Close
Date TimeJuly 10, 2019
Voice

Christian doctor lost his job after refusing to identify a six-foot-tall bearded man as ‘madam’, tribunal hears
A Christian doctor lost his job in a government department after he refused to refer to “a six-foot-tall bearded man” as ‘madam’, a tribunal heard. Dr David Mackereth, 56, claims he was sacked as a disability benefits assessor by the Department of Work and Pensions over his religious beliefs. The father-of-four alleges he was asked in a conversation with a line manager: “If you have a man six foot tall with a beard who says he wants to be addressed as ‘she’ and ‘Mrs’, would you do that?” Dr Mackereth, an evangelist who now works as an emergency doctor in Shropshire, claims his contract was then terminated over his refusal to use transgendered pronouns.  He argues that he was dismissed “not because of any realistic concerns over the rights and sensitivities of transgender individuals, but because of my refusal to make an abstract ideological pledge”. The doctor is now suing the government at an employment tribunal for discrimination on the grounds of his religious belief Credit: Andrew Fox The doctor is now suing the government at an employment tribunal for discrimination on the grounds of his religious belief. A hearing in Birmingham was told how Dr Mackereth believes transgenderism is a “delusional belief” and an ideology “which I disbelieve and detest”. In a statement admitted into evidence, he told the court: “If you believe in gender fluidity, gender is no more than one’s own fantasy about oneself.” The trained theologian and "unashamed" Christian, who has 30 years’ medical experience, secured a job as a Health and Disability Assessor at Birmingham’s Fiveways assessment centre in May 2018. He told the tribunal he was suspended the following month after being “interrogated” by his boss, James Owen, for refusing to “call any six-foot-tall bearded man ‘madam’ on his whim”. The medic claims he was told he was “overwhelmingly likely” to lose his job unless he agreed.  Dr Mackereth left his role on June 25, 2018, after an email exchange with Mr Owen in which he was instructed to follow the “process as discussed in your training”. The email read: “If however you do not want to do this, we will respect your decision and your right to leave your contract.” Dr Mackereth replied: “I am a Christian and in good conscience cannot do what the DWP is requiring of me.” He insists he did not resign his position and is the victim of direct discrimination and harassment.  Dr David Mackereth, pictured outside the employment tribunal building in Birmingham Credit: Matthew Cooper/PA  Dr Mackereth told the hearing: “The very fact a doctor can be pulled of the shop floor for an urgent interrogation about his beliefs on gender fluidity is both absurd and very sinister, even more so if it results in a dismissal.  “If something like that happened in a church setting - people being pulled out of a pew, questioned, and then excommunicated - that would be seen as an outrageous example of religious intolerance and bigotry.” The DWP argues that Dr Mackereth’s views are in breach of the 2010 Equality Act. APM, the recruitment company who hired the medic, is also being sued for religious discrimination. The company claims that the doctor’s beliefs “are not compatible with human dignity”. In a statement put before the court, Dr Mackereth said: “I appreciate that in the present political climate, somepeople, including some of those who believe they are transgender, may find my beliefs to be offensive. “However, in a free society, this is not a good enough reason to censor my beliefs and coerce me to act contrary to my conscience. “Moreover, as a doctor, my responsibility is always to act in good conscience in the best interest of the patients - not to adopt various fancies, prejudices, or delusions, to avoid offence at all cost.” Dr Mackereth added that his inherent belief is that transgenderism is a “rebellion against God, which is both pointless and sinful”. He said: “I am, of course, aware that there are men or women who believe they have been trapped in a wrong body, and I do not question the sincerity of their convictions. “A small number of such people have always existed.  Up until recently, such a belief was considered by medics to be delusional and a symptom of a medical disorder. “It is only recently that transgenderism has been recognised as normal and such delusional beliefs accepted at face value. What is responsible for that change is political pressure, not scientific evidence.” The legal case, which is listed until next week, is being supported by the Christian Legal Centre. Chief executive Andrea Williams described Dr Mackereth as “a Christian hero who chose to sacrifice his distinguished professional career rather than compromise on the Bible and his conscience”. The hearing continues.




Related Stories
Mueller Was Seeking FBI Director Job When He Met with Trump in 2017: ReportMueller Was Seeking FBI Director Job When He Met with Trump in 2017: Report
Gay Softball League Leads to Major Supreme Court Job-Bias CaseGay Softball League Leads to Major Supreme Court Job-Bias Case
When Living For The Weekend Becomes A Sign Of Job BurnoutWhen Living For The Weekend Becomes A Sign Of Job Burnout
Revealed: catastrophic effects of working as a Facebook moderatorRevealed: catastrophic effects of working as a Facebook moderator
GOP Lawmaker Resigns, Will Plead Guilty in Insider-Trading CaseGOP Lawmaker Resigns, Will Plead Guilty in Insider-Trading Case
Biden’s Rivals Are Utterly Perplexed at the Timing of Hunter’s InterviewBiden’s Rivals Are Utterly Perplexed at the Timing of Hunter’s Interview
The Media Scramble the Jets for Elizabeth Warren’s LiesThe Media Scramble the Jets for Elizabeth Warren’s Lies
Does Your Work Ban Weekend And Evening Emails – Or Should It?Does Your Work Ban Weekend And Evening Emails – Or Should It?
Peter Bradford obituaryPeter Bradford obituary
Job Interviewers Make Snap Judgements On Class Within The First 7 Words You SpeakJob Interviewers Make Snap Judgements On Class Within The First 7 Words You Speak
Latest News
Im in charge of the Hatch Act: Trump lashes out at chief of staff over potential ethics violations, report says'I'm in charge of the Hatch Act': Trump lashes out at chief of staff over potential ethics violations, report says
Atatiana Jefferson Funeral Set for Thursday After Judge Ends Family DisputeAtatiana Jefferson Funeral Set for Thursday After Judge Ends Family Dispute
Shark tears womans hands off in Polynesian paradise island attackShark tears woman's hands off in Polynesian paradise island attack
US far-right activists get four years in jail for attacking leftistsUS far-right activists get four years in jail for attacking leftists
Fears Are Growing Among Mainland Chinese Living in Hong KongFears Are Growing Among Mainland Chinese Living in Hong Kong
Tottenham v Red Star Belgrade: Champions League Group B – live!Tottenham v Red Star Belgrade: Champions League Group B – live!
Manchester City v Atalanta: Champions League Group C – live!Manchester City v Atalanta: Champions League Group C – live!
‘We don’t have to bowl a super over’: All Blacks braced for World Cup repeat | Andy Bull‘We don’t have to bowl a super over’: All Blacks braced for World Cup repeat | Andy Bull
US senator Rick Scott says 2022 Winter Olympics should not be held in ChinaUS senator Rick Scott says 2022 Winter Olympics should not be held in China
Presidential hopeful Warren rallies with Chicago teachers as strike enters fourth dayPresidential hopeful Warren rallies with Chicago teachers as strike enters fourth day
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Boris-JohnsonBoris Johnson
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Theresa-MayTheresa May
Member of Parliament of the United Kingdom
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
Mueller Was Seeking FBI Director Job When He Met with Trump in 2017: ReportMueller Was Seeking FBI Director Job When He Met with Trump in 2017: Report
Gay Softball League Leads to Major Supreme Court Job-Bias CaseGay Softball League Leads to Major Supreme Court Job-Bias Case
When Living For The Weekend Becomes A Sign Of Job BurnoutWhen Living For The Weekend Becomes A Sign Of Job Burnout
Revealed: catastrophic effects of working as a Facebook moderatorRevealed: catastrophic effects of working as a Facebook moderator
GOP Lawmaker Resigns, Will Plead Guilty in Insider-Trading CaseGOP Lawmaker Resigns, Will Plead Guilty in Insider-Trading Case
Biden’s Rivals Are Utterly Perplexed at the Timing of Hunter’s InterviewBiden’s Rivals Are Utterly Perplexed at the Timing of Hunter’s Interview
The Media Scramble the Jets for Elizabeth Warren’s LiesThe Media Scramble the Jets for Elizabeth Warren’s Lies
Does Your Work Ban Weekend And Evening Emails – Or Should It?Does Your Work Ban Weekend And Evening Emails – Or Should It?
Peter Bradford obituaryPeter Bradford obituary
Job Interviewers Make Snap Judgements On Class Within The First 7 Words You SpeakJob Interviewers Make Snap Judgements On Class Within The First 7 Words You Speak
Latest News
Im in charge of the Hatch Act: Trump lashes out at chief of staff over potential ethics violations, report says'I'm in charge of the Hatch Act': Trump lashes out at chief of staff over potential ethics violations, report says
Atatiana Jefferson Funeral Set for Thursday After Judge Ends Family DisputeAtatiana Jefferson Funeral Set for Thursday After Judge Ends Family Dispute
Shark tears womans hands off in Polynesian paradise island attackShark tears woman's hands off in Polynesian paradise island attack
US far-right activists get four years in jail for attacking leftistsUS far-right activists get four years in jail for attacking leftists
Fears Are Growing Among Mainland Chinese Living in Hong KongFears Are Growing Among Mainland Chinese Living in Hong Kong
Tottenham v Red Star Belgrade: Champions League Group B – live!Tottenham v Red Star Belgrade: Champions League Group B – live!
Manchester City v Atalanta: Champions League Group C – live!Manchester City v Atalanta: Champions League Group C – live!
‘We don’t have to bowl a super over’: All Blacks braced for World Cup repeat | Andy Bull‘We don’t have to bowl a super over’: All Blacks braced for World Cup repeat | Andy Bull
US senator Rick Scott says 2022 Winter Olympics should not be held in ChinaUS senator Rick Scott says 2022 Winter Olympics should not be held in China
Presidential hopeful Warren rallies with Chicago teachers as strike enters fourth dayPresidential hopeful Warren rallies with Chicago teachers as strike enters fourth day
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Boris-JohnsonBoris Johnson
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Theresa-MayTheresa May
Member of Parliament of the United Kingdom
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Viking bones and DNA will decay quickly as Greenland thaws
EU threatens Turkey with sanctions over Cyprus drilling: draft
Fewer F-35s? Air Force Looks to Buy 80 F-15Xs Instead
What the A-10 Warthog Would Do in a Second Korean War
Meghan McCain is now calling our Kourtney Kardashian for crying over turning 40: 'It's a bad look'
Tommy Robinson given nine-month jail sentence for contempt of court
Julio Iglesias ruled to be father of man, 43
At least seven killed as freak storm lashes Greek resorts
Tropical Storm Barry forms in Gulf, could become hurricane
Venezuela talks with opposition conclude in Barbados, no deal announced
Majority of US vets say Afghanistan war 'not worth fighting': poll
Former NFL defensive tackle Albert Haynesworth says he's in dire need of a kidney
Long Island Bagel Boss customer filmed other public tirades
Tropical Storm Barry develops in the Gulf, threatening more epic flooding in Louisiana
New Book: Former Speaker Paul Ryan’s Retirement Was An ‘Escape Hatch’ From Trump
Melvin Gordon wants new deal or he'll skip training camp, demand to be traded
Trump to announce action over census citizenship question: officials
Pelosi in escalating feud with AOC and fellow young female Democrat progressives: 'Stop tweeting about us'
AP Explains: Mideast tensions threaten key global oil route
Feds not ready to take sentencing position in Flynn case
UK Labour Party in turmoil over new anti-Semitism claims
Missing teen mystery deepens as Vatican dig reveals empty graves
The Latest: Evacuations ordered ahead of weather in the Gulf
U.S. wants 'El Chapo' in prison for life, after he hears from murder plot victim
US diplomat gets 40 months in jail over Chinese agent ties
Nearly two dozen countries unite at UN to condemn China’s mass detention of one million Muslims for first time
No bones found in Vatican tombs searched for missing girl
Bosnian Muslims mark 1995 massacre of thousands with burials
Heavy rains flood New Orleans streets in taste of storm ahead
Trump Says Deutsche Bank, Now ‘Maligned,’ Wanted His Business
Trump to ‘unlawfully’ demand citizenship question included on census despite Supreme Court ruling
Trump to announce action over census citizenship question -source
Bosnian Muslims mark 24th anniversary of Srebrenica massacre
All the people Donald Trump claims he hasn't met - despite evidence to the contrary
Britain says it fended off Iranian attempt to block its oil tanker
From hot sauce to pop gloss, US products seep into Iran
Moldova has Become a Geopolitical Battleground between Russia and the West
U.S. wants North Korea freeze as beginning, not end, of denuclearization
When the U.S. puts a border between migrant kids and their caretakers
Rare 1971 Buick GS 455 To Be Auctioned Soon
Prosecutors seek life in prison for El Chapo
AP Interview: Mayor Pete Buttigieg's straight talk on race
Iran tried to seize British oil tanker: report
US, UK will 'regret' seizing tanker off Gibraltar: Iran Guards
Turkey rejects Greek, EU claims that drilling off Cyprus illegitimate
Erdogan’s Excellent Adventure in Idlib
Ex-combat pilot Amy McGrath challenges Republican McConnell for Senate
US, Egypt warn Turkey over drilling off Cyprus
US peace envoy to Afghanistan in Beijing for meeting
Ilhan Omar calls Tucker Carlson a 'racist fool'
Britain says Iran tried to 'impede' UK tanker in Gulf
Britain says Iranian vessels tried to block tanker in Gulf
Body of Slain University of Utah Student Mackenzie Lueck Was Found Bound in Shallow Grave
Indiana teacher fired for same-sex marriage sues archdiocese
Khashoggi fallout: Saudi holidaymakers urged to shun Turkey
Mass immigration roundups in U.S. to start Sunday: New York Times
Trump defends relationship with paedophile Jeffrey Epstein and says he feels 'very badly' for Acosta
Armoured van spills thousands of dollars in cash across major highway. Police are asking for it back
Delta airlines flight makes emergency landing after broken plane part flies into engine after takeoff
Trump labor secretary who cut Epstein deal plans to slash funds for sex trafficking victims
The Latest: Iran's Guard denies any confrontation in Gulf
Some of Putin’s Top Cops Are Mobsters. Even KGB Vets Are Ashamed
Fact: America Has No Way to Attack Venezula Using Navy Aircraft Carriers
Virginia Lt. Gov. Fairfax says eyewitness backs up his story
Wrecked 1967 Ford Mustang Fastback Drives Entire Power Tour 2019
NASA shake-up in new race to the moon
Aftershocks continue in California desert
US plans to form military coalition to safeguard Gulf waters from Iran attacks
Vegas police release report on lessons from 2017 massacre
Senate leader McConnell says no chance of U.S. default on debt
U.S. wants military coalition to safeguard waters off Iran, Yemen
Christian Student Group Claims Anti-Religious Discrimination at Wayne State University
US-made missiles found at base used by Libyan rebels to attack Tripoli are ours, France admits
Uhhh, Twitter Is Super Mad About Kendall Jenner's Bottle Cap Challenge
Iranian boats 'tried to intercept British tanker'
Angela Merkel says she is 'very well' despite third shaking episode
Rafael Nadal ‘excited’ for long-overdue Wimbledon rematch with Roger Federer
How Cameron Boyce’s Epilepsy May Have Caused His Death at 20
Jim Bouton, 'Ball Four' author and former Yankees pitcher, dies at 80
Forbes' highest paid 2019 celebrities: Taylor Swift, Kylie Jenner, Kanye West make Forbes' list of 100 highest-paid entertainers
Iraqi gets life in jail for teen rape-murder in Germany
Against family wishes, Venezuela government buries navy captain who died in captivity
1971 Chevrolet Corvette Heads To Auction With No Reserve
Jeremy Corbyn pictured ahead of Panorama show on Labour anti-Semitism
Every free NES game added to Nintendo Switch Online in July 2019
Obamacare Is One Step Closer to Death After Tuesday’s Court Hearing
Trump instantly disinvites UK ambassador from dinner after memo leak
As standoff deepens, US tries coalition-building on Iran
Second Couple Sues in Scrambled Embryo Snafu
All-Afghan conference brings country closer to peace
Mexican President Warns Others May Leave Government After Urzua
A man survives plunge over Niagara Falls
California asks US to end plan to drop rat poison on islands
Whoops: India's Navy Left Nearly Sunk Its Own $3 Billion Nuclear Submarine
Brexit: Ex-PM vows legal action if UK Parliament suspended
Ex-White House Counsel Gregory Craig Asks Judge to Toss Lobbying Case
Media watchdog slams Pakistan curbs on TV broadcasters
Mississippi Republican says gay female journalist covering his campaign must have male chaperone
Air strikes hit hospital, kill 11 civilians in northwest Syria: monitor
Family of girl killed in cruise ship fall to return home
Pemex in the Eye of the Storm With AMLO Ruling Mexico’s Economy
Justice Department trying to quash Mueller team testimony
Woman who wrote book on domestic violence 'stabbed to death by boyfriend'
Super Weapon? The Air Force Wants a (New) Nuclear Armed Cruise Missile
Children sexually assaulted and bullied by US border guards at migrant detention camp, report says
Mitch McConnell opponent Amy McGrath breaks Senate fundraising records on first day of campaign
New Zealand PM's neighbour lets the cat out of the bag
Assad hits a wall in Syrian war as front lines harden
Republican gubernatorial candidate says gay female journalist covering his campaign must have male chaperone
Al Qaeda chief calls for unrelenting Kashmir jihad against India and says Pakistan cannot be trusted
Israeli settlers take over east Jerusalem home after court battle
Woman in Nebraska dies when her vehicle is swept by flooding
Secretary Acosta blames Palm Beach state attorney's office for Jeffrey Epstein's 2008 plea deal
Meet India's BrahMos II: The World's Fastest Supersonic Cruise Missile?
Attorney: Girl fell to death from open window on cruise ship
Police find suspect after he passed wind so loudly he gave himself away
Gaza's traditional crafts industries rapidly disappearing
Turkey warns United States against harmful steps over Russian S-400s
Asylum-seeker talks about daughter's death after US custody
Lindsey Graham blames press after Donald Trump causes UK ambassador’s resignation
Court Dismisses Emoluments-Clause Suit against Trump
British ambassador to Washington quits after spat over leaked memos
30 Plus Years After the F-15E's First Flight and the Strike Eagle Is Still Unstoppable
Hong Kong activists hold vigil for deceased supporters
Brexit Bulletin: Parliament Strikes Again
Britain's US ambassador resigns after Trump spat
Amal Clooney faults 'collective shrug' over slain journalist
New Orleans threatened by floods as big storm forms
U.S. Justice Department trying to quash Mueller team testimony -report
The Limits of the Alliance Between China and Russia
China Will Be Mad: Taiwan Will Get M1 Abrams Tanks from America (And More)
Ocasio-Cortez Sued for Blocking Twitter Users
Trump's labor chief Acosta defends Epstein plea deal, calling him 'a sexual predator'
New holding center for migrant children opens in Texas
Merkel says 'very well' despite third shaking spell
Ivanka Trump's women's initiative announces $27M in grants
Trump blasts 'foolish' UK PM May and her 'wacky' envoy over leaked memos
Alexander Acosta Says He’s Actually the Hero of the Jeffrey Epstein Case
Jeffrey Epstein accuser asks court for help in identifying his alleged recruiter
Get ready for summer weather with 2 pairs of best-selling unisex aviator sunglasses for $12
House Democrats Plan Subpoenas for Kushner, Sessions, Rosenstein
Judge's order on government lawyer shake-up adds hurdle for Trump in U.S. Census dispute
Two Marines arrested by border patrol while smuggling migrants near US-Mexico border, officials say
White House directs former aide not to answer over 200 questions in congressional probe
U.K. Ambassador to U.S. Resigns After Leaked Comments Infuriated Trump
Financier in sex abuse case went from math whiz to titan
Two US Marines arrested for migrant trafficking
Why Trump Is Standing by Acosta on the Epstein Plea Deal
Acosta Defends Handling of Epstein Case, Blames State Attorney’s Office for Lenient Sentence
Ilhan Omar responds to Tucker Carlson's rant about her: 'Racist fool'
British Ambassador to U.S. Resigns after Leak of Cables Criticizing Trump Administration
The Second Circuit Court of Appeals Was Wrong to Rule That Trump Can’t Block Twitter Users
Trump news – live: Acosta to make public statement as new alleged child victim of Jeffrey Epstein comes forward
Fed chief calls for Facebook to halt Libra project until concerns addressed
EU greenlights GSK-Pfizer joint venture
Chloe Wiegand: Family of toddler who fell 11 stories to her death blame cruise liner
Iran, Russia pour scorn on US moves at UN nuclear watchdog
Boris Johnson refuses to say he won't sack ambassador who criticised Trump
Israel's Forgotten Battle Against North Korean MiG-21s
Mueller Missed the Crime: Trump’s Campaign Coordinated With Russia
BB gun found at scene of fatal police shooting of California teen Hannah Williams: Prosecutor
Pelosi: 'No regrets about anything' as feud tests Dem unity
Financier Epstein goes from luxury life to confined jail cell after sex trafficking charges
Miley Cyrus' business attire includes a bikini
Meghan Markle steps out with Archie for Prince Harry's polo match
The first all-electric Mini will be available in September, starting at around €35,000
The Latest: Iran says US sanctions are 'warfare'
Why the Internet Thinks Cara Delevingne and Ashley Benson Are Engaged
This Country star Michael Sleggs dies aged 33
Jennifer Araoz describes her alleged encounters and says she told the multi-millionaire to 'stop, please stop'
Donald Glover's Son Can't Wait to See The Lion King, But Not Because of His Dad
Federer, Djokovic reach Wimbledon semifinals
New York City LGBT Bar Owner’s ‘Relief’ as Rainbow Flag Burning Suspect Is Caught
A Flock of Pelicans Took Out one of Israel's F-15 BAZ FrankenEagles
Trump Twitter outbursts test US-UK 'special relationship'
Are These 5 Guns Better Than a Glock?
American Airlines raises unit revenue forecast, shares rise
'Criminal act' caused Crete death of likely American victim
‘Middle Class Joe’ Biden’s Income Surged to $15 Million in Two Years
1977 Toyota Land Cruiser FJ40 Has A V8 Engine Swap
Iran's Rouhani warns UK of tanker seizure 'consequences'
German leader Merkel seen shaking for 3rd time in a month
Britain's PM hopefuls battle over Brexit in bad-tempered debate
It's a Deal: Army Wants Boeing to Build or Fix 600 AH-64E Apaches
Trump accuses Iran of secret nuclear enrichment, says sanctions to be cranked up 'substantially'
U.S. and Iran set to clash at U.N. nuclear watchdog
Two Marines Arrested for Allegedly Smuggling Migrants Across Border
California OKs benefits to immigrants in country illegally
Tucker Carlson: Ilhan Omar Is ‘Living Proof’ Our Immigration Laws Are ‘Dangerous’
Garden City boy gets final golden buzzer on 'America's Got Talent'
Kim Fields' Planning Beth Chapman's Colorado Memorial Service
NFL's Malik McDowell Fights Cop AFTER Being Tased, Insane Video
Marian Spencer, segregation fighter who later served on Cincinnati City Council, dies at age 99
Freddie Jones Dead: Emmerdale Star Dies, Aged 91
Kim Darroch quits as UK ambassador to US 'after Johnson remarks'
Tax returns show Biden income spiked after leaving office
US to sell $2bn in weapons to Taiwan, heightening tensions with China
Report: Focus on Mexican border may cost northern resources
Jeffrey Epstein’s Sick Story Played Out for Years in Plain Sight
US Dept of Homeland Security requests 1,000 soldiers to manage migrant crisis
Close