Close
Date TimeMarch 25, 2018
VoiceAfter an Ars Technica report that Facebook surreptitiously scrapes call and text message data from Android phones and has done so for years, the scandal-burdened company has responded that it only collects that information from users who have given permission.
Facebook denies it collects call and SMS data from phones without permission
Facebook’s public statement, posted on its press site, comes a couple of days after it took out full page newspaper ads to apologize for the misuse of data by third-party apps as it copes with fallout from the Cambridge Analytica scandal (follow the story as it develops here). In the ad, founder and chief executive officer Mark Zuckerberg wrote “We have a responsibility to protect your information. If we can’t, we don’t deserve it.”
The company’s response to the Ars Technica story, however, struck a different tone, with Facebook titling the post “Fact Check: Your Call and SMS History.” It said “You may have seen some recent reports that Facebook has been logging people’s call and SMS (text) history without their permission. This is not the case,” before going on to explain that call and text history logging is included with an opt-in feature on Messenger or Facebook Lite for Android that “people have to expressly agree to use” and that they can turn off at any time, which would also delete any call and text data shared with that app.
Ars Technica has already amended its original post with a response to Facebook’s statement, saying it contradicts several of its findings, including the experience of users who shared their data with the publication.
“In my case, a review of my Google Play data confirms that Messenger was never installed on the Android devices I used,” wrote Ars Technica IT and national security editor Sean Gallagher in the amendment to his post. “Facebook was installed on a Nexus tablet I used and on the Blackphone 2 in 2015, and there was never an explicit message requesting access to phone call and SMS data. Yet there is call data from the end of 2015 until late 2016, when I reinstalled the operating system on the Blackphone 2 and wiped all applications.”
In its statement, Facebook said “Contact importers are fairly common among social apps and services as a way to more easily find the people you want to connect with. This was first introduced in Messenger in 2015, and later offered as an option in Facebook Lite, a lightweight version of Facebook for Android .”
When people first sign up for Messenger or Facebook Lite on Android or log into Messenger on an Android device, they see a screen giving them the option to continuously upload contacts as well as call and text history. Facebook added that on Messenger, users are then given three options: to turn the feature on, “learn more” for more information or “not now” to skip it. On Facebook Lite, they get two options: turn it on or skip. If users who opted in change their minds later, Facebook said they could turn it off in the app’s settings, with the option of turning off continuous call and text history logging while keeping contact uploading enabled or deleting all contact information they’ve uploaded from that app.”
Facebook emphasized in bold text that it “never sell this data, and this feature does not collect the content of your text messages or calls.”
Even though the opt-in screens do state that granting permission will “continuously upload info” about contacts and call and text history, it is arguable that many users don’t really understand what that means and that instead of saying “this lets friends find each other on Facebook and helps us create a better experience for everyone” (a message sweetened with a saccharine cartoon of a figure texting a little heart), Facebook should really be giving more details about what exactly will be recorded and why.
With the Cambridge Analytica scandal still fresh on everyone’s minds, Facebook’s apparent willingness to place the onus for protecting personal data on users who already feel victimized is unlikely to help them regain any goodwill. But even people who truly understand the implications of the feature and chose to opt-in anyway did so assuming that their data would be guarded as Facebook promised. As the Cambridge Analytica fiasco threw into sharp relief, that hasn’t always been the case.

Related Stories
President Trump Is the Latest Critic of Facebooks LibraPresident Trump Is the Latest Critic of Facebook's Libra
Heres the tech behind Facebooks Libra cryptocurrencyHere's the tech behind Facebook's Libra cryptocurrency
Facebook, Instagram And WhatsApp Are Down, AgainFacebook, Instagram And WhatsApp Are Down, Again
Thousands of people have taken a Facebook pledge to storm Area 51 to see them aliensThousands of people have taken a Facebook pledge to storm Area 51 to 'see them aliens'
Aliens, 10,000-year-old UFOs and gravity waves: What do we actually know about Area 51?Aliens, 10,000-year-old UFOs and gravity waves: What do we actually know about Area 51?
Bitcoin rallies 15% topping $13,000Bitcoin rallies 15% topping $13,000
Facebook’s ‘cryptocurrency’ Libra has nothing to do with BitcoinFacebook’s ‘cryptocurrency’ Libra has nothing to do with Bitcoin
Creator of ‘Storm Area 51’ comes forward after Facebook page takes offCreator of ‘Storm Area 51’ comes forward after Facebook page takes off
Keeping up with the Google Nest Hub: The best smart displays of 2019Keeping up with the Google Nest Hub: The best smart displays of 2019
Facebooks photo outage reveals how AI sees your photosFacebook's photo outage reveals how AI sees your photos
News Trends
Courteney Cox posts epic pool video: This is the best video of all timeCourteney Cox posts 'epic' pool video: 'This is the best video of all time'
Chelsea Clinton announces birth of third childChelsea Clinton announces birth of third child
Trump, first lady pay their respects to late Justice StevensTrump, first lady pay their respects to late Justice Stevens
‘Definitely not in any trouble’: UFC champ Jon Jones fires back at strip club battery claims‘Definitely not in any trouble’: UFC champ Jon Jones fires back at strip club battery claims
Tom Brady is being dad-shamed after diving off a cliff with his 6-year-old daughterTom Brady is being dad-shamed after diving off a cliff with his 6-year-old daughter
Sure, Boris Johnson is funny. But has he ever done a job well?Sure, Boris Johnson is funny. But has he ever done a job well?
Jo Swinson elected new Lib Dem leaderJo Swinson elected new Lib Dem leader
‘Fast  Furious 9’ Halts Production After Stuntman Injured on Set‘Fast Furious 9’ Halts Production After Stuntman Injured on Set
Strictly Come Dancing: Oti Mabuses Sister Motsi Joins Show As New JudgeStrictly Come Dancing: Oti Mabuse's Sister Motsi Joins Show As New Judge
How Leonardo DiCaprio Became Hollywoods Last Movie StarHow Leonardo DiCaprio Became Hollywood's Last Movie Star
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Related Stories
President Trump Is the Latest Critic of Facebooks LibraPresident Trump Is the Latest Critic of Facebook's Libra
Heres the tech behind Facebooks Libra cryptocurrencyHere's the tech behind Facebook's Libra cryptocurrency
Facebook, Instagram And WhatsApp Are Down, AgainFacebook, Instagram And WhatsApp Are Down, Again
Thousands of people have taken a Facebook pledge to storm Area 51 to see them aliensThousands of people have taken a Facebook pledge to storm Area 51 to 'see them aliens'
Aliens, 10,000-year-old UFOs and gravity waves: What do we actually know about Area 51?Aliens, 10,000-year-old UFOs and gravity waves: What do we actually know about Area 51?
Bitcoin rallies 15% topping $13,000Bitcoin rallies 15% topping $13,000
Facebook’s ‘cryptocurrency’ Libra has nothing to do with BitcoinFacebook’s ‘cryptocurrency’ Libra has nothing to do with Bitcoin
Creator of ‘Storm Area 51’ comes forward after Facebook page takes offCreator of ‘Storm Area 51’ comes forward after Facebook page takes off
Keeping up with the Google Nest Hub: The best smart displays of 2019Keeping up with the Google Nest Hub: The best smart displays of 2019
Facebooks photo outage reveals how AI sees your photosFacebook's photo outage reveals how AI sees your photos
News Trends
Courteney Cox posts epic pool video: This is the best video of all timeCourteney Cox posts 'epic' pool video: 'This is the best video of all time'
Chelsea Clinton announces birth of third childChelsea Clinton announces birth of third child
Trump, first lady pay their respects to late Justice StevensTrump, first lady pay their respects to late Justice Stevens
‘Definitely not in any trouble’: UFC champ Jon Jones fires back at strip club battery claims‘Definitely not in any trouble’: UFC champ Jon Jones fires back at strip club battery claims
Tom Brady is being dad-shamed after diving off a cliff with his 6-year-old daughterTom Brady is being dad-shamed after diving off a cliff with his 6-year-old daughter
Sure, Boris Johnson is funny. But has he ever done a job well?Sure, Boris Johnson is funny. But has he ever done a job well?
Jo Swinson elected new Lib Dem leaderJo Swinson elected new Lib Dem leader
‘Fast  Furious 9’ Halts Production After Stuntman Injured on Set‘Fast Furious 9’ Halts Production After Stuntman Injured on Set
Strictly Come Dancing: Oti Mabuses Sister Motsi Joins Show As New JudgeStrictly Come Dancing: Oti Mabuse's Sister Motsi Joins Show As New Judge
How Leonardo DiCaprio Became Hollywoods Last Movie StarHow Leonardo DiCaprio Became Hollywood's Last Movie Star
Leaders
Donald-TrumpDonald Trump
45th President of the United States of America
Mike-PenceMike Pence
Vice President of the United States
Theresa-MayTheresa May
British Prime Minister
Angela-MerkelAngela Merkel
Chancellor of Germany
Emmanuel-MacronEmmanuel Macron
President of France
Justin-TrudeauJustin Trudeau
Prime Minister of Canada
Nancy-PelosiNancy Pelosi
Speaker of the United States House of Representatives
Barack-ObamaBarack Obama
44th U.S. President
Vladimir-PutinVladimir Putin
Russian President
Shinzo-AbeShinzō Abe
Prime Minister of Japan
Stormy Daniels interview adds to '60 Minutes' legacy of big hits
Saharan sandstorm turns Russia snow orange
Saudi Arabia intercepts 7 missiles fired from Yemen, military officials say
What you need to know ahead of Stormy Daniels' '60 Minutes' interview
Facebook logs texts and calls, users find as they delete accounts
Rome terror fears: Bomb alert hours after military launch terrorist manhunt in capital
SHOCK VIDEO: Horror moment police officer 'slashed with SWORD' in Manchester attack
Apple CEO Tim Cook Calls for 'Well-Crafted' Regulations on Data Privacy After Facebook Controversy
‘Black Panther’ Makes Box Office History!
Santorum: Instead of calling for gun laws, kids should take CPR classes
Day after March for Our Lives, Pope Francis uses Palm Sunday sermon to urge youths to lead
'Owen Smith jumped the gun!' Peston BLASTS Labour over 'inevitable' second referendum move
Kim Kardashian suffers photoshop faux pas as she attends March for Our Lives protest
BREAKING: Four children dead and 10 injured as huge blaze rips through shopping centre
'Bordering on BANDITRY' Putin attacks UK as tensions SOAR over Russian spy poisoning
Chinese Space Station's Crash to Earth: Everything You Need to Know
Catalonia's ex-leader Carles Puigdemont detained in Germany, lawyer says
I downloaded 14 years of my data on Facebook. Here's what I found
For Stoneman Douglas Alums, Witnessing Tragedy From Afar Sprung Them Into Action
BREAKING: Five men arrested on Thomas Cook flight from Manchester to Las Vegas
BREAKING: South Korea ferry crash - 192 stranded after ship CRASHES into rocks
Obama's message to marchers: 'You're leading us forward'
What Melania now has in common with Hillary
Australian GP: Sebastian Vettel repeats 2017 victory in season-opener
March for Our Lives: Martin Luther King Jr.'s granddaughter has dream 'enough is enough'
Lights go dark for Earth Hour to focus on climate change
White House 'applauds' historic gun control march but no word from Trump
Boat Race 2018 LIVE: Oxford v Cambridge - live updates
Kim Kardashian West fan had $500,000 surgery to resemble her
In pictures: The March for Our Lives protests
March for Our Lives: hundreds of thousands demand end to gun violence
Cameron Bancroft ball-tampering claims mar South Africa v Australia
Paris Jackson reportedly dating super-model Cara Delevingne
New Tavis Smiley witnesses detail sexual misconduct
What Do You Do With $184 Billion? Here's What Elon Musk Is Likely to Do With It
Investigators search Cambridge Analytica's London offices
Car bomb EXPLODES - one dead and three wounded as Alexandria rocked by blast
Game Day: Patrick Corbin, Diamondbacks take on Indians in Goodyear
March for our Lives protests planned for 800 places across the world
Vettel quickest in final Australian GP practice
First non-stop flight between Australia and UK set for take-off
Violent protests break out in Barcelona - riot police on scene
2 Americans, 1 Russian dock with International Space Station
140 whales die on Australian beach
Trump bars most transgender people from military
French officer who offered himself for hostage in supermarket attack dies
A timeline of DACA offers Trump has rejected
NFL star Michael Bennett indicted over injury to paraplegic woman at Super Bowl 51
Trump signs budget deal after raising government shutdown threat
Watch Will Smith and Jimmy Fallon Perform the History of Sitcom Themes
Serena Williams Posts Inspiring Message After Defeat At Miami Open
Jimmy Carter briefed by White House on North Korea
Hostage-taker killed at supermarket, two victims
Elon Musk DELETES SpaceX and Tesla Facebook pages after Twitter challenge
Ibrahimovic leaves Manchester United to sign with LA Galaxy
Putin thanks voters for 'greatest support in modern Russia’s history'
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle in Northern Ireland: Couple's rapturous welcome on unannounced visit
Russian foreign minister: ‘UK stance on Skripal is pushing us to brink of WAR’
5 facts about John Bolton, Trump's new national security adviser
One killed in French supermarket hostage-taking
At least 13 dead and 27 injured as MASSIVE FIRE rips through Vietnam city
Karen McDougal to Melania: I'm sorry for sleeping with Donald Trump
Pakistan celebrates National Day with military parade
Ex-Playboy model says she kept journal of days she met with Trump
Trump replaces H.R. McMaster as national security adviser with John Bolton
Protesters block NBA arena over fatal Sacramento police shooting
Mysterious tiny skeleton found in Chile was human girl with rare genetic mutations, scientists say
PARIS ERUPTS: Furious scenes on streets of France as THOUSANDS rally against Macron
UK passport humiliation: French DEMAND passports are printed in France – UK capitulates
Russia blasts Boris Johnson's Putin-Hitler comparison as insulting, 'totally irresponsible'
James Corden Stole a Candle From Mariah Carey's House Before Filming 'Carpool Karaoke'
Trump Administration Appointee Worked At Cambridge Analytica
Dalai Lama cuts foreign travel due to age, exhaustion
Toys 'R' Us founder Charles Lazarus dies
Donald Trump's top Russia lawyer John Dowd resigns
Giants trading Jason Pierre-Paul to Buccaneers
World Water Day: Deadly plight of Brazil's river defenders goes unheard
Trump attacks Joe Biden amid reports of 2020 presidential run
BREAKING: Dutch parliament horror as man plummets from balcony during MP’s speech
PARIS ERUPTS: Furious scenes on streets of France as THOUSANDS rally against Macron
French ex-leader Sarkozy says he is accused without evidence
Assad closer to Ghouta victory, as some rebels prepare to quit
World's best airports for 2018 named by Skytrax
De La Rue rocked as key executive quits and trading disappoints
Post-Brexit passports set to be made by Franco-Dutch firm
Donald Trump’s 'LASER WAR' with Russia - top secret 'air manipulating' weapon revealed
North Korea: Kim Jong-un MYSTERIES that may be UNCOVERED in historic meeting with Trump
Report: Famed Iranian philosopher Shayegan dies at age 83
Police Found Recorded ‘Confession’ On Austin Bomber’s Cellphone
Facebook founder 'really sorry,' willing to appear before Congress
Elon Musk could become the richest man alive
Stephen Hawking’s ashes to rest near graves of Darwin, Newton
Mark Zuckerberg breaks his silence on Cambridge Analytica scandal
Boris Johnson compares Russian World Cup to Hitler's 1936 Olympics
Texas 'bomber' who blew himself up named as Mark Anthony Conditt, 24, as FBI fear more parcel bombs planted in Austin
Billionaire JB Pritzker wins Illinois Democratic governor primary on strength of $70 million campaign
Sky Reports 11.5 Percent Gender Pay Gap in U.K
Cambridge Analytica CEO: I met Trump 'many times'
Austin bombing suspect is dead, sources say
Ant McPartlin 'could have wiped out my family' says father involved in crash
Saudi Arabia crown prince hails ‘opportunities’ for closer economic ties with U.S. during Trump meeting
Barack Obama arrives in New Zealand for 3-day visit
Israel formally acknowledges destroying suspected Syrian reactor in 2007
Late-Night Hosts Rip Trump for Congratulating Putin on Re-Election
Selena Gomez Dismantles The ‘Beauty Myth’ After Being Body Shamed
Two more package bombs explode in Texas
Facebook execs frustrated by Zuckerberg's silence
YouTuber Count Dankula Who Taught Dog Nazi Salute Faces Jail For Hate Crime
Princess Diana’s secret affairs: How Paul Burrell smuggled Di’s men into Kensington Palace
The Latest: Trump calls Putin on re-election victory
UK Parliament Asks Zuckerberg to Testify in Data Misuse Case
Russian diplomats expelled from UK head back to Moscow
REALLY? Macron congratulates Putin on election 'SUCCESS' just days after ‘EU unity letter’
The Latest: Storms damage homes, knock out power in Georgia
Shooting at Great Mills High School in Maryland, school confirms
How to opt out of Facebook's Platform data sharing
First lady to hold first public event on cyberbullying
Device explodes in FedEx building outside San Antonio, police say
James Corden: Trump’s ‘Madman’ Tweets Suggest 1 Thing
New York City Council Launches Probe Into Kushner Firm’s False Tenant Records
Meghan Markle and Prince Harry reveal details of wedding cake
In Egypt election, el-Sissi imposes stability over democracy
Former French president Sarkozy in police custody - source
World's largest SSD capacity now stands at 100TB
SpaceX rival United Launch Alliance stakes future on new Vulcan rocket
Facebook's value plunges $37 billion on data controversy
World's last male northern white rhino dies
Sex and the City's Cynthia Nixon announces candidacy for governor of New York
Self-driving Uber kills Arizona woman in first fatal crash involving pedestrian
Barcelona embassy hostage situation: Diplomat's wife held as police surround building
Allison Janney Reveals Origin of 'I Did It All By Myself' Oscars Acceptance Speech Joke
Engine failure forces Ivanka, Jared's helicopter to return to airport
UK and EU agree terms for Brexit transition deal
Jim Carrey criticized for portrait believed to be Sarah Huckabee Sanders
British woman Anna Campbell who joined all-female fighting unit killed in Syria
Trump launches WAR on WTO - Brussels panic as EU admits ‘we need a plan B’
UK schools in bomb threat: Evacuations as parents told 'collect your children NOW'
Turkish embassy in Denmark attacked with firebombs
Roger Federer loses to Juan Martin del Potro in Indian Wells final
NCAA tournament 2018: Another No. 1 seed falls as Florida State rallies past Xavier
U.S. and British lawmakers demand answers from Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg after misuse of data
Vladimir Putin dismisses claims Russia was behind Salisbury attack after winning fourth term as president
Trump pushed White House staff to sign non-disclosure agreements: report
2 injured in Austin explosion, authorities say
Aung San Suu Kyi cancels rare public appearance in Australia
Vladimir Putin decisively re-elected as Russian president – preliminary results
U.S. congressman offers Andrew McCabe temporary job so he can access retirement benefits
Here's how to find out which apps have access to your Facebook data
Putin Wins Russia’s Presidential Election: Exit Poll
SEND BREAD! UK snow sparks panic buying CHAOS as supermarket shelves stripped bare
MotoGP 2018 Preview: 9 Things To Watch Out For
Trump rails against Mueller investigation, dismisses McCabe’s notes as ‘Fake Memos’
Two dead after shooting at North York bowling alley
Comedian and actor Mike MacDonald dead at 63
Israel says it destroys new Hamas tunnel network in Gaza
After McCabe firing, Trump attacks FBI, and his lawyer says Russia probe must end
Turkish troops seize Syrian city center from Kurdish fighters
India SLAMS Pakistan for ‘BLOCKING access to websites’ amid rising World War 3 fears
Russian Ambassador Alexander Yakovenko Says Britain Is Using Salisbury Poisoning 'To Divert Attention From Brexit'
Russians vote in presidential election across 11 time zones
White House staffer left encrypted email passwords at bus stop – report
NCAA tournament 2018: Michigan stuns Houston with buzzer-beater by Jordan Poole
What Stephen Hawking said about God, his atheism — and his own death
Syria’s new exiles: Kurds flee Afrin after Turkish assault
Cambridge Analytica: links to Moscow oil firm and St Petersburg university
Iran warns Donald Trump of 'PAINFUL MISTAKE' in stark THREAT over nuclear deal
Significant moments in Putin's 18 years of power
Your Toys 'R' Us closing questions answered
Professor sues Cambridge Analytica to find out what it knows about him
Mohamed Salah hits awesome four as Liverpool romp past Watford
Kurds protest in Germany against Turkish govt, 3 arrested
Here's how Facebook allowed Cambridge Analytica to get data for 50 million users
Ireland seal grand slam in style at Twickenham
Cambridge Analytica responds to Facebook announcement
Miami bridge collapse: engineer's answerphone message about crack not heard
Melania Trump wears emerald green for St Patrick's Day celebration
Snow in LONDON: Capital hit as latest Met Office weather forecast gives warnings across UK
Pope goes to Italy's south to honor popular saint, Padre Pio
10 dead after small plane crashes into house in the Philippines
Russia expels 23 UK diplomats as fallout over nerve agent attack grows
FIFA gives VAR the green light for 2018 World Cup
‘Unforgivable’: Kremlin blasts Boris Johnson for blaming Putin for Skripal poisoning
Adrian Lamo, hacker who reported Chelsea Manning to FBI, dies aged 37
Former FBI deputy director Andrew McCabe fired two days before he planned to retire
Xi reappointed as China's president with no term limits
Facebook suspends Cambridge Analytica, data firm that aided Trump campaign
Trump’s Legal Team Says It Can Sue Stormy Daniels For $20 Million
US pushes for changes to Iran deal
Snapchat stock loses $800M after Rihanna responds to offensive ad
Police launch murder inquiry over death of Nikolai Glushkov
Ivanka Trump REPLACES Rex Tillerson for South Korea meeting as North Korea talks loom
Steve Jobs' 1973 job application sells for over $174K
Jennifer Garner Tries to Explain Her Viral Oscars Moment
Bill Hader and Jimmy Fallon Try Not to Crack Up During Funny-Face Game
Stormy Daniels' attorney claims she was physically threatened
Spain in CHAOS: Streets of Spanish capital Madrid in FLAMES as SHOCKING riots break out
Your personal data may be on the Dark Web: What you need to know
Russia to expand American 'blacklist' after new US sanctions
Robert Mueller Reportedly Subpoenas The Trump Organization
Facebook autocomplete search result shocks users
Close