Close
Date TimeAugust 09, 2018
VoiceThere are multiple reasons that supporters of President Trump latched on to his campaign. But one of the more controversial ones was “cultural anxiety.”
Laura Ingrahams demographic changes monologue is a rallying cry to Trumps base
A post-2016 election survey by the Public Religion Research Institute and the Atlantic found that beyond partisan affiliation, “cultural anxiety — feeling like a stranger in America, supporting the deportation of immigrants, and hesitating about educational investment” — was the best predictor for support for Trump.
Many Trump supporters have since rebuffed the suggestion that they were drawn to Trump because he called Mexicans “rapists” and criminals the day he announced his campaign and promised to build a wall along the U.S.-Mexico border to keep immigrants from entering. But since then, other Trump supporters have been more willing to vocalize the “cultural anxiety” that the groups most willing to vote for Trump found themselves experiencing at the end of the Obama presidency. And the latest to do so was Fox News host Laura Ingraham.
While reacting to a podcast interview in which New York congressional candidate Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, a democratic socialist, lamented how much the United States had changed for the middle and working classes, Ingraham spoke of the changes in the country that she and her viewers found disappointing.
She said:
In some parts of the country, it does seem like the America we know and love doesn’t exist anymore. Massive demographic changes have been foisted upon the American people. And they’re changes that none of us ever voted for and most of us don’t like. From Virginia to California, we see stark examples of how radically in some ways the country has changed. Now much of this is related to both illegal, and in some cases, legal immigration that, of course, progressives love.
Ingraham was speaking in general terms about what Americans believe and want, which is troublesome because most Americans do not feel the way she claims they do. Most Americans — three-quarters — say immigration is a good thing. But the “we” Ingraham was referring to was her viewers — who are more likely to be from groups that still give Trump high approval ratings: Republicans; whites; baby boomers; older, evangelical Christians; working-class and rural Americans.
And she’s right.
The Washington Post previously reported findings from a Post-Kaiser Family Foundation poll:
In response to this poll question — “Which of these do you think is the bigger problem in this country: blacks and Hispanics losing out because of preferences for whites, or whites losing out because of preferences for blacks and Hispanics?” — rural whites are 14 points less likely than urban whites to say they are more concerned about blacks and Hispanics losing out.
And according to a 2017 Atlantic/PRRI survey:
Nearly two-thirds, or 65 percent, of white, working-class Americans believe U.S. culture and way of life has deteriorated since the 1950s.
Nearly half, 48 percent, of white, working-class Americans say that “things have changed so much that I often feel like a stranger in my own country.”
More than 6 in 10, or 62 percent, of white, working-class Americans believe the growing number of newcomers from other countries threatens American culture, while 3 in 10, or 30 percent, say these newcomers strengthen society.
And a recent Pew Research Center survey revealed that no group supports the idea that the United States has a responsibility to accept refugees less than white evangelical Protestants. Only 25 percent of the reliably Republican group says that the United States has a responsibility to welcome those fleeing persecution in other countries.
As some analysts predict a “blue wave” in the upcoming midterm elections, Ingraham’s words can be interpreted as a rallying cry to Trump’s base. Americans looking to elect lawmakers who would advance Trump’s vision of the United States still retain significant influence, although their share of the national population has declined in the past few decades. And their likelihood to vote — especially in midterm elections — remains higher than that of the groups they fear are replacing them, making their worries unfounded to some.
So while Ingraham and her viewers may be anxious about how the nation’s demographics are changing, as long as they are more likely to show up to the polls than the groups they fear, the United States' move away from the period when most Trump supporters concluded the country was “great” is a quite a ways off.

Related Stories
Rep. Ilhan Omar faces backlash over AIPAC commentsRep. Ilhan Omar faces backlash over AIPAC comments
When, where and how to watch President Donald Trumps 2019 State of the Union addressWhen, where and how to watch President Donald Trump's 2019 State of the Union address
2 Indian-American women oppose nomination of Neomi Rao2 Indian-American women oppose nomination of Neomi Rao
Jared Kushners team responds to report Trump ordered security clearance for son-in-lawJared Kushner's team responds to report Trump 'ordered' security clearance for son-in-law
Next to testify on hush-money payments: Sean Hannity?Next to testify on hush-money payments: Sean Hannity?
Shocking interview surfaces of Fox News host Tucker Carlson praising ‘young girls sexually experimenting’Shocking interview surfaces of Fox News host Tucker Carlson praising ‘young girls sexually experimenting’
Former White House lawyer Ty Cobb defends American hero Robert Mueller, says investigation not a witch huntFormer White House lawyer Ty Cobb defends 'American hero' Robert Mueller, says investigation not a 'witch hunt'
Trump to make $8.6 billion wall demand, triggering new standoff with CongressTrump to make $8.6 billion wall demand, triggering new standoff with Congress
News Trends
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle Honor New Zealand Shooting VictimsPrince Harry and Meghan Markle Honor New Zealand Shooting Victims
Mike Trout and LA Angels close to $430m deal, largest in sports historyMike Trout and LA Angels close to $430m deal, largest in sports history
Donald Trump suggests Brazil could join Nato as he meets Jair BolsonaroDonald Trump suggests Brazil could join Nato as he meets Jair Bolsonaro
Here’s how you’ll access Google’s Stadia cloud gaming serviceHere’s how you’ll access Google’s Stadia cloud gaming service
Will Jennifer Lopez Use a Cheating Clause in Her Prenup With Alex Rodriguez?Will Jennifer Lopez Use a Cheating Clause in Her Prenup With Alex Rodriguez?
Chelsea Clinton Apologizes To Students Who Blame Her For NZ AttackChelsea Clinton Apologizes To Students Who Blame Her For NZ Attack
Australian Senator Fraser Anning punches teen after being eggedAustralian Senator Fraser Anning punches teen after being egged
Lewis Hamilton responds to Valtteri Bottas message after Australian GP battleLewis Hamilton responds to Valtteri Bottas message after Australian GP battle
Taylor Swift debuts pink hair at iHeartRadio Music AwardsTaylor Swift debuts pink hair at iHeartRadio Music Awards
Glastonbury 2019 Line-Up Announced With The Killers And The Cure Joining Stormzy As HeadlinersGlastonbury 2019 Line-Up Announced With The Killers And The Cure Joining Stormzy As Headliners
Celebrities
Miley-CyrusMiley Cyrus
American singer-songwriter
Jay_ZJay-Z
American rapper
Justin-BieberJustin Bieber
Canadian singer-songwriter
Ellen-DeGeneresEllen DeGeneres
American comedian
Jennifer-LopezJennifer Lopez
American singer
Oprah-WinfreyOprah Winfrey
American executive
Kylie-JennerKylie Jenner
American television personality
Stephen-ColbertStephen Colbert
American comedian
MadonnaMadonna
American singer-songwriter
BeyoncéBeyoncé
American singer-songwriter
Related Stories
Rep. Ilhan Omar faces backlash over AIPAC commentsRep. Ilhan Omar faces backlash over AIPAC comments
When, where and how to watch President Donald Trumps 2019 State of the Union addressWhen, where and how to watch President Donald Trump's 2019 State of the Union address
2 Indian-American women oppose nomination of Neomi Rao2 Indian-American women oppose nomination of Neomi Rao
Jared Kushners team responds to report Trump ordered security clearance for son-in-lawJared Kushner's team responds to report Trump 'ordered' security clearance for son-in-law
Next to testify on hush-money payments: Sean Hannity?Next to testify on hush-money payments: Sean Hannity?
Shocking interview surfaces of Fox News host Tucker Carlson praising ‘young girls sexually experimenting’Shocking interview surfaces of Fox News host Tucker Carlson praising ‘young girls sexually experimenting’
Former White House lawyer Ty Cobb defends American hero Robert Mueller, says investigation not a witch huntFormer White House lawyer Ty Cobb defends 'American hero' Robert Mueller, says investigation not a 'witch hunt'
Trump to make $8.6 billion wall demand, triggering new standoff with CongressTrump to make $8.6 billion wall demand, triggering new standoff with Congress
News Trends
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle Honor New Zealand Shooting VictimsPrince Harry and Meghan Markle Honor New Zealand Shooting Victims
Mike Trout and LA Angels close to $430m deal, largest in sports historyMike Trout and LA Angels close to $430m deal, largest in sports history
Donald Trump suggests Brazil could join Nato as he meets Jair BolsonaroDonald Trump suggests Brazil could join Nato as he meets Jair Bolsonaro
Here’s how you’ll access Google’s Stadia cloud gaming serviceHere’s how you’ll access Google’s Stadia cloud gaming service
Will Jennifer Lopez Use a Cheating Clause in Her Prenup With Alex Rodriguez?Will Jennifer Lopez Use a Cheating Clause in Her Prenup With Alex Rodriguez?
Chelsea Clinton Apologizes To Students Who Blame Her For NZ AttackChelsea Clinton Apologizes To Students Who Blame Her For NZ Attack
Australian Senator Fraser Anning punches teen after being eggedAustralian Senator Fraser Anning punches teen after being egged
Lewis Hamilton responds to Valtteri Bottas message after Australian GP battleLewis Hamilton responds to Valtteri Bottas message after Australian GP battle
Taylor Swift debuts pink hair at iHeartRadio Music AwardsTaylor Swift debuts pink hair at iHeartRadio Music Awards
Glastonbury 2019 Line-Up Announced With The Killers And The Cure Joining Stormzy As HeadlinersGlastonbury 2019 Line-Up Announced With The Killers And The Cure Joining Stormzy As Headliners
Celebrities
Miley-CyrusMiley Cyrus
American singer-songwriter
Jay_ZJay-Z
American rapper
Justin-BieberJustin Bieber
Canadian singer-songwriter
Ellen-DeGeneresEllen DeGeneres
American comedian
Jennifer-LopezJennifer Lopez
American singer
Oprah-WinfreyOprah Winfrey
American executive
Kylie-JennerKylie Jenner
American television personality
Stephen-ColbertStephen Colbert
American comedian
MadonnaMadonna
American singer-songwriter
BeyoncéBeyoncé
American singer-songwriter
Mike Pence launches plans for Space Force as new military service
Nasa's daring mission to 'touch the sun' explained
From Rihanna's eyebrows to slip dresses: should we embrace the 90s revival?
Interest rates will stay low for 20 years – Bank of England expert
Samsung set to unveil next flagship Note smartphone
Emilia Clarke boyfriend: Is the Game of Thrones star single? Who has she dated?
Cristiano Ronaldo: Juventus star’s girlfriend Georgina Rodriguez nearly spills out of top
Egypt's second sphinx FOUND: Ancient statue discovered during ROAD WORKS
You know aging in Hollywood is rough when Leonardo DiCaprio and Brad Pitt get Photoshopped
Weird, 570-Million-Year-Old 'Leaf' Fossil Is Actually from an Animal
Melania Trump's parents are now US citizens
Assange 'considering' testifying in Russia meddling probe
Lombok earthquake: new quake hits as death toll from earlier tremor tops 300
Police warn Drake fans against doing 'Shiggy' dance on road
Chelsea announce agreement to sign Mateo Kovacic on season-long loan
Carrie Underwood is pregnant, tells fans she is 'over the moon'
Professional golfer Jarrod Lyle dies at age 36 after battling leukemia
Tweet threatens to ‘waste’ everyone at town hall event for Devin Nunes’ opponent
Prince William and Theresa May join ex-soldiers to celebrate Battle of Amiens which signalled beginning of end of WW1
Argentina holds historic abortion vote as 1m women rally to demand change
US confirms Russia DID order Salisbury nerve agent attack and promise REVENGE sanctions
Gaining control of Portugal wildfire will take days, prime minister says
Brad Pitt says he loaned $8 million to Angelina Jolie, paid $1.3 million in child support
NASA's newest spacecraft will fly through the Sun's scorching hot atmosphere
Chelsea sets $91m record for goalkeeper
'Dear Ivanka': Celebrities target Trump's daughter on Instagram
Indonesian earthquake: Death toll rises to 347 after powerful jolt to resort island
Oscars: Academy to add achievement in popular film category
CW Network Casts Ruby Rose as Lesbian Batwoman
From Kong to Kirby: Smash Bros' Masahiro Sakurai on mashing up 35 years of gaming history
GOP Rep. Chris Collins charged with insider trading
Tlaib wins Conyers' seat; Congress to get 1st Muslim woman
Kim, Khloé shade Younes Bendjima after breakup with Kourtney
Key takeaways from Ohio special election and primaries in four other states
Kansas GOP governor primary too close to call; Kobach, Colyer send supporters home
Jarvis Landry delivers epic speech in season premiere of HBO's 'Hard Knocks' with Browns
Manchester United turn down Barcelona offer for Paul Pogba
International Cat Day: 15 facts about moggies
Indian political icon Muthuvel Karunanidhi dies at 94
Dina Asher-Smith and Zharnel Hughes storm to 100m Euro gold
Blackhawks legend, Hockey Hall of Famer Stan Mikita dies at 78
Theresa May calls on Boris Johnson to say sorry for burqa remarks
Elon Musk Might Take Tesla Private in a Move That Values the Company at $82 Billion
'Bachelorette' Becca Kufrin Explains Why Arie Luyendyk Jr. Was Cut From Finale (Exclusive)
Shaun Weiss: 5 Things To Know About 'The Mighty Ducks' Star, 39, Who Was Arrested
Wilbur Ross alleged to have siphoned more than $120 million from associates, Forbes reports
Kathleen Turner discusses Trump's 'gross' handshake, Elizabeth Taylor's 'awful' voice in tell-all interview
Chelsea to pay £71.6m for Athletic Bilbao goalkeeper Kepa Arrizabalaga
Ruby Rose cast as The CW's Batwoman
Ohio special election, Different point of view
Google honours Muslim philosopher Ibn Sina
Margot Robbie's scary good Sharon Tate transformation for 'Once Upon a Time in Hollywood'
Britney Spears will keep her fans dancing 'til the world ends - Brighton Pride review
Man City transfer news LIVE Pep Guardiola's hunt for midfielder and latest on Joe Hart's Burnley transfer
Trabuco Canyon brush fire: Fast-moving blaze burns 4000 acres, prompts evacuations
Don’t you dare let Paul Pogba leave, Rio Ferdinand tells United
Diamondbacks OF David Peralta's shoulder injury not a major concern
Later this year, a SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket will launch its biggest batch of satellites yet
Director of Trayvon Martin documentary says teen’s shooting was ‘turning point’ for U.S
Bachelorette Becca Kufrin picks her man and Bachelor Nation does not approve
Sweep of Yankees shows Red Sox can do 'damage,' too
Hothouse Earth: Runaway global warming threatens 'habitability of the planet for humans'
Stan Kroenke makes £600m offer to buy ‘100% ownership’ of Arsenal
Robert Redford confirms retirement from acting
Bernard to have Everton medical with club set to win battle for Brazil winger
Facebook, Apple, YouTube and Spotify ban Infowars' Alex Jones
Paul Manafort's 'right-hand man' Rick Gates to testify in fraud trial
Actress Charlotte Rae dies
Beyoncé reveals she is 'descended from a slaveowner'
Indonesia earthquake: Lombok hit by SECOND earthquake today - Bali rattled
SpaceX set to re-fly first Falcon 9 Block 5 booster Tuesday
Facebook to Banks: Give Us Your Data, We'll Give You Our Users
NFL's first male dancers will hit the sidelines this season
Trump re-imposes Iran sanctions 'to change, not topple Tehran'
Bologna EXPLOSION: Massive fireball rockets into sky near Italy airport – shock footage
Tiger Woods moves on to PGA Championship as Justin Thomas wins Bridgestone by four shots
Liz Peek: Obama stiffs Ocasio-Cortez as Democrats weigh whether she hurts or helps them in November
Hiroshima marks 73rd anniversary of atomic bombing in World War II
Apple removes podcasts by Infowars' Alex Jones
Man charged with murder of midwife Samantha Eastwood
France LOSES OUT on Brexit billions: Belgian and Dutch ports picked for new Irish route
Police chief orders use of force review after Portland protest
Saudis expel Canadian envoy, freeze new trade deals over tweets about rights activist
14 hours in Chicago: 44 shot, 5 killed
At least 317 killed in ongoing protests in Nicaragua
Hundreds crowd beach, await rescue after massive quake in Indonesia
Theresa May confident of reaching Brexit deal, sources say
Sublime Manchester City sweep Chelsea aside to lift Community Shield
Lady Gaga apologizes for calling Rick 'Zombie Boy' Genest's death a suicide
Hall wins Women's British Open for 1st major title
Kellyanne Conway: 'I don't believe journalists are the enemy of the people'
Patrick Stewart stuns fans with 'Star Trek' return
Radio telescope picks up new frequency in space
Old-time plane crashes in Swiss Alps, killing 20 on board
6.9-magnitude quake hits Indonesia
'The Americans' Wins Big at TV Critics Awards
Entertainer Barry Chuckle dies at 73
A flat tire started the deadly Carr Fire and days of devastation in California
UFC 227: TJ Dillashaw reveals strategy for second Garbrandt KO, declares himself BW GOAT
Randy Moss wears tie during Hall of Fame speech as tribute to slain African-Americans
Emilia Clarke: Game Of Thrones star flashes the flesh as she gives fans insight into break
Man Utd boss Jose Mourinho plots £80m deadline-busting raid for Harry Maguire
Trump may want a ‘Space Force’ but the Pentagon has a different idea
Venezuela's Maduro: Drone attack was attempt to kill him
Convicted child rapist escapes from Kansas prison three days after arrival
Melania Trump contradicts her husband on LeBron James
Meghan Markle dazzles in navy as she arrives for wedding of Prince Harry's close friend
18 killed after Russian helicopter crashes in Siberia, airline says
Urban Meyer says he knew about and reported 2015 incident of alleged abuse by assistant
Astronomers discover a free-range planet with incredible magnetism
Facebook Dating will be a feature, not an app; here's a peek
Barack Obama Day: Former president's political home state of Illinois kicks off holiday
Mission Possible: How To Hike Pulpit Rock Like Tom Cruise Onscreen
Cristiano Ronaldo: Juventus star thought Real Madrid exit was humiliating for one reason
Weekend Box Office: 'Mission: Impossible 6' Making More Honey Than 'Christopher Robin'
Europe's record temperature of 48C could be beaten this weekend
First woman fined in Denmark for wearing full-face veil
President Trump bashes LeBron James over CNN interview: Don Lemon made him 'look smart'
Melania Trump shows of incredible figure in tight white jeans with husband Donald
'Zombie Boy' Rick Genest, tattooed muse to Lady Gaga, dies aged 32
More than 100 goats invade Boise neighbourhood, chew on everything they could find
May and Macron hold 'informal' Brexit talks in France
These 9 Astronauts Will Fly the 1st Flights on SpaceX and Boeing Spaceships
Judge Denies Larry Nassar’s Appeal For New Sentence
Ella Mai: ‘If it were up to England, Boo’d Up definitely wouldn’t be where it is now’
Travis Scott will drop new album this week
Barcelona complete signing of Arturo Vidal for £27m from Bayern Munich
My son, Osama: the al-Qaida leader’s mother speaks for the first time
Donald Trump hits back at criticism: 'DISGUSTING! I was EARLY and waiting for the QUEEN!'
Boeing and SpaceX delay first crucial test flights of new passenger spacecraft again
Colbert Mocks Paul Manafort’s Wardrobe: Looks Like ‘A Blind Pimp Got 100 Wishes’
Black pastors see Trump bringing 'new hope' -- but still need to convince their flocks
395 people sickened in McDonald's salad outbreak
Suspected Russian spy caught working inside US embassy in Moscow
Urban Meyer placed on leave as Ohio State investigates what he knew about alleged abuse
Virat Kohli’s brilliant century frustrates England in India fightback
Trump received letter from North Korea's Kim on August 1: White House
Ivanka Trump: Migrant separations a ‘low point’ and journalists are not ‘enemy of the people’
May prepares for talks with Macron that could make or break Brexit plan
Stonehenge mystery SOLVED: Who built Stonehenge? Latest study on stone formation REVEALED
Naomi Campbell, 48, stuns in two bikini photos, shuts down pregnancy rumors
Iran deploys 50 small boats to Strait of Hormuz for large-scale 'swarming' exercise
Thousands march in Jerusalem Gay Pride amid surrogacy uproar
Elon Musk Shares Image of Reusable Falcon 9 Blazing a Trail in the Night
Kim Kardashian Disses Kourtney As 'Least Exciting To Look At' In Brutal Fight
Papa John's founder says he has 'no confidence' in current management team, including CEO Steve Ritchie
Apple is now worth $1,000,000,000,000
There's a very simple reason Trump wants to sit down with Mueller
NASA says we can't terraform Mars. Elon Musk disagrees
Giant hands lift new Vietnam bridge toward heavens
Bank of England poised to raise interest rates
Mount Olympus: Google doodle celebrates Greece's Mount Olympus and its heroic climbers
BREXIT LIVE: Remainers turn AGAINST EU and warn 'don't offer May Brexit FUDGE'
Life Needs Sunlight — and That Could Change Where We Look for Aliens
Reddit hacked, despite SMS two-factor authentication
Tesla Doubles Loss, but Burns Less Cash Than Expected
Colbert Finds A Way He Could Actually Vote For Trump
Madonna Reveals She Fled To Portugal To Escape Trump
US threatens raising tariffs to 25% on $200 billion of Chinese goods
Ex-wife of Ohio State assistant fired for abuse says Urban Meyer knew of case
Protests in Denmark as 'burqa ban' comes into effect
Manafort put himself 'above the law' to fund his expensive tastes, court hears
LONDON BLOODBATH: One man dead and two injured after triple stabbing in Camberwell
3 Russian journalists killed while filming documentary on private Russian security group in Africa
Bermuda Triangle mystery 'solved,' scientists claim
If We Ever Want to Walk on Mars, We'd Better Get Serious About Planetary Protection
Mother of missing Iowa college student recounts last text she sent to daughter
Former President Obama Endorses 81 Candidates For Midterms
Tiffany Haddish Says She Was Raped By A Police Cadet When She Was 17
‘Friends’ Cast Had An Adorable Backstage Ritual When Lisa Kudrow Was Pregnant
US sanctions 2 Turkish officials over detention of US pastor
What to Know About Gerda Taro, the War Photographer Celebrated By Today’s Google Doodle
Tommy Robinson freed on bail as court orders retrial
Trump pushes Jeff Sessions to end Mueller's Russia investigation 'right now'
Meghan Markle so ‘DEEPLY HURT’ by father Thomas Markle the Queen might get involved
NBA trade news: Lakers told Kawhi Leonard move failed because of LeBron James
Mexico plane crash: 103 people onboard but all survived, say officials
‘Not good, not nice’: At Florida rally, Trump says China has ‘targeted our farmers’
John Kelly says he will remain Donald Trump's chief of staff until 2020
Facebook removes accounts amid fears of Russian meddling in US midterms
Kevin Hart bans phones during Florida comedy performance
Mars Is At Its Closest to Earth Since 2003 Today! It Won't Be Closer Until 2287
Watch Obama and Biden surprise bakery staff
Kim Kardashian: 'I have nothing bad to say about the president'
France bans smartphones from schools
Guardians of the Galaxy cast signs open letter in support of James Gunn
Trump says he would meet with Iran without preconditions
Lady Amelia Windsor: Royal's 'most beautiful member' takes a dip on Ibiza beach
Glasgow fire: Huge blaze erupts at school - firefighters race to scene in Crookston Road
MH370 report says someone deliberately 'manipulated’ plane’s controls
Can We Terraform Mars to Make It Earth-Like? Not Anytime Soon, Study Suggests
IBM's blockchain app store wants to help banks cut costs
Video shows moment harasser slaps woman on streets of Paris
Dillian Whyte and Joseph Parker should have been a DRAW
'A fire tornado': death toll in massive California blaze rises to five
There May be Water on Mars but Don't Pack Your Bags Just Yet
Trump Again Threatens to Shut Down Government
Tour de France 2018: Geraint Thomas wins to make sporting history
Russia's navy parade: Big show without substance?
CEO of broadcast giant CBS Les Moonves investigated for sexual misconduct 
Close