Close
Date TimeApril 12, 2019
Voice“This case raises a number of really thorny questions about what it means to be a journalist.”
Julian Assange arrest: justice or a threat to free press?
Is the arrest of WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange justice against a man who broke the law, or is it a warning shot that journalism is under threat in the United States?
It’s a difficult question to answer, in part because it brings up a host of other related questions: Do you consider WikiLeaks a journalistic organization or not? Did Assange actively participate in criminal activity to obtain classified intel, as the US government alleges, or did he just disseminate information passed on to him and is therefore protected by the First Amendment? Does it matter that Assange and his organization seem to have developed at the very least an affinity to Russia? And is the single charge he faces in the United States the total of the government’s push for justice — or is it just the opening salvo in what will become a larger war to punish Assange (and anyone else who publishes classified information)?
These questions all came to a head on Thursday when, after months of speculation, Assange was arrested in London by British police after being expelled from the Ecuadorian Embassy there. He now faces likely extradition to the US. After his arrest, the Justice Department unsealed an indictment alleging that Assange conspired with former US intelligence analyst Chelsea Manning to crack a password on a Defense Department computer network in order to download classified records and transmit them to WikiLeaks in 2010.
That, however, isn’t all the US government is upset about. Starting in 2010, WikiLeaks published a video of an airstrike in Iraq that killed civilians, military documents about the Iraq and Afghanistan wars, and State Department cables in which diplomats gave candid assessments of foreign governments, all provided by Manning. The unprecedented leaks gained enormous attention and made Assange a sort of celebrity — and a target, as top US officials like Attorney General Eric Holder publicly mused about how they could charge him. Perhaps freshest in mind, however, is the “hacktivist” organization’s decision to publish Hillary Clinton aide John Podesta’s emails in the months before the 2016 election.
There has long been a debate about whether what WikiLeaks does counts as journalism. Some view Assange and WikiLeaks as a bastion of transparency and an ultimate example of forcing government accountability. Others see the work as dangerous and treacherous.
With Assange’s arrest and the unsealing of the Justice Department’s indictment, the dust around WikiLeaks has been kicked up again. Some groups dedicated to free speech and press have decried the incident as a foreshadowing of dark times to come for American journalism, while many observers have celebrated it as justice served.
“This case raises a number of really thorny questions about what it means to be a journalist, and who is entitled to the constitutional protections that do exist to ensure that the public gets the information it needs,” David Schulz, senior counsel at Ballard Spahr LLP and director of the Media Freedom and Information Access Clinic at Yale Law School, told me.

A lot of people are celebrating Assange’s arrest — but not everyone
At WikiLeaks, Assange has made a lot of enemies, and by many accounts, he’s a jerk. He’s also been hiding out in the Ecuadorian Embassy to avoid an investigation into a sexual assault allegation against him in Sweden.
Many in the national security space hold animosity toward him for compromising sensitive confidential information, including about US military activity in Iraq and Afghanistan and communications from State Department officials. Many Democrats also blame him, at least partially, for Hillary Clinton’s loss in the 2016 election after WikiLeaks published Podesta’s emails and hacked information from the Democratic National Committee.
“Julian Assange got what he deserved,” author Michael Weiss wrote in the Atlantic.
“He’s our property, and we can get the facts and truth from him,” Sen. Joe Manchin (D-WV) told CNN.
Groups dedicated to free speech and press have had a different read.
Ben Wizner, director of the American Civil Liberties Union’s speech, privacy, and technology project, said in a statement that any prosecution of Assange for WikiLeaks’ publishing operation would be “unprecedented and unconstitutional, and would open the door to criminal investigations of other news organizations.”
“The potential implications for press freedom of this allegation of conspiracy between publisher and source are deeply troubling,” said Robert Mahoney, deputy director of the Committee to Protect Journalists, in a statement. He added that the US government could “set out broad legal arguments about journalists soliciting information or interacting with sources that could have chilling consequences for investigative reporting and the publication of information of public interest.”
Barry Pollack, an attorney for Assange, echoed the sentiment in an email to Yahoo News. “Journalists around the world should be deeply troubled by these unprecedented criminal charges,” he said.
This is a little like getting Al Capone on tax evasion
When reports surfaced last year that the US government had indicted Assange, there was a lot of speculation about what, specifically, he was being charged with. As Vox’s Andrew Prokop laid out at the time, the US government had already charged people they’d accused of leaking classified information, including Manning, but going after the publisher of that information was highly unusual. It’s one of the reasons President Barack Obama’s Justice Department hadn’t charged Assange years ago.
But after Assange’s arrest on Thursday, the Department of Justice unsealed the indictment, which is dated to March 2018. The charge: “conspiracy to commit computer intrusion,” related to Assange’s alleged attempt in 2010 to help Manning figure out a password she needed to access more classified documents and information. Per the indictment, it appears the attempt was unsuccessful.
Compared to what some observers thought the indictment might be — including much more serious charges under the Espionage Act — the charge against Assange is, frankly, a pretty small one. If he’s convicted, he could face up to five years in prison — less time than he spent hiding out in the Ecuadorian Embassy in the UK.
It’s a bit like gangster Al Capone being arrested on tax evasion charges: It’s probably not what the US government wanted to get him on, but it’s the way they could do it.
“This is not the thing they care about,” Julian Sanchez, a senior fellow at the Cato Institute, told me. “It’s the thing that they can win a court case over.”
For those who view Assange as a criminal as contemptible as Capone, that’s a win — take what you can get. But for civil liberties defenders, it’s a reprehensible overreach.
That the US government would go to such extreme lengths to go after Assange has caused some alarm, especially in light of how small the charge is against him, at least for now. “It would be pretty unusual for the government to go to this amount of effort to extradite someone if that was the only issue,” Sanchez said. “If their only contribution to the crime has been that they ran some software against a password hash and then failed to actually help, then that probably wouldn’t result in someone’s extradition.”
Journalists aren’t given a free pass to commit crimes in the pursuit of a story — but they also haven’t been punished for publishing info that came from one
That’s not to say that what the indictment alleges Assange did, if convicted, isn’t a crime.
And reporters don’t get to just commit any crime they want in the name of journalism. If I punch someone to get them to talk to me for a story or break into their house to steal documents, I can still be charged with assault or robbery.
“Journalists are not scot-free to do whatever they think they need to do in order to pursue an act of journalism,” said Columbia University professor Todd Gitlin.
Whether Assange committed a crime in his work with Manning is something that will ultimately be decided if he is indeed extradited and brought to trial. That’s when courts will determine whether he knowingly violated the law to gain access to information. What it could all hinge on: Did he just advise Manning on how to avoid detection, or was he conspiring with her to get information in an illegal way?
There are some prior cases that illustrate how this could play out, and where the line is. In 2001, the Supreme Court ruled on a case called Bartnicki v. Vopper. In that case, a person intercepted and recorded a phone call between a union negotiator and union president and sent it to a radio station, which played a tape of the conversation. The court ruled that the First Amendment protected the broadcaster because it hadn’t participated in the illegal interception.
Other cases, however, have gone the other way. A Texas television station was implicated when a man made recordings of his neighbor’s cordless phone conversations discussing plans to interfere in the local school district’s insurance contract. (The station ultimately settled the related lawsuit.) A journalist was arrested for allegations that he aided and abetted a TWA pilot who stole evidence from the TWA Flight 800 crash in the 1990s.
“There is established in the law a pretty bright line,” Schulz said. “You cross it when you become a participant in illegal activity.”

This is a lot bigger than a password
The debate about Assange and WikiLeaks stretches far beyond helping Manning crack a password. It has reopened the ongoing discussion about whether what WikiLeaks does counts as journalism. It has also raised questions about the government’s intentions and whether this opens the door to prosecuting more journalists or not.
On the former point, people have different opinions of whether what WikiLeaks does — dumping troves of data indiscriminately — is really journalism.
“Is a data dump journalism? That’s an interesting question,” Gitlin said. “In the case of war crimes footage, I feel comfortable saying that by working with Manning on that, Assange was performing an act of journalism. But when you release terabytes of data indiscriminately, I don’t know what to call that, but it’s not self-evidently journalism.”
Indiscriminate data dumps such as those WikiLeaks engages in can have dangerous consequences. For example, human rights advocates have complained that WikiLeaks’ activities have endangered activists in China, and the platform has released information on government sources that the US has gone to great lengths to protect.
Making the matter even more complicated is the evolution of WikiLeaks itself. Back in 2010, it gave the New York Times, Der Spiegel, and the Guardian troves of information. In 2016, it was clearly rooting for Trump and trying to undermine Clinton. And as Foreign Policy points out, Assange was at the same time declining to publish damaging information on the Russian government. Members of Trump’s administration have even gone so far as to denounce WikiLeaks as a “hostile intelligence service.” (To be sure, a lot of journalism is far from unbiased.)
More specifically to Assange and the charge against him right now, there are concerns that there could be more charges brought against him in the future. That’s one of the concerns Wizner, from the ACLU, raised in his statement. “We have no assurance that these are the only charges the government plans to bring against Mr. Assange,” he said.
The New York Times noted that if the Justice Department does intend to charge Assange with additional offenses, it would likely need to do it before the UK decides whether to send him to the US. The extradition process could take months or even years, so there’s a non-zero chance more charges could be added — and press advocates worry that any broader charges related to WikiLeaks’ work could have a chilling effect on more traditional media outlets that are considering publishing leaked information.
“Never in the history of this country has a publisher been prosecuted for presenting truthful information to the public,” Wizner told CNN in 2017. “Any prosecution of WikiLeaks for publishing government secrets would set a dangerous precedent that the Trump administration would surely use to target other news organizations.”
Adding another layer of anxiety is the Trump administration and its contentious relationship with the press. The president has openly discussed an interest in loosening up libel laws and frequently derides the media.
The controversy over WikiLeaks’ place in the journalistic sphere and what Assange’s arrest means for reporting isn’t going anywhere anytime soon. It may very well be that Assange did commit a crime — but his arrest might not be something we should cheer, at least not without some reflection.

Annunziata Rees-Mogg to stand as MEP for Farage's Brexit party
Comedians pay tribute to Ian Cognito after standup dies on stage
Jaden Smith Shouts Out Nipsey Hussle, Rides Flying Car During Coachella Set
‘Guava Island’ First Look: Childish Gambino’s Mystery Project With Rihanna Is Unveiled
Is New Taylor Swift Music on the Way? Countdown Clock Suggests April 26 Release
Vasiliy Lomachenko defeats Anthony Crolla with fourth-round knockout
Katie Bouman, the MIT grad who made first-ever photograph of black hole possible
Trick or treat? EU, UK agree to delay Brexit until Halloween
Pavelski's painful goal sparks Sharks' take down of Vegas
Jane the Virgin's Latest Cliffhanger Creates Torture For Everyone
Good-bye glaciers: 390 billion tons of snow and ice melts each year as globe warms
Will Emmanuel Macron veto Theresa May's Brexit extension?
Farewell Fleabag: the most electrifying, devastating TV in years
Chris Davis sets record at 0 for 49, including warning track shot
Felicity Huffman to plead guilty in college admissions cheating case
Dean Ambrose’s Last WWE Match Becomes Brawl With Bobby Lashley
Twenty prison officers injured after violence at Feltham youth jail
Debenhams on brink despite Mike Ashley's last-minute offer
Humans are about to see the first-ever photo of a 'supermassive' black hole. Here what we hope to discover
At Least 6 People Shot in Chicago: Police
Pushing for Tighter Borders, President Asks Jews for Support
'Game Of Thrones' Castmates Turn Up To Ask 'SNL' Host Kit Harington How It All Ends
Charlie Rowley: Novichok victim meets Russian ambassador
Rapper Kodak Black accused of sexual assault: Prosecutor
Texas Tech's historic national title shot, courtesy of hero Matt Mooney
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle break Guinness World Record with new Instagram account
Lauren Sanchez Files for Divorce After Bezos Split Finalized
Judge orders Elon Musk and the SEC to settle Tesla tweet dispute
Trump's threat to close the border was just a trap for Democrats
Mick Jagger 'on the mend' following heart surgery
Britain starts issuing passports without 'European Union' on cover
Grand National 2019 sees awkward moment as six attendees wear same PrettyLittleThing dress
Falcon Heavy SpaceX Launch Will Mark First Commercial Mission
Kurt Cobain died 25 years ago today. A fan recalls seeing Nirvana play on the verge of fame
Lil Nas X Added Billy Ray Cyrus to ‘Old Town Road.’ Is It Country Enough for Billboard Now?
Tesla is selling fewer cars, but says it has ‘sufficient’ cash
Joker Trailer: First Look At Joaquin Phoenix As DC Villain In New Clips
Ohio teen tells investigators he's Timmothy Pitzen, child who disappeared in Illinois in 2011: report
Britney Spears reportedly checks herself into mental health facility
Bryce Harper embraces return to Washington
‘This Is Us’ finale ends season with a slew of new questions
Supermodel Amber Rose Announces She’s Expecting Her Second Child
‘Thrones’ actress Gwendoline Christie dazzles at NYC premiere
Trump lashes out at Democrats over Puerto Rico aid vote
Kim Kardashian reveals baby name she's considering for fourth child
Ernie Grunfeld fired as president of the Washington Wizards
Avengers Endgame tickets ballot opens for HUGE fan event in London: How to enter
Tania Mallet, Bond girl in 'Goldfinger,' dies aged 77
‘Keeping Up With the Kardashians’ Returns With Its New Star: Kanye West?
Rare glimpse into Saudi Aramco shows $111 billion net profit
Google adds Snake to Maps for April Fools' Day gag
Nipsey Hussle: Grammy-nominated rapper shot dead in LA
NASA Announces Successful Completion of ISS Spacewalk
Kylie Jenner Speaks Out About Jordyn Woods' Lip Kip Price Cut After Tristan Thompson Cheating Scandal
Saudis gained access to Amazon CEO Bezos' phone: Bezos' security chief
Brexit: Theresa May considers next step to break deadlock
Charles Leclerc pips Sebastian Vettel to Bahrain F1 pole on Ferrari’s day
Kash Ali disqualified for biting David Price in bizarre heavyweight bout
Attorney: NBA star Kristaps Porzingis is accused of rape
Suspect charged in slaying of University of South Carolina student Samantha Josephson
The Rolling Stones postpone U.S. shows, citing advice of Mick jagger's doctors
Purdue’s Carsen Edwards can match Steph Curry NCAA Tournament scoring mark
NASA will pay people $19000 to stay in bed for 2 months
Trump mocks Green New Deal, pokes fun at electric cars during Michigan rally
Texas Tech passes Michigan exam ... but bigger test awaits
Miami Open: Roger Federer reaches quarters, Simona Halep eyes No. 1 ranking
Anger and irreverence on the Brexit Day that wasn't
Justin Bieber Takes a Break From Music To Focus on Mental Health
Cardi B Is Defending Herself After A Video Showed Her Saying She Used To Drug And Rob Men: I Always Own My Shit
Conor McGregor reportedly under investigation for sexual assault
Jussie Smollett: Chicago mayor attacks 'whitewash of justice' as charges dropped
Ranking Roger Dead: The Beat And General Public Singer Dies, Aged 56
Mission Shakti, a long-desired capability tested
Vandals strike again: Downtown statue of Queen Victoria doused in green paint
Government could ignore indicative Brexit votes, says Liam Fox
Scott Walker, experimental pop hero, dies aged 76
Mel B Claims She Slept With Geri Halliwell During Spice Girls Era
‘Shazam!’ Film Review: DC Comics Gets a Bouncy Burst of Big-Screen Ebullience
Sydney Aiello, a survivor of the Parkland school shooting, dies by suicide
Larry Cohen, Writer-Director of 'It's Alive' and 'Hell Up in Harlem,' Dies at 77
Kylie Jenner Doubles Down On Being A 'Self Made' Billionaire
Robert Mueller report will be a gold mine of improprieties. Trump shouldn't celebrate yet
Brexit stitch up: Revoke Article 50 petition hits 4 million – could pass 5 million TONIGHT
Barbra Streisand criticized after saying experience 'didn't kill' Michael Jackson accusers
Persona 5: The Royal Announced for PS4
The Obamas Show Support For Jennifer Lopez and Alex Rodriguez's Engagement in the Sweetest Way
Trump to lift 'not necessary' North Korea sanctions, White House confirms
Historic Midwest flooding devastates Nebraska, Iowa
Brooke Henderson three back after opening round of LPGA Thailand
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle Honor New Zealand Shooting Victims
Mike Trout and LA Angels close to $430m deal, largest in sports history
Donald Trump suggests Brazil could join Nato as he meets Jair Bolsonaro
Here’s how you’ll access Google’s Stadia cloud gaming service
Will Jennifer Lopez Use a Cheating Clause in Her Prenup With Alex Rodriguez?
Chelsea Clinton Apologizes To Students Who Blame Her For NZ Attack
Australian Senator Fraser Anning punches teen after being egged
Lewis Hamilton responds to Valtteri Bottas message after Australian GP battle
Taylor Swift debuts pink hair at iHeartRadio Music Awards
Glastonbury 2019 Line-Up Announced With The Killers And The Cure Joining Stormzy As Headliners
Tesla Model Y: Musk's latest electric vehicle is almost here
'Avengers: Endgame' recruits a familiar face to save the world in new trailer: 'Whatever it takes'
Mosque attacks spark outrage, fuel concern over Islamophobia
New Zealand shooting: PewDiePie reacts after gunman named him before Christchurch attack
New Zealand Shooting: At Least 49 Dead After Massacre At New Zealand Mosques
Crew of Soyuz launch abort set for second try
Why a Kardashian-Jenner Biopic May Be in Our Near Future
Netflix confirms Madeleine McCann documentary release date
F1 race director Charlie Whiting dead
Triple Frontier Review: As They Say, Greed Is a Bottomless Pit
South Florida native Lamar Jackson records Instagram video of himself driving 105 MPH
The Tesla Model Y Is Coming, But Who Is Ready For It?
Frank Cali, alleged boss of New York's Gambino mafia family, shot dead outside his Staten Island home
Beto O’Rourke says he is running for US president
Pi day: What is Pi Day? How have Google broken a world record for Pi?
Kendall Jenner wears Ben Simmons’ jersey at Philadelphia 76ers game
Altior wins the Champion Chase
Jay Leno: Late-Night Shows Are Too Political
Desperate Housewives actress Felicity Huffman among 50 people arrested over £19m college admissions scam
Johnny Depp ‘Overwhelmed’ By Fan Support After Amber Heard Lawsuit
May Day: UK Parliament rejects prime minister’s Brexit deal
Hannah Brown Is the New Star of The Bachelorette, And She Already Gave Out a Rose
AP sources: Browns acquire Odell Beckham Jr. from Giants
One of the Most Recorded Musicians in History Is Dead
Brexit: Legal risk of backstop remains 'unchanged' says Geoffrey Cox
UK parliament speaker does not select any amendments for Brexit vote
Disney's first full 'Aladdin' trailer drops and Will Smith shines in all his genie glory
‘I’ll ‘f–k you up’: Westbrook lashes out at heckling Jazz fan
New York attorney general is investigating Trump projects
MMA fighter Conor McGregor released from jail after being charged with robbery
Brexit: Corbyn asks for PM's withdrawal agreement update
Storm Gareth: warnings issued about power cuts and travel difficulties
Kylie Jenner and Jordyn Woods Are Reportedly Hanging Out Again
Elon Musk's late-night announcement to raise prices and reopen some stores
Trump to make $8.6 billion wall demand, triggering new standoff with Congress
Boeing 737 black box found as planes grounded after Ethiopian Airlines crash
Kelly Catlin, U.S. Olympic Medalist, Dies At Age 23
WATCH: Distressed Serena Williams forced to quit match against Garbine Muguruza after claiming she can't breath
Zinedine Zidane to replace Santiago Solari as Real Madrid manager in coming hours
Amendola joining Lions in search for slot option
New Report Claims Chatroom Involving Seungri And Other Male Singers Shared Illegal Hidden Camera Footage
Pete Buttigieg calls Vice President Pence a 'cheerleader for the porn star presidency'
Alex Rodriguez cheating on Jennifer Lopez? Jose Canseco rips retired Yankees star, wants to fight him
Emmy Rossum Leaves Shameless: What Happened to Fiona Gallagher?
Shocking interview surfaces of Fox News host Tucker Carlson praising ‘young girls sexually experimenting’
Ethiopian Airlines grounds all Boeing 737 Max 8 planes
George Foreman’s daughter found dead in her home
Aston Villa’s Jack Grealish punched by fan in derby win at Birmingham City
Jaguar attacks woman taking a photo at Wildlife World Zoo in Arizona
Roscosmos Chief, Elon Musk Exchange Courtesies After SpaceX Capsule Landing
'SNL': Pete Davidson compares R. Kelly to the Catholic Church, addresses dating Kate Beckinsale
Jennifer Lopez And Alex Rodriguez Announce Engagement With Massive Ring
Gemma Collins has compared herself to Lady Gaga
Steelers agree to trade Antonio Brown to Raiders
Brexiteer MPs say delay would be political calamity
Ethiopian Airlines plane crash: Disaster on flight to Kenya as multiple deaths reported
London to host Formula E finale in 2020
Tesla Drops 1st Real Image Of The Model Y As Event Invites Go Out
Anthony Yarde closes in on title shot as boxing returns to Albert Hall
Newark Airport halts all flights after emergency landing
Meghan Markle reveals whether she still looks at Twitter, hopes that her royal baby will be a feminist
Jordyn Woods Returns to Instagram, Likes Kylie Jenner's Post After Cheating Scandal
Tesla Investors Are Suing Over Elon Musk's Bad Tweets
Facebook only cares about privacy because it has to
United States citizens will need a visa to visit Europe starting in 2021
Chelsea Manning Jailed For Refusing To Testify Over WikiLeaks
Jussie Smollett Charged By Grand Jury Over Empire Star’s Alleged Hate Attack Hoax
'Airwolf' actor and '80s heartthrob Jan-Michael Vincent dies
Manuel Petrovic Charged With Murder Of 17-Year-Old Jodie Chesney
JSU, Murray State meet in OVC semis
Klay Thompson 'shooting the lights out', says former Celtic Ray Allen
Worried about Brexit? What, with these geniuses in charge? | Marina Hyde
The Queen Gives Meghan Markle a New Role on International Women's Day
North Korea rocket site is being monitored 'in real time,' U.S. official says
SpaceX Dragon crew capsule makes successful splashdown after test flight
Let's Use IWD To Talk About The Problematic Balance Of Women In Science
SpaceX Crew Dragon, built to carry humans, heads home from ISS
Justin Bieber Reacts to Shawn Mendes Liking Hailey Baldwin Photo
Paul Manafort Sentenced To Less Than 4 Years In Prison In Mueller Probe
International Women's Day Is Only Powerful If We Make It Inclusive
Album Review: Juice WRLD’s ‘Death Race for Love’
Microsoft is Giving Away a Captain Marvel Xbox One X
Steelers closing in on deal to send Antonio Brown to the Bills, according to report
Kim Kardashian-West Struts Through Paris In A See-Through Catsuit
Tristan Thompson 'dating model Karizma Ramirez' after 'cheating on Khloe Kardashian'
Charlotte Russe will liquidate and close all of its stores
Louis Tomlinson: New song Two Of Us helped me grieve for mum
Amber Rudd 'Mortified' After Calling Diane Abbott A 'Coloured Woman'
David Walliams honoured with special postbox on World Book Day
R. Kelly accused of raping 13-year-old, giving her herpes: report
Magenta Devine, presenter of Network 7 and Rough Guide, dies aged 61
'Tim Apple': Donald Trump gets name of tech giant's CEO wrong
LeBron James moves past Michael Jordan into fourth place on NBA scoring list
History's first all-female spacewalk will take place March 29
In Canada, two of Justin Trudeau’s ministers resigned. Let’s catch up on this scandal
Dictionary.com has beef with 'self-made' billionaire Kylie Jenner
Andy Murray pain-free after operation but cautious over playing prospects
Peter Beardsley leaves role as Newcastle under-23s coach
Meghan Markle and Kate Middleton reunite in first public appearance together since Christmas
Derry Girls Series 2: All the Lingo You Need To Know From 'Boke' To 'Slabber'
‘Game Of Thrones’ Creators Frantically Re-Shoot Finale To Make Peter Dinklage Death Seem Intentional
Close