Close
Date TimeJuly 15, 2019
Voice

Showcase child detention center is clean and bright but its still a jail
The facility at the tiny Texas town of Carrizo Springs is subcontracted to a not-for-profit but its high perimeter fence is topped with barbed wireStaff oversee breakfast at the US government’s government’s newest holding center for migrant children in Carrizo Springs, Texas. Photograph: Pool/ReutersThe searing desert sun had brought the early afternoon temperature close to 100F (38C) but, inside, the rooms were an ambient 72, the beds neatly spaced and the walls decorated with crepe paper flowers and drawings of home or the Stars & Stripes.This is the Trump administration’s newest detention center for children who have crossed the US-Mexico border and been apprehended by border patrol.The health department-controlled facility has been open for less than two weeks, in the remote, tiny town of Carrizo Springs, Texas. It’s a far cry from the sordid scenes of overcrowding, dirt and hunger emerging recently from shocked legal experts and even the government’s own inspectors who had toured Customs and Border Protection (CBP) stations. Officials are keen to show off the new center, last week offering up to three media tours a day.When the Guardian visited last Thursday, just under 200 teens aged 13 to 17 were held there, most from Honduras, Guatemala and El Salvador, who had either entered the US alone or been separated from the adults who accompanied them across the border, and they had all been transferred from other facilities.The total number of children will grow to 1,300 over the coming weeks, all housed in what the government terms a “temporary emergency influx facility”. Carrizo Springs is one of two of these controversial entities – the other, in Homestead, Florida, had become the target of 2020 Democratic candidates’ ire in June – which are run by private companies or non-profits under federal contract. Advocates say they are not subject to the same rules and oversight as government-run centers, while activists say they are less shelter-like, more prison-like.Immigrants say the Pledge of Allegiance in a writing class at the Carrizo Springs holding center in Texas. Photograph: Eric Gay/APIn contrast to images and reports from CBP stations, where children and adults are detained after first crossing the border, the Carrizo Springs facility is run by the not-for-profit Baptist Child and Family Services (BCFS) and is conspicuously clean and bright. It was recently refurbished from an old camp that accommodated men working in the local oil and gas production industries. Deep in rural Texas, it’s a 2.5-hour drive from San Antonio.There were telephones for the children to call relatives or immigration lawyers. Also medical and mental health services and English lessons; there was easy access to showers, soap, toothpaste and toothbrushes, beds and real blankets.This was all in sharp contrast to the border patrol stations that have failed to cater for an influx of families, including children and babies.At a hearing on Capitol Hill last Friday, the Democratic representative Rashida Tlaib, in impassioned testimony, said: “We have a crisis on our border – it is one of morality.”The sprawling Carrizo Springs compound has a high perimeter fence topped with barbed wire.“People say this is a detention center because the kids aren’t ‘free to go’, but where would they go?” Kevin Dinnin, BCFS’s president and CEO, said.He had said earlier that week: “I hate this mission … the only reason we do it is to keep the kids out of the border patrol jail cells,” the Washington Post reported.And, apparently, away from non-government hazards, too.BCFS’s CEO, Kevin Dinnin, talks about medical equipment at the Carrizo Springs holding center. Photograph: Pool/Reuters“To ‘free the kids’ is child abuse because of human trafficking,” Dinnin told the Guardian, without elucidating further.Mark Weber, a spokesman for the federal Office of Refugee Resettlement, an agency within the Department of Health and Human Services, said the Trump administration was committed to getting children out as quickly as possible.“Our number one goal is to unify them with their sponsor and while that’s happening we’re providing them with a quality education,” he said.Donald Trump has railed against releasing migrants. Amid strain on US systems, he and Vice-President Mike Pence blame the Democrats.Systemwide, Weber said releasing teenagers from federal facilities was taking 93 days in November 2018. After removing a fingerprint requirement for sponsors’ households, which was discouraging US-based relatives, who may be undocumented, from coming forward to claim the children while they navigate the court process, the time dropped to 45 days.Teens at Carrizo Springs enjoy religious services, regular meals, soccer and basketball, officials asserted.Visiting media are banned from using recording devices or cameras, or interacting with the children. Those visible from some distance appeared clean and calm. Their true emotions, details of their pasts, treacherous journeys from troubled Central America and within the US and their uncertain future were impossible to discern.Bunk beds are seen at the migrant detention facility at Carrizo Springs. Photograph: Handout/ReutersCarrizo Springs is a quiet town of 5,800 residents, leery of newcomers. Some speaking anonymously said residents have an “out of sight, out of mind” perspective on the center, yet worried these “foreign children” would run amok and create havoc in town.Claudia McDaniel, publisher of the Carrizo Springs Javelin newspaper, said: “Nobody wants kids to be held. I guess everybody’s like, ‘They need to go back home. They don’t have permission to be here if they’re illegal.’ It’s a big border patrol community.” She added the town was supportive of enforcing laws but also “If our government is holding these kids, that they’re doing so in a humane way.” Meanwhile, Mayra Mendoza, a San Antonio immigrant women’s rights activist who participated in a recent demonstration against the detention center, believes the people of Carrizo Springs need to “open their eyes” to the “injustices” in their own backyard.“They are picking places with the biggest land and smallest population. I think that’s by design to encounter the least resistance,” she said.Immigrants play soccer at the Carrizo Springs facility. Photograph: Eric Gay/APCharanya Krishnaswami, advocacy director for the Americas at Amnesty International USA, opposes the Carrizo Springs center. With the facility being run by a non-government agency, it is not subject to the same state-licensing requirements as other facilities, she said.“We believe state licensing is a critical form of oversight,” Krishnaswami said. “It allows state authorities to conduct inspections,” she added, as well as obliging shelters to provide comprehensive education, and follow other guidelines on how the children are looked after.Hope Frye, an attorney and volunteer advocate for migrants, echoed Krishnaswami’s concerns – and said if the government was prepared to change how it helps reunite children with their sponsors in the US, influx shelters wouldn’t even be required.“You don’t need them. You don’t have them. You set up a program designed to release kids. If you release kids expeditiously, you never need an influx shelter – and you need far fewer regular shelters.”A sign at the US Department of Health and Human Services’ unaccompanied minors migrant detention facility at Carrizo Springs, Texas. Photograph: Stringer/ReutersWith such expeditious processing, “you’d never have kids stuck anywhere”, Frye said.Back in Carrizo Springs, Juan Mancias, chairman of the Carrizo/Comecrudo Native American tribe of Texas, said locals are more focused on job opportunities than questions of ethics or morality around the treatment of migrants, although he saw a complicated picture. “There’s an economic void in the area because [of lack] of jobs, so it’s a form of gentrification by corporations coming in and creating false hopes. These jobs aren’t going to last for ever and a lot of people aren’t aware of what happens in rural areas – they really don’t care, if they got a job in the city,” he said.Most of the jobs at the new detention center have gone to out-of-towners, but a few have gone to locals.“A lot of people will do what they can to survive in these small towns,” he said.




Leave the US, Trump tells liberal congresswomen of color
European leaders fail to grasp 'hardening' of UK view on Brexit, Latvia warns
Salvadoran accused of abortion faces retrial, hefty sentence
Carmaker PSA in reverse as Chinese sales hit a wall
Jeffrey Epstein accused of paying $350,000 to potential witnesses in underage sex case
'You're better than that:' Geraldo Rivera hits back at Trump for telling progressive freshman congresswomen to 'go back' to 'broken and crime infested' countries
President Trump's War Power Delusions
In Iran, some take off their hijabs as hard-liners push back
As Big Little Lies airs its penultimate episode, what exactly happened this season?
Facebook-Driven Area 51 Storming May Be Countered With Force, Says US Air Force
Hillary Clinton attacks Trump over tweet aimed at progressive congresswomen
Charles Levin, Hollywood actor, found dead
Congo confirms 1st Ebola case in city of Goma
WWE Extreme Rules Results: Brock Lesnar cashes in MITB contract; The Undertaker, Roman Reigns stand tall
China second quarter GDP growth slows to 27-year low, more stimulus expected
S.Africa's Zuma to take centre stage at graft inquiry
The Latest: Hong Kong police fight with protesters
Donald Trump tells Democrat congresswomen to 'go back' to where they came from in 'racist' tweet
Bose’s new noise cancelling headphones still aren’t as good as Sony’s WH1000XM3, which are $60 off today
Note to Trump: Iran Would Need 1 Year to Build a Nuclear Weapon
China-friendly Taiwan mayor beats Foxconn's Gou in opposition party's presidential primary
One dies, hundreds evacuate after 7.3 quake in Indonesia
Gina Miller to Sue Government If Johnson Suspends Parliament
Trump under fire for 'racist' attack on US congresswomen
NY mayor criticized for being on campaign trail during blackout
Churches jump into action with threat of immigration sweeps
Trump ‘pulled out of Iran nuclear deal to spite Obama’, says Kim Darroch in new leaked memo
How China's crime crackdown has spooked expats used to wilder living
Rare sea turtles smash nesting records in Georgia, Carolinas
Ponzi Scheme Victims Say Epstein Swindled Them
Trump tells Democratic congresswomen to 'go back' to 'fix' countries they came from
Acosta’s Sweetheart Deal Likely to Foreclose Epstein’s SDNY Prosecution
Guatemala president calls off US meeting with Trump
Hong Kong police fight with protesters amid rising tensions
Report: A $15 Minimum Wage Would Be an Economic Disaster
This top-rated $50 4K action cam is just as good as a $350 GoPro for most people
India calls off Moon mission launch 56 minutes before blast-off
Dozens detained in Moscow as opposition demands to be included in vote
Boy slips through Heathrow Security to board British Airways flight to Los Angeles
Inside Epstein network, layer upon layer to protect the boss
A healthy lifestyle may offset genetic risk for Alzheimer's
Police: 69-year-old man dies after attacking migrant jail
Puerto Rico governor rejects calls to resign amid scandal
Hurricane Barry photos show an otherworldly city, deep under water
Egypt's 'bent pyramid', a 4,600-year old landmark in ancient construction, opens to visitors
U.S. grants visa to Iran's Zarif for U.N. meeting this week: sources
ICE raids are under way in New York as Trump administration targets 2,000 undocumented immigrants across US
Taiwanese president courts ally Haiti during Caribbean tour
10 deals you don’t want to miss on Sunday: $20 off AirPods 2, SanDisk sale, $60 off Nest, $9 wireless charger, more
Trump claims migrant detention center visited by Pence was ‘clean but crowded’
Rain, flooding follow Storm Barry as it spins north from New Orleans
US deciding how to punish ally Turkey over Russian arms deal
Rouhani says Iran ready to talk to U.S. if sanctions lifted
How America's 30th Infantry Division Laid Waste to Nazi Panzers at Mortain
Trump ‘Go Back’ Tweets at Progressive Congresswomen Spark Furor
Shanghai leads battle against China's rising mountain of trash
Epstein investigation moves to his New Mexico 'Zorro Ranch' as alleged victims interviewed
Man dead after attacking immigration detention facility in Washington state: police
To Defeat Trump, Democrats Should Nominate Michael Bennet
Israeli minister's remarks on gays widely condemned
Hawaiian activists prepare for Mauna Kea telescope convoys
India says Deloitte misreading law in challenging government's call for ban
How the U.S. Navy Took a Battlecruiser and Made It Into an Aircraft Carrier
Hong Kong extradition protesters escalate fight in suburbs
Jennifer Lopez reschedules Madison Square Garden show after NYC blackout
Bass-heavy Bluetooth headphones that beat Beats dropped to their lowest price in this early Prime Day deal
Prospect of immigration raids across US spark anxiety, anger and protests
Pelosi sets spending demands for two-year budget deal
Teacher jailed for 20 years after having sex with 13-year-old boy
Get Ready, NATO: Russia's S-500 Is Coming Soon to a Battlefield Near You
Clashes at latest Hong Kong anti-extradition march
Trump tells Ocasio-Cortez and other female progressives to 'go back' to 'original' countries
James Bond 25 ‘to introduce FEMALE 007’ replacing Daniel Craig in ‘popcorn-dropping’ scene
Novak Djokovic beats Roger Federer in epic five-set match to win Wimbledon men’s title
Police clashes as Hong Kong protest sweeps into neighbourhood popular with Chinese shoppers
New Indictment in New York Alleges R. Kelly, Entourage ‘Used Stardom’ to Recruit Underage Girls for Sex
Trump tells Congresswomen to 'go back' where they're from
Mall clashes at latest Hong Kong anti-extradition march
Bones found after tombs exhumed in hunt for girl who went missing in Vatican City 30 years ago
Trump Blasted Over Racist Tweets Targeting Congresswomen of Color While ‘Fox Friends’ Laughs: ‘Very Comedic’
The Latest: Tropical Storm Barry weakens to 40 mph (65 kph)
Taiwan president travels to Haiti to bolster relations in the region
Storm Barry moves inland from New Orleans, leaves rain and flooding in its wake
JetBlue flight evacuated at Newark Airport after suicide vest photo AirDropped to passenger iPhones
Germany calls for 'coalition of the willing' to take in migrants rescued from Mediterranean
Trump tells progressive freshman congresswomen to 'go back' to their 'broken and crime infested' countries
How a Modified Iraqi Falcon 50 Business Jet Nearly Destroyed a US Frigate
Netanyahu warns of 'crushing' retaliation after Hezbollah chief's remarks
Struggling in White House bid, Democrat Gillibrand seeks bump in Trump country
Donald Trump 'vandalised' Iran deal to spite Barack Obama, say latest leaked cables
Video Of An Uber Driver In South Africa Singing Opera Goes Viral
Camila Cabello Is Liking Shawn Mendes More and More: She’s Now Happy To Show It Publicly
Steph McGovern Confirms She's Pregnant With First Child In Her Own Irrepressible Way
China Claims It Knows What Caused the Fire Outbreak on India's Aircraft Carrier
France trumpets shared European defence on Bastille Day
Manhattan Gets Power Back After Blackout Chaos
Major 7.3 quake hits remote Malukus in eastern Indonesia
Top Puerto Rico officials resign in group chat scandal that ensnares governor
Storm Area 51: US military 'ready' to confront 600,000 alien-hunters threatening to break into top-secret base
Tropical storm Barry threatens heavy rains and floods as it makes landfall in Louisiana
Hungry brown bears who took over Slovenia's forests face being shot before they reach the villages
Stalled Idlib campaign shows limits of Syrian, Russian power
UK says seized Iranian oil tanker could be released
Climate change forum loses sponsor after dispute over story
Donald Trump says immigration raids across US will start on Sunday
Russia launches X-ray telescope to find 'millions' of black holes
Every Photo of Kate Middleton and Meghan Markle at Wimbledon 2019 Together
Friends, Family, Fugitives Remember Beth Chapman Of ‘Dog the Bounty Hunter’ In Aurora
Spider-Man: Far From Home Writers Explain That Big Captain Marvel Connection
Egypt Opens 2 Ancient Pyramids for the First Time Since 1965
‘Is Bernie going to come?’ Warren seizes on Sanders' Netroots absence
New York's power is restored after Manhattan spent hours in the dark
Glee's Lea Michele Honors Cory Monteith 6 Years After His Death
Scarlett Johansson Talks Freedom of Film Casting
Trump says nationwide immigration arrests to begin Sunday
Oliver Stone’s Latest Piece of Pro-Putin Propaganda May Be His Most Shameless Move Yet
2020 Democratic hopefuls: party needs to embrace progressive ideals, not Trump voters
Feds: Epstein Has Been Paying Off Alleged Accomplices
Jeffrey Epstein's New Mexico ranch linked to investigation
Sandy Hook parents lose state court appeal against Newtown over school shooting
10 deals you don’t want to miss on Saturday: $9 color LED smart bulbs, $14 Wi-Fi extender, $189 Nest, AirPods 2, more
Russia's Real Reasons for Partnering with Iran
Agony of Yazidi women torn between IS kids, or return home
Clashes erupt as Hong Kong protest targets Chinese traders
Dairy Queen worker says she was sacked after making marijuana-themed cake due to ‘manager mistake’
Why Canada Must Protect its 5G Networks from Huawei
Poker Player Dennis Blieden Charged With Embezzling $22M From StyleHaul
Planned ICE raids show Trump runs the U.S. like his business — with no idea what he's doing
Canada says another citizen detained in China amid row
Trump 'pulled out of Iran nuclear deal to spite Obama', suggests Kim Darroch in new leaked memo
See How the Army's Would-Be Stealth Helicopter Borrowed from the F-35
House Democrats who tangled with leader not backing down
Turkey receives first delivery of Russian S-400 missile system: Ankara
Meet Sturmgewehr 57: Sig Sauer's Very First 'Battle' Rifle
UK envoy said Trump ditched Iran deal to spite Obama: report
Michigan Man Allegedly Shot Two Men ‘Because They Were Gay’: Prosecutors
UK police identify suspect behind leaked envoy memos: Sunday Times
Storm Area 51: More than 600,000 people sign up to raid secretive military base to ‘see them aliens’
Appeals court blocks Trump's attempt to allow firms to deny insurance coverage for birth control on moral grounds
Police: Man dies after attacking immigration prison
Vatican mystery over missing girl deepens as bones are found
Hong Kong protesters clash with police on border with mainland China
Curiosity rover is seen creeping up a rugged Martian mountain
Facebook's $5 billion fine adds $10 billion to company's value
TV presenter Emily Hartridge dies in scooter crash
Teacher Brittany Zamora, 28, who had sex with boy, 13, while his pal watched gets 20 years jail
Corbyn And McCluskey Round On Watson Over Anti-Semitism Row With Labour Boss
A sorority canceled its convention because of Hurricane Barry. Members donated 17,000 meals to storm victims
Simona Halep stuns Serena Williams to win first Wimbledon title
This Was Sig Sauer's Plan to Crush Glock's Best Guns
Sprawling storm Barry intensifies into a hurricane
How the Battle of Saipan Ended the Japanese Empire
Trump announces US ambassador to run for Tennessee Senate
Woman suing landlord for evicting her after ‘having African American guest over’
Pence views overcrowded, bad-smelling facility for detained migrants in Texas
California Utilities Get $21 Billion Backstop in Newsom Win
Merchant ships urged to avoid using private armed teams in Mideast Gulf
China says US should not allow visit by Taiwan's leader
Epstein philanthropy since sex plea included all-girl school
Unprecedented fires burn the Arctic
UK's Johnson says his comments about U.S. envoy were a factor in his resignation
‘They're well cared for’: Mike Pence defends Trump administration’s treatment of migrants on tour of detention centres
Hypersonic War: The Weapons of the Future Have Arrived
Most Germans say Merkel's health is a personal issue
Clashes as Hong Kong protesters vent at China border traders
Residents slapped with eviction notices after AP story
U.S. House passes $733-billion defense policy bill after Trump threatens veto
Pelosi’s House of Pain
U.S. lawmakers will delay Mueller testimony by a week
Police officer who lost his job after shooting an unarmed man is ‘rehired to collect lifetime pension’
Analysis: Trump pattern is create a crisis, retreat, move on
J. Lo gives Carli Lloyd a lap dance onstage to celebrate World Cup win
Serena Williams: 'I don't read' stories about BFF Duchess Meghan
Why Dog the Bounty Hunter hasn't fulfilled late wife Beth Chapman's final wishes
Federal R. Kelly Investigation Uncovered 20 Underage Sex Tapes
Tropical Storm Barry: New Orleans flooding risk; storm path; track; latest weather forecast, live updates
Trump Says Ocasio-Cortez Was ‘Very Disrespectful’ Toward Pelosi
Taiwanese president shores up support in crisis-hit Haiti
Billionaire's New Mexico ranch linked to investigation
Chevron spills 800,000 gallons of oil, water in California
London police officer who spiked drink and raped Tinder date is jailed for 15 years in Antigua
Dead Drone: Are Iran and America Headed Towards a Bloody War?
US man accused of sex abuse at Kenyan orphanage he founded
The Jewish Group Taking on ICE — and the ‘Concentration Camp’ Taboo
Sudan's desert nomads untouched by Bashir's downfall
Hong Kong protesters march near border to target traders from China
Will Nationalism Poison Ukraine's New President?
Just How Stealthy Are France's Rafales F4.2s?
E Jean Carroll says she received death threats after accusing Trump of rape
New Mexico AG wants new sex offender law amid Epstein probe
New Zealanders give up weapons after mosque killings
R. Kelly appears in court on federal sex crime charges; singer to remain in custody until at least Tuesday
Body camera video shows Hannah Williams fatally shot by officer on freeway appeared to have handgun
Pence visits migrant detention facilities and calls on Congress to act
Labor Secretary Acosta resigns amid fallout over Epstein plea deal
Ruining a country near you soon: the beta males who think they’re alphas | Marina Hyde
Tyler Skaggs' mother threw out the first pitch. Then his teammates threw a no-hitter
Hawaii governor declares emergency for Maui wildfires
Hong Kong protests augur murky outlook for financial hub
Air Canada flight makes emergency landing in Hawaii
Close