Close
Date TimeJuly 15, 2019
Voice

Kamala Harris might be surging – but her record will soon catch up with her
A leftward moving party is hungry for change. Just like Joe Biden, Kamala Harris’ past will prove to be a liability‘Harris is talking about financial industry abuses, but she’s doing fundraisers with a Wells Fargo executive.’ Photograph: Vernon Ogrodnek/APThe first pair of Democratic presidential primary debates showed how wide open the field is. Former vice-president Joe Biden came in with a comfortable lead, but stumbled during the debates and has dropped in the polls since.California senator Kamala Harris emerged the victor after the debate, confronting Biden on his past chummy relations with segregationist senators and vehement opposition to busing policies meant to integrate public schools. According to one poll, she’s now within two points of him.Joe Biden had a couple things going for him: he was connected to a popular Obama administration and he is still widely perceived as being electable. For stalwart Democratic voters, preventing a second term for Trump and an ever-rightward moving Republican party is a key priority.Biden might have stood out with his relatively conservative stances on healthcare, the environment, financial regulations and other issues that the Democratic base cared about – but at least he seemed like a safe bet to take on Trump. But now with the former vice-president crumbling under debate pressure and committing a seemingly endless string of gaffes, his electability may now be in question.The Biden team is constantly talking about “Obama-Biden” accomplishments, trying to inexorably tie him to the first black president’s legacy, but the more people find out about his own record, the more they’re turned off by it. The same will be true of Kamala Harris, a candidate who says all the right things on the debate stage, is surging in the polls, but will soon find out that positive attention may soon turn into negative scrutiny.> Harris is talking about financial industry abuses, but she’s doing fundraisers with a Wells Fargo executiveHarris is talking about financial industry abuses, but she’s doing fundraisers with a Wells Fargo executive. Though often glibly compared to Obama, Harris’s policy triangulations, donor-base ties, and questionable political past are all reminiscent of Hillary Clinton. Take her stance on what was once seemingly her strongest policy stances. Harris was an initial endorser of Bernie Sanders’s 2017 healthcare bill, which would have set up a Medicare for All, single-payer system. Such a plan would get rid of private insurance middlemen, and improve health outcomes and efficiency across the country. “Let’s eliminate all of that. Let’s move on,” she said at a January town hall.Discussing her mother’s battle with colon cancer, Harris declared that “healthcare should be a right.”When candidates were asked during the debate whether they would “abolish private insurance in favor of a government-run plan”, she joined Bernie Sanders in raising her hand. That’s all fine and good, a brave stance that could have been followed up with an explanation telling millions of curious Americans that they can still keep seeing their regular doctors, only in our future universal healthcare system they no longer will have to deal with insurance companies and the accompanying hefty deductible and premium payments.Instead, she beat a hasty retreat. The morning after the debate, she said she had misunderstood the question and certainly believed the private insurance would continue to play a role providing supplementary coverage. In other words, she would keep around the same companies responsible for our failed healthcare system and allow them to rally their forces to undermine a Medicare for All plan. (Most Americans favor getting rid of private insurance, when told they can keep their doctors.)It’s no wonder that likely Democratic voters see Bernie Sanders as the best candidate to handle health policy – agree or disagree, he’s consistent, and has been standing firm for single-payer as others vacillate. Why trust newcomers to progressive stances over someone who has been saying the same thing for decades?Part of Harris’s dilemma must stem from the fact that she sees that her party’s voters are moving leftward, and sees Biden’s centrist vulnerabilities, but is at the same time reliant on far-from-progressive campaign donors. A recent New York Times headline captures the situation well: “Wall Street Donors Are Swooning for Mayor Pete. (And They Like Biden and Harris, Too.)”Harris is talking about financial industry abuses, but she’s doing fundraisers with a Wells Fargo executive, Miguel Bustos, implicated in the company’s fake accounts scandal. When it comes time to take on big banking interests, is it unreasonable to assume that she’ll be less willing to challenge the sector than, say, Senator Warren?And let’s not forget about racial justice, an issue Harris expertly used to contest Biden’s record. But what will happen when people start to pay closer attention to her history as California attorney general. Harris can talk about her past as a young black girl who personally benefited from school integration. But what about the young black people she sent to prison for drug violations? What about the poor mothers trying to get by in a society that gives them no support that Harris threatened to jail and fine if their kids didn’t show up on time to school?Some political evolutions are genuine, and Harris’s “law-and-order” past wasn’t out of place in the Democratic party at the time. But that old wisdom is now being called into question. It’s hard to imagine that a party tacking to the left in an increasingly polarized country is about to elect a criminal prosecutor as its nominee.For now, Sanders is still among the frontrunners but has some ground to make up. His debate performance was mediocre, and he needs to appeal better to older voters still in the Biden camp. But by having a record that matches his rhetoric and by avoiding monied interests, he’s showing that campaigns can be run on a very different basis than Harris is running hers.Bernie Sanders raised $24m in the second quarter of 2019. The workers that donated to him the most were teachers. His largest sum came from Walmart workers. That shouldn’t be a surprise – when other candidates were holding lavish fundraisers, Sanders was raising hell at a Walmart shareholder meeting, denouncing the Walton family’s greed and calling for the company to pay a living wage to its employees.That’s how you break from a stale establishment consensus. That’s how you actually show Americans that you’re different and that you care. That’s the type of angry and earnest politics that can beat President Trump. Kamala Harris isn’t just not leftwing enough to be the Democratic party’s nominee, she’s also not bold enough to win a presidential election and bring about the change we desperately need. * Bhaskar Sunkara is the founding editor of Jacobin magazine and a Guardian US columnist. He is the author of The Socialist Manifesto: The Case for Radical Politics in an Era of Extreme Inequality




The father of modern computing: Alan Turing's legacy
Brittany Zamora: Teacher who had sex with 13-year-old boy jailed for 20 years
Guatemala court blocks signing of migration deal with US
Erdogan says Trump can waive sanctions on Turkey for Russian defense purchase
Brand new Apple Watches start at all-time low of $169 in this unprecedented Prime Day blowout
How Iran Might Fight a War Against America (Thanks to Russia)
Some Iranian women take off hijabs as hard-liners push back
Desperate for next fix -- heroin-based 'nyaope' grips S.Africa
As Epstein bail fight looms, feds say evidence growing daily
South Korea Warns Japanese Economic Blow Could Backfire
The B-2 Stealth Bomber Is Now 30 Years Old. Take a Look Inside
Neo-Nazi faces sentencing in murder of protester in Charlottesville, Virginia
Holy cow: Sony wireless noise cancelling headphones are just $100 for Prime Day 2019
Populist China-friendly mayor to face President Tsai Ing-wen in Taiwan election clash
Men Literally Died for that Flag, You Idiots
Libya Says Missile Find Shows France Is Backing Haftar Offensive
Afghan radio station shuts down after threats by suspected Taliban
Zimbabwe inflation rate soars to 175%
Meet the Powerful German G3 Assault Rifle
'Racially charged, xenophobic, lowest-rung slur': All the words apart from racist used by newspapers and sites to describe Trump's racist tweets
The Latest: Biden offers health plan 'public option' details
Democrat Booker unveils plan for Americans to age at home
As China locks up Muslims in Xinjiang, it opens its doors to tourists
Populist pro-China mayor to face Tsai in Taiwan presidential clash
South Korea calls Japan reports of North Korea sanctions breach 'grave challenge'
China-friendly Taiwan mayor beats Foxconn's Gou in opposition's presidential primary
China second quarter GDP growth slows to 27-year low as trade war bites, more stimulus seen
Showcase child detention center is clean and bright but it's still a jail
Leave the US, Trump tells liberal congresswomen of color
European leaders fail to grasp 'hardening' of UK view on Brexit, Latvia warns
Salvadoran accused of abortion faces retrial, hefty sentence
Carmaker PSA in reverse as Chinese sales hit a wall
Jeffrey Epstein accused of paying $350,000 to potential witnesses in underage sex case
'You're better than that:' Geraldo Rivera hits back at Trump for telling progressive freshman congresswomen to 'go back' to 'broken and crime infested' countries
President Trump's War Power Delusions
In Iran, some take off their hijabs as hard-liners push back
As Big Little Lies airs its penultimate episode, what exactly happened this season?
Facebook-Driven Area 51 Storming May Be Countered With Force, Says US Air Force
Hillary Clinton attacks Trump over tweet aimed at progressive congresswomen
Charles Levin, Hollywood actor, found dead
Congo confirms 1st Ebola case in city of Goma
WWE Extreme Rules Results: Brock Lesnar cashes in MITB contract; The Undertaker, Roman Reigns stand tall
China second quarter GDP growth slows to 27-year low, more stimulus expected
S.Africa's Zuma to take centre stage at graft inquiry
The Latest: Hong Kong police fight with protesters
Donald Trump tells Democrat congresswomen to 'go back' to where they came from in 'racist' tweet
Bose’s new noise cancelling headphones still aren’t as good as Sony’s WH1000XM3, which are $60 off today
Note to Trump: Iran Would Need 1 Year to Build a Nuclear Weapon
China-friendly Taiwan mayor beats Foxconn's Gou in opposition party's presidential primary
One dies, hundreds evacuate after 7.3 quake in Indonesia
Gina Miller to Sue Government If Johnson Suspends Parliament
Trump under fire for 'racist' attack on US congresswomen
NY mayor criticized for being on campaign trail during blackout
Churches jump into action with threat of immigration sweeps
Trump ‘pulled out of Iran nuclear deal to spite Obama’, says Kim Darroch in new leaked memo
How China's crime crackdown has spooked expats used to wilder living
Rare sea turtles smash nesting records in Georgia, Carolinas
Ponzi Scheme Victims Say Epstein Swindled Them
Trump tells Democratic congresswomen to 'go back' to 'fix' countries they came from
Acosta’s Sweetheart Deal Likely to Foreclose Epstein’s SDNY Prosecution
Guatemala president calls off US meeting with Trump
Hong Kong police fight with protesters amid rising tensions
Report: A $15 Minimum Wage Would Be an Economic Disaster
This top-rated $50 4K action cam is just as good as a $350 GoPro for most people
India calls off Moon mission launch 56 minutes before blast-off
Dozens detained in Moscow as opposition demands to be included in vote
Boy slips through Heathrow Security to board British Airways flight to Los Angeles
Inside Epstein network, layer upon layer to protect the boss
A healthy lifestyle may offset genetic risk for Alzheimer's
Police: 69-year-old man dies after attacking migrant jail
Puerto Rico governor rejects calls to resign amid scandal
Hurricane Barry photos show an otherworldly city, deep under water
Egypt's 'bent pyramid', a 4,600-year old landmark in ancient construction, opens to visitors
U.S. grants visa to Iran's Zarif for U.N. meeting this week: sources
ICE raids are under way in New York as Trump administration targets 2,000 undocumented immigrants across US
Taiwanese president courts ally Haiti during Caribbean tour
10 deals you don’t want to miss on Sunday: $20 off AirPods 2, SanDisk sale, $60 off Nest, $9 wireless charger, more
Trump claims migrant detention center visited by Pence was ‘clean but crowded’
Rain, flooding follow Storm Barry as it spins north from New Orleans
US deciding how to punish ally Turkey over Russian arms deal
Rouhani says Iran ready to talk to U.S. if sanctions lifted
How America's 30th Infantry Division Laid Waste to Nazi Panzers at Mortain
Trump ‘Go Back’ Tweets at Progressive Congresswomen Spark Furor
Shanghai leads battle against China's rising mountain of trash
Epstein investigation moves to his New Mexico 'Zorro Ranch' as alleged victims interviewed
Man dead after attacking immigration detention facility in Washington state: police
To Defeat Trump, Democrats Should Nominate Michael Bennet
Israeli minister's remarks on gays widely condemned
Hawaiian activists prepare for Mauna Kea telescope convoys
India says Deloitte misreading law in challenging government's call for ban
How the U.S. Navy Took a Battlecruiser and Made It Into an Aircraft Carrier
Hong Kong extradition protesters escalate fight in suburbs
Jennifer Lopez reschedules Madison Square Garden show after NYC blackout
Bass-heavy Bluetooth headphones that beat Beats dropped to their lowest price in this early Prime Day deal
Prospect of immigration raids across US spark anxiety, anger and protests
Pelosi sets spending demands for two-year budget deal
Teacher jailed for 20 years after having sex with 13-year-old boy
Get Ready, NATO: Russia's S-500 Is Coming Soon to a Battlefield Near You
Clashes at latest Hong Kong anti-extradition march
Trump tells Ocasio-Cortez and other female progressives to 'go back' to 'original' countries
James Bond 25 ‘to introduce FEMALE 007’ replacing Daniel Craig in ‘popcorn-dropping’ scene
Novak Djokovic beats Roger Federer in epic five-set match to win Wimbledon men’s title
Police clashes as Hong Kong protest sweeps into neighbourhood popular with Chinese shoppers
New Indictment in New York Alleges R. Kelly, Entourage ‘Used Stardom’ to Recruit Underage Girls for Sex
Trump tells Congresswomen to 'go back' where they're from
Mall clashes at latest Hong Kong anti-extradition march
Bones found after tombs exhumed in hunt for girl who went missing in Vatican City 30 years ago
Trump Blasted Over Racist Tweets Targeting Congresswomen of Color While ‘Fox Friends’ Laughs: ‘Very Comedic’
The Latest: Tropical Storm Barry weakens to 40 mph (65 kph)
Taiwan president travels to Haiti to bolster relations in the region
Storm Barry moves inland from New Orleans, leaves rain and flooding in its wake
JetBlue flight evacuated at Newark Airport after suicide vest photo AirDropped to passenger iPhones
Germany calls for 'coalition of the willing' to take in migrants rescued from Mediterranean
Trump tells progressive freshman congresswomen to 'go back' to their 'broken and crime infested' countries
How a Modified Iraqi Falcon 50 Business Jet Nearly Destroyed a US Frigate
Netanyahu warns of 'crushing' retaliation after Hezbollah chief's remarks
Struggling in White House bid, Democrat Gillibrand seeks bump in Trump country
Donald Trump 'vandalised' Iran deal to spite Barack Obama, say latest leaked cables
Video Of An Uber Driver In South Africa Singing Opera Goes Viral
Camila Cabello Is Liking Shawn Mendes More and More: She’s Now Happy To Show It Publicly
Steph McGovern Confirms She's Pregnant With First Child In Her Own Irrepressible Way
China Claims It Knows What Caused the Fire Outbreak on India's Aircraft Carrier
France trumpets shared European defence on Bastille Day
Manhattan Gets Power Back After Blackout Chaos
Major 7.3 quake hits remote Malukus in eastern Indonesia
Top Puerto Rico officials resign in group chat scandal that ensnares governor
Storm Area 51: US military 'ready' to confront 600,000 alien-hunters threatening to break into top-secret base
Tropical storm Barry threatens heavy rains and floods as it makes landfall in Louisiana
Hungry brown bears who took over Slovenia's forests face being shot before they reach the villages
Stalled Idlib campaign shows limits of Syrian, Russian power
UK says seized Iranian oil tanker could be released
Climate change forum loses sponsor after dispute over story
Donald Trump says immigration raids across US will start on Sunday
Russia launches X-ray telescope to find 'millions' of black holes
Every Photo of Kate Middleton and Meghan Markle at Wimbledon 2019 Together
Friends, Family, Fugitives Remember Beth Chapman Of ‘Dog the Bounty Hunter’ In Aurora
Spider-Man: Far From Home Writers Explain That Big Captain Marvel Connection
Egypt Opens 2 Ancient Pyramids for the First Time Since 1965
‘Is Bernie going to come?’ Warren seizes on Sanders' Netroots absence
New York's power is restored after Manhattan spent hours in the dark
Glee's Lea Michele Honors Cory Monteith 6 Years After His Death
Scarlett Johansson Talks Freedom of Film Casting
Trump says nationwide immigration arrests to begin Sunday
Oliver Stone’s Latest Piece of Pro-Putin Propaganda May Be His Most Shameless Move Yet
2020 Democratic hopefuls: party needs to embrace progressive ideals, not Trump voters
Feds: Epstein Has Been Paying Off Alleged Accomplices
Jeffrey Epstein's New Mexico ranch linked to investigation
Sandy Hook parents lose state court appeal against Newtown over school shooting
10 deals you don’t want to miss on Saturday: $9 color LED smart bulbs, $14 Wi-Fi extender, $189 Nest, AirPods 2, more
Russia's Real Reasons for Partnering with Iran
Agony of Yazidi women torn between IS kids, or return home
Clashes erupt as Hong Kong protest targets Chinese traders
Dairy Queen worker says she was sacked after making marijuana-themed cake due to ‘manager mistake’
Why Canada Must Protect its 5G Networks from Huawei
Poker Player Dennis Blieden Charged With Embezzling $22M From StyleHaul
Planned ICE raids show Trump runs the U.S. like his business — with no idea what he's doing
Canada says another citizen detained in China amid row
Trump 'pulled out of Iran nuclear deal to spite Obama', suggests Kim Darroch in new leaked memo
See How the Army's Would-Be Stealth Helicopter Borrowed from the F-35
House Democrats who tangled with leader not backing down
Turkey receives first delivery of Russian S-400 missile system: Ankara
Meet Sturmgewehr 57: Sig Sauer's Very First 'Battle' Rifle
UK envoy said Trump ditched Iran deal to spite Obama: report
Michigan Man Allegedly Shot Two Men ‘Because They Were Gay’: Prosecutors
UK police identify suspect behind leaked envoy memos: Sunday Times
Storm Area 51: More than 600,000 people sign up to raid secretive military base to ‘see them aliens’
Appeals court blocks Trump's attempt to allow firms to deny insurance coverage for birth control on moral grounds
Police: Man dies after attacking immigration prison
Vatican mystery over missing girl deepens as bones are found
Hong Kong protesters clash with police on border with mainland China
Curiosity rover is seen creeping up a rugged Martian mountain
Facebook's $5 billion fine adds $10 billion to company's value
TV presenter Emily Hartridge dies in scooter crash
Teacher Brittany Zamora, 28, who had sex with boy, 13, while his pal watched gets 20 years jail
Corbyn And McCluskey Round On Watson Over Anti-Semitism Row With Labour Boss
A sorority canceled its convention because of Hurricane Barry. Members donated 17,000 meals to storm victims
Simona Halep stuns Serena Williams to win first Wimbledon title
This Was Sig Sauer's Plan to Crush Glock's Best Guns
Sprawling storm Barry intensifies into a hurricane
How the Battle of Saipan Ended the Japanese Empire
Trump announces US ambassador to run for Tennessee Senate
Woman suing landlord for evicting her after ‘having African American guest over’
Pence views overcrowded, bad-smelling facility for detained migrants in Texas
California Utilities Get $21 Billion Backstop in Newsom Win
Merchant ships urged to avoid using private armed teams in Mideast Gulf
China says US should not allow visit by Taiwan's leader
Epstein philanthropy since sex plea included all-girl school
Unprecedented fires burn the Arctic
UK's Johnson says his comments about U.S. envoy were a factor in his resignation
‘They're well cared for’: Mike Pence defends Trump administration’s treatment of migrants on tour of detention centres
Hypersonic War: The Weapons of the Future Have Arrived
Most Germans say Merkel's health is a personal issue
Clashes as Hong Kong protesters vent at China border traders
Residents slapped with eviction notices after AP story
U.S. House passes $733-billion defense policy bill after Trump threatens veto
Pelosi’s House of Pain
U.S. lawmakers will delay Mueller testimony by a week
Police officer who lost his job after shooting an unarmed man is ‘rehired to collect lifetime pension’
Analysis: Trump pattern is create a crisis, retreat, move on
J. Lo gives Carli Lloyd a lap dance onstage to celebrate World Cup win
Close