Close
Date TimeJune 26, 2019
Voice

Are these your ‘animals’, Mr Trump? Photo of drowned father and daughter at US border illustrates ultimate human cost of president’s attitude towards families desperately seeking a better life
A 23-month-old girl lies face down in the waters of the Rio Grande, tucked into her father’s black t-shirt. Her arm is draped around his neck, suggesting she died clutching his body.The image of the bodies of Oscar Alberto Martinez Ramirez and his daughter Valeria have prompted outrage across Mexico and the US, further highlighting the plight faced by Central American migrants hoping to claim asylum in America.Mr Ramirez crossed the river which separates the neighbouring on Sunday, carrying his child, according to La Jornada, a Mexican newspaper.The 26-year-old placed the girl on the US bank of the river and started to return to the other side, to fetch his wife, when his daughter jumped after him.Mr Martinez caught hold of Valeria, but both were swept away by the current. The pair were found dead shortly afterwards.Amid tears and screams, Tania Vanessa Avalos, Mr Ramirez’s wife, reportedly described the drowning to police officers at the scene.The family fled their home in El Salvador on 3 April and lived for around two months in a shelter in Tapachula, near Mexico’s border with Guatemala.Mr Ramirez decided to swim across the river after reportedly growing frustrated over the family’s inability to present themselves to US border authorities and formally request asylum.A Mexican state official said the family visited the US consulate in the city of Matamoros early on Sunday.Asylum claims in the US can take months and years to process. It is unclear what occurred at the consulate but the family decided to cross the river later that day.“When the girl jumped in is when he tried to reach her, but when he tried to grab the girl, he went in further ... and he couldn’t get out,” Rosa Ramirez, the 26-year-old’s mother, said. “He put her in his shirt, and I imagine he told himself, ‘I’ve come this far’ and decided to go with her.”Ms Ramirez is in El Salvador and spoke to her daughter-in-law on the phone after the drownings.“I begged them not to go, but he wanted to scrape together money to build a home,” she said.“They hoped to be there a few years and save up for the house.”The Independent has taken the decision to publish the image in an effort to illustrate the human cost of the Trump administration's approach towards immigration and those families desperately attempting to enter the country in search of a better life.Mexican newspapers have compared the image of the father and daughter to a 2015 photograph of Alan Kurdi, a three-year-old Syrian boy who drowned in the Mediterranean.“Very regrettable that this would happen,” Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador, the Mexican president, said.“We have always denounced that as there is more rejection in the United States, there are people who lose their lives in the desert or crossing [the river]”.Mexico has attempted to work with the Trump administration on the migrant crisis, which has been fuelled by people fleeing unrest and violence in Central America.The Trump administration’s immigration policy has dramatically reduced the number of migrants who are allowed to request asylum, down from dozens per day previously to sometimes just a handful at some ports of entry. “With greater crackdowns and restrictions,” said Cris Ramon, senior immigration policy analyst at the Bipartisan Policy Center think tank in Washington, “we could see more desperate measures by people trying to enter Mexico or the US.”Mr Trump himself has frequently used demonising language when talking of immigrants - not least those crossing the US-Mexico border \- employing terms such as "animals", "stone cold criminals" and "bad hombres" who he has described as "infesting our country".A series of Democratic candidates hoping to face Mr Trump in the 2020 presidential race spoke out in response to the photo.Beto O'Rourke said "Trump is responsible for these deaths", while Cory Booker also sought to link the deaths to the president's policies, saying: "These are the consequences of Donald Trump’s inhumane and immoral immigration policy. This is being done in our name."Kamala Harris said: "That is inhumane. Children are dying. This is a stain on our moral conscience."In 2018 283 migrants died crossing between ports of entry.Mr Ramirez and Valeria’s bodies will be flown to El Salvador on Thursday.There was no immediate comment on the tragedy from the Trump administration.Additional reporting by agencies




Related Stories
Feds confirm ‘Ice Bae’ is a CBP officer, is free to use social mediaFeds confirm ‘Ice Bae’ is a CBP officer, is free to use social media
Bianca Devins Found Refuge Online. Then Her Murder Went ViralBianca Devins Found Refuge Online. Then Her Murder Went Viral
Meghan Markle shamed online for how she held son Archie at polo eventMeghan Markle shamed online for how she held son Archie at polo event
Instant Hotel Series 2: Everything The Netflix Show Doesnt Tell You About The ContestantsInstant Hotel Series 2: Everything The Netflix Show Doesn't Tell You About The Contestants
Hailey Baldwin Has Legs For Days In Tiny Daisy Dukes On Lunch Date With Justin BieberHailey Baldwin Has Legs For Days In Tiny Daisy Dukes On Lunch Date With Justin Bieber
Police make arrest in gruesome murder of Russian Instagram starPolice make arrest in gruesome murder of Russian Instagram star
Miley Cyrus Says She Felt Ridiculous Being Hannah Montana After Having SexMiley Cyrus Says She Felt 'Ridiculous' Being Hannah Montana After Having Sex
Miley Cyrus business attire includes a bikiniMiley Cyrus' business attire includes a bikini
Former NFL star Mitch Petrus dies of suspected heat stroke aged just 32Former NFL star Mitch Petrus dies of suspected heat stroke aged just 32
British woman arrested over false rape claim in Ayia NapaBritish woman 'arrested over false rape claim' in Ayia Napa
Latest News
UK consulate staffer returns to Hong Kong after China detentionUK consulate staffer returns to Hong Kong after China detention
Trump challenges court ruling barring him from blocking Twitter usersTrump challenges court ruling barring him from blocking Twitter users
Nasa investigating first ever ‘space crime’ as astronaut accused of committing theft from ISSNasa investigating first ever ‘space crime’ as astronaut accused of committing theft from ISS
Iceland Held Talks With U.S. Ambassador Over Pence VisitIceland Held Talks With U.S. Ambassador Over Pence Visit
Fear grips Bangladesh camp as 2 Rohingya refugees killedFear grips Bangladesh camp as 2 Rohingya refugees killed
Hong Kong protests met with tear gas; China frees UK mission stafferHong Kong protests met with tear gas; China frees UK mission staffer
Docking aborted for Russias first humanoid robot in spaceDocking aborted for Russia's first humanoid robot in space
Liverpool v Arsenal: Premier League – live!Liverpool v Arsenal: Premier League – live!
Maitland and Harris edge Scotland to comeback victory over FranceMaitland and Harris edge Scotland to comeback victory over France
South Africa’s Aphiwe Dyanti tests positive for banned substanceSouth Africa’s Aphiwe Dyanti tests positive for banned substance
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
Feds confirm ‘Ice Bae’ is a CBP officer, is free to use social mediaFeds confirm ‘Ice Bae’ is a CBP officer, is free to use social media
Bianca Devins Found Refuge Online. Then Her Murder Went ViralBianca Devins Found Refuge Online. Then Her Murder Went Viral
Meghan Markle shamed online for how she held son Archie at polo eventMeghan Markle shamed online for how she held son Archie at polo event
Instant Hotel Series 2: Everything The Netflix Show Doesnt Tell You About The ContestantsInstant Hotel Series 2: Everything The Netflix Show Doesn't Tell You About The Contestants
Hailey Baldwin Has Legs For Days In Tiny Daisy Dukes On Lunch Date With Justin BieberHailey Baldwin Has Legs For Days In Tiny Daisy Dukes On Lunch Date With Justin Bieber
Police make arrest in gruesome murder of Russian Instagram starPolice make arrest in gruesome murder of Russian Instagram star
Miley Cyrus Says She Felt Ridiculous Being Hannah Montana After Having SexMiley Cyrus Says She Felt 'Ridiculous' Being Hannah Montana After Having Sex
Miley Cyrus business attire includes a bikiniMiley Cyrus' business attire includes a bikini
Former NFL star Mitch Petrus dies of suspected heat stroke aged just 32Former NFL star Mitch Petrus dies of suspected heat stroke aged just 32
British woman arrested over false rape claim in Ayia NapaBritish woman 'arrested over false rape claim' in Ayia Napa
Latest News
UK consulate staffer returns to Hong Kong after China detentionUK consulate staffer returns to Hong Kong after China detention
Trump challenges court ruling barring him from blocking Twitter usersTrump challenges court ruling barring him from blocking Twitter users
Nasa investigating first ever ‘space crime’ as astronaut accused of committing theft from ISSNasa investigating first ever ‘space crime’ as astronaut accused of committing theft from ISS
Iceland Held Talks With U.S. Ambassador Over Pence VisitIceland Held Talks With U.S. Ambassador Over Pence Visit
Fear grips Bangladesh camp as 2 Rohingya refugees killedFear grips Bangladesh camp as 2 Rohingya refugees killed
Hong Kong protests met with tear gas; China frees UK mission stafferHong Kong protests met with tear gas; China frees UK mission staffer
Docking aborted for Russias first humanoid robot in spaceDocking aborted for Russia's first humanoid robot in space
Liverpool v Arsenal: Premier League – live!Liverpool v Arsenal: Premier League – live!
Maitland and Harris edge Scotland to comeback victory over FranceMaitland and Harris edge Scotland to comeback victory over France
South Africa’s Aphiwe Dyanti tests positive for banned substanceSouth Africa’s Aphiwe Dyanti tests positive for banned substance
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Trump calls for US census delay after Supreme Court defeat
Iran's Zarif rejects Trump idea of short war as 'illusion'
Joe Biden Attacked at the Democratic Debate for Being Old
Trump on Democratic debate: 'BORING'
‘Trump is responsible’: Democrats, celebrities and activists react to photo of drowned father and toddler
Trump slams Democratic debates at G20 summit over healthcare for migrants: ‘That’s the end of that race!’
The Reason Russia All of a Sudden Scrambled Half Of Its Stealth Fighters
Beth Chapman Will Be Honored With 2 Memorial Services
Kim Kardashian Stands By Kimono Brand Name Despite Cries Of Cultural Appropriation
Vladimir Putin says liberalism has 'become obsolete' and praises Donald Trump as 'talented person'
Jony Ive, Apple designer behind iPhone and iMac, to exit company after 30 years
Marianne Williamson stands out from Democratic field with eccentric debate display
Harris attacks Biden's record on race in Democratic debate's key moment
Venezuela Regime Says Guaido, Two Dozen More Planned Coups
Hawaii skydiving crash victims remembered by friends, family
SCOTUS Rules Gerrymandering Constitutional, Says Courts Have No Role in Deciding Partisanship Claims
Boeing aims to finish software fix to 737 Max in September
U.S., China agree tentative trade truce ahead of G20 summit: SCMP
Why Trump Lost the Census Case
The Latest: Man gets life in prison for daughter's death
Iran delays threat to breach terms of nuclear deal ahead of signatories' summit
The Latest: House clears Senate version of border aid bill
Fox News’ Brian Kilmeade: ‘I Don’t Think’ Mueller ‘Knows the Details’ of His Own Report
Pelosi Caves, Will Hold Vote on Senate-Passed Border-Funding Bill
Navy Seal Witness Contradicts Testimony from Snipers Who Said Eddie Gallagher Shot Civilian
Democrats Turn Mueller Frustration Into Election Security Focus
Oppo’s new messaging app doesn’t need Wi-Fi or even cellular service to send and receive messages
Uruguay withdraws from OAS meeting over Venezuela opposition delegation
Apple's star designer Jony Ive to set up own firm
Search for missing student turns up 'person of interest'
Supreme Court allows partisan districts, blocks census query
How lifeless body of toddler came to be slumped by dead father in river on US-Mexico border
Real, Unrestored, And Rare 1967 Ford Mustang GTA
Supreme Court Backs Partisan Voting Maps, Opening Path for More
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Mocks Beto and Booker’s ‘Humorous’ Spanish Skills at Democratic Debate
Marine testifies Navy SEAL did not stab Iraq captive
Two women come forward to corroborate Donald Trump rape accuser E Jean Carroll's claim
Boeing shares hit as FAA finds new 737 MAX issue
SCOTUS Blocks Trump Administration from Including Census Citizenship Question
Family of Slain University of Utah Student Lauren McCluskey Files $56 Million Lawsuit Against School
High Court Thwarts Trump on Census, Prompting Him to Seek Delay
Google now lets you set a timer to auto-delete mobile location history and activity data
Exclusive: Western intelligence hacked 'Russia's Google' Yandex to spy on accounts - sources
John Roberts Throws the Administrative State a Lifeline
Michigan AG sues to shut down oil pipeline in Great Lakes
Astronomers Have Decoded a Weird Signal Coming from a Strange, 3-Body Star System
In Surprise Census Decision, Supreme Court Finally Calls BS on the Trump Administration
‘Angry’ Rex Tillerson Says Jared Kushner Hijacked U.S. Foreign Policy
Elon Musk: SpaceX flights between cities will feel like Disney's Space Mountain
'Charlie’s Angels’ trailer: Can Kristen Stewart help beat the original?
'Person of interest' emerges in case of missing Utah woman
Huawei employees worked with China’s military on tech research projects
Western intelligence hacked 'Russia's Google' Yandex to spy on accounts
'The Untouchables,' 'Hills Have Eyes' star Billy Drago dead at 73
World powers scramble to salvage Iran nuclear deal days before country breaches stockpile limits
The Latest: House to vote on Senate's emergency border bill
Democratic debate: Cory Booker explains his 'side eye' look when Beto O'Rourke spoke Spanish
Airlines cancel more Boeing 737 MAX flights as some crash victims refuse to settle
Trump Wants Census Delay After Citizenship Question Blocked
The Border Crisis Isn’t Partisan
OAS seeks to increase pressure on Venezuela's Maduro at meeting
U.S. House panel votes to subpoena Trump adviser Kellyanne Conway on Hatch Act
Texas man gets life sentence in 3-year-old daughter's death
Cory Booker's peeved reaction to Beto speaking Spanish at the debate is an instant meme
Did India Just Make China's New Stealth Fighters Obsolete?
Meghan McCain Complains Too Much Spanish at Debate, Battles Julián Castro on ‘Open Borders’
Supreme Court Unleashes New Era of Extreme Gerrymandering
Supreme Court refuses to set limits on electoral redistricting
You can still get the upgraded, faster version of Amazon’s best-selling Wi-Fi extender for $25
Warren emerges from first Democratic debate unscathed
The Navy Will Soon Have a New Weapon to Kill 'Battleships' or Submarines
New software glitch found in Boeing's troubled 737 Max jet
Trump tweets bizarre Democratic debate meme from Air Force One moments before landing in Japan for G20
How Trump Would Strike Iran: Think F-35s, B-2 Bombers, Aircraft Carriers and More
Wipe Out Student Debt and Everyone Wins, Says Bernie's Economist
Evangelical group to spend $50M on get-out-the-vote efforts
First Cut of Steel: The Navy's New Ballistic Missile Submarine Is Coming Soon
Death Match: U.S. Navy F-14 Tomcat vs. Air Force F-15 Eagle (Who Wins)?
NATO weighs boost to air defenses over Russia missile system
First Democratic Debate Shows What the Party Stands For
Ocasio-Cortez: Biden ‘Not a Pragmatic Choice’
Why did the media downplay the latest sexual assault allegation against Trump?
Trump steals the show from 2020 Democrat candidates with top YouTube ads
Former allies of Turkey's Erdogan plan rival party after Istanbul defeat
Jacob Wohl Says He’ll Enlist if Trump Attacks Iran
Abe Hails China Ties, Raises Tough Issues as Xi Visits Japan
Dozens of drivers get stuck in mud after Google reroutes them down dirt road
Cardi B takes it all off in new 'Press' music video
Angela Merkel seen shaking for second time in just over a week
Legend: How 1 Battle Made the F-15 Eagle a Real 'Top Gun'
Jess Glynne Axes Further Live Shows, After Controversy Over Isle Of Wight Cancellation
‘Charlie’s Angels’: Kristen Stewart, Naomi Scott and Ella Balinska Team Up in First Trailer
Republicans demand Trump face rape investigation
Erasing College Debt Helps Everyone, Says Economist Behind Plan
House Panel Subpoenas Kellyanne Conway over ‘Egregious’ Ethics Violations
Mika Brzezinski to Trump: If E. Jean Carroll ‘Not Your Type,’ Who Would You Rape?
U.S. Supreme Court blocks Trump's census citizenship question, for now
Galaxy Note 10 might get an exciting iPhone feature, and it’s all thanks to… Windows 10?
Iran Could Never Counter This Move: America Gives Israel F-22s and B-52 Bombers
Baby India: Newborn baby found in plastic bag in woods
Mexico national guard shows lighter touch with migrants after president's warning
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez says Beto O'Rourke and Cory Booker's Spanish is 'humorous'
2 more deputies fired for inaction after school shooting
Defense: Chinese scholar's killer offered to locate body
Boris Johnson Predicts ‘Million-to-One’ Chance of No-Deal Brexit
Abe Hails China Ties on Xi's First Visit to Japan in a Decade
Tesla's senior production executive at Fremont facility quits - source
Iran warns U.S. of stronger reaction if its borders violated again: Tasnim
China Says Its Demands for a Trade Deal With the U.S. Haven't Changed
U.S. F-35s and B-2 Bombers Will Soon Be Armed with the Ultimate Weapon
Watch Arnold Schwarzenegger go undercover and prank prospective car buyers
What Would a U.S. Attack on Iran Look Like? Think F-35s and B-2 Bombers
Democratic debate winners and losers: Elizabeth Warren triumphs while Beto O'Rourke flounders
NATO agrees response to new Russia missile
Astronauts snapped an incredible photo of a volcano erupting in the Pacific Ocean
Khloe Kardashian Screams At Jordyn Woods In New ‘KUWTK’ Finale Preview: ‘Liar’
Madonna makes powerful gun control statement in disturbing music video: ‘We need to wake up’
Democrats: Mueller testimony to set Russia record straight
Amazon Prime Day adds a July 10th concert headlined by Taylor Swift
Beth Chapman's daughter mourns the late 'Bounty Hunter' star: 'You’ve got a halo now'
Report: Kevin Durant declines player option, will become unrestricted free agent
White House blocks Conway from House oversight hearing
Democratic Debate: Julian Castro Stands Out on Immigration Reform
Tulsi Gabbard's sister calls out MSNBC for favoring Elizabeth Warren in the debate
Shepherd's Bush stabbing leaves teenager dead
Wayne Rooney scores stunning goal from beyond halfway line for DC United
Icahn steps up fight with Occidental over deal, wants board seats
Time Capsule 1974 Oldsmobile Toronado Is An Amazing Survivor
Democrats approve $4.5bn border aid proposal to rein in Trump’s immigration crackdown
Iran says saving nuclear deal not its problem, EU warns no alternative
Can't Afford That Shiny F-35? This Jet Fighter Might Be Able to Fight Your War
U.S. House passes border aid bill, Trump vows veto
U.S. regulator cites new flaw on grounded Boeing 737 MAX
Elon Musk says he knows why Falcon Heavy’s core booster missed its landing
Democrats clash on healthcare, border in scrappy first U.S. presidential debate
John Roberts Isn’t the Conservative You Thought He Was
The Latest: Zhang family says no promise body would be found
First Democratic Debate Begins With All Eyes on Sen. Elizabeth Warren
NRA splits with PR firm, lobbyist and TV amid infighting
Donald Trump dismisses rape accusation, saying E Jean Carroll is 'not my type'
Venezuela government says thwarted attempted 'coup'
Huawei employees worked with China military on research projects: Bloomberg
Oppo's Under-Display Camera Is the Best Notch Killer Yet
Deescalation Wanted: How Trump Can Steer Clear of a War
Cambodia charges 7, including Chinese, in building collapse
Donald Trump says woman who claimed he raped her is 'not my type'
Forget the Galaxy Note 10: Samsung is making a more affordable 5G phone
Democrats are ready to throw punches but vow debate won't become 'crazytown'
Senate Passes $4.6 Billion Border-Funding Bill after Rejecting Pelosi’s Version
Senate passes $4.6B border aid measure; Pelosi seeks talks
No 'boots on the ground' in Iran dispute, Trump says; cites 'unlimited time' for new deal
China renews demand on Canada for Huawei executive's release
Graves of US WWII servicemen unearthed on Pacific island
U.S. Navy SEAL charged with war crimes had confidence of his immediate superior
Latest sex accusation against Trump lands with a thud
U.S. aims to restart China trade talks, will not accept conditions on tariff use
SpaceX Is Launching 152 Human Remains Into Space
Boris Johnson Predicts ‘Million-to-One’ Chance of No-Deal Brexit
US FAA: Boeing must address new issue on 737 MAX
US prosecutor Mueller to testify publicly on Russia probe
Senate rejects House-backed version of border aid bill
Oklahoma woman caught on own CCTV camera firebombing and shooting into neighbour’s home
Venezuela government says it thwarted 'coup' plot
Witness could face perjury charge in Navy SEAL court-martial
'I told him not to' go, mother of drowned Salvadoran migrant laments
Democrats hope Mueller testimony will have 'profound impact'
Global chipmakers rally on Micron's upbeat results, Huawei shipments
Microsoft is reportedly testing two exciting new Surface models
Ex-GOP House Staffer Rory Riley-Topping: Duncan Hunter Groped Me in 2014
Trump news - LIVE: President responds to photo of drowned migrants as he plans to live tweet Democratic debate
Galaxy Fold 2, which actually might not be awful, rumored for release mere months after the original
Watch Out, Russia and China: The Navy Has a New Plan to Kill Your Submarines
Venezuela's former spy chief says Maduro could yet fall
U.S. FAA identifies new risk on Boeing 737 MAX
Conservative U.S. Justice Gorsuch again sides with liberals in criminal case
Microsoft might beat Apple to market with an ARM-powered laptop
Palestinian Windfall Hinges on Political Moves, U.S. Envoy Says
Is Parliament Ready to Back a No-Deal Brexit? You Do the Math
Bank of America to stop financing operators of private prisons, detention centers
Senate passes border aid bill, sends it to House
Here’s why your Windows 10 computer has been taking forever to shut down lately
‘The river is treacherous’: the migrant tragedy one photo can't capture
Mueller Sets Up Airing of Trump Probe With Risks for Both Sides
Trump warns any conflict with Iran 'wouldn't last long'
Khamenei Scorns Talks With U.S. After Being Sanctioned by Trump
The Navy’s Smallest Warships Could Be the First to See Combat Against Iran
Russia to withdraw military 'technicians' from Venezuela on Wednesday: embassy
Hong Kong protesters urge G20 to raise plight with China
Here’s the Rumored Nintendo Switch Mini Compared to the Current Switch
Stephen Colbert Goes Off on New York Post for Deleting E. Jean Carroll Trump Rape Story
Math Explains Why the Democrats May Have Trouble Picking a Candidate
Illinois joins 10 other U.S. states in legalizing recreational marijuana
SpaceX finally caught one of its rocket’s nose cones
Supreme Court chips away at federal agency power
Man slashes own throat in court during trial for murder of Tinder date
Trump aide Conway will not testify before Congress: White House
A House Dem Calls for Investigating Trump Sexual Assault Allegations as Her Colleagues Shrug
Saudi envoy blasts UN expert's report on Khashoggi killing
Falcon Heavy Takes Off in First Night Launch, Center Core Smashes into the Ocean
Camila Cabello Splits From BF Matthew Hussey After Dropping Sexy Video With Shawn Mendes
Close