Close
Date TimeJuly 14, 2018
VoiceIf you've just been perusing the science headlines this week, you might be under the impression NASA found evidence of life on Mars but accidentally destroyed it.
No, NASA did not find proof of life on Mars then accidentally destroy it
This is absolutely untrue.
To understand the real story, we have to briefly go back to 1976 when NASA's twin Viking landers arrived on the Red Planet and scooped up some Martian dirt. The soil was then heated in the landers' special ovens to allow for an on-board Gas Chromatograph Mass Spectrometer (GCMS) to detect any organic molecules within. To the surprise of many at the time, the results showed the samples appeared to be devoid of any such organics, which are often referred to as the building blocks of life.
It would be more than three decades until the Curiosity rover would finally confirm the presence of those important molecules on Mars. Just last month, we learned more about evidence of organics found by the rover in both the soil and atmosphere of the fourth planet.
Those most recent findings inspired a team of scientists to go back and check that old Viking data. They then published a paper in the Journal of Geophysical Research that suggests one explanation for why no organic molecules were found with Viking is because they were accidentally burned up in the ovens.
That's a very brief summary of the story.
And yet a number of headlines attached to stories covering the new research say NASA accidentally destroyed "evidence for life on Mars" or even worse: "proof of life on Mars."
To be clear: the building blocks of life and life itself are very, very different things. The building blocks of life are pretty widespread throughout the universe. In fact, they're flying around on comets right now. Does that mean there's life on comets? Not that we've seen. (If you've seen life on comets, firsthand -- not on YouTube -- please contact me.)
What's bizarre, but not totally surprising for the internet, is that if you click through these headlines and read the stories attached to them, many do a pretty good job drawing the distinction between inanimate organics that we know are on Mars and actual living, breathing, swimming things that they can support, but which we have yet to find on other worlds.
In the process, these stories completely contradict their own headlines. And unfortunately, we're all guilty of sometimes never reading beyond the headline, which is a real problem in this case.
I contacted the study's authors, including Chris McKay from NASA's Ames Research Center in California, and he told me he was also baffled by the editorial dissonance between the hyperbolic headlines and the relatively accurate stories beneath them.
"For example, we see organics in meteorites and they are not evidence of life. Not sure how the mistake got propagated. It is certainly not in our paper," McKay said.
Seems there's some confusion somewhere. To be clear, in chemistry "organic" does not mean something that comes from living plant or animal sources even though that is another definition of the word. Rather, an organic molecule typically refers to a carbon compound.
And while pretty much all life as we know it requires certain organic molecules to survive, it doesn't work in reverse. In other words, where ever there's life there's organic molecules, but that doesn't mean that wherever there's organic molecules there's life.
"I think it's interesting that life is mentioned in the title with no allusion to the life detection Viking did try to do," lead author Melissa Guzman told me via email.
There were experiments on Viking that looked for evidence of actual life, and through the decades Viking's principal investigator Gilbert Levin has suggested, including in peer-reviewed papers, that one of those experiments did find evidence of Martian microbes. This notion has been easily dismissed, however, by pointing to Viking's failure to find organic molecules on Mars.
"It was the lack of organics detected by the GCMS that made it impossible for scientists to imagine life was there," Guzman told me.
So the real story is not that NASA may have burned up evidence of life, but rather that it may have torched evidence of the prerequisites for life to exist, thereby negating another experiment, which may have really found indications of actual life.
This may seem like nitpicking, but it's a critical distinction and -- somewhat ironically -- the actual story is more encouraging for those hoping to find signs of Martian life.
Guzman says we may begin to get a more clear picture of what is really happening in Martian soil in just a few years, when the ExoMars 2020 rover will perform its own set of experiments looking for evidence of life.
Hope this clears things up, and perhaps most important: remember to always read past the headlines.

Related Stories
Hurricane Dorian: Catastrophic damage in Bahamas leaves 60,000 needing drinking waterHurricane Dorian: 'Catastrophic' damage in Bahamas leaves 60,000 needing drinking water
Trigger happy: the amazing rise of TwitchTrigger happy: the amazing rise of Twitch
Can shifting to a female-focused future overcome Terminator: Dark Fates bad buzz?Can shifting to a female-focused future overcome Terminator: Dark Fate's bad buzz?
Massage Therapist Who Accused Kevin Spacey of Groping DiesMassage Therapist Who Accused Kevin Spacey of Groping Dies
India Loses Contact With Spacecraft During Attempted Moon LandingIndia Loses Contact With Spacecraft During Attempted Moon Landing
Mark Ronson Hits Back At Lord Sugar After He Questions If Producer Has Any Real TalentMark Ronson Hits Back At Lord Sugar After He Questions If Producer Has Any 'Real Talent'
Stephen Colbert chides Trump for stealing his Colbert Report alligator-moat bit from ObamaStephen Colbert chides Trump for stealing his Colbert Report alligator-moat bit from Obama
Watch as India attempts a historic moon landing this afternoonWatch as India attempts a historic moon landing this afternoon
Chandrayaan-2: Indias second moon mission thought to have failed as scientists lose contact with landerChandrayaan-2: India's second moon mission thought to have failed as scientists lose contact with lander
India space agency loses communication with Moon-landing craftIndia space agency loses communication with Moon-landing craft
Latest News
Donald Trump Cancels Plan To Host G7 At His Golf ResortDonald Trump Cancels Plan To Host G7 At His Golf Resort
British Teenager, 15, Dies On School Exchange Trip In Spain After Falling From BalconyBritish Teenager, 15, Dies On School Exchange Trip In Spain After 'Falling From Balcony'
BBC leadership is in  crisis at a time of great danger | Emily BellBBC leadership is in crisis at a time of great danger | Emily Bell
How Catalan protest tactics are inspired by Hong KongHow Catalan protest tactics are inspired by Hong Kong
Let jihadists return home, French anti-terror magistrate urgesLet jihadists return home, French anti-terror magistrate urges
Trumps actions worse than Nixons - and Democrats must impeach him immediately, George Bushs former ethics lawyer warnsTrump's actions worse than Nixon's - and Democrats must impeach him immediately, George Bush's former ethics lawyer warns
Conquer The Terrain With A 1963 Volvo L3314 Laplander CamperConquer The Terrain With A 1963 Volvo L3314 Laplander Camper
South Africa to face Wales in semi-final after grinding down hosts JapanSouth Africa to face Wales in semi-final after grinding down hosts Japan
Haringey chairman says walk-off for alleged racism must be watershed momentHaringey chairman says walk-off for alleged racism must be watershed moment
Players protest unpaid wages by standing still in Mexican football match – videoPlayers protest unpaid wages by standing still in Mexican football match – video
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Boris-JohnsonBoris Johnson
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Theresa-MayTheresa May
Member of Parliament of the United Kingdom
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
Hurricane Dorian: Catastrophic damage in Bahamas leaves 60,000 needing drinking waterHurricane Dorian: 'Catastrophic' damage in Bahamas leaves 60,000 needing drinking water
Trigger happy: the amazing rise of TwitchTrigger happy: the amazing rise of Twitch
Can shifting to a female-focused future overcome Terminator: Dark Fates bad buzz?Can shifting to a female-focused future overcome Terminator: Dark Fate's bad buzz?
Massage Therapist Who Accused Kevin Spacey of Groping DiesMassage Therapist Who Accused Kevin Spacey of Groping Dies
India Loses Contact With Spacecraft During Attempted Moon LandingIndia Loses Contact With Spacecraft During Attempted Moon Landing
Mark Ronson Hits Back At Lord Sugar After He Questions If Producer Has Any Real TalentMark Ronson Hits Back At Lord Sugar After He Questions If Producer Has Any 'Real Talent'
Stephen Colbert chides Trump for stealing his Colbert Report alligator-moat bit from ObamaStephen Colbert chides Trump for stealing his Colbert Report alligator-moat bit from Obama
Watch as India attempts a historic moon landing this afternoonWatch as India attempts a historic moon landing this afternoon
Chandrayaan-2: Indias second moon mission thought to have failed as scientists lose contact with landerChandrayaan-2: India's second moon mission thought to have failed as scientists lose contact with lander
India space agency loses communication with Moon-landing craftIndia space agency loses communication with Moon-landing craft
Latest News
Donald Trump Cancels Plan To Host G7 At His Golf ResortDonald Trump Cancels Plan To Host G7 At His Golf Resort
British Teenager, 15, Dies On School Exchange Trip In Spain After Falling From BalconyBritish Teenager, 15, Dies On School Exchange Trip In Spain After 'Falling From Balcony'
BBC leadership is in  crisis at a time of great danger | Emily BellBBC leadership is in crisis at a time of great danger | Emily Bell
How Catalan protest tactics are inspired by Hong KongHow Catalan protest tactics are inspired by Hong Kong
Let jihadists return home, French anti-terror magistrate urgesLet jihadists return home, French anti-terror magistrate urges
Trumps actions worse than Nixons - and Democrats must impeach him immediately, George Bushs former ethics lawyer warnsTrump's actions worse than Nixon's - and Democrats must impeach him immediately, George Bush's former ethics lawyer warns
Conquer The Terrain With A 1963 Volvo L3314 Laplander CamperConquer The Terrain With A 1963 Volvo L3314 Laplander Camper
South Africa to face Wales in semi-final after grinding down hosts JapanSouth Africa to face Wales in semi-final after grinding down hosts Japan
Haringey chairman says walk-off for alleged racism must be watershed momentHaringey chairman says walk-off for alleged racism must be watershed moment
Players protest unpaid wages by standing still in Mexican football match – videoPlayers protest unpaid wages by standing still in Mexican football match – video
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Boris-JohnsonBoris Johnson
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Theresa-MayTheresa May
Member of Parliament of the United Kingdom
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Emmys: HBO’s ‘Game of Thrones’ Aims to Claim Creative Arts Crown
Belgium records best finish with victory over England
Donald Trump: I didn't criticise PM over Brexit. That is fake news
Stockport shooting: One in hospital, gunman on the run
Tens of thousands of protesters greet Trump in U.K. — along with giant baby balloon
Microsoft says it doesn’t work on ICE facial recognition and calls for regulation
Queen Elizabeth Meets With Trump And Melania
Justin Bieber and Katy Perry among Twitter users hit hardest by follower purge
12 Russians indicted in Mueller investigation
Investigation reopened in brutal slaying of Emmett Till
Antonio Conte sacked by Chelsea with Maurizio Sarri set to replace him
Serena Williams nears 8th Wimbledon title, 24th Slam overall
NASA May Have Accidentally Destroyed Evidence of Organics on Mars 40 Years Ago
What is Apple's True Tone technology on the 2018 MacBook Pro, and why does it matter?
Trump releases letter from Kim Jong Un, touts 'great progress'
Ariana Grande on why she refuses to 'shut up and sing' and not talk politics
Stormy Daniels arrested at strip club
Trump claims he's popular in the UK over his immigration stance
Cardi B welcomes baby daughter Kulture
Sarah Palin says she was ‘duped’ into doing interview on Sacha Baron Cohen’s new show
Merkel pushes back against Trump’s claim that Germany is ‘totally controlled’ by Russia
Putin and Netanyahu meet for Syria-focused talks in Moscow
Kylie Jenner Covers Forbes As The Next Youngest Self-Made Billionaire Ever
Duke and Duchess of Sussex arrive in Ireland on first international trip
Emmanuel Macron cheers on France at World Cup semi-final against Belgium
All 12 boys, coach rescued from Thai cave, ending gruelling 18-day ordeal
France beat Belgium's 'golden generation' to reach World Cup final
Real Madrid agrees Ronaldo transfer deal
Thailand cave rescue: EIGHTH BOY carried out on stretcher as operation HALTED - 4 inside
Barcelona tourist bus STORMED by protesters as they launch summer of CHAOS
Prince Louis christening: George and Charlotte seen with brother for first time
Boris Johnson's letter of resignation: 'The Brexit dream is dying'
Robin Wright breaks silence on Kevin Spacey
Jordan Pickford: 'I wasn't born' for England's last World Cup semifinal
'DO YOUR JOB' Sadiq Khan ‘should be ashamed over Trump balloon insult’ warns Giuliani
4 are out; 9 to go: Captivated world watches Thailand cave rescue
Justin Bieber reportedly engaged to Hailey Baldwin
Turkey train derailment kills at least 10, injures 73
Spiders Use Electricity To Fly For Miles Without Wings
Giuliani 'comfortable' about possibility of Cohen flipping
Tyler Honeycutt, former UCLA and Sacramento Kings basketball player, dies after standoff with police
Croatia book World Cup semi-final with England after penalty shootout win
38 dead, nearly 50 reported missing as heavy rain hits Japan
Elon Musk's Team Due in Thailand to Help Rescue Soccer Team Trapped in Flooded Cave
Women's top seed Simona Halep suffers shock defeat at Wimbledon
England beats Sweden to reach first World Cup semifinal since 1990
World's smallest living dog, 'Miracle Milly', cloned 49 times in South Korea laboratory
Brazil knocked out of World Cup by Kevin De Bruyne and brilliant Belgium
President Trump, Melania to meet Queen Elizabeth II at Windsor Castle during UK visit
It Sounds Like Meghan Markle Has A Slight British Accent Now
Trump Mocks ‘Me Too Generation’ At Rally
Former MSNBC Host Ed Schultz Dies at 64
Donald Trump to be met by protests at each stage of UK visit
NHS hailed as 'unifying ideal' on 70th anniversary
Firework explosions near Mexico City kills 19 people, injures dozens, officials say
EPA chief Scott Pruitt resigns amid ethics scandals
Dozens missing after boats capsize in Thailand
Brexit nightmare coming true for businesses
Three charged with kidnapping actress, holding man naked for 30 hours in Los Angeles
Stormy Daniels lawyer Michael Avenatti teases potential 2020 run against Trump
Seth Meyers Mocks Trump's Knowledge of Independence Day in 'Late Night' Spoof
Forty-nine percent of voters said Trump is racist in a new poll
US and Russian officials hold 'frank' talks before Trump-Putin summit
Queen invites King and Queen of Netherlands for state visit – but Meghan is not invited
Today's talker: Melania Trump is making money as first lady ... bless her heart
TV Ratings: 'The Bachelorette' Softens at Start of July 4th Week
NASA to test 'quiet' supersonic flights
First confirmed image of a newborn planet revealed
Michael Cohen hints at flipping and says 'first loyalty' is to family – not Trump
Justin Trudeau 'does not remember' groping reporter at festival
Harvey Weinstein faces three new sexual misconduct charges
Mars Is the Closest to Earth Since 2003 This Month (There's a Long Blood Moon Eclipse, Too)!
Serena Williams wins first Wimbledon match as a mom
Neymar breaks Mexican hearts
Missing Thai soccer team found alive in cave after nine days
Portraits of Royal Family NEVER SEEN BEFORE finally revealed
LeBron James agrees to 4-year, $154 million deal with Los Angeles Lakers
Key Merkel ally offers to resign over migration policy
Video of mom seeing baby hear for first time goes viral
OnePlus 6 Red is coming to the US in July
Michelle Wolf Urges People To Heckle Ivanka Trump In A Very Specific Way
Leftist Lopez Obrador wins landslide victory in Mexico election
Google doodle: Who was Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz? What does the doodle mean?
Verstappen wins Austrian GP as Hamilton fails to finish
Serena Williams questions frequency of her drug tests
Mysterious 'Oumuamua' space object has finally been identified
French convict escapes prison again -- this time with a hijacked helicopter
Russia knocks out Spain in penalty shootout
Operation UFO: Britain's race to beat Russia to alien weapons REVEALED in secret files
Rocket bursts into flames in Japan after second failed launch
Meet the 4 candidates vying to become Mexico's president
Trump Pressures Saudi Arabia to Increase Oil Production
9 injured in mass stabbing at Idaho apartment complex
Iran protest turns violent; at least 1 death reported
French protest Macron's new reduced speed limits
US ambassador to Estonia resigns over Trump policies and provocations
Ex-NASA scientist says aliens exist but encounters are covered up by governments
Cristiano Ronaldo's World Cup ends as Uruguay beats Portugal
Reporter resigns after false tweet that Maryland shooting suspect had MAGA hat
North Korea has increased nuclear production at secret sites, say US officials
7 days in the dark: How the Thailand cave search unfolded
Comcast is experiencing a nationwide outage
Serena Williams and baby Alexis inspect Wimbledon's childcare arrangement before going back to work
See the 'Space Jellyfish' and Other Jaw-Dropping Views from SpaceX's Dragon Launch
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez Breaks Down Viral Reaction to Democratic Primary Win
Trump Responds To Annapolis Shooting
Susan Sarandon Arrested Protesting Trump’s Immigration Policy
Michael Moore Reveals Release Date for His Anti-Trump Doc
FREXIT? Donald Trump 'told Macron to pull France out of EU in return for US trade deal'
Pence tells Central American leaders that illegal immigration to U.S. ‘must end’
NASA uses Earth as laboratory to study distant worlds
Rob. Gerald. John. Rebecca. Wendi. These are the victims of the newsroom shooting
The Biggest Bombshells Drake Drops on His New Album
SpaceX is sending an AI robot 'crew member' to join the astronauts on the space station
Why Ellen DeGeneres Divorce Rumors Made Portia de Rossi Feel ‘Accepted’
Forget the football, Vladimir Putin is the real World Cup winner
Maryland shooting: Gunman 'OPENS FIRE' at Capital Gazette newsroom - 'MULTIPLE FATALITIES'
You can finally follow Julia Roberts on Instagram
Melania Trump arrives in Arizona for her second trip to immigration facilities
Summit between Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin to be held in Helsinki on July 16
England team news: Jamie Vardy set to start against Belgium in Harry Kane selection clue
'You have not been forgotten,' Prince William tells Palestinians
Late-Night Weighs In On Justice Anthony Kennedy's Supreme Court Shakeup
Milky Way is full of 'space grease,' study finds
Trump and Putin to reveal details of first official summit
President Trump says process to replace Kennedy on Supreme Court will 'begin immediately'
Launch of NASA's James Webb Space Telescope delayed again as costs rise
What the hell was that, Germany?
Laura Benanti Brings Back Melania Trump Impression to Discuss 'I Really Don't Care' Jacket
Joe Jackson, musical family patriarch, dead at 89
Who is Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez?
David Beckham joins Duke and Duchess of Sussex and Queen at young leaders awards ceremony
Huge EXPLOSION at Texas Hospital - 'building collapse' leaves one dead and a dozen injured
Japan space explorer arrives at asteroid to collect samples
Late-Night Hosts Sound Off on SCOTUS Upholding Trump Travel Ban
Trump plots controversial Putin meeting and leaves NATO allies guessing
Argentina avoids humiliation with late winner against Nigeria
This Scientist Thinks Aliens Will Need to 'Catch' Stars to Survive
Uber wins right to keep operating in London
Trump scores huge win over controversial travel ban
Two dead and 18 injured after Cambridgeshire bus-lorry crash
Emmanuel Macron holds long meeting with Pope Francis
Cardi B confirms she secretly married Offset in September, before they were 'engaged'
Houston Rockets star James Harden wins 2017-2018 NBA MVP
Police dog 'performs CPR' in adorable viral video
Jimmy Fallon responds to Trump: 'Why are you tweeting at me?'
Democrat's ad for run in Texas goes viral
Richard Harrison, Known as 'The Old Man' on 'Pawn Stars,' Dies at 77
Iran so close to stunning Portugal but Quaresma goal enough for draw
Protesters swarm Iran's Grand Bazaar in Tehran, force shops to close in anger over economy
NASA's stunning new photo of Jupiter looks like a work of art
AI bots from a lab backed by Elon Musk trained for thousands of lifetimes to beat humans at Dota 2
What Erdogan's reelection means for Turkey and the world
Stunning NASA photo shows blue sand dune on Mars, the Red Planet
Trump Responds To Restaurant Kicking Out Sanders, Calls It ‘Dirty’
BET Awards: Meek Mill Pays Tribute to XXXTentacion While Performing 'Stay Woke'
Prince William reveals childhood details about Kate during historical Middle East tour
Thousands flee as flames race across dry rural California
Black Astronaut Jeanette Epps Still Doesn't Know Why NASA Cancelled Her Historic Mission This Year
Trump Attacks Jimmy Fallon for Hollywood Reporter Podcast 'Hair Tussle' Comments: 'Be a Man, Jimmy!'
Erodgan declares victory in Turkey presidential election
Donald Hall, US poet laureate and prize-winning man of letters, dies at 89
Donald Trump vows to deport illegal immigrants IMMEDIATELY without trial
Why Lionel Messi hates playing for Argentina in World Cup
Prince William starts historic Middle East tour
Mo Salah considering quitting Egypt national team
Turkey elections: Erdogan ahead in early results
GERMANY EXPLOSION: At least 25 injured in blast sparking multiple fires
World's Ugliest Dog title goes to English bulldog named Zsa Zsa
Tom Holland Reveals Next 'Spider-Man' Movie Is Called 'Far From Home'
New Zealand prime minister Jacinda Ardern introduces baby Neve te Aroha to the world
Trump-Putin meeting will follow Bolton trip to Moscow, says Pompeo
Saudi women in the driver’s seat — and in the crosshairs of change
Turkey elections: Polls open in tough challenge for Erdogan
Toni Kroos brings off late miracle for Germany to stun Sweden
Eddie Vedder's wife, more stars are responding to Melania Trump with their own jackets
8 perfect astronaut selfies for when you just need some space
Sarah Huckabee Sanders Got Kicked Out Of A Restaurant Because Of Trump
'Game of Thrones' stars Kit Harington and Rose Leslie are married
OPEC meets Russia, other allies to agree oil output boost
Romelu Lukaku and Eden Hazard star as Belgium rout Tunisia
Tom Arnold Went On TV To Hype Up Getting Dirt On Trump And Boy Did Things Get Awkward
Hundreds of women march in Rio to demand legal abortion
Jimmy Fallon Launches First-Ever 'Tonight Show' Book Club
Vinnie Paul, Pantera drummer and co-founder, dies at 54
Four people arrested in Pittsburgh protests over death of Antwon Rose
'Modern Family' star Sarah Hyland shares shocking photo of swollen face after hospitalization
Face-scanning technology at Orlando airport expands to all international travelers
Sleeping beauty discovered 2,000 years after death wearing skirt and clutching make up box
Summer camp illness in Florida sends 33 kids, 3 adults to hospital
Biggest winners and losers of 2018 NBA draft
World Cup: Fan Apologizes to TV Reporter For Groping Her on Live TV
Lewandowski Still Refuses to Apologize For ‘Womp Womp’ Comment
Airbus plans UK job cuts amid fears of hard Brexit impact
Utah Jazz select Grayson Allen with 21st pick
Charing Cross station in London evacuated after bomb threat
SpaceX's massive Falcon Heavy rocket lands $130 million military launch contract
Kim Kardashian Tries To Defend Wearing Fulani Braids Again
Colbert Mocks Melania’s Jacket: Was ‘Womp Womp’ Your First Choice?
WaPo: National Enquirer sent Trump stories to Michael Cohen before publication
Close