Close
Date TimeJuly 28, 2019
Voice
How Mueller’s Lawyers Spun the OLC Guidance on Indicting a Sitting President
This is Part Two of a two-part series. In Part One, we took a look at the OLC guidance that bars the indictment of a sitting president. (The OLC is the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel.) In particular, we looked at (a) how, in investigating President Trump for purported obstruction, special counsel Robert Mueller’s staff distorted the guidance into a prohibition against even considering whether an offense occurred; and (b) the futile hope of congressional Democrats, during Wednesday’s hearings, that Mueller would contradict his final report on this point.In Part Two, we explore why Mueller’s staff of very able lawyers, many of them activist Democrats, twisted the OLC guidance. (Spoiler: Their priority was to get their evidence to Congress, intact and as quickly as possible, in hopes of fueling an impeachment drive, or at least damaging Trump politically.) We also analyze how attorney general Bill Barr deftly dealt with the Mueller staff’s gamesmanship.As we observed at the end of Part One, Mueller’s report makes the whopper of the claim that prosecutors construed to OLC guidance to forbid them to make a charging decision on obstruction because they were trying to protect President Trump.How’s that?Well, Justice Department protocols prohibit prosecutors from prejudicing suspects by publicizing the evidence against them unless and until they are formally charged. The idea is that the government must refrain from speaking until it files an indictment. For at that point, the person becomes an “accused” under the Constitution, vested with all the due process guarantees our law provides: assistance of counsel, confrontation of witnesses, subpoena power — the full array of rights to challenge the government’s indictment.From this commonsense proposition, Mueller’s staff leapt to an untenable conclusion: Because the OLC guidance prevents the Justice Department from formally charging a sitting president, poor President Trump would have been denied his due process protections if Mueller had recommended an indictment: It would be as if the government slimed him by publicizing the evidence but denied him his day in court to clear his name.If this doesn’t insult the intelligence, nothing will. Sliming the uncharged president by publicizing the evidence is exactly what Mueller’s team did.The special counsel’s staff wrote a 448-page tome, overflowing with details about a traitorous collusion plot that never happened and the obstruction of an investigation that was never actually impeded in the slightest. Even though the regulations call for a confidential report from the special counsel to the attorney general, the Mueller report was patently written with the intention that it would be transmitted to Congress and the public. (Indeed, even before the report was submitted to the Justice Department, various industrious publishers planned to make it available for sale.) Moreover, when AG Barr undertook to announce only the special counsel’s bottom-line conclusions, Mueller’s staff threw a fit, grousing to the media that Barr was wrongly withholding the report and denying the public the condemnatory narrative in which they had couched these benign conclusions.Another of many reasons the Mueller staff’s claim to be protecting Trump is laughable: If Mueller and his staff were actually playing by the rules, they would have demanded that their report to Barr be kept confidential — like a normal consultation between a prosecutor and a supervisor about whether an indictment should be sought. If they had done that, there would have been no need for their touching expression of concern about the president’s rights. Any recommendation to indict or other prosecutorial deliberations would have remained non-public; only the indictment, if one were ever filed, would become public. But Mueller’s staff wrote a report that was patently intended to be the antithesis of confidential. Due process is protected when the regulations are followed, not when they are flouted.Finally, there are three other manifest problems with Mueller’s construction of the OLC guidance. First, if Mueller really believed the OLC guidance prevented him from even considering whether President Trump could be charged, why did he render a decision on the collusion aspect of the probe? He can’t have it both ways. Second, if Mueller really believed the OLC guidance prevented him from performing the prosecutor’s task, why on earth did he accept the appointment to act as a prosecutor? Third, if Mueller really believed the OLC guidance prevented him from considering whether to indict, why did he tell AG Barr, two weeks before filing his report, that the OLC guidance was not the reason he would refrain from recommending obstruction charges?The Obstruction DisputeNow, let’s bear in mind: Mueller’s staffers are very good lawyers. And many of them, including such laboring oars as Andrew Weissmann and Michael Dreeben, undoubtedly would like to see Trump driven from office — whether by prosecutors, lawmakers, or voters. So why would exceptional, aggressive prosecutors adopt a risible interpretation of the OLC guidance that tied their own hands, preventing them from finding an obstruction offense against the president when they had clearly tried very hard to make the case?Because they were smart enough to know they couldn’t make the criminal case in court, and that the best way to hurt Trump was to get their work to Congress, where it might fuel an impeachment push and would surely damage the president politically.Why couldn’t they make the criminal case? That brings us to an issue more central than the OLC guidance: the law of obstruction.Mueller’s staff and the Justice Department, particularly under Barr, disagree fundamentally about what conduct may constitute an obstruction offense against a president. And there is a corollary: When there is a difference of opinion at the Justice Department, someone gets to decide. In this instance, that someone was Barr, not Mueller. That is, the special counsel could recommend an obstruction indictment, but it would be up to the attorney general to determine whether to follow the recommendation.To summarize, Mueller’s staff operated under an expansive construction of obstruction, claiming that any presidential act — including legitimate exercises of a president’s constitutional prerogatives, such as firing or considering firing such subordinates as the FBI director and the special counsel himself — could be grounds for an obstruction charge if a prosecutor (i.e., an inferior executive official) decided the chief executive’s motive was corrupt.Barr, by contrast, hews to the traditional understanding that a president is only liable for a criminal obstruction charge if he engages in blatantly corrupt conduct that is not within his constitutional prerogatives — e.g., bribing witnesses or destroying evidence. Importantly, that does not mean a president is immune from accountability for abusing executive powers; rather, in our system, it is for Congress, not an inferior executive official, to second-guess the legitimacy of the chief executive’s acts — i.e., Congress can impeach the president.How did these divergent views of obstruction law play out in the Mueller investigation?For most of the probe, because of AG Jeff Sessions’s recusal, Mueller’s staff was “supervised” by deputy AG Rod Rosenstein (the same guy who considered invoking the 25th Amendment against Trump, and who decided that the faded Mueller we watched testify this week would be a perfect fit to run the Russia investigation). Rosenstein’s passivity gave Mueller’s staff carte blanche to investigate obstruction under their ever-elastic theory. They intimidated administration officials, who feared that any objection to the legitimacy and tactics of Mueller’s probe would result in more allegations of corruption and obstruction.Then in mid-February 2016, after Mueller’s staff had been going merrily along this way for 21 months, Barr became attorney general. At that point, Mueller’s staffers knew they were now dealing with a strong AG who had a scholarly understanding of obstruction law and would not be cowed by their skill and aggression.Barr was not going to buy the Mueller staff’s theory of obstruction. Consequently, if Mueller had recommended obstruction charges against Trump based on the legal analysis explicated in Volume II of the report, then the Justice Department would have rejected the recommendation and the legal analysis. There would have been an intense debate within the Justice Department involving the special counsel’s staff, OLC, and the AG — a debate Mueller’s staffers had to know they would lose if they were foolish enough to force it. Volume II would have gotten much more Justice Department scrutiny. Mueller’s staff would not only have been thwarted in their quest to indict Trump; their report might have been tied up at DOJ for months — and perhaps never be released in its current form.The Mueller Staff’s Strategic RetreatMueller’s anti-Trump staffers knew they were never going to be able to drive Trump from office by indicting him. The only plausible way to drive him from office was to prioritize, over all else, making the report public. Then, perhaps Congress would use it to impeach. At the very least, the 448 pages of uncharged conduct would wound Trump politically, helping lead to his defeat in 2020 — an enticing thought for someone who had, say, attended the Hillary Clinton “victory” party and expressed adulatory “awe” for acting AG (and fellow Obama holdover) Sally Yates when she insubordinately refused to enforce Trump’s border security order.Of course, it wouldn’t be enough to get the report to Congress. The challenge was to get it there with the obstruction case still viable even though prosecutors knew they couldn’t get away with recommending an obstruction indictment. How to accomplish this? By pretending that the OLC guidance prevented prosecutors from even making a charging decision.First, Barr would need to be informed that Mueller would not be rendering a decision on whether Trump should be charged with obstruction. Barr would no doubt be surprised and irked by this. Yet, the staff surmised that he would grudgingly accept it. For Barr, Mueller’s non-decision would not be nearly as hot a potato as a recommendation to indict Trump would be — he’d take the former to avoid the latter. They figured: What the administration most desired was to be able to say that Mueller had not found any obstruction (or collusion) offenses. Accepting Mueller’s abdication would allow for that. Plus, Barr would realize that if he ordered Mueller to make a decision, Mueller’s staff would probably recommend an indictment — the anti-Trump staff would never concede that Trump had not committed obstruction and, as Wednesday’s testimony made clear, Mueller was not up to a confrontation with his staff over the esoterica of obstruction law. If Mueller recommended an indictment of Trump, Barr would be unrelentingly vilified if he disagreed with Mueller’s obstruction analysis and overruled the recommendation.Mueller’s staff also knew there would be great congressional and public demand to read their report, and that Barr had committed in his confirmation hearings to be as transparent as law and Justice Department policy allowed. If they conceded that they could not recommend obstruction charges, Mueller’s staff figured the report would be published rapidly, despite any disagreements Barr might have with its substance, including their expansive interpretation of obstruction law.It was a very clever plan. There was just one potential hitch: the OLC guidance.Mueller’s staff realized that Barr would want Mueller to explain his reasoning for not making a charging decision on obstruction. The staff would not want to say that the evidence of obstruction was not strong enough — that would hurt the position of congressional Democrats who want to impeach Trump. But neither would they be permitted to claim that the OLC guidance forbidding indictment of a sitting president prevented them from recommending obstruction charges. Barr would know that such a claim would be the functional equivalent of saying Trump should be charged. He would not countenance that; he would instruct Mueller to make a recommendation, one way or the other, about whether Trump should be indicted, and leave it to Barr to worry about the OLC guidance.That is, Mueller’s staff knew that if they claimed the OLC guidance was the sole reason they could not recommend an indictment, they’d be right back to square one: confronting all the downsides of making a recommendation to indict that would be rejected by Barr, that would provoke major Justice Department evaluation of their report, and that would likely keep the report under wraps interminably.So, they would have to finesse the OLC guidance. (That’s a polite way to put it, right?)Consequently, in their first meeting about the investigation, Mueller assured Barr that the OLC guidance was not his basis for refusing to decide the obstruction issue. When Barr inevitably pressed him on what, then, was his rationale, Mueller said his team was still formulating its reasoning. . . even though the decision not to decide had already been made.They were buying time.Then, two weeks later, they filed the report. It was a masterful exercise in doublespeak. Mueller’s staff relied on the OLC guidance, but not for the purpose of refusing to make a recommendation (which, again, would have been unacceptable to Barr). Instead, they claimed to interpret the guidance to prohibit them from even considering whether Trump should be charged. It is a head spinner: Mueller’s prosecutors acknowledged that they were not finding Trump had committed an obstruction crime; but they carefully qualified that neither were they saying he had not committed obstruction — in their constitutionally offensive parlance, they were not “exonerating” the president. With a wink to congressional Democrats, Mueller’s activist Democratic staff essentially said: We’re not charging him, but that doesn’t mean there is insufficient evidence to charge. . . which means there might very well be impeachable offenses.Barr’s CheckmateBarr, of course, is no slouch at the chess game. What would his responsive move be?He could have decided that Mueller’s position on the OLC guidance was untenable and that the special counsel must make a recommendation, yes or no, on obstruction. But Barr realized that if he cornered Mueller’s staffers this way, they would probably recommend an indictment. Again, that would draw Barr into a major controversy over whether to overrule Mueller, which the AG surely wanted to avoid. Barr thus opted to make a different move: He would accept Mueller’s report and exploit its weakness, namely, the special counsel’s failure to decide the central question of whether there was sufficient evidence to indict. With Mueller having abdicated, Barr would fill the void by making the decision — and he would do it in conjunction with Rosenstein, which would mean the official who supervised Mueller’s investigation for almost all of its duration was in agreement with the Barr’s determination.Nor was that all. Even though he disagreed with Mueller’s interpretation of obstruction law, Barr adopted it for argument’s sake; and similarly, he assumed the accuracy of Mueller’s investigation and undertook to decide the obstruction question solely on the facts as Mueller found them.This was adroit. No matter what legal standard is employed, a prosecutor cannot prove obstruction without establishing, beyond a reasonable doubt, that the defendant had corrupt intent. To say there is insufficient evidence of corrupt intent does not mean there is no evidence. At Wednesday’s hearing, Democrats seemed to believe that if there is evidence of corrupt intent (or any other element of a criminal offense) then that element is deemed to be satisfied. That, however, is not how it works. With an essential element of a criminal offense, there is almost always evidence on both sides. That evidence must be weighed, and the element is only deemed satisfied if it is proved beyond a reasonable doubt.That is, Barr could accept all of the unsavory conduct Mueller uncovered, he could freely concede that some of this evidence implied an improper purpose, and yet he could still credibly find that intent could not be proved beyond a reasonable doubt. Why? Because (a) Trump provided extraordinary cooperation to Mueller (even making his White House counsel extensively available, which he did not have to do); (b) Trump never shut down the investigation or fired Mueller, though he had the power to do so; (c) the investigation was not actually impeded in any way; (d) there was no underlying collusion crime so Trump could not have been trying to cover up a conspiracy with Russia; and (e) Trump was lashing out due to frustration, not corruption, because he knew he was not a Russian agent but had to endure slanders that he was by investigators and political opponents.In the end, then, Barr accepted Team Mueller’s gamesmanship on the OLC guidance, accepted their obstruction analysis, and accepted their conclusions of fact. By doing so, he left them no credible grounds to object, while he was nevertheless finding that Trump had not committed obstruction. He made the prosecutors’ conclusions publicly available quickly — and they looked derelict because, in deciding to try to do Congress’s job, they had failed to do their own. All they could complain about was that the public did not get access to the anti-Trump flavor of their narrative quickly enough to suit them.Mueller’s team was sharp. They creatively used the OLC guidance to try to signal an obstruction crime without quite accusing Trump of obstruction — banking on congressional Democrats to finish the job. In Barr, they just happened to run into a guy who figured out what they were doing, and who had the brains and the power to stay a step ahead.

Related Stories
Police make arrest in gruesome murder of Russian Instagram starPolice make arrest in gruesome murder of Russian Instagram star
Tensions Between Bernie Sanders and MSNBC Boil OverTensions Between Bernie Sanders and MSNBC Boil Over
President Trump Is the Latest Critic of Facebooks LibraPresident Trump Is the Latest Critic of Facebook's Libra
Russian boxer Maxim Dadashev dies at 28 from injuries sustained in fightRussian boxer Maxim Dadashev dies at 28 from injuries sustained in fight
Russia Instagram influencer Ekaterina Karaglanova found dead in suitcaseRussia Instagram influencer Ekaterina Karaglanova found dead in suitcase
Robert Mueller tells Congress his report did not exonerate TrumpRobert Mueller tells Congress his report did not exonerate Trump
Creator of ‘Storm Area 51’ comes forward after Facebook page takes offCreator of ‘Storm Area 51’ comes forward after Facebook page takes off
The Squad revives feud with Pelosi: Be aware when you single us out that were women of color'The Squad' revives feud with Pelosi: Be aware when you 'single us out' that we're 'women of color'
APNewsBreak: Gun safety groups to host presidential forumAPNewsBreak: Gun safety groups to host presidential forum
South Korea fires 360 warning shots at Russian military aircraftSouth Korea fires 360 warning shots at Russian military aircraft
Latest News
Jimmy Fallon and Stephen Colbert flippantly wave John Hickenlooper out of the 2020 presidential raceJimmy Fallon and Stephen Colbert flippantly wave John Hickenlooper out of the 2020 presidential race
Bolivia president does about-face and will now accept aid to put out wildfiresBolivia president does about-face and will now accept aid to put out wildfires
Prince Andrew took flight on Epstein private  jet with Russian modelPrince Andrew took flight on Epstein private jet with Russian model
U.S. equity futures reopen lower, U.S.-China trade relations at new low ebbU.S. equity futures reopen lower, U.S.-China trade relations at new low ebb
Greece seeking Parthenon sculpture loan from Louvre : officialGreece seeking Parthenon sculpture loan from Louvre : official
Attorneys: Charges expected in Florida nursing home deathsAttorneys: Charges expected in Florida nursing home deaths
Ariana Grande returns to Manchester to play poignant Pride showAriana Grande returns to Manchester to play poignant Pride show
Sleater-Kinney: The Centre Wont Hold review | Ben Beaumont-Thomass album of the weekSleater-Kinney: The Centre Won't Hold review | Ben Beaumont-Thomas's album of the week
Stephen Colbert drops some civil theology on CNN, explains why Trump is a heretic against realityStephen Colbert drops some civil theology on CNN, explains why Trump is a 'heretic against reality'
Angel of Mine review – Noomi Rapace radiates with dangerous longingAngel of Mine review – Noomi Rapace radiates with dangerous longing
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
Police make arrest in gruesome murder of Russian Instagram starPolice make arrest in gruesome murder of Russian Instagram star
Tensions Between Bernie Sanders and MSNBC Boil OverTensions Between Bernie Sanders and MSNBC Boil Over
President Trump Is the Latest Critic of Facebooks LibraPresident Trump Is the Latest Critic of Facebook's Libra
Russian boxer Maxim Dadashev dies at 28 from injuries sustained in fightRussian boxer Maxim Dadashev dies at 28 from injuries sustained in fight
Russia Instagram influencer Ekaterina Karaglanova found dead in suitcaseRussia Instagram influencer Ekaterina Karaglanova found dead in suitcase
Robert Mueller tells Congress his report did not exonerate TrumpRobert Mueller tells Congress his report did not exonerate Trump
Creator of ‘Storm Area 51’ comes forward after Facebook page takes offCreator of ‘Storm Area 51’ comes forward after Facebook page takes off
The Squad revives feud with Pelosi: Be aware when you single us out that were women of color'The Squad' revives feud with Pelosi: Be aware when you 'single us out' that we're 'women of color'
APNewsBreak: Gun safety groups to host presidential forumAPNewsBreak: Gun safety groups to host presidential forum
South Korea fires 360 warning shots at Russian military aircraftSouth Korea fires 360 warning shots at Russian military aircraft
Latest News
Jimmy Fallon and Stephen Colbert flippantly wave John Hickenlooper out of the 2020 presidential raceJimmy Fallon and Stephen Colbert flippantly wave John Hickenlooper out of the 2020 presidential race
Bolivia president does about-face and will now accept aid to put out wildfiresBolivia president does about-face and will now accept aid to put out wildfires
Prince Andrew took flight on Epstein private  jet with Russian modelPrince Andrew took flight on Epstein private jet with Russian model
U.S. equity futures reopen lower, U.S.-China trade relations at new low ebbU.S. equity futures reopen lower, U.S.-China trade relations at new low ebb
Greece seeking Parthenon sculpture loan from Louvre : officialGreece seeking Parthenon sculpture loan from Louvre : official
Attorneys: Charges expected in Florida nursing home deathsAttorneys: Charges expected in Florida nursing home deaths
Ariana Grande returns to Manchester to play poignant Pride showAriana Grande returns to Manchester to play poignant Pride show
Sleater-Kinney: The Centre Wont Hold review | Ben Beaumont-Thomass album of the weekSleater-Kinney: The Centre Won't Hold review | Ben Beaumont-Thomas's album of the week
Stephen Colbert drops some civil theology on CNN, explains why Trump is a heretic against realityStephen Colbert drops some civil theology on CNN, explains why Trump is a 'heretic against reality'
Angel of Mine review – Noomi Rapace radiates with dangerous longingAngel of Mine review – Noomi Rapace radiates with dangerous longing
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Apple may introduce a custom 5G modem for the iPhone sooner than expected
Cyprus frees Israelis in rape case, accuser arrested
Southern California water polo players among injured in deadly balcony collapse at South Korea nightclub
World War III? How Russia, China, Japan and South Korea Nearly Started a War
'Slow war of attrition' on Syria's Idlib frontline
Ruth Davidson 'Will Not Support' A No-Deal Brexit
Ex-UK finance minister, Labour plot ways to block no-deal Brexit: paper
The Latest: Hong Kong police warn protesters of arrest
Girl's murder sparks outcry and protests in Romania
The Navy Reportedly booted SEAL Team 7 out of Iraq
Jeremy Corbyn Says He Would Offer Referendum On Labour Brexit Deal
AP Explains: How big a threat is an electromagnetic attack?
Iran invites Pompeo for interview by reporter once detained in US
Trump news - live: Backlash over president’s attack on congressman’s ‘rat-infested’ district, amid new bid for impeachment
World powers meet Iran in Vienna to salvage nuclear deal
Trump Supports Labeling Antifa A ‘Major Organization Of Terror’
A Tale of Two Jeffreys: How the Virgin Islands Welcomed a Rich Sex Offender—and Punished a Poor One
N. Korea says missile test was 'solemn warning' to S. Korea
U.S. Supreme Court lets Trump use disputed funds for border wall
Grasshoppers invade Las Vegas Strip
Mueller’s Testimony: A Complete Disaster for Liberals
Iran to meet nuclear deal members
Russian Police Arrest 1,000 In Mass Protest Over Moscow Election
Jeremy Corbyn Says He Is 'Fit And Ready' to Fight Boris Johnson At A General Election
Game Of Thrones' Nathalie Emmanuel Has No Time For That Controversial Fan Petition
France's Macron to host Putin ahead of G7 summit
Russian police arrest over 1,000 in Moscow election protest
From Africa to Mexico: How far would you go for the American dream?
Europeans stall on mission to protect tankers in Gulf after Raab calls for joint patrols with US
Impeachment Would Probably Cost Democrats the House
‘Fox & Friends’ Hosts Laugh as Brian Kilmeade Says Trump Has ‘Policy of Underreacting’
Jordyn Woods Has ‘Zero Chance’ Of Reconciling With Kylie Jenner After James Harden Hangout
Priyanka Chopra Cuddles Up To Hubby Nick Jonas & Rocks Pink Bikini In Stunning Birthday Pics
Russi Taylor, voice of Minnie Mouse, dies at 75
Holloway beats Edgar, defends featherweight title
Jessica Alba wants to learn Spanish
Donald Trump and Boris Johnson working on 'very substantial' post-Brexit trade deal
Sorry, AOC: Socialism is the Zombie Ideology of Our Time
Georgia could be ordered to use paper ballots over fears electronic voting machines vulnerable to hacking
Climate change warning as Arctic Circle burning at record rate
Police arrest Scottish rape suspect who may have faked death
India boosts Hindu pilgrimage to holy cave in conflict-torn Kashmir
Trump Loses It On Fox News Over Latest 2020 Poll
SKoreans, Russians returned days after boat drifts to NKorea
A US Reality TV Expert Swapped Versions Of Love Island With A UK Super Fan – Here's Their Verdicts
'Will & Grace' Ending With Upcoming Season
Netflix Canceling ‘Tuca & Bertie’ Is a Disappointing Loss for TV (Column)
UK Weather: Warning Issued As Heatwave Gives Way To Downpours
Minnie Mouse Voice Actress Russi Taylor Dies Aged 75
Bye, Bye F-35: The Navy's F/A-XX 6th Generation Fighter Is Coming
Sudan generals, protest leaders, to meet rebel chief in S.Sudan
Russian officials in Iran visit Russian members of detained UK vessel
Murdered Israelis involved in 'money laundering,' says Mexico government
Moscow police arrest hundreds at rally for fair elections: monitor
If Young People Watch Love Island As Sex Education, Should We Be Worried?
Boris Johnson and Donald Trump Are Peak White Male Privilege
YouTube's Plan To Rein In Conspiracy Theories Is Failing
Two Weeks Of Holiday Binge Drinking Can Be 'Acutely Toxic To The Liver', Expert Warns
Antifa: Trump says he could declare antifascist movement a terrorist organisation
Paris Digs in on Digital Tax as Trump Floats Wine Tariffs
No 'day in court': U.S. deportation orders blindside some families
Student group says Harvard failed to address racist messages
Ex-Nazi testimony casts fresh doubt on 1933 Reichstag blaze: media
Man accidentally shot dead by own passenger in ‘failed drive-by attempt’
US and Guatemala sign agreement to restrict asylum cases
A foldable smartphone that’s better in every way than the Galaxy Fold just leaked
Iran ships stranded in Brazil are set to depart: officials
Guatemala agrees to new migration measures to avoid Trump sanctions threat
The Latest: 19 troops arrested in migrant smuggling case
Boko Haram kills 23 mourners after Nigeria funeral
UK PM Johnson tells EU: ditch the backstop or there will be no-deal Brexit
Russian police arrest hundreds at Moscow election protest
Friends remember victims of shooting rampage in Los Angeles
Nadler: We’re Pursuing a De Facto Impeachment Inquiry
Moscow police arrest hundreds at rally for fair elections
Border Patrol Arrests 7 Migrants Who Entered Maine Illegally From Canada
Pelosi denies curbing impeachment push as Dems seek grand jury secrets
Russian police arrest more than 1,000 in Moscow protest
Epstein case: judge agrees to keep documents on 2008 plea deal secret
CNN Anchor Chokes Up While Defending Baltimore From Trump's Racist Attacks
Bones of girl who vanished 34 years ago found at Colorado pipeline site
Sebastian Kurz accused of secretly destroying hard drives in oligarch far-Right scandal
US, Guatemala sign controversial asylum deal
Flags of inconvenience: noose tightens around Iranian shipping
North Korean economy shrinks at fastest rate in 21 years under US sanctions and drought
At least 7 dead as quakes shake northern Philippine isles
Trump signs ‘cruel and illegal’ deal with Guatemala to stop asylum seekers getting to US
Trump threatens to investigate Obama: ‘Let's subpoena all of his records’
Indian navy rescues hundreds stranded on train in floods
The Mueller Report’s Fundamental Dodge
Everything You Wanted to Know About the New Sniper Rifles the Military Is Getting
Two dogs escape animal shelter and kill 29 cats in Alabama
‘Fox Friends’ Hosts Laugh as Brian Kilmeade Says Trump Has ‘Policy of Underreacting’
Ivanka Trump and Jared Kusher to be ordered to hand over private emails and texts
Nicki Minaj Hints At Being Married And Pregnant In New Chance The Rapper Collab. Could It Be True?
Trump attacks another African American lawmaker, and calls Baltimore a 'disgusting, rat and rodent infested mess'
Vettel 'bitter' as Ferrari endures qualifying nightmare in Germany
Nadine Dorries joins Department of Health and Social Care
Trump administration plan for Bears Ears slammed as 'recklessly' weakening protections
US drug busts in Pacific net cocaine worth $350 mn
Why Democrats Are Further Away From Impeachment Than Ever
Trump news - live: Impeachment chances grow after bid to unseal grand jury evidence, as president attacks Macron and threatens Obama probe
Taliban vows future Afghanistan won't be terrorists' hotbed
Eight killed as quakes hit far northern Philippines
Will Turkey Buy Russian Su-35s Instead of F-35s?
Brexit is a 'massive economic opportunity': PM Johnson
Sorry, AOC and Bernie Sanders: Scandinavia Is No Socialist Paradise
School will accept donations to cover student lunch debt after threatening child with foster care
How North Korea Could Launch a Nuclear War from the Sea
Iran ships stranded in Brazil to depart this weekend: officials
Buckingham Palace Denies Harry And Meghan Told Neighbours Not To Speak To Them
Ex-Swedish Prime Minister Warns Trump To Back Off A$AP Rocky Case
Leonardo DiCaprio's girlfriend Camila Morrone defends 22-year age gap
Woman dies while trying to reach ‘Into the Wild’ bus in Alaska
German GP: Ferrari top in Germany as Gasly crashes
Boris Johnson Says Politicians Have 'Failed' In The North Of England
'Blood Everywhere' – Passenger 'Dressed As Clown' Sparks Mass Brawl On Cruise Ship
MSNBC Host Says Democrats Aren’t Going To ‘Play Fair’ To Put Trump In Jail
Man killed by ‘brain-eating’ amoeba after swimming in lake
Airline asks two strangers to share hotel room with one bed after missing flight
From Europe to the Arctic, temperature records tumble in 2019
Imagine This: F-35s Going to War (Accompanied by Stealth Drone 'Wingman')
Russia warns British media after RT fined for coverage of poisoned spy
US financier Epstein found injured in cell after possible suicide attempt: media
Love Island Fans Devastated As Twist Means Ovie Could Lose Out On A Place In The Final
Jake Gyllenhaal Says Heath Ledger Had No Time For Brokeback Mountain Homophobia
Hong Kongers defy police ban and gather for 'anti-triad' rally
Honduras: Where climate change and mass migration have created a village of women
Irish PM says no-deal Brexit could lead to united Ireland
U.S. lawmakers delay action to hold Trump adviser Conway in contempt
Trump Says He And Boris Johnson Are Already Working On A 'Very Substantial' Post-Brexit Trade Deal
How To Crack An Egg Perfectly, Without Getting Shell Everywhere
Man With Burglary Tools Arrested Near Taylor Swift's Beachfront Mansion
Amber Heard Denies Putting Out Cigarette On Johnny Depp's Face
Surprise ‘city-killer’ asteroid almost hit Earth, whizzing by at 15 miles a second
Joe Jonas, Sophie Turner’s dog struck, killed by car in New York City
Kylie Jenner Unfollows Jordyn Woods After She’s Seen Dancing With Khloe’s Ex James Harden
Twitter reports small user growth and small profits
President Donald Trump Calls For Investigation Into Obama Book Deals
John Ferriter dead: Piers Morgan's manager dies aged 59
Supreme Court allows Trump to use military funds for border wall
Diego Costa scores four and is sent off as Atlético thrash Real Madrid in friendly
'As If The ‘B’ In BAME Is Silent': Are Javid And Patel A Victory For All Ethnic Minorities?
Massive manhunt in Canadian wilderness for teen murder suspects
Amanda Knox: Yes, I Asked Supporters to Donate to My Wedding But It’s Not a Crowdfunder
Justice Department approves $26.5 billion T-Mobile and Sprint merger
U.S. Maximum Pressure on Iran Unsettles Syria's Kurds
Blunder sees Donald Trump appear with fake presidential seal mocking golf and Russia links
Let's Talk About Having Sex On Your Period
Jo Swinson Might Be Against Brexit – But The Lib Dems Were Part Of Its Making
Are We Handling The Bee Crisis All Wrong?
Why Some People Have A Higher Alcohol Tolerance Than Others
Five Things Boris Johnson Has Promised To Do That Have Nothing To Do With Brexit
Donald Trump's Decision To Resume Federal Executions, Explained For Brits
This Photographer Asks Elderly Couples To Pose For Engagement-Style Photos
Stealth Rules: Israel's F-35I Adir Is the First to Attack an Enemy
WHO says e-cigarettes 'undoubtedly harmful'
Trump denies tariff exemption for the Mac Pro, tells Apple to ‘make them in the USA’
U.S. presidential hopeful Harris would spend $60 billion on historically black colleges
Trump news - live: President invents imaginary word as bizarre propaganda video shown to right-wing youth group emerges
No, McConnell Isn’t ‘Moscow Mitch’
Ex-MSNBC Host Krystal Ball: MSNBC’s Russia ‘Conspiracies’ Have Done ‘Immeasurable Harm’ to the Left
Trump speech: Staffer responsible for fake US presidential seal with Russian eagles and golf clubs fired
U.S. tax collectors urge owners of virtual currencies to pay back taxes, file amended returns
Ultimate Showdown: America's F-15C Eagle vs Russia's Su-57
'Unprecedented': more than 100 Arctic wildfires burn in worst ever season
SC murder suspect planned escape with fire, attack on guards
Slain Ole Miss Sorority Sister Called Accused Killer ‘Crazy Aggressive’: Friend
Today's Climate Change Is Worse Than Anything Earth Has Experienced in the Past 2,000 Years
Turkey determined to destroy 'terror corridor' in Syria
Senate Intel Committee Confirms Russians Hacked Election Systems in 50 States, Didn’t Change Vote Totals
From Sharon Tate and Bruce Lee to Rick Dalton and Cliff Booth, here's what's real and what's fake in 'Once Upon a Time in Hollywood'
‘Venom 2’: Andy Serkis, ‘Bumblebee’ Helmer Among Candidates to Direct
Trump speaks in front of fake presidential seal mysteriously manipulated to feature Russian eagles and golf clubs
Father of slain Mississippi student Ally Kostial shares heartbreaking photo on day of her vigil
EU partners warn Johnson against Brexit 'provocations'
Nancy Pelosi and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez meet to ‘get on same page’ after party infighting
Ruth Bader Ginsburg praises Brett Kavanaugh as 'very decent' man
Democrats Raise Impeaching Trump in Suit for Mueller's Evidence
A look at the 5 federal death row inmates facing execution
US teenager detained at border lost 26 pounds in a month: 'It was inhumane how they treated us'
India farmers shocked as suspected meteorite crashes into rice field
Ex-Host Krystal Ball: MSNBC’s Russia ‘Conspiracies’ Have Done ‘Immeasurable Harm’ to the Left
House panel approves subpoenas for Trump officials' private emails
2020 presidential candidate Kamala Harris introduces a plan to invest $60 billion in historically black colleges
Photo of mother begging Mexican guard becomes symbol of migrants' struggle
Why the B-21 Stealth Bomber Could Be a the Ultimate Game Changer
The death of Neil Armstrong and a $6 million secret
Marcus Hutchins, The Hacker Who Saved The NHS, Spared Jail Sentence For Creating Malware
These New Conservative Party Ministers Have Just Been Revealed
Big Mouth Scores Three-Season Renewal From Netflix
Emmys: This Year’s Telecast Will Include a Whopping 27 Awards Handed Out on Air
‘Once Upon a Time in Hollywood’ Billboard Vandalized to Blast ‘Pedowood’
Bindi Irwin revealed how she plans to honor late dad Steve Irwin in her wedding to Chandler Powell
SpaceX’s Starhopper Makes Its First Free Flying Leap
Amy Schumer Comedy ‘Love, Beth’ Gets Hulu Series Order As Part Of First-Look Deal
Miley Cyrus Claps Back At MTV VMAs and Says There’s ‘No Way’ She’ll Perform After Being Snubbed
Jimmy Patton, Sibling Of The Chuckle Brothers, Dies Aged 87
Sharon Tate’s 1969 Murder Began a Sorry Chapter in Hollywood History
Chance the Rapper Dropped $30,000 on Postmates Since 2014
Close