Close
Date TimeJuly 03, 2019
Voice

Democrats’ Leftward Turn Was a Reaction to Hillary Clinton
The consensus view on the right is that Hillary Clinton was a primary reason for Donald Trump’s success in 2016. But not all conservatives agree about why that was.For devotees of the Trump-as-savior narrative, Clinton -- and all the allegedly nefarious forces at her beck and call -- was a uniquely formidable opponent. Defeating her required a different kind of Republican, one who’d be willing to fight as dirty and as tough as the Democrats. This was a “Flight 93 election,” and Trump was the hero we needed to storm the cockpit.Others on the right see it differently. It wasn’t so much that Trump was the one person who could beat Clinton, but that she was the one candidate he could beat. In other words, it was only thanks to the fact that she was so unpopular that Trump had a chance. Trump-reluctant Republicans and independents could be persuaded that he was better than Clinton -- when presented with a binary choice.The latter seems vastly more plausible for the simple reason that Trump didn’t have to convince those voters that Clinton was unlikable and a little scary; he simply had to exploit their pre-existing opinion of her. Indeed, Trump’s continued obsession with bashing Clinton points to how central she is to his identity.This has consequences for 2020 because the White House’s entire strategy boils down to making Trump’s opponent more unlikable than he is. If Trump wasn’t responsible for Hillary’s unfavorable numbers in the first place, it remains to be seen whether he can Hillaryize another Democrat.It may not be all that hard, though, because the Democrats are doing everything they can to keep the Flight 93 panic alive on the right. They’re doing this by running so far to the left that many Trump-skeptical Republicans feel as if they have no choice but to vote for him again. (I hear this from my fellow conservatives every day.) Democratic candidates have openly praised socialism, the Green New Deal, the abolition of private insurance, voting rights for incarcerated felons, federal funding of abortion late into pregnancy, confiscatory “wealth taxes,” and even the right to sex-change operations paid for by taxpayers.And here is where I think Clinton’s true historical significance isn’t being recognized. Again, conservatives (including yours truly) invested a lot of time and energy in shaping public perceptions of Clinton. But the blame -- or credit -- doesn’t just go to the right. Clinton herself did much to help the effort. She was never the natural politician her husband was. She lacked his gift for reading the electorate and speaking to voters’ concerns. She collected all of her husband’s baggage without any of her husband’s skill at deflecting criticism. She wasn’t very likable.This was a huge advantage for Bernie Sanders in 2016. He came way closer to beating Clinton in the primaries than most people thought he would by tapping into the passion of the base and the frustrations of other Democrats who didn’t relish a Clinton dynasty and disliked both Hillary personally and the corrupt practices of the establishment she represented. She ran on the implied claim that it was simply her “turn” to be president -- a poisonous framing in a populist moment (just ask Jeb Bush). In retrospect, not being Hillary was almost as big a boon for Sanders as it was for Trump.If the Clinton machine had not scared away more talented and resourceful politicians from running in 2016, it’s possible that someone other than Sanders would have captured the passion of the party, just as Obama did when he toppled Hillary as the inevitable nominee in 2008.But that didn’t happen, and as a result, the Democratic party got the message that Sanders-style socialist populism was the key to success, just as the GOP has concluded that Trump-style nationalist populism is the future of the right.Sanders’ frustration at no longer being the undisputed voice of the base is palpable. “They said our ideas are crazy and wild and extreme,” he recently complained. “And now it turns out all of the other candidates are saying what we said four years ago.”He’s right.Of course, there are larger historical forces at work here, but it sure looks like Hillary Clinton’s candidacy was an inflection point, because it galvanized not only the GOP’s turn toward nationalism but the Democrats’ turn toward socialism. She’ll never be president, but she’s made history nonetheless.© 2019 Tribune Content Agency, LLC




Related Stories
Chelsea Clinton announces birth of third childChelsea Clinton announces birth of third child
How Mueller’s Lawyers Spun the OLC Guidance on Indicting a Sitting PresidentHow Mueller’s Lawyers Spun the OLC Guidance on Indicting a Sitting President
Jeffrey Epstein kept painting of Bill Clinton in drag at his houseJeffrey Epstein kept painting of Bill Clinton in drag at his house
You Can’t Beat Trump without Throwing a PunchYou Can’t Beat Trump without Throwing a Punch
Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell boasted of collecting compromising material on the rich and famousJeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell 'boasted of collecting compromising material on the rich and famous'
Boris Johnson and Donald Trump Are Peak White Male PrivilegeBoris Johnson and Donald Trump Are Peak White Male Privilege
#ClintonBodyCount Trends on Twitter, Dems Blame Russians#ClintonBodyCount Trends on Twitter, Dems Blame Russians
What Is QAnon? The Conspiracy Theory So Whacky The FBI Has Declared It A Domestic Terror ThreatWhat Is QAnon? The Conspiracy Theory So Whacky The FBI Has Declared It A Domestic Terror Threat
How the Ilhan Omar Marriage Smear Went From Fever Swamp to TrumpHow the Ilhan Omar Marriage Smear Went From Fever Swamp to Trump
Donald Trump fuels conspiracy theories about Jeffrey Epsteins apparent suicideDonald Trump fuels conspiracy theories about Jeffrey Epstein's apparent suicide
Latest News
Transgender journalist loses discrimination claim against the TimesTransgender journalist loses discrimination claim against the Times
Does overconsumption of bad TV lead to populism? | Oliver BurkemanDoes overconsumption of bad TV lead to populism? | Oliver Burkeman
Trump tells Republicans he may begin cutting social security and Medicare if he wins in 2020Trump tells Republicans he may begin cutting social security and Medicare if he wins in 2020
British man choked to death in row over noise while holidaying with wife and child in ThailandBritish man choked to death in 'row over noise' while holidaying with wife and child in Thailand
Irans Zarif praises Macron nuclear crisis suggestionsIran's Zarif praises Macron nuclear crisis suggestions
Russias Chechnya inaugurates what it says is Europes largest mosqueRussia's Chechnya inaugurates what it says is Europe's largest mosque
Michael Bennet Rips Into Democrats 2020 Rules: Campaign UpdateMichael Bennet Rips Into Democrats' 2020 Rules: Campaign Update
Israel warns Hamas further attacks risk more Gaza sufferingIsrael warns Hamas further attacks risk more Gaza suffering
John Oliver and Trevor Noah think you should know about Turkmenistans compellingly odd dictator, Gurbanguly BerdimuhamedovJohn Oliver and Trevor Noah think you should know about Turkmenistan's 'compellingly odd' dictator, Gurbanguly Berdimuhamedov
England’s Ashes hopes fade as Australia turn screw on Joe Root’s day of despairEngland’s Ashes hopes fade as Australia turn screw on Joe Root’s day of despair
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
Chelsea Clinton announces birth of third childChelsea Clinton announces birth of third child
How Mueller’s Lawyers Spun the OLC Guidance on Indicting a Sitting PresidentHow Mueller’s Lawyers Spun the OLC Guidance on Indicting a Sitting President
Jeffrey Epstein kept painting of Bill Clinton in drag at his houseJeffrey Epstein kept painting of Bill Clinton in drag at his house
You Can’t Beat Trump without Throwing a PunchYou Can’t Beat Trump without Throwing a Punch
Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell boasted of collecting compromising material on the rich and famousJeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell 'boasted of collecting compromising material on the rich and famous'
Boris Johnson and Donald Trump Are Peak White Male PrivilegeBoris Johnson and Donald Trump Are Peak White Male Privilege
#ClintonBodyCount Trends on Twitter, Dems Blame Russians#ClintonBodyCount Trends on Twitter, Dems Blame Russians
What Is QAnon? The Conspiracy Theory So Whacky The FBI Has Declared It A Domestic Terror ThreatWhat Is QAnon? The Conspiracy Theory So Whacky The FBI Has Declared It A Domestic Terror Threat
How the Ilhan Omar Marriage Smear Went From Fever Swamp to TrumpHow the Ilhan Omar Marriage Smear Went From Fever Swamp to Trump
Donald Trump fuels conspiracy theories about Jeffrey Epsteins apparent suicideDonald Trump fuels conspiracy theories about Jeffrey Epstein's apparent suicide
Latest News
Transgender journalist loses discrimination claim against the TimesTransgender journalist loses discrimination claim against the Times
Does overconsumption of bad TV lead to populism? | Oliver BurkemanDoes overconsumption of bad TV lead to populism? | Oliver Burkeman
Trump tells Republicans he may begin cutting social security and Medicare if he wins in 2020Trump tells Republicans he may begin cutting social security and Medicare if he wins in 2020
British man choked to death in row over noise while holidaying with wife and child in ThailandBritish man choked to death in 'row over noise' while holidaying with wife and child in Thailand
Irans Zarif praises Macron nuclear crisis suggestionsIran's Zarif praises Macron nuclear crisis suggestions
Russias Chechnya inaugurates what it says is Europes largest mosqueRussia's Chechnya inaugurates what it says is Europe's largest mosque
Michael Bennet Rips Into Democrats 2020 Rules: Campaign UpdateMichael Bennet Rips Into Democrats' 2020 Rules: Campaign Update
Israel warns Hamas further attacks risk more Gaza sufferingIsrael warns Hamas further attacks risk more Gaza suffering
John Oliver and Trevor Noah think you should know about Turkmenistans compellingly odd dictator, Gurbanguly BerdimuhamedovJohn Oliver and Trevor Noah think you should know about Turkmenistan's 'compellingly odd' dictator, Gurbanguly Berdimuhamedov
England’s Ashes hopes fade as Australia turn screw on Joe Root’s day of despairEngland’s Ashes hopes fade as Australia turn screw on Joe Root’s day of despair
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
James Lovelock on the future of AI and climate change
US singer Halle Bailey cast as Ariel in Disney's live-action remake of The Little Mermaid
Frank Lampard confirmed as Chelsea manager to succeed Sarri
Putin signs bill to suspend Russia's participation in nuclear treaty
North Korea says US 'hell-bent on hostile acts' despite wanting to talk
Trump casts himself, military, Republican VIPs as stars of July 4th pageant
Mexican police protest president's National Guard plan
US federal judge blocks indefinite detention of asylum seekers
Australian Alek Sigley Released From Detention in North Korea
Trump Says Migrants Living ‘Far Better’ in Detention Than at Home
Suspect in woman's death barred from campus, report says
Trump administration relents over census citizenship question
Iran to bypass uranium enrichment maximum despite calls for rethink
Iraq tries to bring Iran-backed militias in country to heel as tensions escalate
How U.S. Chipmakers Pressed Trump to Ease China's Huawei Ban
Last Hand-Built M-Car: 1991 BMW M5
Trump touts July 4 military 'salute'; critics see politics
Know This: A U.S.-Iran War Would Not Be Fought Only in Iran
Airstrike kills 44 migrants in Libyan detention center
It's Time to Formally End the Korean War
Trump says immigrants 'unhappy' with detention centers should stay home
Tesla deliveries surge as automakers report dip in 1H 2019 US sales
2020 Democrats Caught Between Corn and Ethanol Foes in Iowa
Multiple walls collapse in India monsoon rains, killing 31
China to Britain: Keep your 'colonial' hands off Hong Kong
Judge blocks Trump policy keeping asylum-seekers locked up
Hong Kong police vow action over parliament storming
White House Slams Judge for Inflicting ‘Open-Borders Views’ on Country
Trump tells Iran threats 'can come back to bite you' in nuclear standoff
Mexican police revolt against plans to join National Guard
Migrant children's drawings depict 'horrific' conditions in cages
Vegas police fire officer who hesitated during mass shooting
Tanks roll into Washington DC for Trump's 4 July parade, as $2.5m ‘diverted from parks funding’ to help pay for it
Navy Seal found not guilty of murdering Isis captive
Kamala Harris Vaults Into Second Place as Joe Biden Slips After First Debate
Trump baby blimp may not fly over president’s Fourth of July extravaganza
Navy SEAL sentenced for posing with dead Iraq war casualty
Game of Thrones Season 8 ending: Bran is completely DOOMED from the start
Arte Johnson dead: Laugh-In actor dies aged 90 after bladder and prostate cancer
Video: Volcano erupts on Italian island of Stromboli
US Air Force accidentally drops dummy bombs on Florida after hitting a bird
Trump's Political Plan for the Palestinian-Israeli Conflict
Cruz Asks DHS to Create Process for Collecting Donations to Migrants in U.S. Custody
Kyle Edmund blows two-set lead as Fernando Verdasco wins five-set thriller
Ex-NFL QB Jared Lorenzen dead at 38 after battling multiple health issues, family says
Trump, producer-president, makes July 4th his own show
That Time Israel Withdrew from the Red Flag Alaska Wargames Because of Iran
Democrats blast Trump's migrant detention centers as inhumane
DHS, CBP officials push back on Democratic delegation's claims of grim conditions at migrant detention centers
Erdogan says people live happily in Xinjiang: Chinese state media
Indian dam overflows after heavy monsoon rains, 12 dead
Fox’s Jesse Watters Says He’s ‘Tired and Bored’ of AOC, Proceeds to Talk at Length About Her
It’s Not Just Warren. The Next Democratic President Is Coming for Your Monopoly
Hubble Captures Stunning Fireworks of Exploding Star
US rapper A$AP Rocky arrested in Sweden after brawl: prosecutor
Hailey Baldwin In Red Bikini & Jean Shorts With Justin Bieber
Biden’s Flip-Flops on China
Trump, Republicans raise $105 million in second quarter for re-election bid
'They started this too late': Trump officials and allies anxious about July 4 fest
China is installing spyware on tourists' phones
Joao Felix: Atletico Madrid signs teenager in fifth richest transfer
Facebook, Instagram And WhatsApp Are Down, Again
Nike pulls US flag-themed shoe after Kaepernick objection: report
Joe Biden raises $21.5 million in second quarter, keeps pace with Buttigieg
Eight arrested over cyberattacks against Hong Kong police
One tourist reported dead in Stromboli volcano eruption
Video Alert: Watch an Iranian F-14A Launch a Fakour-90 Air-To-Air Missile
Iran's Navy Has a Big Problem: A Track Record of Getting Crushed in Battle
Iran breaches uranium stockpile limit set by nuclear deal
Britain summons Chinese ambassador as he accuses Government of taking 'wrong side' on Hong Kong
Does the Air Force Really Need 74 Additional Combat Squadrons?
Ex-Border Patrol employees discuss 'vile' Facebook posts
Kellyanne Conway Calls AOC a Liar for Claim That Migrants Are ‘Drinking Out of Toilets’
Boeing promises $100 million to help families affected by deadly crashes
Trump says US-China trade talks 'already begun'
Iran Under Pressure: Why America's Sanctions Strategy Will Work
Man wears blackface in court then launches bizarre rant about being ‘treated like a black man’
A Reluctant Mueller Is Democrats’ Best Shot to Revive Their Trump Investigations
Harris picks up new endorsement among divided black caucus
Chinese ambassador accuses Britain of taking 'wrong side' over Hong Kong protests
EU, France, Germany and UK urge Iran to reverse uranium decision
'Help': Photos from US migrant detention centres reveal despair and overcrowding as people go a month without showers
China lashes back over British remarks on Hong Kong protests
Poll: Two-Thirds of Voters Say Citizenship Question Should Be Allowed on Census
Another Mysterious Space Signal Was Just Traced Back to Its Source
Kim Kardashian Awarded $2.7 Mil in Knockoff Dress Lawsuit
Parkland shooting survivor Emma Gonzalez slams Madonna's 'God Control' video
Disney Deletes ‘Toy Story 2’ Casting Couch Blooper After #MeToo Movement
Dubai's Princess Haya battles billionaire ruler husband in UK High Court
Biden's support from black voters cut in half after debate: Reuters/Ipsos poll
Two Women Surge in Race to Take on Trump
Beijing’s Message to Hong Kong: Get in Line or Face Irrelevance
Who is Christine Lagarde? The woman who rolled her eyes at Ivanka Trump is now set to take Europe's most most important monetary position
Jeff Green leaves Wizards for Jazz in latest free agent departure
BUSTED: Trump caught taking $2.5 million from America’s national parks, to pay for his Fourth of July military show
Kentucky Fire Threatens 45,000 Barrels of Jim Beam Bourbon
Instagram down: Social networking site not working for users, Server status latest
One of Iran's Last F-14A Tomcats Just Crashed
Trump Revamps July 4 With Speech, Fighter Jets, Military Tanks
Navy SEAL Edward Gallagher Found Not Guilty of Murdering Teen ISIS Prisoner
Kamala Harris Thinks That Busing in 2019 Would Be a Good Idea — Seriously
Major NRA donor to lead rebellion gunning for ‘radioactive’ leader Wayne LaPierre
Why America Fears (And Would Try to Kill) Iran's F-14 Tomcats In a War
Texas migrant detention facilities 'dangerously overcrowded' – US government report
Trump erupts after Supreme Court rejects 2020 census citizenship question: 'USA! USA! USA!'
Hong Kong protests and China's tightening grip rattle business community
Police reports shed light on rape probe at Phoenix facility
Nike pulls sneaker after Kaepernick objection, prompting Republican fury
Alert level increased at world's largest volcano in Hawaii
Japan whale restaurants cheer hunt resumption
Man pours water on Baidu CEO at AI conference
Iran to exceed uranium enrichment limit from Sunday: Rouhani
Lagerfeld lives on in Chanel Paris haute couture show
Japanese whalers bring catches ashore after first commercial hunt for three decades
Twenty Things You Probably Didn’t Know about Marianne Williamson
What everyone can learn from the $300 million deal that Taylor Swift claims ‘stripped me of my life’s work’
At least 40 killed after airstrike targets migrant center in Libya
Paul Jubb emerges from Joao Sousa defeat with pride intact after battling Wimbledon debut
Fox News hosts admits they would have criticised North Korea visit by Obama
Auto industry legend Lee Iacocca dies at 94
Canada knocked out by Haiti in Gold Cup quarterfinals
Pregnant Kelly Mary Fauvrelle Murder: Detectives Release CCTV Of Running Man
Obesity rivals smoking as cause of cancer, UK charity warns
Timeline: 'Sewing Circle' to murder case against Navy SEAL
Lagerfeld successor brings demure librarians to Chanel catwalk
Hong Kong protests: Chinese state media cover demonstrations for first time after month of censorship
'Difficulties on the road to AI': man pours water on Baidu chief at conference
Taiwan leader plans US stopover on diplomatic tour
Jury to decide SEAL's punishment for posing with corpse
Strong Model 3 demand helped Tesla set a new all-time record for quarterly deliveries
Joe Biden's backing drops by third in new polls after debate clash with Kamala Harris
Tucker Carlson Defends Don Jr. for Retweeting Birther-Style Kamala Harris Smear
Mexico deports 33% more migrants after deal with US
Bernie Sanders raises $18 million in second quarter for 2020 bid, trails Buttigieg
The Latest: Hong Kong leader condemns protest in legislature
Hong Kong protest demands: drop extradition, free arrested
North Korea Economic Crisis Looms on Sanctions, Think Tank Says
Iran's breach of uranium limits complicates nuclear deal
EU summit suspended amid 'enormous frustration' over jobs stalemate
Harris surges, Biden slips after debates: polls
Venezuela: widow of 'tortured' navy captain demands UN investigation
House Democrats Sue Treasury, IRS Head for Trump Tax Returns
AOC denounces ICE as 'rogue agency' after visit to 'unsafe' child detention centre
Federal Inspectors Release Photos to Blast DHS for ‘Dangerous’ Overcrowding at Border Facilities
Pompeo vows support for Venezuela's Guaido ahead of march
European powers won't trigger Iran deal dispute mechanism for now: diplomats
Can't Touch This: Iran's Anti-Aircraft Missiles Won't Hurt the F-35
Top US official to meet Salvadoran, Honduran leaders on migration
US Navy SEAL found not guilty of murder in war crimes trial
China Fears A Soviet-Style Collapse in Hong Kong
Take the Spotlight Off North Korea
Chinese State Media Seizes on Hong Kong Chaos, Defends Police
U.S. Navy SEAL acquitted of murder in war crimes trial
First whales caught as Japan resumes commercial hunt after 30 years
Shocking photos show migrants in cramped and unsanitary facilities
Man who claimed to have protected students during school shooting revealed to be a hoax
'Dangerous overcrowding' decried at Texas migrant detention centers
Hungary passes controversial science sector reform bill
The Latest: 4 family members among Texas plane crash victims
Church steps in to host LGBT+ prom after library cancels in face of backlash
Europeans urge Iran to abide by nuclear pact; Israel says preparing military
Biden Support Shrinks in Second Post-Debate Poll as Harris Rises
Kylie Jenner says being a mother made her respect Kris much more
China slams Trump's 'gross interference' in Hong Kong
Silver Frost 1966 Ford Mustang Fastback Will Send Chills Down Your Back
U.S. Navy SEAL acquitted of most serious charges in war crimes trial
Trump news: Congress files tax return lawsuit as president rages against Robert Mueller and insists military leaders 'thrilled' to take part in 4th of July tank display
Mexico buses home dozens of asylum seekers returned by US
Tesla stock surges after setting new delivery and production records
2020 Census Won’t Have Citizenship Question as Trump Administration Drops Effort
US duty free magnates fund controversial Israeli settlements
Harris surges, Biden slips after debate: new poll
‘Midsommar’ Review: Building a Horror Møusetrap With Swedish Bait
Love Island Results: Amber Left Single After Michael Recouples With Joanna
England Knocked Out Of Women's World Cup After Defeat To USA In Semi-Final
Trump administration charging undocumented immigrants $500,000 ahead of planned mass raids
Navy SEAL acquitted of murder in killing of captive in Iraq
There Are 500,000 U.S. Citizens Living in Mexico
Government photos show detained migrants pleading for help
Xi urged Trump to ease North Korea sanctions in 'timely' fashion
800-Horsepower 1968 Plymouth GTX Is Big, Bad, And Pink
Iran trying to 'blackmail' world by violating nuclear deal: Netanyahu
As U.S. Forces Gather Near Iran (Think F-22s and F-35s), Russia Jams Their GPS
Mike Pence abruptly returns to White House as reports of ‘emergency’ situation spark online misinformation
Christine Lagarde continues to break glass ceilings
Carrie Lam: Hong Kong's divisive, pro-Beijing leader
Jury reviews testimony on knife in Navy SEAL murder case
US Border Patrol chief responds to lewd officer Facebook group, after reports of 'hostility' from members of congress
Mom who tried to kill baby held in his death 11 years later
Secret Service agent who served president dies in tragic accident
Virginia Beach worker charged; won't return to crime scene
Iran Risks Rift With Europe by Breaching Nuclear Deal Limit
Can China Track and Shoot Down the F-22?
Hong Kong grapples with protest aftermath as China demands criminal probe
NASA tests abort system for spacecraft that will carry humans to the moon in 2024
Khloé Kardashian gets reminded of weight struggles after calling Jordyn Woods 'fat'
Prince Harry Ignoring Meghan Markle at a Baseball Game Prove Royals Are as Awkward as Us
Miley Cyrus wears vagina dentata catsuit in 'Mother's Daughter' video
Apex Legends Season 2 Battle Charge: New weapons, characters and game modes come to battle royale sensation in latest update
Women's Ashes: Ellyse Perry out after 'wonderful glovework' by Sarah Taylor
Close