Close
Date TimeMay 23, 2018
VoiceThe Labour leader had the PM on the back foot over outsourcing, but May found a decent comeback
PMQs verdict: Jeremy Corbyn fails to press home advantages on NHS
Key points
Jeremy Corbyn said that a year since the Grenfell Tower fire, justice had not been done. He said that in 2010, £4bn of NHS services were outsourced to private services. How much was it today?
May said spending on the private sector nearly doubled in the last four years of the Labour government.
Corbyn said May did not answer the question. It was now almost £9bn. And Surrey NHS had just paid Virgin Healthcare £1.5m because its bid was not chosen. He said a report on outsourcing said NHS England’s handling of this puts patients at risk of harm.
May said the National Audit Office report said no one was put at harm, and it said the savings helped to fund more operations. She said last year the spending on outsourcing in England did not go up. But it went up in Wales.
Corbyn said outsourcing to Capita had put patients at risk of harm. Outsourcing of GP services had led to records being mislaid. Wasn’t the government tearing up the founding principles of the NHS and putting private profit before care?
May said Labour had made claims about privatisation at every election. But after every election the Conservative government had protected the NHS.
Corbyn replied that that was a bit rich from the party that voted against the NHS. He said that, according to the Royal College of GPs, the long list of failures by Capita had been incredibly frustrating for doctors. They were leaving the profession in despair. One in 10 had left in the last five years. How many more GPs were there than in 2015?
May responded that there were more than 14,000 more doctors than there were in 2010. Corbyn talked about the private sector. Why not ask Jonathan Ashworth, the shadow health secretary, who said Labour would still buy from the private sector?
Corbyn said Ashworth would put patients’ interests first. GPs were the bedrock of the service and we needed more of them. He quoted from someone who wrote to him about the care provided to her mother in a nursing home. What was the government doing about the substandard care provided by the private sector?
May said she wanted people to get good care. That was why Ashworth backed the use of the private sector in some circumstances.
Corbyn said Ashworth was dedicated to the NHS, not to handing it over to private contractors. This year was the 70th anniversary of the NHS. It had the worst waiting lists on record, the worst cancer referrals and falling numbers of GPs. Yet the government was opening up the door to more profiteering.
May said she paid tribute to the NHS. The government wanted a bright future for it. That was why she would come forward with a long-term plan. More people were being treated. There were people alive today who would not have been alive in the past. And yet you could only do this with a good economy. This week we learned Labour wanted to overthrow capitalism. That would mean more people in debt, fewer people in jobs and lasting damage to the NHS.

Snap verdict
Asking about the NHS at PMQs is a home game for a Labour leader (it’s a “Labour issue” as much today as ever) and Corbyn notched up a creditable performance, but not quite the decisive win he had last week, or the week before.
His questions had May on the back foot, particularly at the start when he was pressing her on the detail of outsourcing. But towards the end his questions started to lose focus, and it felt very much as if he was attacking the record of the last eight years, rather than anything the government had done on health since May became prime minister.
And, with the BBC reporting this week that May was poised to rip up parts of the 2012 Health and Social Care Act, it was hard to see why Corbyn failed to challenge her to defend it, or to signal at PMQs (by refusing to defend it) that a U-turn was on the cards.
May is uncomfortable on this territory, but she had a half-decent comeback on outsourcing (it is not increasing in England, but it is in Wales), and she was beginning to open up quite effectively a divide between Corbyn (who instinctively dislikes any mention of profit in relation to NHS) and more centrist figures in his party, such as Jon Ashworth, who are more comfortable acknowledging some role for the private sector in health. May received very loud cheers from Tory MPs at the end as she concluded with an (over-long) peroration. It sounded more like consolation applause rather than a recognition that she had won, but overall it wasn’t a great outing by either of them.

Memorable lines
Jeremy Corbyn on NHS outsourcing:
Isn’t this the inevitable consequence of this government tearing up the founding principles of the NHS and putting private profit before public service?

Theresa May’s response:
We have protected the NHS, we have improved the NHS services, we have put more funding into the NHS and we have made sure we remain true to the founding principle of the NHS that it is free at the point of delivery.

Related Stories
Lyra McKee funeral: politicians urged to seize the momentLyra McKee funeral: politicians urged to seize the moment
Local Elections 2019: Tories And Labour Punished Over Brexit As Lib Dems Win BigLocal Elections 2019: Tories And Labour Punished Over Brexit As Lib Dems Win Big
Tony Blair Chips In With Advice On European Elections and It Wont Please Jeremy CorbynTony Blair Chips In With Advice On European Elections and It Won't Please Jeremy Corbyn
Feel no pity for Theresa May. She has been the worst prime minister in modern times | Owen JonesFeel no pity for Theresa May. She has been the worst prime minister in modern times | Owen Jones
Boris Johnson confirms bid for Tory leadershipBoris Johnson confirms bid for Tory leadership
Boris Johnson Says UK Must Be Prepared To Leave EU With No-Deal In OctoberBoris Johnson Says UK Must Be Prepared To Leave EU With No-Deal In October
Theresa May Announces Resignation, New Prime Minister Will Takeover In JulyTheresa May Announces Resignation, New Prime Minister Will Takeover In July
News Trends
Kendall Jenner Soaks Up the Sun on Jet Skis With Luka Sabbat in MonacoKendall Jenner Soaks Up the Sun on Jet Skis With Luka Sabbat in Monaco
Natalie Portman calls Moby an older man being creepy, denies relationship rumorsNatalie Portman calls Moby an 'older man being creepy,' denies relationship rumors
How yoga teacher Amanda Eller survived 17 days lost in a Hawaiian jungleHow yoga teacher Amanda Eller survived 17 days lost in a Hawaiian jungle
Sasha Obama stuns in fitted black gown for high school promSasha Obama stuns in fitted black gown for high school prom
Shami Chakrabarti warns police over Extinction Rebellion prosecutionsShami Chakrabarti warns police over Extinction Rebellion prosecutions
Auburn radio voice Rod Bramblett, wife Paula, die following car accidentAuburn radio voice Rod Bramblett, wife Paula, die following car accident
Warriors open as massive NBA Finals favorites over Raptors in Las VegasWarriors open as massive NBA Finals favorites over Raptors in Las Vegas
Inside Kim Kardashian and Kanye Wests Low-Key Anniversary DinnerInside Kim Kardashian and Kanye West's Low-Key Anniversary Dinner
Federal judge blocks Trump from using Defense funds for parts of border wallFederal judge blocks Trump from using Defense funds for parts of border wall
Naomi Wolf admits blunder over Victorians and sodomy executionsNaomi Wolf admits blunder over Victorians and sodomy executions
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
Lyra McKee funeral: politicians urged to seize the momentLyra McKee funeral: politicians urged to seize the moment
Local Elections 2019: Tories And Labour Punished Over Brexit As Lib Dems Win BigLocal Elections 2019: Tories And Labour Punished Over Brexit As Lib Dems Win Big
Tony Blair Chips In With Advice On European Elections and It Wont Please Jeremy CorbynTony Blair Chips In With Advice On European Elections and It Won't Please Jeremy Corbyn
Feel no pity for Theresa May. She has been the worst prime minister in modern times | Owen JonesFeel no pity for Theresa May. She has been the worst prime minister in modern times | Owen Jones
Boris Johnson confirms bid for Tory leadershipBoris Johnson confirms bid for Tory leadership
Boris Johnson Says UK Must Be Prepared To Leave EU With No-Deal In OctoberBoris Johnson Says UK Must Be Prepared To Leave EU With No-Deal In October
Theresa May Announces Resignation, New Prime Minister Will Takeover In JulyTheresa May Announces Resignation, New Prime Minister Will Takeover In July
News Trends
Kendall Jenner Soaks Up the Sun on Jet Skis With Luka Sabbat in MonacoKendall Jenner Soaks Up the Sun on Jet Skis With Luka Sabbat in Monaco
Natalie Portman calls Moby an older man being creepy, denies relationship rumorsNatalie Portman calls Moby an 'older man being creepy,' denies relationship rumors
How yoga teacher Amanda Eller survived 17 days lost in a Hawaiian jungleHow yoga teacher Amanda Eller survived 17 days lost in a Hawaiian jungle
Sasha Obama stuns in fitted black gown for high school promSasha Obama stuns in fitted black gown for high school prom
Shami Chakrabarti warns police over Extinction Rebellion prosecutionsShami Chakrabarti warns police over Extinction Rebellion prosecutions
Auburn radio voice Rod Bramblett, wife Paula, die following car accidentAuburn radio voice Rod Bramblett, wife Paula, die following car accident
Warriors open as massive NBA Finals favorites over Raptors in Las VegasWarriors open as massive NBA Finals favorites over Raptors in Las Vegas
Inside Kim Kardashian and Kanye Wests Low-Key Anniversary DinnerInside Kim Kardashian and Kanye West's Low-Key Anniversary Dinner
Federal judge blocks Trump from using Defense funds for parts of border wallFederal judge blocks Trump from using Defense funds for parts of border wall
Naomi Wolf admits blunder over Victorians and sodomy executionsNaomi Wolf admits blunder over Victorians and sodomy executions
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
3 more teens charged in death of Maryland police officer
Tesla's Model 3 isn't really for the mass market. It's a luxury car
Lupe Valdez Makes History In Texas By Winning Democratic Nod For Governor
Philip Roth: Portnoy's Complaint and American Pastoral author dies aged 85
'Get a job!’ Millennial, 30, evicted from parents’ house after losing legal battle
Syrian official rejects US demand for Iranian withdrawal
Merkel heads to China to talk economy, trade, rule of law
MH370 not deliberately crashed by pilot, say investigators
Jon Stewart Camps Out Under Stephen Colbert's Desk With Charity Contest Winner
Trevor Noah Reveals The Question He’d Ask Trump That No Else Has Dared To
Mark Zuckerberg's big European test did not go well
Young Americans try to stop Ireland from voting Yes to abortion
F-35 stealth fighter jets get first taste of combat
Active shooter in Panama City, Florida - BOMB SQUAD scrambled and 'flash grenade thrown'
No repeat of data scandal, vows Mark Zuckerberg in Brussels
Trump suggests historic North Korea summit in June could be delayed
Will Amazon's facial-recognition tech enable mass surveillance?
Duke and Duchess of Sussex make first appearance since royal wedding
Manchester bombing: Prince William and Theresa May pay respects as UK falls silent
Ariana Grande sends love to fans as Manchester marks a year since concert bombing
James Corden Reveals The Worst Part Of The Royal Wedding Ceremony
The Onion Mocks Michael Cohen With His Own Cease-And-Desist Note
10 confirmed dead from Nipah virus outbreak in India, including nurse treating patients
Melbourne grenade attack signals gang trouble in 'world's best city'
Irish abortion vote: 'propagandistic' use of children with Down's syndrome condemned
Manchester Arena attack: thousands to mark anniversary
Santa Fe comes together through faith after school shooting that left 10 dead
French Open is punishing Serena Williams for having a baby
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg to tell European Parliament: 'I'm sorry'
Former Playboy model pushed son, 7, out of NYC hotel room window before own fatal leap: report
Australian Archbishop Found Guilty In Cover-Up Of Child Sex Abuse
Foreign media arrive in North Korea, suggesting nuclear shutdown on track
'American Idol': Winner Revealed
Colbert Just Can’t Resist Turning Trump’s Nickname Into A Pee Tape Joke
Japanese climber Nobukazu Kuriki dies on eighth Everest attempt
Heatwave kills at least 65 in Pakistan
Sweden to send war pamphlet to 4.8 million households
'Alien' asteroid discovered orbiting the wrong way near Jupiter 
Marseille shooting: Hooded men open fire with Kalashnikovs
LONDON BLOODBATH: Man stabbed to death in Islington as wave of violence grips capital
Trump praises new CIA director, Gina Haspel
Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the company doesn't 'die,' Musk says
Janet Jackson Becomes First Black Woman To Receive Billboard Icon Award
Prince Harry And Meghan Markle Release Official Royal Wedding Photos
The Obamas Are Coming To Your Netflix Queue
Russian billionaire Abramovich runs into UK visa issues
Pompeo threatens US will 'crush' Iran through sanctions and pressure campaign
Hawaii lava reaches ocean, brings new danger
Billboard Music Awards: Khalid and Normani Deliver Rousing Performance of "Love Lies"
Trump demands U.S. justice department see if FBI infiltrated his 2016 election campaign
Robots can now complete tasks by simply observing humans
A New Policy at Starbucks: People Can Sit Without Buying Anything
China launches satellite as part of mission to explore moon's dark side
Venezuela says President re-elected; US calls it a 'sham'
Turkey's Erdogan seeks votes in Bosnia after ban on campaigning elsewhere
Oliver North Blames School Shootings On Ritalin
Premier League transfer news: Gianluigi Buffon, Willian, Robert Lewandowski
John Cena and Nikki Bella PICTURED: WWE Superstars reunite in San Diego after breaking engagement
One dead and another injured in a cougar attack in Washington state
Basketball great Bill Russell released from hospital
Trump misspells Melania's name in tweet on return to White House from hospital
Cuba mourns more than 100 killed in plane crash
Watch: The royal wedding in 90 seconds
Juventus mark Buffon's last match and raise Serie A trophy
Meghan Markle reveals second royal wedding dress as she heads to Frogmore House
Chelsea’s Eden Hazard spot-on to sink Manchester United and win FA Cup
At least 10 people killed in Texas high school shooting, suspect in custody
Victoria Beckham arrives for the royal wedding in a figure hugging navy pencil dress
Meghan Markle royal wedding dress first look as she enters chapel to marry Prince Harry
Harry and Meghan to be Duke and Duchess of Sussex
FA Cup final: Man Utd could make interesting decision for Chelsea clash - Martin Keown
Royal wedding dress code: What will guests be wearing for Meghan and Harry nuptials?
Flowers for Merkel as pair meet on back of Trump pressure
Prince Charles saves the day: Meghan Markle to walk down aisle with new father-in-law
Police shoot man firing gun inside Trump hotel and ‘yelling’ about president, authorities say
SpaceX: Elon Musk details plans to get you anywhere on Earth in one hour
Europe not backing down on Iran
Box-Office Preview: 'Deadpool 2' Plots $130M-$150M Weekend Picnic
French police foil ricin terror plot and arrest Egyptian brothers
Ebola reaches DRC city, raising epidemic fears as 11 new cases confirmed
German-Russian pipeline takes shape despite protests from U.S., allies
Elon Musk brings high-tech charm offensive to Los Angeles tunnel plan
Bill Gates Says Trump Didn’t Know The Difference Between HPV And HIV
U.S. Senate confirms Haspel to be first woman CIA director
Donald Trump on North Korea summit: Kim should make deal (or face regime change)
1 adult, 1 child killed in 'horrific' accident involving school bus and dump truck in New Jersey
Trump Jr called blocked number before and after Trump Tower meeting. Who was it?
Gianluigi Buffon to leave Juventus but is considering 'interesting proposals'
Amy Schumer says royal wedding is going to 'suck,' compares day to Westminster Dog Show
National Geographic’s Clever New Cover Contains Chilling Warning About Plastics
Scientists suspect banned chemical that destroys ozone layer being secretly manufactured
Trump calls some unauthorized immigrants ‘animals’ in White House rant
Democrats Force Vote To Keep Net Neutrality Rules
Stephen Colbert Wants Mueller To Give Trump A Special Anniversary Gift
Nassar victims will receive Arthur Ashe Courage Award
Trump: 'We'll see' if North Korea summit is on after Kim's threat to cancel
China's private space sector ready for liftoff
Yanny or Laurel? Audio clip spurs social media debate
NASA satellite falls to Earth after 2 decades in space
Facebook Removed More Than 500 Million Fake Accounts In First Quarter Of 2018
Malaysian political leader Anwar Ibrahim walks free after royal pardon
Diplomatic WAR escalates as Turkey and Israel EXPEL ambassadors following Twitter spat
Meet Tesla's new bondholder: Billionaire George Soros
Deadpool Crashes Colbert's 'Late Show' Monologue
Tom Wolfe, American journalist and novelist, dies at 88
Revealed: Ecuador spent millions on spy operation for Julian Assange
Royal Wedding U-TURN: Meghan Markle's dad CHANGES MIND and now wants to go to Windsor
Putin: New weapons will maintain Russia's might for decades
North Korea threatens to cancel US meeting over American military drills with South Korea, report says
Ariana Grande and Jimmy Fallon Perform "No Tears Left to Cry" Using Nintendo Labo Cardboard Instruments
Bohemian Rhapsody: first trailer of Queen and Freddie Mercury biopic released
The Honor 10 is exactly the budget Huawei P20 Pro we were expecting
Jlloyd Samuel, former Aston Villa and Bolton defender, dies in car crash
Global protests grow after Israeli killing of Palestinian protesters
Bernie Sanders' son slams Democratic Party, Hillary Clinton
Kristen Stewart goes barefoot on Cannes Film Festival red carpet, rebels against heel rule
Colbert Savages ‘Peace-Treaty Barbie And Collusion Ken’ Over Embassy Opening
Meghan Markle, Prince Harry ask for privacy for her father who won't attend wedding
Trump, China, ZTE and the art of the deal
In pictures: Deadliest day in Gaza since 2014
Margot Kidder, Superman's Lois Lane, dies aged 69
Meghan Markle's dad has ‘heart attack and will NOT attend wedding' after photo scandal
White House blames Hamas for dozens of deaths in Gaza protests
Melania Trump undergoes kidney surgery at Walter Reed medical center
Alfie Evans funeral LIVE: ‘Our Hero’ Thousands line streets of Liverpool to say goodbye
Armenia's new PM meets with Russia's Putin for the 1st time
Facebook suspends ~200 suspicious apps out of “thousands” reviewed so far
37 Palestinians killed in Gaza protests ahead of US Embassy opening
'SHE'S PARANOID': Hillary Clinton WARNS Australia of China and Russian 'INTERFERENCE'
British reality TV star Joe Tilley found dead at bottom of waterfall in Colombia
France gives Brexit ULTIMATUM to finalise Irish border issue by NEXT MONTH
Trump’s decision to open Jerusalem embassy complicates promise to seek peace
Powerful storms kill at least 40 across northern India
Shiite cleric al-Sadr leads in Iraq's initial vote results
Noisy Hawaiian volcano lava fissure prompts more evacuations
Salma Hayek: male Hollywood stars should take pay cut
Lewis Hamilton wins Spanish Grand Prix to stretch lead in F1 title race
Ivanka Trump in Jerusalem for embassy opening as Gaza braces for bloodshed
Trump team sends mixed signals to Europe
Trump says US working with China to save ZTE
BREAKING: British tourists kidnapped by gang in Congo have been RELEASED
Catalonia's radical separatists clear way for new leader
John Bolton says North Korea has prospect to become 'a normal nation'
One million students join calls for vote on Brexit deal
Tessa Jowell dead: Labour MP dies at 70 after year-long battle with brain cancer
Trump thanks North Korea for plan to dismantle nuke site
Amy Schumer Honors Moms and Plays a Conservative Actress in 'SNL' Hosting Gig
Netta Barzilai of Israel wins Eurovision Song Contest
Attacker yells 'Allahu Akbar,' stabs five in Paris before police take him down
At least 10 killed in Indonesia church attacks
Cardi B disappears from social media after Azealia Banks’ shade
Eurovision 2018: STOP WHINGING Britain! Euro-experts say contest non-political
Yes, NASA Is Actually Sending a Helicopter to Mars: Here's What It Will Do
North Korea Outlines Plans To Dismantle Nuclear Test Sites
WORLD CUP: Moscow a vast and varied destination
Video: Cop beat up teen daughter in school office as employees looked on
Der Spiegel Cover Portrays Trump As A Finger Flipping Off Europe
Trump claims he saved almost $999,800,000 on US embassy in Jerusalem
Mike Pompeo offers aid to North Korea in exchange for forfeiting nukes
Google sells the future, powered by your personal data
Robot dogs that freaked people by opening doors out may soon come to a building near you
'Brooklyn Nine-Nine' Officially Revived at NBC
Iraq elections: Voters head to the polls at critical time
Two Britons kidnapped in the Democratic Republic of the Congo
At meeting with automakers, Trump launches new attack on NAFTA
Kremlin: US move on Iran brings Russia and Europe closer
Police confirm death of Frightened Rabbit singer Scott Hutchison
John Kelly: Trump ‘Somewhat Embarrassed’ About Russia Probe
SpaceX Aborts 1st Launch of Upgraded Falcon 9 Rocket at the Last Minute
Rihanna's wedding night advice for Meghan Markle and Prince Harry
Emmanuel Macron preaches European unity amid U.S. tensions
'He's dying anyway': White House official mocked Sen. John McCain, reports say
Elon Musk's first underground LA tunnel could be ready to ride in a few months
7 Killed In What May Be Australia’s Worst Mass Shooting Since 1996
Cisco has yanked all its ads from YouTube
ISIS: Trump says five 'most wanted' leaders captured
Putin scores 5 goals in exhibition hockey game
David Goodall tells CNN: I 'welcome' death
Trump reveals details of meeting with Kim Jong Un
Wayne Rooney agrees to join DC United
Has NASA found aliens? Discovery of habitable planets with seasons could reveal alien life
Monica Lewinsky says she was uninvited from event when Bill Clinton decided to attend
Trump signs Holocaust property law that has angered Poland
Malaysia's former leader set to become world's oldest PM at 92
The Latest: Israel says 'nearly all' Iranian targets hit
President Trump greets American prisoners freed by North Korea
Israel and Iran's most direct confrontation
Boris Johnson and Ivanka Trump photo MOCKED on Twitter: ‘CREEPIER version of your daddy'
CIA nominee Gina Haspel says ‘tough lessons’ learned from interrogation
Amy Schumer Struggles With 'SNL' Facts in Behind-the-Scenes Tour
Trump rules out DMZ as location for North Korea summit
New outbreak of Ebola kills 17 in Democratic Republic of Congo 
MIDDLE EAST CRISIS: Saudi Arabia ATTACKED as country's air defence intercepts TWO missiles
SpaceX set to debut newest Falcon 9 Rocket: 'Block 5'
Late-Night Hosts Weigh in on U.S. Pulling Out of Iran Deal
US officials concerned Iran could attack Israel
US company linked to Russian oligarch paid $500K to Trump's personal attorney
Iran nuclear deal: Donald Trump sends EU into a PANIC with decision to pull US from pact
Trump: Pompeo heading to North Korea to arrange summit with Kim Jong Un
Trump announces withdrawal from Iran nuclear deal, isolating him further from world
Close