Close
Date TimeOctober 06, 2017
Voice

All you’re hearing out of the voice activated “smart speaker” market is static. You wish you could ask Alexa or the Google Assistant to help you sort out this burgeoning business, a space in which the biggest names in tech are all crowding around to grab your attention.
You wonder how much to spend. Mini, Max, Plus or original? Whether to choose a speaker with a screen? And must you commit to one virtual assistant over another?
The latest noise came with Google’s unveiling Wednesday of new Google Home offerings built around the Google Assistant. Only a week earlier, Amazon announced the expansion of its own line of Echo speakers, featuring its voice-driven virtual assistant Alexa.
Meantime, Apple is readying its HomePod speaker activated with Siri, best known from the iPhone. Harman Kardon (owned by Samsung) is doing the same with the upcoming, yet-to-be priced, Invoke speaker that houses Microsoft’s Cortana assistant.
Alexa continues to branch out into other devices, too, including speakers made by the likes of Sonos and Lenovo.
The smart speaker market really got going in 2015, when Amazon introduced consumers to Alexa as part of the original Echo speaker. Amazon has remained the clear leader since, controlling about 70% of the market, eMarketer says, and now boasting north of 20,000 Alexa “skills.”
Here are the key questions to help you get smarter about smart speakers:

What makes a speaker smart?



These aren't the dumb speakers of yesteryear but rather connected speakers that leverage the Internet and artificial intelligence.
You engage them by calling upon one of the aforementioned cloud-connected virtual assistants by barking out a wake word—notably “Alexa” in the case of an Echo.
Amazon and Google have each lined up partners to work with the speakers, and the kinds of things you can accomplish with the devices continues to mushroom.
There are the basic, and yes useful, things you can do: asking for the weather, a wake-up alarm or kitchen timer, for example. Or getting the speakers to deliver news, podcasts or music on command—limited by the available services you subscribe to.
The speakers can respond to financial queries and answer queries related to trivia or your kids’ schoolwork. You can use them to make calls, too.
There’s also a growing emphasis on home automation: using your voice to control lights, thermostats, doorbells and other items around what tech companies are banking on will become your increasingly intelligent home.

What are the main buying decisions?
In simple terms: design, price, and any steadfast loyalty you might have for one ecosystem or digital assistant over another.
Alexa may help you shop (through Amazon of course). A Google advantage comes through search and the company’s vast reservoir of knowledge. If you’ve got an iPhone you’re probably most comfortable with Siri, though many pundits believe Apple’s assistant must play catch-up to the others.

Amazon and Microsoft announced recently that Alexa will talk to Cortana and vice versa, though it is unclear how smooth (or useful) such interactions will be. Meanwhile, don’t hold your breath waiting for the other virtual assistants to become chums anytime soon.
Why such a disparity in price—from around $49 to $399?

Google Home, Amazon Echo, Apple HomePod— or all 3? How to choose a smart speaker

In general terms, you’re paying for speaker quality, though there are other factors like whether the device has a screen or built-in smart home hub.
Let’s start at the low end. Amazon sells the $49 Echo Dot, a price matched by the just- announced Google Home Mini. The pint-sized Dot speakers are adequate for Alexa or the spoken voice generally but not for music mavens seeking richer, louder and purer sound. Though I haven’t tested one yet, the same can surely be said for the Google Home Mini.
You do have options if you want a better music experience, however. In the case of the Echo Dot, you can connect optional headphones or other speakers by running a 3.5mm stereo cable to the jack on the unit. Or you can connect Dot wirelessly to a range of Bluetooth speakers.

Google Home, Amazon Echo, Apple HomePod— or all 3? How to choose a smart speaker


There’s no such 3.5mm jack on the Home Mini or Bluetooth support But in keeping things within the Google ecosystem, you can connect Google Home Mini wirelessly to Chromecast Audio-capable speakers.
At first blush, the new stone-shaped Home Mini is better looking than the Dot. It comes in three colors, is covered in fabric and is meant to blend in nicely with your home décor. But either the Dot or Home Mini can be helpful bedside or kitchen companions.
The benefits of stepping up?

Google Home, Amazon Echo, Apple HomePod— or all 3? How to choose a smart speaker


You get better sound, for starters. And Amazon did recently lower the price of the full-size Echo to $99.99, where it competes against the full-size $129.99 Google Home, which is now on back order.
Amazon also just unveiled a $149.99 Echo Plus with a smart home hub inside, a price that under a temporary promotion includes a free Philips Hue smart light bulb. Setting up smart home devices can be exceedingly complicated but Amazon insists Echo Plus makes it a breeze to do so, a claim we’ll have to put to the test.
Since Apple, Google, Samsung and others have a vested interest in pursuing a smart home strategy, don’t be surprised to see speakers that follow suit down the line. Even without a dedicated hub, you can use your voice and these speakers to control many of the smart devices you may have in your house.

HomePod vs. Max: Spending even more?

Google Home, Amazon Echo, Apple HomePod— or all 3? How to choose a smart speaker

For now, the highest end of the smart speaker market means Apple’s $349 HomePod with Siri and Google’s $399 Google Home Max with Google Assistant, both not slated to ship until December. Such speakers still may not tickle the fancy of audiophiles, but these pricier options are meant to get music lovers jazzed.
Google says it will be able to deliver superior sound not just through tweeters and woofers but by employing artificial intelligence and machine learning. It has trained the Max speaker in thousands of different room configurations to fine-tune sound profiles based on the environment and can pretty much change on the fly as you move it around (though it still must be plugged in).

Google Home, Amazon Echo, Apple HomePod— or all 3? How to choose a smart speaker

Worth considering though if you’re a music fan is the Sonos One speaker that was also announced Wednesday, which features Alexa and a lower $199 price tag.
Since these are larger speakers more likely to be out in the open, you’ll want to pay attention to the aesthetics. That's a very personal thing  but Apple often comes on top when it comes to design.
Of course, the most important way to evaluate these speakers will be to listen to them.

Portable speakers?

Google Home, Amazon Echo, Apple HomePod— or all 3? How to choose a smart speaker

Though you can schlep Dots or Minis from room to room, these and most other speakers need to be plugged in. One exception is the Amazon Tap, a portable Bluetooth Alexa speaker that operates on a battery. And when it comes to portability, all these digital assistants live in your smartphone.
Do I want a screen?

Google Home, Amazon Echo, Apple HomePod— or all 3? How to choose a smart speaker

In short, maybe. For now, you have two options, and both are from Amazon. There's the $229.99 Echo Show ($100 off when you buy two), which has a 7-inch color touchscreen, and the $129.99 Echo Spot, which has a 2.5-inch screen. The latter won’t be available until December.
A show and tell Echo means you can eyeball song lyrics, watch movie trailers or other clips, peek at security cameras, and yes, make a “drop-in” video call to a loved on equipped with their own Echo Show or Spot.
Show is functional but but won't win any awards for beauty. The compact Spot is more appealing physically.

Google Home, Amazon Echo, Apple HomePod— or all 3? How to choose a smart speaker

It should be noted that through a recent spat between companies, Google recently removed YouTube videos from Echo Show.
Google hasn’t ruled out coming out with a Google Home unit with its own display, but for now, as Google exec Rishi Chandra told me, the company would rather “take advantage of screens you already have,” be it the phone in your pocket or the TV in the living room.
But Chandra says manufacturers are going to eventually build devices with every screen size imaginable to see which ones sticks and which ones don't.
Which means there’s likely to be a lot more noise surrounding your decision to choose which speakers down the road to buy.

Late-Night Hosts Take On Trump, Tillerson "Moron" Report
Trump wins, Congress loses with Iran deal politics
Yahoo HACK hit BILLIONS - Find out if YOUR account was HACKED, how to change password
Catalonia is NOT alone: Mapped - the other European regions desperate for independence
Yes, San Juan Mayor’s ‘Nasty’ Shirt Was Aimed At Trump
Kate Winslet stripped NAKED for Idris Elba romp but you WON'T believe what he requested
CIA: Kim Jong Un isn't crazy
Julia Roberts Reenacts Her Film Career With the Help of James Corden
Catalan crisis: Spanish court bars MPs' independence move
British writer Kazuo Ishiguro wins 2017 Nobel Prize for Literature
‘Brexit should be a lesson!' Furious Hungary promises EU WAR over new Brussels crackdown
Welcome to England's chosen hotel for their Russia 2018 base... and it may not be what WAGS are used to - Telegraph.co.uk
Vladimir Putin gives 'lifeline' to Kim Jong-un in bid to save regime and stop World War 3
Google Clips camera: creepy or fun?
Queen has revealed her favourite song but it is not what you might think
NASA ‘solves’ baffling mystery of ‘alien megastructures’ surrounding distant Tabby’s Star
Evidence Suggests Las Vegas Shooter Planned Escape, Police Say
Catalonia leader attacks king's speech and insists region IS following democratic process
Google Pixel 2 XL and Pixel 2: Google unveils its iPhone rival
Miley Cyrus and Jimmy Fallon Freak Out Fans In 'Tonight Show' Photobomb Gag
France uses THATCHER QUOTE to demand Britain pays Brexit bill: 'We want our money back!'
Celine Dion donates concert proceeds to Vegas shooting victims: 'So many are still suffering'
Nicole Richie and Tina Fey Spoof Taylor Swift's "Bad Blood" Video on 'Great News'
Las Vegas shooting: Stephen Paddock's girlfriend, Marilou Danley, returns to U.S., reports say
GET UP Boris! Moment Amber Rudd orders Johnson to STAND up for PM in show of support
Justin Trudeau Suggests $1 Per Gram Tax On Marijuana
Catalonia could BRING DOWN EU: Brussels warned NOT to wash its hands or risk its FUTURE
Yahoo tops the list of largest ever data breaches
Vegas shooter modified guns for rapid fire, used cameras to monitor police
Bitcoin to hit highest level EVER as with digital currency set to be worth £6,000 per coin
French police arrest couple with ROCKET LAUNCHER near Marseille days after knife terror
Theresa May: Boris Johnson isn't undermining me
Catalonia Referendum: Spain's King Felipe calls independence vote illegal and undemocratic
Ellen DeGeneres Offers "Message of Hope" After Las Vegas Massacre
Shame on Labour! Priti Patel demolishes Corbyn's 'vile brand of socialism' in fiery speech
Trump landed in Puerto Rico and wasted no time before criticizing its leaders.
Why Equifax will continue to profit by selling your personal information
David Davis speech LIVE: UK is READY for NO DEAL - Brexit secretary hints at alternative
Storms, earthquakes, North Korea and now the Las Vegas massacre. We have to wonder: 'What's next?'
'Game of Thrones' Podcast: The Cost of Moving the Mountain
Spain in CHAOS: Police evicted from hotels after BRUTALITY of Catalonia referendum vote
BREAKING: EU MEPs declare NO sufficient Brexit progress in vote blasted a 'distraction'
Facebook: Russian ads reached 10 million people
Longer jail terms for viewing terror content online
Don't bash Britain over Brexit: 'Schadenfreude' is DEVASTATING the EU, warns German paper
Late-Night Hosts Speak Out About Gun Violence in Wake of Las Vegas Tragedy
'Shots fired' at California university – police order students to take shelter
'Beyond horrific.' Country music world stunned by Las Vegas shooting
Mariah Carey Reacts to Vegas Shooting on Live TV: "It's Terrible"
SPAIN IN CRISIS: Stock market crash over Catalonia chaos - ‘WORST outcome for Madrid’
The Las Vegas attack is the deadliest mass shooting in modern US history
'The Gifted': Who's Who in Fox's New X-Men Series
BREAKING: ISIS claims responsibility for Las Vegas shooting - 'he converted months ago'
Sandy Hook Senator: ‘It’s Time for Congress To Get Off Its Ass And Do Something’
Las Vegas shooting: What we know
Las Vegas shooting: 'YOU'RE ALL GOING TO DIE' – SHOCK WARNING 45 minutes before attack
Who is Stephen Paddock? Las Vegas shooting suspect named as 64-year-old man
More than 20 dead after shooting on Las Vegas Strip
Catalonia referendum: Catalans to ‘declare INDEPENDENCE’ after 90 per cent Yes vote
Las Vegas shooting video: HORRIFYING moments shots ring out across Mandalay Bay concert
Couple admits to stealing $1.2 million from Amazon
North Korea provided with internet by Russian company despite UN sanctions
Catalonia votes to LEAVE Spain as 90 per cent say 'Yes' in referendum
Catalan referendum: muted response from EU leaders over police crackdown - The Guardian
‘Not European anymore’ Furious Catalans slam EU for silence over police violence in Spain
Trump: Tillerson 'wasting his time' negotiating with North Korea
2 women stabbed to death at Marseille train station, attacker shot dead
Catalan government: '465 injured by Spanish police violence' during referendum - live
FC Barcelona bars public from match amid Catalan vote chaos
BREAKING: Marseille attack: Knifeman shot dead by army as one killed in stabbing
REVEALED: China’s plans to ‘REMOVE’ volatile North Korean leader Kim Jong-un
Catalan referendum: Police fire grenades and rubber bullets as voters bleed in streets
Catalonia referendum LIVE: Riot police STORM polling stations as independence vote begins
US talking to North Korea 'directly,' Tillerson says
Meghan Markle and her mother cozy up to Prince Harry at Invictus Games closing ceremony
Ryan Gosling Makes Fun of His 'La La Land' Character in 'SNL' Opener
Royal Canadian Legion Sends A Chilling Message To Employees
SEE IT: Engine destroyed on Air France flight from Paris to LA - New York Daily News
Trump called San Juan's mayor a weak leader. Here's what her leadership looks like. - Washington Post
Your Google Assistant: Now on Android TV
Elon Musk: Rockets will fly people from city to city in minutes
Shay Mitchell to Star in ABC Drama From 'Pretty Little Liars' Creators
‘We expect CHAOS’ Neo-Nazi group descend on Swedish city as police arrest protestors
Spanish police move to enforce ban on Catalan independence poll
HHS Secretary Tom Price resigns
Jay-Z and Ryan Gosling Are 'Together Again at Last' in 'SNL' Promos
Brexit: Boris Johnson urges two-year transition time limit
Barack Obama joins Prince Harry for Invictus surprise
World War 3 threat: North Korea spotted moving MISSILES from rocket facility
BREAKING: Man stabbed to death near Tory Party Conference in Manchester city centre fight
Trump’s tax plan is very good for Trump: $757 million over 10 years.
World War 3: North Korea & Russia issued nuclear WARNING – 'they're reckless & aggressive'
Teach Your Preteen That Looking 'Sexy' Doesn't Mean 'Ready For Sex'
Ellen DeGeneres Brings Back Karla Kardashian for 'Keeping Up With the Kardashians' Parody
‘We love Great Britain!’ Merkel targeted in angry protest outside EU summit
How to stop your devices from listening to (and saving) what you say
Rihanna to Trump: 'Don't let your people die like this'
Face au cancer du sein, de l'esprit ou du corps, qui va maîtriser l'autre?
Fin des allocations familiales pour tous: pourquoi Macron va devoir trancher
Elon Musk Unveils Ambitious Plan To Build A City On Mars
Oh no you don’t May! Photo shows how EU kept PM from talking to Merkel in Brexit block
Let's Talk About Hugh Hefner's Political Legacy - New York Times
UK only has HOURS to prepare for WW3: North Korea vs US is REAL possibility - shock report
Theresa meets Ange: May to steal 30 minutes away from EU prying eyes to speak to Merkel
This Blind Astrophysicist 'Sees' the Universe in the Most Amazing Way | Short Film Showcase
UK's top supplier of supermarket chicken fiddles food safety dates
Attorney: Kushner used private email account to talk to WH officials
Uber ruling puts jobs at risk, says Theresa May
Inside the Playboy Mansion With Hugh Hefner - RollingStone.com
Julia Louis-Dreyfus Reveals Breast Cancer Diagnosis
Rising up against May: 50,000 anti-Brexit protesters to descend on Tory conference
What is the Jones Act?
Rep. Steve Scalise returns to House after shooting
Netflix commits half a billion dollars to new Canadian productions: sources
U.S. Plans To Monitor Immigrants’ Social Media Accounts, Search Histories
Theresa May threatens US TRADE WAR over Bombardier row
Emmanuel Macron launches SAVAGE attack on David Cameron for failing during Brexit campaign
Hefner started Playboy with $600 and built it into a multimillion-dollar entertainment empire. He died at 91
'Survivor' Season 35: The First One Out Reveals What Went Wrong
Trudeau ‘disappointed’ in U.S. decision to slap 220 per cent duty on Canada’s Bombardier jets
World War 3 latest: Russia on war footing as Putin's troops amass on North Korea border
Robots could destabilise world through war and unemployment, says UN
Passengers in Puerto Rican airport have little water or food, no working ATMs and no idea when they'll leave
'Big Brother' Fan-Favorites to Compete on 'The Amazing Race' (Exclusive)
Russia and US will cooperate to build moon's first space station
Iraqi Kurds back independence in referendum
'Schengen dies, EU dies' Brussels faces tussle with Merkel and Macron over border controls
Prince Harry hits the CN Tower and the crowd goes wild
Britain will be BETTER OFF after Brexit and EU could FAIL, Austrian politician says
Roy Moore beats Trump’s choice to claim Alabama’s GOP Senate nomination.
Jurgen Klopp frustrated as Liverpool fail to unlock Spartak on crazy European night
Twitter trials 280-character tweet limit
Prince George is already fed up of school and does NOT want to go, Prince William reveals
Clinton: White House private emails 'height of hypocrisy'
What doctors want from health care reform
BREAKING: Russia fires ballistic missile with HUGE warhead as Putin ratchets up WW3 threat
BREAKING: Trump says US will take 'devastating military option' to end North Korea tension
Madonna Tries Her Kim Kardashian Impression on 'The Tonight Show'
Microsoft's new coding language is made for quantum computers - Engadget
As millions struggle for food, water and fuel after Hurricane Maria, Trump tweeted how Puerto Rico is billions in debt
ADIOS MAJORCA: End of an era as Britons HATED by ‘arrogant locals’ start leaving isle
U.S. Vice-President Mike Pence blasts ‘failings’ of Canadian health system
Palestinian gunman kills three Israelis in West Bank
Thousands in mass evacuation as Monaro volcano ERUPTS
Tony Blair claims UK opinion changing on Iraq War outrage despite 'faulty evidence'
The war of words could be pushing the region to the point where a wrong move could be calamitous
'Big Bang Theory' Boss Explains That Season 11 Premiere Double Shocker
North Korea accuses Trump of declaring war
For Prince Harry and Meghan Markle, it's love during wheelchair tennis match at Invictus Games
'Pretty Little Liars' Spinoff Starring Sasha Pieterse, Janel Parrish a Go at Freeform
Chelsea Manning says she's been denied entry into Canada
Review: Megyn Kelly tries to ditch politics for 'fun' on 'Today'
The country's foreign minister says President Trump declared war through a tweet over the weekend
What's the deal with the new travel ban? - CBS News
Uber boss Dara Khosrowshahi apologises after London ban
'German vote shows federalism has FAILED' Vanis Varoufakis says four years of EU collapse
Jeremy Corbyn BANS Labour conference vote on Brexit - uses 'ultra-lefts' to stop MPs vote
America watched as NFL players united in protest after Trump's criticism. These are the most powerful photos
'I, Tonya' Gets 2017 Awards-Qualifying Release Date (Exclusive)
Gunman opens fire in Nashville church; 1 dead, 8 hurt
BREXIT SABOTAGE: Macron and Merkel to unleash plot to tie UK to Brussels FOREVER
Trump responds to protests: Locking arms is good, kneeling is not
'Now you can feel Russia's power:' Russian military in Syria eager to show its victories
German election polls latest LIVE: Angela Merkel and AfD push for victory in final hour
NFL Players Kneel to Protest Anthem and Trump Comments in Opening Game
Women should pop a squat for equality: Teitel
BBC's Laura Kuenssberg to get 'bodyguards to protect her from Labour hate mob'
LeBron James Explains Why Trump’s Attack On The NFL Is Personal
‘You’re not just here to inspire, you’re here to win’: Trudeau to athletes at Invictus Games opening ceremony
Brexit: Jeremy Corbyn urges caution on single market
Meghan Markle makes first PUBLIC appearance with Prince Harry at Invictus Games
Mystery SOLVED: Archaeologists uncover who made the Great Pyramid of Giza
Bruce Maxwell is the first MLB player to kneel during the national anthem.
The President, NFL commissioner and top basketball players are embroiled in a public fight over patriotism
North Korea says rockets to U.S. 'inevitable' as U.S. bombers fly off North Korean coast
Uber protest petition tops 600,000
Westfield shopping centre acid attack: Six injured in east London, police at the scene
MACRON BACKLASH: Angry scenes as thousands march in Paris against president's reforms
With 'son of a b**** comments, Trump tried to divide NFL and its players
Canada could win the Amazon sweepstakes due to Trump scaring 'the bejesus out of everyone'
North Korea hit by EARTHQUAKE sparking fears of fresh Kim Jong-un missile test
Trump said he wanted NFL owners to “get that son of a b*tch off the field.”
Diego Costa opens up on Chelsea exit and delight at returning home to Atletico Madrid
Brexit: UK needs to clarify issues - Macron
Meghan Markle 'given VIP pass' to Prince Harry’s Invictus Games – will he propose?
UK storm season ARRIVES: Floods to SMASH Britain THIS WEEKEND as misery fortnight begins
Ivanka Trump: It's 'not my job' to be voice of moderation in White House
Ellen DeGeneres Parodies Taylor Swift's "Look What You Made Me Do" Video
Theresa May fires back at BBC's Kuenssberg during HEATED exchange after Brexit speech
Facebook Is Now The Federal Election Commission, But With More Secrets
Cillizza: President's tweets about a 'Russia hoax' contradict every intel agency and his own adviser
Theresa May Florence speech: Europe reacts LIVE with Brexit chiefs set for warm response
What happens if N. Korea explodes a H-bomb above the Pacific?
Netflix Children's Show Producer Says Penis Drawing Was "Very Bad Joke" From One Artist
German election becomes battle for third place in coalition
How to make your CV stand out from the crowd
Brink of war: Kim Jong-un vows USA will pay as North Korea considers 'STRONGEST response'
Trump orders new sanctions to tighten screws on North Korea nuclear program
Spain in CRISIS: Troops sent in as 40,000 protest over 'WAR' on Catalan independence vote
Canada struggles to improve conditions for Indigenous People, Trudeau says at the UN
Close