August 25, 2018
When Elon Musk declared this month that he wanted to take Tesla private, his board was caught off guard. Barely three weeks later, the chief executive told the board he had changed his mind. Tesla would be staying public, after all.
Inside Elon Musks Reversal on Taking Tesla Private
The startling reversal — announced late Friday in a blog post, a day after he discussed it with directors — capped a tumultuous series of moves that drew in Wall Street’s biggest investment banks, prompted an investigation by regulators and raised fresh questions about Mr. Musk’s leadership.
In that time, according to five people close to the events, Mr. Musk came to realize that his thinking had been overly simplistic. While going private might have removed some problems, it would have introduced new ones.
Among his concerns were ceding too much control to private investors — including conventional car companies and Saudi Arabia, a symbol of big oil — and shutting out smaller investors who might be unable to retain a stake.
Those were issues both symbolic and substantive for Tesla, which has staked its future on making electric vehicles the transportation of choice — a vision that has made it the nation’s most highly valued car company. Even with its shares worth $55 billion, it faces concerns common to many young companies, including its vulnerability to the whims of public shareholders.
For his part, Mr. Musk has come under new scrutiny as his impulsiveness has played out in real time in the stock market, with billions of dollars on the line.
And even with the decision to stand pat, Mr. Musk and the company could remain in the sights of the Securities and Exchange Commission over the circumstances of the original announcement.
“Tesla investors must realize that they have a panicky, erratic, possibly self-destructive C.E.O. at the helm,” said Jeffrey Sonnenfeld, a professor at the Yale School of Management. “No C.E.O. is ever this confused and confusing.”
For years, Mr. Musk had romanticized the idea of Tesla going private. Doing so, he has mused publicly, would free him from the short-term pressures of the public markets, unburden him of the distractions of a volatile stock price and, more recently, get rid of the short sellers betting that Tesla would fail. Instead, Mr. Musk believed he could focus on Tesla’s work of popularizing electric vehicles and reducing the world’s dependence on fossil fuels.
But from the moment of his nine-word Twitter posting announcing his thoughts on Aug. 7 and saying that he had “funding secured,” other considerations came into play.
In his note announcing that Tesla would remain public, Mr. Musk cited four main factors that changed his mind: existing shareholders believe Tesla is better off as a public company; not all existing investors would be able to own shares of a private company; it wasn’t clear how individual investors would take part in a deal; and the process could distract the company from production of its first mass-market offering, the Model 3, which is crucial to its financial health.
By the account of people familiar with Mr. Musk’s thinking, deepening ties with new private investors presented its own challenges. By taking money from Saudi Arabia’s sovereign wealth fund — something Mr. Musk said he believed was a sure thing — Tesla would have been teaming up with a country whose very foundation is fossil fuels, and one often criticized on human-rights grounds.
That cognitive dissonance — an electric-car company backed by big oil — was pointed out to Mr. Musk several times, these people said.
As Tesla representatives reached out to officials at the Saudi fund and other sovereign funds, it also became clear that they might want more than just Tesla equity in exchange for an investment. Some, said someone briefed on those talks, would expect Tesla to open manufacturing operations in their countries, for example.
And while several big carmakers approached Tesla about funding a deal, people familiar with the discussions said, there were issues there, too. Some of those companies have their own reputational baggage. And Mr. Musk, proud that Tesla’s cars are made in America, did not want to let foreign interests dictate his decisions about manufacturing.
Inside Elon Musks Reversal on Taking Tesla Private
At the same time, it became clear that not all of Tesla’s big institutional shareholders would have been able to take part in a buyout. Many big investors hold Tesla stock in funds that can only own publicly traded stocks.
“On the whole, some of our clients will find it very difficult to follow,” James Anderson, a partner at Baillie Gifford, which is Tesla’s largest shareholder after Mr. Musk, said in an interview before Mr. Musk called off a deal. “We’ve had this conversation with Mr. Musk himself. He understands that there is an issue here.”
The same was probably true for other institutional investors in Tesla, including T. Rowe Price, BlackRock and Fidelity. And Mr. Musk heard from many individual investors who wanted Tesla to stay public. On Thursday, a small Tesla investor released a public letter imploring Mr. Musk to keep Tesla public.
Those pleas were notable because many individual investors are not able to invest in private companies for regulatory reasons.
On Thursday morning, Elon Musk and Tesla’s board gathered for a meeting on the factory floor of the company’s manufacturing plant in Fremont, Calif., people with knowledge of the events said. They were joined by representatives from the investment bank Goldman Sachs and the private equity firm Silver Lake, which were advising on a deal.
After a Silver Lake representative made a presentation expressing confidence in their ability to manage the process of taking Tesla private — a transaction that could have required $24 billion or more — the Wall Street representatives left the room, and the floor was given to Mr. Musk.
But instead of telling his board just how far he’d come in securing new investors for a potential deal, Mr. Musk backtracked: He no longer believed going private was in the best interest of the company, and he would not be bringing forward a proposal to buy out the company.
Doing so would be too distracting, big institutional investors could not all take part and there was no easy path for retail shareholders to be involved, he told the board.
The directors — some of whom have expressed concern about Mr. Musk’s use of Twitter and erratic behavior — were supportive.
During the meeting, the board voted to dissolve the special committee established to evaluate a potential deal. And before lunchtime, the meeting — held in the same room where Mr. Musk sometimes sleeps during late nights at the factory — was over.
Later that day, Mr. Musk drafted a statement announcing that Tesla would remain public, which the board approved Thursday night. On Friday, working from the office of SpaceX, his private rocket company, based near Los Angeles, Mr. Musk and his team refined the letter.
In the statement, even while retreating from the idea of going private, Mr. Musk doubled down on his original assertion that he had the financial backing. “My belief that there is more than enough funding to take Tesla private was reinforced during this process,” he said.
Still, the S.E.C., which is investigating whether Mr. Musk’s original tweet about a potential buyout violated securities law, may have more to say about the sequence of events — particularly the “funding secured” declaration. The initial tweet sent Tesla’s stock soaring and caused a halt in trading pending a fuller announcement. The stock tapered off in ensuing weeks and never came close to the $420 buyout price that Mr. Musk had said was in prospect, indicating investor skepticism.
“In a sense it lessens the impact of the initial tweet,” Peter Henning, professor of law at Wayne State University, said of the reversal. “But the S.E.C. looks at what happens at the time of the disclosure. Walking it back later doesn’t necessary mitigate the effect. And it was clearly incomplete.”
“You can’t throw out information that moves the market and say, ‘Never mind,’” Mr. Henning added. “This is the C.E.O. of the company. His statements are the company’s statements. Will they make an example of him? Maybe.”
And while Mr. Musk may have appeased some constituencies, management experts were left shaking their heads at the chaotic process, which began with a tweet as Mr. Musk drove his Tesla Model S through Los Angeles just over two weeks ago.
“A major enterprise should not navigate its ownership path and market valuation through the frantic, public, volatile impulses of the C.E.O.,” Mr. Sonnenfeld said. “Let alone through the selective disclosures of elite shareholder referenda.”
Related Stories
Latest News
Top news around the world
Coronavirus Disease

Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) is an infectious disease caused by a newly discovered coronavirus.

Most people infected with the COVID-19 virus will experience mild to moderate respiratory illness and recover without requiring special treatment. Older people, and those with underlying medical problems like cardiovascular disease, diabetes, chronic respiratory disease, and cancer are more likely to develop serious illness.

Around the World

Celebrity News

> Latest News in Media

Watch It
Carrie's ACM Foul, "RHOBH" WTF Moments & Lori's Prison Perks
September 18, 2020
f3KwHPyBFSI
"Cheer" Star Jerry Harris Arrested for Child Pornography | E! News
September 17, 2020
bVnmbrwqmTE
Vanessa Hudgens Celebrates Ashley Tisdale's Pregnancy | E! News
September 17, 2020
WPQFWYio1Ao
Television Humanitarian Awards Virtual Gala - The Creative Coalition
September 16, 2020
wSGcqa7Jvus
How the 'Antebellum' Team Used Horror to Present Racial Injustice
September 16, 2020
c0zWheU3sIU
'Ratched' Star Cynthia Nixon on Queer Couple Representation, Her Thoughts on J.K. Rowling
September 15, 2020
8yjq_Ohi94c
Trump Star Vandal James Otis Drops Anti-Trump Flyers from Empire State Building
September 17, 2020
C1oQ7xzFFeI
Kroy Biermann Claps Back at Trolls Over Pic of Brielle Sitting On His Lap | TMZ
September 17, 2020
OUieGQfmR8w
What's In Jimmy Fallon's Briefcase? | TMZ TV
September 17, 2020
_qQfHmucGpk
Brad Pitt and Jennifer Aniston get flirty during ‘Fast Times’ read | Page Six Celebrity News
September 18, 2020
9zVukSXgXx8
‘Cheer’ coach Monica Aldama breaks silence on Jerry Harris’ arrest | Page Six Celebrity News
September 18, 2020
ic8vKVuiAqY
Euphoria cast lights up the red carpet | Page Six Celebrity News
September 18, 2020
EGgz-2keTXw
TV Schedule
Late Night Show
Watch the latest shows of U.S. top comedians

Sports

Latest sport results, news, videos, interviews and comments
Latest Events
18
Sep
PERU: Primera Division, Apertura
Universitario - Inti Gas Ayacucho
18
Sep
PARAGUAY: Apertura
12 de Octubre - Sol de America
18
Sep
ENGLAND: Championship
Coventry - QPR
18
Sep
PERU: Primera Division, Apertura
Melgar - Univ. San Martin
18
Sep
CHINA: FA Cup
Shandong Luneng - Dalian Yifang
18
Sep
CHINA: FA Cup
Guangzhou Evergrande - Henan Jianye
18
Sep
PORTUGAL: Primeira Liga
Guimaraes - Belenenses
18
Sep
ROMANIA: Liga 1
Astra - Cluj
18
Sep
URUGUAY: Segunda Division
Atenas - Villa Teresa
18
Sep
URUGUAY: Segunda Division
Villa Espanola - Juventud
18
Sep
ASIAN CHAMPIONS LEAGUE: Group Stage
Al Taawon - Persepolis
18
Sep
ASIAN CHAMPIONS LEAGUE: Group Stage
Al Nasr Riyadh - Sepahan
18
Sep
PERU: Primera Division, Apertura
Deportivo Binacional - Dep. Llacuabamaba
18
Sep
POLAND: Ekstraklasa
Wisla Krakow - Wisla Plock
18
Sep
GREECE: Super League 1
PAOK - Atromitos
18
Sep
RUSSIA: Premier League
FK Krasnodar - Khimki
18
Sep
PORTUGAL: Primeira Liga
Famalicao - Benfica
18
Sep
CROATIA: 1 HNL
Sibenik - Lokomotiva Zagreb
18
Sep
UKRAINE: Premier League
Dnipro - Mariupol
18
Sep
SERBIA: Super Liga
Vojvodina - Radnik Surdulica
18
Sep
POLAND: Ekstraklasa
Podbeskidzie - Rakow
18
Sep
ASIAN CHAMPIONS LEAGUE: Group Stage
Al Sadd SC Doha - Al Ain
18
Sep
CYPRUS: 1. Division
Ermis Aradippou - Olympiakos Nicosia
18
Sep
ENGLAND: Premier League 2, Divison 2
Leeds U-23 - Wolves U-23
18
Sep
ARMENIA: National Cup
Urartu - Pyunik
18
Sep
ROMANIA: Liga 1
Chindia Targoviste - Hermannstadt
18
Sep
BELARUS: Premier League
Neman - FC Minsk
18
Sep
KAZAKHSTAN: Premier League
Okzhepes - Kaspyi
18
Sep
POLAND: I Liga
Arka Gdynia - Miedz Legnica
18
Sep
MOLDOVA: Divizia Nationala
Floresti - Dinamo-Auto
18
Sep
URUGUAY: Segunda Division
Albion - Cerrito
18
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Sevilla - Athletic Bilbao
18
Sep
BELARUS: Premier League
Smolevichi-STI - Ruh Brest
18
Sep
UKRAINE: Youth League
Oleksandria U-21 - Vorskla U-21
18
Sep
ARMENIA: National Cup
West Armenia - Gandzasar-Kapan
18
Sep
ARMENIA: National Cup
Van - Noravank
17
Sep
EUROPA LEAGUE: Second qualifying round
Shamrock - AC Milan
16
Sep
FRANCE: Ligue 1
PSG - Metz
16
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Barcelona - Girona
15
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Inter Milan - Lugano
14
Sep
ENGLAND: Premier League
Brighton - Chelsea
14
Sep
GERMANY: National cup
Duisburg - Borussia Dortmund
13
Sep
ENGLAND: Premier League
Tottenham Hotspur - Everton
13
Sep
FRANCE: Ligue 1
PSG - Marseille
13
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Juventus - Novara
12
Sep
ENGLAND: Premier League
Liverpool - Leeds
12
Sep
ENGLAND: Premier League
Fulham - Arsenal
10
Sep
FRANCE: Ligue 1
Lens - PSG
09
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Frosinone - Roma
09
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
AC Milan - Vicenza
07
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Borussia Dortmund - Sparta Rotterdam
06
Sep
UEFA NATIONS LEAGUE A: Group Stage
Switzerland - Germany
05
Sep
UEFA NATIONS LEAGUE A: Group Stage
Sweden - France
05
Sep
UEFA NATIONS LEAGUE A: Group Stage
Iceland - England
05
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
AC Milan - Monza
05
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Roma - Sambenedettese
05
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Watford - Tottenham Hotspur
03
Sep
UEFA NATIONS LEAGUE A: Group Stage
Germany - Spain
02
Sep
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
AC Milan - Novara
29
Aug
ENGLAND: FA Community Shield
Arsenal - Liverpool
29
Aug
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Brighton - Chelsea
29
Aug
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Tottenham Hotspur - Birmingham
28
Aug
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Tottenham Hotspur - Reading
28
Aug
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Borussia Dortmund - Bochum
28
Aug
INTERNATIONAL: Club Friendlies
Borussia Dortmund - Paderborn
Find us on Instagram
at @feedimo to stay up to date with the latest.
Featured Video You Might Like
i1XRgbyUtOo -g9Qziqbif8 0vmRhiLHE2U JFCZUoa6MYE UfN5PCF5EUo 2PV55f3-UAg W3y9zuI_F64 -7qCxIccihU pQ9gcOoH9R8 g5MRDEXRk4k tudKp5Vhs3k iwWHibhssSo
Copyright © 2020 Feedimo. All Rights Reserved.