Close
Date TimeJuly 08, 2019
Voice

The Other Census Disaster That’s Waiting to Happen
GettyEveryone hoping for an accurate 2020 Census breathed a sigh of relief two weeks ago when the Supreme Court ruled 5-4 to block the Trump administration’s cynical attempt to add a citizenship question to the forms—only to experience Twitter-tantrum whiplash when the president ordered his administration to make a last-ditch attempt to include it.But with so much attention focused on the controversy over the citizenship question, another similarly disastrous Census Bureau decision has gone largely unnoticed: the administration’s choice not to substantively update the decennial survey’s questions on race. As a result, no matter how conscientiously Census Bureau staff administer the survey, a woefully inadequate portrait of the changing face of America will emerge.The last census, in 2010, became a data disaster when “some other race,” showed up as the third-largest racial group in America. Over 20 million respondents, most with roots in Latin America or the Middle East, selected this none-of-the-above option, making it the most popular choice after white and black. Any time a public-opinion survey asks respondents to self-categorize and “none of the above” comes back as a popular answer, it’s a clear sign that the choices given don’t match up with people’s identities.Facing this problem squarely, the Obama administration convened the National Advisory Committee on Racial, Ethnic and Other Populations, a panel of academic experts and minority community leaders, to advise the Bureau on improving its race questions for 2020. The committee made myriad recommendations, most crucially suggesting that a “Middle East or North Africa” category sit alongside the “Hispanic origins” box in the upcoming questionnaire. But the Trump administration overruled this advice and, aside from a few minor tweaks, is flying into the 2020 survey without substantive changes. Given continued Latin American and Middle Eastern immigration since 2010, and the more extreme forms of racial “othering” these groups have faced ever since candidate Donald J. Trump came down the escalator in 2015, experts fear that “some other race” will become the second-largest racial group in America according to the 2020 Census.Trump’s Census Tweet Shows the U.S. Government Is Led by a MadmanEvery census since the founding of the country has asked about race and ethnicity. Until recent decades, race was not a matter of self-identification; historically, federal census-takers were charged with determining the race of each resident of their assigned census tracts according to their era’s standards. Tracing how race questions have changed over time offers a time-lapse history of American racial concepts in 10-year snapshots. (All of the race questions are conveniently archived on the website racebox.org.)The most drastic changes to the census race questions took place after the fall of Reconstruction, at the rise of Jim Crow, when America’s mixed-race realities were blotted out and a strict racial binary imposed. Openly mixed-race activists, in particular Charleston’s “Browns” and New Orleans’s “Creoles of color,” had been central to post-Civil War civil rights progress. Their court challenges to segregation, of which Plessy v. Ferguson (1896) was only the last and most famous, assailed the notion that Europeans and Africans remained distinct racial groups in America given centuries of overt and covert race-mixing. At the time, the “one-drop rule” that any African ancestry at all made an American a “Negro” was still new and not widely accepted. This more fluid racial mindset was reflected in the late 19th-century censuses, which all catalogued biracial “mulattos” as distinct from “whites” and “blacks.” The 1890 questionnaire recorded even finer-grained mixed-race categories: “quadroon” (an American with three European grandparents and one African grandparent) and “octoroon” (an American with seven European great-grandparents and one African great-grandparent). But with the firm establishment of the color line post-Plessy, the 1900 census switched to a unitary race. (Not until 2000 would the census again allow respondents to claim mixed-race identities, this time by checking more than one racial box.)As segregation took root, the stakes of being deemed “white” grew higher. Even as Jim Crow laws proliferated in the early 20th century, the states differed on their official definitions of what exactly a “white person” was and who precisely constituted a “colored person.” Myriad ethnic groups clamored to get into whiteness, often petitioning through the courts. “Semites,” for example, won their way into whiteness using clever, albeit pseudo-scientific, arguments. Their trump card, first argued in 1907 by H. A. Elkourie, a Syrian Christian physician in Birmingham, Alabama, was that if he wasn’t white then Jesus hadn’t been white either. Anglo-Americans’ revulsion at the thought they were worshipping a person of color each Sunday was strong enough that Elkourie and the fellow members of his “Semitic” “race” were deemed “white.”The next major revamp of the census’s race questions came in the wake of the 1960s civil rights movement. For the first time, the Census Bureau empowered each respondent to choose her own race rather than have a census-taker determine it for her. And embracing the modern understanding that race has no biological reality, only societal meanings, the Census Bureau modified the racial categories to learn more about American society rather than engage in the fool’s errand of sorting humans into some fixed number of distinct races. To this end, the 1970 Census listed eight racial categories, one of which was “Hawaiian”—a useful category for understanding American society but a group so tiny no early-20th-century race scientists ever elevated it into their core “Races of Man.”Only in 1980 did the census begin to grapple with Latino identity. Rather than add “Hispanic” to the list of races, it introduced a question to stand apart from the various racial choices: “Is this person of Spanish/Hispanic origin or descent?” By noting that Hispanics can be of any race, the Census Bureau hoped to track the growth of this community that comes in all colors. But this well-meaning attempt never fully worked since the Latin American and Anglo-American conceptions of race are fundamentally incompatible.While the U.S., after Reconstruction, forced Americans to claim a retroactive racial purity, Latin America never denied its mestizo realities. On the most recent Brazilian census, for example, the majority of respondents identified as afrodecendente (Afro-descended). But in Brazil this identity does not in any way suggest that the same person is not also of European, Native American, and/or Asian descent; indeed, over 80 percent of self-identified afrodecendente Brazilians claimed roots on non-African continents as well.In Mexico, the concept of race (la raza) is even more un-American. The Mexican supposition is that the people of the New World are, in a sense, a new race unto themselves, a mixture of all the world’s peoples. It is these mutually-incompatible conceptions of race between the U.S. and Latin America that has led millions of census respondents to check that they are of Latino origin but are members of “some other race.”Arab-Americans are similarly migrants from an alternate racial system. Arab identity embraces people of all skin colors and is largely tied to language—people whose mother tongue is Arabic are Arabs even if they don’t live on Asia’s Arabian Peninsula. Though officially white in America since the early-20th-century rulings that “Semites” are white, contemporary American racism has again called Arab whiteness into question.The most recent federal definition of a “white person,” formulated in 1997 by the Office of Management and Budget and currently used by the Census Bureau—“A person having origins in any of the original peoples of Europe, the Middle East, or North Africa”—clearly includes Arabs. But if “whiteness” has no biological reality and is purely a socially-constructed category in American society for those who enjoy full citizenship, including the presumption of innocence, since 9/11, Middle Easterners have no longer been white. This mismatch between being officially white by the federal definition but not being treated as white in American society has sparked a wildcat campaign among some Middle Easterners not to check the “white” box on the Census (tag-line: “Check it right, you ain’t white”). Indeed, the National Advisory Committee on Racial, Ethnic and Other Populations found many Middle Eastern- and North African-Americans are doing just that, checking “some other race” in defiance of the current federal definition of whiteness.At this point the 2020 race questions are set, with just a few tweaks from 2010. The 2020 form will include “Lebanese” and “Egyptian” as examples of white ethnicities to remind Arabs to, essentially, “check it right, you are white.” The new wording also adds “Aztec” and “Mayan” as examples of American Indian ethnicities to instruct people with roots in the New World beyond the United States borders that they should still identify themselves as indigenous.Even with these minor changes, the best-case scenario is that none-of-the-above comes out as the third-largest race in America rather than second-largest. Whiteness in America is in flux today in a way it hasn’t been in a century—even if the Census Bureau’s political appointees, in keeping with the Trump administration’s Know-Nothingism on race, won’t admit it. An administration that has backed border walls and Muslim bans has already shown Latinos and Middle Easterners that, if whiteness means first-class citizenship, they’re no longer white. The painful irony is that the rise of “some other race” at first glance suggests America is becoming post-racial, while its real roots are in rising racism.Daniel Brook is the author of The Accident of Color: A Story of Race in Reconstruction. Before becoming a journalist and author, he worked in public opinion research.Read more at The Daily Beast.Get our top stories in your inbox every day. Sign up now!Daily Beast Membership: Beast Inside goes deeper on the stories that matter to you. Learn more.




Sri Lanka police chief, ex-defense secretary released on bail in Easter attacks case
Trump shares fake Ronald Reagan quote predicting his presidency: 'Cute!'
Nicki Minaj Pulls Out of Saudi Arabia Show
The Godfather of the Islamic Republic of Iran
China slams pro-democracy Hong Kong singer as 'delusional'
'Acosta must go': Democrats urge labor secretary to quit over Epstein plea deal
Ariana Grande opens up about Mac Miller and Pete Davidson in Vogue
'Friends' Officially Leaving Netflix for WarnerMedia's Streaming Service
Apple may launch three 5G iPhones in 2020, as well as a cheap iPhone 8 replacement
Trump launches furious attack on Fox News after commentators fail to praise him
Sister of Saudi crown prince tried in France over 'beaten workman'
Anaheim Police Investigating Disneyland Fight in Viral Video
Shawn Mendes and Camila Cabello are doing nothing to shut down relationship rumours
Saudi princess tried in absentia for alleged Paris beating
Texan billionaire Ross Perot, who took two runs at US presidency, dies at 89
Johanna Konta crashes out as Barbora Strycova powers into semi-finals
MPs vote to extend abortion and same-sex marriage rights to Northern Ireland
Watch: Why A Nissan Skyline GT-R R32 Was Worth A 22 Year Wait
Double the speed of your Fire TV or Chromecast with one $14 gadget
Trump lashes out at Britain's ambassador for a second day
Vessels Change Names or Go Dark to Ship Venezuelan Crude to Cuba
Obamacare's future in play as U.S. appeals court weighs its constitutionality
Trump news – live: Angry president lashes out amid pressure on aide over Epstein sex ring case, as Moscow Tower associate testifies
Asian shares retreat ahead of Fed statement to Congress
1-year-old dies in fall from cruise ship in Puerto Rico
Iran's Military Vows Retaliation for U.K. Seizing Oil Tanker
Europeans take first step to punish Iran over nuclear pact breaches
The U.S. Navy Wants to Add the Ultimate Weapon: 'Laser Guns'?
Elizabeth Warren Triples Her First-Quarter Haul, Outraises Bernie Sanders and Kamala Harris
Jeffrey Epstein: The billionaire paedophile with links to Donald Trump, Bill Clinton and Prince Andrew
Billionaire Steyer Enters 2020 Democratic Race: Campaign Update
Trump says migrant detention centers to open to media
Barr sees a legal way to ask about citizenship on census
Seeking unity, Pelosi calls for bill to protect migrant kids
F-35 in Trouble? Dispute with Lockheed Martin Means No More American F-35 Deliveries
Rule of law has crumbled in Venezuela: jurists' group
U.S. appeals court to take up constitutionality of Obamacare
Sister of Saudi leader MBS faces verdict over 'beaten workman'
Couple sues clinic over IVF mix-up after giving birth to twins unrelated to them
Disney star Cameron Boyce's father and co-stars speak out after his death
In losing legal battles over census, Trump may win political war
Sofia Vergara, 46, Looks Gorgeous In Bikini On Romantic Italian Vacation With Joe Manganiello
Trump takes a fresh whack at Obamacare
Liverpool striker Daniel Sturridge pleads for dog's return after home ransacked: 'I'll pay anything'
Amy McGrath announces bid to take on Sen. Mitch McConnell in 2020
Pro-Life Women Travel to the Border, with Supplies
23 governors join Calif. in opposing Trump mileage standards
Pelosi, AOC Clash over Reach of Progressives’ Influence
Hong Kong leader says extradition bill is dead, but critics unconvinced
Prime Day just got here early for Amazon’s best-selling Instant Pot
At UN, Hong Kong activist calls for more pressure on China
These true wireless earbuds have a better design than AirPods and double the battery life for $30 less
How ‘Middle Class Joe’ Biden Made Millions: Campaign Update
Barr: Mueller's Hill testimony will be 'public spectacle'
British capture of Iranian tanker won't go 'unanswered': officer
Iran's Zarif says there won't be a better nuclear deal than 2015 accord
Technological Theft: China's J-20 Stealth Fighter Has American DNA
Wife of Chinese ex-head of Interpol sues over disappearance
Iran warns Britain's seizure of oil tanker in Gibraltar 'will not go unanswered'
Hong Kong leader says extradition bill 'dead', but critics not satisfied
US Rep. Swalwell ends presidential bid, will seek reelection
Bill Clinton: I Flew With Jeffrey Epstein but Knew ‘Nothing’ About ‘Terrible Crimes’
California earthquake: 7.1 magnitude quake created crack so big it can be seen in satellite images
Protesters unmoved as Hong Kong leader says China extradition bill 'dead'
Stranger Things season 3: The new season of Stranger Things breaks Netflix records after just 4 days
Kim Kardashian's Painful Met Gala Corset Left Indentations on Her Back and Stomach
Hong Kong Leader Carrie Lam Says Extradition Bill Is ‘Dead’ as Unrest Continues
Hong Kong protesters to continue after bill declared 'dead'
Trump says US will 'no longer deal' with British ambassador after leaked anti-Trump cables
Dark Money review, a child abuse drama that is slight but horribly real
California congressman Eric Swalwell withdraws from 2020 presidential race
'Gamer Girl' Belle Delphine is Selling Her Used Bath Water
Roger Federer, Novak Djokovic & Rafael Nadal into Wimbledon 2019 quarter-finals
Trisha Yearwood: 'Country music has to change'
Hong Kong: Carrie Lam says extradition bill is 'dead' but stops short of withdrawal
If Tom Watson had guts, he would quit Labour. Instead he is weakening the party | Dawn Foster
Here’s What the Feds Found in Jeffrey Epstein’s Manhattan Mansion
Pelosi Says Trump Seeks to ‘Make America White Again’ in Census
Could the Violent Protests in Hong Kong Backfire?
The Latest: Pelosi says Trump wants to make US 'white again'
Lam says Hong Kong bill is 'dead' but unclear if demand met
Man arrested in Oregon in death of original Mouseketeer
Rights violations in contested Kashmir continue unchecked, U.N. report says
Cuomo Signs Law Permitting Congress to Access Trump’s New York Tax Returns
U.N.'s Bachelet 'appalled' at U.S. treatment of migrants and refugees
Swalwell Abandons Race, Seeks House Re-Election: Campaign Update
Back in 2017, an F-35 Stealth Fighter Was Killed in a Simulation
YouTube engineer on LSD-fuelled 4th July rampage leaves eight people hurt
Bedraggled Jeffrey Epstein Pleads Not Guilty to Sex Charges and Stays in Jail—for Now
Financier Epstein pleads not guilty to U.S. sex trafficking charges involving girls
Mexico's new National Guard was created to fight crime, but now it's in a face-off with migrants
Billionaire Jeffrey Epstein Pleads Not Guilty to Sex Trafficking of Minors
F-35 Is Old: Russia Could Turn Its Su-57 Into a 6th Generation Stealth Monster
South Korean citizen makes a rare defection to the North
Rains strand Washington drivers, flood White House basement
Could Justin Amash Cost Trump Reelection?
Boy stabs brother because he 'would rather be in jail than spend eight hours in a car with him'
Couple Forced to Give Up Babies After Embryo Mixup, Lawsuit Says
Make your Instant Pot feel like new with this 12-piece accessory set, on sale today for $25
Saudi carrier cancels troubled Boeing 737 order for Airbus
Guaido says talks with Venezuela govt to resume, move to Barbados
To Dim Guaido's Appeal, Maduro Offers Venezuela His Own Version
AP Interview: Kamala Harris on race and electability in 2020
US won't waver from Iran pressure as nuclear deal unravels
Top Secret: We Can Now Show You Inside the Cockpit of a B-2 Stealth Bomber
Ukraine's president says ready to meet Russia's Putin in Minsk
Jeffrey Epstein - live updates: Billionaire and former Trump associate in court over sex trafficking ring involving girls as young as 14
Warren Pulls in over $19 Million in Second Quarter
Warren raises $19.1 million for presidential bid in second quarter, third among crowd of rivals
Wall St. drops as Apple falls, Fed eyed
Iran breached uranium enrichment cap: nuclear agency confirms
Meghan McCain Keeps ABC Hanging, Refuses To Say On Air If She’s Staying With ‘The View’
Billionaire financier Jeffrey Epstein pleads not guilty to sex trafficking charges
Iran enriches uranium past cap and warns only 60 days to save deal
SunTrust Is Latest Bank to Halt Financing of Private Prisons
Son of prominent South Korean defector moves to North Korea
No Matter 18,000 Lost Jobs, Germany OK With Deutsche Bank Cull
Migrant children held in Texas facility need access to doctors, says attorney
Jeffrey Epstein: Financier and former friend of Trump arrested on sex trafficking charges
Hundreds of thousands celebrate Madrid Gay Pride
Hong Kong protesters moot Bank of China 'stress test' after latest clashes
Top immigration official says ICE will begin deporting 1 million illegal immigrants with final removal orders
Disney Star Cameron Boyce Suffered from Epilepsy
See This Old Plane? It Killed 4 F-15s In Simulated Battles in the Sky
From boomerangs to A-bombs? Australia debates nukes
Life-threatening rains pound U.S. capital; White House basement offices leak
Richard Bacon's GMB treatment at hands of co-host Susanna Reid slammed by outraged viewers
Amy Hart Quits Love Island Following Curtis Pritchard Split
Johanna Konta battles past Petra Kvitova to reach Wimbledon last eight
Iran passes uranium enrichment cap set by endangered deal
Young girl falls to death from cruise ship ‘after being accidentally dropped by grandfather’
Rafael Nadal crushes Joao Sousa in straight sets to reach quarter-finals
The Coco bubble pops at Wimbledon as Simona Halep ousts Gauff
Mother sues NHS for £200,000 claiming hospital failed to inform her of son's Down's Syndrome diagnosis
Man says he killed black teen for listening to rap music. Activists want #JusticeforElijah
Jeffrey Epstein sexual abuse case could push powerful friends into spotlight
U.S. Women’s World Cup Win Tops Men’s Final Ratings by 20%
Kris Kobach Enters U.S. Senate Race, Misspells Own First Name
Jeffrey Epstein: Billionaire charged with sex trafficking and abusing girls as young as 14, unsealed indictment reveals
What Has Become of Abdul-Salaam Ojeili's Syria
Trump appears to revoke invite to White House for US women’s team after World Cup win
Hickenlooper: Vast majority of campaign's problem 'was me'
Iran accuses US of using oil sanctions to gain market clout
Photographed: The U.S. Air Force’s Secretive Robot X-37B Space Shuttle
Pixel 4 XL’s design just leaked again, and it still doesn’t look good
America did not allow Iranians to benefit from nuclear deal: Jahangiri
US hedge fund billionaire charged with sex trafficking minors
The Latest: UN confirms Iran has increased enrichment
Trump’s migrant camps on US border ‘undignified and damaging’, says UN human rights chief
Ex-GOPer Amash doubles down on call for Trump impeachment
Amnesty identifies new 'killing field' in Philippines drugs war ahead of key UN vote
Iran Announces Breaking Nuclear Deal Limit for Uranium Enrichment
Trump Is Against South Korean Cooperation With the North: Yomiuri
American financier Epstein lured underage girls for sex acts: U.S. prosecutors
Iran minister vows to respond to UK detaining oil tanker
Michelle Obama lifts lid on final days in White House before Trump moved in
India's latest Google probe sparked by junior antitrust researchers
Iran breaches key uranium enrichment limit in nuclear deal
Jeffrey Epstein: sex abuse allegations against billionaire socialite began in 2005
India 'dosa king' seeks delay to life sentence for love-saga murder
A 19th Century lesbian 'marriage' proposal | Gentleman Jack
Ariana Grande explains tearful performance: 'I'm still processing a lot'
Justin Bieber Calls Out Tom Cruise and Wife Hailey Bieber During Bottle Cap Challenge
AirPods 2 with Wireless Charging Case are only $20 more than the standard case right now
Jeffrey Epstein Shouldn’t Expect to Wriggle Free Again
Boston suburb reflects broad changes in US immigration
Indictment Alleges Jeffrey Epstein Created ‘Vast Network’ of Underage Sex Victims as Young as 14
Iran makes new nuclear threats that would reverse steps in pact
Elon Musk says free self-driving chip upgrade could come to older Teslas this year
UK Trade Minister to apologize after leaked cables call Trump 'inept' and 'clumsy': report
Heather Mills receives apology and payout in phone-hacking case
World No 1 Ashleigh Barty crashes out of Wimbledon to Alison Riske
Pro-Brexit Labour MP Kate Hoey to stand down at next election
13 Nigeria civilians killed in air raid targeting jihadists: sources
‘If not now, when?’ Jews in America see echoes of the Holocaust in immigrant detention centres
The Incredible Guts of Thae Yong-ho
The Latest: China blames US for Iran crisis
Global stocks steady after big Asia falls post US payrolls
F-22s vs. F-35s: Who Wins When the 2 Deadliest Stealth Fighters Fight?
Trump White House 'uniquely dysfunctional', says UK's ambassador in Washington
Rainbow flag again set on fire at New York gay bar
Tens of thousands in Hong Kong take message to mainlanders
Hundreds of thousands march across Europe for Gay Pride
Trump attacks Britain’s ambassador in Washington after leaked memo branded president ‘dysfunctional’
Biden Explains Delay in Apologizing for Segregationist Comments
Holocaust Survivor: Yes, the Border Detention Centers Are Like Concentration Camps
2019 Women’s World Cup Finals: USA vs. Netherlands, How to Watch and Live Stream Online
China tech giant Baidu partners with Geely, Toyota
U.S. financier Epstein expected to be charged in sex trafficking case -source
Jeffrey Epstein due in court after sex trafficking arrest
Poll: 1 in 4 don't plan to retire despite realities of aging
UK minister to apologize to Ivanka Trump for ambassador's leaked memos
Trump administration 'uniquely dysfunctional', says UK ambassador to U.S.: newspaper
Otto Warmbier's family files claim on seized North Korean coal ship
Hong Kong police arrest six at Kowloon protest
Proud Boys’ D.C. Free-Speech Rally Goes Off With a Whimper
The Latest: Japan concerned over Iran's uranium enrichment
Trump frightens Republicans but 'doesn't scare me,' departing party congressman Amash says
Iran steps further from nuke deal, adding pressure on Europe
Thomas Markle wishes Archie 'health and happiness' from afar, as Prince Harry and Meghan's friends rally for secretive christening operation
Close