Close
Date TimeMarch 09, 2018
VoiceEvidence is growing that the ‘sunshine vitamin’ helps protect against a wide range of conditions including cancers
Is vitamin D really a cure-all – and how should we get our fix?
Vitamin D is having quite a moment. In the past few months, evidence has been growing that the “sunshine vitamin” not only has an important role in bone and muscle health, but might also help prevent a range of cancers, reduce the chance of developing rheumatoid arthritis, protect against multiple sclerosis and cut the risk of colds and flu.
But is vitamin D truly a cure-all? And if the benefits are real, should we all be taking vitamin D supplements or even fortifying our foods?
Vitamin D is not one chemical, but a label that covers a group of substances, including vitamin D2 and D3. The latter is the form made when sunlight hits your skin and is also found in other animals. Non-animal sources such as fungi and yeasts primarily produce the D2 form. Once in the body, these substances are converted into biologically active steroids that circulate in the blood.
One area where the impact on health appears to be clear is vitamin D’s role in keeping bones and teeth healthy and improving muscle strength.
“The musculoskeletal stuff is really good and really strong,” said Helen Bond, a spokesperson for the British Dietetic Association, pointing out that vitamin D is important in calcium and phosphate absorption.
Too little vitamin D can be serious: the skeletal disorders osteomalacia and rickets are known to be caused by a vitamin D deficiency, and the latter is on the rise in the UK, a finding some put down to the impact of poverty on poor nutrition.
But do the wider health claims stand up?
“Intuition suggests that it can’t all be right,” said Julia Newton-Bishop, professor of dermatology and vitamin D expert from the University of Leeds. But while a recent review of evidence by the scientific advisory committee on nutrition only found strong evidence in the case of bone and muscle health, Newton-Bishop says a growing body of research is exploring other conditions.
Newton-Bishop says the fact that receptors for vitamin D are present on a huge array of body cells suggests the substance might indeed play a central role in our health, adding that human history offers further evidence: as humans moved to higher latitudes, skin tone became paler. “[One] explanation is that vitamin D was so important that that was a selective pressure,” she said. “The fact that Inuits aren’t pale-skinned and for millennia they have had an exclusively fish diet is an argument for the fact that vitamin D was a driver, because why would they be different to everyone else?”
Martin Hewison, professor of molecular endocrinology at the University of Birmingham, who carried out the recent study into vitamin D and rheumatoid arthritis, said evidence from cell studies backs up the idea that the vitamin is important.
“In most of the models, vitamin D appears to have quite a positive effect,” he said. “If you are using cancer cell lines or cancer cells, vitamin D has anti-cancer effects, and likewise in cells that have been used for models for infection and immune disorders, vitamin D has quite clear antibacterial and anti-inflammatory effects.”
But when it comes to studies in humans, the picture is far from clear-cut. While some studies find links to diseases, others do not.
That, say experts, could be partly down to the way they are conducted – for example, not all studies take into account the starting levels of vitamin D in participants, or they may have been carried out in populations with different genetic factors that might affect the impact of vitamin D.
Other experts have doubts about vitamin D’s influence. Prof Tim Spector, author of The Diet Myth, wrote in the Independent: “The evidence so far suggests (with the possible exception of multiple sclerosis and some cancers) that low vitamin D levels are either irrelevant or merely a marker of the disease.”
Hewison says that while vitamin D might help prevent certain conditions such as tuberculosis, respiratory infections and autoimmune diseases, it should not be seen as a cure for them. “It is good at protecting against things,” he said, “but once a disease is settled in, it is unlikely you are going to be able to give somebody who has got prostate cancer vitamin D and it is going to get dramatically better.”
What about the case for supplements? With some having previously been found to cause more harm than good, Newton-Bishop says caution towards this apparent panacea is unsurprising. “Everyone within the cancer world is nervous about supplements,” she said. “I would say to patients don’t take supplements, with the exception of avoiding a low vitamin D level.”
But how low is low? With the amount of sunlight needed varying with genetics, skin colour, time of day, how much one covers up and a host of other factors, the scientific advisory committee on nutrition said it was too difficult to say how much sun we need to make sure our vitamin D levels are up to scratch. In any case, from October until March the sun in the UK isn’t strong enough to do the job.
The upshot is that national guidelines now recommend that during the autumn and winter at least, individuals should consider taking supplements or boosting their intake of vitamin-D-rich foods to get an intake of 10 micrograms a day, with higher-risk individuals such as some ethnic minority groups advised to follow the guidelines all year round.
However, Bond says it is hard to get enough from diet alone.
“There are very few naturally rich sources of vitamin D, and most really good sources are of animal origin, which doesn’t bode well for vegans and vegetarians,” she said. “A serving of oily fish like mackerel will give you easily your 10 micrograms of vitamin D a day, but if you drop down to a tin of canned tuna, you are only getting 1.5 micrograms.”
And as Adrian Martineau, clinical professor of respiratory infection and immunity at Queen Mary University of London, points out, even in the summer, “sunshine isn’t going to be the answer, especially because there is an associated risk of skin cancer.”
If you are considering taking supplements, it might be worth checking which form of vitamin D they contain. “Some people don’t want an animal form of vitamin D,” said Hewison. However, “What studies have shown is that if you want to raise your blood vitamin D levels, vitamin D3 is much more efficient at doing that.”
Dr Benjamin Jacobs, a consultant paediatrician and spokesperson for the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, says supplements are not the way forward as it is hard to make sure people actually take them. Instead, he suggests the UK consider food fortification.
Some countries, including Canada and Finland, have embraced fortification of milk. But although infant formula and some breakfast cereals, plant-based milks and fruit juices are already fortified in the UK, most foods are not.
Hewison believes the government should consider a national fortification plan and that the risks of it resulting in dangerously high vitamin D intake are negligible: “I think most people in the field agree that if you want to have a large-scale improvement in people’s vitamin D levels then it can only really be done through fortified foods.”

Before Trump: 6 past high-level US visits to North Korea
Barack and Michelle Obama 'in talks with Netflix to produce series'
Tariffs, Trump and trade wars: Here's what it all means
Trump will meet with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un by May, South Korea says.
NASA mission discovers Jupiter's inner secrets
US allies are upset. The top economist quit. Trump doesn't care.
And the worst country to be a woman is ...
Davide Astori: Thousands gather for funeral of Fiorentina captain
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle urge schoolgirls to break gender stereotypes on International Women’s Day
China to build massive $1.5 billion panda conservation area
Adam Rippon Says He Would Talk to Mike Pence Post-Olympics
On first International Women’s Day since #MeToo went viral, survey asks: Has anything really changed?
Amazon's fix for creepy laughing Alexa reports will disable the 'Alexa, laugh' phrase
Big Tesla Shareholders Back Musk's $2.6 Billion Pay Package
Huffman High School shooting: Courtlin Arrington killed; Birmingham police question injured teen
Trump's immigration war with California has reached a fever pitch
Russian spy was poisoned by nerve agent, UK police believe
Saudi crown prince's UK visit prompts heavy criticism by opposition
America and Israel must stand together against a dangerous Iran
New Look Announces Store Closures In Company Voluntary Arrangement Proposal
Sri Lanka blocks social media as deadly violence continues
Forbes Billionaires 2018: Meet The Richest People On The Planet
The world's first flying car you can buy is now taking orders
Coca-Cola breaks 130-year-old tradition with first alcoholic drink
Missouri shooting: One police officer killed, 2 others injured
Colbert Has A Theory About Gary Cohn’s Sudden Departure From The White House
Porn Star Stormy Daniels Sues Trump Over Non-Disclosure Agreement
Russian cargo plane crashes in Syria, killing 39, military says
Trump Responds to Oscars' Record-Low Ratings
Jennifer Garner Pokes Fun at Her Viral Oscars Moment
Threatened with 'acid, rape, abuse': Protesting Iran's compulsory hijab law
North Korea promises no nuclear weapons use against South, hold talks with US
Porsche Positions Itself Against Tesla, on the Road and Beside It
Washington State Sets Net Neutrality Showdown As Governor Signs Law
North Korea Says It’s Open To Talking Denuclearization With The U.S.
Inside the war between Spotify and Apple
Justin Trudeau Called Donald Trump To Talk About Steel, Aluminum Tariffs And NAFTA
Paris launches 'shock' poster campaign against sexual harassment on public transport
Kremlin 'ready to cooperate' over former spy's illness in UK
Facebook says it mistakenly asked users for views on grooming
Oscars: 15 Memorable Audience Reactions
Dreamers Aren’t Safe Just Because The Courts Ruled Against Trump On DACA
Trump says Canada won’t be exempt from steel and aluminum tariffs until ‘fair’ NAFTA is signed
Terry Bryant Arrested For Stealing Frances McDormand's Oscars Trophy
Italian election results cast a pall over the European Union
'House of Cards' Debuts Teaser for Final, Kevin Spacey-Less Season
Russia will ‘never’ extradite citizens accused by U.S., Putin says
ISIS suspects arrested after US Embassy in Turkey closed due to 'security threat'
What Is an Inclusion Rider? Frances McDormand's Oscars Speech Explained
Victory for Eurosceptic, populist parties shocks the establishment in Italy election
Fans react to Allison Janney's first Oscar win
Oscars 2018: The Winner’s List
Oscars Embrace 'The Shape of Water' In a Consciously Inclusive Ceremony
Oscars: Watch All of the Musical Performances From the Show
Fiorentina captain Davide Astori dies of 'sudden illness' at 31, team says
Leicester explosion: sixth man arrested
Women march in London to call for gender equality
Theresa May tells Trump of 'deep concern' over US trade tariff plans
Watch out for this clever credit card scam
Amazon To Stop Selling Google's Nest Products
Northeast Storm Leaves At Least 9 Dead, More Than 1.5 Million Without Power
Senator Says Kushner Must Go If He Shaped Foreign Policy To Aid Family Business
Trump tells Gridiron: North Korea 'called up' and 'would like to talk'
Theresa May Rejects 'Passporting' For City Of London After Brexit
BREAKING: Sir Roger Bannister dead - First to run a mile in under four minutes dies at 88
WATCH: Moment topless activist confronts Silvio Berlusconi as he casts vote
'President for life' not a bad idea, Trump says of China proposal
South Korea to send high-level officials to North for talks
Spirit Awards: Greta Gerwig Wins Best Screenplay for 'Lady Bird'
Donald Trump jokes about White House chaos at Gridiron Dinner: 'Who will be next to leave? Steve Miller, or Melania?'
Italy goes to the polls after divisive election campaign
MH370 disappearance 4 years on, Malaysia to end search in June
'SNL': Alec Baldwin's Donald Trump Rambles on Gun Control, Wakanda in Cold Open
White House on lockdown and staff told to take shelter after gunman SHOOTS HIMSELF
Beyoncé returns to a vegan diet
Need a North Korean Missile? Call the Cairo Embassy
Where Hollywood Stars and Insiders Are Watching the Oscars
Putin tells U.S. to send evidence of vote meddling
Why 'Get Out' is the future of the Oscars
Lebanon PM posts selfie with Saudi crown prince after strain
Razzie Awards name 'The Emoji Movie' worst film of 2017
Ex-GOP Senate candidate Roy Moore pleads for money to cover legal fees
Police arrest Michigan college student suspected of killing parents
Jennifer Lawrence, Jodie Foster to present Best Actress at Oscars, report says
Jessica Alba to Star Alongside Gabrielle Union in NBC's 'Bad Boys' Spinoff
Report: Muslims Were Attacked At Least 950 Times In Germany In 2017
Central Michigan University shooting TWO DEAD - ALL schools in city on lockdown
Theresa May says Brexit will reduce UK access to single market
What to Wear at the Oscars When You Know You're Probably Not Going to Win
Trump tweeted that “trade wars are good, and easy to win.”
President Trump Has a Message for ‘Alex’ Baldwin About His SNL Impression
GitHub Survived the Biggest DDoS Attack Ever Recorded
French embassy 'under attack' in Burkina Faso's capital
Why Silvio Berlusconi looks like stability to many Italians
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle's 'people's wedding': Hundreds of school children invited to Windsor Castle
Holi Festival 2018: Google marks Festival of Colour with dramatic doodle
Israeli police question Netanyahu in telecoms corruption case
Melania Trump Got A Green Card For Immigrants With ‘Extraordinary Abilities’
Chinese state media loves Elon Musk's latest tweets
Here's why Trump's tariffs spooked markets around the world
World Book Day 2018: teachers, send us pictures of your costumes
How to celebrate Women's History Month in Philadelphia
‘Mass casualty incident’ Ambulances rush to Houston school amid fears of major gas leak
Ex-USA Volleyball coach accused of raping six girls 'hundreds of times,' lawsuit alleges
Jennifer Lawrence Unsure If She Will Speak With Ryan Seacrest at Oscars
Prince William to make first official royal visit to Israel and Palestine
Equifax identifies additional 2.4 million customers hit by data breach
Russia developing nuclear weapons immune to interception, Putin claims
Uber Health will get patients to and from the doctor
UK snow latest: Make sure your car is fully protected from STORM EMMA with these 10 tips
Meghan Markle SPEAKS OUT for women in first Royal engagement with the Duchess of Cambridge
Chadwick Boseman Surprises Passionate 'Black Panther' Fans on 'Tonight Show'
White House Comms Director And Longtime Trump Aide Is Resigning
The unseen power of Hope Hicks
'Tutu' painting by Ben Enwonwu sells for $1.6 million
Oscars Host Jimmy Kimmel Explains Why He Won't Reference #MeToo And Time's Up
Georgia teacher arrested after firing gunshot alone in school classroom
#MeToo and #TimesUp have pushed 48% of companies to review pay policies
10 best foods for your heart
Thousands of jobs at risk as Maplin and Toys R Us fall into administration - business live
Florida school shooting survivors return to school for first time since massacre
Bill Gates Says Cryptocurrencies Have Caused Deaths
Afghanistan offers to recognize Taliban as legitimate 'political party'
Hope Hicks refuses to answer U.S. House investigators’ questions about Trump administration
Japan unveils Tokyo 2020 Olympics superhero mascots
Jared Kushner, President Trump's son-in-law, has security clearance downgraded
Facebook Named Live Stream Partner for 'The Oscars: All Access'
iQiyi, the Netflix of China, is going public in the US
Close Trump aide Hope Hicks testifies in House Intelligence Committee regarding Russia probe
Donald Trump WILL run for US President in 2020 as Republican names his campaign chief
Jennifer Lawrence Drinks Rum With Stephen Colbert, Calls Harvey Weinstein a "Horrible Ass Boil"
Apple is leading the race to $1 trillion
Four billboards say Serena Williams is the 'greatest momma of all time'
Global Markets: Asian shares rise to three-week high ahead of Powell's testimony
Kim Kardashian West's Vogue India Cover Sparks Debate About Representation
Russia's 'humanitarian pause' comes into effect in eastern Ghouta
Gov Jay Inslee To Trump: ‘Less Tweeting ... More Listening’
Saudi Arabia sacks military commanders in late-night reshuffle
North Carolina man killed on Facebook Live minutes after leaving police station
Supreme Court won't hear Trump bid to end DACA program
Apple confirms that it's a Google Cloud customer — and it's a big victory for Google cloud boss Diane Greene
Ivanka Trump: It’s ‘Inappropriate’ To Ask Me About My Father’s Accusers
“I really believe I’d run in there even if I didn’t have a weapon,” said Trump.
Kevin Smith suffers massive heart attack, tweets 'For now, I’m still above ground!'
Jennifer Lawrence dropped out of middle school, says she's 'self educated'
Qualcomm Leaves Price as Final Hurdle to Broadcom Takeover
Lewinsky sees 'problematic' issue of consent in Clinton affair
Jacinda Ardern's 'sexist, creepy' 60 Minutes interview angers New Zealand
Ivanka Trump Doesn’t Know If Teachers Should Be Armed
'Black Panther' roars past $700M worldwide
Storms kill four people in Kentucky, Arkansas
Kompany on target as Manchester City cruise past Arsenal in Carabao Cup final
Papua New Guinea hit by 7.5 earthquake
From News to Shoes: How big is big tech?
Olympian Gus Kenworthy Burns Ivanka Trump: ‘TF Is She Doing Here?’
Sridevi Kapoor, Bollywood superstar, dies aged 54
US, Britain in cybersecurity divide over Chinese tech firm Huawei
NRA defends itself after corporations pull away
Toyota, Hyundai recall roughly 110000 vehicles
Record-breaker Marit Bjoergen sends Norway top of final medal tally
China to drop presidential term limits, clearing way for Xi Jinping to stay on
North Korea willing to talk to US, South Korea says
Deandre Ayton dominant but Arizona falls in OT
Democrats' new Russia memo is an anti-Trump political attack
Mexican president cancels trip to Washington after heated call with Trump.
Ivanka Trump tours Olympic venues, meets athletes after vow to increase pressure on North Korea
Warren Buffett letter: 3 tips for stock investors
Emma Chambers Dies at 53
UN Security Council approves 30-day Syria ceasefire
Italian election: Chaos on the streets of Italy as riot police CLASH with antifascists
Watch: Moment when police officers catch falling 5-year-old
Jennifer Lawrence, Catt Sadler Prepping #MeToo, Time's Up Movement TV Docuseries
Apple, Amazon, YouTube Urged To Pull NRA TV Channel
Report: School shooter describes emotional struggle in 911 call
Ivanka Trump practices diplomacy on South Korea Olympics trip
How Kylie Jenner should really use her power
The secret behind Norway's Winter Olympic success
I try like hell to hide that bald spot, says Donald Trump – video
U.S. expects to open Jerusalem embassy in May, officials say
Switzerland: 2 killed in shooting in Zurich
Trump announces new North Korea sanctions
Tesla buyers to lose $7,500 tax credit later this year
Harvery Weinstein apologizes to Jennifer Lawrence, Meryl Streep for lawyers' words
Tiffany Haddish named host of 2018 MTV Movie & TV Awards
There Could Be 7 Amazon Go Stores This Year
Alina Zagitova edges countrywoman Evgenia Medvedeva to win figure skating gold
Rights group: Turkey not avoiding civilians in Syria strikes
'The Bachelor Winter Games' Finale Delivers Surprise Engagement
Ivanka Trump to attend closing ceremony
Justin Trudeau's India visit sparks outrage
How does KFC run out of chicken?
'France is no longer free': Marine Le Pen's niece brings French far right to CPAC
NRA's Wayne LaPierre says gun control advocates 'hate individual freedom'
WATCH: Bundestag speech SCOLDING Merkel for THREATS to Britain prompts HUGE APPLAUSE
Jimmy Kimmel, Stephen Colbert, Trevor Noah on kids who 'got woke' in Best of Late Night
Oprah Reacts To Trump’s Tweet Calling Her ‘Very Insecure’
Snapchat stock drops on news Kylie Jenner no longer uses the app
U.S women's hockey gold medal came in great Olympic game, made even greater statement
White powder letter sent to Prince Harry and Meghan Markle
Trump says only 'highly trained' teachers should have guns to prevent school shootings
Close