Close
Date TimeJune 28, 2019
Voice

Kamala Harris Is Surging and Birtherism Is Back
Photo Illustration by The Daily Beast/GettyKamala Harris broke out from the other nine Democrats onstage during the second Democratic presidential primary debate on Thursday, calling on her personal experiences of racial injustice as a black woman.“As the only black person on this stage, I would like to speak on the issue of race,” Harris said.That’s when she was attacked on Twitter by a conservative provocateur for not being an “American black.” It’s a play straight out of the racist birther playbook used against Barack Obama when he ran for president a decade earlier. This time, though, those kinds of allegations don’t have to circulate for years on obscure right-wing forums before they reach a mainstream audience. On Thursday night, spammers and even one of President Trump’s sons spread the attack to millions of people within hours. Kamala Harris Shows She’s Here to Capture the CrownHarris, 54, was born in Oakland, California to a father from Jamaica and a mother from India. She spoke of her experience growing up black in the debate, recalling a story about neighbors who wouldn’t let their children play with Harris and her sister because of the color of their skin.The attacks on Harris’s background started Thursday when Ali Alexander tweeted she is not an “American black.” “She is half Indian and half Jamaican,” Alexander wrote. “I'm so sick of people robbing American Blacks (like myself) of our history. It's disgusting. Now using it for debate time at DemDebate2? These are my people not her people. Freaking disgusting.”Alexander’s claim was picked up by Donald Trump Jr., who tweeted it to his nearly 3.6 million followers. “Is this true?” Trump Jr. wrote. “Wow.”Trump Jr., who later deleted his tweet, wasn’t the only one using Alexander’s tweet to question Harris’s ethnicity. Harris’s team denounced the comment as racist. “This is the same type of racist attacks his father used to attack Barack Obama. It didn’t work then and it won’t work now,” a Harris spokesperson told The Daily Beast.More Twitter users copied and pasted Alexander’s message verbatim and tweeted it as their own, according to screenshots posted by writer Caroline Orr. Some of those accounts, like “@prebs_73,” have copy-pasted other popular right-wing tweets verbatim. Other accounts with right-wing references in their usernames and biographies piled on, accusing Harris of not being black.“Ummmmm @KamalaHarris you are NOT BLACK. you are Indian and Jamaican,” wrote a Twitter user with a cross emoji, the word “CONSERVATIVE,” a red “X” emoji (a right-wing Twitter trope), and three stars (a QAnon symbol) in their username.At least one known network of bot accounts was found spreading Alexander’s original tweet, BuzzFeed reported.Shireen Mitchell, a technologist and founder of the group Stop Online Violence Against Women, said the accusation against Harris plays into a long-running debate that has been used to drive a white nationalist wedge through black communities.“We are and have always been, for centuries in this country, having this little fight about who gets opportunities as black people and who doesn’t,” Mitchell said. “That includes colorism; that includes distinctions of where the ship actually landed; it includes if you are (and I am) a descendant of a slave who was born here versus a descendant of slavery from another country. Those distinctions, from my perspective, make no sense ever. But what it does is allow for white nationalist and nativist conversations to be planted in my community.”A spokesman for Trump Jr. said Trump sent the tweet originally because he had not known that Harris’s mother was Indian. “Don’s tweet was simply him asking if it’s true that Kamala Harris was half-Indian because it’s not something he had ever heard before and once he saw that folks were misconstruing the intent of his tweet he quickly deleted it,” the spokesman said. Alexander, who describes himself as black and Arab, said that Harris has a “nasty, lying history with Black people.” “Me pointing out that Kamala Harris has a mother from India and a father from Jamaica went viral last night because many people assume she descends from Black American Slaves,” he said in a statement to The Daily Beast. “She does not. I corrected Kamala Harris last night because she stole debate time under the premise that she is an African-American when she is in fact a biracial Indian-Jamaican who is a first generation American.”This isn’t the first time pro-Trump activists have tried to undermine Harris and her authority to speak on issues of race based on her parents. In January, right-wing operative Jacob Wohl, an associate of Alexander, argued on Twitter that Harris was ineligible to be president because her parents weren’t from the United States, even though she was born in California. Wohl’s claims were circulated by other right-wing figures online, in an attempt to create a birther-style question about whether Harris could legally run for president.Mitchell, who has monitored harassment campaigns against black women since 2013, said Harris is facing a new, digital permutation of the birther conspiracy theory attacks President Trump levied against Obama.“It’s a different iteration of birtherism: ‘where were you born?’ She was born in Oakland!” Mitchell said, referring to the conspiracy theory that falsely accused Obama of being born outside the U.S. “The conversation is, no matter who we are, our blackness should be challenged because what we look like is not ‘American enough.’”Mitchell draws a distinction between two kinds of fraudulent accounts that try to discredit black people online. Botnets, an automated network of fake accounts, often tweet the same message. The technique allows a message to spread far and fast, with little effort. Some of the copy-paste accounts sharing Alexander’s message appear to be operated by real people. Mitchell also monitors a trend called “marionetting,” in which someone will falsely pose as a black person online to push ideas that many black people might otherwise find objectionable. Recent examples of marionetting include a troll who stole a black transgender activist’s picture to pose as a Trump supporter, and Russian-run accounts like “Blacktivist” that impersonated black Americans to sway black voters away from Hillary Clinton in 2016.“I actually thought the botnet was going to die, because I felt like more marionetting was happening ... After this debate, I saw more botnets responding again, versus just marionetting.”Fraudulent accounts often rely on stereotypes that trolls hope to apply to a collection of fake accounts, Mitchell said.“The ‘black enough’ line has been a stereotypical frame,” she said. “It has always been a systemic narrative. It’s just being expanded in this national debate”‘Digital Blackface’: Pro-Trump Trolls Are Impersonating Black People on TwitterRead more at The Daily Beast.Get our top stories in your inbox every day. Sign up now!Daily Beast Membership: Beast Inside goes deeper on the stories that matter to you. Learn more.




Grab This Survivor 1966 Ford Mustang Convertible
Iran Strikes Back Against America. Is a War Coming to the Middle East?
US Rapper Slim 400 'shot eight times' in Compton
NBA free agency: Kemba Walker will sign with Boston Celtics, Kyrie Irving is on the move
The Killers' Brandon Flowers pays tribute to Welsh crowd at Cardiff Castle show
Huawei ban prompts Apple to slightly increase iPhone production
Another critical software bug means the Boeing 737 Max still isn’t safe to fly
Ram tough: FCA turns up the heat on GM and Ford in U.S. truck sales war
Indian women's heads shaved for 'resisting' rape
Widow, mother of drowning victims returns to El Salvador
Video Of First Corvettes Being Built Is An Entertaining Blast From The Past
Supreme Court majority strikes down efforts to stop gerrymandering
Trump: If There Was a Wall, Immigrant Dad and Daughter Who Drowned ‘Would Be Saved’
Who won the Democratic debates? Kamala Harris, Elizabeth Warren – and Trump
China says Trump, Xi reach trade truce
Trump reveals US companies will be allowed to sell to Huawei as China trade talks get ‘back on track’
Carrie Underwood in Birmingham UK - setlist, tickets, start and finish times
Newark Airport reopens after being shut down due to 'airport emergency'
Cara Delevingne and girlfriend Ashley Benson attend Zoe Kravitz's wedding rehearsal dinner in Paris
Cigarettes, alcohol and a 5am jog: how to become Liam Gallagher
Meghan Markle, Prince Harry visit Yankees, Red Sox before first London game
Biden’s Debate Stumble Exposes His Fragile Front-Runner Status
Trump aide Jared Kushner held meetings with foreign nations without telling State Department, Rex Tillerson says
Iran judges 'progress' made at nuclear meeting but 'still not enough'
Tillerson says Kushner conducted foreign policy without him
Texas Prep School Faculty Abused 15 Students Over 3 Decades, Investigation Reveals
Trump Says Neither Biden Nor Harris Won Debate Clash Over Race
Bank of America to Cut Ties with Companies That Run Migrant-Detention Facilities
Trump dismisses Carter's attacks on his legitimacy
Tesla provides update on the Model S that burst into flames for no apparent reason
Western liberalism is obsolete, warns Putin, ahead of May meeting
Trump hints at softer stance on China's Huawei
Ex-prosecutor locked up after guilty verdict in Hawaii
Trump jokingly warns Putin not to ‘meddle’ in 2020 election
SNL’s Kate McKinnon Debuts Spot-On Marianne Williamson Impression
The Latest: Biden says Harris misrepresented busing stance
Chinese military gets Hong Kong harbour dock, despite tensions
'Back on track': Trump, Xi seal trade war truce
Is Kylie Jenner Pregnant With Baby No.2?
Meghan Markle and Kate Middleton Are Bonding Over This Commonality
Britney Spears gives off strong '…Baby One More Time' vibes in throwback schoolgirl outfit
Katharine McPhee and David Foster are married: 'This one just felt right'
Bad Bunny & Drop Surprise Album 'OASIS': Listen
'We'll follow her campaign until the White House': Harris a hit among among those watching 2020 Democratic debate
‘I didn’t want them to go’: Mother remembers father and daughter who drowned in Rio Grande
SpaceX targets 2021 commercial Starship launch
Luis Alvarez, former NYPD cop who advocated for 9/11 responders with Jon Stewart, dies
Charles Leclerc takes Austrian Grand Prix pole ahead of Lewis Hamilton
Lewis Hamilton faces three-place grid penalty at Austrian GP from qualifying incident
Trump Bows to Xi Jinping's Huawei Demands at G20
US deploys F-22 stealth fighters to Qatar amid Iran tensions
New ruling puts high court overhaul back on 2020 Dems' radar
Kamala Harris just changed the direction of the presidential race
Middle East War: How Iran Could Attack the U.S. Navy's Aircraft Carriers
Breathtaking 1965 Chevrolet Impala SS Thrills In More Ways Than One
U.S. federal judge blocks use of some funds for border wall
Donald Trump says he wants to meet Kim Jong-un at DMZ 'just to shake his hand and say hello'
Debate Takeaways: Harris Soars, Biden Stumbles, Buttigieg Scores
Trump Supreme Court pick Kavanaugh delivered the goods for conservatives
Russia vs. America: Su-35s Attack F-15s and F-16s (Who Wins?)
Uruguay protests role of Venezuela's opposition at gathering
GOP whip Scalise cites Trump accuser’s ‘bizarre’ CNN interview in doubting her account
4 weighted blankets on sale this weekend
Putin says oil output deal helped stabilize world markets
Bad News: Iran is Using Western Drone Technology Against America
El Salvador president says China relations fully established
Mysterious 'Fast Radio Burst' Traced Back to Its Home Galaxy for First Time Ever
The Battleship USS Maryland Had One Mission: Kill Other Battleships
Trump says Saudi crown prince doing 'spectacular job'
Trump’s ‘Remain in Mexico’ immigration policy threatens migrants’ lives, asylum officers say
New Istanbul mayor a catalyst for change in old Erdogan stronghold
Glock Gun Battle Royal: Glock's Model 19 vs. Model 23 (Which Is Better?)
The Latest: Biker killed remembered as public servant
Putin brings own mug to G20 summit
Central American migrants plead to seek asylum in U.S., not Mexico
All of the Reasons Why the Glock 46 Gun Dominates
Harris's Personal Story Bests Biden's Senate Record on Race
The Dalai Lama slams Trump for lack of moral principle
Lady Gaga makes surprise appearance outside Stonewall Inn
Katharine McPhee weds David Foster on anniversary of 'very first single'
Surprise! Shay Mitchell is expecting her first child months after revealing miscarriage
Melissa McCarthy in talks to play Ursula in live-action Little Mermaid
Darren Collison's sudden retirement stuns former Pacers teammates
Slim 400 Reportedly Shot 10 Times and Is Currently Hospitalized
States poised to take up fight over partisan gerrymandering
US seeks NATO help in anti-Iran coalition
Judge weighs new US policy keeping asylum seekers locked up
Hedge-Fund Heir Found Guilty of Murdering Father After Allowance Was Cut
Democrats Debate, Round 2: Who Won, Who Lost and Who Needs to Quit
'We only want to sell our oil,' Iran official says before nuclear talks
Catholic Bishop Escorts Migrants over Border to Protest U.S. Immigration Policy
It took two minutes for Taco Bell to sell out its new hotel, because people are weird
Last C7 Sells For $2.7 Million At Barrett-Jackson Auction
China hopes new Pentagon chief seeks to avoid confrontation
Biden scrambles after slipping in Democrats' debate
Air Force Fighter Pilot Reveals Why Nothing Gets Close To An F-35 or F-22
Debate takeaways: Biden slips, Harris soars, Dems tilt left
Trump Playing Joker Is Putin's G-20 Ace Card
US expects 25 pc drop in arrests on Mexico border in June
Russia Has Low Expectations Ahead of Trump-Putin G20 Meeting
Harris Lights Into Biden as Democratic Debate Turns Testy
Debate Exposes Split Among 2020 Democrats on Direction for Party
Famous 1965 Kirkham Cobra Could Be All Yours
US female footballer Ali Krieger joins teammate in White House boycott: 'I will sit this one out as well'
Women who fought off gang rape 'shamed' by having heads shaved in Indian village square
Fox News Anchor Chris Wallace: Joe Biden ‘Looked Like a Wimp’
Trump news: Jimmy Carter questions president's legitimacy as POTUS jokes with Putin about election interference
SCOTUS Won’t Revive Alabama Law Banning Dismemberment Abortion
Kamala Harris Just Taught a Debate Clinic. You’re Welcome
2020 Election Meddling by China, Iran, N. Korea Likely, Administration Officials Warn
Kamala Harris Uses Her Story to Force Dems to Really Consider Race
Trump official blames migrant father for drowning with daughter
Border bill exposes Dems' rift over limits of fighting Trump
NASA will fly a drone to Titan to search for life
Justices won't revive Alabama ban on abortion procedure
Watch This Controversial Electric Shelby Cobra Daytona In Action
US sanctions Maduro's son as it raises pressure on Venezuela
AOC says three Democratic candidates stood out during 'breakaway' night of debates
Jony Ive to leave Apple and form his own design company
Senate backs massive defense bill, targets China, sets Iran vote
Senate Rejects Proposal to Curtail Trump's Options in Iran
Trump jokes with Putin at G20: 'Don't meddle in the election, please'
The Story of How America's Mach 3 SR-71 Spy Plane Out Ran Missiles
Bernie Sanders Says He Would ‘Rotate’ Conservative Judges Off the Supreme Court
Supreme Court Thwarts Trump on Census, Prompting Him to Seek Delay
Bishop walks migrants across US border bridge to protest Trump policy
Report: Apple to shift assembly of Mac Pro from US to China
The 1985 Case That Sets the Rules for How Government Can Treat Migrant Children
It might as well already be Prime Day now that Apple Watches are back down to $199
Bodies of father and daughter taken home as Trump blamed for border chaos
China's Xi to present Trump with terms for settling trade fight: WSJ, citing Chinese officials
Wargames: This Amazing Picture Shows F-35s Doing Something Only F-35s Can Do
U.S. will sanction any countries that import Iranian oil: special envoy
Huge crowd flocks to Istanbul mayor inauguration
Senate Bill to Curtail Trump's Iran Options Faces Tough Odds
The supreme court is supposed to be a check on the political process. Is it still?
Supreme Court to hear Trump bid to ditch 'Dreamers' immigration program
Beth Chapman's public memorial service set
NBA rumors: Celtics are hiring Kara Lawson as an assistant coach
Jimmy Carter suggests Trump is an illegitimate president
Iran sees some progress on nuclear deal, but not enough
Trump, with a wag, asks Putin not to meddle in U.S. elections
Trump jokes about election meddling with Putin
This 1996 Chevrolet Impala SS is One Sinister Sedan
'Emotional' Ukraine president urges Putin to free sailors
With a smile, Trump tells Putin 'don't meddle in the election'
Bikers bid farewell to those killed in pickup collision
Supreme Court declines Alabama bid to revive abortion restriction
Kamala Harris Shows She’s Here to Capture the Crown
U.S. Supreme Court declines Alabama bid to revive abortion restriction
This huge leak might be our first look at the Galaxy Note 10+ in real-life photos
Norwegian man sentenced to 16 years for abusing hundreds of boys
No country for old white men: Kamala Harris heralds changing of the guard
Bikers bidding farewell to those killed in pickup collision
Theresa May calls on Vladimir Putin to halt 'irresponsible' activity around the world
Last Night's Big Debate: Democratic Candidates Are Sounding a Lot like Teddy Roosevelt
‘He Is Not Going To Like This’: Twitter Will Downgrade Trump Tweets That Break Site’s Rules
Trump news – live: Outrage over president's joke with Putin about election interference, as he says 'get rid of' journalists on deadly newsroom shooting anniversary
Yellowstone's Steamboat Geyser Is Incredibly Active Right Now, and We Don't Know Why
'Get rid of them': Trump unites with Putin over disdain for journalists who write stories they don't like
France records all-time highest temperature of 45.1C
'Despicable act': May confronts Putin over Salisbury poisoning
Trump jokes to Putin they should 'get rid' of journalists
Trump can't help himself when it comes to Putin
Dalai Lama Says Any Female Successor Would Need To Be 'Attractive'
Five takeaways from the second Democratic presidential debate
China warns of 'severe threats' to global order at G20
Kamala Harris Stakes Claim as Top 2020 Contender in Clash With Biden
Pope responds 'with immense sadness' to death of father and daughter who drowned at US-Mexico border
Stealth vs. Russia: U.S. F-22s and F-35s vs. Russia's S-300 and S-400 (Who Wins?)
Who won the Democrats' second debate? Our panelists' verdicts
House sends Trump $4.6B border bill, yielding to Senate
Alabama: pregnant woman shot in stomach is charged in fetus's death
Mika Brzezinski on success of 'Morning Joe': 'I'm the reason it's still going'
A U.S.-China Trade Deal Would Do Little To Fix 1 Big Issue
Democratic debate result: Kamala Harris comes off above the 'food fight' as Biden and Sanders disappoint
In victory for Trump, U.S. House Democrats back down on border aid bill demands
Mueller to Testify Publicly Before Congress
No country for old white men: Kamala Harris leads changing of the guard
This Dark Ivy Green 1970 Ford Mustang Fastback Arouses Envy
High court's ruling shifts gerrymandering focus to states
This 'Old' Bomber from Russia Could Sink U.S. Navy Warships
Iraqi general, U.S. Marine dispute murder charge against Navy SEAL
Parties to Iran nuclear deal meet amid threat of collapse
Russia's Putin says liberal values are obsolete: Financial Times
The Price Is Right On This 1985 Ford F-250 Lariat XLT
Shot American woman who miscarried faces homicide charge
New Mexico mother accused of boiling puppies to punishment children
Russia Thinks America's Stealth Fighters Are Paper Fiction
Harris sends Biden into a meltdown with poignant speech on race
Are these your ‘animals’, Mr Trump? Photo of drowned father and daughter at US border illustrates ultimate human cost of president’s attitude towards families desperately seeking a better life
Trump calls for US census delay after Supreme Court defeat
Iran's Zarif rejects Trump idea of short war as 'illusion'
Joe Biden Attacked at the Democratic Debate for Being Old
Trump on Democratic debate: 'BORING'
‘Trump is responsible’: Democrats, celebrities and activists react to photo of drowned father and toddler
Trump slams Democratic debates at G20 summit over healthcare for migrants: ‘That’s the end of that race!’
The Reason Russia All of a Sudden Scrambled Half Of Its Stealth Fighters
Beth Chapman Will Be Honored With 2 Memorial Services
Kim Kardashian Stands By Kimono Brand Name Despite Cries Of Cultural Appropriation
Close