festival
As A Disabled Woman, I'm Harassed On The Street Daily – Where's My #MeToo Movement?
This Woman Helped Popularise Gender Reveal Parties. Now There's A 'Plot Twist.'
Stacey Dooley Praises 'Amazing' Kevin Clifton While Discussing Romance For The First Time
Trump attacks black congressman for second day in a row amid growing anger over racist use of 'infested'
Woman wakes up in hotel, finds snake on her arm: 'I won't be sleeping for a while after this'
Iran Took Advantage of the Royal Navy's Weakness
Nigeria bans local Shi'ite group after protests
Blast, gunbattle at Afghan VP candidate's office, 2 dead
Protesters clash in Hong Kong as cycle of violence intensifies
Kourtney Kardashian's Paparazzi Thong Bikini Pics Shock The World, Fans Hadn't Expected Cellulite
Jennifer Lopez twerks on Alex Rodriguez, stops concert to sing him happy birthday
Meghan Markle's Specific Instructions for Cover of Guest-Edited Vogue Issue: 'I Want to See Freckles'
'Once Upon a Time in Hollywood,' Tarantino and When Violence Against Women Is a Punchline
How some of the world's rarest fish dodged a California earthquake
The Latest: Shooter described as thin man in camouflage
John Wick TV series confirmed to be a prequel
Jessie J shuts down Channing Tatum questions during awkward interview
California garlic festival shooting: gunman kills at least four at Gilroy event
U.K. Starts No-Deal Brexit Meetings as It’s Now a Real Prospect
Africa's booming cities face a severe toilet crisis
Julian Castro Is ‘Hypercritical’ Of Trump Immigration Policies He Once Praised Under Obama
Trump says director of national intelligence is resigning
Gilroy garlic festival shooting: Gunman shot dead after killing at least three at California event
Close