Close
Date TimeFebruary 28, 2019
VoiceA woman who bludgeoned her husband to death has won an appeal against her murder conviction in a landmark ruling.
Sally Challen wins appeal against murder conviction in landmark ruling
Georgina 'Sally' Challen, 65, was fighting to be released from prison today, hoping to get her conviction downgraded to manslaughter on the grounds that her husband, Richard, subjected her to decades of coercive and controlling behaviour in their 31-year marriage, which impacted her mental state.
But, in a partial win for Mrs Challen, Justice Lady Heather Hallett ordered a retrial, meaning she won't be immediately released.
The judge told the courtroom: "The Court of Appeal heard in the opinion of a consultant forensic psychiatrist the appellant was suffering from two mental disorders at the time of the opinion, this evidence was not available at the original trial.
"The court quashed the conviction and ordered a retrial."
Sally cried and hugged her prison officer while her two sons cried with relief.
Sally Challen wins appeal against murder conviction in landmark ruling
The historic decision was handed down in a packed courtroom on Thursday afternoon, eight years after Mrs Challen was convicted of murder at Guildford Crown Court in June 2011, in a trial that painted her as a "jealous spouse".
She was sentenced to 22 years, decreased to 18 on appeal.
A new understanding of the events that led to Mr Challen's death surfaced in 2015, when coercive control was criminalised as a form of domestic abuse.
Eight years after her conviction, the court heard Mrs Challen had been bullied, isolated from friends and family, and 'gaslighted', a form of abuse in which perpetrators manipulate victims into questioning their sanity. Mr Challen, it was claimed, cheated on Mrs Challen and lied to her, leading her to attempt suicide more than once. On one occasion, he raped her 'as a punishment'.
The Court of Appeal accepted new evidence from Dr Gwen Adshead that Mrs Challen had bipolar and a dependent personality disorder that was triggered by the abuse.
But did not downgrade the conviction to manslaughter as the family had hoped. She now faces an anxious wait to see whether or not she will be freed before the retrial as judges consider bailing her.
At the second day of the appeal hearing, which started Wednesday, close to 50 supporters filled the benches in the courtroom, a reflection of the public attention on the case, which many see as a test of the way courts treat coercive control.
For those on Mrs Challen's side, the case was a chance for justice for their abused mother and sister. But the court stressed the argument wasn't just about coercive control, which doesn't amount to a defence.
"As you know this case is received greatly in the public attention and there are people out there who think it’s only about coercive control, but it’s not," said Justice Lady Heather Hallett. “It's about psychiatric conditions that were undiagnosed at the time."
She continued: "We can’t just say if you’re a victim of coercive control that gives you a defence, it doesn’t. To raise it to provocation you’ve got to have something more."
Supporters of Mrs Challen - formerly an office manager at the Police Federation - were tense and let out an audible groan when Caroline Carberry, QC for the Crown Prosecution Service, said a trip to Wisley Gardens and the cinema in the lead up to the killing were evidence that she was not suffering from a mental disorder.
Lady Hallett scolded the courtroom: "I appreciate people are very interested in these proceedings. I don't want to have to clear the court, but I promise you I shall."

Stacey Dooley’s Comic Relief Filming Criticised By MP David Lammy In ‘White Saviourism’ Row
Junior minister George Eustice resigns over article 50 vote
Otto Warmbier: Trump says he believes Kim Jong-un was unaware of torture
Kyler Murray’s moment of truth: He’s taller than we thought
Oprah Winfrey to interview Michael Jackson’s accusers: report
North Korea leader Kim says ready to denuclearize
Cohen's testimony escalates Trump's legal troubles in New York
Selma Blair opens up about MS: 'People with disabilities are invisible'
Sensational Kyrgios downs Nadal in Mexico
Dull 'Dark Phoenix' Trailer Takes A Huge Risk With The 'X-Men' Series
Donald Trump hails ‘great leader’ Kim Jong-un at Hanoi summit
Is Meghan Markle Further Along Than Expected?
Larsa Pippen shades Jordyn Woods' various 'versions' of Tristan Thompson story
Jimmy Kimmel mocks Ivanka, thinks GOP Rep. Matt Gaetz's tweeted threat to Michael Cohen is 'kind of nice'
BritBox: the bizarre Netflix rival that will surely bomb
Labour doesn’t have zero tolerance of antisemitism if Chris Williamson is an MP
Pokémon Sword And Shield Revealed For Nintendo Switch, New Starters Shown
SpaceX Cleared to Launch Unmanned Crew Dragon Capsule to ISS on March 2
Donald Trump says his 'friend' Kim Jong Un can learn from Vietnam
Pakistani Military Says It Shot Down 2 Indian Aircraft
Michael Cohen To Accuse Donald Trump Of Racism And Being A 'Conman' In His First Public Hearing
China reiterates call for India and Pakistan to exercise restraint
Firefighters Tackle Huge Blaze On Saddleworth Moor Following Hottest Winter Day
Donald Trump in Vietnam for summit with North Korean leader Kim Jong-un
Tommy Robinson permanently banned by Facebook and Instagram
Leicester City to announce No 1 target Brendan Rodgers as new manager
Michael Cohen, once keeper of Donald Trump's secrets, will accuse the president of 'criminal conduct'
Emma Thompson’s letter to Skydance: Why I can’t work for John Lasseter
Lady Gaga and Madonna appear to squash years-long beef with iconic post-Oscars embrace
Tesla's Elon Musk may be in contempt over tweet
Kendall Jenner Is One Mistake Away From Flashing Everybody At Oscars After-Party
Journalist Jorge Ramos' equipment seized at Maduro interview
Colton Underwood Reveals How Therapy Keeps Him ''Sane'' in Empowering Message About Mental Health
WWE star Roman Reigns reveals he is in remission from cancer
Indian Air Force violated Line of Control, claims Pakistan
Here's the Proof You Need That There's NO Beef Between Lady Gaga and Irina Shayk
Khloé appears to call Jordyn Woods a 'snake' in latest cryptic message
Oscars 2019: Monica Lewinsky makes glamorous appearance at Vanity Fair party
More passwordless logins are coming to Android
True Detective season 3 was grim and, finally, ludicrous
Hezbollah to be added to UK list of terrorist organisations
Ariana Grande adds third Dublin date to tour
Reports: Rangers ship Hayes to Jets for Lemieux
Harry Reid wishes for George W. Bush again 'every day'
Politics at the Oscars: A Statement Against Trump, Without Mentioning His Name
Rami Malek is a champion, my friends
Watch Lady Gaga and Bradley Cooper's sizzling performance of 'Shallow'
Alan Partridge: Time in his home county of Norfolk
Oscars save shocks for last with big wins for Green Book and Olivia Colman
Terrence Howard defends Jussie Smollett: ‘It’s God’s job to judge’
Robert Kraft was spotted mingling with ‘hot’ Asian women before Super Bowl
Syracuse coach Jim Boeheim addresses fatal car accident
Oscars 2019: predictions, timetable and all you need to know for the big night
Serena Williams brought her daughter to Oscars rehearsals. Plus, more celeb gossip!
Lady Gaga ran into her ex while 'in a corner' with Bradley Cooper at Oscars pre-party
Venezuela standoff turns deadly as troops block aid delivery
The Greatest Dancer judge Cheryl opts for sparkly look in fringed dress
Rockets get crucial 2 points (WHL)
Chris Eubank Jr beats James DeGale to send Londoner towards retirement
Why celebs should get a workout in on Oscars morning
PewDiePie features Elon Musk and Rick and Morty’s Justin Roiland on Meme Review and fans can’t handle it
Stanley Donen, director of Singin' in the Rain, dies aged 94
Burnley’s Ashley Barnes hits Spurs’ title hopes with winner after Kane goal
Microsoft Workers Say the Company Is War Profiteering, and They’ve Timed Their Protest to Hurt
R. Kelly Turns Himself in to Chicago Police
Joe Swash mocking pregnant girlfriend Stacey Solomon on Instagram is everything
Jihadi Jack, the Briton accused of fighting for Isil: 'I miss my mum, pasties and Doctor Who - I want to go home'
Feinstein Gets Confrontational With Children Asking Her to Support Green New Deal
Comedian Brody Stevens dies at 48, prompting mourning: 'Everybody loved Brody'
Paul George for MVP: OKC fans go wild after dramatic winner in double OT win over Jazz
Historic Israeli Mission to the Moon Underway Following SpaceX Launch
Women: We Went to R. Kelly Concert, Ended Up Victims
Jordyn Woods Makes First Public Appearance Since Tristan Scandal
Stacey Solomon And Joe Swash Announce She's Pregnant With Their First Child
Teenager Who Murdered Six-Year-Old Alesha MacPhail Identified As Aaron Campbell
Police: Patriots owner Robert Kraft solicited prostitute
NASA’s confidence in SpaceX and Boeing may be wavering
Tesla begins Model 3 delivery in China ahead of schedule
Kylie Jenner Put Her Lipstick Shade Named After Jordyn Woods On Sale
Google Doodle marks 'Crocodile Hunter' Steve Irwin's birthday
Lakers climb back from double-digit deficit to beat Rockets 111-106
Six Key Numbers From Ariana Grande's Record-Breaking Week
MP Chris Davies charged over expenses claims
Dublin Airport forced to suspend all flights due to drone sighting over airfield
Beyoncé and Jay-Z pay unexpected tribute to Meghan, Duchess of Sussex
Hoda Muthana: Trump bars Alabama woman who joined ISIS from US return
Kim Kardashian Officially Unfollows Jordyn Woods and Tristan Thompson Amid Cheating Allegations
Puma deletes poor-taste tweet about Zion Williamson's Nike shoe mishap
Kilmarnock manager Steve Clarke calls out anti-Catholic abuse at Ibrox
Meghan Markle Hits Fancy NYC Restaurant with Serena Williams
Putin warns: Russia will target US with new weapons if it deploys missiles to Europe
Anna Soubry, Sarah Wollaston And Heidi Allen Quit Conservative Party To Join Independent Group Of MPs
Trump Wishes 'Crazy Bernie' Sanders Well
Ryder Cup: Steve Stricker named US captain for 2020 against Europe
Trey Gowdy Doesn't Believe McCabe's Obstruction Probe Claim
Kim Kardashian slams Fashion Nova over 'devastating' knockoffs
Trump Threatens To Cancel California's $929 Million High Speed Rail Grant
Lady Gaga splits from fiancé Christian Carino
Money talks: Padres' big offer brings Manny Machado to San Diego
‘This Is Us’: Susan Kelechi Watson on Beth’s Past, Grief and Working With Phylicia Rashad (SPOILERS)
Khloe Kardashian Splits With Tristan Thompson After He Allegedly Cheats With Kylie's BFF
Joan Ryan Becomes Eighth MP To Quit Labour To Join Independent Group
Instagram wants you to look like a good person, but Facebook just wants your credit card
Kylie Jenner: Get Rich or Die Following
Karl Lagerfeld, Chanel fashion designer, dies aged 85
Bernie Sanders 2020: where the presidential candidate stands on key issues – video profile
The Real Reason Prince William and Kate Middleton's Breakup Made Them Stronger
'Lara Logan' Trending on Twitter After Recommending Reading Breitbart to Get 'The Other Side'
Nigel Farage slams 'APPALLING' Angela Smith race apology - 'Looks like a HOSTAGE VIDEO!'
Malia Obama, 20, spotted sipping on a $20 bottle of Whispering Angel Rose with friends in Miami
Maajid Nawaz, LBC presenter, hurt in 'racially motivated' attack
Jussie Smollett 'Angered And Devastated' By Claims He Played A Role In His Own Attack
Labour MPs Ann Coffey, Chuka Umunna, Luciana Berger, Angela Smith, Chris Leslie, Gavin Shuker And Mike Gapes Quit Party To Form 'The Independent Group'
Carmaker Honda plans to close Swindon factory
Presidents Day shows how time can change legacies. Just look at Washington and Lincoln
How time spent in space creates unusual immune-system impact
Trump slams 'SNL' for mocking his national emergency
Team LeBron rallies to beat Team Giannis, 178-164
Conor McGregor hypes up Kron Gracie’s UFC debut on Velasquez vs Ngannou card
Newport West Labour MP Paul Flynn dies aged 84
Shawn Mendes Gives a New Meaning to the Word Smolder in His Calvin Klein Ad
'SNL': Alec Baldwin returns to mock Trump's national emergency press conference
Sergio Ramos sent off as Real Madrid’s resurgence is ended by Girona
Graham: I 'support' Trump emergency declaration
Miranda Lambert weds mystery man Brendan Mcloughlin
‘Bohemian Rhapsody,’ ‘Marvelous Mrs. Maisel’ Among Cinema Audio Society Winners
Chicago police seek follow-up interview with 'Empire' actor Jussie Smollett
Regional airline Flybmi collapses blaming Brexit uncertainty
Bellator 215 ends early after Sergei Kharitonov takes kick to groin
Payless is closing all its 2,100 US stores
‘Downfall’ star Bruno Ganz dead at 77
Kusal Perera heroics lead Sri Lanka to remarkable Test win in South Africa
Ashley Cole goal celebration: This is what Derby star really cared about when scoring
Jet carrying Jennifer Aniston, Courteney Cox Makes Emergency Landing
Colin Kaepernick reaches settlement with NFL over kneeling protest fallout
Streaming recommendations: The Umbrella Academy and Lorena, both arriving Friday
Aurora shooting: sacked employee kills five in Illinois warehouse
By any measure, Winx is streets ahead
Watch: Trump gives Rose Garden speech after vowing to declare national emergency
Kaepernick, Eric Reid settle collusion grievances with NFL
Katy Perry and Orlando Bloom are engaged
Former Massachusetts Gov. Bill Weld looking to challenge Trump in 2020 Republican primary
Trump plans national emergency to build border wall as Senate passes spending bill
Andrea Levy had to fight for a recognition she truly deserved
NASA heading back to Moon soon, and this time to stay
Miley Cyrus Marks Valentine's Day With A Series Of Sweet New Wedding Photos
Rachel Johnson goes completely topless for live Brexit debate
Brexiteer Steve Baker issues DIRE WARNING to Theresa May - 'will COLLAPSE the government'
'The beginning of great change': Greta Thunberg hails school climate strikes
Cardi B returns to Instagram and announces new single featuring Bruno Mars
'Breaking Bad' Film Reportedly Headed to Netflix and AMC
Actress Regina King nearly trampled while courtside during NBA game
Singer Ryan Adams hits back over claims of sexual misconduct
FBI's Andrew McCabe feared he would be fired before Trump investigations were on 'solid ground'
Parkland one year on: what victories have gun control advocates seen?
Happy Valentines Day! The BEST messages and quotes to write in a Valentine’s Day card
Kendall Jenner wears blazer with no pants at New York Fashion Week
Michelle Obama's Grammy appearance did not impress mom
Airbus to scrap production of A380 superjumbo
London schoolgirl who fled to join Isis wants to return to UK
Eric Harrison, Manchester United’s Class of 92 coach, dies aged 81
Rapper YNW Melly Charged In Double Murder of His Friends
Jennifer Lopez Announces U.S. 'It's My Party' Tour for 50th Birthday
Trump intends to sign border deal to avoid another shutdown
Galentine's Day 2019: Why women across the world celebrate female friendship on 13 February
Anthony Joshua set for career-high purse as Jarrell Miller fight nears confirmation
'Frozen 2' Trailer Debuts Online
Lady Gaga Defends Brave Cardi B Amid Grammy Win Backlash
Katy Perry's fashion line under fire
UK chief Brexit negotiator Olly Robbins warns MPs the choice is May's deal or extension
This Is Us Just Added Another Twist to Kevin's Story...What Happens Now?
Huge second-half comeback lifts No. 2 Duke at Louisville
$500,000 Will Get You Ticket To Mars, Hopes Elon Musk
George Clooney Comes to Meghan Markle's Defense
NASA astronaut Mark Kelly launches Senate campaign
Nintendo Direct To Air Tomorrow, Wednesday 13th February
Gordon Banks, World Cup winner with England in 1966, dies aged 81
Jennifer Aniston's 50th birthday party packed with exes
Reddit users are the least valuable of any social network
John Dorsey believes Kareem Hunt signing will create competition
Grammys 2019 worst dressed: Cardi B and Katy Perry in most bizarre frocks on red carpet
'The Bachelor' recap: Shocker! Colton sends 4 contestants home, 1 quits
Why Was Jennifer Lopez Representing Black Music History at the Grammys?
Grammys 2019: Joy Villa dresses up in barbed wire and Donald Trump border wall dress
Netflix’s Roma wins best film and best director awards at BAFTAs
Rep. Ilhan Omar faces backlash over AIPAC comments
British ‘lethality’? Gavin Williamson’s brain has gone absent without leave
Grammys 2019 Winners List: Kacey Musgraves And Childish Gambino Are Top Artists
Grammys 2019 best dressed: Alicia Keys and Lady Gaga exude style in red carpet pictures
Cardi B the first woman to win best rap album Grammy
Grammys 2019: Ariana Grande Has Her Red Carpet Moment, Despite Not Actually Being On Red Carpet
Halsey on SNL: She hosted, sang, and painted a giant upside-down portrait
Let's not overreact, but Brad Pitt turned up to Jennifer Aniston's 50th birthday party
Tesla Model 3 = #1 Best Selling Electric Car in World, 7% of Global EV Market in 2018
Prince Philip gives up driving licence three weeks after car crash
Jeff Bezos's messy 2019: Divorce, blackmail and an Amazon HQ2 feud
Elizabeth Warren launches White House 2020 bid
Russell Westbrook ties NBA record for consecutive triple-doubles; James Harden scores 42
Uber drivers are not a fan of Halsey
Ariana Grande drops album amid Grammys spat
Close