Close
Date TimeJuly 13, 2019
VoiceThis isn't how punishment is meant to work
Facebooks $5 billion fine adds $10 billion to companys value
What just happened? The big story yesterday was the FTC hitting Facebook with a record fine of $5 billion, following numerous scandals around the handling of personal data. But markets appeared happy with the fine, and sent Facebook’s market-cap up by over $10 billion, entirely negating the punitive action.
Yesterday, we reported that the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) had levied a $5 billion fine against Facebook as punishment for a string of breaches, scandals and controversies.
In almost any other context a $5 billion fine would be huge – not only as a punitive measure, but also in signalling just how poorly the business in question had behaved. But in the context of Facebook, given its size, reach and worth, $5 billion is little more than a slap on the wrist. So much so, that following news of the FTC’s decision, the social media giant’s stock price rose by 1.81%, adding $10.4 billion to their market valuation.
Markets have rewarded Facebook for getting off so lightly, covering the cost of the fine and adding another $5 billion to the company’s coffers.
Many have been quick to point out the flaw in this effort to hold such a mammoth company to account. Senator and Democratic Presidential candidate, Elizabeth Warren, called it a “drop in the bucket penalty,” tweeting our renewed calls for Facebook to be broken up.
There’s no question that $5 billion is a lot of money, but given that Facebook made $22 billion in profit last year, and another $15 billion in revenues last quarter, many people think that the punishment doesn’t fit the crime.
It should be said that the FTC’s decision wasn’t only monetary. The Washington Post reports that Facebook “may have to document every decision it makes about data before offering new products, keep closer watch over third-party apps that tap users’ information, and require its top executives, including CEO Mark Zuckerberg, to attest that the company adequately has protected privacy.” Though it seems reasonable to wonder why none of those things were mandatory to begin with.

Related Stories
Dominic Cummings: Labour Says A Whistleblower Has Raised Serious Concerns About PMs AideDominic Cummings: Labour Says A Whistleblower Has Raised 'Serious Concerns' About PM's Aide
Cops Bust Unicorn Protesting White Supremacy at Indiana Farmer’s MarketCops Bust Unicorn Protesting White Supremacy at Indiana Farmer’s Market
Family Of Amelia Bambridge Urge Social Media Users To Report Graphic Pictures Circulating OnlineFamily Of Amelia Bambridge Urge Social Media Users To Report Graphic Pictures Circulating Online
Klobuchar attacks Bloomberg and Buttigieg as Democrat infighting growsKlobuchar attacks Bloomberg and Buttigieg as Democrat infighting grows
SPAC Nation Scandal: Church Fighting Knife Crime Fails To Act On Rogue Pastors Flourishing In Its RanksSPAC Nation Scandal: Church Fighting Knife Crime Fails To Act On Rogue Pastors Flourishing In Its Ranks
Exclusive: Tory Ministers Accused Of Spending Public Cash On Facebook Ads In Election Swing SeatsExclusive: Tory Ministers Accused Of Spending Public Cash On Facebook Ads In Election Swing Seats
SPAC Nation: Allegations Of Safeguarding Abuses In Trap Houses Linked To Controversial ChurchSPAC Nation: Allegations Of Safeguarding Abuses In 'Trap Houses' Linked To Controversial Church
Google Gathering Health Care Data on Millions of Americans with Secret ‘Project Nightingale’Google Gathering Health Care Data on Millions of Americans with Secret ‘Project Nightingale’
Labour Candidate Branded Women Campaigning Against Strip Club Trashy SWERFsLabour Candidate Branded Women Campaigning Against Strip Club 'Trashy SWERFs'
Nancy Pelosi Is Worried 2020 Candidates Are on Wrong TrackNancy Pelosi Is Worried 2020 Candidates Are on Wrong Track
Latest News
Indian border officials on lookout for fugitive cosmic guruIndian border officials on lookout for fugitive cosmic guru
Supreme Court temporarily blocks resumption of federal executionsSupreme Court temporarily blocks resumption of federal executions
As unions turn the screws, French PM says pension reform unavoidableAs unions turn the screws, French PM says pension reform unavoidable
Passport of elusive Maltese professor Joseph Mifsud turns up in lost-and-found office in MadeiraPassport of elusive Maltese professor Joseph Mifsud turns up in lost-and-found office in Madeira
Jeremy Warmsley: A Year reviewJeremy Warmsley: A Year review
European roundup: Drama as Gladbach beat Bayern; Napoli slump continuesEuropean roundup: Drama as Gladbach beat Bayern; Napoli slump continues
Iran releases US hostage held for three years as suspected spy in prisoner swapIran releases US hostage held for three years as suspected spy in prisoner swap
Saudi gunman called US nation of evil before Florida shooting, monitoring group saysSaudi gunman called US 'nation of evil' before Florida shooting, monitoring group says
Iraqis protest to defy slaughter in Baghdad as drone hits clerics homeIraqis protest to defy 'slaughter' in Baghdad as drone hits cleric's home
Indian police investigated over killings of rape suspectsIndian police investigated over killings of rape suspects
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Boris-JohnsonBoris Johnson
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Theresa-MayTheresa May
Member of Parliament of the United Kingdom
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
Dominic Cummings: Labour Says A Whistleblower Has Raised Serious Concerns About PMs AideDominic Cummings: Labour Says A Whistleblower Has Raised 'Serious Concerns' About PM's Aide
Cops Bust Unicorn Protesting White Supremacy at Indiana Farmer’s MarketCops Bust Unicorn Protesting White Supremacy at Indiana Farmer’s Market
Family Of Amelia Bambridge Urge Social Media Users To Report Graphic Pictures Circulating OnlineFamily Of Amelia Bambridge Urge Social Media Users To Report Graphic Pictures Circulating Online
Klobuchar attacks Bloomberg and Buttigieg as Democrat infighting growsKlobuchar attacks Bloomberg and Buttigieg as Democrat infighting grows
SPAC Nation Scandal: Church Fighting Knife Crime Fails To Act On Rogue Pastors Flourishing In Its RanksSPAC Nation Scandal: Church Fighting Knife Crime Fails To Act On Rogue Pastors Flourishing In Its Ranks
Exclusive: Tory Ministers Accused Of Spending Public Cash On Facebook Ads In Election Swing SeatsExclusive: Tory Ministers Accused Of Spending Public Cash On Facebook Ads In Election Swing Seats
SPAC Nation: Allegations Of Safeguarding Abuses In Trap Houses Linked To Controversial ChurchSPAC Nation: Allegations Of Safeguarding Abuses In 'Trap Houses' Linked To Controversial Church
Google Gathering Health Care Data on Millions of Americans with Secret ‘Project Nightingale’Google Gathering Health Care Data on Millions of Americans with Secret ‘Project Nightingale’
Labour Candidate Branded Women Campaigning Against Strip Club Trashy SWERFsLabour Candidate Branded Women Campaigning Against Strip Club 'Trashy SWERFs'
Nancy Pelosi Is Worried 2020 Candidates Are on Wrong TrackNancy Pelosi Is Worried 2020 Candidates Are on Wrong Track
Latest News
Indian border officials on lookout for fugitive cosmic guruIndian border officials on lookout for fugitive cosmic guru
Supreme Court temporarily blocks resumption of federal executionsSupreme Court temporarily blocks resumption of federal executions
As unions turn the screws, French PM says pension reform unavoidableAs unions turn the screws, French PM says pension reform unavoidable
Passport of elusive Maltese professor Joseph Mifsud turns up in lost-and-found office in MadeiraPassport of elusive Maltese professor Joseph Mifsud turns up in lost-and-found office in Madeira
Jeremy Warmsley: A Year reviewJeremy Warmsley: A Year review
European roundup: Drama as Gladbach beat Bayern; Napoli slump continuesEuropean roundup: Drama as Gladbach beat Bayern; Napoli slump continues
Iran releases US hostage held for three years as suspected spy in prisoner swapIran releases US hostage held for three years as suspected spy in prisoner swap
Saudi gunman called US nation of evil before Florida shooting, monitoring group saysSaudi gunman called US 'nation of evil' before Florida shooting, monitoring group says
Iraqis protest to defy slaughter in Baghdad as drone hits clerics homeIraqis protest to defy 'slaughter' in Baghdad as drone hits cleric's home
Indian police investigated over killings of rape suspectsIndian police investigated over killings of rape suspects
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Boris-JohnsonBoris Johnson
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Theresa-MayTheresa May
Member of Parliament of the United Kingdom
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
TV presenter Emily Hartridge dies in scooter crash
Teacher Brittany Zamora, 28, who had sex with boy, 13, while his pal watched gets 20 years jail
Corbyn And McCluskey Round On Watson Over Anti-Semitism Row With Labour Boss
A sorority canceled its convention because of Hurricane Barry. Members donated 17,000 meals to storm victims
Simona Halep stuns Serena Williams to win first Wimbledon title
This Was Sig Sauer's Plan to Crush Glock's Best Guns
Sprawling storm Barry intensifies into a hurricane
How the Battle of Saipan Ended the Japanese Empire
Trump announces US ambassador to run for Tennessee Senate
Woman suing landlord for evicting her after ‘having African American guest over’
Pence views overcrowded, bad-smelling facility for detained migrants in Texas
California Utilities Get $21 Billion Backstop in Newsom Win
Merchant ships urged to avoid using private armed teams in Mideast Gulf
China says US should not allow visit by Taiwan's leader
Epstein philanthropy since sex plea included all-girl school
Unprecedented fires burn the Arctic
UK's Johnson says his comments about U.S. envoy were a factor in his resignation
‘They're well cared for’: Mike Pence defends Trump administration’s treatment of migrants on tour of detention centres
Hypersonic War: The Weapons of the Future Have Arrived
Most Germans say Merkel's health is a personal issue
Clashes as Hong Kong protesters vent at China border traders
Residents slapped with eviction notices after AP story
U.S. House passes $733-billion defense policy bill after Trump threatens veto
Pelosi’s House of Pain
U.S. lawmakers will delay Mueller testimony by a week
Police officer who lost his job after shooting an unarmed man is ‘rehired to collect lifetime pension’
Analysis: Trump pattern is create a crisis, retreat, move on
J. Lo gives Carli Lloyd a lap dance onstage to celebrate World Cup win
Serena Williams: 'I don't read' stories about BFF Duchess Meghan
Why Dog the Bounty Hunter hasn't fulfilled late wife Beth Chapman's final wishes
Federal R. Kelly Investigation Uncovered 20 Underage Sex Tapes
Tropical Storm Barry: New Orleans flooding risk; storm path; track; latest weather forecast, live updates
Trump Says Ocasio-Cortez Was ‘Very Disrespectful’ Toward Pelosi
Taiwanese president shores up support in crisis-hit Haiti
Billionaire's New Mexico ranch linked to investigation
Chevron spills 800,000 gallons of oil, water in California
London police officer who spiked drink and raped Tinder date is jailed for 15 years in Antigua
Dead Drone: Are Iran and America Headed Towards a Bloody War?
US man accused of sex abuse at Kenyan orphanage he founded
The Jewish Group Taking on ICE — and the ‘Concentration Camp’ Taboo
Sudan's desert nomads untouched by Bashir's downfall
Hong Kong protesters march near border to target traders from China
Will Nationalism Poison Ukraine's New President?
Just How Stealthy Are France's Rafales F4.2s?
E Jean Carroll says she received death threats after accusing Trump of rape
New Mexico AG wants new sex offender law amid Epstein probe
New Zealanders give up weapons after mosque killings
R. Kelly appears in court on federal sex crime charges; singer to remain in custody until at least Tuesday
Body camera video shows Hannah Williams fatally shot by officer on freeway appeared to have handgun
Pence visits migrant detention facilities and calls on Congress to act
Labor Secretary Acosta resigns amid fallout over Epstein plea deal
Ruining a country near you soon: the beta males who think they’re alphas | Marina Hyde
Tyler Skaggs' mother threw out the first pitch. Then his teammates threw a no-hitter
Hawaii governor declares emergency for Maui wildfires
Hong Kong protests augur murky outlook for financial hub
Air Canada flight makes emergency landing in Hawaii
'It's powerful': Tropical storm starts lashing Louisiana
Appeals court gives Trump a win in sanctuary city case
Trump asks Supreme Court to unfreeze border wall money
Jeffrey Epstein Dodged Questions About Sex With His Dalton Prep-School Students
Hawaii governor declares emergency for Maui wildfire
Trump official resigns after climate change warning is blocked
The Latest: Mississippi River won't be as high as feared
Ninth Circuit Hands Trump Administration Win in Sanctuary-City Case
The Latest: US aware Turkey taking Russian missile system
The Queen Is the Reason Boris Johnson Would Struggle to Suspend Parliament
Epstein’s Defenses: From Due Process to Done Deal, a Glimpse
Bill Clinton Failed to Mention His Intimate 1995 Dinner With Epstein
US House votes to curb Trump powers to start Iran war
Vice President Pence Tours Border Patrol Facility With Almost 400 Men in ‘Crowded’ Cages, ‘Horrendous Stench’
AOC’s Chief of Staff Admits the Green New Deal Is Not about Climate Change
Why the Sexual Predator in the White House Needed to Get Rid of Acosta
Britain sends second warship to Gulf after Iran tanker standoff
Flynn's absence leaves hole at trial of ex-business partner
Police: Oilfield workers, truck driver killed in fiery crash
South Africa sends troops into 'warzone' township
Trump and Bill Clinton Worry About Creepy Jeffrey Epstein Connection in ‘Our Cartoon President’
Washington AG opens inquiry into NRA's financial affairs
How the Tragic Death of 1 Aircraft Carrier Sealed Imperial Japan's Fate
China to impose sanctions on US firms in Taiwan arms sale
Crackdown on immigrant families to start Sunday, Trump says
India prepares to land rover on moon in global space race
The Latest: Prosecution: Epstein could influence witness
Trump vs. Darroch: Whose Government Is 'Inept' and 'Dysfunctional?'
Pregnant woman, son die after car swept away in heavy rains
Hezbollah chief says has reduced fighters in Syria
37 countries defend China over Xinjiang in UN letter
Trump news: President sends warning to Iran after attacking AOC and Ilhan Omar in rambling presser
A Mississippi politician abides by the 'Billy Graham rule,' but his refusal to be alone with a woman other than his wife in a work setting could be illegal, according to an employment law expert
Braced for Barry: New Orleans girds for 'extreme' storm
Chess grandmaster accused of cheating after using phone on toilet during tournament
Indonesia frees Canadian convicted in child sex case
China fails to buy agricultural goods as promised: Trump
AP: Public unions see only modest decline after court ruling
Saudi Arabia and Russia among 37 states backing China's Xinjiang policy
U.S. lawmakers expected to delay Mueller testimony by a week
Duterte mocks 'ice-eating' Iceland over U.N. vote on Philippine war on drugs
Donald Trump's labour secretary Alex Acosta resigns after outcry over Andrew Epstein plea deal
Pakistan joins US-led call for Afghan ceasefire, talks
UK PM contenders say EU will drop Irish backstop for Brexit deal
EU to Cut the Flow of Funds to Turkey as Drilling Spat Heats Up
Low-cost Moon mission puts India among lunar pioneers
China warns US 'not to play with fire' regarding Taiwan
Federal court: Duggar sister privacy lawsuit can proceed
Lil Nas X blesses us with a new 'Old Town Road' remix
Ed Sheeran confirmed he's married to longtime love Cherry Seaborn
Duterte critics laud UN vote to scrutinize drug killings
TRNSMT 2019 sees Scots show off their festival style as sun shines on Glasgow Green
Oprah Winfrey praised for opening her private road during Maui fire to help evacuations
Migrants, refugees in Libyan centres must be freed: UN
Kamala Harris Shuts Down Meghan McCain for Siding With Joe Biden
Nasa chief fired as Trump administration vents frustration over moon landing delays
Why Was an American Scientist Murdered in a Nazi Bunker?
Federer prevails over Nadal, gets Djokovic in final
'Check your facts!' Andrew Neil scolded by Boris Johnson in fiery BBC interview
Jeffrey Epstein's opulent New York mansion said to contain bizarre, disturbing art
Trump’s border patrol chief 'posted in secret Facebook group' featuring violent anti-migrant content
Father chases down thief who stole car with children inside and beats him to death with help of bystanders
Trump Concedes Legal Fight to Add Citizenship Question to Census, Issues Executive Order to Get Information By Other Means
Europe's ties with Africa must change: Ghana president
Remains of Napoleon's One-Legged General Found Under Russian Dance Floor
DRC opposition figure drops activism for African Bank job
US Coast Guard filmed raiding moving submarine filled with £185m of cocaine
Trump news - live: President sends warning to Iran after attacking AOC and Ilhan Omar in rambling presser
South African court finds Zuma's son not guilty over car crash death
Democrats Counter GOP Border Proposals on Migrant Conditions
For Palestinian family, tunnel under Israel barrier leads home
Britain to send second warship to Gulf amid rising tension with Iran
The Latest: Japan blames S.Korea export control 'weaknesses'
Swedish Government Won’t Sign ‘Problematic’ UN Nuclear Treaty
China police bust bitcoin miners for stealing $3 mn in electricity
Fights break out as Taiwan's President Tsai visits New York
Despite US warnings, Russian S-400 systems land in Turkey
Radioactive uranium, whiskey and rattlesnake found in stolen car pulled over by police
Vietnam Goes From Trade War Winner to Trump Target
Epstein Offers to Put Up Mansion, Jet to Get Out of Jail
Taiwan president in U.S. after warning of threat from 'overseas forces'
Britain sending destroyer to Gulf amid Iranian threats
Miley Cyrus Says She Felt 'Ridiculous' Being Hannah Montana After Having Sex
Diane Keaton revealed that she hasn't been on a date in a whopping 35 years
Prince Harry ‘would be completely left out’ by other royals during his childhood, author claims
New Mexico, Colorado get fired up over hot peppers
Raped, widowed, homeless: Haiti's slum women abandoned to gangs
Missing girl's family lawyer: no bones in Vatican tombs
Earthquake rattles Washington state, followed by aftershock
Former Blue Peter presenter John Leslie charged with sexual assault
How Jermaine Dupri made stars of Alicia Keys, Kris Kross and more
Ed Sheeran Drops Star-Studded Collaboration Album
Russia delivers missile system to Turkey in challenge to NATO
Greece recognizes Venezuela's Guaido, in line with EU
Takeover Trap: Why Imperialist China Is Invading Africa
Turkey drills off Cyprus in bid for regional influence
Warren, Biden Campaigns Appear to Find Loophole Around Paid Internships
Nancy Pelosi’s renewed attacks on AOC aren’t just disrespectful, they’re dangerous
Envoy to Afghanistan says US not 'cutting and running'
Boris Johnson says he's not to blame for ambassador's ouster
First parts of Russian S-400 system delivered to Turkey: ministry
12,000 Years Ago, a Boy Had His Skull Squashed into a Cone Shape. It's the Oldest Evidence of Such Head-Shaping
Iran calls on Britain to release seized oil tanker immediately
Black Caucus Member Charges AOC With Playing the Race Card
Four Britons held in China, two days after drugs bust
Sudan general says coup attempt foiled
Hong Kong protesters march with mock coffin of city leader
Dog the Bounty Hunter Says He's Lost 17 Pounds in 2 Weeks Since Beth Chapman's Death
President Trump Is the Latest Critic of Facebook's Libra
Serena Williams credits Murray after beating Strycova to reach Wimbledon final
Remains of missing Kentucky mom Savannah Spurlock found after months-long search
Terry Barber show takes fans into Freddie Mercury’s world
AOC, other liberal Dems in spotlight at immigration hearing
Stuber review, Uber-set action-comedy gets stuck in first gear
AP source: Russell Westbrook going to Rockets for Chris Paul
R Kelly arrested on federal sex trafficking charges
eBay says Prime Day is mostly deals on ‘random stuff nobody really wants’
Fossil of 99 million-year-old bird with giant toe found in Burma
Trump Lost on the Census, but the Scandal Is Just Getting Started
I was terrified: Jeffrey Epstein accused of building a network of victims
AOC weeps while hearing mother’s story of toddler who died after being detained by ICE
The Latest: Police say remains are missing Kentucky woman
Taiwan former leader Ma cleared in political leaks case
Trump criticism widespread among diplomats amid Darroch resignation: ‘It could have been any of us’
Pelosi implores Democrats to unify, warning of dangers ahead
Man eaten by his own pet dogs
Harley-Davidson's electric Hog: 0 to 60 mph in 3 seconds
Trump's Pentagon pick says he won't be bullied into making 'stupid decisions'
Warren's new U.S. immigration policy would end border crossing as a crime
Fox News Hasn’t Asked Paid Contributor Ken Starr About His Pedophile Client Jeffrey Epstein
The Latest: House members request briefing on Epstein deal
2020 Democrats paint contrast with Trump on immigration
US plans Gulf naval escorts after Iranians menace UK oil tanker
Afghan women note Taliban shift after Doha talks
Cuban-Americans sue French bank over Castro-era nationalization
Britain 'recommends heightened security' for ships in Straits of Hormuz after Iran tries to block oil tanker
Man facing death penalty after murdering woman he found through Tinder 'with girlfriend'
Brazil cotton farmers sue Bayer over patent on GMO seed
The Latest: Trump approves federal declaration due to Barry
Venezuela government, opposition agree to pursue crisis talks
Venezuela seeks extradition of suspect accused of burning man to death
Head of Boeing's 737 MAX program to retire: company memo
Police: Remains found in Kentucky confirmed as missing woman
Pelosi Advises Illegal Immigrants on How to Avoid ICE
Close