Close
Date TimeFebruary 12, 2019
VoiceLast night, I’d been reporting on the meeting at the UK Ambassador’s Residence in Brussels between Michel Barnier and Brexit Secretary Stephen Barclay.
They’d been joined for their dinner by their respective teams, including Olly Robbins, the UK’s chief Brexit negotiator.
I saw Olly Robbins leave the dinner and walk to his taxi as my cameraman and I were preparing to report live outside for ITV News.
Once we’d finished we returned to our hotel and decided to have a quick nightcap in the bar.
It was then, when we walked into the bar, we realised Olly Robbins was also in the same hotel. He too was having a drink.
He was with two colleagues in the bar and could be clearly overheard by other guests as he gossiped about Brexit, the cabinet and MPs.
He was speaking in such a manner that you didn’t have to listen hard to hear him. But to be clear, I was hearing chunks of their conversation and not every single word.
UK chief Brexit negotiator Olly Robbins warns MPs the choice is Mays deal or extension
But during that conversation Olly Robbins said that, in his view, he expects the choice for MPs to be either backing May’s deal or extending talks with the EU.
He expects MPs in March to be presented with backing a reworked Brexit deal or a potentially significant delay to Brexit, he told colleagues last night.
“The issue is whether Brussels is clear on the terms of extension,” he was overheard saying. “In the end they will probably just give us an extension.”
This is significant. The prime minister has consistently said that we are leaving the EU on March 29th and that she will not engage with discussion about delaying our departure.
We now know her chief negotiator – who works directly for her – appears to be expecting a delay. A delay which she has always said was an option that was not on the table.
Robbins added that he thought the fear of a long extension to Article 50 might focus MPs' minds.
UK chief Brexit negotiator Olly Robbins warns MPs the choice is Mays deal or extension
He suggested: “... Got to make them believe that the week beginning end of March... Extension is possible but if they don’t vote for the deal then the extension is a long one...”
On the backstop, Robbins outlined a strategy to satisfy Theresa May's backbenchers, saying the European Commission would need to agree that the word “necessary” in the Northern Ireland protocol is defined as “necessary subject to the future trade deal”.
At the moment the text of the document says the backstop must “maintain the necessary conditions” for North-South cooperation under the Good Friday Agreement.
It appears that Robbins and the prime minister want the Withdrawal Agreement amended so that the Good Friday Agreement would be less of an obstacle to the backstop being superseded by a new long-term trading relationship between the UK and EU.
What is also striking is how Robbins confirmed that the original plan was for the backstop, which would keep the UK in the customs union, was designed not as a "safety net" for the island of Ireland but as "a bridge" to the long-term trading relationship - which is something the prime minister has always denied.
“The big clash all along is the ‘safety net’,” Robbins said. “We agreed a bridge but it came out as a ‘safety net’.”
These remarks by Robbins are explosive, because they will confirm the fears of Tory Brexiters that he and May always saw some form of customs union membership as the long term ambition for the UK's trading relationship with the EU.
Had it stayed as a ‘bridge’ into a customs union that might have lessened Labour opposition to the deal.
He explained that the current talks in Brussels need to find a ‘way out’ for those who see the backstop as a “trap”.
The talks go on.
A government spokesperson said: “We don’t propose to comment on alleged remarks from a private conversation. The government’s focus is on securing the improvements Parliament needs to pass a deal so we leave the EU on 29th March.”

Related Stories
Queen Elizabeth Wouldnt Allow Prince William and Kate Middleton to Get Divorced, Heres WhyQueen Elizabeth Wouldn't Allow Prince William and Kate Middleton to Get Divorced, Here's Why
Kate Middleton attends Donald Trump state banquet in white lace dressKate Middleton attends Donald Trump state banquet in white lace dress
Donald Trump meets the Queen at start of UK state visitDonald Trump meets the Queen at start of UK state visit
Change UK loses six of its 11 MPs after dire EU elections resultChange UK loses six of its 11 MPs after dire EU elections result
Suspect arrested in soccer star Emiliano Sala’s fatal plane crashSuspect arrested in soccer star Emiliano Sala’s fatal plane crash
BBC defends Jo Brand after she says: Why bother with milkshake when you could get some battery acid?BBC defends Jo Brand after she says: 'Why bother with milkshake when you could get some battery acid?'
Boris Johnson To Face Jeremy Hunt In Final Run-Off For Tory Leadership As Michael Gove Knocked OutBoris Johnson To Face Jeremy Hunt In Final Run-Off For Tory Leadership As Michael Gove Knocked Out
Dubais Princess Haya battles billionaire ruler husband in UK High CourtDubai's Princess Haya battles billionaire ruler husband in UK High Court
Oxford University accepts £150m from US private equity bossOxford University accepts £150m from US private equity boss
Boris Johnson pledges new determination to leave EU by 31 OctoberBoris Johnson pledges new determination to leave EU by 31 October
News Trends
Leonardo DiCaprio Gets Asked About the Titanic Door ControversyLeonardo DiCaprio Gets Asked About the Titanic Door Controversy
Bonnie Chapman Reveals Whether Dad Dog The Bounty Hunter Will Remarry After Beth Chapman’s DeathBonnie Chapman Reveals Whether Dad Dog The Bounty Hunter Will Remarry After Beth Chapman’s Death
These Republican women say they stand behind Trump and dont see his recent tweets as racistThese Republican women say they stand behind Trump and don't see his recent tweets as racist
Game Of Thrones fans realise Emmy nominated Alfie Allen is Lily Allens brotherGame Of Thrones fans realise Emmy nominated Alfie Allen is Lily Allen's brother
I love the tweet: Eric Trump says 95% of Americans agree with his dads message to love US or leave'I love the tweet': Eric Trump says 95% of Americans agree with his dad's message to love US or leave
El Chapo: Mexican drug lord sentenced to life in prisonEl Chapo: Mexican drug lord sentenced to life in prison
Modern Family star Sarah Hyland and Bachelorette contestant Wells Adams are engaged'Modern Family' star Sarah Hyland and 'Bachelorette' contestant Wells Adams are engaged
Elon Musks Neuralink hopes to put sensors in human brains next yearElon Musk's Neuralink hopes to put sensors in human brains next year
EU opens Amazon antitrust investigationEU opens Amazon antitrust investigation
Love Island: Michaels Behaviour Towards Amber Sparks Ofcom ComplaintsLove Island: Michael's Behaviour Towards Amber Sparks Ofcom Complaints
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
Queen Elizabeth Wouldnt Allow Prince William and Kate Middleton to Get Divorced, Heres WhyQueen Elizabeth Wouldn't Allow Prince William and Kate Middleton to Get Divorced, Here's Why
Kate Middleton attends Donald Trump state banquet in white lace dressKate Middleton attends Donald Trump state banquet in white lace dress
Donald Trump meets the Queen at start of UK state visitDonald Trump meets the Queen at start of UK state visit
Change UK loses six of its 11 MPs after dire EU elections resultChange UK loses six of its 11 MPs after dire EU elections result
Suspect arrested in soccer star Emiliano Sala’s fatal plane crashSuspect arrested in soccer star Emiliano Sala’s fatal plane crash
BBC defends Jo Brand after she says: Why bother with milkshake when you could get some battery acid?BBC defends Jo Brand after she says: 'Why bother with milkshake when you could get some battery acid?'
Boris Johnson To Face Jeremy Hunt In Final Run-Off For Tory Leadership As Michael Gove Knocked OutBoris Johnson To Face Jeremy Hunt In Final Run-Off For Tory Leadership As Michael Gove Knocked Out
Dubais Princess Haya battles billionaire ruler husband in UK High CourtDubai's Princess Haya battles billionaire ruler husband in UK High Court
Oxford University accepts £150m from US private equity bossOxford University accepts £150m from US private equity boss
Boris Johnson pledges new determination to leave EU by 31 OctoberBoris Johnson pledges new determination to leave EU by 31 October
News Trends
Leonardo DiCaprio Gets Asked About the Titanic Door ControversyLeonardo DiCaprio Gets Asked About the Titanic Door Controversy
Bonnie Chapman Reveals Whether Dad Dog The Bounty Hunter Will Remarry After Beth Chapman’s DeathBonnie Chapman Reveals Whether Dad Dog The Bounty Hunter Will Remarry After Beth Chapman’s Death
These Republican women say they stand behind Trump and dont see his recent tweets as racistThese Republican women say they stand behind Trump and don't see his recent tweets as racist
Game Of Thrones fans realise Emmy nominated Alfie Allen is Lily Allens brotherGame Of Thrones fans realise Emmy nominated Alfie Allen is Lily Allen's brother
I love the tweet: Eric Trump says 95% of Americans agree with his dads message to love US or leave'I love the tweet': Eric Trump says 95% of Americans agree with his dad's message to love US or leave
El Chapo: Mexican drug lord sentenced to life in prisonEl Chapo: Mexican drug lord sentenced to life in prison
Modern Family star Sarah Hyland and Bachelorette contestant Wells Adams are engaged'Modern Family' star Sarah Hyland and 'Bachelorette' contestant Wells Adams are engaged
Elon Musks Neuralink hopes to put sensors in human brains next yearElon Musk's Neuralink hopes to put sensors in human brains next year
EU opens Amazon antitrust investigationEU opens Amazon antitrust investigation
Love Island: Michaels Behaviour Towards Amber Sparks Ofcom ComplaintsLove Island: Michael's Behaviour Towards Amber Sparks Ofcom Complaints
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
This Is Us Just Added Another Twist to Kevin's Story...What Happens Now?
Huge second-half comeback lifts No. 2 Duke at Louisville
$500,000 Will Get You Ticket To Mars, Hopes Elon Musk
George Clooney Comes to Meghan Markle's Defense
NASA astronaut Mark Kelly launches Senate campaign
Nintendo Direct To Air Tomorrow, Wednesday 13th February
Gordon Banks, World Cup winner with England in 1966, dies aged 81
Jennifer Aniston's 50th birthday party packed with exes
Reddit users are the least valuable of any social network
John Dorsey believes Kareem Hunt signing will create competition
Grammys 2019 worst dressed: Cardi B and Katy Perry in most bizarre frocks on red carpet
'The Bachelor' recap: Shocker! Colton sends 4 contestants home, 1 quits
Why Was Jennifer Lopez Representing Black Music History at the Grammys?
Grammys 2019: Joy Villa dresses up in barbed wire and Donald Trump border wall dress
Netflix’s Roma wins best film and best director awards at BAFTAs
Rep. Ilhan Omar faces backlash over AIPAC comments
British ‘lethality’? Gavin Williamson’s brain has gone absent without leave
Grammys 2019 Winners List: Kacey Musgraves And Childish Gambino Are Top Artists
Grammys 2019 best dressed: Alicia Keys and Lady Gaga exude style in red carpet pictures
Cardi B the first woman to win best rap album Grammy
Grammys 2019: Ariana Grande Has Her Red Carpet Moment, Despite Not Actually Being On Red Carpet
Halsey on SNL: She hosted, sang, and painted a giant upside-down portrait
Let's not overreact, but Brad Pitt turned up to Jennifer Aniston's 50th birthday party
Tesla Model 3 = #1 Best Selling Electric Car in World, 7% of Global EV Market in 2018
Prince Philip gives up driving licence three weeks after car crash
Jeff Bezos's messy 2019: Divorce, blackmail and an Amazon HQ2 feud
Elizabeth Warren launches White House 2020 bid
Russell Westbrook ties NBA record for consecutive triple-doubles; James Harden scores 42
Uber drivers are not a fan of Halsey
Ariana Grande drops album amid Grammys spat
National Enquirer faces new legal woes after Bezos claims
Virginia black caucus, Dem lawmakers call for Justin Fairfax to step down after new sexual assault accusation
British rapper Cadet dies in taxi crash on way to Staffordshire gig
Pogba drives Manchester United into top four as Fulham fans rail at Ranieri
Patriots WR, Super Bowl MVP Julian Edelman looks completely different after shaving his giant beard
Sharon Osbourne supports Ariana Grande snubbing the Grammys
Danniella Westbrook Sent To Rehab By 'Good Mate' Jeremy Kyle
UK weather: Storm Erik batters Britain with rain and 70mph winds
Jeff Van Gundy says Gayle Benson should stand up to NBA, disses local reporters during ESPN broadcast
Kim Kardashian Makes Big Baby No. 4 Reveal & Talks Kanye West's Many Feuds in New KUWTK Season 16 Promo! on Kardashians
Body recovered from plane wreckage identified as footballer Emiliano Sala
Whitaker squares off with Democrats at fiery hearing
Tory MP Christopher Chope Does It Again Blocks Bill To Protect Women At Risk Of FGM
Albert Finney, cinema's original 'angry young man', dies aged 82
Jeff Bezos accuses National Enquirer owner of 'extortion and blackmail'
Former Rep. John Dingell dies at 92
Rajon Rondo delivers the dagger to the Celtics
The Drama Between Ariana Grande And The Grammys Just Escalated
Cindy McCain apologizes for disputed sex trafficking claim
BB&T to Buy SunTrust in Biggest Bank Merger Since Financial Crisis
Gucci withdraws $890 jumper after blackface backlash
Little sign of Brexit progress as May and Juncker clash
Bank of England sees weakest outlook for the UK since 2009 amid Brexit uncertainty
SpaceX and Boeing commercial crew capsule test dates slip yet again
Germany to fall short of 2020 climate goals: report
NASA lost contact with two mini Mars spacecraft and they don't know exactly why
Elon Musk Recommends You Watch This Movie
Brexit: What awaits Theresa May in Brussels after 'hell' jibe?
Trump's State of the Union showed he represents the people, not the swamp
Kim Kardashian responds to tabloid criticizing her 'bad skin day'
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Reveals Why She Refused To Be ‘Spirited And Warm’ For Trump
'Modern Family' has been renewed for the final 11th season
Sources: Clippers agree to deal Harris to Sixers
Donald Tusk: 'special place in hell' for those who promoted Brexit without plan
Ariana Grande Not Attending Grammys After Disagreements With Producers
Cory Booker says he's in a relationship
Boyfriend left Holby City actor John Michie's daughter to die of drug overdose because he didn't want to be arrested, court hears
State of the Union: Trump attacks Mueller and Democrats in divisive speech
Child abuser Rolf Harris investigated over entering school grounds
BBC Veteran John Humphrys Is Set To Leave Today Show This Year
Is Meghan Markle Using A Doula?
Kendall Jenner Got Bangs and She Looks Like a Completely Different Person
Andy Cohen welcomes baby boy via surrogate
John Barnes Says Liam Neeson 'Deserves A Medal' Amid Controversy Over Independent Interview
2 Indian-American women oppose nomination of Neomi Rao
Lunar New Year 2019: Year of the Pig is welcomed across Asia
Democratic women to send political message by wearing white to State of the Union
Did Kylie Jenner and Travis Scott Get Engaged at the Super Bowl?
Apex Legends Hits 1 Million Players In 8 Hours
First-ever papal mass begins in the Arabian peninsula
HMV sold to Canada's Sunrise Records
When, where and how to watch President Donald Trump's 2019 State of the Union address
With wait over, Bengals free to hire Zac Taylor as coach
Liam Neeson: After a friend was raped, I wanted to kill a black man
Bill Gross Retires After Storied Four-Decade Career in Bonds
'Young and Restless' actor Kristoff St. John dead at 52
World Cancer Day: German health minister defends setting 'big goals'
A third of Himalayan ice cap doomed, finds report
Gary Anderson: Premier League Darts' two-time winner out with back injury
Gisele Bündchen shows love for Tom Brady ahead of Super Bowl
Maroon 5's Super Bowl performance: Adam Levine's torso can't save tedious affair
Hermes to offer gig economy drivers better rights under union deal
Demi Lovato Deletes Twitter After Comments About 21 Savage Spark Backlash
Here Are the Winners of the 2019 Sundance Awards
'Trump kicks back': Ohio voters expect strong state of the union
Tulsi Gabbard officially launches 2020 campaign
Pete Davidson and Kate Beckinsale Reunite and Show PDA After Comedy Show
Cardi B 'stands behind' Colin Kaepernick in refusing Super Bowl show
Rebel Labour MPs set to quit party and form centre group
Sergey Kovalev avenges loss to Eleider Alvarez, wins light-heavyweight title for third time
Ralph Northam has to resign, even if he doesn't know it yet
Blair Kinghorn hat-trick sparks Scotland’s Six Nations victory over Italy
Bow Wow arrested in Atlanta for alleged assault
Netflix’s Russian Doll: TV’s answer to Groundhog Day?
Ellen Page Calls Out Trump And Pence Over Hate: This Needs To F**king Stop!
Cory Booker announces run for presidency in 2020
Brexit: Gibraltar 'colony' row flares as EU makes travel visa-free for Britons
Comedian Jeremy Hardy dies of cancer aged 57
Jennifer Hudson To Sing Ruth Bader Ginsburg Song 'I'll Fight' At The Oscars
‘Strong is the new pretty’ for Miss Bala director Catherine Hardwicke
Sojourner Truth: The life and legacy of pioneering anti-slavery and women's rights activist
Brexit: Third of UK businesses considering move abroad - survey
So, poorer Brexiters voted to be worse off? There’s nothing wrong in that | Gary Younge
With LeBron back, Lakers outlast Clippers in OT 123-120
What Serena Williams Hopes to Teach Her Daughter About Being a Strong Woman
Justin Timberlake videos Jessica Biel asleep on his birthday date and moms totally relate
Watch Christina Aguilera Surprise Customers With Epic Donut Shop Prank
Pelosi: No money for wall in U.S. border deal talks
Kristaps Porzingis SHOCKS Knicks in showdown talks amid Anthony Davis rumours
Kate Spade's niece Rachel Brosnahan is the new face of her label
What is a snow squall, the weather phenomenon that caused a whiteout in New York and Pennsylvania?
Anthony Martial: Man Utd forward signs new contract until 2024
Newark Airport fire: Dozens of cars ENGULFED by flames at airport carpark
Jackie Robinson Showed Me How to Fight On, Not Fight Back
How ‘The Masked Singer’ became TV’s newest hit
'The Batman' to fly in 2021 without Ben Affleck as Bruce Wayne
Venezuela: Jeremy Hunt to call for EU sanctions on key Maduro figures
Dick Miller, ‘Gremlins’ and ‘Terminator’ Actor, Dies at 90
You Can See Venus, Jupiter, Saturn, and a Gorgeous Crescent Moon in a 'Celestial Parade' Tomorrow Morning
Jennifer Lopez's Ex-Boyfriend and Current Man Are Adorably Falling Into Her Instagram Thirst Traps
Ariana Grande Has Major Tattoo Fail, Accidentally Inks 'BBQ Grill' In Japanese
Why Shares of AMD Are Surging Today
Trump calls his own intel chiefs 'extremely passive and naive'
Foxconn reconsiders plan for Wisconsin manufacturing hub
Tyson Foods recalls more than 36,000 pounds of chicken nuggets after possible rubber contamination
Best of Late Night: Colbert on the Polar Vortex: ‘Viral Marketing for 'Game of Thrones' Has Gone Too Far’
Snow hits the UK; Manchester Airport closed, flights canceled
Filmmaker Sir Peter Jackson announces new documentary on the Beatles
Theresa May and Jeremy Corbyn clash over Irish backstop 'alternatives' at PMQs
Maroon 5 cancels its news conference at Super Bowl LIII
Celine Dion responds to body-shamers concerned over her slimmer figure: 'Leave me alone'
Laura Plummer lands back in Britain after being released from prison in Egypt
Grammy-Winning R&B Star James Ingram Dead At 66
Phillies fans fooled by fake Bryce Harper MLB rumor on Twitter
Stacey Abrams to deliver the Democratic response to Trump’s State of the Union
Empire Actor Jussie Smollett Attacked In Suspected Racist And Homophobic Incident
Labour ready to back Cooper amendment on article 50 extension
Kendall Jenner and Bella Hadid facing possible subpoenas over Fyre Festival
'Black Panther' returning to theaters for free Black History Month screenings
Brexit: May to ask EU to reopen withdrawal agreement over Irish backstop
Former Labour MP Fiona Onasanya jailed in speeding case
Aasia Bibi cleared after years on death row for blasphemy in Pakistan
Let Me Finish review: Everybody hates Chris Christie – and he hates Jared Kushner
Jeff Flake rules out 2020 primary challenge to Trump
Trump accepts invitation from Pelosi to deliver State of the Union on Feb. 5
John Krasinski Causes Meltdown on Twitter As He Tears Up During Wife Emily Blunt's SAG Speech
Katie Price reveals plans to adopt a Nigerian orphan
Apple rushes to fix FaceTime bug that let users eavesdrop on others
Toy Story 4: NEW teaser gives first look at THIS major original character’s return
Facebook's popularity dips with UK children, says Ofcom
Green MSP Ross Greer and James Cleverly on Churchill legacy
Miley Cyrus honors Ellen with earrings featuring her iconic Time cover
Elon Musk demands PewDiePie to let him host meme review with hilarious Tweet
3-year-old boy who went missing in woods for days says bear kept him safe
George Groves announces his retirement from boxing
Manchester United plot FA Cup revenge after being drawn against Chelsea
Michael Jackson Family Condemns 'Leaving Neverland' Documentary About Accusers
Lady Gaga and Christian Carino SAG Awards PDA - Lady Gaga and Christian Carino Kiss at SAG Awards
Hillary Clinton tells friends she's leaving 2020 door open
Pelicans star Anthony Davis wants to be traded, agent says
Will the next iPhone charge wirelessly?
NASA’s Mars Opportunity rover may have 'died' in dust storm, scientists fear
Emma Stone and Boyfriend Dave McCary at 2019 SAG Awards
2019 SAG Awards Analysis
Kamala Harris says the powerful seek to divide America
Gemma Collins Left In Tears After Falling Flat On Her Face During Live ‘Dancing On Ice’ Routine
Vanessa Hudgens' Most Iconic Rent Live Moments
WWE Royal Rumble: Becky Lynch WIN sends fans WILD after eliminating Nia Jax and Charlotte
Zac Efron Sundance party leaves attendees angry, freezing
Formula E: Rita Ora looks on as Sam Bird wins in Santiago
Connor Wickham ends long wait as Crystal Palace knock out Tottenham
SAG Awards 2019 Winners: The Complete List
Earth’s Oldest Known Rock Found on Moon - Scientists Explain How It Got There
Dakota Theriot, suspect in 5 killings in Louisiana, arrested in Virginia
Lady Gaga and Bradley Cooper Perform 'Shallow' Together in Las Vegas: Watch
Novak Djokovic outclasses Rafael Nadal to win his seventh Australian Open
One in 20 Britons ‘does not believe’ Holocaust took place, poll finds
Banksy drawing, worth millions, of sad-faced girl stolen in Paris
Pete Davidson’s Stand-Up Sets Are All About ‘Sick Genius’ Ariana Grande
M. Night Shyamalan and James McAvoy clear up Glass
UK's 'highest taxpayers' revealed in first-ever Sunday Times list
Meghan Markle's independence is rubbing royals the wrong way
Did Kylie Jenner Reference Taylor Swift With New Valentine's Day Collection?
Matt LeBlanc Stole A 'Friends' Prop For The Sweetest Reason
Roger Stone set to appear in federal court in Washington DC
Fatima Ali, 'Top Chef' fan favorite, dies at 29
Ann Coulter Admits To Bill Maher: ‘OK, I’m Very Stupid Girl' About Donald Trump
Katie Price Admits To Self-Medicating With Drugs But Denies It Was Reason Behind Rehab Stint
Naomi Osaka wins Australian Open final to seal back-to-back grand slams
Bernie Sanders set to announce 2020 presidential run
Close