Close
Date TimeJune 05, 2018
VoiceShareholders voted to maintain Elon Musk’s role as chairman of Tesla’s board during the company’s annual shareholder meeting in Mountain View, Calif., on Tuesday despite a controversial proposal to strip him of that position.
Elon Musk appears emotional as he overcomes vote to remove him as Tesla chairman
The vote of confidence is a major boon for Tesla’s embattled chief executive and founder but arrives six months into what is arguably his company’s toughest year to date.
Moments after the vote, Musk — who appeared emotional as his voice quivered — said the company has experienced “the most excruciating hellish several months that we’ve ever had.”
“But I think we’re getting there,” he added.
In recent months, Tesla has been beset by critical production challenges involving its highly anticipated Model 3 sedan, accusations of poor worker safety and discrimination at company facilities, and headline-grabbing wrecks and investigations that have raised questions about the company’s semiautonomous technology.
Tesla’s stock is down about 7 percent year-to-date.
The delayed rollout of the Model 3 — which has a waiting list hundreds of thousands of buyers long — has been the source of extreme frustration inside the company and out, generating concerns among some analysts that Musk’s manufacturing pronouncements can’t be trusted.
At the shareholder meeting, Musk said Tesla is producing 3,500 Model 3’s a week and he expects that number to reach 5,000 cars per week by the end of the month. Musk said manufacturing will be Tesla’s greatest strength long-term and predicted the company would be profitable in Q3 and Q4.
“We’re confident we know how to address them and we are addressing them,” Musk said, referring to production issues plaguing the Model 3. “One of the biggest mistakes we made was trying to automate things that are super easy for a person to do, but super hard for a robot to do.”
Tuesday’s vote also determined the fate of three members of Tesla’s board of directors: Antonio Gracias, a private equity investor; Kimbal Musk, Elon Musk’s brother; and James Murdoch, the chief executive of Twenty-First Century Fox. Despite concerns that each member would be unable to help Musk focus on the many challenges Tesla faces, stockholders voted to maintain their positions on the board.
The proposal to remove Musk from his role as chairman of Tesla’s board was introduced by Jing Zhao, a shareholder who has questioned whether Musk — who leads several other companies in addition to Tesla — is spread too thin.
“Although the current leadership structure, in which the positions of Chairman and CEO are held by one person, could provide an effective leadership for Tesla at the early stage, now in this much more highly competitive and rapidly changing technology industry, it is more and more difficult to oversee Tesla’s business and senior management (especially to minimize any potential conflicts) that may result from combining the positions of CEO and Chairman,” Zhao wrote in his proposal.
Musk’s exceptional ability to raise capital and convince investors to buy into his long-term vision is why Steve Blank — a retired Silicon Valley entrepreneur who teaches business at Stanford — thought it was unlikely Musk would be removed from his position on Tesla’s board.
Like Steve Jobs before him, Blank said, Musk excels as a visionary and innovator but struggles to implement that vision. Jobs eventually mastered both innovation and execution, and Blank thinks Musk will, too, so long as he continues to move past the creative phase of his career.
“This is no longer an innovation problem, this is an execution at scale problem — unless Tesla wants to be a niche innovator chasing profitability and sucking up cash,” Blank said. “They need to become experts at execution at scale, but that’s hard for people who in their DNA want to continually innovate.”
“It gets boring to execute,” he added. “I am a huge Elon fan. What people miss is that this is an authentic American hero and most of these heroes have in them the seeds of their own destruction.”

Related Stories
Tesla Model 3 goal not met, leaked documents suggestTesla Model 3 goal not met, leaked documents suggest
Elon Musk Mistook a ‘Blood Moon’ for Mars in New SpaceX TweetElon Musk Mistook a ‘Blood Moon’ for Mars in New SpaceX Tweet
SpaceX targets 2021 commercial Starship launchSpaceX targets 2021 commercial Starship launch
Tesla stock surges after setting new delivery and production recordsTesla stock surges after setting new delivery and production records
Elon Musks Neuralink hopes to put sensors in human brains next yearElon Musk's Neuralink hopes to put sensors in human brains next year
Elon Musk: SpaceX flights between cities will feel like Disneys Space MountainElon Musk: SpaceX flights between cities will feel like Disney's Space Mountain
Falcon Heavy Takes Off in First Night Launch, Center Core Smashes into the OceanFalcon Heavy Takes Off in First Night Launch, Center Core Smashes into the Ocean
Elon Musk says free self-driving chip upgrade could come to older Teslas this yearElon Musk says free self-driving chip upgrade could come to older Teslas this year
News Trends
Beyoncé Literally Broke Alllll the Strict Royal Rules When Meeting Meghan MarkleBeyoncé Literally Broke Alllll the Strict Royal Rules When Meeting Meghan Markle
‘The Lion King’ Roars to $23 Million Opening on Thursday Night‘The Lion King’ Roars to $23 Million Opening on Thursday Night
Cruise Herts club: Who are the car enthusiasts and what happened at the Stevenage motor meeting?Cruise Herts club: Who are the car enthusiasts and what happened at the Stevenage motor meeting?
2020 Chevrolet Corvette C8 Stingrays price and features draw gasps2020 Chevrolet Corvette C8 Stingray's price and features draw gasps
Brexit activist Darren Grimes wins appeal against £20,000 Electoral Commission fineBrexit activist Darren Grimes wins appeal against £20,000 Electoral Commission fine
NFL won’t suspend Chiefs’ Tyreek Hill in case involving sonNFL won’t suspend Chiefs’ Tyreek Hill in case involving son
Kylie Jenner Doesnt Want to Marry Travis ScottKylie Jenner Doesn't Want to Marry Travis Scott
Rep. Ilhan Omar Receives Heros Welcome Home Amid Trump AttacksRep. Ilhan Omar Receives Hero's Welcome Home Amid Trump Attacks
Britons urged to help record influx of painted lady butterfliesBritons urged to help record influx of painted lady butterflies
Beyoncés Lion King album is more about Beyoncé than The Lion KingBeyoncé's Lion King album is more about Beyoncé than The Lion King
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
Tesla Model 3 goal not met, leaked documents suggestTesla Model 3 goal not met, leaked documents suggest
Elon Musk Mistook a ‘Blood Moon’ for Mars in New SpaceX TweetElon Musk Mistook a ‘Blood Moon’ for Mars in New SpaceX Tweet
SpaceX targets 2021 commercial Starship launchSpaceX targets 2021 commercial Starship launch
Tesla stock surges after setting new delivery and production recordsTesla stock surges after setting new delivery and production records
Elon Musks Neuralink hopes to put sensors in human brains next yearElon Musk's Neuralink hopes to put sensors in human brains next year
Elon Musk: SpaceX flights between cities will feel like Disneys Space MountainElon Musk: SpaceX flights between cities will feel like Disney's Space Mountain
Falcon Heavy Takes Off in First Night Launch, Center Core Smashes into the OceanFalcon Heavy Takes Off in First Night Launch, Center Core Smashes into the Ocean
Elon Musk says free self-driving chip upgrade could come to older Teslas this yearElon Musk says free self-driving chip upgrade could come to older Teslas this year
News Trends
Beyoncé Literally Broke Alllll the Strict Royal Rules When Meeting Meghan MarkleBeyoncé Literally Broke Alllll the Strict Royal Rules When Meeting Meghan Markle
‘The Lion King’ Roars to $23 Million Opening on Thursday Night‘The Lion King’ Roars to $23 Million Opening on Thursday Night
Cruise Herts club: Who are the car enthusiasts and what happened at the Stevenage motor meeting?Cruise Herts club: Who are the car enthusiasts and what happened at the Stevenage motor meeting?
2020 Chevrolet Corvette C8 Stingrays price and features draw gasps2020 Chevrolet Corvette C8 Stingray's price and features draw gasps
Brexit activist Darren Grimes wins appeal against £20,000 Electoral Commission fineBrexit activist Darren Grimes wins appeal against £20,000 Electoral Commission fine
NFL won’t suspend Chiefs’ Tyreek Hill in case involving sonNFL won’t suspend Chiefs’ Tyreek Hill in case involving son
Kylie Jenner Doesnt Want to Marry Travis ScottKylie Jenner Doesn't Want to Marry Travis Scott
Rep. Ilhan Omar Receives Heros Welcome Home Amid Trump AttacksRep. Ilhan Omar Receives Hero's Welcome Home Amid Trump Attacks
Britons urged to help record influx of painted lady butterfliesBritons urged to help record influx of painted lady butterflies
Beyoncés Lion King album is more about Beyoncé than The Lion KingBeyoncé's Lion King album is more about Beyoncé than The Lion King
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Shawn Mendes Indulges Harry Potter Obsession, Sings Hits on 'Carpool Karaoke'
Bill Clinton Responds to Monica Lewinsky Comment Controversy: 'I Was Mad at Me'
Ariana Grande: I had PTSD following Manchester attack
US government to use facial recognition technology at Mexico border crossing
Macron uses laws and sausages to deflect Trump call question
Putin says he speaks regularly to Trump, isn't trying to divide Europe
Trump to NFL: 'No escaping to locker rooms'
Novak Djokovic OUT of French Open after quarter-final defeat to Marco Cecchinato
Designer Kate Spade, 55, found dead in New York
First ‘Bumblebee’ Trailer Is Heavy on Feels, Light on ‘Transformers’ Action
Serena Williams Withdraws From French Open With A Fierce Message
Guatemala volcano: at least 62 killed and 300 injured after Fuego erupts
Miss America is scrapping the swimsuit portion from its pageant
Sex robots won’t solve loneliness nor curb violence against women, doctors say
NASA to make MAJOR announcement on Thursday about LIFE on Mars
Braless Kim Kardashian West gets cheeky in CFDA Awards speech: 'I'm naked most of the time'
Late-Night Hosts Take Jabs at Trump's Self-Pardon Tweet
French man to cross Great Pacific Garbage Patch on 6-month swim
Apple's new 'digital wellbeing' tools aim to help reduce screen time
Edward Snowden: 'The people are still powerless, but now they're aware'
Trump's phone call with Macron described as 'terrible'
Google honors legendary marathoner Tom Longboat
Vladimir Putin invites North Korean leader Kim Jong-un to Russia – how will Trump react?
Steph Curry's historic NBA Finals Game 2 a window to Warriors before Kevin Durant
Bill Clinton says he doesn't owe Monica Lewinsky an apology
North Korea shakes up military leadership
Scott Disick and Sofia Richie split
The Queen's EXTRAORDINARY wedding gift to Prince Harry and Meghan Markle REVEALED
Melania Trump to skip G7, North Korea summits
Jimmy Fallon Surprises Students at Parkland High School Graduation
500 quakes in 24 hours at Hawaii volcano
Massive NATO exercise starts in Poland and the Baltics
At least 7 dead, international airport closed, 1.7 million could be affected by Guatemala volcano
Fans worried about Johnny Depp's health after new photos appear online
Trump lawyer Giuliani says president can probably pardon himself
Berlin Cathedral ON LOCKDOWN - 'rampaging' knifeman shot by armed police in city centre
United States of Europe moves CLOSER as Angela Merkel backs Emmanuel Macron EU reforms
Suspect arrested after gunfire heard near San Diego marathon; police say no ongoing threat
Kim says he'll meet Assad in North Korea
Thousands of breast cancer patients could avoid chemo, study finds
Iraq sentences French woman to life for joining IS
Russian space capsule with 3 crew lands in Kazakhstan
FBI agent accidentally fires gun while dancing at a Denver nightclub
Saudi 'temporarily' frees activists who want women to be able to drive
Trump lawyers to Mueller: Trump cannot be forced to testify
Israel intercepts MISSILES fired from Gaza Strip and responds with AIRSTRIKES
A fan paid $3 million for a lunch with Warren Buffett—but you can get his best advice for free
WaPo: US determining who will pay for North Korea leader's hotel room
Nigeria World Cup football shirts capture public imagination
Replace May with Gove to sort out Brexit, Tory donor urges
Angela Merkel refuses Italy debt write-off amid fears government could DESTROY eurozone
Peckham shooting: Man 'shot in face' as London violence continues to rage
U.S. In Early Talks To Arrange Trump, Putin Summit: Report
Serena Williams to face Maria Sharapova at French Open
President Trump misses LGBTQ Pride Month again
Pedro Sánchez sworn in as Spain’s prime minister after no-confidence vote
Katy Perry accidentally posts private Orlando Bloom comment on his public Instagram page
Cellphone surveillance detected near the White House, DHS says
Visa apologises after system crash causes card payment chaos
Serena Williams shines even as she struggles at French Open
Hawaii volcano eruption: Watch CURTAIN of lava SPRING OUT of crack with devastating force
Google to drop Pentagon AI contract after employee objections to the 'business of war'
Mattis takes hard line on China in Singapore speech
MSNBC host Joy Reid apologizes for incendiary old blog posts
Theresa May attacks Donald Trump's 'unjustified' steel tariffs
Google under fire for listing 'Nazism' as the ideology of the California Republican Party
What We Know About Meghan Markle’s Life As A Duchess So Far
Trump says Singapore summit with Kim is back on
John Brennan unleashes on Trump, says president 'grandstands like a snake-oil salesman'
Cosmetics retailer Lush criticised by police over 'spycops' ad campaign
Visa Outage Across Europe Causes Payment Chaos For Millions
NASA Just Released These Incredible Images Of Earth
WATCH: TERRIFYING video shows FURIOUS cyclist pulling HUGE knife at driver
Unemployment rate falls to 3.8% as employers add 223,000 jobs in May
Donald Trump Says Samantha Bee Should Be Fired
Spanish PM forced out after losing no-confidence vote amid ongoing European turmoil
Kanye West Debuts New Album, ‘Ye,’ Via Live Stream From Wyoming
Could Tristan Thompson be suspended for Game 1 altercation with Draymond Green?
Telegram app is 'mouthpiece' for terror, Sajid Javid says as jihadi admits encouraging attack on Prince George
Ecuador's president says Julian Assange can stay in embassy 'with conditions'
Magaluf rape horror: Police arrest man over 'sex attack on British woman, 22'
Robert Mueller's Russia investigation costs near $17 million, Justice says
Justin Trudeau says retaliation against the US is necessary
Trump is starting a global trade war
The 1975 to release new song Give Yourself A Try
Roman Abramovich shelves £1bn Chelsea stadium after visa delays
ITALY LATEST: Populists say breakthrough coalition deal has been AGREED - 'We've done it!'
7000 years ago men were a sub-species ruled by WOMEN & outnumbered 20 to 1, scientists say
Fake news on WhatsApp is getting people killed in India
White House says Bee's joke was 'vile and vicious'
Trump says North Korean official bringing him a letter from Kim
Brigitte Nielsen announces pregnancy at 54
Samantha Bee calls Ivanka Trump a 'cunt,' leading Megyn Kelly to call host 'disgusting'
Trump tweets he will give full pardon to Dinesh D'Souza
Paolo Guerrero cleared to play at World Cup for Peru after doping ban frozen
Zidane steps down as Real Madrid head coach in shock announcement
Trump imposes steel, aluminum tariffs on U.S. allies and Europe plans to retaliate
Donald Trump says he didn't fire James Comey over Russia despite video evidence
Russian foreign minister meets Kim, calls for lifting of sanctions
Illinois Ratifies the Equal Rights Amendment - 36 Years After the Deadline
North Korean 'spymaster' Kim Yong-chol meets Mike Pompeo in New York ahead of planned Trump summit
Melania Trump tweets she’s ‘feeling great’ after nearly three weeks out of public eye
Russia foreign minister arrives for talks in North Korea
Julia Roberts to Present AFI Life Achievement Award to George Clooney
'The Americans' Bosses Break Down 'Tragic' Series Finale
Trump And Kim Kardashian Met At The White House Because 2018
Half of world's children at risk of war, poverty, discrimination, report finds
Valerie Jarrett calls for turning Roseanne Barr's racist tweet into 'teaching moment'
Virginia poised to expand Medicaid
Sarah Sanders gets choked up after child asks about about 'senseless' school shootings
Channel 4 reveals shortlisted cities for new national HQ
What is 'Right to Try'? A look at the drug law Trump supports
Ambien maker responds to Roseanne Barr: 'Racism is not a known side effect'
Pakistan and India agree to stop exchanging fire in Kashmir
Italy at risk of new financial crisis in wake of coalition's collapse
Cleveland Cavaliers have almost no chance of winning NBA title, Vegas oddsmakers say
Jimmy Kimmel Picks Controversial Frontrunner to Win 'The Bachelorette'
TV Ratings: 'America's Got Talent' Makes a Strong Return
Paris Jackson Leaves Dior Fashion Show Because Animals ‘Whipped’
'Active Shooter' video game is pulled from Steam gaming platform after backlash from shooting survivors
Kim Kardashian meeting Kushner to discuss prison reform
'Murdered' Russian journalist appears on Ukrainian TV after staged death
Top best-selling books all time
Pokemon Let's Go Pikachu And Let's Go Eevee: Everything We Know So Far
Pusha-T Fires Back at Drake With Ferocious Diss Track ‘The Story of Adidon’ (Listen)
Liverpool to sign Brazilian Fabinho
EDL founder Tommy Robinson jailed for contempt of court
Soros-backed campaign to push for new Brexit vote within a year
More Hawaii residents forced to evacuate as Kilauea volcano danger continues
Gaza's Hamas rulers say cease-fire reached with Israel
Tesla in Autopilot mode crashes into parked police cruiser
At Rally in Nashville, Trump Links Democrats to MS-13
Roseanne Returns to Twitter: 'Don't Feel Sorry For Me'
Americans Are Split Over The NFL’s Decision On Anthem Protests
‘The Daily Show’ Leaks Starbucks’ Training Video And It’s Hilarious
Santa Fe High School students to return to campus after shooting
Police: 52 patients accuse former USC gynecologist of inappropriate conduct
Seven killed, 32 wounded during Memorial Day weekend in Chicago
Hurricane Maria killed more than 4,600 people, not 64. That’s more than 70 times the official estimate
Apple Releases iOS 11.4 With Messages in iCloud and AirPlay 2
ABC cancels 'Roseanne' after star's racist Twitter rant
One million people in France quit smoking last year
Raheem Sterling defends gun tattoo against media criticism
Israeli jets bomb Gaza after more than 25 mortar shells fired from strip
New find at Pompeii shows skeleton of man crushed trying to flee eruption
Rwanda defends $39 million sponsorship deal with Arsenal
Trump announces tariffs on China, tech crackdown ahead of key trade meeting
2 police officers and passerby shot dead in Belgium
'Spider-Man' of Paris to get French citizenship after child rescue
How scientists are using Hawaii’s Kilauea volcano to study Mars
North Korean officials and U.S. meet in Singapore ahead of summit
More than 25 mortar shells fired from Gaza, Israel says
French billionaire dead at 93
It could take 10 years for N Korea to give up its nuclear weapons, experts say
Former Aberdeen player Neale Cooper dies after collapsing at home
Roman Abramovich granted Israeli citizenship
Video Shows Police Officer Punching Woman On New Jersey Beach
Eminem responds to Nicki Minaj dating rumor
Michelle Wolf doubles down on Sarah Sanders jokes on new Netflix show
From Neighbours sweetheart to pop superstar: Kylie Minogue turns 50 – in pictures
Macron rewards migrant hero who saved dangling child in Paris
Trump marks Memorial Day with Twitter video
Italy's 'political referee' waves red card
CATASTROPHIC flash flood in Ellicott City Maryland as state of EMERGENCY declared
Ivanka Trump photo with son sparks backlash over separations at border
Driver tries to run down cops, jumps sidewalk in dramatic video
LeBron James scores 35 as Cavs advance to NBA Finals
Elon Musk has more to say about the media
'Spiderman' rescues child dangling from Paris balcony
US Navy operation threatens China's security, Beijing says
Danica crashes out of Indy 500, her final race
Chelsea Clinton: Trump 'degrades what it means to be an American'
France's Macron to host Libya summit pushing for elections
Giuliani admitted the White House is trying to discredit the Russia probe
George H.W. Bush hospitalized for low blood pressure and fatigue
Daniel Ricciardo keeps cool in stricken car to win Monaco Grand Prix
Horrifying pictures after massive fire rips through Germany’s biggest theme park
United Kingdom sees more than 60,000 lightning strikes during thunderstorms
US delegation travels to North Korea for potential summit preparation
Warriors force Game 7 after Klay Thompson shines in 115-86 victory over Rockets
North Korea-US summit on track, says Moon, after candid talks with 'friend' Kim Jong-un
President Trump welcomes Josh Holt, American held in Venezuela, back to the US
Florida, Mississippi and Alabama declare emergencies ahead of storm Alberto
Real Madrid win Champions League as brilliant Bale sinks Liverpool
Official tally shows big win for abortion rights in Ireland
Justin Timberlake Visits Texas School Shooting Victims
Alan Bean, the 4th person to walk on the moon, dies at 86
'Worse than ever seen before' - Vladimir Putin in STARK warning of MAJOR financial CRISIS
American freed from Venezuela prison heading home, Trump says
North and South Korean leaders meet again
Irish strongly in favor of ending abortion ban, exit poll shows
Pusha T on 'Daytona': Kanye West paid $85K for Whitney Houston bathroom photo on album
Liverpool vs Real Madrid prediction: 'Mohamed Salah, Cristiano Ronaldo will score but'
New helium tank for SpaceX crew launches still waiting to fly
Irish voters appear to embrace repeal of abortion ban
2 hospitalized in Indiana school shooting, suspect in custody: Police
Tommy Robinson arrested for 'breaching the peace' outside court during grooming trial
Donald Trump says North Korea summit could be back on
Putin accuses Britain of blaming 'all their mortal sins' on Russia
Meghan Markle honoured with Coat of Arms as new Duchess welcomed by the Queen
Close